%PDF-1.1
%
2 0 obj
<<
/Dest [1 0 R /FitH 757]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [108 694 484 706]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
5 0 obj
<<
/Dest [4 0 R /FitH 757]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [113 659 484 671]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
7 0 obj
<<
/Dest [6 0 R /FitH 757]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [113 635 484 647]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
8 0 obj
<<
/Dest [6 0 R /FitH 430]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 618 484 630]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
10 0 obj
<<
/Dest [9 0 R /FitH 652]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 606 484 618]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
11 0 obj
<<
/Dest [9 0 R /FitH 399]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 594 484 606]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
13 0 obj
<<
/Dest [12 0 R /FitH 567]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 582 484 594]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
14 0 obj
<<
/Dest [12 0 R /FitH 252]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 570 484 582]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
16 0 obj
<<
/Dest [15 0 R /FitH 567]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 559 484 571]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
17 0 obj
<<
/Dest [15 0 R /FitH 414]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 547 484 559]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
19 0 obj
<<
/Dest [18 0 R /FitH 758]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 535 484 547]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
20 0 obj
<<
/Dest [18 0 R /FitH 589]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 524 484 536]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
21 0 obj
<<
/Dest [18 0 R /FitH 281]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 512 484 524]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
23 0 obj
<<
/Dest [22 0 R /FitH 666]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 500 484 512]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
24 0 obj
<<
/Dest [22 0 R /FitH 342]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 488 484 500]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
26 0 obj
<<
/Dest [25 0 R /FitH 757]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 477 484 489]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
27 0 obj
<<
/Dest [25 0 R /FitH 564]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 465 484 477]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
28 0 obj
<<
/Dest [25 0 R /FitH 443]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 453 484 465]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
30 0 obj
<<
/Dest [29 0 R /FitH 757]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 441 484 453]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
31 0 obj
<<
/Dest [29 0 R /FitH 622]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 417 484 429]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
33 0 obj
<<
/Dest [32 0 R /FitH 757]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [113 400 484 412]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
34 0 obj
<<
/Dest [32 0 R /FitH 232]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 382 484 394]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
36 0 obj
<<
/Dest [35 0 R /FitH 652]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 371 484 383]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
37 0 obj
<<
/Dest [35 0 R /FitH 399]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 347 484 359]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
39 0 obj
<<
/Dest [38 0 R /FitH 723]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 335 484 347]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
40 0 obj
<<
/Dest [38 0 R /FitH 536]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 312 186 324]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
42 0 obj
<<
/Dest [41 0 R /FitH 680]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 288 484 300]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
43 0 obj
<<
/Dest [41 0 R /FitH 344]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 276 484 288]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
45 0 obj
<<
/Dest [44 0 R /FitH 752]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 264 484 276]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
46 0 obj
<<
/Dest [44 0 R /FitH 588]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 253 484 265]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
48 0 obj
<<
/Dest [47 0 R /FitH 758]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 241 484 253]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
50 0 obj
<<
/Dest [49 0 R /FitH 757]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [113 223 484 235]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
51 0 obj
<<
/Dest [49 0 R /FitH 600]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 206 484 218]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
52 0 obj
<<
/Dest [49 0 R /FitH 276]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 194 484 206]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
54 0 obj
<<
/Dest [53 0 R /FitH 694]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 182 484 194]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
55 0 obj
<<
/Dest [53 0 R /FitH 558]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 171 484 183]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
56 0 obj
<<
/Dest [53 0 R /FitH 267]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 159 484 171]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
58 0 obj
<<
/Dest [57 0 R /FitH 482]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 147 484 159]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
60 0 obj
<<
/Dest [59 0 R /FitH 757]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [113 129 484 141]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
61 0 obj
<<
/Dest [59 0 R /FitH 671]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 111 484 123]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
62 0 obj
<<
/Dest [59 0 R /FitH 488]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 100 484 112]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
64 0 obj
<<
/Dest [63 0 R /FitH 695]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 88 484 100]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
65 0 obj
<<
/Dest [63 0 R /FitH 527]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 76 484 88]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
67 0 obj
<<
/Dest [66 0 R /FitH 666]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 745 484 757]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
69 0 obj
<<
/Dest [66 0 R /FitH 465]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 733 484 745]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
71 0 obj
<<
/Dest [70 0 R /FitH 553]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 721 484 733]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
73 0 obj
<<
/Dest [72 0 R /FitH 680]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 710 484 722]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
74 0 obj
<<
/Dest [72 0 R /FitH 498]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 698 484 710]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
76 0 obj
<<
/Dest [75 0 R /FitH 757]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 686 484 698]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
77 0 obj
<<
/Dest [75 0 R /FitH 579]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 674 484 686]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
78 0 obj
<<
/Dest [75 0 R /FitH 269]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 663 484 675]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
80 0 obj
<<
/Dest [79 0 R /FitH 482]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 651 484 663]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
82 0 obj
<<
/Dest [81 0 R /FitH 511]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 639 484 651]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
83 0 obj
<<
/Dest [81 0 R /FitH 329]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 627 484 639]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
85 0 obj
<<
/Dest [84 0 R /FitH 695]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 603 484 615]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
86 0 obj
<<
/Dest [84 0 R /FitH 404]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 592 484 604]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
88 0 obj
<<
/Dest [87 0 R /FitH 758]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 580 484 592]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
89 0 obj
<<
/Dest [87 0 R /FitH 335]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 568 484 580]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
91 0 obj
<<
/Dest [90 0 R /FitH 184]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 557 484 569]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
93 0 obj
<<
/Dest [92 0 R /FitH 581]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 545 484 557]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
95 0 obj
<<
/Dest [94 0 R /FitH 757]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [113 527 484 539]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
96 0 obj
<<
/Dest [94 0 R /FitH 317]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 498 160 510]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
98 0 obj
<<
/Dest [97 0 R /FitH 596]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 486 484 498]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
99 0 obj
<<
/Dest [97 0 R /FitH 351]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 474 484 486]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
101 0 obj
<<
/Dest [100 0 R /FitH 609]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 462 484 474]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
103 0 obj
<<
/Dest [102 0 R /FitH 708]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 450 484 462]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
104 0 obj
<<
/Dest [102 0 R /FitH 545]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 439 484 451]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
105 0 obj
<<
/Dest [102 0 R /FitH 429]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 427 484 439]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
106 0 obj
<<
/Dest [102 0 R /FitH 264]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [149 416 484 427]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
108 0 obj
<<
/Dest [107 0 R /FitH 595]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [149 406 484 417]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
109 0 obj
<<
/Dest [107 0 R /FitH 476]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [149 395 484 406]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
110 0 obj
<<
/Dest [107 0 R /FitH 357]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 384 484 396]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
112 0 obj
<<
/Dest [111 0 R /FitH 737]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 372 484 384]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
114 0 obj
<<
/Dest [113 0 R /FitH 567]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [149 361 484 372]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
115 0 obj
<<
/Dest [113 0 R /FitH 334]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [149 351 484 362]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
117 0 obj
<<
/Dest [116 0 R /FitH 581]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 339 484 351]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
118 0 obj
<<
/Dest [116 0 R /FitH 267]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 327 484 339]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
120 0 obj
<<
/Dest [119 0 R /FitH 270]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [149 316 484 327]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
122 0 obj
<<
/Dest [121 0 R /FitH 581]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [149 306 484 317]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
124 0 obj
<<
/Dest [123 0 R /FitH 694]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 294 484 306]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
125 0 obj
<<
/Dest [123 0 R /FitH 573]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [149 283 484 294]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
127 0 obj
<<
/Dest [126 0 R /FitH 757]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 272 484 284]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
128 0 obj
<<
/Dest [126 0 R /FitH 508]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 261 484 273]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
129 0 obj
<<
/Dest [126 0 R /FitH 412]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [149 250 484 261]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
131 0 obj
<<
/Dest [130 0 R /FitH 757]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [149 239 484 250]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
132 0 obj
<<
/Dest [130 0 R /FitH 284]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [149 229 484 240]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
134 0 obj
<<
/Dest [133 0 R /FitH 284]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 217 484 229]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
135 0 obj
<<
/Dest [133 0 R /FitH 219]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [149 206 484 217]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
137 0 obj
<<
/Dest [136 0 R /FitH 524]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [149 196 484 207]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
139 0 obj
<<
/Dest [138 0 R /FitH 651]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [149 185 484 196]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
140 0 obj
<<
/Dest [138 0 R /FitH 391]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 174 484 186]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
142 0 obj
<<
/Dest [141 0 R /FitH 425]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 162 484 174]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
144 0 obj
<<
/Dest [143 0 R /FitH 757]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 150 484 162]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
146 0 obj
<<
/Dest [145 0 R /FitH 255]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 138 484 150]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
148 0 obj
<<
/Dest [147 0 R /FitH 482]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 126 484 138]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
150 0 obj
<<
/Dest [149 0 R /FitH 757]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [113 108 484 120]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
151 0 obj
<<
/Dest [149 0 R /FitH 699]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 79 160 91]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
153 0 obj
<<
/Dest [152 0 R /FitH 398]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 745 484 757]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
156 0 obj
<<
/Dest [155 0 R /FitH 468]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 733 484 745]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
158 0 obj
<<
/Dest [157 0 R /FitH 757]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [113 715 484 727]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
159 0 obj
<<
/Dest [157 0 R /FitH 671]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 698 484 710]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
160 0 obj
<<
/Dest [157 0 R /FitH 417]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 686 484 698]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
161 0 obj
<<
/Dest [157 0 R /FitH 279]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 674 484 686]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
163 0 obj
<<
/Dest [162 0 R /FitH 757]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 651 186 663]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
164 0 obj
<<
/Dest [162 0 R /FitH 534]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 639 484 651]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
165 0 obj
<<
/Dest [162 0 R /FitH 305]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 627 484 639]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
167 0 obj
<<
/Dest [166 0 R /FitH 497]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 615 484 627]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
168 0 obj
<<
/Dest [166 0 R /FitH 338]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 603 484 615]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
170 0 obj
<<
/Dest [169 0 R /FitH 751]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 592 484 604]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
171 0 obj
<<
/Dest [169 0 R /FitH 521]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 580 484 592]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
172 0 obj
<<
/Dest [169 0 R /FitH 270]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 568 484 580]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
174 0 obj
<<
/Dest [173 0 R /FitH 567]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 557 484 569]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
175 0 obj
<<
/Dest [173 0 R /FitH 386]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 545 484 557]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
177 0 obj
<<
/Dest [176 0 R /FitH 651]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 533 484 545]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
178 0 obj
<<
/Dest [176 0 R /FitH 503]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 521 484 533]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
180 0 obj
<<
/Dest [179 0 R /FitH 757]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 510 484 522]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
181 0 obj
<<
/Dest [179 0 R /FitH 423]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 486 186 498]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
183 0 obj
<<
/Dest [182 0 R /FitH 758]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 474 484 486]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
184 0 obj
<<
/Dest [182 0 R /FitH 457]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 462 484 474]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
186 0 obj
<<
/Dest [185 0 R /FitH 652]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 450 484 462]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
187 0 obj
<<
/Dest [185 0 R /FitH 437]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 427 186 439]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
189 0 obj
<<
/Dest [188 0 R /FitH 757]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 415 484 427]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
190 0 obj
<<
/Dest [188 0 R /FitH 562]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 404 484 416]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
192 0 obj
<<
/Dest [191 0 R /FitH 468]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 392 484 404]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
194 0 obj
<<
/Dest [193 0 R /FitH 757]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 369 484 381]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
195 0 obj
<<
/Dest [193 0 R /FitH 392]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 357 484 369]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
197 0 obj
<<
/Dest [196 0 R /FitH 680]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 345 484 357]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
198 0 obj
<<
/Dest [196 0 R /FitH 443]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 333 484 345]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
199 0 obj
<<
/Dest [196 0 R /FitH 319]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 321 484 333]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
201 0 obj
<<
/Dest [200 0 R /FitH 723]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 309 484 321]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
202 0 obj
<<
/Dest [200 0 R /FitH 629]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 298 484 310]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
203 0 obj
<<
/Dest [200 0 R /FitH 451]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 286 484 298]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
205 0 obj
<<
/Dest [204 0 R /FitH 723]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 274 484 286]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
206 0 obj
<<
/Dest [204 0 R /FitH 484]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 251 484 263]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
208 0 obj
<<
/Dest [207 0 R /FitH 610]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 239 484 251]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
209 0 obj
<<
/Dest [207 0 R /FitH 394]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 227 484 239]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
211 0 obj
<<
/Dest [210 0 R /FitH 757]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 204 484 216]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
212 0 obj
<<
/Dest [210 0 R /FitH 548]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 192 484 204]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
213 0 obj
<<
/Dest [210 0 R /FitH 339]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 180 484 192]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
214 0 obj
<<
/Dest [210 0 R /FitH 190]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 168 484 180]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
216 0 obj
<<
/Dest [215 0 R /FitH 638]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 156 484 168]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
217 0 obj
<<
/Dest [215 0 R /FitH 485]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 145 484 157]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
218 0 obj
<<
/Dest [215 0 R /FitH 350]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 133 484 145]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
219 0 obj
<<
/Dest [215 0 R /FitH 214]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 121 484 133]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
221 0 obj
<<
/Dest [220 0 R /FitH 538]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [149 111 484 122]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
222 0 obj
<<
/Dest [220 0 R /FitH 306]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 99 484 111]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
224 0 obj
<<
/Dest [223 0 R /FitH 723]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 87 484 99]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
226 0 obj
<<
/Dest [225 0 R /FitH 757]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [113 745 484 757]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
228 0 obj
<<
/Dest [225 0 R /FitH 671]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 727 484 739]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
229 0 obj
<<
/Dest [225 0 R /FitH 470]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 715 484 727]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
231 0 obj
<<
/Dest [230 0 R /FitH 638]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 704 484 716]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
232 0 obj
<<
/Dest [230 0 R /FitH 437]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 692 484 704]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
234 0 obj
<<
/Dest [233 0 R /FitH 737]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 680 484 692]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
235 0 obj
<<
/Dest [233 0 R /FitH 488]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 657 484 669]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
237 0 obj
<<
/Dest [236 0 R /FitH 758]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 645 484 657]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
238 0 obj
<<
/Dest [236 0 R /FitH 348]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 621 186 633]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
239 0 obj
<<
/Dest [236 0 R /FitH 153]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 609 484 621]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
241 0 obj
<<
/Dest [240 0 R /FitH 751]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 598 484 610]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
242 0 obj
<<
/Dest [240 0 R /FitH 564]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 574 484 586]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
243 0 obj
<<
/Dest [240 0 R /FitH 342]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 563 484 575]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
245 0 obj
<<
/Dest [244 0 R /FitH 567]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 551 484 563]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
246 0 obj
<<
/Dest [244 0 R /FitH 400]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 539 484 551]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
248 0 obj
<<
/Dest [247 0 R /FitH 757]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 527 484 539]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
249 0 obj
<<
/Dest [247 0 R /FitH 562]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [137 516 484 528]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
251 0 obj
<<
/Dest [250 0 R /FitH 757]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [113 498 484 510]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
252 0 obj
<<
/Dest [250 0 R /FitH 572]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 480 484 492]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
254 0 obj
<<
/Dest [253 0 R /FitH 723]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 468 484 480]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
255 0 obj
<<
/Dest [253 0 R /FitH 584]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 445 484 457]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
256 0 obj
<<
/Dest [253 0 R /FitH 251]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 433 484 445]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
258 0 obj
<<
/Dest [257 0 R /FitH 468]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 421 484 433]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
260 0 obj
<<
/Dest [259 0 R /FitH 757]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [113 392 484 404]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
261 0 obj
<<
/Dest [259 0 R /FitH 487]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 374 484 386]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
262 0 obj
<<
/Dest [259 0 R /FitH 290]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [125 363 484 375]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
264 0 obj
<<
/Dest [263 0 R /FitH 757]
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/Rect [113 337 484 357]
/C [0 0 0]
/Border [0 0 0]
>>
endobj
266 0 obj
<<
/Length 601
>>
stream
BT
/F1 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 217.53 743.55 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(*5$'8$7\(\0037+\(6,6\017\003\025\0233)Tj
-4.84 -1.41 TD
(\)$&8/7<\0032\)\003/$:\017\00381,9\(56,7<\0032\)\003/81'\017)Tj
9.14 -1.41 TD
(6:\('\(1)Tj
-7.8 -1.41 TD
(683\(59,625\035\003352\)\(6625\003/\(11$57)Tj
6.8 -1.41 TD
(69\(16b7\(5)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
21.96 0 0 21.96 291.57 651.15 Tm
1 g
0 Tw
(6)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
27.96 0 0 27.96 179.01 589.83 Tm
0 g
-0.003 Tc
[(,1)-6(7)-4(\()-4(//\()-4(&7)-4(8)-6($)0(/)]TJ
-1.7768 -1.4077 TD
0.001 Tc
(3523\(57<\003,668\(6\003,1)Tj
2.2489 -1.4077 TD
-0.002 Tc
(&<%\(563$&\()Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
267 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F1 268 0 R
/F2 269 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
273 0 obj
<<
/Length 1212
>>
stream
BT
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 745.47 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(\251 J)-11(ohan Carl Sj\366beck 1998)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 680.07 Tm
0.001 Tc
(Preface)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 651.51 Tm
0 Tc
[(I)23( would like to take this opportunity)30( to thank my)30( dear parents, B)7(o)0( and)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(B)7(a)4(rbro. W)-6(ithout their warm support in numerous way)30(s)-1(, it would definitely)]TJ
T*
[(have been more burdensome to write this thesis. B)7(y)30( supply)30(i)-2(ng)10( me with)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(computers since my)29( early)29( teens, they)29( undoubtedly)29( awakened my)29( interest for)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(computers. I)23( owe my)30( parents every)30(t)-2(hing)10(. I)23( would also like to thank Cristina)]TJ
T*
[(L)21(a)4(ndg)10(ren for patiently)30( listening)10( to my)30( tedious monolog)10(ues reg)10(a)4(rding)10( the)]TJ
T*
[(issues in this thesis and for g)10(i)-2(ving)10( valuable advice. I)23( am also very)30( g)10(r)3(ateful to)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Professor L)20(e)3(nnart Svens\344ter, who believed in this subject and ag)9(reed to let)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
(me write the thesis under his supervision.)Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
274 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F4 275 0 R
/F5 276 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
277 0 obj
<<
/Length 18353
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
18 0 0 18 113.49 739.95 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0.001 Tc
(Content)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 113.49 696.63 Tm
0 Tc
[(\024)-1904(,1752'8&7,21)-60(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
)-169(\024)]TJ
0 -2.3735 TD
[(\025)-1904(%5,\(\)\003+,6725<\0032\)\0037+\(\003\(92/87,21\003$1'\003*52:7+\0032\)\0037+\()]TJ
0 -1.1687 TD
[(,17\(51\(7)-205(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)]TJ
35.5181 0 TD
[(\021\021\021)-169(\026)]TJ
-35.5181 -2.3735 TD
[(\026)-1904(+<3\(5/,1.,1*)-121(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
)-169(\027)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
1.2048 -1.759 TD
0.005 Tc
[(3.1)-1146(H)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 156.69 620.19 Tm
-0.006 Tc
0.01 Tw
[(YPE)-7(R)-11(T)8(E)-7(XT)8( L)23(I)28(NK)15(S)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 222.81 620.19 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(....................................................................................................)-169(4)]TJ
-9.7711 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(3.2)-1146(I)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 152.85 608.43 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(NL)23(I)28(N)0(E)-7( L)23(I)28(NK)15(I)28(N)0(G)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 212.73 608.43 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(........................................................................................................)-169(6)]TJ
-8.759 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(3.3)-1146(F)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 155.01 596.67 Tm
[(RA)27(MI)40(N)12(G)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 187.53 596.67 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(..................................................................................................................)-169(6)]TJ
-6.2289 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(3.4)-1146(T)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 155.73 584.91 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(HE)-7( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 168.45 584.91 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(W)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 177.93 584.91 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(A)15(S)-2(HI)28(NG)15(T)8(ON )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 225.93 584.91 Tm
0 Tc
(P)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 231.57 584.91 Tm
-0.005 Tc
[(OST)9( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 248.61 584.91 Tm
0 Tc
(C)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 255.21 584.91 Tm
-0.005 Tc
0.009 Tw
[(OM)-12(PA)16(NY E)-6(T)9( A)16(L)24( V)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 321.69 584.91 Tm
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
(. T)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 332.97 584.91 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(OT)8(A)15(L)23( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 355.89 584.91 Tm
0 Tc
(N)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 363.09 584.91 Tm
0.001 Tc
[(EW)20(S)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 379.89 584.91 Tm
0.003 Tc
(, I)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 388.29 584.91 Tm
-0.006 Tc
(NC)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 399.45 584.91 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(.)-229(............................)-169(7)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
-26.3012 -1.1807 TD
0 Tc
[(\026\021\027\021\024)-1591(7KH\003IUDPHG\003VLWHV\003ZHUH\003GLVSOD\\HG\003LQ\003D\003GLVWRUWHG\003ZD\\)-229(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\032)]TJ
T*
[(\026\021\027\021\025)-1591(3RWHQWLDO\003FRQIXVLRQ\003DPRQJ\003XVHUV\003UHJDUGLQJ\003WKH\003RULJLQ\003RI\003WKH\003QHZV\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\033)]TJ
T*
[(\026\021\027\021\026)-1591(\2639ROXQWDU\\\264\003VHWWOHPHQW)-60(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\033)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
-1.2048 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(3.5)-1146(T)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 155.73 537.87 Tm
-0.021 Tc
0.025 Tw
[(I)13(C)-26(KE)-22(T)-7(M)-28(AS)-17(T)-7(E)-22(R)-26( V)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 219.09 537.87 Tm
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
(. M)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 233.01 537.87 Tm
0.005 Tc
[(I)39(CRO)11(S)9(O)11(F)24(T)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 273.21 537.87 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(................................................................................)-169(9)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
-13.6265 -1.1807 TD
0 Tc
[(\026\021\030\021\024)-1591(0LFURVRIW\266V\003VLWH\003OLQNHG\003WR\003WKH\003H[WUHPHO\\\003SRSXODU\0037LFNHWPDVWHU\003VLWH)-72(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\034)]TJ
T*
[(\026\021\030\021\025)-1591(7KH\003ODZIXOQHVV\003RI\003K\\SHUWH[W\003OLQNV)-144(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\034)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
-1.2048 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(3.6)-1146(S)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 155.01 502.59 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(HE)-7(T)8(L)23(A)15(ND )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 194.37 502.59 Tm
0 Tc
(N)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 201.57 502.59 Tm
0.001 Tc
[(EW)20(S)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 220.29 502.59 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(...................................................................................................)-169(10)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
-8.3133 -1.1807 TD
0 Tc
[(\026\021\031\021\024)-1591(7KH\003LQWHULP\003LQMXQFWLRQ\003LV\003QRW\003WKH\003GHDWK\003RI\003K\\SHUOLQNLQJ\003LQ\003WKH\0038\021.\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\024\023)]TJ
T*
[(\026\021\031\021\025)-1591(1HZVSDSHU\003KHDGOLQHV\003RQ\003D\003ZHEVLWH\003PD\\\003HQMR\\\003FRS\\ULJKW)-48(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\024\024)]TJ
T*
[(\026\021\031\021\026)-1591(85/\003PD\\\003HQMR\\\003FRS\\ULJKW)-156(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\024\024)]TJ
T*
[(\026\021\031\021\027)-1591(\)DLU\003GHDOLQJ\003DQG\003LPSOLHG\003OLFHQVH\003ZKHQ\003FRS\\LQJ\00385/V\003DQG\003QHZV\003KHDGOLQHV)-301(\024\024)]TJ
T*
[(\026\021\031\021\030)-1591(6HWWOHPHQW\003UHDFKHG\003LQ\0031RYHPEHU\003\024\034\034\032)-217(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\024\025)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
-1.2048 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(3.7)-1146(H)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 156.69 432.03 Tm
-0.005 Tc
0.009 Tw
[(YPE)-6(R)-10(T)9(E)-6(XT)9(S I)29(N)1( A)16( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 221.85 432.03 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(S)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 227.37 432.03 Tm
