Advanced

Contagious contacts: How police trainees influence each other’s memories for a criminal event

Allwood, Carl Martin LU ; Knutsson, Jens LU and Granhag, Pär Anders (2004) 14th European Conference on Psychology and Law of the EAP & L In Paper presented at the 14th European Conference on Psychology and Law of the EAP & L Crakow, Polen, July 7–10, 2004
Abstract
This study investigated the effect of confirmatory and disconfirmatory feedback on the accuracy (realism) in witnesses’ confidence judgements of their event memory. After watching a short video of a kidnapping the participants answered 44 two-alternative questions on the videotape. Two weeks later the participants were handed their old question-answering sheet with the original questions and their own answers. In addition feedback was provided in writing for each answer. The participants were asked to give confidence ratings with respect to the correctness of each answer. In the Control condition the participants received no feedback. Overall, the witnesses’ confidence ratings showed overconfidence in all conditions. Furthermore,... (More)
This study investigated the effect of confirmatory and disconfirmatory feedback on the accuracy (realism) in witnesses’ confidence judgements of their event memory. After watching a short video of a kidnapping the participants answered 44 two-alternative questions on the videotape. Two weeks later the participants were handed their old question-answering sheet with the original questions and their own answers. In addition feedback was provided in writing for each answer. The participants were asked to give confidence ratings with respect to the correctness of each answer. In the Control condition the participants received no feedback. Overall, the witnesses’ confidence ratings showed overconfidence in all conditions. Furthermore, confirmatory feedback caused higher overconfidence, compared both with disconfirmatory feedback and no feedback. The results show that the realism in the eyewitnesses’ confidence judgements of their event memory is indeed sensitive to co-witness feedback, especially to confirming feedback. (Less)
Please use this url to cite or link to this publication:
author
organization
publishing date
type
Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceeding
publication status
published
subject
in
Paper presented at the 14th European Conference on Psychology and Law of the EAP & L Crakow, Polen, July 7–10, 2004
conference name
14th European Conference on Psychology and Law of the EAP & L
language
English
LU publication?
yes
id
3da4ab63-c704-402c-ac97-c9a93103f711 (old id 936118)
date added to LUP
2008-01-23 13:49:45
date last changed
2016-07-06 13:43:21
@misc{3da4ab63-c704-402c-ac97-c9a93103f711,
  abstract     = {This study investigated the effect of confirmatory and disconfirmatory feedback on the accuracy (realism) in witnesses’ confidence judgements of their event memory. After watching a short video of a kidnapping the participants answered 44 two-alternative questions on the videotape. Two weeks later the participants were handed their old question-answering sheet with the original questions and their own answers. In addition feedback was provided in writing for each answer. The participants were asked to give confidence ratings with respect to the correctness of each answer. In the Control condition the participants received no feedback. Overall, the witnesses’ confidence ratings showed overconfidence in all conditions. Furthermore, confirmatory feedback caused higher overconfidence, compared both with disconfirmatory feedback and no feedback. The results show that the realism in the eyewitnesses’ confidence judgements of their event memory is indeed sensitive to co-witness feedback, especially to confirming feedback.},
  author       = {Allwood, Carl Martin and Knutsson, Jens and Granhag, Pär Anders},
  language     = {eng},
  series       = {Paper presented at the 14th European Conference on Psychology and Law of the EAP & L Crakow, Polen, July 7–10, 2004},
  title        = {Contagious contacts: How police trainees influence each other’s memories for a criminal event},
  year         = {2004},
}