-0.004 Tc
0.008 Tw
[(W)15(E)-5(DI)30(SH PER)-9(SPEC)-9(T)10(I)30(V)2(E)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 311.97 432.03 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.004 Tw
(: M)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 326.13 432.03 Tm
-0.006 Tc
0.01 Tw
[(A)15(K)15(I)28(NG)15( A)15( L)23(I)28(NK)15( I)28(S)-2( NOT)8( E)-7(QUI)28(VA)15(L)23(E)-7(NT)8( OF)]TJ
-24.9552 -1.4627 TD
[(PR)-11(ODUC)-11(I)28(N)0(G)15( A)15( C)-11(O)0(PY OF)13( T)8(H)0(E)-7( M)-13(A)15(T)8(E)-7(R)-11(I)28(A)15(L)23( L)23(I)28(NK)15(E)-7(D)0( T)8(O)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 321.09 420.27 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(...........................................................)-169(12)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
-20.8434 -1.7952 TD
0 Tc
[(\027)-1904(&$&+,1*)-193(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\024\027)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
1.2048 -1.759 TD
0.005 Tc
[(4.1)-1146(C)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 156.09 384.87 Tm
-0.005 Tc
0.009 Tw
[(A)16(C)-10(HI)29(NG)16( I)29(S)-1( SOM)-12(E)-6(T)9(I)29(M)-12(E)-6(S C)-10(ONSI)29(D)1(E)-6(R)-10(E)-6(D)1( A)16( C)-10(O)1(PYR)-10(I)29(G)16(H)1(T)9( I)29(N)1(F)14(R)-10(I)29(N)1(G)16(E)-6(M)-12(E)-6(NT)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 414.33 384.87 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(......................)-169(14)]TJ
-29 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(4.2)-1146(L)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 155.49 373.11 Tm
-0.006 Tc
0.01 Tw
[(E)-7(G)15(A)15(L)23( C)-11(ONSI)28(D)0(E)-7(R)-11(A)15(T)8(I)28(ONS C)-11(ONC)-11(E)-7(R)-11(NI)28(NG)15( B)-11(R)-11(O)0(W)13(S)-2(I)28(N)0(G)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 346.29 373.11 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(.................................................)-169(15)]TJ
-22.1687 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(4.3)-1146(T)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 155.73 361.35 Tm
-0.005 Tc
0.009 Tw
[(HE)-6( I)29(N)1(C)-10(R)-10(E)-6(A)16(S)-1(I)29(N)1(G)16( USA)16(G)16(E)-6( OF)14( PA)16(SSW)14(OR)-10(DS A)16(ND USE)-6(R)-10( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 350.37 361.35 Tm
0.004 Tc
(ID)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 360.93 361.35 Tm
-0.003 Tc
0.007 Tw
[(S SUPPOR)-8(T)11(S T)11(H)3(E EXI)31(S)1(T)11(E)-4(NC)-8(E OF)]TJ
-29.2836 -1.4627 TD
-0.005 Tc
0.009 Tw
[(A)16(N)1( I)29(M)-12(PL)24(I)29(E)-6(D L)24(I)29(C)-10(E)-6(NSE)-6( T)9(O)1( VI)29(SI)29(T)9( PUB)-10(L)24(I)29(C)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 269.85 349.59 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(-)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 273.09 349.59 Tm
-0.004 Tc
0.008 Tw
[(A)17(C)-9(C)-9(E)-5(SS SI)30(T)10(E)-5(S)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 328.65 349.59 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(........................................................)-169(15)]TJ
-20.3976 -1.1807 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(4.4)-1147(M)1(A)15(I)0( S)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 176.85 337.83 Tm
-0.005 Tc
[(YST)9(E)-6(M)-12(S)-1( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 210.45 337.83 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(C)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 217.05 337.83 Tm
-0.006 Tc
0.01 Tw
[(OR)-11(POR)-11(A)15(T)8(I)28(ON V)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 275.97 337.83 Tm
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
(. P)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 286.65 337.83 Tm
-0.021 Tc
[(E)-22(AK )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 304.89 337.83 Tm
0 Tc
(C)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 311.49 337.83 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(OM)-13(PUT)8(E)-7(R)-11( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 351.81 337.83 Tm
0 Tc
(I)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 355.17 337.83 Tm
-0.006 Tc
(NC)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 366.33 337.83 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(.)-12(........................................)-169(16)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
-22.9759 -1.1807 TD
0 Tc
[(\027\021\027\021\024)-1591($\003FRS\\\003VWRUHG\003LQ\003WKH\0035$0\003LV\003FRQVLGHUHG\003D\003IL[HG\003FRS\\\003XQGHU\003WKH\003&RS\\ULJKW)]TJ
T*
[($FW)-2277(\024\031)]TJ
T*
[(\027\021\027\021\025)-1591(7KH\003ULJKWIXO\003SRVVHVVRU\003RI\003D\003FRPSXWHU\003SURJUDP\003FDQQRW\003DXWKRUL]H\003D\003WKLUG\003SDUW\\)]TJ
T*
[(WR\003PDNH\003D\003FRS\\)-217(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\024\032)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
-1.2048 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(4.5)-1146(T)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 155.73 279.03 Tm
-0.001 Tw
[(RI)39(A)26(D)11( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 179.01 279.03 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(S)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 184.53 279.03 Tm
-0.005 Tc
[(YST)9(E)-6(M)-12(S)-1( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 218.13 279.03 Tm
0 Tc
(C)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 224.73 279.03 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(OR)-11(P)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 240.33 279.03 Tm
0.003 Tc
(. )Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 245.37 279.03 Tm
0 Tc
(V)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 251.13 279.03 Tm
0.003 Tc
(. S)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 261.69 279.03 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(OUT)8(HE)-7(A)15(S)-2(T)8(E)-7(R)-11(N)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 321.09 279.03 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(...........................................................)-169(17)]TJ
-19.6386 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(4.5)-1146(E)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 155.61 267.27 Tm
-0.004 Tc
[(XPR)-9(E)-5(SS )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 187.05 267.27 Tm
0 Tc
(C)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 193.65 267.27 Tm
(O)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 199.41 267.27 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(.)-72(..........................................................................................................)-169(18)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
-6.2169 -1.1807 TD
0 Tc
[(\027\021\030\021\024)-1591('HIHQVH\003RI\003IDLU\003XVH\003UHMHFWHG)-241(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\024\033)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
-1.2048 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(4.6)-1146(S)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 155.01 243.75 Tm
[(U)12(MMA)27(RY)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 192.57 243.75 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(..............................................................................................................)-169(19)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
-7.9398 -1.7952 TD
0 Tc
[(\030)-1904(352;<&$&+,1*)-169(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\025\023)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
1.2048 -1.759 TD
0.005 Tc
[(5.1)-1146(T)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 155.73 208.35 Tm
-0.006 Tc
0.01 Tw
[(HE)-7( L)23(E)-7(G)15(A)15(L)23( DI)28(L)23(E)-7(M)-13(M)-13(A)15( OF)13( PR)-11(OXYC)-11(A)15(C)-11(HI)28(NG)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 313.53 208.35 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(..............................................................)-169(20)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
-17.6747 -1.1807 TD
0 Tc
[(\030\021\024\021\024)-1591(3DJH\003LPSUHVVLRQV)-120(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\025\023)]TJ
T*
[(\030\021\024\021\025)-1591($\003SUR[\\FDFKHG\003VLWH\003FRQVWLWXWHV\003D\003FRS\\)-217(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\025\024)]TJ
T*
[(\030\021\024\021\026)-1591(\)DLU\003XVH\003WR\003XWLOL]H\003SUR[\\FDFKLQJ)-205(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\025\024)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
-1.2048 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(5.2)-1146(P)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 155.13 161.31 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(R)-11(OXYC)-11(A)15(C)-11(HI)28(NG)15( I)28(N)0( A)15( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 233.73 161.31 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(S)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 239.25 161.31 Tm
-0.004 Tc
0.008 Tw
[(W)15(E)-5(DI)30(SH L)25(E)-5(G)17(A)17(L)25( PER)-9(SPEC)-9(T)10(I)30(V)2(E)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 353.85 161.31 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(..............................................)-169(21)]TJ
-22.9277 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(5.3)-1146(S)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 155.01 149.55 Tm
[(U)12(MMA)27(RY)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 192.57 149.55 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(..............................................................................................................)-169(22)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
-7.9398 -1.7952 TD
0 Tc
[(\031)-1904('20$,1\0031$0\(6)-129(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\025\026)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
1.2048 -1.759 TD
0.005 Tc
[(6.1)-1146(I)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 152.85 114.15 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(NT)8(E)-7(R)-11(NE)-7(T)8( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 191.25 114.15 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(P)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 196.89 114.15 Tm
0.004 Tc
[(RO)10(T)18(O)10(CO)10(L)33( A)25(D)10(D)10(R)-1(ES)8(S)8(E)3(S)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 283.29 114.15 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(..........................................................................)-169(23)]TJ
-15.8434 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(6.2)-1146(T)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 155.73 102.39 Tm
-0.005 Tc
0.009 Tw
[(OP L)24(E)-6(VE)-6(L)24( DE)-6(SI)29(G)16(N)1(A)16(T)9(OR)-10(S)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 250.53 102.39 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(.......................................................................................)-169(23)]TJ
-12.5542 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(6.3)-1146(S)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 155.01 90.63 Tm
-0.006 Tc
0.01 Tw
[(E)-7(C)-11(ONDA)15(R)-11(Y)0( L)23(E)-7(VE)-7(L)23( DE)-7(SI)28(G)15(N)0(A)15(T)8(OR)-11(S)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 285.81 90.63 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(.........................................................................)-169(24)]TJ
-16.0964 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(6.4)-1146(T)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 155.73 78.87 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(HE)-7( NE)-7(E)-7(D)0( F)13(O)0(R)-11( A)15( UNI)28(VE)-7(R)-11(S)-2(A)15(L)23( DOM)-13(A)15(I)28(N DI)28(R)-11(E)-7(C)-11(T)8(OR)-11(Y SE)-7(R)-11(V)0(I)28(C)-11(E)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 381.57 78.87 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(...................................)-169(24)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
278 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
281 0 obj
<<
/Length 18742
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 125.49 747.39 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0.005 Tc
[(6.5)-1146(R)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 156.09 747.39 Tm
-0.006 Tc
0.01 Tw
[(E)-7(G)15(I)28(S)-2(T)8(E)-7(R)-11(I)28(NG)15( DOM)-13(A)15(I)28(N NA)15(M)-13(E)-7(S I)28(N)0( T)8(H)0(E)-7( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 296.73 747.39 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(U)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 303.93 747.39 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(NI)28(T)8(E)-7(D )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 329.61 747.39 Tm
0 Tc
(S)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 335.13 747.39 Tm
-0.014 Tc
[(TA)7(TE)-15(S)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 361.41 747.39 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(...........................................)-169(25)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
-22.4819 -1.1807 TD
0 Tc
[(\031\021\030\021\024)-1591(7KH\003GRPDLQ\003QDPH\003GLVSXWH\003SROLF\\)-217(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\025\030)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
-1.2048 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(6.6)-1146(R)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 156.09 723.87 Tm
-0.006 Tc
0.01 Tw
[(E)-7(G)15(I)28(S)-2(T)8(E)-7(R)-11(I)28(NG)15( DOM)-13(A)15(I)28(N NA)15(M)-13(E)-7(S I)28(N)0( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 279.21 723.87 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(S)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 284.73 723.87 Tm
-0.019 Tc
[(WE)-20(D)-13(E)-20(N)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 313.53 723.87 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(..............................................................)-169(26)]TJ
-18.8795 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(6.7)-1146(C)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 156.09 712.11 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(YB)-11(E)-7(R)-11(SQUA)15(T)8(T)8(I)28(NG)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 222.81 712.11 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(..................................................................................................)-169(27)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
-8.5663 -1.1807 TD
0 Tc
[(\031\021\032\021\024)-1591(5HDVRQV\003ZK\\\003RQH\003RXJKW\003WR\003ILJKW\003D\003F\\EHUVTXDWWHU)-229(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\025\032)]TJ
T*
[(\031\021\032\021\025)-1591(+RVWLOH\003WDNHRYHU\003RI\003WUDGHPDUN\003E\\\003F\\EHUVTXDWWHU)-72(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\025\033)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
-1.2048 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(6.8)-1146(C)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 156.09 676.83 Tm
-0.006 Tc
0.01 Tw
[(ONF)13(USI)28(N)0(G)15( DOM)-13(A)15(I)28(N NA)15(M)-13(E)-7(S)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 260.61 676.83 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(...................................................................................)-169(28)]TJ
-13.5663 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(6.9)-1146(P)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 155.13 665.07 Tm
-0.005 Tc
0.009 Tw
[(OSSI)29(B)-10(L)24(E)-6( C)-10(ONF)14(L)24(I)29(C)-10(T)9(S B)-10(E)-6(T)9(W)14(E)-6(E)-6(N)1( DOM)-12(A)16(I)29(N NA)16(M)-12(E)-6(S A)16(ND T)9(R)-10(A)16(D)1(E)-6(M)-12(A)16(R)-10(K)16(S)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 414.33 665.07 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(......................)-169(28)]TJ
-29 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(6.10)-1844(T)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 167.73 653.31 Tm
-0.006 Tc
0.01 Tw
[(R)-11(A)15(DE)-7(M)-13(A)15(R)-11(K)15(S A)15(ND DOM)-13(A)15(I)28(N NA)15(M)-13(E)-7(S I)28(N)0( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 313.77 653.31 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(S)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 319.29 653.31 Tm
-0.019 Tc
[(WE)-20(D)-13(E)-20(N)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 348.81 653.31 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(................................................)-169(29)]TJ
-22.4217 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(6.11)-1844(D)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 168.69 641.55 Tm
-0.005 Tc
0.009 Tw
[(OM)-12(A)16(I)29(N NA)16(M)-12(E)-6(S A)16(R)-10(E)-6( NOT)9( SOL)24(E)-6(L)24(Y)1( DE)-6(SC)-10(R)-10(I)29(PT)9(I)29(V)1(E)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 348.81 641.55 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(................................................)-169(30)]TJ
-22.4217 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(6.12)-1844(R)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 168.09 629.79 Tm
-0.021 Tc
0.025 Tw
[(E)-22(G)0(I)13(S)-17(T)-7(E)-22(R)-26(I)13(N)-15(G)0( A T)-7(R)-26(AD)-15(E)-22(M)-28(AR)-26(K C)-26(O)-15(N)-15(S)-17(I)13(S)-17(T)-7(I)13(N)-15(G)0( O)-15(F)-2( A G)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 350.85 629.79 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(T)-13(L)12(D)-118(.......................................)-169(30)]TJ
-22.6265 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(6.13)-1844(T)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 167.73 618.03 Tm
-0.006 Tc
0.01 Tw
[(HE)-7( POSSI)28(B)-11(I)28(L)23(I)28(T)8(I)28(E)-7(S)-2( OF)13( DOM)-13(A)15(I)28(N NA)15(M)-13(E)-7(S I)28(N)0(F)13(R)-11(I)28(N)0(G)15(I)28(NG)15( UPON A)15(L)23(R)-11(E)-7(A)15(DY E)-7(X)0(I)28(S)-2(T)8(I)28(NG)]TJ
-5.2537 -1.4627 TD
-0.021 Tc
0.025 Tw
[(T)-7(R)-26(AD)-15(E)-22(M)-28(AR)-26(KS)-17( AN)-15(D)-15( V)-15(I)13(C)-26(E)-22( V)-15(E)-22(R)-26(S)-17(A)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 250.53 606.27 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(.......................................................................................)-169(31)]TJ
-12.5542 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(6.14)-1844(D)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 168.69 594.51 Tm
-0.006 Tc
0.01 Tw
[(OM)-13(A)15(I)28(N NA)15(M)-13(E)-7( I)28(N)0(F)13(R)-11(I)28(N)0(G)15(E)-7(M)-13(E)-7(NT)8(S A)15(ND DI)28(SPUT)8(E)-7(S)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 346.29 594.51 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(.................................................)-169(31)]TJ
-22.1687 -1.1807 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(6.15)-1845(MT)-12(V N)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 193.53 582.75 Tm
0.001 Tc
0.003 Tw
[(ET)15(W)20(O)7(RK)22(S V)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 239.73 582.75 Tm
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
(. A)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 251.85 582.75 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(DA)15(M)-13( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 272.49 582.75 Tm
0 Tc
(C)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 279.09 582.75 Tm
0.005 Tc
[(U)11(RRY)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 303.45 582.75 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(..................................................................)-169(32)]TJ
-17.8675 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(6.16)-1844(R)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 168.09 570.99 Tm
-0.006 Tc
0.01 Tw
[(OA)15(DR)-11(UNNE)-7(R)-11( V)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 226.05 570.99 Tm
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[(. NSI)-86(........................................................................................)-169(32)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
-8.8916 -1.1807 TD
0 Tc
[(\031\021\024\031\021\024)-1085(+RVWLOH\003WDNHRYHUV\003RI\003GRPDLQ\003QDPHV)-193(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\026\026)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
-1.2048 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(6.17)-1844(S)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 167.01 547.47 Tm
[(U)12(MMA)27(RY)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 205.17 547.47 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(.........................................................................................................)-169(34)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
-9.2048 -1.7952 TD
0 Tc
[(\032)-1904(,17\(//\(&78$/\0033523\(57<\0033,5$&<\003,1\003&<%\(563$&\()-60(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\026\030)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
1.2048 -1.759 TD
0.005 Tc
[(7.1)-1146(R)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 156.09 512.07 Tm
-0.033 Tc
0.037 Tw
[(E)-34(S)-29(P)-29(O)-27(N)-27(S)-29(IB)-38(ILIT)-19(Y)-27( F)-14(O)-27(R)-38( P)-29(O)-27(S)-29(T)-19(IN)-27(G)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 266.49 512.07 Tm
0.003 Tc
(, )Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 271.53 512.07 Tm
-0.006 Tc
0.01 Tw
[(ST)8(OR)-11(I)28(N)0(G)15( A)15(ND DOW)13(NL)23(OA)15(DI)28(NG)15( PR)-11(OT)8(E)-7(C)-11(T)8(E)-7(D M)-13(A)15(T)8(E)-7(R)-11(I)28(A)15(L)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 149.49 500.31 Tm
0.006 Tc
(35)Tj
-2.4096 -1.1807 TD
[(7.2)-1146(T)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 155.73 488.55 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(HE)-7( F)13(I)28(R)-11(S)-2(T)8( C)-11(O)0(PY M)-13(A)15(DE)-7( F)13(R)-11(OM)-13( T)8(H)0(E)-7( OR)-11(I)28(G)15(I)28(N)0(A)15(L)23( SOUR)-11(C)-11(E)-7( OUT)8(SI)28(DE)-7( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 392.37 488.55 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(C)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 398.97 488.55 Tm
-0.003 Tc
[(YB)-8(ER)-8(SPA)18(C)-8(E)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 447.09 488.55 Tm
0.004 Tc
[(.........)-168(36)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
-31.0843 -1.1807 TD
0 Tc
[(\032\021\025\021\024)-1591(&RS\\LQJ\003VRIWZDUH\003RII\020OLQH\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\026\031)]TJ
T*
[(\032\021\025\021\025)-1591(&RS\\LQJ\003PXVLF\003RII\020OLQH)-96(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\026\032)]TJ
T*
[(\032\021\025\021\026)-1591(&RS\\LQJ\003SLFWXUHV\003RII\020OLQH)-217(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\026\033)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
-1.2048 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(7.3)-1146(L)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 155.49 441.51 Tm
-0.034 Tc
0.038 Tw
[(E)-35(G)-13(A)-13(L)-5( R)-39(E)-35(S)-30(P)-30(O)-28(N)-28(S)-30(IB)-39(ILIT)-20(Y)-28( W)-15(H)-28(E)-35(N)-28( P)-30(O)-28(S)-30(T)-20(IN)-28(G)-13( P)-30(R)-39(O)-28(T)-20(E)-35(C)-39(T)-20(E)-35(D)-28( M)-41(A)-13(T)-20(E)-35(R)-39(I)0(A)-13(L)-5( IN)-28( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 405.81 441.51 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(C)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 412.41 441.51 Tm
-0.003 Tc
[(YB)-8(ER)-8(SPA)18(C)-8(E)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 459.69 441.51 Tm
0.004 Tc
[(....)-168(38)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
-32.3494 -1.1807 TD
0 Tc
[(\032\021\026\021\024)-1591(8SORDGLQJ\003VRIWZDUH)-229(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\026\033)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 149.49 418.95 Tm
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(7.3.1.1)-1216(U)6(ploa)8(ding)11( is not e)8(quiv)11(a)8(le)8(nt of)17( priv)11(a)8(t)2(e)8( c)8(opy)24(ing)-56(...................................................)-186(38)]TJ
0 -1.1733 TD
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[(7.3.1.2)-1217(O)5(n-line)7( ba)7(c)7(k)10(up c)7(opy)-217(...........................................................................................)-187(39)]TJ
T*
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(7.3.1.3)-1216(T)15(he)8( uploa)8(ding)11( pe)8(rs)6(on is)6( re)8(s)6(pons)6(ible)-205(...................................................................)-186(39)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 137.49 386.31 Tm
0 Tc
[(\032\021\026\021\025)-1591(8SORDGLQJ\003SLFWXUHV)-193(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\026\034)]TJ
0 -1.1807 TD
[(\032\021\026\021\026)-1591(8SORDGLQJ\003PXVLF)-72(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\027\023)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 149.49 363.75 Tm
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[(7.3.3.1)-1217(U)5(ploa)7(ding)10( MP)-14(3 f)16(ile)7(s to a)7( w)18(e)7(bsite)7(........................................................................)-187(41)]TJ
0 -1.1733 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(7.3.3.2)-1216(B)4(a)8(c)8(k)11(g)11(r)4(ound m)22(u)-3(s)6(i)2(c)8( on w)19(e)8(bs)6(ite)8(s)-220(...........................................................................)-186(41)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 125.49 341.67 Tm
0.005 Tc
[(7.4)-1146(T)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 155.73 341.67 Tm
-0.033 Tc
0.037 Tw
[(H)-27(E)-34( LE)-34(G)-12(A)-12(L)-4( R)-38(E)-34(S)-29(P)-29(O)-27(N)-27(S)-29(IB)-38(ILIT)-19(IE)-34(S)-29( O)-27(F)-14( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 279.21 341.67 Tm
0.004 Tc
[(IS)6(P)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 293.73 341.67 Tm
-0.005 Tc
0.009 Tw
[(S A)16(ND )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 319.41 341.67 Tm
0.008 Tc
[(BBS)10( )]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 340.89 341.67 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(OPE)-7(R)-11(A)15(T)8(OR)-11(S)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 389.13 341.67 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(................................)-169(42)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
-25.2651 -1.1807 TD
0 Tc
[(\032\021\027\021\024)-1591(7KH\003PRQLWRULQJ\003RI\003SRVWHG\003LQIRUPDWLRQ)-181(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\027\025)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 149.49 319.11 Tm
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[(7.4.1.1)-1217(T)14(he)7( m)21(o)-4(st suita)7(ble)7( supe)7(rv)10(isor)-144(...............................................................................)-187(43)]TJ
0 -1.1733 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(7.4.1.2)-1216(T)15(ra)8(ns)6(f)17(e)8(rring)11( the)8( re)8(s)6(pons)6(ibility)24( f)17(r)4(om)22( the)8( ISP)-13( to the)8( s)6(ubs)6(c)8(r)4(ibe)8(r)-170(............................)-186(44)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 137.49 297.03 Tm
0 Tc
[(\032\021\027\021\025)-1591(&\\EHUVSDFH\003ZLWKRXW\003,63\003OLDELOLW\\)-217(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\027\030)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 149.49 286.23 Tm
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[(7.4.2.1)-1217(T)14(he)7( U.S. ISP)-14( e)7(x)10(e)7(m)21(ption)-137(......................................................................................)-187(45)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 137.49 274.71 Tm
0 Tc
[(\032\021\027\021\026)-1591(\(XURSHDQ\003SURSRVDOV\003FRQFHUQLQJ\003,63\003OLDELOLW\\)-48(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\027\031)]TJ
0 -1.1807 TD
[(\032\021\027\021\027)-1591(&DVHV\003VXJJHVWLQJ\003WKDW\003,63V\003RU\003%%6\003RSHUDWRUV\003KDYH\003D\003OHJDO\003UHVSRQVLELOLW\\)-205(\021\021)-169(\027\031)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 149.49 252.15 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(7.4.4.1)-1217(N)5(J)5(A)18( 1996:74)-217(.......................................................................................................)-187(46)]TJ
0 -1.1733 TD
[(7.4.4.2)-1217(P)-14(la)7(y)23(boy)23( Ente)7(rprise)7(s v)10(.)0( Fre)7(n)-4(a)-113(...............................................................................)-187(47)]TJ
T*
[(7.4.4.3)-1217(S)-1(e)7(g)10(a)7( Ente)7(rprise)7(s L)14(t)1(d. V)-8(.)0( Ma)7(phia)-46(.........................................................................)-187(47)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 137.49 219.51 Tm
0 Tc
[(\032\021\027\021\030)-1591(&DVHV\003GHQ\\LQJ\003,63\003RU\003%%6\003RSHUDWRU\003UHVSRQVLELOLW\\)-229(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\027\033)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 149.49 208.71 Tm
0.005 Tc
(7.4.5.1)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
4 0 TD
0.003 Tc
[(N)5(J)5(A)18( 1996:79 \223)7(T)14(he)7( BBS-c)7(a)7(s)5(e)7(\224)-180(............................................................................)-187(48)]TJ
-4 -1.1733 TD
[(7.4.5.2)-1217(Z)1(e)7(r)3(a)7(n)-4( v)10(.)0( A)18(m)21(e)7(r)3(ic)7(a)7( Online)-180(.....................................................................................)-187(49)]TJ
T*
[(7.4.5.3)-1217(D)5(oe)7( v)10(.)0( A)18(m)21(e)7(r)3(ic)7(a)7( Online)7( Inc)7(.)-80(.................................................................................)-187(50)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 137.49 176.07 Tm
0 Tc
[(\032\021\027\021\031)-1591(0XVLF\003DUFKLYHV\003LQ\003&\\EHUVSDFH)-169(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\030\023)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
-1.2048 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(7.5)-1146(L)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 155.49 164.31 Tm
-0.006 Tc
0.01 Tw
[(E)-7(G)15(A)15(L)23( R)-11(E)-7(SPONSI)28(B)-11(I)28(L)23(I)28(T)8(Y W)13(H)0(E)-7(N)0( DOW)13(NL)23(OA)15(DI)28(NG)15( PR)-11(OT)8(E)-7(C)-11(T)8(E)-7(D M)-13(A)15(T)8(E)-7(R)-11(I)28(A)15(L)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 421.89 164.31 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(...................)-169(51)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
-28.5542 -1.1807 TD
0 Tc
[(\032\021\030\021\024)-1591(5HVSRQVLELOLW\\\003ZKHQ\003GRZQORDGLQJ\003VRIWZDUH\003IURP\003WKH\003,QWHUQHW)-96(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\030\025)]TJ
T*
[(\032\021\030\021\025)-1591(5HVSRQVLELOLW\\\003ZKHQ\003GRZQORDGLQJ\003PXVLF\003IURP\003WKH\003,QWHUQHW)-193(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\030\026)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
-1.2048 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(7.6)-1146(S)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 155.01 129.03 Tm
[(U)12(MMA)27(RY)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 192.57 129.03 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(..............................................................................................................)-169(54)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
-7.9398 -1.7952 TD
0 Tc
[(\033)-1904(-85,6',&7,21)-24(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021)-169(\030\031)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
1.2048 -1.759 TD
0.005 Tc
[(8.1)-1146(T)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 155.73 93.63 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(HE)-7( I)28(M)-13(POR)-11(T)8(A)15(N)0(C)-11(E)-7( OF)13( JUR)-11(I)28(SDI)28(C)-11(T)8(I)28(ON I)28(N)0( T)8(H)0(E)-7( W)13(O)0(R)-11(L)23(D OF)13( I)28(N)0(F)13(O)0(R)-11(M)-13(A)15(T)8(I)28(ON T)8(E)-7(C)-11(HNOL)23(OG)15(Y)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 149.49 81.87 Tm
0.006 Tc
(56)Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
282 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
283 0 obj
<<
/Length 20228
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 125.49 747.39 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0.005 Tc
[(8.2)-1146(S)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 155.01 747.39 Tm
-0.005 Tc
0.009 Tw
[(W)14(E)-6(DI)29(SH R)-10(U)1(L)24(E)-6(S C)-10(ONC)-10(E)-6(R)-10(NI)29(NG)16( JUR)-10(I)29(SDI)29(C)-10(T)9(I)29(ON)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 323.61 747.39 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(..........................................................)-169(57)]TJ
-19.8916 -1.1807 TD
[(8.3)-1148(U)2(.S. )]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 169.77 735.63 Tm
-0.004 Tc
0.008 Tw
[(JUR)-9(I)30(SDI)30(C)-9(T)10(I)30(ON I)30(SSUES I)30(N)2( B)-9(R)-9(I)30(EF)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 288.33 735.63 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(........................................................................)-169(58)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
-17.5542 -1.7952 TD
0 Tc
[(\034)-1904($0\(5,&$1\003&$6\(6\003,1\003:+,&+\003-85,6',&7,21\003,6\003*5$17\(')-205(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\031\023)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
1.2048 -1.759 TD
0.005 Tc
[(9.1)-1146(U)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 156.69 700.23 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(NI)28(T)8(E)-7(D )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 182.37 700.23 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(S)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 187.89 700.23 Tm
-0.014 Tc
0.018 Tw
[(TA)7(TE)-15(S)-10( V)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 220.29 700.23 Tm
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
(. T)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 231.57 700.23 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(HOM)-13(A)15(S)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 260.61 700.23 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(...................................................................................)-169(60)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
-12.3614 -1.1807 TD
0 Tc
[(\034\021\024\021\024)-1591(7KH\003&DOLIRUQLD\003ZHEVLWH\003GLVWULEXWHG\003REVFHQH\003PDWHULDO\003LQ\0037HQQHVVHH)-108(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\031\023)]TJ
T*
[(\034\021\024\021\025)-1591(7KH\003REVFHQH\003GRZQORDGHG\003PDWHULDO\003GLG\003OHDYH\003WKH\003&DOLIRUQLDQ\003ZHEVLWH)-48(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\031\023)]TJ
T*
[(\034\021\024\021\026)-1591(5HIXVLQJ\003FXVWRPHUV\003LQ\003FHUWDLQ\003MXULVGLFWLRQV\003LQ\003RUGHU\003WR\003GLPLQLVK\003ULVN\003RI)]TJ
T*
[(OLDELOLW\\)-494(\031\024)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
-1.2048 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(9.2)-1146(I)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 152.85 641.43 Tm
-0.005 Tc
[(NSE)-6(T)9( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 174.81 641.43 Tm
0 Tc
(S)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 180.33 641.43 Tm
-0.005 Tc
[(YST)9(E)-6(M)-12(S)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 211.89 641.43 Tm
0.003 Tc
(, I)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 220.29 641.43 Tm
-0.006 Tc
(NC)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 231.45 641.43 Tm
0.003 Tc
(. )Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 236.49 641.43 Tm
0 Tc
(V)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 242.25 641.43 Tm
0.003 Tc
(. I)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 250.65 641.43 Tm
-0.005 Tc
[(NST)9(R)-10(UC)-10(T)9(I)29(ONS )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 307.41 641.43 Tm
0 Tc
(S)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 312.93 641.43 Tm
0.001 Tc
(ET)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 322.65 641.43 Tm
0.003 Tc
(, I)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 331.05 641.43 Tm
-0.006 Tc
(NC)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 342.21 641.43 Tm
0 Tc
(.)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 344.73 641.43 Tm
( )Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 348.81 641.43 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(................................................)-169(61)]TJ
ET
1 i
344.73 640.35 1.8 -0.36 re
f
BT
/F6 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 137.49 629.67 Tm
0 Tc
[(\034\021\025\021\024)-1591(:HEVLWH\003DGYHUWLVHPHQW\003IXOILOOHG\003WKH\003\263PLQLPXP\003FRQWDFWV\003WHVW\264)-205(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\031\024)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
-1.2048 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(9.3)-1146(P)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 155.13 617.91 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(L)23(A)15(YB)-11(OY )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 190.17 617.91 Tm
0 Tc
(E)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 196.29 617.91 Tm
0.001 Tc
0.003 Tw
[(N)7(T)15(ERPRI)35(S)5(ES V)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 251.01 617.91 Tm
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
(. C)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 262.65 617.91 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(HUC)-11(K)15(L)23(E)-7(B)-11(E)-7(R)-11(R)-11(Y)0( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 323.73 617.91 Tm
0 Tc
(P)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 329.37 617.91 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(UB)-11(L)23(I)28(SHI)28(N)0(G)15( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 373.65 617.91 Tm
0 Tc
(I)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 377.01 617.91 Tm
-0.006 Tc
(NC)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 388.17 617.91 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(.)-96(...............................)-169(62)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
-25.1687 -1.1807 TD
0 Tc
[(\034\021\026\021\024)-1591(3ODFLQJ\003LQIRUPDWLRQ\003RQ\003DQ\003,WDOLDQ\003VHUYHU\003LV\003HTXLYDOHQW)-193(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\031\025)]TJ
T*
[(\034\021\026\021\024)-1591(RI\003GLVWULEXWLQJ\003WKH\003LQIRUPDWLRQ\003ZLWKLQ\003WKH\0038\0216\021)-181(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\031\026)]TJ
T*
[(\034\021\026\021\025)-1591(,WDOLDQ\003SXEOLVKHU\003RUGHUHG\003WR\003LJQRUH\0038\0216\021\003XVHUV\003RU\003VKXW\003GRZQ\003WKH\003VLWH)-157(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\031\026)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
-1.2048 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(9.4)-1146(C)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 156.09 570.87 Tm
-0.005 Tc
[(OM)-12(PU)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 179.25 570.87 Tm
0 Tc
(S)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 184.77 570.87 Tm
0.003 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(ERV)9(E)2( V)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 213.57 570.87 Tm
0 Tw
(. P)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 224.25 570.87 Tm
-0.014 Tc
[(A)7(TTE)-15(R)-19(S)-10(O)-8(N)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 268.17 570.87 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(................................................................................)-169(63)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
-13.1205 -1.1807 TD
0 Tc
[(\034\021\027\021\024)-1591($\003IHZ\003VDOHV\003YLD\003WKH\003,QWHUQHW\003DUH\003FRQVLGHUHG\003VXIILFLHQW\003FRQWDFWV\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\031\027)]TJ
T*
[(\034\021\027\021\025)-1591(6WXEERUQ\003IRFXV\003RQ\003WKH\003SK\\VLFDO\003SODFHPHQW\003RI\003WKH\003VHUYHU)-84(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\031\027)]TJ
T*
[(\034\021\027\021\026)-1591(3RVVLELOLW\\\003RI\003\263VHUYHU\003KDYHQV\264\003LQ\003UHPRWH\003ORFDWLRQV)-205(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\031\030)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
-1.2048 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(9.5)-1146(M)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 158.37 523.83 Tm
-0.021 Tc
[(AR)-26(I)13(T)-7(Z)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 181.41 523.83 Tm
0.003 Tc
(, I)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 189.81 523.83 Tm
-0.006 Tc
(NC)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 200.97 523.83 Tm
0.003 Tc
(. )Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 206.01 523.83 Tm
0 Tc
(V)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 211.77 523.83 Tm
0.003 Tc
(. C)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 223.41 523.83 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(YB)-11(E)-7(R)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 244.89 523.83 Tm
0 Tc
(G)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 252.09 523.83 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(OL)23(D)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 268.29 523.83 Tm
0.003 Tc
(, I)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 276.69 523.83 Tm
-0.006 Tc
(NC)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 287.85 523.83 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(.)-48(.......................................................................)-169(65)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
-15.0964 -1.1807 TD
0 Tc
[(\034\021\030\021\024)-1591(0LQLPXP\003FRQWDFWV)-36(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\031\031)]TJ
T*
[(\034\021\030\021\025)-1591(7KH\003LQWHQW\003RI\003VHWWLQJ\003XS\003D\003VLWH\003FDQ\003GHFLGH\003ZKHWKHU\003LW\003LV\003FODVVLILHG\003DV\003SDVVLYH)]TJ
T*
[(RU\003DFWLYH)-72(\031\031)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
-1.2048 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(9.6)-1146(P)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 155.13 476.79 Tm
-0.021 Tc
[(AN)-15(AV)-15(I)13(S)-17(I)13(O)-15(N)-15( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 200.73 476.79 Tm
0 Tc
(I)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 204.09 476.79 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(NT)8(E)-7(R)-11(NA)15(T)8(I)28(ONA)15(L)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 265.41 476.79 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(, L)12(.)0(P)-7(,)0( )]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 289.65 476.79 Tm
0 Tc
(V)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 295.41 476.79 Tm
0.003 Tc
(. D)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 307.65 476.79 Tm
-0.005 Tc
[(E)-6(NNI)29(S )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 332.97 476.79 Tm
0 Tc
(T)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 339.21 476.79 Tm
-0.002 Tc
(OEPPEN)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 371.49 476.79 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(.......................................)-169(67)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
-23.494 -1.1807 TD
0 Tc
[(\034\021\031\021\024)-1591(7KH\003WKUHH\020SDUW\003WHVW\003FRQFHUQLQJ\003VSHFLILF\003MXULVGLFWLRQ)-193(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\031\032)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
-1.2048 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(9.7)-1146(S)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 155.01 453.27 Tm
-0.014 Tc
0.018 Tw
[(TA)7(TE)-15( O)-8(F)5( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 189.33 453.27 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(M)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 198.21 453.27 Tm
-0.006 Tc
0.01 Tw
[(I)28(NNE)-7(SOT)8(A)15( V)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 245.49 453.27 Tm
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
(. G)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 257.73 453.27 Tm
0.005 Tc
[(RA)26(N)11(I)39(T)19(E)4( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 288.69 453.27 Tm
0 Tc
(G)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 295.89 453.27 Tm
-0.021 Tc
[(AT)-7(E)-22( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 313.29 453.27 Tm
0 Tc
(R)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 319.89 453.27 Tm
-0.002 Tc
[(ESO)4(R)-7(T)12(S)2( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 351.69 453.27 Tm
0 Tc
(I)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 355.05 453.27 Tm
-0.006 Tc
(NC)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 366.21 453.27 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(.)-24(........................................)-169(68)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
-22.9639 -1.1807 TD
0 Tc
[(\034\021\032\021\024)-1591(/DV\0039HJDV\003,QWHUQHW\003DGYHUWLVHPHQW\003YLRODWHG\0030LQQHVRWD\003FRQVXPHU\003SURWHFWLRQ)]TJ
3.6145 -1.1807 TD
(\031\033)Tj
-3.6145 -1.1807 TD
[(\034\021\032\021\025)-1591($\003GLVFODLPHU\003RQ\003WKH\003ZHEVLWH\003QRW\003HQRXJK\003WR\003DYRLG\0030LQQHVRWD\003MXULVGLFWLRQ)-217(\021\021\021)-169(\031\034)]TJ
T*
[(\034\021\032\021\026)-1591(,QWHUQHW\003DGYHUWLVHPHQWV\003PRUH\003SHUYDVLYH\003WKDQ\003WUDGLWLRQDO\003DGYHUWLVHPHQWV)-12(\021\021\021\021)-169(\031\034)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
-1.2048 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(9.8)-1146(H)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 156.69 394.47 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(ERO)9(E)2(S)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 182.13 394.47 Tm
(, I)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 190.53 394.47 Tm
-0.006 Tc
(NC)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 201.69 394.47 Tm
0.003 Tc
(. )Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 206.73 394.47 Tm
0 Tc
(V)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 212.49 394.47 Tm
0.003 Tc
(. H)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 224.73 394.47 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(ERO)5(E)-2(S )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 252.21 394.47 Tm
0 Tc
(F)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 257.73 394.47 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(OUNDA)15(T)8(I)28(ON)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 305.97 394.47 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(.................................................................)-169(70)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
-16.9157 -1.1807 TD
0 Tc
[(\034\021\033\021\024)-1591($\003ZHEVLWH\003DQG\003DGYHUWLVHPHQW\003LQ\003D\003QHZVSDSHU\003LV\003HQRXJK\003WR\003H[HUFLVH)]TJ
T*
[(MXULVGLFWLRQ\003LQ\003&ROXPELD)-205(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\032\024)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
-1.2048 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(9.9)-1146(Z)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 155.49 359.19 Tm
-0.005 Tc
[(I)29(PPO )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 174.57 359.19 Tm
0 Tc
(M)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 183.45 359.19 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(A)15(NUF)13(A)15(C)-11(T)8(U)0(R)-11(I)28(NG)15( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 247.77 359.19 Tm
0 Tc
(C)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 254.37 359.19 Tm
(O)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 260.13 359.19 Tm
0.003 Tc
(. )Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 265.17 359.19 Tm
0 Tc
(V)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 270.93 359.19 Tm
0.003 Tc
(. Z)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 281.97 359.19 Tm
-0.005 Tc
[(I)29(PPO )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 301.05 359.19 Tm
0 Tc
(D)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 308.25 359.19 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(OT)8( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 320.85 359.19 Tm
0 Tc
(C)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 327.45 359.19 Tm
-0.006 Tc
(OM)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 340.41 359.19 Tm
0.003 Tc
(, I)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 348.81 359.19 Tm
-0.006 Tc
(NC)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 359.97 359.19 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(.)-145(..........................................)-169(71)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
-22.3373 -1.1807 TD
0 Tc
[(\034\021\034\021\024)-1591(7KH\003OHYHO\003RI\003FRPPHUFLDO\003DFWLYLW\\\003DQG\003LQWHUDFWLYLW\\\003RI\003ZHEVLWHV)-12(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\032\025)]TJ
T*
[(\034\021\034\021\025)-1591(\(QWHULQJ\003LQWR\003FRQWUDFW\003DQG\003WUDQVPLWWLQJ\003FRPSXWHU\003ILOHV\003YLD\003WKH\003,QWHUQHW\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\032\025)]TJ
T*
[(\034\021\034\021\026)-1591(3DVVLYH\003ZHEVLWHV)-24(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\032\025)]TJ
T*
[(\034\021\034\021\027)-1591(,QWHUDFWLYLW\\)-48(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\032\026)]TJ
T*
[(\034\021\034\021\030)-1591(7KH\003'RW\003&RP\003ZHEVLWH\003ZDV\003PRUH\003WKDQ\003LQWHUDFWLYH\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\032\026)]TJ
T*
[(\034\021\034\021\031)-1591($QDORJ\\\003EHWZHHQ\003SDVVLYH\003ZHEVLWHV\003DQG\003SDSHUEDFN\003DGYHUWLVHPHQWV)-168(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\032\026)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
-1.2048 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(9.10)-1844(C)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 168.09 276.87 Tm
-0.006 Tc
0.01 Tw
(ODY V)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 193.17 276.87 Tm
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
(. W)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 207.69 276.87 Tm
-0.021 Tc
[(AR)-26(D)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 225.33 276.87 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(.................................................................................................)-169(74)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
-8.8193 -1.1807 TD
0 Tc
[(\034\021\024\023\021\024)-1085(\)LIWHHQ\003H\020PDLOV\003DQG\003D\003IRXU\003SKRQH\003FDOOV\003IXOILOOV\003WKH\003UHTXLUHPHQW\003RI\003SXUSRVHIXO)]TJ
T*
[(PLQLPXP\003FRQWDFWV\003ZLWK\003&RQQHFWLFXW)-217(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\032\027)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
-1.2048 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(9.11)-1844(D)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 168.69 241.59 Tm
-0.034 Tc
[(IG)-13(IT)-20(A)-13(L)-5( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 196.29 241.59 Tm
0 Tc
(E)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 202.41 241.59 Tm
-0.005 Tc
[(QUI)29(PM)-12(E)-6(N)1(T)9( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 245.49 241.59 Tm
0 Tc
(C)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 252.09 241.59 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(OR)-11(P)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 267.69 241.59 Tm
0.003 Tc
(. )Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 272.73 241.59 Tm
0 Tc
(V)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 278.49 241.59 Tm
0.003 Tc
(. A)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 290.61 241.59 Tm
-0.032 Tc
[(LT)-18(A)-11(V)-26(IS)-28(T)-18(A)-11( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 330.81 241.59 Tm
0 Tc
(T)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 337.05 241.59 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(E)-7(C)-11(HNOL)23(OG)15(Y )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 388.53 241.59 Tm
0 Tc
(I)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 391.89 241.59 Tm
-0.006 Tc
(NC)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 403.05 241.59 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(.)-120(.........................)-169(75)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
-26.6627 -1.1807 TD
0 Tc
[(\034\021\024\024\021\024)-1085(&RQIXVLQJO\\\003VLPLODU\003ZHEVLWHV)-205(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\032\030)]TJ
T*
[(\034\021\024\024\021\025)-1085($\003FRQVWDQWO\\\003DFFHVVLEOH\003ZHEVLWH\003LV\003D\003VLJQ\003RI\003FRQGXFWLQJ\003EXVLQHVV\003LQ)]TJ
T*
[(0DVVDFKXVHWWV)-193(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\032\031)]TJ
T*
[(\034\021\024\024\021\026)-1085(&RQVHTXHQFHV\003RI\003EXVLQHVV\003LQ\003&\\EHUVSDFH\003VKRXOG\003EH\003FRQVLGHUHG\003LQ\003DGYDQFH\032\031)]TJ
T*
[(\034\021\024\024\021\027)-1085(&RVW\003HIILFLHQF\\\003DQG\003MXULVGLFWLRQ)-217(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\032\031)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
-1.2048 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(9.12)-1844(H)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 168.69 171.03 Tm
-0.029 Tc
0.033 Tw
[(A)-8(LL V)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 191.49 171.03 Tm
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
(. L)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 202.53 171.03 Tm
0 Tc
(A)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 208.17 171.03 Tm
(R)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 214.77 171.03 Tm
-0.006 Tc
(ONDE)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 237.93 171.03 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(............................................................................................)-169(76)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
-10.0843 -1.1807 TD
0 Tc
[(\034\021\024\025\021\024)-1085(\(\020PDLO\003DQG\003WHOHSKRQH\003FDOOV\003ZHUH\003WKH\003RQO\\\003FRQWDFWV\003EHWZHHQ\003WKH\003SDUWLHV)-84(\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\032\032)]TJ
T*
[(\034\021\024\025\021\025)-1085(*HQHUDO\003SHUVRQDO\003MXULVGLFWLRQ)-97(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\032\032)]TJ
T*
[(\034\021\024\025\021\026)-1085(6SHFLILF\003SHUVRQDO\003MXULVGLFWLRQ)-205(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\032\032)]TJ
T*
[(\034\021\024\025\021\027)-1085(0LQLPXP\003FRQWDFWV\003FDQ\003EH\003HOHFWURQLF)-193(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\032\032)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 149.49 113.19 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(9.12.4.1)-2044(P)-14(e)7(ople)7( v)10(.)0( L)14(i)1(psitz)-20(.............................................................................................)-187(78)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 137.49 101.67 Tm
0 Tc
[(\034\021\024\025\021\030)-1085(1R\003DOWHUQDWLYH\003WUHDWLQJ\003RI\003&\\EHUVSDFH\003LVVXHV)-241(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\032\033)]TJ
T*
[(\034\021\024\025\021\031)-1085(-XULVGLFWLRQDO\003FRQVLGHUDWLRQV)-36(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\032\034)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
284 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
285 0 obj
<<
/Length 11689
>>
stream
BT
/F2 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 113.49 747.27 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
[(\024\023)-1398($0\(5,&$1\003&$6\(6\003,1\003:+,&+\003-85,6',&7,21\003,6\0035\(\)86\(')-24(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\033\023)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
1.2048 -1.759 TD
0.005 Tc
[(10.1)-1844(P)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 167.13 729.75 Tm
0.003 Tc
(RES)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 181.89 729.75 Tm
-0.008 Tc
(-K)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 192.33 729.75 Tm
-0.021 Tc
[(AP)-17( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 204.45 729.75 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(I)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 207.81 729.75 Tm
-0.006 Tc
(NC)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 218.97 729.75 Tm
0.003 Tc
(. )Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 224.01 729.75 Tm
0 Tc
(V)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 229.77 729.75 Tm
0.003 Tc
(. S)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 240.33 729.75 Tm
-0.005 Tc
[(YST)9(E)-6(M)-12( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 269.49 729.75 Tm
0 Tc
(O)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 276.69 729.75 Tm
-0.006 Tc
(NE)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 287.37 729.75 Tm
0.003 Tc
(, D)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 299.61 729.75 Tm
-0.034 Tc
[(IR)-39(E)-35(C)-39(T)-20( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 324.57 729.75 Tm
0 Tc
(A)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 331.65 729.75 Tm
0.004 Tc
[(CCES)8(S)8( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 358.29 729.75 Tm
0 Tc
(I)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 361.65 729.75 Tm
-0.006 Tc
(NC)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 372.81 729.75 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(.)-120(.....................................)-169(80)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
-23.6265 -1.1807 TD
0 Tc
[(\024\023\021\024\021\024)-1085(3ODFHPHQW\003RI\003VHUYHU\003LUUHOHYDQW)-60(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\033\023)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
-1.2048 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(10.2)-1844(B)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 168.21 706.23 Tm
-0.004 Tc
[(ENSUSA)17(N )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 206.97 706.23 Tm
0 Tc
(R)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 213.57 706.23 Tm
-0.014 Tc
[(E)-15(S)-10(TA)7(U)-8(R)-19(A)7(N)-8(T )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 262.77 706.23 Tm
0 Tc
(C)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 269.37 706.23 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(OR)-11(P)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 284.97 706.23 Tm
0.003 Tc
(. V. R)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 308.85 706.23 Tm
-0.034 Tc
[(IC)-39(H)-28(A)-13(R)-39(D)-28( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 341.25 706.23 Tm
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
(B. K)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 360.21 706.23 Tm
-0.034 Tc
[(IN)-28(G)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 374.01 706.23 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(......................................)-169(81)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
-23.747 -1.1807 TD
0 Tc
[(\024\023\021\025\021\024)-1085($\003JHQHUDO\017\003SDVVLYH\003ZHEVLWH\003GRHV\003QRW\003IRFXV\003RQ\003DQ\\\003SDUWLFXODU\003MXULVGLFWLRQ)-145(\021\021\021)-169(\033\024)]TJ
T*
[(\024\023\021\025\021\025)-1085(7KUHH\003IDFWRUV\003GHWHUPLQLQJ\003MXULVGLFWLRQ)-217(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\033\025)]TJ
T*
[(\024\023\021\025\021\026)-1085($\003JHQHUDO\017\003SDVVLYH\003ZHEVLWH\003DORQH\003FDQQRW\003VXEMHFW\003D\003ZHE\020HGLWRU\003WR\003RWKHU)]TJ
T*
[(IRUXP\266V\003MXULVGLFWLRQV)-181(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\033\025)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
-1.2048 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(10.3)-1844(H)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 168.69 647.43 Tm
0.001 Tc
[(EA)22(RST)15( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 195.93 647.43 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(C)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 202.53 647.43 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(OR)-11(POR)-11(A)15(T)8(I)28(ON)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 253.65 647.43 Tm
0.003 Tc
(. )Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 258.69 647.43 Tm
0 Tc
(V)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 264.45 647.43 Tm
0.003 Tc
(. A)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 276.57 647.43 Tm
0.005 Tc
[(RI)39( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 286.41 647.43 Tm
0 Tc
(G)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 293.61 647.43 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(OL)23(DB)-11(E)-7(R)-11(G)15(E)-7(R)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 343.77 647.43 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(..................................................)-169(83)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
-20.7108 -1.1807 TD
0 Tc
[(\024\023\021\026\021\024)-1085($\003ZHEVLWH\003LV\003DQDORJRXV\003WR\003D\003WUDGLWLRQDO\003DGYHUWLVHPHQW\003LQ\003D\003SDSHU\003PDJD]LQH)]TJ
3.6145 -1.1807 TD
(\033\026)Tj
-3.6145 -1.1807 TD
[(\024\023\021\026\021\025)-1085(-XULVGLFWLRQ\003EDVHG\003XSRQ\003VROHO\\\003D\003ZHEVLWH\003ZRXOG\003FUHDWH)-157(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\033\026)]TJ
T*
[(\024\023\021\026\021\025)-1085(ZRUOGZLGH\003MXULVGLFWLRQ)-145(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\033\027)]TJ
T*
[(\024\023\021\026\021\026)-1085($\003ZHEVLWH\003GLUHFWHG\003DW\003WKH\003ZKROH\003ZRUOG\003FRXOG\003EH\003HTXLYDOHQW\003RI\003D\003QDWLRQDO)]TJ
T*
[(PDJD]LQH)-157(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\033\027)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
-1.2048 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(10.4)-1844(C)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 168.09 565.11 Tm
-0.005 Tc
[(YB)-10(E)-6(R)-10(SE)-6(L)24(L)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 208.29 565.11 Tm
0.003 Tc
(, I)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 216.69 565.11 Tm
-0.006 Tc
(NC)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 227.85 565.11 Tm
0.003 Tc
(., )Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 235.41 565.11 Tm
0 Tc
(V)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 241.17 565.11 Tm
0.003 Tc
(. C)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 252.81 565.11 Tm
-0.005 Tc
[(YB)-10(E)-6(R)-10(SE)-6(L)24(L)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 293.01 565.11 Tm
0.003 Tc
(, I)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 301.41 565.11 Tm
-0.006 Tc
(NC)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 312.57 565.11 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(.)-96(.............................................................)-169(84)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
-17.5783 -1.1807 TD
0 Tc
[(\024\023\021\027\021\024)-1085(7KUHH\020SDUW\003WHVW\003LQ\003RUGHU\003WR\003H[HUFLVH\003VSHFLILF\003MXULVGLFWLRQ)-145(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\033\030)]TJ
T*
[(\024\023\021\027\021\025)-1085(6ROHO\\\003D\003ZHEVLWH\003GLG\003QRW\003WULJJHU\003MXULVGLFWLRQ)-133(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\033\030)]TJ
T*
[(\024\023\021\027\021\026)-1085($\003SDVVLYH\003VLWH\003ZLWK\003QR\003FRPPHUFLDO\003DFWLYLWLHV\003UHODWLQJ\003WR\003WKH\003MXULVGLFWLRQ)-97(\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\033\031)]TJ
T*
[(\024\023\021\027\021\027)-1085(0F\021'RQRXJK\003Y\021\003\)DOORQ\0030F\(OOLJRWW\017\003,QF\021)-60(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021)-169(\033\031)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
-2.4096 -1.7952 TD
[(\024\024)-1398(&21&/86,21\0035\(*$5',1*\0037+\(\003&$6\(6\003,192/9,1*\003-85,6',&7,21)-120(\021\021)-169(\033\032)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
1.2048 -1.759 TD
0.005 Tc
[(11.1)-1844(I)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 164.85 482.67 Tm
-0.005 Tc
0.009 Tw
[(NT)9(E)-6(R)-10(A)16(C)-10(T)9(I)29(VI)29(T)9(Y)1( A)16(ND PA)16(SSI)29(VI)29(T)9(Y)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 285.81 482.67 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(.........................................................................)-169(87)]TJ
-16.0964 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(11.2)-1844(D)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 168.69 470.91 Tm
[(I)39(S)9(CL)34(A)26(I)39(MERS)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 217.77 470.91 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(....................................................................................................)-169(88)]TJ
-9.2651 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(11.3)-1844(A)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 168.57 459.15 Tm
-0.005 Tc
[(VA)16(I)29(L)24(I)29(N)1(G)16( ONE)-6(SE)-6(L)24(F)14( OF)14( T)9(H)1(E)-6( PR)-10(I)29(V)1(I)29(L)24(E)-6(G)16(E)-6( OF)14( C)-10(ONDUC)-10(T)9(I)29(NG)16( B)-10(U)1(SI)29(NE)-6(SS W)14(I)29(T)9(H)1(I)29(N)1( T)9(H)1(E)]TJ
-5.3582 -1.4627 TD
0.004 Tc
0 Tw
[(F)23(O)10(REI)38(G)25(N)10( J)5(U)10(RI)38(S)8(D)10(I)38(C)-1(T)18(I)38(O)10(N)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 215.25 447.39 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(.....................................................................................................)-169(88)]TJ
-9.012 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(11.4)-1844(T)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 167.73 435.63 Tm
-0.005 Tc
0.009 Tw
[(HE)-6( PHYSI)29(C)-10(A)16(L)24( L)24(O)1(C)-10(A)16(T)9(I)29(ON OF)14( SE)-6(R)-10(V)1(E)-6(R)-10(S A)16(ND DA)16(T)9(A)16(B)-10(A)16(SE)-6(S)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 379.05 435.63 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(....................................)-169(88)]TJ
-25.4578 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(11.5)-1844(E)2(-)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 170.85 423.87 Tm
-0.006 Tc
0.01 Tw
[(M)-13(A)15(I)28(L)23( C)-11(ONT)8(A)15(C)-11(T)8(S)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 235.41 423.87 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(.............................................................................................)-169(89)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
-12.241 -1.7952 TD
0 Tc
[(\024\025)-1398(7+\(\00352/\(\0032\)\0031$7,21$/\003/\(*$/\003\)5$0\(:25.6\003,1\003$)]TJ
0 -1.1687 TD
[(08/7,1$7,21$/\003&<%\(5:25/')-108(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021)-169(\034\023)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
1.2048 -1.759 TD
0.005 Tc
[(12.1)-1844(V)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 168.69 376.83 Tm
-0.034 Tc
[(IR)-39(T)-20(U)-28(A)-13(L)-5( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 199.41 376.83 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(C)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 206.01 376.83 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(YB)-11(E)-7(R)-11(C)-11(OUR)-11(T)8(S)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 260.61 376.83 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(...................................................................................)-169(90)]TJ
-13.5663 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
[(12.2)-1844(I)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 164.85 365.07 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(NT)8(E)-7(R)-11(NA)15(T)8(I)28(ONA)15(L)23( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 228.21 365.07 Tm
0 Tc
(C)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 234.81 365.07 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(OPYR)-11(I)28(G)15(HT)8( )]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 276.81 365.07 Tm
0 Tc
(T)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 283.05 365.07 Tm
0.003 Tc
[(REA)24(T)17(I)37(E)2(S)]TJ
9.96 0 0 9.96 316.05 365.07 Tm
[(.............................................................)-169(90)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
-20.3373 -1.7952 TD
0 Tc
[(\024\026)-1398(&21&/86,21)-12(\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\021\
\021\021\021)-169(\034\025)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
286 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
287 0 obj
<<
/Length 5550
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 294.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
0 Tw
(1)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
24 0 0 24 113.49 733.71 Tm
[(\024\003)-310(,QWURGXFWLRQ)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 693.27 Tm
[(I)23(n)0( the modern society)30( of today)30(,)0( it is difficult not to be influenced in any)30( way)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(by)29( the rapidly)29( evolving)9( computer technolog)9(y)29( that enables people to)]TJ
T*
[(communicate without respect to g)9(e)3(og)9(raphical or national borders at a)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(rem)-4(a)2(rkabl)-4(e)2( l)-4(o)-2(w cost)-4(. One coul)-4(d say)28( t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( C)-5(y)28(berspace i)-4(s)-3( g)8(r)1(owi)-4(n)-2(g)8( wi)-4(t)-4(h)-2( such)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(confidence and speed, that it may)29( very)29( well become an additional world,)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
(parallel to the \223real\224 world. Authorities, companies and individuals around)Tj
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(the)5( g)11(l)-1(obe)5( a)5(r)4(e)5( on the)5( e)5(d)1(g)11(e)5( of re)5(a)5(lizing)11( the)5( va)5(st pote)5(n)1(tia)5(ls of this ne)5(w swe)5(lling)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(electronic world. I)22(f)2( one chooses to enter Cy)29(berspace, one can be seen)]TJ
T*
[(every)29(w)1(here, be contacted by)29( any)29(one and contact any)29(one, no matter where)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(the parties are phy)30(sically)30( situated on the g)10(l)-2(obe. I)23( am of the opinion that it is)]TJ
T*
[(fa)4(ir to sa)4(y)30( tha)4(t)-2( this ne)4(w world is sa)4(tura)4(te)4(d with dig)10(itize)4(d)0( informa)4(tion of)]TJ
T*
[(va)4(rie)4(d)0( qua)4(lity)30( a)4(nd importa)4(nc)4(e)4(.)0( Due)4( to the)4( fa)4(c)4(t)-2( tha)4(t)-2( a)4(ll informa)4(tion is)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(dig)9(itized, virtually)29( every)29(one can reproduce every)29(t)-3(hing)9( flowing)9( throug)9(h the)]TJ
T*
[(g)9(i)-3(ant sy)29(stem. I)22(n)-1(tellectual property)29(,)-1( as a whole, has never ex)-11(perienced such a)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(haz)-6(a)4(rdous environment, as it does in Cy)30(berspace. I)23(n)0( this thesis I)23( will try)30( to)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(point out the new rapidly)29( developing)9( dang)9(ers concerning)9( intellectual)]TJ
T*
[(property)29( in Cy)29(berspace. S)-5(i)-3(nce one cannot investig)9(ate and analy)29(z)-7(e every)29(t)-3(hing)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(about every)30(t)-2(hing)10(, one is unfortunately)30( forced to limit the thesis to cover)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(merely)29( a few areas of this ex)-11(tremely)29( interesting)9( field. I)22( have chosen to study)]TJ
T*
[(various intellectual property)29( issues from a Swedish perspective. However,)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(sinc)5(e)5( the)5( Swe)5(d)1(ish le)5(g)11(a)5(l sy)31(ste)5(m)-1( a)5(t)-1( this point in time)5( only)31( is on the)5( ve)5(rg)11(e)5( of)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(g)8(r)1(aspi)-4(ng)8( t)-4(h)-2(e pot)-4(ent)-4(i)-4(a)2(l)-4( dang)8(ers t)-4(o)-2( i)-4(n)-2(t)-4(e)2(l)-4(l)-4(ect)-4(ual)-4( propert)-4(y)28( i)-4(n)-2( C)-5(y)28(berspace, I)21( have)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(chosen to investig)10(ate and focus intensively)30( on the leg)10(a)4(l developments)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(concerning)9( these issues in the U.S. Since Europe is roug)9(hly)29( lag)9(g)9(i)-3(ng)9( two or)]TJ
T*
[(three y)29(ears behind the U.S. reg)9(a)3(rding)9( the I)22(n)-1(ternet, I)22( believe it is of hig)9(h)-1(est)]TJ
T*
[(importance to study)29( their problems and possibly)29( be able to take advantag)9(e of)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(some of their leg)10(a)4(l solutions. Even thoug)10(h the leg)10(a)4(l sy)30(stems are completely)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(different, one should not completely)29( ig)9(nore the American case law, because)]TJ
T*
[(such cases may)29( provide helpful g)9(u)-1(idance to various problems that may)29( arise)]TJ
T*
[(in Cy)29(berspace. One must realiz)-7(e that Cy)29(berspace is not at all bound by)29( any)]TJ
T*
[(national borders. I)22(t)-3( is a universal reg)9(i)-3(on where all the leg)9(a)3(l sy)29(stems of the)]TJ
T*
[(world may)29( intersect in one way)29( or another.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(The)5( ma)5(te)5(ria)5(l)-1( I)24( ha)5(ve)5( studie)5(d)1( c)5(onsists of la)5(ws, le)5(g)11(a)5(l lite)5(ra)5(ture)5(, le)5(g)11(a)5(l a)5(r)4(tic)5(le)5(s,)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(c)4(a)4(s)-1(e)4(s)-1( a)4(nd va)4(rious othe)4(r le)4(g)10(a)4(l doc)4(ume)4(n)0(ts. Ma)4(ny)30( of the)4( sourc)4(e)4(s)-1( I)23( ha)4(ve)4( utilize)4(d)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(are electronic, and I)22( have supplied all the web addresses in the footnotes, in)]TJ
T*
[(order to facilitate further reading)9(.)-1( The dates supplied after the websites)]TJ
T*
[(indicate the day)29( the sites were viewed. Primarily)29(, I)22( briefly)29( describe the)]TJ
T*
[(history)29( of the I)22(n)-1(ternet before describing)9( specific I)22(n)-1(ternet related problems,)]TJ
T*
[(such as l)-3(i)-3(nki)-3(ng)9(, cachi)-3(n)-1(g)9(,)-1( prox)-11(y)29(cachi)-3(n)-1(g)9( and dom)-3(ai)-3(n nam)-3(e)3(s. Aft)-3(e)3(r t)-3(h)-1(i)-3(s)-2(, I)]TJ
T*
[(describe the various problems of intellectual property)29( piracy)29(, and determine)]TJ
T*
(who is responsible when music, software and pictures are copied, uploaded,)Tj
T*
[(stored and downloaded. I)22( describe the problems concerning)9( I)22(SP and B)6(B)6(S)-5(-)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(ope)4(ra)4(tor lia)4(bility)30(. I)23(n)0( a)4(ddition to this, I)23( ha)4(ve)4( c)4(hose)4(n)0( to study)30( the)4( proble)4(m)-2( of)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
288 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
291 0 obj
<<
/Length 566
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 294.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
0 Tw
(2)Tj
-15.1 58.94 TD
[(jurisdiction in Cy)30(berspace. I)23(f)3( one does not know which jurisdiction that is)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(considered the proper one, there is a risk that much of one\222s national leg)9(a)3(l)]TJ
T*
[(knowledg)9(e concerning)9( intellectual property)29( becomes superfluous. I)22(t)-3( is)]TJ
T*
[(important to know where one can sue and which country)29(\222s laws that are)]TJ
T*
(applicable and which ones that are not.)Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
292 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
293 0 obj
<<
/Length 4398
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 294.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
0 Tw
(3)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
24 0 0 24 113.49 733.71 Tm
[(\025\003)-310(%ULHI\003KLVWRU\\\003RI\003WKH\003HYROXWLRQ)]TJ
0 -1.175 TD
(DQG\003JURZWK\003RI\003WKH\003,QWHUQHW)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 665.07 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(I)22(t)-3( is not until recently)29( that the I)22(n)-1(ternet has become an important every)29(d)-1(ay)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(tool for all various sorts of people around the g)9(l)-3(obe. The orig)9(ins of the)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(I)21(n)-2(t)-4(e)2(rnet)-4( are norm)-4(a)2(l)-4(l)-4(y)28( t)-4(r)1(aced back t)-4(o)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e Advanced R)-5(e)2(search P)-6(r)1(oj)-4(ect)-4(s)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Ag)9(ency)29(\222s developments undertaken by)29( the American Department of Defense)]TJ
T*
[(in the 1960s. Some of the basic concepts from these day)29(s)-2( have been refined)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(a)4(nd modifie)4(d)0( a)4(nd a)4(r)3(e)4( no long)10(e)4(r)3( sole)4(ly)30( se)4(rving)10( milita)4(ry)30( purpose)4(s)-1(, suc)4(h)0( a)4(s)-1( e)4(-)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(mail, file transfers etc. I)22(n)-1( those day)29(s)-2(, not much but unformatted tex)-11(t)-3(-)]TJ
T*
(transfers were supported. One crucial factor of the enormous success of the)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(I)23(n)0(ternet lies in the fact that it encourag)10(es transmission not only)30( of tex)-10(t)-2(, but)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(also of various kinds of complicated g)9(r)2(aphics. I)22(n)-1( the future, the amount of)]TJ
T*
[(users havi)-3(ng)9( an I)22(n)-1(t)-3(e)3(rnet)-3( access wi)-3(t)-3(h)-1( suffi)-3(ci)-3(ent)-3( bandwi)-3(d)-1(t)-3(h)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 387.57 528.99 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(1)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 391.65 523.47 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[( may)28( play)28( an)]TJ
-23.18 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(important role since the applications are rapidly)29( becoming)9( larg)9(er and tend to)]TJ
T*
(use up more and more bandwidth.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 276.57 500.67 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(2)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 280.65 495.15 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[( Today)28(,)-2( the very)28( heavy)28( traffic of packets)]TJ
-13.93 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(flowing)10( throug)10(h the)4( wire)4(s c)4(onta)4(i)-2(ning)10( re)4(a)4(l)-2(-time)4( g)10(r)3(a)4(phic)4( a)4(nd a)4(udio e)4(t)-2(c)4( ha)4(s)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(lead to a severe cong)9(estion of the telecommunication infrastructure. Once)]TJ
T*
[(the problem of cong)9(estion is solved, a g)9(r)2(eat deal more audiovisual packets)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(ma)5(y)31( be)5( a)5(b)1(le)5( to pa)5(ss throug)11(h the)5( c)5(a)5(b)1(le)5(s. I)24(n)1(te)5(rne)5(t)-1( c)5(onne)5(c)5(tion throug)11(h sa)5(te)5(llite)5(s)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(i)-4(s)-3( t)-4(h)-2(e l)-4(a)2(t)-4(e)2(st)-4( devel)-4(opm)-4(ent)-4( i)-4(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e area. The accel)-4(erat)-4(i)-4(n)-2(g)8( devel)-4(opm)-4(ent)-4(s)-3( i)-4(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(ese)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(fie)4(l)-2(ds ha)4(ve)4( a)4(nd will le)4(a)4(d)0( to nume)4(r)3(ous ne)4(w proble)4(m)-2(s c)4(onc)4(e)4(r)3(ning)10( inte)4(lle)4(c)4(t)-2(ua)4(l)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(property)29( around the g)9(l)-3(obe. W)-7(e)3( are only)29( in the beg)9(i)-3(nning)9( of a new era of)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(inte)5(lle)5(c)5(t)-1(ua)5(l prope)5(rty)31(.)]TJ
0 -21.77 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 123.75 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 112.95 Tm
(1)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 145.05 108.39 Tm
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( B)-6(a)0(n)8(d)-4(w)25(i)3(dth)8( is a m)21(easu)8(r)-2(e of)10( data tran)8(sm)21(ission)8( capacity)20( of)10( a sy)20(stem)21( or ch)8(an)8(n)8(e)0(l.)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 101.19 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(2)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 145.05 96.63 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(7KH\003\)XWXUH\003RI\003WKH\003,QWHUQHW\003\261\003:KDW\0035ROH\003IRU\003\(XURSH")Tj
/F3 1 Tf
20.8072 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( In)10(t)5(e)2(ri)5(m)23( R)8(e)2(port)5( of)12( an)]TJ
-21.3855 -1.1807 TD
[(A)15(d)-2(v)10(i)5(s)7(o)-2(ry)22( Grou)10(p 970311. Http://)]TJ
12.9277 0 TD
-0.023 Tc
[(www.)-26(c)-25(o)-29(r)-27(d)-29(i)-22(s)-20(.)-26(l)-22(u)-17(/)-22(e)-25(s)-20(p)-29(r)]TJ
7.7831 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(it/src/i2)-7(eurep)-7(o)-7(.)-4(htm)]TJ
-20.7108 -1.1807 TD
0.006 Tc
(\(970805\))Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
294 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
295 0 obj
<<
/Length 7265
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 294.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
0 Tw
(4)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
24 0 0 24 113.49 733.71 Tm
[(\026\003)-310(+\\SHUOLQNLQJ)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 693.27 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(I)22(n)-1( order to provide more interesting)9( websites, to make surfing)9( easier, more)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(e)5(ffic)5(i)-1(e)5(n)1(t a)5(nd le)5(ss time)5( c)5(onsuming)11(,)1( most we)5(bsite)5(s toda)5(y)31( provide)5( va)5(rious)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(kinds of hy)30(perlinks. Hy)30(perlinking)10( has proven to be an essential part of the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(success of the I)22(n)-1(ternet as a resource and financially)29( profitable medium.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 453.69 656.31 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(3)Tj
12 0 0 12 457.77 650.79 Tm
( The)Tj
-28.69 -1.18 TD
[(a)4(b)0(ility)30( to link to othe)4(r sourc)4(e)4(s)-1( of informa)4(tion sure)4(ly)30( ha)4(s re)4(volutionize)4(d)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(information retrieval as well as reading)9( documents. Hy)29(perlinks are points in)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(web documents throug)10(h which users may)30( transport themselves directly)30( to)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(another website or retrieve information without ty)29(ping)9( a new location in the)]TJ
T*
[(Uniform Resource L)20(o)-1(cator \(URL)20(\). The traditional method of finding)9( and)]TJ
T*
[(retrieving)9( documents requires the browser to know the ex)-11(act address)]TJ
T*
[(required in the URL)20( and ty)29(pe it by)29( hand or equivalent. Once the complete)]TJ
T*
[(and ex)-11(act address is ty)29(ped in the URL)20(,)-1( the search for the address beg)9(i)-3(ns, and)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
(the user is transported to the new desired location. The utilization of)Tj
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(hy)29(perlinks makes knowledg)9(e of the ex)-11(act addresses as well as the manual)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(ty)30(ping)10( obsolete. I)23(f)3( the active web document display)30(s)-1( a link to another site,)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(fi)-3(l)-3(e)3( or pl)-3(ace wi)-3(t)-3(h)-1(i)-3(n)-1( t)-3(h)-1(e sam)-3(e)3( docum)-3(ent)-3(,)-1( and t)-3(h)-1(e user cl)-3(i)-3(c)3(ks on i)-3(t)-3( wi)-3(t)-3(h)-1( t)-3(h)-1(e)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(mouse, he/she will instantly)30(, without ty)30(ping)10(, be transported in one way)30( or)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(another to the linked pag)9(e)3(, file or place. The three most important methods)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(of linking)10( are hy)30(pertex)-10(t links, inline links and framing)10(.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 414.63 Tm
[(\026\021\024\003)-435(+\\)11(SHUWH[W\003OLQNV)]TJ
10.56 0 0 10.56 261.09 422.19 Tm
(\027)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 383.79 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Hy)29(perlinking)9( is one of the streng)9(ths of the W)-7(o)-1(rld W)-7(i)-3(de W)-7(e)3(b, allowing)9( users)]TJ
T*
[(to jump from one I)22(n)-1(ternet site to another. Hy)29(pertex)-11(t links \(Hy)29(p)-1(ertex)-11(t)]TJ
T*
[(Reference links are often called HREF)5( links\) is the most widely)29( used linking)]TJ
T*
[(method in Cy)29(berspace. Hy)29(pertex)-11(t links are very)29( convenient, since the)]TJ
T*
[(hy)29(perlinks are imbedded in a piece of tex)-11(t)-3( without hindering)9( the reader nor)]TJ
T*
[(using)9( too much memory)29( as pictures sometimes have a tendency)29( to do. Often)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(the)4( link is diffe)4(re)4(ntia)4(te)4(d from the)4( re)4(st of the)4( te)4(x)-10(t)-2( ma)4(te)4(ria)4(l)-2( by)30( the)4( wa)4(y)30( it is)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(display)29(e)3(d. I)22(t)-3( can for ex)-11(ample consist of a hig)9(h)-1(lig)9(hted or underlined word,)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(indic)4(a)4(ting)10( to the)4( surfe)4(r tha)4(t)-2( it is a)4( \224)4(f)3(ootnote)4(-)3(like)4(\224)4( link to a)4(nothe)4(r I)23(n)0(te)4(rne)4(t)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(location. Once the surfer activates the hy)29(pertex)-11(t link by)29( clicking)9( on it, the)]TJ
T*
[(computer immediately)29( establishes a new connection with a site on another)]TJ
T*
[(server \(inter-sy)29(s)-2(tem linking)9(\))]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 249.45 233.55 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(5)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 253.53 228.03 Tm
[( that is linked to \(linking)10( out\))]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 394.17 233.55 Tm
(6)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 398.25 228.03 Tm
[(. Alte)4(rna)4(tive)4(l)-2(y)]TJ
-23.73 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(h)-2(ere can be a l)-4(i)-4(nk t)-4(o)-2( anot)-4(her pl)-4(ace i)-4(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e sam)-4(e)2( docum)-4(ent)-4( \(i)-4(nt)-4(ra-pag)8(e)]TJ
0 -2.87 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 182.55 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 171.75 Tm
(3)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 145.05 167.19 Tm
0.003 Tc
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.506 0 TD
0 Tc
(\)UDPH\003/LDELOLW\\\003&ORXGV\003WKH\003,QWHUQHW\266V\003\)XWXUH)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
18.0482 0 TD
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(, T)-14(h)8(e New)25( York)8( L)11(a)0(w)25( J)-7(o)-4(u)8(r)-2(n)8(a)0(l,)]TJ
-18.8795 -1.1807 TD
0 Tw
[(May)21( 19, 1997. Htttp://)]TJ
9.012 0 TD
-0.022 Tc
[(www.)-25(l)-21(j)-33(x)-16(.)-25(c)-24(o)-28(m/)-21(I)-26(n)-16(t)-21(e)-24(r)-26(n)-16(e)-24(t)-21(/)]TJ
9.0361 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(0519n)11(y)23(f)13(ram)24(e)3(.h)11(t)6(m)24(l)6( \(971006\).)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 148.23 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(4)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 145.05 143.67 Tm
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( T)-12(h)10(i)5(s)7( part)5( i)5(s)7( bas)7(e)2(d on)10( )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
8.8193 0 TD
0 Tc
('DQJHURXV\003/LDLVRQV\035\0037KH\003/HJDO\0035LVNV\003RI\003/LQNLQJ\003:HE)Tj
-9.1446 -1.1807 TD
(6LWHV)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.8916 0 TD
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[(, R)7(i)4(ch)9(ard R)7(a)1(y)21(s)6(m)22(a)1(n)9( an)9(d P)-7(e)1(ter B)-5(r)-1(ow)26(n)9(,)0( T)-13(h)9(e New)26( York)9( L)12(a)1(w)26( J)-6(o)-3(u)9(r)-1(n)9(a)1(l, A)14(p)-3(ril)]TJ
-1.8916 -1.1807 TD
(8, 1997. Http://)Tj
6.1566 0 TD
-0.022 Tc
[(www.)-25(l)-21(j)-33(x)-16(.)-25(c)-24(o)-28(m/)-21(I)-26(n)-16(t)-21(e)-24(r)-26(n)-16(e)-24(t)-21(/)]TJ
9.0361 0 TD
0.006 Tc
-0.003 Tw
[(0408l)7(i)7(a)4(s)9(.)3(h)12(t)7(m)25(l)7( \(971006\))]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 112.95 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(5)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 145.05 108.39 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(/LQNLQJ\003&RS\\ULJKW\003WR\003+RPHSDJHV)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
13.4337 0 TD
0.001 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(, Matt J)-8(ack)7(s)4(o)-5(n)7(.)]TJ
-14.012 -1.1807 TD
-0.022 Tc
[(H)-23(t)-21(t)-21(p)-28(:)-21(/)-21(/)-21(www.)-25(l)-21(a)-24(w.)-25(i)-21(n)-16(d)-28(i)-21(a)-24(n)-16(a)-24(.)-25(e)-24(d)-28(u)-16(/)-21(f)-14(c)-24(l)-21(j)-33(/)-21(v)-16(4)-28(9)-28(/)-21(n)-16(o)-28(3)-28(/)-21(j)-33(a)-24(c)-24(k)-16(s)-19(o)-28(n)-16(.)-25(h)-16(t)-21(ml)]TJ
/T1 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\031)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 145.05 84.87 Tm
(\003\)UHHGRP\003WR\003/LQN\0038QGHU\003$WWDFN)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12.5904 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(, T)-11(h)11(e New)28( York)11( L)14(a)3(w)28( Jou)11(r)1(n)11(a)3(l)6(,)2( Ju)11(n)11(e)3( 23 1997.)]TJ
-12.9157 -1.1807 TD
-0.022 Tc
[(H)-23(t)-21(t)-21(p)-28(:)-21(/)-21(/)-21(www.)-25(l)-21(j)-33(x)-16(.)-25(c)-24(o)-28(m/)-21(I)-26(n)-16(t)-21(e)-24(r)-26(n)-16(e)-24(t)-21(/)]TJ
11.6506 0 TD
0.006 Tc
[(0623l)7(i)7(n)12(k)12(.)3(h)12(t)7(m)25(l)7( \(971006\))]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
296 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
/T1 297 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
299 0 obj
<<
/Length 7535
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 294.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
0 Tw
(5)Tj
-15.1 58.94 TD
0.001 Tc
[(linking)11(\))]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 151.41 750.99 Tm
0 Tc
(7)Tj
12 0 0 12 155.49 745.47 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( or to another document on the same server \(intra-sy)29(s)-2(tem linking)9(\))]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 469.17 750.99 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(8)Tj
12 0 0 12 473.25 745.47 Tm
(.)Tj
-29.98 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(At this point in time)5(, only)31( one)5( doc)5(ume)5(n)1(t c)5(a)5(n)1( be)5( vie)5(w)3(e)5(d)1( a)5(t)-1( a)5( time)5( using)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(standard hy)29(pertex)-11(t links.)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
[(The linking)9( site can link to another site without the other author\222s)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(knowledg)9(e or consent unless special security)29( measures are taken. Some)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(claim that permission is required when including)10( a link to another\222s site. I)23(t)-2( is)]TJ
T*
[(still not possible)4( to link to a)4( spe)4(c)4(i)-2(fic)4( pic)4(t)-2(ure)4( or word in the)4( othe)4(r site)4( unle)4(s)-1(s)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(the g)9(r)2(aphics or word has an URL)20( address of its own.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 365.01 637.71 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(9)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 369.09 632.19 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
( However, if anchors)Tj
-21.3 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(are used, it is possible to link directly)30( to subsections of a document. An)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(anchor is an HTML)20( tag)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 225.57 609.39 Tm
0.007 Tc
(10)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 233.73 603.87 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[( that marks a specific point in an HTML)20( document)]TJ
-10.02 -1.18 TD
[(as either the source or destination of a hy)29(pertex)-11(t link. This allows any)29(one to)]TJ
T*
[(create links from one hy)29(pertex)-11(t document to another, as well as to different)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(se)5(c)5(tions within the)5( sa)5(me)5( doc)5(ume)5(n)1(t.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(B)6(a)3(sically)29(, there are two important and interesting)9( leg)9(a)3(l questions concerning)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(links. F)6(i)-2(rstly)30(, there is the question whether linking)10( to another site, without)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(permission is lawful and secondly)29(,)-1( the question whether the linker is)]TJ
T*
[(responsible for any)29( of the content in the site that has been linked to. I)22(t)-3( may)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(in some instances be a question of contributory)30( copy)30(rig)10(h)0(t infring)10(ement.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 455.49 481.95 Tm
0.007 Tc
(11)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 462.27 Tm
0 Tc
[(Some web authors are opposed to linking)10( without permission, since it is in a)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(way)28( a m)-4(a)2(t)-4(t)-4(e)2(r of freeri)-4(d)-2(i)-4(n)-2(g)8(.)-2( For ex)-12(am)-4(pl)-4(e, t)-4(h)-2(e Georg)8(i)-4(a C)-5(o)-2(m)-4(put)-4(er S)-6(y)28(st)-4(em)-4(s)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(Protection Act)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 183.09 439.47 Tm
0.007 Tc
(12)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 191.25 433.95 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( could be interpreted as forbidding)10( linking)10( without consent)]TJ
-6.48 -1.18 TD
[(from the linked-to site. A site without any)30( individual content of its own can)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(link to many)29( other sites in order to make the site more useful and at the same)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(time)5( g)11(i)-1(ve)5( the)5( site)5( a)5(n)1( e)5(x)-9(tra)5( touc)5(h of e)5(x)-9(c)5(ite)5(me)5(nt. I)24(f)4( a)5( site)5( c)5(onta)5(i)-1(ns nume)5(r)4(ous)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(links to various interesting)10( pag)10(e)4(s, it could function as a frequently)30( visited)]TJ
T*
[(starting)10( point for many)30( users of the web. Often, links g)10(o)0( straig)10(ht to the most)]TJ
T*
[(popular pag)10(e)4(s, thus by)30(passing)10( all the pag)10(e)4(s preceding)10( them. W)-6(h)0(y)30( do some)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(people consider this inappropriate?)-17( One must look the web of today)29( as a)]TJ
T*
[(g)9(r)2(and market for advertising)9( and advertising)9( revenues. I)22(f)2( sites containing)]TJ
T*
[(advertising)9( banners are by)29(passed as a result of direct links that ploug)9(h deep)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(into the)5( site)5(s, the)5( numbe)5(r of hits de)5(c)5(r)4(e)5(a)5(s)0(e)5( on the)5( ma)5(in front site)5(s a)5(n)1(d)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(consequently)29( fewer advertisers choose to place their banners there. The)]TJ
0 -2.33 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 253.35 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 242.55 Tm
(7)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 145.05 237.99 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(/LQNLQJ\003&RS\\ULJKW\003WR\003+RPHSDJHV)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
13.4337 0 TD
0.001 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(, Matt J)-8(ack)7(s)4(o)-5(n)7(.)]TJ
-14.012 -1.1807 TD
-0.022 Tc
[(H)-23(t)-21(t)-21(p)-28(:)-21(/)-21(/)-21(www.)-25(l)-21(a)-24(w.)-25(i)-21(n)-16(d)-28(i)-21(a)-24(n)-16(a)-24(.)-25(e)-24(d)-28(u)-16(/)-21(f)-14(c)-24(l)-21(j)-33(/)-21(v)-16(4)-28(9)-28(/)-21(n)-16(o)-28(3)-28(/)-21(j)-33(a)-24(c)-24(k)-16(s)-19(o)-28(n)-16(.)-25(h)-16(t)-21(ml)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 219.03 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(8)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 145.05 214.47 Tm
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
( Ibid.)Tj
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 207.27 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(9)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 145.05 202.71 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(/LQNLQJ\003&RS\\ULJKW\003WR\003+RPHSDJHV)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
13.4337 0 TD
0.001 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(, Matt J)-8(ack)7(s)4(o)-5(n)7(.)]TJ
-14.012 -1.1807 TD
-0.022 Tc
[(H)-23(t)-21(t)-21(p)-28(:)-21(/)-21(/)-21(www.)-25(l)-21(a)-24(w.)-25(i)-21(n)-16(d)-28(i)-21(a)-24(n)-16(a)-24(.)-25(e)-24(d)-28(u)-16(/)-21(f)-14(c)-24(l)-21(j)-33(/)-21(v)-16(4)-28(9)-28(/)-21(n)-16(o)-28(3)-28(/)-21(j)-33(a)-24(c)-24(k)-16(s)-19(o)-28(n)-16(.)-25(h)-16(t)-21(ml)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 141.81 182.79 Tm
0.007 Tc
(10)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 149.97 177.27 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( Anchors t)-3(h)-1(at)-3( poi)-3(nt)-3( t)-3(o)-1( di)-3(fferent)-3( pl)-3(aces i)-3(n)-1( t)-3(h)-1(e sam)-3(e)3( docum)-3(ent)]TJ
-0.68 -1.18 TD
[(use the tag)9( and are used to navig)9(a)3(te long)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(documents with many)30( sections. Anchors that point to other)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(hy)29(pertex)-11(t documents use the tag)9(.)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Http://www.g)10(l)-2(ossary)30(.com \(971014\).)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 112.95 Tm
(11)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 108.39 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(/LQNLQJ\0035LJKWV)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
5.8916 0 TD
-0.022 Tc
0.025 Tw
[(,)-25( B)-30(r)-26(a)-24(d)-28( T)-38(e)-24(mp)-28(l)-21(e)-24(t)-21(o)-28(n)-16(.)-25( H)-23(t)-21(t)-21(p)-28(:)-21(/)-21(/)-21(www.)-25(c)-24(l)-21(a)-24(r)-26(i)-21(.)-25(n)-16(e)-24(t)-21(/)-21(b)-28(r)-26(a)-24(d)]TJ
17.8554 0 TD
-0.003 Tc
[(/linkr)-7(ight.)-6(h)3(tm)16(l)]TJ
-24.6506 -1.1807 TD
0.006 Tc
(\(971021\))Tj
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
0 Tc
(12)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 84.87 Tm
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( Georg)10(i)5(a C)8(o)-2(m)23(p)-2(u)10(t)5(er S)6(y)22(s)7(t)5(em)23(s)7( Prot)5(ect)5(i)5(o)-2(n)10( A)15(c)2(t)5( 16-)12(9-)12(93.1\))]TJ
-0.6506 -1.1807 TD
-0.021 Tc
0.024 Tw
[(H)-22(t)-20(t)-20(p)-27(:)-20(/)-20(/)-20(www.)-24(mi)-20(n)-15(d)-27(s)-18(p)-27(r)-25(i)-20(n)-15(g)-15(.)-24(c)-23(o)-27(m/)-20(~)-22(a)-23(j)-32(c)-23(1)-27(0)-27(/)-20(g)-15(a)-23(l)-20(a)-23(w.)-24(h)-15(t)-20(ml)-20( \()]TJ
19.759 0 TD
0.006 Tc
(980215\))Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
300 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
303 0 obj
<<
/Length 8626
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 294.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
0 Tw
(6)Tj
-15.1 58.94 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(advertisers may)29( choose to place their ads in the middle of the most popular)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(\(linked to\) pag)9(e)3(s, such as in the middle of a news report. They)29( may)29( perhaps)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(choose to advertise on the popular linking)10( sites instead, if it will g)10(e)4(nerate a)]TJ
T*
[(g)10(r)3(eater number of hits than the sites that are linked to. The linking)10( site)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(created no material of its own, ex)-11(cept for the compilation of links to other)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(site)5(s. This wa)5(s the)5( c)5(a)5(s)0(e)5( in )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
10.57 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(7)-11(KH\003:DV)-9(K)1(L)-8(QJW)-8(RQ\0033RV)-9(W)-8(\003&)-12(RPSDQ\\\003HW)-8(\003DO)-8(\003)-2(Y\021\0037)-11(RW)-8(DO)]TJ
-10.57 -1.18 TD
0.006 Tc
[(1H)12(ZV\017)9(\003)9(,)13(Q)12(F)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
3.94 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(.)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 163.77 666.03 Tm
0.007 Tc
(13)Tj
12 0 0 12 171.93 660.51 Tm
0 Tc
[( whic)4(h will be)4( a)4(n)0(a)4(l)-2(y)30(z)-6(e)4(d)0( furthe)4(r be)4(low.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 636.75 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(\026\021\025\003)-436(,QOLQH\003OLQNLQJ)]TJ
10.56 0 0 10.56 244.53 644.31 Tm
0.002 Tc
(\024\027)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 605.91 Tm
0 Tc
[(Another way)30( of linking)10( web documents is throug)10(h )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
20.32 0 TD
0.003 Tc
[(LQ)9(OLQ)9(H)9(\003)6(OLQ)9(N)9(V)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
4.42 0 TD
0 Tc
[( \(I)23(nline)4(d)]TJ
-24.74 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(imag)9(e)3(s, known as I)22(M)-2(G\). I)22(M)-2(Gs are g)9(r)2(aphics display)29(e)3(d on webpag)9(e)3(s. An)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(I)24(M)0(G link is a)5(u)1(toma)5(tic)5(a)5(lly)31( a)5(c)5(tiva)5(t)-1(e)5(d)1( a)5(s)0( the)5( pa)5(g)11(e)5( is first loa)5(d)1(e)5(d)1( into the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Random Access Memory)29( \(RAM\), and is often used by)29( the web-editors to)]TJ
T*
[(bring)9( g)9(r)2(aphic imag)9(e)3(s into and around the tex)-11(t)-3( on a pag)9(e)3(. The g)9(r)2(aphics are)]TJ
T*
[(stored in separate files and often they)29( are part of material belong)9(ing)9( to other)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(websites \(linking)10( in\).)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 215.01 526.47 Tm
0.007 Tc
(15)Tj
12 0 0 12 223.17 520.95 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[( One coul)-4(d say)28( t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( t)-4(h)-2(ese g)8(r)1(aphi)-4(c fi)-4(l)-4(e)2(s are)]TJ
-9.14 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(a)5(u)1(toma)5(tic)5(a)5(lly)31( loa)5(d)1(e)5(d)1( into the)5( pa)5(g)11(e)5(, a)5(s)0( the)5( use)5(r)4( is wa)5(iting)11( for the)5( c)5(onte)5(n)1(t of)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(the site to emerg)10(e)4(. To a user, it may)30( look as if the linking)10( site is authoriz)-6(ed)]TJ
T*
[(to use)4( the)4( g)10(r)3(a)4(phic)4( ma)4(te)4(ria)4(l)-2( tha)4(t)-2( wa)4(s tra)4(n)0(sporte)4(d from the)4( site)4( linke)4(d to. I)23(n)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(cert)-4(a)2(i)-4(n)-2( ci)-4(rcum)-4(st)-4(ances, t)-4(h)-2(i)-4(s)-3( m)-4(a)2(y)28( l)-4(ead t)-4(o)-2( si)-4(t)-4(u)-2(at)-4(i)-4(ons were users recei)-4(ve fal)-4(s)-3(e)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(confidence in sites. I)22(n)-1( most cases, however, the averag)9(e user would not be)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(a)5(w)3(a)5(r)4(e)5( tha)5(t)-1( the)5( ima)5(g)11(e)5( wa)5(s inc)5(o)1(rpora)5(t)-1(e)5(d)1( into the)5( doc)5(ume)5(n)1(t a)5(u)1(toma)5(tic)5(a)5(lly)31( from)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(a remote site, and not stored locally)30(. To most people it does not matter at all,)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(from)-4( where t)-4(h)-2(e request)-4(ed i)-4(n)-2(form)-4(at)-4(i)-4(on com)-4(e)2(s.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 383.91 Tm
0 Tc
[(\026\021\026\003)-435(\)UDPLQJ)]TJ
10.56 0 0 10.56 209.97 391.47 Tm
0.002 Tc
(\024\031)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 353.07 Tm
-0.004 Tc
[(\)U)-8(DPL)-7(Q)2(J)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
3.5 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( is another method of linking)10( to other remote sites. Since the)]TJ
-3.5 -1.18 TD
[(introduction by)30( Netscape Communications Corp. in J)-11(a)4(nuary)30( 1996 with the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(release of Navig)9(a)3(tor 2, it has developed to be a very)29( popular tool frequently)]TJ
T*
[(used in many)29( websites around the world.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 309.21 316.11 Tm
0.007 Tc
(17)Tj
12 0 0 12 317.37 310.59 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( Today)30(,)0( most browsers support)]TJ
-16.99 -1.18 TD
[(fra)4(me)4(s. B)7(y)30( utilizing)10( fra)4(me)4(s it is possible)4( to divide)4( a)4( pa)4(g)10(e)4( into se)4(ve)4(ra)4(l fra)4(me)4(s)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(or windows that are scrollable reg)9(i)-3(ons operating)9( independently)29( of each)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(othe)4(r. The)4( spe)4(c)4(i)-2(a)4(l)-2( fe)4(a)4(t)-2(ure)4( of fra)4(ming)10(,)0( c)4(o)0(mpa)4(r)3(e)4(d)0( to the)4( othe)4(r possibilitie)4(s of)]TJ
T*
[(linking)10(, is the)4( fa)4(c)4(t)-2( tha)4(t)-2( the)4( we)4(bpa)4(g)10(e)4( tha)4(t)-2( fra)4(me)4(s a)4( re)4(mote)4( site)4( inc)4(o)0(rpora)4(t)-2(e)4(s)]TJ
0 -1.31 TD
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 241.35 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 230.55 Tm
(13)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 225.99 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(:DVKLQJWRQ\0033RVW\003&RPSDQ\\\003HW\003DO\021\0039\021\0037RWDO\0031HZV\003,QF)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
20.6506 0 TD
0.001 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(., U.S. Dis)4(t)2(rict C)5(o)-5(u)7(r)-3(t,)]TJ
-21.5542 -1.1807 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(S)6(o)-2(u)10(t)5(h)10(e)2(rn)10( Di)5(s)7(t)5(ri)5(ct)5( of)12( New)27( York)10(, 97 C)8(i)5(v)10(.)1(1190\(PKL)13(\))0(.)]TJ
T*
-0.022 Tc
[(H)-23(t)-21(t)-21(p)-28(:)-21(/)-21(/)-21(www.)-25(l)-21(j)-33(x)-16(.)-25(c)-24(o)-28(m/)-21(I)-26(n)-16(t)-21(e)-24(r)-26(n)-16(e)]TJ
11.0964 0 TD
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[(t/totals)6(e.h)9(t)4(m)22( \(971011\))]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 195.27 Tm
0 Tc
(14)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 190.71 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
('DQJHURXV\003/LDLVRQV\035\0037KH\003/HJDO\0035LVNV\003RI\003/LQNLQJ\003:HE\0036LWHV)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
23.6506 0 TD
0.003 Tc
[(, R)7(i)4(ch)9(ard)]TJ
-24.5542 -1.1807 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(R)8(a)2(y)22(s)7(m)23(a)2(n)10( an)10(d Pet)5(e)2(r Brow)27(n)10(,)1( T)-12(h)10(e New)27( York)10( L)13(a)2(w)27( Jou)10(r)0(n)10(a)2(l)5(,)1( A)15(p)-2(ri)5(l)5( 8, 1997.)]TJ
T*
-0.022 Tc
[(H)-23(t)-21(t)-21(p)-28(:)-21(/)-21(/)-21(www.)-25(l)-21(j)-33(x)-16(.)-25(c)-24(o)-28(m/)-21(I)-26(n)-16(t)-21(e)-24(r)-26(n)-16(e)-24(t)-21(/)]TJ
11.6506 0 TD
0.006 Tc
-0.003 Tw
[(0408l)7(i)7(a)4(s)9(.)3(h)12(t)7(m)25(l)7( \(971006\))]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 159.99 Tm
0 Tc
(15)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 155.43 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(\)UHHGRP\003WR\003/LQN\0038QGHU\003$WWDFN)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12.3373 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(, T)-11(h)11(e New)28( York)11( L)14(a)3(w)28( Jou)11(r)1(n)11(a)3(l)6(,)2( Ju)11(n)11(e)3( 23 1997.)]TJ
-13.241 -1.1807 TD
-0.022 Tc
[(H)-23(t)-21(t)-21(p)-28(:)-21(/)-21(/)-21(www.)-25(l)-21(j)-33(x)-16(.)-25(c)-24(o)-28(m/)-21(I)-26(n)-16(t)-21(e)-24(r)-26(n)-16(e)-24(t)-21(/)]TJ
11.6506 0 TD
0.006 Tc
[(0623l)7(i)7(n)12(k)12(.)3(h)12(t)7(m)25(l)7( \(971006\))]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 136.47 Tm
0 Tc
(16)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 131.91 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
('DQJHURXV\003/LDLVRQV\035\0037KH\003/HJDO\0035LVNV\003RI\003/LQNLQJ\003:HE\0036LWHV)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
23.6506 0 TD
0.003 Tc
[(, R)7(i)4(ch)9(ard)]TJ
-24.5542 -1.1807 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(R)8(a)2(y)22(s)7(m)23(a)2(n)10( an)10(d Pet)5(e)2(r Brow)27(n)10(,)1( T)-12(h)10(e New)27( York)10( L)13(a)2(w)27( Jou)10(r)0(n)10(a)2(l)5(,)1( A)15(p)-2(ri)5(l)5( 8, 1997.)]TJ
T*
-0.022 Tc
[(H)-23(t)-21(t)-21(p)-28(:)-21(/)-21(/)-21(www.)-25(l)-21(j)-33(x)-16(.)-25(c)-24(o)-28(m/)-21(I)-26(n)-16(t)-21(e)-24(r)-26(n)-16(e)-24(t)-21(/)]TJ
11.6506 0 TD
0.006 Tc
-0.003 Tw
[(0408l)7(i)7(a)4(s)9(.)3(h)12(t)7(m)25(l)7( \(971006\))]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 101.19 Tm
0 Tc
(17)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 96.63 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(\265\)UDPLQJ\266\035\003,QWHUQHW\003\(TXLYDOHQW\003RI\0033LUDWLQJ"\017)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
17.9759 0 TD
0.003 Tc
[( T)-13(h)9(e New)26( York)9( L)12(a)1(w)26( J)-6(o)-3(u)9(r)-1(n)9(a)1(l)]TJ
-18.8795 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(A)16(p)-1(ri)6(l)6( 4 an)11(d 11, 1997 \(pu)11(b)-1(l)6(i)6(s)8(h)11(e)3(d i)6(n)11( t)6(w)28(o part)6(s)8(\))]TJ
T*
-0.022 Tc
[(H)-23(t)-21(t)-21(p)-28(:)-21(/)-21(/)-21(www.)-25(l)-21(j)-33(x)-16(.)-25(c)-24(o)-28(m/)-21(I)-26(n)-16(t)-21(e)-24(r)-26(n)-16(e)-24(t)-21(/)]TJ
11.6506 0 TD
0.005 Tc
[(0411f)13(ram)24(e)3(.h)11(t)6(m)24(l)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
304 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
305 0 obj
<<
/Length 7005
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 294.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
0 Tw
(7)Tj
-15.1 58.94 TD
[(the)4( fra)4(me)4(d site)4( )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
6.18 0 TD
0.003 Tc
[(LQ)9(WR)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
1.56 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( its own pag)9(e)3(. A whole site or only)29( a part of a site can be)]TJ
-7.74 -1.18 TD
[(framed. The controversy)29( reg)9(a)3(rding)9( this phenomenon is that the framed site)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
[(is surrounded by)29( the framers\222 own site or frame. As a result, the framer can)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(tra)5(n)1(sport the)5( c)5(onte)5(n)1(ts of a)5( re)5(mote)5( site)5( to his own site)5( a)5(nd imbe)5(d)1( this into his)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(own desig)10(n, surrounded by)30( advertising)10( belong)10(ing)10( to him. The user may)30( not)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(understand that the content of the framed site orig)9(inates from a remote site,)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(sinc)5(e)5( the)5( URL)22( of the)5( fra)5(me)5(d site)5( will not be)5( displa)5(y)31(e)5(d. The)5( URL)22( will still be)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(tha)4(t)-2( of the)4( fra)4(ming)10( site)4( a)4(nd not of the)4( fra)4(me)4(d site)4(. This is like)4(l)-2(y)30( to c)4(a)4(u)0(se)]TJ
T*
[(confusion and uncertainty)30( concerning)10( the orig)10(in of information display)30(e)4(d on)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(sc)5(re)5(e)5(n. I)24(t)-1( ma)5(y)31( fa)5(lse)5(l)-1(y)31( g)11(i)-1(ve)5( the)5( impre)5(ssion tha)5(t)-1( the)5( orig)11(ina)5(l)-1( site)5( is a)5(u)1(thorize)5(d)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(to use the material of the framed site, like mentioned above at the I)22(M)-2(G link.)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(This wa)4(s a)4( ve)4(ry)30( c)4(r)3(uc)4(ia)4(l issue)4( in )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
12.75 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(7)-11(KH\003:DV)-9(K)1(L)-8(QJW)-8(RQ\0033RV)-9(W)-8(\003&)-12(RPSDQ\\\003HW)-8(\003DO)-8(\003)-2(Y\021\0037)-11(RW)-8(DO)]TJ
-12.75 -1.18 TD
0.006 Tc
[(1H)12(ZV\017)9(\003)9(,)13(Q)12(F)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
3.94 0 TD
0 Tc
(.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 163.77 581.07 Tm
0.007 Tc
(18)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 551.79 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(\026\021\027\003)-436(7KH\003:DVKLQJWRQ\0033RVW\003&RPSDQ\\)10(\003HW\003DO\003Y)20(\021)]TJ
0 -1.1805 TD
[(7RWDO\0031HZ)-15(V\017\003,QF\021)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
10.56 0 0 10.56 234.45 540.51 Tm
0.001 Tc
(19)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 502.11 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Total News used framing)9( technolog)9(y)29( in order to put all the major web news)]TJ
T*
[(sources tog)9(e)3(ther in one site on the I)22(n)-1(ternet. This was a purely)29( commercial)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(site)4(, sinc)4(e)4( the)4( Tota)4(l Ne)4(ws g)10(e)4(ne)4(ra)4(te)4(d re)4(ve)4(nue)4( by)30( se)4(lling)10( a)4(dve)4(rtise)4(m)-2(e)4(n)0(t spa)4(c)4(e)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(on the site. Several larg)9(e news providers such as The W)-7(a)3(shing)9(t)-3(on Post,)]TJ
T*
[(CNN, L)20(o)-1(s Ang)9(e)3(les Times, Dow J)-12(ones &)7( Company)29( and Reuters were framed)]TJ
T*
[(by)29( Total News. They)29( all sued Total News on F)5(e)3(bruary)29( 20 1997, claiming)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(tha)4(t)-2( by)30( fra)4(ming)10( the)4(i)-2(r c)4(onte)4(n)0(t Tota)4(l Ne)4(ws pira)4(te)4(d c)4(opy)30(rig)10(h)0(te)4(d ma)4(te)4(ria)4(l)-2( a)4(n)0(d)]TJ
T*
[(a)4(c)4(t)-2(e)4(d)0( a)4(s)-1( a)4( pa)4(ra)4(sitic)4( site)4(, sinc)4(e)4( Tota)4(l Ne)4(ws did not provide)4( muc)4(h, if a)4(n)0(y)30(,)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(content of its own. The news sites claimed that Total News practice of)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(fra)4(ming)10( the)4( c)4(onte)4(n)0(t of the)4( othe)4(r we)4(bsite)4(s c)4(onstitute)4(d misa)4(ppropria)4(tion,)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(federal trademark infring)9(ement, dilution and false desig)9(n)-1(ation of orig)9(in and)]TJ
T*
[(copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(t infring)9(ement. Total News did not own any)29( famous trademarks and)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(created no copy)30(rig)10(h)0(ted news stories itself. Total News solely)30( provided the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(framing)9( links in order to attract as many)29( users as possible, and thus created a)]TJ
T*
[(popular site in order to attract more advertisers and g)9(e)3(nerate more revenues.)]TJ
T*
[(Advertising)9( has become an important source of revenue for many)29( websites.)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(Ac)5(c)5(o)1(rding)11( to the)5( c)5(o)1(mpla)5(int)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 244.89 281.07 Tm
0.007 Tc
(20)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 253.05 275.55 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( it is e)4(s)-1(tima)4(te)4(d tha)4(t)-2( for the)4( first thre)4(e)4( qua)4(rte)4(r)3(s of)]TJ
-11.63 -1.18 TD
[(1996, over $150 million was spent on advertising)10( on websites.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 239.07 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\026\021\027\021\024)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(7KH\003IUDPHG\003VLWHV\003ZHUH\003GLVSOD\\HG\003LQ\003D\003GLVWRUWHG\003ZD\\)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 210.63 Tm
0 Tc
[(None)4( of the)4( fra)4(me)4(d site)4(s a)4(ppe)4(a)4(r)3(e)4(d)0( in the)4( form orig)10(ina)4(lly)30( inte)4(nde)4(d whe)4(n)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(fra)4(me)4(d. The)4(y)30( we)4(re)4( a)4(lte)4(re)4(d in va)4(rious wa)4(y)30(s)-1(, suc)4(h)0( a)4(s)-1( diminishe)4(d size)4( or c)4(u)0(t in)]TJ
T*
[(orde)4(r to fit into inte)4(nde)4(d portions of the)4( Tota)4(l Ne)4(ws site)4(. As the)4( fra)4(me)4(d)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(news sites were display)29(e)3(d in windows of the Total News site, these were)]TJ
0 -2 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 147.27 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 136.47 Tm
(18)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 131.91 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(:DVKLQJWRQ\0033RVW\003&RPSDQ\\\003HW\003DO\021\0039\021\0037RWDO\0031HZV\003,QF)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
20.6506 0 TD
0.001 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(., U.S. Dis)4(t)2(rict C)5(o)-5(u)7(r)-3(t,)]TJ
-21.5542 -1.1807 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(S)6(o)-2(u)10(t)5(h)10(e)2(rn)10( Di)5(s)7(t)5(ri)5(ct)5( of)12( New)27( York)10(, 97 C)8(i)5(v)10(.)1(1190\(PKL)13(\))0(.)]TJ
T*
-0.022 Tc
[(H)-23(t)-21(t)-21(p)-28(:)-21(/)-21(/)-21(www.)-25(l)-21(j)-33(x)-16(.)-25(c)-24(o)-28(m/)-21(I)-26(n)-16(t)-21(e)-24(r)-26(n)-16(e)]TJ
11.0964 0 TD
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[(t/totals)6(e.h)9(t)4(m)22( \(971011\))]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 101.19 Tm
0 Tc
(19)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 96.63 Tm
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
( Ibid.)Tj
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
0 Tc
(20)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 84.87 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.004 Tw
[( Co)-7(m)18(p)-7(laint: )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
4.988 0 TD
0 Tc
(7KH\003:DVKLQJWRQ\0033RVW\003&RPSDQ\\\003Y\0037RWDO\0031HZV\017\003,QF)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
19.9759 0 TD
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
(. at 5. \(Dated)Tj
-25.6145 -1.1807 TD
0 Tw
(Feb. 20 1997\) Http://)Tj
8.506 0 TD
-0.021 Tc
0.024 Tw
[(www.)-24(l)-20(j)-32(x)-15(.)-24(c)-23(o)-27(m/)-20(I)-25(n)-15(t)-20(e)-23(r)-25(n)-15(e)-23(t)-20(/)-20(c)-23(o)-27(m)-2(p)-27(l)-20(a)-23(i)-20(n)-15(.)-24(h)-15(t)-20(ml)-20( \()]TJ
15.3976 0 TD
0.006 Tc
(971006\))Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
306 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F5 276 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
307 0 obj
<<
/Length 7053
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 294.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
0 Tw
(8)Tj
-15.1 58.94 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(totally)29( surrounded by)29( material unrelated to the orig)9(inal content of the framed)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(ne)4(ws site)4(s. This c)4(r)3(e)4(a)4(t)-2(e)4(d)0( a)4( situa)4(tion we)4(re)4( the)4( a)4(dve)4(rtise)4(m)-2(e)4(n)0(ts of the)4( fra)4(me)4(d)]TJ
T*
[(ne)4(ws site)4(s we)4(re)4( ve)4(ry)30( diminishe)4(d a)4(nd c)4(u)0(t in size)4( a)4(nd ha)4(d to c)4(o)0(mpe)4(t)-2(e)4( with the)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(a)5(dve)5(rtise)5(m)-1(e)5(n)1(ts displa)5(y)31(e)5(d on the)5( Tota)5(l ne)5(ws site)5( a)5(s)0( we)5(ll with the)5( visua)5(l)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(clutter of the actual \223totalnews.com\224 frame. This is serious, since a)Tj
T*
[(copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(t owner\222s rig)9(h)-1(ts may)29( be infring)9(ed if the material is altered, modified)]TJ
T*
(or presented to the public in a distorted form.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 330.21 666.03 Tm
0.007 Tc
(21)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 338.37 660.51 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( The)5(r)4(e)5( wa)5(s a)5( possibility)31( tha)5(t)]TJ
-18.74 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(the)4( a)4(dve)4(rtise)4(m)-2(e)4(n)0(ts from the)4( fra)4(me)4(d site)4(s a)4(nd those)4( from the)4( Tota)4(l Ne)4(ws)]TJ
T*
[(would be)4( dire)4(c)4(tly)30( c)4(o)0(mpe)4(titive)4(.)0( The)4( a)4(dve)4(rtise)4(r)3(s of the)4( fra)4(me)4(d ne)4(ws site)4(s we)4(re)]TJ
T*
[(not obtaining)10( the kind of presentation they)30( paid for. One must keep in mind,)]TJ
T*
[(tha)4(t)-2( the)4( Tota)4(l Ne)4(ws site)4( ne)4(ve)4(r a)4(lte)4(re)4(d or c)4(h)0(a)4(n)0(g)10(e)4(d a)4(n)0(y)30( ma)4(te)4(ria)4(l)-2( be)4(long)10(ing)10( to)]TJ
T*
[(the)4( othe)4(r ne)4(ws site)4(s. Tota)4(l Ne)4(ws me)4(re)4(ly)30( pre)4(s)-1(e)4(n)0(te)4(d the)4( c)4(onte)4(n)0(ts of the)4(s)-1(e)4( site)4(s)]TJ
T*
[(in its own wa)4(y)30( in its own site)4(.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 553.23 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\026\021\027\021\025)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(3)6(RWHQWLDO\003FRQIXVLRQ\003DPRQJ\003XVHUV\003UHJDUGLQJ\003WKH\003RULJLQ)]TJ
-2.6154 -1.1795 TD
(RI\003WKH\003QHZV)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 508.23 Tm
0.001 Tw
[(Surfers could have been confused concerning)9( the orig)9(in of the information)]TJ
T*
[(display)29(e)3(d on the Total News site, since the URL)20( only)29( display)29(e)3(d the address)]TJ
T*
[(of Total News and not the addresses of the framed sites. I)22(t)-3( may)29( be arg)9(u)-1(ed)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( one coul)-4(d recei)-4(ve t)-4(h)-2(e i)-4(m)-4(p)-2(ressi)-4(on t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( Tot)-4(a)2(l)-4( News was t)-4(h)-2(e aut)-4(hor of t)-4(h)-2(e)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(di)-3(spl)-3(a)3(y)29(e)3(d news bel)-3(ong)9(i)-3(n)-1(g)9( t)-3(o)-1( t)-3(h)-1(e ot)-3(her si)-3(t)-3(e)3(s. S)-5(u)-1(rfers coul)-3(d al)-3(so recei)-3(ve t)-3(h)-1(e)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(impression that Total News was in some way)30( sponsored by)30( the well known)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(news si)-4(t)-4(e)2(s, or t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e si)-4(t)-4(e)2(s were associ)-4(at)-4(ed.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 400.95 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\026\021\027\021\026)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
(\2639ROXQWDU\\\264\003VHWWOHPHQW)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 372.51 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(A se)5(ttle)5(me)5(nt)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 174.45 378.03 Tm
0.007 Tc
(22)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 182.61 372.51 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( was reached on J)-12(une 5 1997, prohibiting)9( Total News from)]TJ
-5.76 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(fra)4(ming)10( the)4( othe)4(r ne)4(ws site)4(s. Tota)4(l Ne)4(ws wa)4(s not a)4(llowe)4(d to displa)4(y)30( a)4(n)0(y)]TJ
T*
[(log)10(o)0(s e)4(t)-2(c)4(.)0( re)4(la)4(ting)10( to the)4( othe)4(r ne)4(ws site)4(s. Howe)4(ve)4(r, Tota)4(l Ne)4(ws wa)4(s)]TJ
T*
[(pe)4(rmitte)4(d to use)4( ordina)4(ry)30( te)4(dious HREF)6( hy)30(pe)4(rlinking)10( in the)4( form of pla)4(i)-2(n)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(te)5(x)-9(t)-1( tha)5(t)-1( is hig)11(h)1(lig)11(hte)5(d. This will c)5(o)1(mple)5(te)5(ly)31( tra)5(n)1(sport the)5( use)5(r)4( to the)5( de)5(sire)5(d)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(news site, instead of bring)10(i)-2(ng)10( the desired news site to the user within the)]TJ
T*
[(Tota)4(l Ne)4(ws fra)4(me)4(. Tota)4(l Ne)4(ws wa)4(s not a)4(llowe)4(d to use)4( a)4(lte)4(rna)4(tive)4( me)4(a)4(n)0(s of)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(framing)9(,)-1( such as using)9( an indirect link via a third-party)29( website from which)]TJ
T*
(users of the Total News site would be able to view the other news sites via a)Tj
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(fra)5(me)5(. One)5( must ke)5(e)5(p)1( in mind tha)5(t)-1( this is only)31( a)5( \224)5(volunta)5(r)4(y)31(\224)5( se)5(ttle)5(me)5(nt, a)5(n)1(d)]TJ
T*
[(not a)5( ruling)11( by)31( a)5( c)5(ourt. Until suc)5(h)1( a)5( ruling)11( is g)11(i)-1(ve)5(n, this se)5(ttle)5(me)5(nt ma)5(y)31( )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
28.65 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
(GH)Tj
-28.65 -1.18 TD
[(I)-9(DFW)-9(R)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
2 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( set the standards for hy)29(perlinking)9(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 303.45 222.27 Tm
0.007 Tc
(23)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 144.15 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 147.27 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 136.47 Tm
(21)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 131.91 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(\)UDPH\003/LDELOLW\\\003&ORXGV\003WKH\003,QWHUQHW\266V\003\)XWXUH)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
18.0482 0 TD
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(, T)-14(h)8(e New)25( York)8( L)11(a)0(w)25( J)-7(o)-4(u)8(r)-2(n)8(a)0(l,)]TJ
-18.9518 -1.1807 TD
0 Tw
[(May)21( 19, 1997. Htttp://)]TJ
9.012 0 TD
-0.022 Tc
[(www.)-25(l)-21(j)-33(x)-16(.)-25(c)-24(o)-28(m/)-21(I)-26(n)-16(t)-21(e)-24(r)-26(n)-16(e)-24(t)-21(/)]TJ
9.0361 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(0519n)11(y)23(f)13(ram)24(e)3(.h)11(t)6(m)24(l)6( \(971006\).)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 112.95 Tm
0 Tc
(22)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 108.39 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(:DVKLQJWRQ\0033RVW\003&RPSDQ\\\003HW\003DO\021\0039\021\0037RWDO\0031HZV\003,QF)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
20.6506 0 TD
0.001 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(., U.S. Dis)4(t)2(rict C)5(o)-5(u)7(r)-3(t,)]TJ
-21.5542 -1.1807 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(S)6(o)-2(u)10(t)5(h)10(e)2(rn)10( Di)5(s)7(t)5(ri)5(ct)5( of)12( New)27( York)10(, 97 C)8(i)5(v)10(.)1(1190\(PKL)13(\))0(.)]TJ
T*
-0.022 Tc
[(H)-23(t)-21(t)-21(p)-28(:)-21(/)-21(/)-21(www.)-25(l)-21(j)-33(x)-16(.)-25(c)-24(o)-28(m/)-21(I)-26(n)-16(t)-21(e)-24(r)-26(n)-16(e)]TJ
11.0964 0 TD
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[(t/totals)6(e.h)9(t)4(m)22( \(971011\))]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 77.67 Tm
0 Tc
(23)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 73.11 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(/DJ\003RFK\003UlWW\003Sn\003,QWHUQHW)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
9.6747 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, T)-12(h)10(om)23(as)7( )]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
3.9759 0 TD
[(C)8(a)2(rl)5(\351n)10(-)12(W)-4(en)10(del)5(s)7(, pag)10(e)2( 98.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
308 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
309 0 obj
<<
/Length 6282
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 294.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
0 Tw
(9)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 741.51 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(\026\021\030\003)-436(7LFNHWPDVWHU\003Y)20(\021)-1(\0030LFURVRIW)]TJ
ET
1 i
113.49 739.83 21.96 -1.56 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 710.67 Tm
0.001 Tw
[(Ticketmaster is a company)29( eng)9(a)3(g)9(e)3(d in the business of providing)9( automated)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(ticketing)9( services to various arenas and places throug)9(hout the United S)-5(t)-3(ates.)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
[(Ticketmaster owns a website on the I)22(n)-1(ternet called \224www.ticketmaster.com\224)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(and accordi)-4(n)-2(g)8( t)-4(o)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e com)-4(p)-2(l)-4(a)2(i)-4(n)-2(t)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 261.81 673.71 Tm
0.007 Tc
(24)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 269.97 668.19 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( filed by)30( Ticketmaster on May)30( 8, 1997, it is)]TJ
-13.04 -1.18 TD
[(ex)-10(tremely)30( popular, since it averag)10(es over 1 million visits and 12.9 million)]TJ
T*
[(pag)10(e)4( views per month. Ticketmaster pointed out that a link to the popular)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(Tic)5(k)1(e)5(tma)5(ste)5(r)4( site)5( ma)5(y)31( re)5(sult in inc)5(r)4(e)5(a)5(s)0(e)5(d)1( hits on the)5( linking)11( site)5( \(not the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Ticketmaster site\), and thus lead to increased advertising)9( revenue \(often)]TJ
T*
[(g)9(e)3(nerated by)29( the number of hits\).)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 575.07 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\026\021\030\021\024)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(0)23(LFURVRIW\266V\003VLWH\003OLQNHG\003WR\003WKH\003H[WUHPHO\\\003SRSXODU)]TJ
-2.6154 -1.1795 TD
0 Tc
(7LFNHWPDVWHU\003VLWH)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 530.07 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(One)5( of Mic)5(r)4(osoft\222s c)5(ity)31( g)11(u)1(ide)5( we)5(bsite)5(s \224)5(s)0(e)5(a)5(ttle)5(.side)5(w)3(a)5(l)-1(k.c)5(om\224)5( c)5(onta)5(i)-1(ne)5(d)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
(numerous links to Ticketmaster\222s site. As a result of this, Ticketmaster)Tj
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(cl)-4(ai)-4(m)-4(e)2(d t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( Mi)-4(crosoft)-4( vi)-4(ol)-4(at)-4(ed t)-4(h)-2(e federal)-4(l)-4(y)28( reg)8(i)-4(st)-4(ered t)-4(r)1(adem)-4(arks and t)-4(h)-2(at)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(Mic)5(r)4(osoft wa)5(s a)5( fre)5(e)5(r)4(ide)5(r)4(, c)5(o)1(mmitting)11( e)5(l)-1(e)5(c)5(t)-1(ronic)5( pira)5(c)5(y)31( by)31( utilizing)11( the)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Tic)4(k)0(e)4(tma)4(ste)4(r)3( site)4( in orde)4(r to g)10(e)4(ne)4(ra)4(te)4( more)4( a)4(dve)4(rtising)10( re)4(ve)4(nue)4( to itse)4(l)-2(f.)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Ticketmaster claimed it was deprived of favorable advertising)9( business and)]TJ
T*
[(opportunities due to the hy)29(perlinking)9( performed by)29( Microsoft. Ticketmaster)]TJ
T*
[(feared that the hy)29(perlinks could confuse the potential consumers and g)9(i)-3(ve)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(h)-2(em)-4( reason t)-4(o)-2( fal)-4(s)-3(el)-4(y)28( bel)-4(i)-4(e)2(ve t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( Ti)-4(cket)-4(m)-4(a)2(st)-4(er was associ)-4(at)-4(ed wi)-4(t)-4(h)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Microsoft in any)29( way)29(,)-1( or that the two websites were supporting)9( each other.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(On May)30( 28, 1997, Microsoft replied)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 287.25 379.83 Tm
0.007 Tc
(25)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 295.41 374.31 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( to Tic)5(k)1(e)5(tma)5(ste)5(r\222s c)5(o)1(mpla)5(int.)]TJ
-15.16 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(Mi)-4(crosoft)-4( t)-4(o)-2(t)-4(a)2(l)-4(l)-4(y)28( deni)-4(ed bei)-4(n)-2(g)8( a freeri)-4(d)-2(er, and st)-4(at)-4(ed t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( Ti)-4(cket)-4(m)-4(a)2(st)-4(er\222s)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(complaint was based upon pure fiction since Microsoft itself never accessed)Tj
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(Tic)5(k)1(e)5(tma)5(ste)5(r\222s we)5(bsite)5( a)5(t)-1( a)5(ll. I)24(t)-1( wa)5(s the)5( I)24(n)1(te)5(rne)5(t)-1( use)5(r)4(s tha)5(t)-1( visite)5(d the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Ticketmaster site. Microsoft claimed not to be a party)29( between the I)22(n)-1(ternet)]TJ
T*
[(users and Ticketmaster. Microsoft merely)29( provided the URL)20( address in the)]TJ
T*
[(shape of a link to any)29( I)22(n)-1(ternet user that demanded it.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 267.03 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\026\021\030\021\025)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
(7KH\003ODZIXOQHVV\003RI\003K\\SHUWH[W\003OLQNV)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 238.59 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(Mi)-4(crosoft)-4( had recei)-4(ved revenue from)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e sal)-4(e)2( of advert)-4(i)-4(s)-3(i)-4(n)-2(g)8( space \(on t)-4(h)-2(e)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(Mic)5(r)4(osoft we)5(bsite)5(\) in c)5(onne)5(c)5(tion with the)5( links to the)5( Tic)5(k)1(e)5(tma)5(ste)5(r)4( site)5(, but)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(denied that Ticketmaster had been deprived of favorable advertising)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
(business or opportunities. Microsoft said that if Ticketmaster did not desire)Tj
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(al)-3(l)-3( I)22(n)-1(t)-3(e)3(rnet)-3( users vi)-3(ewi)-3(n)-1(g)9( t)-3(h)-1(e si)-3(t)-3(e)3(s, i)-3(t)-3( coul)-3(d have refused access t)-3(o)-1( any)29(one.)]TJ
T*
(Since Microsoft wanted to inform the public where to purchase tickets,)Tj
T*
[(Ticketmaster\222s name had to be display)29(e)3(d on Microsoft\222s site. According)9( to)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Mic)4(r)3(osoft, Tic)4(k)0(e)4(tma)4(ste)4(r\222s c)4(o)0(mpla)4(int ra)4(ise)4(d)0( the)4( que)4(stion whe)4(t)-2(he)4(r the)4( use)4( of)]TJ
0 -2.15 TD
( )Tj
ET
113.49 116.79 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 141.81 105.03 Tm
0.007 Tc
(24)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 149.97 99.51 Tm
0 Tc
[( Http://www.ljx)-10(.com/L)21(J)-11(X)2(files/ticketmaster/complaint.html)]TJ
-0.68 -1.18 TD
(\(971017\))Tj
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 77.67 Tm
(25)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 73.11 Tm
-0.022 Tc
0.025 Tw
[( H)-23(t)-21(t)-21(p)-28(:)-21(/)-21(/)-21(www.)-25(l)-21(j)-33(x)-16(.)-25(c)-24(o)-28(m/)-21(L)-13(J)-31(X)-23(f)-14(i)-21(l)-21(e)-24(s)]TJ
11.9518 0 TD
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(/tick)8(e)0(tm)21(as)5(ter/an)8(s)5(w)25(er.h)8(tm)21(l \(971017\))]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
310 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
311 0 obj
<<
/Length 6191
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(10)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
0 Tw
[(hy)30(pertex)-10(t links is lawful. Microsoft wanted the court to remove all the)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(doubts concerning)9( the free working)9(s)-2( of the I)22(n)-1(ternet. On J)-12(une 23, 1997,)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(Tic)5(k)1(e)5(tma)5(ste)5(r)4( re)5(plie)5(d,)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 215.25 722.67 Tm
0.007 Tc
(26)Tj
12 0 0 12 223.41 717.15 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( deny)29(ing)9( that it attacked the g)9(e)3(neral use of hy)29(perlinks,)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
-9.16 -1.18 TD
(and that it was an unlawful use and misappropriation of Ticketmaster\222s)Tj
T*
[(property)29(.)-1( This case is y)29(e)3(t to be treated in court, and it may)29( \(hopefully)29(\))]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(be)4(c)4(o)0(me)4( the)4( first U.S. hy)30(pe)4(rlinking)10( c)4(a)4(s)-1(e)4( not se)4(ttling)10( out of c)4(ourt.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 650.91 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(\026\021\031\003)-436(\0036KHWODQG\0031HZ)-15(V)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 620.07 Tm
0.001 Tw
[(On 24 October 1996, J)-12(udg)9(e L)20(o)-1(rd Hamilton in Scotland g)9(a)3(ve a preliminary)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(inte)4(rdic)4(t \(e)4(qua)4(l to injunc)4(tion\) to pre)4(v)0(e)4(n)0(t the)4( ne)4(wspa)4(pe)4(r She)4(tla)4(nd Ne)4(ws from)]TJ
T*
[(using)10( hy)30(perlinks on its website to the rival Shetland Times.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 397.65 597.27 Tm
0.006 Tc
-0.002 Tw
( 27)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 407.85 591.75 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[( The S)-6(h)-2(et)-4(l)-4(a)2(nd)]TJ
-24.53 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(News site \(www.shetland-news.co.uk\) display)29(e)3(d various news headlines)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(orig)10(inating)10( from the Shetland Times site \(www.shetland-times.co.uk\). These)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(headlines consisted of hy)29(pertex)-11(t links, that linked \223deep\224 into the Shetland)]TJ
T*
[(Times site. The main front pag)9(e)3( of the Shetland Times site was by)29(passed, as)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(we)5(ll a)5(s)0( a)5(ll a)5(dve)5(rtising)11( on it. The)5( She)5(tla)5(nd Time)5(s a)5(r)4(g)11(u)1(e)5(d)1( tha)5(t)-1( suc)5(h)1( be)5(ha)5(vior)]TJ
T*
[(c)5(onstitute)5(d c)5(opy)31(rig)11(h)1(t infring)11(e)5(m)-1(e)5(n)1(t. The)5( judg)11(e)5( g)11(r)4(a)5(n)1(te)5(d inte)5(rim inte)5(rdic)5(t,)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(since the Shetland News would not suffer any)29( major loss if prevented from)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(hy)31(pe)5(rlinking)11( to the)5( She)5(tla)5(nd Time)5(s site)5(s. Pe)5(rha)5(p)1(s the)5( She)5(tla)5(nd Ne)5(ws site)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(would be less interesting)10( without the links to the S)-4(h)0(etland Times and receive)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(fewer hits, which could lead to loss of advertising)9( revenue, in the long)9( run.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(One m)-4(a)2(y)28( arg)8(u)-2(e t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e S)-6(h)-2(et)-4(l)-4(a)2(nd Ti)-4(m)-4(e)2(s does not)-4( suffer any)28( harm)-4( when)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(being)10( the subject linked to. This may)30( be true, but one should not forg)10(et that)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(the linking)9( mig)9(ht result in a loss of advertising)9( revenue, since the front)]TJ
T*
[(pag)9(e)3(s are by)29(passed. W)-7(h)-1(en it comes to intellectual property)29(,)-1( there are pride)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(and possessive feeling)10(s)-1( involved as well. I)23(t)-2( is completely)30( understandable)]TJ
T*
[(that authors detest seeing)10( their work being)10( utilized without compensation.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 328.71 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\026\021\031\021\024)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(7KH\003LQWHULP\003LQMXQFWLRQ\003LV\003QRW\003WKH\003GHDWK\003RI\003K\\SHUOLQNLQJ)Tj
-2.6154 -1.1795 TD
-0.003 Tc
(LQ\003WKH\0038\021.\021)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 283.71 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(The main question in the case was whether hy)29(perlinks are considered lawful.)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(The interim injunction g)10(i)-2(ven by)30( J)-11(udg)10(e L)21(o)0(rd Hamilton should not be seen as)]TJ
T*
[(the death of hy)30(perlinking)10(, since all the court considers in such a situation, is)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(whether there is an issue to be tried and the balance of convenience. The)Tj
T*
[(questions concerning)9( hy)29(perlinking)9( and whether a publisher on the I)22(n)-1(ternet)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(re)5(ta)5(ins c)5(opy)31(rig)11(h)1(t in a)5(n)1(y)31( ma)5(te)5(ria)5(l)-1( onc)5(e)5( it is publishe)5(d on the)5( I)24(n)1(te)5(rne)5(t)-1(,)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
[(re)4(ma)4(ins.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 154.41 204.27 Tm
0.007 Tc
(28)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 148.95 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 152.07 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 141.81 140.31 Tm
0.007 Tc
(26)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 149.97 134.79 Tm
0 Tc
[( Http://www.ljx)-10(.com/L)21(J)-11(X)2(files/ticketmaster/reply)30(.html)]TJ
-0.68 -1.18 TD
(\(971017\))Tj
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 112.95 Tm
(27)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 108.39 Tm
-0.023 Tc
0.026 Tw
[( H)-24(t)-22(t)-22(p)-29(:)-22(/)-22(/)-22(www.)-26(s)-20(h)-17(e)-25(t)-22(l)-22(a)-25(n)-17(d)-29(-)-15(n)-17(e)-25(w)0(s)-20(.)-26(c)-25(o)-29(.)-26(u)-17(k)-17(/)-22(o)-29(p)-29(i)-22(n)-17(i)-22(o)-29(n)-17(.)-26(h)-17(t)-22(m)-4(l)-22( \()]TJ
19.3253 0 TD
0.006 Tc
(971006\))Tj
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 101.19 Tm
0 Tc
(28)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 96.63 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(7KH\003,QWHUQHW\003&RS\\ULJKW\003&DVH\003DQG\003LWV\003LPSOLFDWLRQV\003IRU\003XVHUV\003RI\003WKH\003:::)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
28.7108 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
(, by)Tj
-29.6145 -1.1807 TD
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[(P)-7(r)-1(of)11(es)6(s)6(o)-3(r C)7(h)9(arles)6( Oppen)9(h)9(e)1(im)22(, Dec.6, 1996. Http://)]TJ
20.5301 0 TD
-0.023 Tc
[(www.)-26(s)-20(h)-17(e)-25(t)-22(l)-22(a)-25(n)-17(d)-29(-)]TJ
-20.5301 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(n)11(e)3(w)28(s)8(.co.u)11(k)11(/)6(edi)6(t)6(o)-1(ri)6(al)6(/)6(p)-1(rof)13(opp1.h)11(t)6(m)24( \(970715\))]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
312 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
313 0 obj
<<
/Length 6845
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(11)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 743.31 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\026\021\031\021\025)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(1HZVSDSHU\003KHDGOLQHV\003RQ\003D\003ZHEVLWH\003PD\\\003HQMR\\\003FRS\\ULJKW)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 714.87 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(I)24(n)1( the)5( She)5(tla)5(nd Ne)5(ws c)5(a)5(s)0(e)5(,)1( only)31( the)5( URL)22(s)0( a)5(nd the)5( title)5(s of the)5( a)5(r)4(tic)5(le)5(s we)5(re)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(actually)29( copied, and therefore the Shetland Times had to prove that the)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(URL)21(s)-1( a)4(nd the)4( he)4(a)4(d)0(line)4(s)-1( we)4(re)4( lite)4(ra)4(ry)30( works worthy)30( of c)4(opy)30(rig)10(h)0(t prote)4(c)4(tion.)]TJ
T*
[(Ac)4(c)4(o)0(rding)10( to Profe)4(ssor Cha)4(r)3(le)4(s Oppe)4(nhe)4(im, the)4( c)4(ourts in the)4( Unite)4(d)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(King)9(dom very)29( seldom consider copy)29(ing)9( or quoting)9( parts of a sentence, or a)]TJ
T*
[(sing)9(le word as a copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(t infring)9(ement.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 307.17 649.59 Tm
0.007 Tc
(29)Tj
12 0 0 12 315.33 644.07 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( This le)5(a)5(d)1(s to the)5( que)5(stion)]TJ
-16.82 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(whether sing)9(le sentences, like in this case, a newspaper headline, could)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(enjoy)30( copy)30(rig)10(h)0(t. Professor Charles Oppenheim doubted that this could be)]TJ
T*
[(the)4( c)4(a)4(s)-1(e)4(,)0( due)4( to the)4( a)4(b)0(se)4(nc)4(e)4( of unique)4(ne)4(ss a)4(nd orig)10(ina)4(lity)30( of the)4( c)4(opie)4(d)]TJ
T*
[(sentences, but he did not totally)30( dismiss the idea that they)30( could enjoy)]TJ
T*
[(copy)30(rig)10(h)0(t.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 550.95 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\026\021\031\021\026)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(85/\003PD\\\003HQMR\\\003FRS\\ULJKW)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 522.51 Tm
0 Tc
[(I)23(n)0( the United King)10(dom, it is not possible to have a sing)10(le fact protected by)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(t, and one could arg)9(u)-1(e that the URL)20(s)-2( are merely)29( addresses, i.e.)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(facts, and not worthy)30( of copy)30(rig)10(h)0(t protection. Compilations of facts,)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(however, could enjoy)29( such protection. Professor Charles Oppenheim found)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(it unlikely)30( that the copy)30(ing)10( of the URL)21(s)-1( in this case would be considered a)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(t infring)9(ement, since only)29( a few URL)20(s)-2( were copied.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 403.05 457.23 Tm
0.007 Tc
(30)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 429.39 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\026\021\031\021\027)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(\)DLU\003GHDOLQJ\003DQG\003LPSOLHG\003OLFHQVH\003ZKHQ\003FRS\\LQJ\00385/)-5(V)]TJ
-2.6154 -1.1795 TD
(DQG\003QHZV\003KHDGOLQHV)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 384.39 Tm
0.001 Tw
[(I)22(f)2( a court would find the materials that was linked to copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(table, the nex)-11(t)]TJ
T*
[(question, according)9( to P)-5(r)2(ofessor Charles Oppenheim, is whether the)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
[(Shetland News was allowed to copy)29( under the \224fair dealing)9(\224)3( doctrine or if)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(a)5(n)1(y)31( implie)5(d lic)5(e)5(n)1(se)5( to c)5(opy)31( e)5(x)-9(iste)5(d. He)5( sta)5(t)-1(e)5(d)1( tha)5(t)-1( in the)5( Unite)5(d King)11(dom,)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(newspapers g)9(e)3(nerally)29( can copy)29( from each other under this doctrine, due to)]TJ
T*
[(the freedom of speech. Concerning)9( an implied license, Professor Charles)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Oppenheim arg)10(u)0(ed that by)30( display)30(i)-2(ng)10( information on a site on the W)-6(o)0(rld)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(W)-7(i)-3(de W)-7(e)3(b, one m)-3(u)-1(st)-3( accept)-3( ot)-3(hers l)-3(i)-3(nki)-3(ng)9( t)-3(o)-1( i)-3(t)-3(,)-1( si)-3(nce l)-3(i)-3(nki)-3(ng)9( i)-3(s)-2( t)-3(h)-1(e core of)]TJ
T*
[(the W)-7(o)-1(rld W)-7(i)-3(de W)-7(e)3(b\222s construction and success. Oppenheim succumbs to)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(the opinion that permission to link is g)10(r)3(anted by)30( implication due to the mere)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(fact)-4( t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e si)-4(t)-4(e)2( ex)-12(i)-4(s)-3(t)-4(s)-3( on t)-4(h)-2(e net)-4(.)-2( P)-6(r)1(ofessor C)-5(h)-2(arl)-4(e)2(s Oppenhei)-4(m)-4( decl)-4(ared)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
(that if the Shetland Times would win the case, this would function as a)Tj
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(barrier to the further development of the I)22(n)-1(ternet in the United King)9(dom.)]TJ
T*
[(Sites overseas would not be affected by)29( such an outcome he wrote.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 433.77 205.83 Tm
0.007 Tc
(31)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 155.91 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 159.03 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 148.23 Tm
(29)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 143.67 Tm
-0.023 Tc
0.026 Tw
[( H)-24(t)-22(t)-22(p)-29(:)-22(/)-22(/)-22(www.)-26(s)-20(h)-17(e)-25(t)-22(l)-22(a)-25(n)-17(d)-29(-)-15(n)-17(e)-25(w)0(s)-20(.)-26(c)-25(o)-29(.)-26(u)-17(k)-17(/)-22(e)-25(d)-29(i)-22(t)-22(o)-29(r)-27(i)-22(a)-25(l)-22(/)-22(p)-29(r)-27(o)-29(f)]TJ
18.9157 0 TD
0.006 Tc
-0.003 Tw
[(opp1.h)12(t)7(m)25( \(970715\))]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 136.47 Tm
0 Tc
(30)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 131.91 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(7KH\003,QWHUQHW\003&RS\\ULJKW\003&DVH\003DQG\003LWV\003LPSOLFDWLRQV\003IRU\003XVHUV\003RI\003WKH\003:::)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
28.7108 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
(, by)Tj
-29.6145 -1.1807 TD
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[(P)-7(r)-1(of)11(es)6(s)6(o)-3(r C)7(h)9(arles)6( Oppen)9(h)9(e)1(im)22(, Dec.6, 1996. Http://)]TJ
20.5301 0 TD
-0.023 Tc
[(www.)-26(s)-20(h)-17(e)-25(t)-22(l)-22(a)-25(n)-17(d)-29(-)]TJ
-20.5301 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(n)11(e)3(w)28(s)8(.co.u)11(k)11(/)6(edi)6(t)6(o)-1(ri)6(al)6(/)6(p)-1(rof)13(opp1.h)11(t)6(m)24( \(970715\))]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 101.19 Tm
0 Tc
(31)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 96.63 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(7KH\003,QWHUQHW\003&RS\\ULJKW\003&DVH\003DQG\003LWV\003LPSOLFDWLRQV\003IRU\003XVHUV\003RI\003WKH\003:::)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
28.7108 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
(, by)Tj
-29.6145 -1.1807 TD
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[(P)-7(r)-1(of)11(es)6(s)6(o)-3(r C)7(h)9(arles)6( Oppen)9(h)9(e)1(im)22(, Dec.6, 1996. Http://)]TJ
20.5301 0 TD
-0.023 Tc
[(www.)-26(s)-20(h)-17(e)-25(t)-22(l)-22(a)-25(n)-17(d)-29(-)]TJ
-20.5301 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(n)11(e)3(w)28(s)8(.co.u)11(k)11(/)6(edi)6(t)6(o)-1(ri)6(al)6(/)6(p)-1(rof)13(opp1.h)11(t)6(m)24( \(970715\))]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
314 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
315 0 obj
<<
/Length 7797
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(12)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 743.31 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\026\021\031\021\030)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(6HWWOHPHQW\003UHDFKHG\003LQ\0031RYHPEHU\003\024\034\034\032)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 714.87 Tm
0 Tc
[(The)4( c)4(ourt unfortuna)4(te)4(ly)30( ne)4(ve)4(r trie)4(d the)4( c)4(a)4(s)-1(e)4(,)0( sinc)4(e)4( the)4( pa)4(rtie)4(s se)4(ttle)4(d outside)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(the courtroom on November 11, 1997. Under the settlement, the Shetland)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(News was g)10(r)3(anted permission to link to the Shetland Times\222 headlines, but)]TJ
T*
[(had to label individual articles as \223A Shetland Times Story)30(.)0(\224)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 403.53 677.91 Tm
0.007 Tc
(32)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 411.69 672.39 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( She)5(tla)5(nd)]TJ
-24.85 -1.18 TD
[(Ne)5(ws a)5(l)-1(so a)5(g)11(re)5(e)5(d)1( to displa)5(y)31( a)5( button with the)5( She)5(tla)5(nd Time)5(s\222 log)11(o)1( tha)5(t)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(links to the newspaper\222s \223front\224 homepag)9(e and not deep into its\222 website)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
[(sy)31(stem.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 606.15 Tm
0 Tc
[(\026\021\032\003)-435(+\\)11(SHUWH[WV\003LQ\003D\0036Z)-14(H)-1(GLVK\003SHUVSHFWLY)21(H\035)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
[(0DNLQJ\003D\003OLQN\003LV\003QRW\003HTXLY)20(DOHQW\003RI\003SURGXFLQJ\003D)]TJ
T*
[(FRS\\)10(\003RI\003WKH\003PDWHULDO\003OLQNHG\003WR)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 537.63 Tm
[(I)22(n)-1( Sweden, as far as I)22( understand, there still do not ex)-11(ist any)29( cases involving)]TJ
T*
[(hy)29(perlinking)9(, but there are rules that mig)9(ht be applicable. According)9( to Mr.)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(C)-5(a)2(rl)-4(\351n-W)-8(endel)-4(s)-3(, a l)-4(a)2(wy)28(er speci)-4(al)-4(i)-4(z)-8(ed i)-4(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e fi)-4(el)-4(d of I)21(T)-1(, t)-4(h)-2(ere do not)-4( ex)-12(i)-4(s)-3(t)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(a)5(n)1(y)31( Swe)5(d)1(ish rule)5(s prohibiting)11( hy)31(pe)5(rte)5(x)-9(t links,)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 334.05 500.67 Tm
0.007 Tc
(33)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 342.21 495.15 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( since solely)29( producing)9( a)]TJ
-19.06 -1.18 TD
[(link is not considered equivalent of producing)9( a copy)29(. As the HTML)20( code is)]TJ
T*
[(written in the source of the web document, no copy)29( is made, according)9( to)]TJ
T*
[(Mr.Carl\351n-W)-7(e)3(ndels. However, the user produces a copy)29( \(in his computer\))]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
(once he )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
3.32 0 TD
0.004 Tc
[(IR)10(OOR)10(ZV)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
2.9 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( the link. Not even a larg)9(e protected photog)9(raph in the shape)]TJ
-6.22 -1.18 TD
[(of an I)22(M)-2(G should be considered infring)9(ement, since no copy)29( is produced by)]TJ
T*
[(the web-editor. W)-7(h)-1(en the user visits the site, a copy)29( is produced and)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(displa)5(y)31(e)5(d on the)5( site)5( a)5(u)1(toma)5(tic)5(a)5(lly)31(. I)24(t)-1( is the)5( use)5(r)4( tha)5(t)-1( uninte)5(n)1(tiona)5(lly)31( trig)11(g)11(e)5(rs)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(the)4( c)4(opy)30(ing)10( by)30( visiting)10( the)4( site)4(. The)4( use)4(r)3( is proba)4(bly)30( una)4(wa)4(re)4( of the)4( fa)4(c)4(t)-2( tha)4(t)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(he/she produces a copy)29( of a protected photog)9(raph. Even thoug)9(h one may)]TJ
T*
[(arg)9(u)-1(e that the user infring)9(es upon copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(ts by)29( producing)9( a copy)29(, it would)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(m)-4(o)-2(st)-4( cert)-4(a)2(i)-4(n)-2( be consi)-4(d)-2(ered l)-4(a)2(wful)-4( accordi)-4(n)-2(g)8( t)-4(o)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e S)-6(w)0(edi)-4(s)-3(h \224pri)-4(vat)-4(e)2( use)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
[(doc)4(trine)4(\224)4(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 161.01 330.75 Tm
0.007 Tc
(34)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 169.17 325.23 Tm
-0.023 Tc
0.023 Tw
[( It)-25( )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
1.09 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
(PD\\)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
1.66 0 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( be)5( ille)5(g)11(a)5(l if one)5( c)5(onside)5(r)4(s the)5( situa)5(tion a)5(s)0( infring)11(e)5(m)-1(e)5(n)1(t of)]TJ
-7.39 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(the developer\222s rig)9(h)-1(t of delivery)29( or performance, but this is uncertain at the)]TJ
T*
[(moment. I)22(f)2( the link consist of a protected trademark log)9(o, the Swedish law)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 471.33 302.43 Tm
0.007 Tc
(35)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 282.75 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(is a)5(pplic)5(a)5(b)1(le)5( whe)5(n)1( the)5( ma)5(rk is use)5(d)1(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 286.89 288.27 Tm
0.007 Tc
(36)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 254.43 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(According)10( to Swedish law, a traditional HREF)6( link, written in a neutral font)]TJ
T*
[(without display)30(i)-2(ng)10( any)30( log)10(o)0(s or trademarks should not be considered an)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(infring)9(ement. However, if a link consists of parts of the linked-to-site\222s)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(c)5(onte)5(n)1(t \(te)5(x)-9(t, not pic)5(t)-1(ure)5(s)0(\), it ma)5(y)31( c)5(onstitute)5( infring)11(e)5(m)-1(e)5(n)1(t, but it ma)5(y)31( on the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(other hand be leg)9(a)3(l due to the rig)9(h)-1(t to quote.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 325.65 203.31 Tm
0.007 Tc
(37)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 333.81 197.79 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( The Swedish rig)10(h)0(t to quote is,)]TJ
-18.36 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(nonetheless, dependent upon moral and ethics.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 336.81 189.15 Tm
0.007 Tc
(38)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 344.97 183.63 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[( W)-7(h)-1(ether it would be moral)]TJ
-19.29 -2.31 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 159.03 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 148.23 Tm
(32)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 143.67 Tm
-0.023 Tc
0.026 Tw
[( H)-24(t)-22(t)-22(p)-29(:)-22(/)-22(/)-22(www.)-26(n)-17(e)-25(ws)-20(.)-26(c)-25(o)-29(m)-4(/)-22(N)-24(e)-25(w)0(s)-20(/)-22(I)-27(t)-22(e)-25(m)-4(/)-22(0)-29(,)-26(4)-29(,)]TJ
15.6265 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(16280,00.h)11(t)6(m)24(l)6(?)-9(d)-1(t)6(n)11(.h)11(ead \(971212\))]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 136.47 Tm
0 Tc
(33)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 131.91 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(/DJ\003RFK\003UlWW\003Sn\003,QWHUQHW)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
9.6747 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, T)-12(h)10(om)23(as)7( )]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
3.9759 0 TD
[(C)8(a)2(rl)5(\351n)10(-)12(W)-4(en)10(del)5(s)7(, pag)10(e)2( 95.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 124.71 Tm
0 Tc
(34)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 120.15 Tm
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[( L)12(a)1(g)9( \(1960:729\) om)22( u)9(pph)9(ov)9(r\344tt till litter\344ra och)9( k)9(o)-3(n)9(s)6(tn)9(\344rlig)9(a v)9(e)1(rk)9(, 1:12.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 112.95 Tm
0 Tc
(35)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 108.39 Tm
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( Varu)10(m)23(\344)2(rk)10(es)7(l)5(a)2(g)10( \(1960:)5(644\))]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 101.19 Tm
0 Tc
(36)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 96.63 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(/DJ\003RFK\003UlWW\003Sn\003,QWHUQHW)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.6747 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, T)-12(h)10(om)23(as)7( C)8(a)2(rl)5(\351n)10(-)12(W)-4(en)10(del)5(s)7(, pag)10(e)2( 95.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
0 Tc
(37)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 84.87 Tm
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[( L)12(a)1(g)9( \(1960:729\) om)22( u)9(pph)9(ov)9(r\344tt till litter\344ra och)9( k)9(o)-3(n)9(s)6(tn)9(\344rlig)9(a v)9(e)1(rk)9(, 1:22.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 77.67 Tm
0 Tc
(38)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 73.11 Tm
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( \223)14(G)3(od s)7(e)2(d\224 i)5(n)10( S)6(w)27(edi)5(s)7(h)10(.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
316 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
318 0 obj
<<
/Length 1571
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(13)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
0 Tw
[(or not to quote the linked site in the linking)10( site is uncertain. However, it)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(may)29( be possible to define the tex)-11(t)-3( describing)9( the content of the linked-to-)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(site)4(, a)4(s)-1( a)4(n)0( ordina)4(ry)30( summa)4(ry)30( or re)4(vie)4(w)2(. Writing)10( a)4( brie)4(f summa)4(ry)30( e)4(x)-10(pla)4(i)-2(ning)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(the)5( c)5(onte)5(n)1(t of the)5( linke)5(d site)5( is most like)5(l)-1(y)31( la)5(wful.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 353.73 708.51 Tm
0.007 Tc
(39)Tj
12 0 0 12 361.89 702.99 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
( This of course, requires)Tj
-20.7 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(that the linker does not simply)30( copy)30( the tex)-10(t)-2(, or write too resembling)10(.)0( The)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(linker should write a summary)29( with his/her own words in order to avoid)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(being)10( subject to the reg)10(u)0(lations concerning)10( quotations. This may)30( not alway)30(s)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(be an easy)29( t)-3(a)3(sk.)]TJ
0 -46.75 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 88.47 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 77.67 Tm
(39)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 73.11 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(/lURERN\003L\003,PPDWHULDOUlWW\017)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
10.3494 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( Kok)10(t)5(v)10(e)2(dg)10(aard an)10(d L)13(e)2(v)10(i)5(n)10(,)1( , pag)10(e)2( 158.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
319 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
320 0 obj
<<
/Length 6193
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(14)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
24 0 0 24 113.49 733.71 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(\027\003)-311(&DFKLQJ)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 693.27 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(C)-5(achi)-4(n)-2(g)8( i)-4(s)-3( an operat)-4(i)-4(on of st)-4(ori)-4(n)-2(g)8( som)-4(e)2(t)-4(h)-2(i)-4(n)-2(g)8( i)-4(n)-2( a pl)-4(ace of st)-4(orag)8(e. C)-5(achi)-4(n)-2(g)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(in the)4( world of c)4(o)0(mpute)4(r)3(s is possible)4( a)4(t)-2( multiple)4( le)4(ve)4(ls. I)23(n)0( orde)4(r to vie)4(w)2( a)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(document on the screen it is necessary)29( that a \224copy)29(\224 of that document is)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(loaded into the Random Access Memory)30( \(RAM\). I)23(f)3( no copy)30( is made in the)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(RAM, nothing)11( will be)5( displa)5(y)31(e)5(d on the)5( use)5(r\222s monitor. Whe)5(n)1( a)5( c)5(o)1(mpute)5(r)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(browses the web, a plethora of information, such as recently)29( visited web)]TJ
T*
[(pag)9(e)3(s, pictures and tex)-11(t)-3(s, are stored locally)29( on the computer\222s harddrive as)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(wel)-4(l)-4( as i)-4(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e com)-4(put)-4(er\222s R)-5(A)0(M. Oft)-4(e)2(n t)-4(h)-2(e browser creat)-4(es a m)-4(a)2(p cal)-4(l)-4(e)2(d)]TJ
T*
[(\223cache\224 i)-4(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e com)-4(put)-4(er\222s di)-4(rect)-4(ory)28( i)-4(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e ex)-12(pl)-4(orer. Thi)-4(s)-3( m)-4(a)2(p cont)-4(ai)-4(ns)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(frag)10(m)-2(ents of visited sites, but it should not be confused with the caching)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(t)-3(a)3(ki)-3(ng)9( pl)-3(ace i)-3(n)-1( t)-3(h)-1(e R)-4(A)1(M. I)22(f)2( t)-3(h)-1(e com)-3(put)-3(er i)-3(s)-2( swi)-3(t)-3(c)3(hed off, onl)-3(y)29( t)-3(h)-1(e)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(informa)4(tion store)4(d)0( on the)4( ha)4(rddrive)4( will re)4(ma)4(in. The)4( informa)4(tion store)4(d)0( in)]TJ
T*
[(the)4( RAM will be)4( lost fore)4(ve)4(r.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(How does t)-4(h)-2(e l)-4(o)-2(cal)-4( cachi)-4(n)-2(g)8( work?)-18( I)21(f)1( a person usi)-4(n)-2(g)8( Net)-4(s)-3(cape Navi)-4(g)8(a)2(t)-4(o)-2(r for)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(i)-3(n)-1(st)-3(ance, wi)-3(shes t)-3(o)-1( ret)-3(r)2(i)-3(e)3(ve a pag)9(e)3( recent)-3(l)-3(y)29( vi)-3(si)-3(t)-3(e)3(d, i)-3(t)-3( i)-3(s)-2( possi)-3(bl)-3(e t)-3(o)-1( press t)-3(h)-1(e)]TJ
T*
[(\224back\224 button in order to do so. The computer is then likely)29( to display)29( a)]TJ
T*
[(pag)9(e)3( that is stored in the RAM instead of display)29(i)-3(ng)9( a \224new\224 copy)29( of the)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
[(pag)8(e)2(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 138.93 443.91 Tm
0.007 Tc
(40)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 147.09 438.39 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[( This can easily)29( be demonstrated by)29( closing)9( down the I)22(n)-1(ternet)]TJ
-2.8 -1.18 TD
[(connection after browsing)9(, while keeping)9( the Netscape)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 376.29 429.75 Tm
0.007 Tc
(41)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 384.45 424.23 Tm
-0.001 Tc
( window active.)Tj
-22.58 -1.18 TD
[(Even thoug)9(h the user is off-line and the computer has no connection with)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(the)5( ne)5(twork, it is still possible)5( to re)5(-visit some)5( of the)5( site)5(s the)5( use)5(r)4( visite)5(d, a)5(s)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(he/she was on-line. These sites have been stored locally)29( in the RAM, and)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(frag)8(m)-4(ent)-4(s)-3( such as pi)-4(ct)-4(ures et)-4(c. have been st)-4(ored i)-4(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e cache fi)-4(l)-4(e)2( on t)-4(h)-2(e)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(ha)4(rddrive)4(.)0( Onc)4(e)4( the)4( c)4(o)0(mpute)4(r)3( is switc)4(he)4(d off, a)4(ll the)4( informa)4(tion in the)]TJ
T*
(RAM will be lost. The information stored in the cache file, however, is still)Tj
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(intact after the computer has been switched off, but is insufficient in order to)Tj
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(re-vi)-4(s)-3(i)-4(t)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e si)-4(t)-4(e)2(s off-l)-4(i)-4(n)-2(e, si)-4(nce t)-4(h)-2(e cache-fi)-4(l)-4(e)2( m)-4(a)2(i)-4(n)-2(l)-4(y)28( consi)-4(s)-3(t)-4(s)-3( of frag)8(m)-4(ent)-4(s)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(from the sites. I)22(n)-1( a normal browser, the user can easily)29( decide the siz)-7(e)3( of the)]TJ
T*
[(memory)29( cache and the disk cache when setting)9( the network preferences. The)]TJ
T*
[(siz)-7(e)3( of the memory)29( cache is, however, limited by)29( the amount of RAM the)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(computer is equipped with and the disk cache is limited by)30( the amount of)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(MB)6( the harddrive contains.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 216.39 Tm
0 Tc
[(\027\021\024\003)-435(&)0(DFKLQJ\003LV\003VRPHWLPHV\003FRQVLGHUHG\003D)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
[(FRS\\)10(ULJKW\003LQIULQJHPHQW)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 166.71 Tm
[(Some people arg)9(u)-1(e that the copy)29( made in the RAM is a copy)29( that can be)]TJ
T*
[(jux)-11(t)-3(aposed to any)29( other form of copy)29(, and therefore RAM-copies could)]TJ
T*
[(infring)9(e copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(ts. How could a copy)29( in the RAM be sufficiently)29( fix)-11(e)3(d in)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(orde)4(r to c)4(onstitute)4( a)4( c)4(opy)30(?)-16( Ac)4(c)4(o)0(rding)10( to Swe)4(d)0(ish la)4(w, a)4( c)4(opy)30( is ma)4(de)4( if the)]TJ
0 -1.28 TD
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 111.99 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 101.19 Tm
(40)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 96.63 Tm
0.001 Tc
0.002 Tw
[( T)-15(h)7(is procedu)7(r)-3(e sav)7(e)-1(s tim)20(e f)9(o)-5(r th)7(e u)7(s)4(er an)7(d reliev)7(e)-1(s u)7(n)7(n)7(ecessary)19( con)7(g)7(e)-1(stion)]TJ
-0.6506 -1.1807 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.004 Tw
[(f)7(r)-5(o)-7(m)18( the inf)7(r)-5(astructure.)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 77.67 Tm
0 Tc
(41)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 73.11 Tm
-0.004 Tc
0.007 Tw
[( O)-5(r)-8( a)-6(n)2(o)-10(t)-3(he)-6(r)-8( e)-6(q)-10(uiva)-6(le)-6(nt b)-10(r)-8(o)-10(w)19(se)-6(r)-8( suc)-6(h)2( a)-6(s)-1( )]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
15.8554 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(Mi)5(cros)7(of)12(t)5(\222)12(s)7( In)10(t)5(e)2(rn)10(et)5( Ex)10(pl)5(orer.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
321 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
322 0 obj
<<
/Length 6324
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(15)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(work is transferred to a device throug)9(h which it can be reproduced and)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
[(display)30(e)4(d.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 162.09 736.83 Tm
0.007 Tc
(42)Tj
12 0 0 12 170.25 731.31 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[( Once the computer is switched off, the copy)29( does not ex)-11(ist any)]TJ
-4.73 -1.18 TD
[(more, but until then, the copy)29( can be reproduced and display)29(e)3(d forever. I)]TJ
T*
[(believe that such a copy)29( would be leg)9(a)3(l under the fair use doctrine.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 433.29 708.51 Tm
0.007 Tc
(43)Tj
12 0 0 12 441.45 702.99 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
( This)Tj
-27.33 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(doctrine in Sweden does not include computer prog)9(rams thoug)9(h. The EU)]TJ
T*
[(makes no distinction between temporary)29( copies and permanent copies, as an)]TJ
T*
(act of reproduction.)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 207.57 666.03 Tm
0.007 Tc
(44)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 636.75 Tm
0 Tc
[(\027\021\025\003)-435(/)0(HJDO\003FRQVLGHUDWLRQV\003FRQFHUQLQJ\003EURZ)-14(VLQJ)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 605.91 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(W)-7(h)-1(en users surf the I)22(n)-1(ternet, browsers)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 298.17 611.43 Tm
0.007 Tc
(45)Tj
12 0 0 12 306.33 605.91 Tm
-0.001 Tc
( are used in order to enable)Tj
-16.07 -1.18 TD
[(connection to all the various sites available. The phenomenon of caching)9( is)]TJ
T*
[(vital to the art of browsing)9(, as described above. As the user ploug)9(hs throug)9(h)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(h)-2(e avai)-4(l)-4(a)2(bl)-4(e post)-4(e)2(d i)-4(n)-2(form)-4(at)-4(i)-4(on i)-4(n)-2( C)-5(y)28(berspace, t)-4(h)-2(e com)-4(put)-4(er m)-4(a)2(kes copi)-4(es)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(of the)4( visite)4(d ma)4(te)4(ria)4(l)-2( in the)4( RAM, in orde)4(r to displa)4(y)30( it on the)4( use)4(r\222s)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(monitor. I)22(f)2( no copies of the material were made into the RAM, nothing)9( from)]TJ
T*
[(remote sites would have been ex)-11(posed to the user at all. Some arg)9(u)-1(e that)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(browsing)11( is ille)5(g)11(a)5(l due)5( to the)5( c)5(opy)31(ing)11( of poste)5(d prote)5(c)5(t)-1(e)5(d)1( ma)5(te)5(ria)5(l)-1( into the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(RAM, and thus the whole concept of surfing)9( the net would be unlawful. One)]TJ
T*
[(could arg)9(u)-1(e that businesses and persons setting)9( up public-access websites)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(\(site)4(s not prote)4(c)4(t)-2(e)4(d)0( by)30( pa)4(sswords or othe)4(r forms of se)4(c)4(u)0(rity)30(\), implic)4(itly)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(a)5(g)11(re)5(e)5(s)0( to le)5(t use)5(r)4(s e)5(n)1(te)5(r, study)31( a)5(nd e)5(x)-9(plore)5( the)5( site)5(. I)24(f)4( the)5(r)4(e)5( e)5(x)-9(ists a)5(n)1( implie)5(d)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(license to enter and ex)-11(plore a site, such a license would naturally)29( include the)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(copy)30(ing)10( of material into the RAM. I)23(f)3( not, why)30( would any)30(one g)10(o)0( throug)10(h the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(process of setting)9( up a website if nobody)29( can ever see it?)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 383.91 Tm
0 Tc
[(\027\021\026\003)-435(7)0(KH\003LQFUHDVLQJ\003XVDJH\003RI\003SDVVZ)-14(RUGV\003DQG)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
(XVHU\003,'V\003VXSSRUWV\003WKH\003H[LVWHQFH\003RI\003DQ\003LPSOLHG)Tj
T*
[(OLFHQVH\003WR\003Y)20(LVLW\003SXEOLF\020DFFHVV\003VLWHV)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 315.39 Tm
[(Today)29( many)29( sites require personal passwords and user I)22(D)1(s in order to enter,)]TJ
T*
[(which further supports the ex)-11(istence of an implied license for web users. I)22(t)]TJ
T*
[(has been arg)9(u)-1(ed that the fact that websites consist of intellectual property)29(,)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(not real property)30(,)0( does not hinder an implied license to visit, and)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(consequently)29( make a copy)29( into the RAM as well.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 348.81 264.27 Tm
0.007 Tc
(46)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 230.43 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(The question of implied licenses is very)30( interesting)10(.)0( Could one ex)-10(tend this)]TJ
T*
[(ide)4(a)4( a)4(nd a)4(r)3(g)10(u)0(e)4( tha)4(t)-2( busine)4(sse)4(s a)4(nd pe)4(rsons implic)4(itly)30( a)4(g)10(re)4(e)4( to more)4(, suc)4(h)0( a)4(s)]TJ
0 -4.05 TD
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 170.79 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 159.99 Tm
(42)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 155.43 Tm
0.003 Tc
[( L)12(a)1(g)9( \(1960:729\) om)22( Upph)9(ov)9(s)6(r)-1(\344tt till litter\344ra och)9( k)9(o)-3(n)9(s)6(tn)9(\344rlig)9(a v)9(e)1(rk)9( 2:2.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 148.23 Tm
0 Tc
(43)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 143.67 Tm
0.003 Tc
[( L)12(a)1(g)9( \(1960:729\) om)22( Upph)9(ov)9(s)6(r)-1(\344tt till litter\344ra och)9( k)9(o)-3(n)9(s)6(tn)9(\344rlig)9(a v)9(e)1(rk)9( 2:12.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 136.47 Tm
0 Tc
(44)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 131.91 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(3URSRVDO\003IRU\003D\003\(XURSHDQ\0033DUOLDPHQW\003DQG\003&RXQFLO\003'LUHFWLYH\003RQ\003WKH)Tj
-0.9036 -1.1807 TD
(KDUPRQLVDWLRQ\003RI\003FHUWDLQ\003DVSHFWV\003RI\003FRS\\ULJKW\003DQG\003UHODWHG\003ULJKWV\003LQ\003WKH)Tj
T*
(,QIRUPDWLRQ\0036RFLHW\\)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
7.9639 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(, Bru)11(s)8(s)8(e)3(l)6(s)8(, 10.12.1997. C)9(O)4(M\(97\)628 f)13(i)6(n)11(a)3(l)6(,)2( pag)11(e)3( 37.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 101.19 Tm
0 Tc
(45)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 96.63 Tm
0.001 Tc
0.002 Tw
[( T)-15(h)7(e tw)24(o m)20(o)-5(st com)20(m)20(o)-5(n)7( brow)24(sin)7(g)7( tools at th)7(is poin)7(t)2( in)7( tim)20(e are Netscape)]TJ
-0.6506 -1.1807 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(Nat)5(v)10(i)5(g)10(at)5(or/)5(C)8(om)23(m)23(u)10(n)10(i)5(cat)5(or an)10(d Mi)5(cros)7(of)12(t)5( In)10(t)5(e)2(rn)10(et)5( Ex)10(pl)5(orer.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 77.67 Tm
0 Tc
(46)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 73.11 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(&\\EHU/DZ\003\261\0037KH\003ODZ\003RI\003WKH\003,QWHUQHW)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
14.3373 0 TD
0.003 Tc
[(, by)21( J)-6(o)-3(n)9(a)1(th)9(an)9( R)7(o)-3(s)6(e)1(n)9(o)-3(er, pag)9(e)1( 10.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
323 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
325 0 obj
<<
/Length 6692
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(16)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(downl)-3(oadi)-3(ng)9( of t)-3(h)-1(e post)-3(e)3(d m)-3(a)3(t)-3(e)3(ri)-3(al)-3( i)-3(n)-1(t)-3(o)-1( a personal)-3( st)-3(orag)9(e pl)-3(ace, si)-3(m)-3(p)-1(l)-3(y)29( by)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(se)5(tting)11( up a)5( site)5(?)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 193.89 736.83 Tm
0.007 Tc
(47)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 707.55 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(\027\021\027\003)-436(0$,\0036\\)10(V)-2(WHPV\003&RUSRUDWLRQ\003Y)20(\021)-1(\0033HDN\003&RPSXWHU)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
(,QF\021)Tj
10.56 0 0 10.56 140.97 696.27 Tm
-0.007 Tc
[(\003\027)-7(\033)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 657.87 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(I)21(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e U.S)-6(., t)-4(h)-2(ere ex)-12(i)-4(s)-3(t)-4( a few cases concerni)-4(ng)8( t)-4(h)-2(e i)-4(n)-2(fect)-4(ed R)-5(A)0(M i)-4(ssue. I)21(n)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(the)5( wide)5(ly)31( c)5(r)4(itic)5(ize)5(d)1( c)5(a)5(s)0(e)5( )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
10.34 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(0$,\0036\\V)-9(W)-8(H)1(PV)-9(\003&)-12(RU)-9(SRU)-9(DW)-8(L)-8(RQ\003Y\021\0033HDN\003&)-12(R)1(PSXW)-8(HU)-9(\003,QF)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
19.39 0 TD
0 Tc
(.,)Tj
-29.73 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(MAI)22(,)-1( a computer manufacturer, sued Peak, an independent service)]TJ
T*
[(org)9(a)3(niz)-7(a)3(tion \(I)22(SO\) servicing)9( MAI)22( computers for more than one hundred)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(c)5(lie)5(nts. MAI)24( c)5(l)-1(a)5(ime)5(d tha)5(t)-1( e)5(v)1(e)5(r)4(y)31( time)5( Pe)5(a)5(k)1( se)5(rvic)5(e)5(d)1( a)5( MAI)24( c)5(o)1(mpute)5(r)4(, pa)5(rts)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(of t)-4(h)-2(e MAI)21( sy)28(st)-4(em)-4( soft)-4(ware were copi)-4(ed i)-4(n)-2(t)-4(o)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e R)-5(A)0(M and t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( t)-4(h)-2(ese copi)-4(es)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(violated MAI)22(\222)2(s copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(t. The MAI)22( software is an operating)9( sy)29(stem)]TJ
T*
[(software, which is one of the vital prog)9(rams needed in order to run any)29( other)]TJ
T*
[(prog)9(rams on MAI)22( computers.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 522.27 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\027\021\027\021\024)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
[($\003FRS\\\003VWRUHG\003LQ\003WKH\0035$0)23(\003LV\003FRQVLGHUHG\003D\003IL[HG\003FRS\\)]TJ
-2.6154 -1.1795 TD
(XQGHU\003WKH\003&RS\\ULJKW\003$FW)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 477.27 Tm
0.001 Tw
[(As Peak conducted routine maintenance and emerg)9(e)3(ncy)29( repairs, it was often)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(necessary)28( for P)-6(eak t)-4(echni)-4(ci)-4(ans)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 259.65 468.63 Tm
0.007 Tc
(49)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 267.81 463.11 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
( to operate the computers, and thus starting)Tj
-12.86 -1.18 TD
[(up the operating)9( sy)29(stem software in order to be able to see if the machines)]TJ
T*
[(were functioning)9( and operating)9( as they)29( should. I)22(n)-1( the case it was)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(indisputable that if a computer is switched on, the operating)10( sy)30(stem is)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(l)-4(o)-2(aded i)-4(n)-2(t)-4(o)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e com)-4(put)-4(er')8(s)-3( R)-5(A)0(M. P)-6(eak arg)8(u)-2(ed t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e l)-4(o)-2(adi)-4(n)-2(g)8( of)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(c)4(opy)30(rig)10(h)0(te)4(d softwa)4(re)4( did not c)4(onstitute)4( c)4(opy)30(rig)10(h)0(t infring)10(e)4(m)-2(e)4(n)0(t sinc)4(e)4( the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(copy)29( created in the RAM was not \224fix)-11(ed\224. The court defined RAM as a)]TJ
T*
[(computer component in which data and computer prog)9(rams can be)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(te)4(mpora)4(r)3(ily)30( re)4(c)4(o)0(rde)4(d, until the)4( c)4(o)0(mpute)4(r)3( is switc)4(he)4(d off. Howe)4(ve)4(r, the)4( c)4(ourt)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(did not find any)29( evidence showing)9( that a copy)29( created in the RAM would)]TJ
T*
[(not be of a fix)-11(e)3(d nature, and stated that copies made in the RAM are \224fix)-11(ed\224)]TJ
T*
[(and qualify)29( as copies under the Copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(t Act.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(I)23(t)-2( is very)30( interesting)10( that both the District Court and the Court of Appeal)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(accept)-3(e)3(d MAI)22(\222)2(s arg)9(u)-1(m)-3(e)3(nt)-3(. I)22(t)-3( was st)-3(at)-3(ed t)-3(h)-1(at)-3( copy)29(i)-3(n)-1(g)9( for purposes of)]TJ
T*
[(copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(t law occurs when a computer prog)9(ram is transferred from a)]TJ
T*
[(permanent storag)9(e device to a computer\222s RAM. I)22(t)-3( was shown that the work)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(created in the RAM was \224...sufficiently)30( permanent or stable to permit it to be)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(perceived, reproduced, or otherwise communicated for a period of more than)Tj
0 -4.36 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 159.03 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/T1 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 148.23 Tm
(\027\032)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 143.67 Tm
(\003,QWHUQHW\0037HFKQRORJ\\\003PDNHV\003LW\003KDUG\003WR\003SURWHFW\003D\003FRS\\ULJKW)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
23.1084 0 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.005 Tw
[(,)-5( I)-6(n)4(sid)-8(e)-4( B)-10(u)4(siness)]TJ
-23.759 -1.1807 TD
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(J)-7(u)8(ly)20( 1997, by)20( Kris)5(ten)8( C)6(a)0(ldw)25(e)0(ll. Http:// )]TJ
15.8313 0 TD
-0.023 Tc
(www.)Tj
2.3494 0 TD
-0.003 Tc
[(hunto)-9(n)3(.)-6(c)-5(o)-9(m)16(/in)]TJ
5.7711 0 TD
0.006 Tc
[(0797i)7(b.h)12(t)7(m)]TJ
-23.9518 -1.1807 TD
(\(971015\))Tj
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 112.95 Tm
0 Tc
(48)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 108.39 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(0$,\0036\\VWHPV\003&RUSRUDWLRQ\003Y\021\0033HDN\003&RPSXWHU\003,QF)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
19.506 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(., 991 F)7(.)2(2d 511 \(9)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 416.97 112.95 Tm
0 Tc
(th)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 141.81 96.63 Tm
0.005 Tc
[(C)9(i)6(r.1993\))]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
3.8916 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
-0.023 Tc
[(H)-24(t)-22(t)-22(p)-29(:)-22(/)-22(/)-22(www.)-26(l)-22(a)-25(w.)-26(s)-20(e)-25(a)]TJ
7.9157 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(ttleu)10(.)1(edu)10(/)5(ch)10(on)10(m)23(/)5(C)8(a)2(s)7(e)2(s)7(/)5(m)23(a)2(i.h)10(t)5(m)23(l)5( \(971026\))]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
0 Tc
(49)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 84.87 Tm
-0.003 Tc
0.006 Tw
[( E)-6(v)3(e)-5(n)3( tho)-9(ugh it ha)-5(s no)-9( r)-7(e)-5(le)-5(va)-5(nc)-5(e)-5( in the)-5( c)-5(a)-5(s)0(e)-5(,)-6( it m)16(a)-5(y)15( b)-9(e)-5( inte)-5(r)-7(e)-5(sting to)-9( no)-9(te)]TJ
-0.6506 -1.1807 TD
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[(th)9(at a f)11(e)1(w)26( MA)14(I em)22(ploy)21(ees lef)11(t)4( MA)14(I an)9(d w)26(e)1(re h)9(i)4(red by)21( P)-7(eak)9(.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
326 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
/T1 297 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
327 0 obj
<<
/Length 8495
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(17)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
-14.85 58.94 TD
0 Tw
[(transitory)30( duration.\224)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 210.33 750.99 Tm
0.007 Tc
(50)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 218.49 745.47 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
( This lead to a situation where Peak Computer, would)Tj
-8.75 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(be)5( lia)5(ble)5( to c)5(opy)31(rig)11(h)1(t infring)11(e)5(m)-1(e)5(n)1(t e)5(v)1(e)5(r)4(y)31( time)5( a)5(n)1(y)31( of its se)5(rvic)5(e)5(m)-1(e)5(n)1( turne)5(d)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(on a computer with MAI)22( software on it, in order to service the equipment. I)22(t)]TJ
T*
[(is worth noting)9( that since Peak did not raise fair use as a defense, the court)]TJ
T*
(never considered this issue.)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 666.51 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\027\021\027\021\025)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(7KH\003ULJKWIXO\003SRVVHVVRU\003RI\003D\003FRPSXWHU\003SURJUDP\003FDQQRW)Tj
-2.6154 -1.1795 TD
(DXWKRUL]H\003D\003WKLUG\003SDUW\\\003WR\003PDNH\003D\003FRS\\)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 621.51 Tm
0.001 Tw
[(How could the courts reach such a biz)-7(a)3(rre decision?)-17( One should keep in)]TJ
T*
[(mind, that before the Copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(t Act)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 284.85 612.87 Tm
0.007 Tc
(51)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 293.01 607.35 Tm
-0.001 Tc
( was enacted, the Commission on New)Tj
-14.96 -1.18 TD
[(Technolog)9(ical Uses of Copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(ted W)-7(o)-1(rks, known as the CONTU)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
(Commission)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 174.33 584.55 Tm
0.007 Tc
(52)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 182.49 579.03 Tm
-0.001 Tc
( recommended two words in section 117 to be replaced. The)Tj
-5.75 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(CONTU Commission sug)10(g)10(e)4(sted a wording)10( stating)10( that it would not be an)]TJ
T*
[(infring)10(e)4(m)-2(e)4(n)0(t if the)4( )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
7.73 0 TD
0.004 Tc
[(ULJ)10(K)10(WIX)10(O\003)7(S)10(R)10(VVH)10(VVR)10(U)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
7.15 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( of a copy)29( of a computer prog)9(ram)]TJ
-14.88 -1.18 TD
[(authoriz)-7(ed the making)9( of another copy)29( under certain circumstances. This)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(would ha)4(ve)4( fa)4(c)4(ilita)4(te)4(d for pe)4(rsons with only)30( softwa)4(re)4( lic)4(e)4(n)0(se)4(s \(softwa)4(r)3(e)4( is)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(g)9(e)3(nerally)29( licensed, not sold nowaday)29(s)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 294.69 513.75 Tm
0.007 Tc
(53)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 302.85 508.23 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(\), to authoriz)-7(e third parts, such as)]TJ
-15.78 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(P)-6(eak C)-5(o)-2(m)-4(put)-4(er I)21(n)-2(c. t)-4(o)-2( servi)-4(ce t)-4(h)-2(ei)-4(r com)-4(put)-4(ers and hel)-4(p)-2( t)-4(h)-2(em)-4( when t)-4(h)-2(e)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(computers are stuck. Cong)10(ress did not listen to the CONTU Commission)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(and used the word )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
7.54 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(RZ)-13(QHU)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
2.5 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(, instead of )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
4.66 0 TD
0.004 Tc
[(ULJ)10(K)10(WIX)10(O\003)7(S)10(R)10(VVH)10(VVR)10(U)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
7.15 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(, which \(with help)Tj
-21.85 -1.18 TD
[(from the)4( c)4(ourts\) ha)4(s le)4(a)4(d)0( to the)4( situa)4(tion whe)4(r)3(e)4( no othe)4(r c)4(o)0(mpa)4(n)0(y)30( tha)4(n)0( the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(software copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(t holder is allowed to turn on the computer in order to)]TJ
T*
[(service it. Some arg)9(u)-1(e that the use of the word owner was unnecessary)29( since)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
(owners did not need additional protection.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 315.93 414.63 Tm
0.007 Tc
(54)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 324.09 409.11 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
( An owner would be able to)Tj
-17.55 -1.18 TD
[(copy)29( and do whatever he wanted with the prog)9(ram he developed any)29(w)1(ay)29(.)]TJ
T*
[(Some arg)9(u)-1(e that the distinction between copy)29(ing)9( and using)9( has been diluted)]TJ
T*
[(as a result of the case and the wording)9( of the section 117 of the Copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(t)]TJ
T*
(Act.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 133.77 357.99 Tm
0.007 Tc
(55)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 328.71 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(\027\021\030\003)-436(7ULDG\003\0036\\)10(V)-2(WHPV\003&RUS\021\003Y)20(\021\0036RXWKHDVWHUQ)]TJ
ET
1 i
113.49 327.03 21.96 -1.56 re
f
BT
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 306.63 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
113.49 309.75 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 141.81 297.99 Tm
0.007 Tc
(50)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 149.97 292.47 Tm
0 Tc
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.25 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(0$,\0036\\V)-9(W)-8(H)1(PV)-9(\003&)-12(RU)-9(SRU)-9(DW)-8(L)-8(RQ\003Y\021\0033HDN\003&)-12(R)1(PSXW)-8(HU)-9(\003,QF)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
19.39 0 TD
0 Tc
[(., 991 F)6(.2d)]TJ
-20.32 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(511 \(9)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 172.77 283.83 Tm
0.006 Tc
(th)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 179.13 278.31 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
( Cir.1993\) at /11.)Tj
-3.11 -1.18 TD
(\(17 U.S.C. s 101\))Tj
T*
(Http://www.law.seattleu.edu/chonm/Cases/mai.html \(971026\))Tj
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 242.31 Tm
(51)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 237.75 Tm
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( T)-12(h)10(e C)8(opy)22(ri)5(g)10(h)10(t)5( )]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
6.3614 0 TD
[(A)15(c)2(t)5( \247117 L)13(i)5(m)23(i)5(t)5(a)2(t)5(i)5(o)-2(n)10(s)7( on)10( ex)10(cl)5(u)10(s)7(i)5(v)10(e ri)5(g)10(h)10(t)5(s)7(:)5( C)8(o)-2(m)23(p)-2(u)10(t)5(er)]TJ
-7.012 -1.1807 TD
-0.022 Tc
0.025 Tw
[(p)-28(r)-26(o)-28(g)-16(r)-26(a)-24(ms)-19(.)-25( H)-23(t)-21(t)-21(p)-28(:)-21(/)-21(/)-21(www.)-25(s)-19(g)-16(p)-28(d)-28(l)-21(a)-24(w)1(.)-25(c)-24(o)-28(m)-3(/)-21(s)-19(o)-28(f)-14(t)-21(w)1(a)-24(r)-26(e)-24(_)-28(c)-24(o)-28(p)-28(y)-4(r)-26(i)-21(g)-16(h)-16(t)-21(/)-21(p)-28(a)-24(r)-26(t)-21(1)-28(.)-25(h)-16(t)-21(m)-3(l)]TJ
26.9518 0 TD
0.006 Tc
(#117)Tj
-26.9518 -1.1807 TD
(\(971025\))Tj
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 207.03 Tm
0 Tc
(52)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 202.47 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(7XUQLQJ\0032Q\003DQG\0037XUQLQJ\0032II\035\003&DQ\0030HUHO\\\0037XUQLQJ\0032Q\003D\003&RPSXWHU)Tj
-0.9036 -1.1807 TD
(&RQVWLWXWH\003&RS\\ULJKW\003,QIULQJHPHQW"\003,Q\003WKH\0031LQWK\003&LUFXLW\017\003>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
329 0 obj
<<
/Length 6282
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(18)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 741.51 Tm
(\([SUHVV\003&R\021)Tj
/F5 1 Tf
10.56 0 0 10.56 205.77 749.07 Tm
0.001 Tc
(56)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 710.67 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(A simila)4(r c)4(a)4(s)-1(e)4( broug)10(ht the)4( que)4(stion one)4( ste)4(p)0( furthe)4(r by)30( inc)4(l)-2(uding)10( the)4( fa)4(ir use)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(doc)5(trine)5( into the)5( ma)5(tte)5(r. The)5( fa)5(c)5(t)-1(s a)5(r)4(e)5( simila)5(r to those)5( in )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
22.69 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
(0$,\003Y\021\0033HDN)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
4.95 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(.)Tj
-27.64 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(S)-5(out)-3(heast)-3(e)3(rn i)-3(s)-2( an I)22(S)-5(O t)-3(h)-1(at)-3( servi)-3(ces Tri)-3(a)3(d com)-3(put)-3(ers. The l)-3(i)-3(cense t)-3(e)3(rm)-3(s)]TJ
T*
[(used by)29( Triad, prohibited reproduction or use of the software by)29( third)]TJ
T*
[(parties. W)-7(h)-1(en Southeastern technicians serviced Triad computers, they)29( had)]TJ
T*
[(to make copies of the operating)9( sy)29(stem, as well as of the service and)]TJ
T*
[(di)-3(ag)9(nost)-3(i)-3(c)3( soft)-3(ware i)-3(n)-1( t)-3(h)-1(e R)-4(A)1(M. Because of t)-3(h)-1(i)-3(s)-2(, Tri)-3(a)3(d sued S)-5(out)-3(heast)-3(e)3(rn i)-3(n)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(April 1992, claiming)10( copy)30(rig)10(h)0(t infring)10(ement. Southeastern lost in the district)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
(court)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 138.09 602.91 Tm
0.007 Tc
(57)Tj
12 0 0 12 146.25 597.39 Tm
0 Tc
[( and was prohibited from servicing)10( Triad computer sy)30(stems.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 575.07 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\027\021\030\021\024)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
('HIHQVH\003RI\003IDLU\003XVH\003UHMHFWHG)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 546.63 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(The case was t)-4(r)1(i)-4(e)2(d ag)8(ai)-4(n i)-4(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e 9)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 269.97 552.15 Tm
0.006 Tc
(th)Tj
12 0 0 12 276.33 546.63 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
( circuit in 1995. Southeastern raised fair)Tj
-13.57 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(use as a defense but the court rejected this. The court cited the Copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(t)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
(Act \247107,)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 160.77 523.83 Tm
0.007 Tc
(58)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 168.93 518.31 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( which sets out four main factors determining)9( whether a use is)]TJ
-4.62 -1.18 TD
[(considered fair use. F)5(i)-3(rstly)29(, it is necessary)29( to determine the purpose and)]TJ
T*
[(character of the use. I)22(s)-2( it of a commercial nature or is it for nonprofit)]TJ
T*
[(educational purposes?)-17( Secondly)29(,)-1( one must decide the nature of the)]TJ
T*
[(copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(ted work. Thirdly)29(,)-1( the amount or quantity)29( of the copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(ted)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(material used must be decided. I)23(s)-1( it all of it, or only)30( a portion?)-16( F)6(ourth, the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(effect of the use upon the potential market must be determined. Has the)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(va)4(lue)4( of the)4( c)4(opy)30(rig)10(h)0(te)4(d work diminishe)4(d a)4(s)-1( a)4( re)4(sult of the)4( use)4(?)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
[(The ninth Circuit concluded that Southeastern had developed nothing)10( of its)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(own and that the copies made by)29( Southeastern while servicing)9( Triad)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(c)4(o)0(mpute)4(r)3(s diminishe)4(d the)4( va)4(lue)4( of Tria)4(d\222s c)4(opy)30(rig)10(h)0(t. Sinc)4(e)4( Tria)4(d inve)4(nte)4(d)0(,)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(developed, and marketed its software in order to be able to service Triad)Tj
T*
[(computers, Southeastern was \224...g)9(etting)9( a free ride when it uses that)]TJ
T*
[(software to perform precisely)29( the same service.\224)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 344.73 325.59 Tm
0.007 Tc
(59)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 352.89 320.07 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[( The fai)-4(r)1( use was rej)-4(ect)-4(ed.)]TJ
-19.95 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Southeastern should pay)29( license fees to Triad.)]TJ
0 -5.4 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 244.23 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 141.81 232.47 Tm
0.007 Tc
(56)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 149.97 226.95 Tm
0 Tc
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.25 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(7)-11(U)-9(L)-8(DG\0036\\V)-9(W)-8(H)1(PV)-9(\003&)-12(RU)-9(SRU)-9(DW)-8(L)-8(RQ\003Y\021\0036RXW)-8(KHDV)-9(W)-8(H)1(U)-9(Q)1(\003\([SU)-9(HV)-9(V)-9(\003)-2(&)-12(R)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
22.14 0 TD
0 Tc
(., 64)Tj
-23.07 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(F)5(.3d 1330 \(9)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 203.37 218.31 Tm
0.006 Tc
(th)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 209.73 212.79 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
( Cir.1995\))Tj
-5.66 -1.18 TD
[(Http://www.softwareindustry)30(.org)10(/)-2(software/issues/docs-)]TJ
T*
(htm/triad-1.html)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 176.79 Tm
(57)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 172.23 Tm
-0.023 Tc
0.026 Tw
[( H)-24(t)-22(t)-22(p)-29(:)-22(/)-22(/)-22(www.)-26(l)-22(a)-25(w.)-26(s)-20(e)-25(a)]TJ
8.1687 0 TD
0 Tc
0.003 Tw
[(ttleu.ed)-6(u/cho)-6(n)6(m)19(/)1(Cases/triad)-6(.)-3(htm)19(l)1( \(District co)-6(urt\))]TJ
/T2 1 Tf
8.039 0 0 8.039 141.81 164.07 Tm
(\030\033)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 149.97 158.55 Tm
-0.005 Tc
[(\0037)-11(U)-9(L)-8(DG\003Y\021\0036RXW)-8(KHDV)-9(W)-8(H)1(U)-9(Q)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
8.89 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( at [)-7(14])-7( p.10907. \(17 U.S.C. S 107. Tex)-10(t)]TJ
-9.57 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
(can be found at)Tj
T*
0 Tc
(http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml\))Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 141.81 121.59 Tm
0.007 Tc
(59)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 149.97 116.07 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( At [)-7(5)0(])-7( p. 10908. )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
6.93 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(7)-11(U)-9(L)-8(DG\0036\\V)-9(W)-8(H)1(PV)-9(\003&)-12(RU)-9(SRU)-9(DW)-8(L)-8(RQ\003Y\021\0036RXW)-8(KHDV)-9(W)-8(H)1(U)-9(Q)]TJ
-7.61 -1.18 TD
[(\([SU)-10(HV)-10(V)-10(\003)-3(&)-13(R)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
4.58 0 TD
0 Tc
[(., 64 F)6(.3d 1330 \(9)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 282.33 107.43 Tm
0.006 Tc
(th)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 288.69 101.91 Tm
0 Tc
( Cir.1995\))Tj
-12.24 -1.18 TD
[(Http://www.softwareindustry)30(.org)10(/)-2(software/issues/docs-)]TJ
T*
(htm/triad-1.html)Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
330 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F5 276 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
/T2 331 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
332 0 obj
<<
/Length 2276
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(19)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 741.51 Tm
[(\027\021\031\003)-435(6XPPDU\\)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 710.67 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(P)-5(r)2(esum)-3(abl)-3(y)29( m)-3(o)-1(st)-3( peopl)-3(e succum)-3(b)-1( t)-3(o)-1( t)-3(h)-1(e opi)-3(ni)-3(on t)-3(h)-1(at)-3( cachi)-3(n)-1(g)9( i)-3(s)-2( one of t)-3(h)-1(e)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(basic cornerstones of the I)22(n)-1(ternet. I)22(n)-1( order to browse, or even see)]TJ
T*
(documents, one must allow the computer to produce copies in the RAM and)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(on the harddrive. Even thoug)10(h this is natural and obvious to most I)23(n)0(ternet)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(users, one should not forg)9(et that courts such as the MAI)22( court and the Triad)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(court stated that copies in the RAM technically)30( qualify)30( as copies within the)]TJ
T*
[(meaning)10( of the law. I)23(f)3( one cannot claim that it is lawful to produce)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(temporary)29( copies in the ram, or relatively)29( permanent copies on the)]TJ
T*
(harddrive, due to the private use doctrine \(and fair use doctrine as well\), the)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(whole I)23(n)0(ternet community)30( could be infring)10(ing)10( upon copy)30(rig)10(h)0(ts all the time.)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(However, I)22( believe such copies are lawful, due to the private use doctrine. I)22(f)]TJ
T*
[(the private use doctrine would not be applicable, one could arg)9(u)-1(e that)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(implie)5(d lic)5(e)5(n)1(se)5(s a)5(llow suc)5(h)1( c)5(opy)31(ing)11(.)1( The)5( que)5(stion of implie)5(d lic)5(e)5(n)1(se)5(s se)5(e)5(m)-1(s)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(o)-2( becom)-4(e)2( cl)-4(earer and cl)-4(earer, due t)-4(o)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e i)-4(n)-2(creased usag)8(e of passwords as)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(wel)-3(l)-3( as user I)22(D)1(s. P)-5(e)3(rhaps one can assum)-3(e)3( t)-3(h)-1(at)-3( when a si)-3(t)-3(e)3( i)-3(s)-2( a publ)-3(i)-3(c)3(-access)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(site, there alway)30(s)-1( ex)-10(ists an implied license to visit the site, and thus produce)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(the necessary)29( copies in order to view the posted information?)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
333 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
334 0 obj
<<
/Length 5965
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(20)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
24 0 0 24 113.49 733.71 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(\030\003)-311(3UR[\\FDFKLQJ)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 693.27 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(W)-8(h)-2(en cachi)-4(n)-2(g)8( occurs at)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e server l)-4(e)2(vel)-4(,)-2( i)-4(t)-4( i)-4(s)-3( oft)-4(e)2(n referred t)-4(o)-2( as)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(prox)-11(y)29(cachi)-3(n)-1(g)9(.)-1( C)-4(o)-1(m)-3(p)-1(ani)-3(e)3(s, whi)-3(c)3(h st)-3(ore t)-3(h)-1(e m)-3(o)-1(st)-3( frequent)-3(l)-3(y)29( request)-3(ed si)-3(t)-3(e)3(s)]TJ
T*
[(on t)-3(h)-1(ei)-3(r servers, such as AOL)20( and C)-4(o)-1(m)-3(puS)-5(erve, g)9(a)3(i)-3(n)-1( from)-3( prox)-11(y)29(cachi)-3(n)-1(g)9(.)]TJ
T*
[(Copies of the most popular sites are cached on secondary)29( servers in order to)]TJ
T*
[(avoi)-3(d servers braki)-3(n)-1(g)9( down due t)-3(o)-1( overl)-3(oad. As a resul)-3(t)-3( of prox)-11(y)29(cachi)-3(n)-1(g)9(,)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(the)4( re)4(que)4(ste)4(d)0( da)4(ta)4( will be)4( de)4(live)4(r)3(e)4(d)0( fa)4(ste)4(r)3( to a)4( g)10(r)3(e)4(a)4(t)-2(e)4(r)3( numbe)4(r of use)4(r)3(s a)4(n)0(d)]TJ
T*
(with as few interruptions as possible.)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 584.55 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(\030\021\024\003)-436(7)-1(KH\003OHJDO\003GLOHPPD\003RI\003SUR[\\)10(FDFKLQJ)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 553.71 Tm
0.001 Tw
[(W)-7(e)3(bsite owners may)29( not be able to control the data being)9( delivered to those)]TJ
T*
[(users requesting)9( the site, when additional copies of the site are stored on)]TJ
T*
[(remote servers. I)22(f)2( the website owner updates the information on his/her site,)]TJ
T*
[(it is not certain that the various prox)-11(y)29(cached copies are updated as well. The)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(result following)10( this would be that some users would access the updated)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(version, while others access the prox)-11(y)29(cached old version. S)-5(uppose that the)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(we)4(bsite)4( owne)4(r disc)4(ove)4(rs tha)4(t)-2( some)4( informa)4(tion poste)4(d on the)4( site)4( is ille)4(g)10(a)4(l)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(or incorrect, and removes it as fast as possible in order to avoid leg)9(a)3(l)]TJ
T*
[(repercussions. Even if the harmful information is removed from the orig)9(inal)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(site, it may)30( very)30( well still be posted on the prox)-10(y)30(cached version until the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(company)29( providing)9( the server decides to refresh the site.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 384.09 417.63 Tm
0.007 Tc
(60)Tj
12 0 0 12 392.25 412.11 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
( The users)Tj
-23.23 -1.18 TD
[(recei)-4(vi)-4(ng)8( t)-4(h)-2(e ol)-4(d cached versi)-4(on m)-4(a)2(y)28( be offended or base cert)-4(a)2(i)-4(n)-2( act)-4(i)-4(ons)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(upon the incorrect information and file a suit, since they)29( believe that they)29( are)]TJ
T*
[(receiving)9( up-to-date information. Another problem may)29( arise if the site)]TJ
T*
[(owner has contract with advertisers who boug)9(ht space on the site. Often the)]TJ
T*
[(banner ads chang)9(e)3( reg)9(u)-1(larly)29( and advertisers pay)29( for certain amount of time)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e banner i)-4(s)-3( di)-4(spl)-4(a)2(y)28(e)2(d. I)21(f)1( t)-4(h)-2(e si)-4(t)-4(e)2( i)-4(s)-3( prox)-12(y)28(cached, t)-4(h)-2(e banner ad m)-4(a)2(y)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(not be display)29(e)3(d at all, or much long)9(er than the contract say)29(s)-2(.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 406.53 318.51 Tm
0.007 Tc
(61)Tj
12 0 0 12 414.69 312.99 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( I)24(f)4( the)]TJ
-25.1 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(com)-4(p)-2(ani)-4(e)2(s perform)-4(i)-4(n)-2(g)8( t)-4(h)-2(e prox)-12(y)28(cachi)-4(n)-2(g)8( woul)-4(d refresh t)-4(h)-2(e prox)-12(y)28(cached si)-4(t)-4(e)2(s)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(ex)-11(tremely)29( often, no situation as described above would probably)29( occur.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 262.35 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\030\021\024\021\024)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
[(3)7(DJH\003LPSUHVVLRQV)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 233.91 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Another problem may)29( arise for the site owner. He/she may)29( not be able to)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(keep track of the number of users that visit the site, and this may)29( have)]TJ
T*
[(neg)9(a)3(tive consequences when advertisers choose where in Cy)29(berspace to)]TJ
T*
[(place their ads, or if the site owner charg)9(e)3(s advertisers based upon the)]TJ
T*
[(num)-3(ber of hi)-3(t)-3(s)-2(. I)22(f)2( t)-3(h)-1(e si)-3(t)-3(e)3( i)-3(s)-2( prox)-11(y)29(cached on several)-3( servers, i)-3(t)-3( m)-3(a)3(y)29( be)]TJ
T*
[(troublesome to keep track of all the users visiting)9( the various copies of the)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
[(same document. Professor Eric Schlachter mentioned \224pag)9(e impressions\224 as)]TJ
T*
[(an ex)-11(ample of when prox)-11(y)29(caching)9( leads to difficulties in charg)9(i)-3(ng)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 123.75 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 112.95 Tm
(60)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 108.39 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(&DFKH\020\025\025\035\003&RS\\LQJ\003DQG\003VWRULQJ\003:HE\003SDJHV\003LV\003YLWDO\003WR\003WKH\003,QWHUQHW\266V)Tj
-0.9036 -1.1807 TD
(VXUYLYDO\003\020\003EXW\003LV\003LW\003OHJDO")Tj
/F3 1 Tf
9.8554 0 TD
0.003 Tw
[( B)-8(y)18( Eric Schlachter. Intellectual P)-10(r)-4(o)-6(p)-6(e)-2(rty)18( Magazine)]TJ
-9.8554 -1.1807 TD
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Su)8(m)21(m)21(e)0(r 1996. Http://)]TJ
8.747 0 TD
-0.021 Tc
[(www.)-24(i)-20(p)-27(ma)-23(g)-15(.)-24(c)-23(o)-27(m/)-20(s)-18(c)-23(h)-15(l)-20(a)-23(c)-23(h)-15(t)-20(.)-24(h)-15(t)-20(m)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 77.67 Tm
0 Tc
(61)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 73.11 Tm
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
( Ibid.)Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
335 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
336 0 obj
<<
/Length 6690
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(21)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(advertisers. Pag)9(e)3( impression is when the charg)9(e)3( is based upon the number of)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(times the banner ads are ex)-11(posed to users. I)22(f)2( the site is prox)-11(y)29(cached, it is)]TJ
T*
[(impossible to tell how many)29( users that were ex)-11(posed to the banner, and thus)]TJ
T*
[(more difficult to charg)9(e)3( advertisers for the impressions done from the cache.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 680.67 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\030\021\024\021\025)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
($\003SUR[\\FDFKHG\003VLWH\003FRQVWLWXWHV\003D\003FRS\\)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 652.23 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(The process of cachi)-4(n)-2(g)8( a si)-4(t)-4(e)2( and st)-4(ori)-4(n)-2(g)8( i)-4(t)-4( on a rem)-4(o)-2(t)-4(e)2( server som)-4(e)2(where i)-4(s)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(most likely)30( equivalent of producing)10( a copy)30(. I)23(f)3( no consent is g)10(i)-2(ven from the)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(site)5( owne)5(r, it c)5(ould in c)5(e)5(r)4(ta)5(in c)5(i)-1(rc)5(umsta)5(n)1(c)5(e)5(s)0( c)5(onstitute)5( c)5(opy)31(rig)11(h)1(t)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(i)-4(n)-2(fri)-4(ng)8(em)-4(ent)-4(.)-2( P)-6(r)1(ofessor Eri)-4(c)2( S)-6(c)2(hl)-4(acht)-4(e)2(r st)-4(at)-4(ed t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e com)-4(p)-2(ani)-4(e)2(s usi)-4(n)-2(g)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(prox)-11(y)29(caching)9(,)-1( may)29( be liable for copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(t infring)9(ement \224...both of the W)-7(e)3(b)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(si)-4(t)-4(e)2(s bei)-4(n)-2(g)8( cached, and of t)-4(h)-2(i)-4(r)1(d part)-4(i)-4(e)2(s i)-4(f)1( t)-4(h)-2(e cached pag)8(e)2(s have i)-4(n)-2(fri)-4(ng)8(ed)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(others\222 copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(ts.\224)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 208.17 572.79 Tm
0.007 Tc
(62)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 544.95 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\030\021\024\021\026)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(\))6(DLU\003XVH\003WR\003XWLOL]H\003SUR[\\FDFKLQJ)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 516.51 Tm
0 Tc
(As in )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
2.39 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(7)-11(U)-9(L)-8(DG\003Y\021\0036RXW)-8(KHDV)-9(W)-8(H)1(U)-9(Q)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
8.64 0 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(, i)-4(t)-4( m)-4(a)2(y)28( be possi)-4(bl)-4(e t)-4(o)-2( cl)-4(ai)-4(m)-4( t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( prox)-12(y)28(cachi)-4(n)-2(g)]TJ
-11.03 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(would constitute fair use. I)23(f)3( one looks at the Copy)30(rig)10(h)0(t Act \247107, the four)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(factors discussed above must be considered. The purpose of the use of)Tj
T*
[(prox)-11(y)29(caching)9( would be to speed up connections in order to g)9(e)3(t the most out)]TJ
T*
[(of the present infrastructure. Reg)9(a)3(rding)9( the nature of the copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(ted work, I)]TJ
T*
(succumb to the opinion of Professor Eric Schlachter, that all material posted)Tj
T*
[(on the I)22(n)-1(ternet, is considered published \(for purposes of copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(t\).)]TJ
T*
[(Reg)9(a)3(rding)9( the amount of the copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(ted work that is used when copied to a)]TJ
T*
[(remote server, I)22( believe that almost the whole content of the site is copied.)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(However, I)21( do bel)-4(i)-4(e)2(ve t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( som)-4(e)2( I)21(M)-3(G l)-4(i)-4(nks are not)-4( part)-4( of t)-4(h)-2(e prox)-12(y)28(cachi)-4(n)-2(g)8(,)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(and therefore should not be included in the amount of the work that is)Tj
T*
(considered used. The important factor is that almost the whole work is)Tj
T*
[(copied. Concerning)9( the effect upon the potential market, I)22( ag)9(ain, succumb to)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Professor Eric Schlachter\222s opinion, that mostly)30( sites containing)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(advert)-4(i)-4(s)-3(em)-4(ent)-4(s)-3( i)-4(n)-2( any)28( way)28( are di)-4(st)-4(urbed by)28( t)-4(h)-2(e prox)-12(y)28(cachi)-4(n)-2(g)8(.)-2( I)21(t)-4( i)-4(s)-3( di)-4(ffi)-4(cul)-4(t)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(to decide what a potential market is for a plain site that does not contain any)Tj
T*
[(advertisements. One can only)29( speculate how a court would decide in a)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(ma)5(tte)5(r like)5( this.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 252.03 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(\030\021\025\003)-436(3)-1(UR[\\)10(FDFKLQJ\003LQ\003D\0036Z)-15(H)-2(GLVK\003OHJDO)]TJ
T*
[(SHUVSHFWLY)20(H)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 202.35 Tm
0.001 Tc
[(Ac)5(c)5(o)1(rding)11( to Swe)5(d)1(ish la)5(w)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 240.21 207.87 Tm
0.007 Tc
(63)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 248.37 202.35 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( only)30( the author has the rig)10(h)0(t to copy)30( his work.)]TJ
-11.24 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(I)22(f)2( the work is posted on a database or equivalent, it is considered as copy)29(ing)9(,)]TJ
T*
[(if the work can be reproduced by)29( such an act.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 330.45 179.55 Tm
0.007 Tc
(64)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 338.61 174.03 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[( I)22( do not consider the copy)29(ing)]TJ
-18.76 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(a)2(ki)-4(ng)8( pl)-4(ace i)-4(n)-2( a prox)-12(y)28(cachi)-4(n)-2(g)8( si)-4(t)-4(u)-2(at)-4(i)-4(on bei)-4(n)-2(g)8( m)-4(u)-2(ch di)-4(fferent)-4( from)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e)]TJ
0 -2.29 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 135.51 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 124.71 Tm
(62)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 120.15 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(&DFKH\020\025\025\035\003&RS\\LQJ\003DQG\003VWRULQJ\003:HE\003SDJHV\003LV\003YLWDO\003WR\003WKH\003,QWHUQHW\266V)Tj
-0.9036 -1.1807 TD
(VXUYLYDO\003\020\003EXW\003LV\003LW\003OHJDO")Tj
/F3 1 Tf
9.8554 0 TD
0.003 Tw
[( B)-8(y)18( Eric Schlachter. Intellectual P)-10(r)-4(o)-6(p)-6(e)-2(rty)18( Magazine)]TJ
-9.8554 -1.1807 TD
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Su)8(m)21(m)21(e)0(r 1996. Http://)]TJ
8.747 0 TD
-0.021 Tc
[(www.)-24(i)-20(p)-27(ma)-23(g)-15(.)-24(c)-23(o)-27(m/)-20(s)-18(c)-23(h)-15(l)-20(a)-23(c)-23(h)-15(t)-20(.)-24(h)-15(t)-20(m)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
0 Tc
(63)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 84.87 Tm
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[( L)12(a)1(g)9( \(1960:729\) om)22( u)9(pph)9(ov)9(s)6(r)-1(\344tt till litter\344ra och)9( k)9(o)-3(n)9(s)6(tn)9(\344rlig)9(a v)9(e)1(rk)9( 8\247.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 77.67 Tm
0 Tc
(64)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 73.11 Tm
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( Dag)10( Mat)5(t)5(s)7(on)10( i)5(n)10( Karn)10(ov)10( 1996/)5(97, pag)10(e)2( 919 at)5( n)10(o)-2(t)5(e)2( 14.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
337 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
338 0 obj
<<
/Length 5774
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(22)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(copy)29(i)-3(n)-1(g)9( t)-3(a)3(ki)-3(ng)9( pl)-3(ace when post)-3(i)-3(n)-1(g)9( a work on a dat)-3(a)3(base where i)-3(t)-3( m)-3(a)3(y)29( be)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(re)4(produc)4(e)4(d. The)4(r)3(e)4( a)4(r)3(e)4( ma)4(ny)30( simila)4(ritie)4(s in c)4(opy)30(ing)10( a)4( c)4(o)0(mple)4(te)4( work to a)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(database, and copy)29(ing)9( a complete work to a server. The work may)29( be viewed)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(a)4(nd re)4(produc)4(e)4(d)0( in e)4(ithe)4(r)3( wa)4(y)30(.)0( Some)4(time)4(s a)4( c)4(o)0(mpila)4(tion of hy)30(pe)4(rlinks on a)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(webpag)9(e)3( is considered a compilation of facts,)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 331.89 694.35 Tm
0.007 Tc
(65)Tj
12 0 0 12 340.05 688.83 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( which enjoy)30( copy)30(rig)10(h)0(t. I)23(f)]TJ
-18.88 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(such a compilation or any)29( other copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(ted work is copied onto a second)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(server i)-4(n)-2( order t)-4(o)-2( perform)-4( prox)-12(y)28(cachi)-4(n)-2(g)8(,)-2( I)21( am)-4( of t)-4(h)-2(e opi)-4(ni)-4(on t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( i)-4(t)-4( i)-4(s)-3( a)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(que)4(stion of c)4(opy)30(ing)10( within the)4( me)4(a)4(n)0(ing)10( of the)4( Swe)4(d)0(ish la)4(w.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 401.37 651.87 Tm
0.007 Tc
(66)Tj
12 0 0 12 409.53 646.35 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[( P)-6(r)1(ox)-12(y)28(cachi)-4(n)-2(g)]TJ
-24.67 -1.18 TD
[(woul)-4(d t)-4(h)-2(erefore not)-4( be l)-4(e)2(g)8(a)2(l)-4( accordi)-4(n)-2(g)8( t)-4(o)-2( S)-6(w)0(edi)-4(s)-3(h l)-4(a)2(w. S)-6(o)-2(m)-4(e)2( m)-4(a)2(y)28( arg)8(u)-2(e t)-4(h)-2(at)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(this copy)29(ing)9( would be leg)9(a)3(l due to the \223private use doctrine\224)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 403.77 623.55 Tm
0.007 Tc
(67)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 411.93 618.03 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(, but I)23( believe)]TJ
-24.87 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(that reproducing)9( a website that becomes available to an infinite number of)]TJ
T*
[(users should not be considered private use. One could arg)9(u)-1(e, as in the case)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(wi)-4(t)-4(h)-2( norm)-4(a)2(l)-4( cachi)-4(n)-2(g)8(,)-2( t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( by)28( post)-4(i)-4(n)-2(g)8( m)-4(a)2(t)-4(e)2(ri)-4(al)-4( on a si)-4(t)-4(e)2(, t)-4(h)-2(e si)-4(t)-4(e)2( owners)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(implic)5(itly)31( a)5(g)11(re)5(e)5( to a)5(llow suc)5(h)1( c)5(opie)5(s)0( to be)5( ma)5(de)5(, sinc)5(e)5( it is a)5(lmost a)5( ma)5(tte)5(r)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(of normal procedure in Cy)29(berspace nowaday)29(s. The risk that sites will be)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(vic)4(tims of c)4(ong)10(e)4(s)-1(tion a)4(nd bre)4(a)4(k)0( down is diminishe)4(d whe)4(n)0( a)4(dditiona)4(l c)4(opie)4(s)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(are stored on different servers. However, since the site owners tend to loose)Tj
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(cont)-4(rol)-4( over t)-4(h)-2(ei)-4(r si)-4(t)-4(e)2(s aft)-4(e)2(r bei)-4(n)-2(g)8( prox)-12(y)28(cached, one coul)-4(d arg)8(u)-2(e t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( i)-4(t)-4( i)-4(s)-3( not)]TJ
T*
[(at)-4( al)-4(l)-4( cert)-4(a)2(i)-4(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( t)-4(h)-2(ere ex)-12(i)-4(s)-3(t)-4(s)-3( an i)-4(m)-4(p)-2(l)-4(i)-4(e)2(d l)-4(i)-4(cense t)-4(o)-2( prox)-12(y)28(cache.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 466.83 Tm
0 Tc
[(\030\021\026\003)-435(6)0(XPPDU\\)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 435.99 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(The problems which come with the creation of several versions of the same)Tj
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(websi)-4(t)-4(e)2( \(when prox)-12(y)28(cachi)-4(n)-2(g)8(\))1(, coul)-4(d easi)-4(l)-4(y)28( be avoi)-4(ded i)-4(f)1( t)-4(h)-2(e prox)-12(y)28(cached)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(websites are updated on a daily)30( basis. This is technically)30( possible, but)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(whet)-4(her i)-4(t)-4( i)-4(s)-3( econom)-4(i)-4(cal)-4( for t)-4(h)-2(e com)-4(p)-2(ani)-4(e)2(s perform)-4(i)-4(n)-2(g)8( t)-4(h)-2(e prox)-12(y)28(cachi)-4(n)-2(g)8( i)-4(s)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(burdensom)-3(e t)-3(o)-1( t)-3(e)3(l)-3(l)-3(.)-1( W)-7(h)-1(en a si)-3(t)-3(e)3( i)-3(s)-2( prox)-11(y)29(cached, a copy)29( of t)-3(h)-1(e work i)-3(s)]TJ
T*
[(produced, and since the copy)29( is available to a larg)9(e number of users, it)]TJ
T*
[(should not be lawful according)9( to any)29( private use or fair use doctrine. I)22(t)-3( is)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(not a)5(t)-1( a)5(ll c)5(e)5(r)4(ta)5(in tha)5(t)-1( the)5(r)4(e)5( e)5(x)-9(ists a)5(n)1( implie)5(d lic)5(e)5(n)1(se)5( to produc)5(e)5( c)5(opie)5(s)0( of the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(websites on a remote server, since site owners tend to loose control over)Tj
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(the)5(i)-1(r site)5(s.)]TJ
0 -16.64 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 111.99 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 101.19 Tm
(65)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 96.63 Tm
0.003 Tc
[( L)12(a)1(g)9( \(1960:729\) om)22( u)9(pph)9(ov)9(s)6(r)-1(\344tt till litter\344ra och)9( k)9(o)-3(n)9(s)6(tn)9(\344rlig)9(a v)9(e)1(rk)9( 5\247.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
0 Tc
(66)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 84.87 Tm
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( L)11(a)0(g)8( \(1960:729\) om)21( u)8(pph)8(ov)8(s)5(r)-2(\344tt till litter\344ra och)8( k)8(o)-4(n)8(s)5(tn)8(\344rlig)8(a v)8(e)0(rk)8(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 77.67 Tm
0 Tc
(67)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 73.11 Tm
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[( L)12(a)1(g)9( \(1960:729\) om)22( u)9(pph)9(ov)9(s)6(r)-1(\344tt till litter\344ra och)9( k)9(o)-3(n)9(s)6(tn)9(\344rlig)9(a v)9(e)1(rk)9( 12\247.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
339 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
340 0 obj
<<
/Length 6736
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(23)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
24 0 0 24 113.49 733.71 Tm
[(\031\003)-310('RPDLQ\0031DPHV)]TJ
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 655.35 Tm
[(\031\021\024\003)-435(,)2(QWHUQHW\0033URWRFRO\003DGGUHVVHV)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 610.35 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(I)22(t)-3( i)-3(s)-2( i)-3(n)-1( C)-4(y)29(berspace, as i)-3(t)-3( i)-3(s)-2( i)-3(n)-1( t)-3(h)-1(e real)-3( worl)-3(d, t)-3(h)-1(at)-3( peopl)-3(e and org)9(a)3(ni)-3(z)-7(a)3(t)-3(i)-3(ons)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
(need names and addresses in order to be contacted and identified. A)Tj
T*
[(company)29( without a name would probably)29( not g)9(o)-1( very)29( far. W)-7(ho would trust)]TJ
T*
[(i)-3(t)-3(?)-17( I)22(n)-1( C)-4(y)29(berspace, I)22(n)-1(t)-3(e)3(rnet)-3( P)-5(r)2(ot)-3(ocol)-3( addresses \(I)22(P)-5( addresses\) are used i)-3(n)]TJ
T*
[(order to locate and disting)9(u)-1(ish all computers connected to the I)22(n)-1(ternet. I)22(P)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(addresses consist of dig)10(its divided into several parts separated by)30( periods. A)]TJ
T*
[(ty)30(pical I)23(P)-4( address could look like the following)10(: 123.45.67.890. I)23(P)-4( addresses)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(contain a network portion beg)9(i)-3(nning)9( on the left and a local portion ending)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(on the)5( rig)11(h)1(t.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 171.69 502.59 Tm
0.007 Tc
(68)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 473.31 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(\031\021\025\003)-436(7)-1(RS\003OHY)20(H)-2(O\003GHVLJQDWRUV)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 442.47 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Since it is bothersome to remember miscellaneous combinations of dig)10(its,)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(h)-2(ere ex)-12(i)-4(s)-3(t)-4( m)-4(n)-2(em)-4(oni)-4(c desi)-4(g)8(n)-2(at)-4(i)-4(ons)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 279.69 433.83 Tm
0.007 Tc
(69)Tj
12 0 0 12 287.85 428.31 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(, called domain names that are)Tj
-14.53 -1.18 TD
[(connected to the I)22(P)-5( addresses, which makes the whole on-line sy)29(stem user-)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(frie)5(ndlie)5(r. Most I)24(n)1(te)5(rne)5(t)-1( a)5(pplic)5(a)5(tions will a)5(u)1(toma)5(tic)5(a)5(lly)31(, whe)5(n)1( g)11(i)-1(ve)5(n a)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(domain name, contact the corresponding)9( I)22(P)-5( address in order to retrieve the)]TJ
T*
[(requested site. The Domain Name Service \(DNS\) does this throug)9(h an)]TJ
T*
(invisible conversion process.)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 252.33 363.03 Tm
0.007 Tc
(70)Tj
12 0 0 12 260.49 357.51 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[( An ex)-11(ample of a complete domain name)]TJ
-12.25 -1.18 TD
[(could be www.sjobeck.com. Domain names are, as the I)22(P)-5( numbers, divided)]TJ
T*
[(into parts separated by)29( periods. The first name from the rig)9(h)-1(t is the top-level)]TJ
T*
[(desig)9(n)-1(ator \(TL)20(D)1(\), or primary)29( level domain name. There ex)-11(ist various ty)29(pes)]TJ
T*
[(of TL)20(Ds at the moment.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 228.81 306.39 Tm
0.007 Tc
(71)Tj
12 0 0 12 236.97 300.87 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[( Country)29( codes are one ex)-11(ample. These represent)]TJ
-10.29 -1.18 TD
[(the country)29( \(two letters\) to which the address belong)9(s. Currently)29(, there ex)-11(ists)]TJ
T*
[(over 180 two-letter country)29( code TL)20(Ds. F)5(o)-1(r instance, .com \(commercial\), .se)]TJ
T*
[(\(Sweden\), .de \(Germany)29(\), .uk \(United King)9(dom\), .be \(B)6(elg)9(i)-3(um\) etc. I)22(n)-1( the)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(U.S., c)4(e)4(r)3(ta)4(in TL)21(Ds \(thre)4(e)4( le)4(tte)4(rs\) a)4(r)3(e)4( re)4(se)4(rve)4(d)0( for the)4( milita)4(ry)30( \(.mil\),)]TJ
0 -1.48 TD
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 229.59 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 218.79 Tm
(68)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 214.23 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(7UDGHPDUNV\003$ORQJ\003WKH\003,QIREDKQ\035\003$\003ILUVW\003/RRN\003DW\003WKH\003\(PHUJLQJ\003/DZ\003RI)Tj
-0.9036 -1.1807 TD
(&\\EHUPDUNV)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
4.8916 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, by)22( Dan)10( L)13(.)1( Bu)10(rk)10(, A)15(p)-2(ri)5(l)5( 10, 1995, 1R)8(i)5(c)2(h)10(.)1( J.L)13( &)11( T)-12(ech)10(.1\(1995\).)]TJ
-4.8916 -1.1807 TD
-0.023 Tc
[(H)-24(t)-22(t)-22(p)-29(:)-22(/)-22(/)-22(www.)-26(n)-17(l)-22(c)-25(-)-15(b)-29(n)-17(c)-25(.)-26(c)-25(a)-25(/)-22(i)-22(f)-15(l)-22(a)-25(/)-22(d)-29(o)-29(c)-25(u)-17(m)-4(e)-25(n)-17(t)-22(s)-20(/)-22(i)-22(n)-17(f)]TJ
16.6626 0 TD
0.006 Tc
-0.003 Tw
[(opol)7(/)7(c)4(opy)24(ri)7(g)12(h)12(t)7(/)7(b)0(u)12(r)2(d1.h)12(t)7(m)25( \(970725\))]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 183.51 Tm
0 Tc
(69)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 178.95 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(7HQVLRQ\003%HWZHHQ\0033DUDOHOO\0038QLYHUVHV\035\0037UDGHPDUNV\003FODVK\003ZLWK\003GRPDLQ)Tj
-0.9036 -1.1807 TD
(QDPHV\003DV\003EXVLQHVV\003LGHQWLI\\\003PRYHV\003RQWR\003WKH\003,QWHUQHW)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
20.3494 0 TD
0.003 Tc
[(, by)21( Mark)9( F. R)7(a)1(dclif)11(f)11(e)1( an)9(d)]TJ
-20.3494 -1.1807 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(Mau)10(r)0(een)10( S)6(.)1( Dorn)10(ey)22(. In)10(t)5(e)2(l)5(l)5(ect)5(u)10(a)2(l)5( Propert)5(y)22( Mag)10(azi)5(n)10(e)2(, w)27(i)5(n)10(t)5(er 1996.)]TJ
T*
-0.021 Tc
0.024 Tw
[(H)-22(t)-20(t)-20(p)-27(:)-20(/)-20(/)-20(www.)-24(i)-20(p)-27(ma)-23(g)-15(.)-24(c)-23(o)-27(m/)-20(r)-25(a)-23(d)-27(c)-23(l)-20(i)-20(f)-13(f)-13(.)-24(h)-15(t)-20(m \()]TJ
15 0 TD
0.006 Tc
(970716\))Tj
/T1 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 136.47 Tm
0 Tc
(\032\023)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 131.91 Tm
(\0037UDGHPDUNV\003$ORQJ\003WKH\003,QIREDKQ\035\003$\003ILUVW\003/RRN\003DW\003WKH\003\(PHUJLQJ\003/DZ\003RI)Tj
-0.6506 -1.1807 TD
(&\\EHUPDUNV)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
4.8916 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, by)22( Dan)10( L)13(.)1( Bu)10(rk)10(, A)15(p)-2(ri)5(l)5( 10, 1995, 1R)8(i)5(c)2(h)10(.)1( J.L)13( &)11( T)-12(ech)10(.1\(1995\).)]TJ
-4.8916 -1.1807 TD
-0.023 Tc
[(H)-24(t)-22(t)-22(p)-29(:)-22(/)-22(/)-22(www.)-26(n)-17(l)-22(c)-25(-)-15(b)-29(n)-17(c)-25(.)-26(c)-25(a)-25(/)-22(i)-22(f)-15(l)-22(a)-25(/)-22(d)-29(o)-29(c)-25(u)-17(m)-4(e)-25(n)-17(t)-22(s)-20(/)-22(i)-22(n)-17(f)]TJ
16.6626 0 TD
0.006 Tc
-0.003 Tw
[(opol)7(/)7(c)4(opy)24(ri)7(g)12(h)12(t)7(/)7(b)0(u)12(r)2(d1.h)12(t)7(m)25( \(970725\))]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 101.19 Tm
0 Tc
(71)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 96.63 Tm
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[( T)-13(h)9(ere is)6( a propos)6(al adv)9(a)1(n)9(ced by)21( th)9(e In)9(tern)9(ation)9(a)1(l A)14(d)-3( Hoc C)7(o)-3(m)22(m)22(ittee on)]TJ
-0.6506 -1.1807 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(t)5(h)10(e In)10(t)5(e)2(rn)10(et)5( \(IA)15(HC)8(\) i)5(n)10( i)5(t)5(s)7( f)12(i)5(n)10(a)2(l)5( report)5( f)12(r)0(om)23( F)6(e)2(b.4, 1997 t)5(o)-2( add s)7(e)2(v)10(e)2(n)10( n)10(e)2(w)]TJ
T*
[(g)10(T)-12(L)13(D)3(s)7( \(or m)23(o)-2(re\).)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
341 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
/T1 297 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
342 0 obj
<<
/Length 7101
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(24)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
0 Tw
[(e)4(duc)4(a)4(tiona)4(l institutions \(.e)4(du\) a)4(nd g)10(ove)4(rnme)4(nta)4(l)-2( a)4(g)10(e)4(n)0(c)4(i)-2(e)4(s)-1( \(.g)10(ov\). Also, the)4(r)3(e)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(ex)-11(ists g)9(e)3(neric TL)20(Ds, often referred to as g)9(T)0(L)20(D)1(s. These can be used by)]TJ
T*
[(any)29(one from any)29( country)29( in the world \(.com, .org)9(,)-1( and .net\). Another TL)20(D)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(\(.int\) is re)4(se)4(rve)4(d)0( for inte)4(rna)4(tiona)4(l tre)4(a)4(t)-2(y)30( org)10(a)4(niza)4(tions.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 372.57 708.51 Tm
0.007 Tc
(72)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 679.23 Tm
0 Tc
[(\031\021\026\003)-435(6)0(HFRQGDU\\)11(\003OHY)21(H)-1(O\003GHVLJQDWRUV)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 648.39 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(The secondary)29( level \(SL)20(D)1(\) of the I)22(n)-1(ternet domain name is an ex)-11(tremely)]TJ
T*
[(controversial issue all over the world, since only)29( one reg)9(i)-3(stration of a)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(spe)4(c)4(i)-2(fic)4( na)4(me)4( is a)4(llowe)4(d. The)4(r)3(e)4( c)4(a)4(n)0( be)4( a)4(n)0( unlimite)4(d numbe)4(r of diffe)4(re)4(nt)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(S)-6(L)19(Ds i)-4(n)-2( each TL)19(D, but)-4( t)-4(h)-2(ere can be onl)-4(y)28( one of each speci)-4(fi)-4(c S)-6(L)19(D i)-4(n)-2( each)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(TL)20(D. I)22(f)2( \223sjobeck\224 is reg)9(i)-3(stered as a SL)20(D, nobody)29( else can use that ex)-11(act)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(word as a SL)21(D tog)10(e)4(ther with the same TL)21(D. Only)30( modified variations of)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(\223sj)-4(obeck\224 can be used wi)-4(t)-4(h)-2(i)-4(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e sam)-4(e)2( TL)19(D. For ex)-12(am)-4(pl)-4(e, \223sj)-4(obeck1\224)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(woul)-3(d m)-3(o)-1(st)-3( l)-3(i)-3(k)-1(el)-3(y)29( be accept)-3(e)3(d, si)-3(nce i)-3(t)-3( i)-3(s)-2( not)-3( t)-3(h)-1(e very)29( sam)-3(e)3( phrase or word.)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(L)21(i)-2(kelihood of confusion does not matter.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 309.09 540.63 Tm
0.007 Tc
(73)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 511.35 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(\031\021\027\003)-436(7KH\003QHHG\003IRU\003D\003XQLY)20(HUVDO\003GRPDLQ\003GLUHFWRU\\)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
[(VHUY)22(LFH)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 461.67 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(However, companies strive to have the user-friendliest UR)-4(L)20( possible, since)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(nobody)30( can remember various combinations of dig)10(its and letters. Sometimes)]TJ
T*
[(a domain name has a third-level domain name, but this is not mandatory)30(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 462.81 438.87 Tm
0.007 Tc
(74)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 419.19 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Generally)29( speaking)9(,)-1( domain names are not very)29( difficult to obtain, but)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(recei)-4(vi)-4(ng)8( a dom)-4(ai)-4(n nam)-4(e)2( very)28( cl)-4(osel)-4(y)28( rel)-4(a)2(t)-4(e)2(d t)-4(o)-2( a com)-4(p)-2(any)28(\222)1(s own)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(trademark, log)9(o)-1(ty)29(pe, service mark, business mark or product name may)29( be)]TJ
T*
[(troublesome. Users often search for the company)29(\222)2(s name \(tog)9(ether with)]TJ
T*
[(www and the ending)9( .com\) in order to find the company)29( they)29( are searching)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
(for.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 130.41 353.91 Tm
0.007 Tc
(75)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 138.57 348.39 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[( Most companies strug)9(g)9(l)-3(e to have a domain name that is easy)29( to)]TJ
-2.09 -1.18 TD
[(remember, due to the lack of a universal directory)29( service that allows users)]TJ
T*
[(to find the domain name of any)29( trademark holder in the world. A very)29( long)]TJ
T*
[(and complicated URL)20( may)29( function as a deterrent upon laz)-7(y)29( users. The)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(ba)4(ttle)4( for the)4( most na)4(tura)4(l a)4(nd simple)4( doma)4(i)-2(n na)4(me)4(s ha)4(s g)10(i)-2(ve)4(n rise)4( to)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(numerous trademark disputes around the g)9(l)-3(obe. W)-7(I)22(PO is of the opinion that)]TJ
T*
[(by)29( creating)9( a universal directory)29(,)-1( the pressure upon the domain name sy)29(stem)]TJ
0 -4.06 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 217.83 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 207.03 Tm
(72)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 202.47 Tm
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( W)-6(I)-2(P)-8(O)1(, Issu)8(es relatin)8(g)8( to tradem)21(ark)8(s)5( an)8(d In)8(tern)8(et dom)21(ain)8( n)8(a)0(m)21(e)0(s. First)]TJ
-0.6506 -1.1807 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(s)7(e)2(s)7(s)7(i)5(on)10(, Gen)10(e)2(v)10(a)2(, May)22( 26 t)5(o)-2( 30, 1997.)]TJ
T*
-0.022 Tc
[(H)-23(t)-21(t)-21(p)-28(:)-21(/)-21(/)-21(www.)-25(wi)-21(p)-28(o)-28(.)-25(i)-21(n)-16(t)-21(/)-21(e)-24(n)-16(g)-16(/)-21(I)-26(n)-16(t)-21(e)-24(r)-26(n)-16(e)-24(t)-21(/)-21(d)-28(o)-28(m)-3(a)-24(i)-21(n)-16(s)-19(/)-21(t)-21(d)-28(n)-16(/)-21(c)-24(m)-3(/)-21(c)-24(m_)-28(I)-26(_)-28(2)-28(.)-25(h)-16(t)-21(m)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 171.75 Tm
0 Tc
(73)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 167.19 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(5HYLVHG\0035XOHV\003*RYHUQ\003'RPDLQ\0201DPH\003'LVSXWHV)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
18.7952 0 TD
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(, by)20( Sey)20(a)0(m)21(ack)8( Kou)8(r)-2(etch)8(ian)8(,)]TJ
-19.6988 -1.1807 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(T)-12(h)10(e Nat)5(i)5(o)-2(n)10(a)2(l)5( L)13(a)2(w)27( Jou)10(r)0(n)10(a)2(l)5(,)1( Oct)5( 28, 1996.)]TJ
T*
-0.022 Tc
0.025 Tw
[(H)-23(t)-21(t)-21(p)-28(:)-21(/)-21(/)-21(www.)-25(l)-21(j)-33(x)-16(.)-25(c)-24(o)-28(m/)-21(I)-26(n)-16(t)-21(e)-24(r)-26(n)-16(e)-24(t)-21(/)-21(f)-14(i)-21(l)-21(e)-24(t)-21(m)-3(.)-25(h)-16(t)-21(m)-3(l)-21( \()]TJ
16.6626 0 TD
0.006 Tc
(971104\))Tj
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 136.47 Tm
0 Tc
(74)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 131.91 Tm
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( T)-14(h)8(ere m)21(u)8(st alw)25(a)0(y)20(s)5( be at least tw)25(o parts. A)13(n)8( ex)8(am)21(ple of)10( a th)8(irdlev)8(el dom)21(ain)]TJ
-0.6506 -1.1807 TD
-0.004 Tc
0.007 Tw
[(na)-6(m)15(e)-6( c)-6(o)-10(uld)-10( b)-10(e)-6( sj)-15(o)-10(b)-10(e)-6(c)-6(k)2(.)-7(c)-6(o)-10(.)-7(uk.)-7( D)-5(o)-10(m)15(a)-6(in na)-6(m)15(e)-6( le)-6(ve)-6(ls a)-6(r)-8(e)-6( c)-6(o)-10(unte)-6(d)-10( fr)-8(o)-10(m)15( r)-8(i)-3(ght to)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
[(lef)9(t)2(.)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 101.19 Tm
0 Tc
(75)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 96.63 Tm
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( W)-6(I)-2(P)-8(O)1(, Issu)8(es relatin)8(g)8( to tradem)21(ark)8(s)5( an)8(d In)8(tern)8(et dom)21(ain)8( n)8(a)0(m)21(e)0(s. First)]TJ
-0.6506 -1.1807 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(s)7(e)2(s)7(s)7(i)5(on)10(, Gen)10(e)2(v)10(a)2(, May)22( 26 t)5(o)-2( 30, 1997.)]TJ
T*
-0.022 Tc
[(H)-23(t)-21(t)-21(p)-28(:)-21(/)-21(/)-21(www.)-25(wi)-21(p)-28(o)-28(.)-25(i)-21(n)-16(t)-21(/)-21(e)-24(n)-16(g)-16(/)-21(I)-26(n)-16(t)-21(e)-24(r)-26(n)-16(e)-24(t)-21(/)-21(d)-28(o)-28(m)-3(a)-24(i)-21(n)-16(s)-19(/)-21(t)-21(d)-28(n)-16(/)-21(c)-24(m)-3(/)-21(c)-24(m_)-28(I)-26(_)-28(2)-28(.)-25(h)-16(t)-21(m)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
343 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
344 0 obj
<<
/Length 8059
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(25)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(would decline, since companies would then be less reluctant towards using)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
0 -1.18 TD
(\223not memorable\224 domain names.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 271.89 736.83 Tm
0.007 Tc
(76)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 702.99 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(Some)5(time)5(s se)5(ve)5(ra)5(l c)5(o)1(mpa)5(n)1(ie)5(s with the)5( sa)5(me)5( re)5(g)11(i)-1(ste)5(r)4(e)5(d)1( tra)5(d)1(e)5(m)-1(a)5(r)4(k \(pe)5(r)4(ha)5(ps)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(in different countries or concerning)9( different kind of g)9(oods\) desire the same)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(UR)-5(L)19(.)-2( Onl)-4(y)28( one can have t)-4(h)-2(e preferred t)-4(r)1(adem)-4(ark reg)8(i)-4(st)-4(ered as a S)-6(L)19(D.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 650.91 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(\031\021\030\003)-436(5HJLVWHULQJ\003GRPDLQ\003QDPHV\003LQ\003WKH\0038QLWHG)]TJ
T*
(6WDWHV)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 601.23 Tm
0.001 Tw
[(I)22(n)-1( t)-3(h)-1(e U.S)-5(., dom)-3(ai)-3(n nam)-3(e)3(s are assi)-3(g)9(n)-1(ed by)29( t)-3(h)-1(e I)22(n)-1(t)-3(e)3(rnet)-3( Assi)-3(g)9(n)-1(ed Num)-3(b)-1(ers)]TJ
T*
[(Authority)29( \(I)22(ANA\), which has deleg)9(a)3(ted most of the duties to I)22(n)-1(ternet)]TJ
T*
[(Network I)22(n)-1(formation Center \(I)22(nterNI)22(C\) which is operated by)29( Network)]TJ
T*
[(Solutions, I)22(n)-1(c \(NSI)22(\). NSI)22( has a contract to operate I)22(n)-1(terNI)22(C)-4( throug)9(h)]TJ
T*
(September 1998.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 194.73 550.11 Tm
0.007 Tc
(77)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 202.89 544.59 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[( I)22(n)-1(terNI)22(C)-4( charg)9(e)3(s a fee \(about $100\) per domain name)]TJ
-7.45 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(re)4(g)10(i)-2(ste)4(r)3(e)4(d. This pa)4(y)30(m)-2(e)4(n)0(t will only)30( c)4(ove)4(r the)4( first two y)30(e)4(a)4(r)3(s. I)23(n)0( a)4(ddition,)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(there is an annual maintenance cost \(about $50\) of keeping)9( a domain name)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
[(reg)8(i)-4(st)-4(ered.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 163.53 507.63 Tm
0.007 Tc
(78)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 171.69 502.11 Tm
-0.001 Tc
( The second-level domain names have been distributed on a so-)Tj
-4.85 -1.18 TD
(called \223first come, first served\224 basis until September 1996. After series of)Tj
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(c)5(y)31(be)5(rsqua)5(tting)11(,)1( NSI)24( c)5(hose)5( to c)5(h)1(a)5(n)1(g)11(e)5( this polic)5(y)31(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 344.01 479.31 Tm
0.007 Tc
(79)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 451.47 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\031\021\030\021\024)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(7KH\003GRPDLQ\003QDPH\003GLVSXWH\003SROLF\\)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 408.87 Tm
0.001 Tw
[(The applicants must, nowaday)29(s, certify)29( to the best of their knowledg)9(e that)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(the)4(y)30( a)4(r)3(e)4( not viola)4(ting)10( a)4(n)0(y)30( othe)4(r e)4(n)0(tity)30(\222s tra)4(d)0(e)4(m)-2(a)4(r)3(k rig)10(h)0(ts a)4(nd tha)4(t)-2( the)4(y)30( ha)4(ve)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(the leg)9(a)3(l rig)9(h)-1(t to use the proposed names. I)22(n)-1(terNI)22(C)-4( has reserved the rig)9(h)-1(t to)]TJ
T*
[(revoke an assig)9(n)-1(ed domain name upon thirty)29( day)29(s)-2( written notice.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 424.89 371.91 Tm
0.007 Tc
(80)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 433.05 366.39 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
( Because)Tj
-26.63 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(NSI)23( wa)4(s ma)4(de)4( the)4( ta)4(rg)10(e)4(t)-2( of se)4(ve)4(ra)4(l la)4(wsuits, spe)4(c)4(i)-2(a)4(l)-2( re)4(g)10(i)-2(stra)4(tion polic)4(ie)4(s)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
(were formed.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 177.21 343.59 Tm
0.007 Tc
(81)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 185.37 338.07 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( I)22(n)-1(terNI)22(C)-4( developed a widely)29( debated domain name dispute)]TJ
-5.99 -1.18 TD
[(policy)29( which has been revised a number of times since 1995. NSI)22( has taken)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(the position that it is not competent enoug)10(h to resolve all domain name)]TJ
0 -2.04 TD
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 288.39 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 277.59 Tm
(76)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 273.03 Tm
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
( Ibid.)Tj
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 265.83 Tm
0 Tc
(77)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 261.27 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(7KH\0031DPH\0037UDGH\035\003+RZ\003WR\003GHDO\003IRU\003D\003GRPDLQ)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
17.7108 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(, by)23( Jef)13(f)13(e)3(rs)8(on)11( S)7(c)3(h)11(e)3(r,)]TJ
-18.6145 -1.1807 TD
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[(In)9(tellectu)9(a)1(l P)-7(r)-1(operty)21( Mag)9(azin)9(e)1(, Decem)22(ber 1996.)]TJ
T*
-0.021 Tc
0.024 Tw
[(H)-22(t)-20(t)-20(p)-27(:)-20(www.)-24(i)-20(p)-27(ma)-23(g)-15(.)-24(c)-23(o)-27(m/)-20(s)-18(c)-23(h)-15(e)-23(r)-25(.)-24(h)-15(t)-20(m \()]TJ
13.6145 0 TD
0.006 Tc
(970716\))Tj
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 230.55 Tm
0 Tc
(78)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 225.99 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(7HQVLRQ\003%HWZHHQ\0033DUDOHOO\0038QLYHUVHV\035\0037UDGHPDUNV\003FODVK\003ZLWK\003GRPDLQ)Tj
-0.9036 -1.1807 TD
(QDPHV\003DV\003EXVLQHVV\003LGHQWLI\\\003PRYHV\003RQWR\003WKH\003,QWHUQHW)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
20.3494 0 TD
0.003 Tc
[(, by)21( Mark)9( F. R)7(a)1(dclif)11(f)11(e)1( an)9(d)]TJ
-20.3494 -1.1807 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(Mau)10(r)0(een)10( S)6(.)1( Dorn)10(ey)22(. In)10(t)5(e)2(l)5(l)5(ect)5(u)10(a)2(l)5( Propert)5(y)22( Mag)10(azi)5(n)10(e)2(, Wi)5(n)10(t)5(er 1996.)]TJ
T*
-0.021 Tc
0.024 Tw
[(H)-22(t)-20(t)-20(p)-27(:)-20(/)-20(/)-20(www.)-24(i)-20(p)-27(ma)-23(g)-15(.)-24(c)-23(o)-27(m/)-20(r)-25(a)-23(d)-27(c)-23(l)-20(i)-20(f)-13(f)-13(.)-24(h)-15(t)-20(m \()]TJ
15 0 TD
0.006 Tc
(970716\))Tj
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 183.51 Tm
0 Tc
(79)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 178.95 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(7KH\003GRPDLQ\003QDPH\003FXUUHQWO\\\003FDOOHG\0033ULQFH)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
16.7831 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
0.008 Tw
[(,)-8( b)-11(y)13( D)-6(o)-11(ughla)-7(s)-2( H)-6(a)-7(y)13(w)18(a)-7(r)-9(d)-11(.)]TJ
-17.6867 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(T)-11(ech)11(w)28(i)6(re 07/)6(31/)6(97.)]TJ
T*
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Http://tech)8(w)25(e)0(b2.w)25(e)0(b.cerf)10(.)-1(n)8(e)0(t/w)25(ire/n)8(e)0(w)25(s)5(/j)-9(u)8(l/0731prin)8(ce.h)8(t)3(m)21( \(970801)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
27.506 0 TD
0 Tc
(\014\036)Tj
-27.506 -1.1807 TD
(5HYLVHG\0035XOHV\003*RYHUQ\003'RPDLQ\0201DPH\003'LVSXWHV)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
18.7952 0 TD
0.002 Tc
[(, by)20( Sey)20(a)0(m)21(ack)8( Kou)8(r)-2(etch)8(ian)8(,)]TJ
-18.7952 -1.1807 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(T)-12(h)10(e Nat)5(i)5(o)-2(n)10(a)2(l)5( L)13(a)2(w)27( Jou)10(r)0(n)10(a)2(l)5(,)1( Oct)5( 28, 1996.)]TJ
T*
-0.022 Tc
0.025 Tw
[(H)-23(t)-21(t)-21(p)-28(:)-21(/)-21(/)-21(www.)-25(l)-21(j)-33(x)-16(.)-25(c)-24(o)-28(m/)-21(I)-26(n)-16(t)-21(e)-24(r)-26(n)-16(e)-24(t)-21(\()-26(f)-14(i)-21(l)-21(e)-24(t)-21(m)-3(.)-25(h)-16(t)-21(m)-3(l)-21( \()]TJ
16.7229 0 TD
0.006 Tc
(971104\))Tj
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 112.95 Tm
0 Tc
(80)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 108.39 Tm
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( Satterlee Steph)8(e)0(n)8(s)5( B)-6(u)8(rk)8(e &)9( B)-6(u)8(rk)8(e L)11(L)11(P)-8(.)]TJ
-0.6506 -1.1807 TD
-0.022 Tc
0.025 Tw
[(H)-23(t)-21(t)-21(p)-28(:)-21(/)-21(/)-21(www.)-25(s)-19(s)-19(b)-28(b)-28(.)-25(c)-24(o)-28(m/)-21(t)-21(r)-26(a)-24(d)-28(e)-24(m)-3(a)-24(r)-26(.)-25(h)-16(t)-21(m)-3(l)-21( \()]TJ
15.1928 0 TD
0.006 Tc
(971009\))Tj
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
0 Tc
(81)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 84.87 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(&\\EHUODZ\035\003,VVXHV\003LQ\003,QWHUQHW\003&RPPHUFH)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
15.988 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, by)22( T)-12(h)10(om)23(as)7( E. J)-5(e)2(n)10(s)7(en)10(.)]TJ
-16.8916 -1.1807 TD
-0.023 Tc
0.026 Tw
[(H)-24(t)-22(t)-22(p)-29(:)-22(/)-22(/)-22(www.)-26(c)-25(y)-5(b)-29(e)-25(r)-27(l)-22(a)-25(w)0(.)-26(c)-25(o)-29(m)-4(/)-22(i)-22(s)-20(s)-20(u)-17(e)-25(s)-20(.)-26(h)-17(t)-22(m)-4( \()]TJ
15.5904 0 TD
0.006 Tc
(970724\))Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
345 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
347 0 obj
<<
/Length 7545
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(26)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(disputes in a rig)9(h)-1(teous way)29(,)-1( and therefore those matters are to be solved)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(privately)29( or in courts. However, in the event of a dispute, certain procedures)]TJ
T*
[(should be followed. F)5(o)-1(r instance, a trademark owner must send a letter to)]TJ
T*
[(the domain name holder, containing)9( a warning)9(.)-1( I)22(f)2( the warning)9( letter and a)]TJ
T*
[(certified copy)29( of the trademark reg)9(i)-3(stration are sent to I)22(n)-1(terNI)22(C)-4(, the domain)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(na)5(me)5( will be)5( c)5(l)-1(ose)5(d)1( down a)5(f)4(te)5(r thirty)31( da)5(y)31(s)0(, a)5(w)3(a)5(iting)11( the)5( se)5(ttle)5(me)5(nt of the)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(dispute. This policy)30( has caused domain name proprietors to protest. They)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(c)5(l)-1(a)5(im tha)5(t)-1( the)5( NSI)24( polic)5(y)31( pe)5(na)5(lize)5(s)0( site)5( ope)5(ra)5(tors c)5(h)1(a)5(r)4(g)11(e)5(d with tra)5(d)1(e)5(m)-1(a)5(r)4(k)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(infring)9(ement, before any)29( actual infring)9(ement has been proven.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 411.81 637.71 Tm
0.007 Tc
(82)Tj
12 0 0 12 419.97 632.19 Tm
-0.023 Tc
0.023 Tw
[( N)-21(S)-27(I In)-23(t)-25(e)-19(r)-20(n)-23(e)-19(t)]TJ
-25.54 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(business manag)9(e)3(r David Graves defends the dispute policy)29(,)-1( say)29(i)-3(ng)9( that there)]TJ
T*
[(are several options available to domain reg)9(i)-3(strants, such as chang)9(i)-3(ng)9( the)]TJ
T*
[(domain name, having)9( the site deactivated, or resolving)9( the matter in court.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 469.41 595.23 Tm
0.007 Tc
(83)Tj
12 0 0 12 113.49 575.55 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(I)23(f)3( one has done nothing)10( wrong)10( or unlawful, such options seem quite)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(burdensome and unfair.)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 537.63 Tm
[(\031\021\031\003)-436(5HJLVWHULQJ\003GRPDLQ\003QDPHV\003LQ\0036Z)-15(H)-2(GHQ)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 506.79 Tm
[(I)22(n)-1( Europe, the reg)9(i)-3(stration of domain names is controlled by)29( the \223Resaux)-11( I)22(P)]TJ
T*
[(Europ\351ens\224 \(Reg)9(ional I)22(n)-1(ternet Reg)9(i)-3(stry)29( for Europe\) Network Coordination)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Centre \(RI)23(P)-4(E NCC\). RI)23(PE deleg)10(a)4(te the responsibility)30( to national)]TJ
T*
[(institutions, suc)4(h)0( a)4(s)-1( the)4( \223)4(S)-4(we)4(dish Kung)10(lig)10(a)4( Te)4(kniska)4( H\366g)10(s)-1(kola)4(n)0( Ne)4(twork)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Operation Centre/I)22(nternic.se\224 \(KTHNOC\). The \223I)22(nformationstekniska)]TJ
T*
[(Standardisering)9(e)3(n\224 \(I)22(TS\) and its workg)9(r)2(oup 12 \(AG12\) are responsible for)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(se)4(tting)10( up a)4( polic)4(y)30( a)4(nd a)4( fra)4(me)4(work of rule)4(s re)4(la)4(ting)10( to doma)4(i)-2(n na)4(me)4(s.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 452.01 427.35 Tm
0.007 Tc
(84)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 407.67 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(This polic)5(y)31( re)5(quire)5(s tha)5(t)-1( only)31( c)5(o)1(mpa)5(n)1(ie)5(s, org)11(a)5(niza)5(tions, or a)5(u)1(thoritie)5(s ma)5(y)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(reg)9(i)-3(ster a domain name. Private persons may)29( not do so. The domain name)]TJ
T*
[(must be closely)29( and uniquely)29( linked to the official reg)9(i)-3(stered name used by)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(h)-2(e com)-4(p)-2(any)28( i)-4(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e \223phy)28(si)-4(cal)-4(\224 worl)-4(d out)-4(si)-4(de C)-5(y)28(berspace. I)21(n)-2( ot)-4(her words, i)-4(n)]TJ
T*
[(order t)-4(o)-2( recei)-4(ve a cert)-4(a)2(i)-4(n)-2( dom)-4(ai)-4(n nam)-4(e)2(, t)-4(h)-2(ere m)-4(u)-2(st)-4( ex)-12(i)-4(s)-3(t)-4( a subst)-4(a)2(nt)-4(i)-4(a)2(l)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(g)9(e)3(nuine relationship to the name before sending)9( in the application. A)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(document proving)10( such a relationship must be attached to the application.)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(The Swedish rules concerning)9( reg)9(i)-3(stration of domain names are quite)]TJ
T*
[(string)9(ent, in comparison to the corresponding)9( American rules. There should)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(not be a g)10(r)3(eat amount of domain name disputes with the Swedish domain)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(name sy)29(stem. However, one should not ig)9(nore the fact that two companies)]TJ
T*
[(in different businesses may)29( use the same trademark, and this could lead to)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(di)-4(sput)-4(es, si)-4(nce onl)-4(y)28( one of t)-4(h)-2(e com)-4(p)-2(ani)-4(e)2(s can use t)-4(h)-2(e t)-4(r)1(adem)-4(ark as a dom)-4(ai)-4(n)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(na)4(me)4( with the)4( TL)21(D .se)4(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 226.41 229.11 Tm
0.007 Tc
(85)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 234.57 223.59 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( Suppose the insurance company)29( \223W)-7(ASA\224 and the)]TJ
-10.09 -1.18 TD
[(breadmaker \223W)-7(AS)-5(A\224 both want the domain \223www.wasa.se\224.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 408.45 214.95 Tm
0.007 Tc
(86)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 416.61 209.43 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( W)-5(ho is)]TJ
-25.26 -1.18 TD
[(e)5(n)1(title)5(d to the)5( doma)5(i)-1(n?)-15( Ge)5(og)11(ra)5(phic)5(a)5(l)-1( na)5(me)5(s ma)5(y)31( not be)5( use)5(d, unle)5(ss the)]TJ
0 -2.3 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 170.79 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 159.99 Tm
(82)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 155.43 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
('RPDLQ\003QDPH\003GLVSXWHV\035\0033UHHPSWLYH\0036XLWV\017\003)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
17.0843 0 TD
-0.007 Tc
0.01 Tw
[(b)-13(y)11( J)-16(o)-13(a)-9(nna)-9( G)-8(l)-6(a)-9(s)-4(ne)-9(r)-11(.)-10( La)-9(w)16( J)-16(o)-13(ur)-11(na)-9(l)]TJ
-17.9879 -1.1807 TD
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[(EXT)-13(R)7(A)14(!)11(, Sept. 17, 1997. Http://)]TJ
13.1205 0 TD
-0.022 Tc
[(www.)-25(l)-21(j)-33(x)-16(.)-25(c)-24(o)-28(m/)-21(l)-21(j)-33(x)-16(f)-14(i)-21(l)-21(e)-24(s)-19(/)-21(d)-28(o)-28(m)-3(a)-24(i)-21(n)-16(l)-21(a)-24(w)1(.)-25(h)-16(t)-21(m)-3(l)]TJ
-13.1205 -1.1807 TD
0.006 Tc
(\(971012\))Tj
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 124.71 Tm
0 Tc
(83)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 120.15 Tm
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
( Ibid.)Tj
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 112.95 Tm
0 Tc
(84)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 108.39 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(1lWMXULGLN\017\003/DJ\003RFK\003UlWW\003Sn\003,QWHUQHW)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
14.3012 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, by)22( T)-12(h)10(om)23(as)7( C)8(a)2(rl)5(\351n)10(-)12(W)-4(en)10(del)5(s)7(, p 106)]TJ
-15.2048 -1.1807 TD
-0.022 Tc
0.025 Tw
[(a)-24(n)-16(d)-28( h)-16(o)-28(me)-24(p)-28(a)-24(g)-16(e)-24( o)-28(f)-14( i)-21(n)-16(t)-21(e)-24(r)-26(n)-16(i)-21(c)-24(.)-25(s)-19(e)-24( a)-24(t)-21( H)-23(t)-21(t)-21(p)-28(:)-21(/)-21(/)-21(www.)-25(i)-21(n)-16(t)-21(e)-24(r)-26(n)-16(i)-21(c)-24(.)-25(s)-19(e)-24( \()]TJ
22.1807 0 TD
0.006 Tc
(971104\))Tj
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
0 Tc
(85)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 84.87 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(3UDNWLVN\003,7\020UlWW)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
6.2651 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, by)22( A)15(g)10(n)10(e)2( L)13(i)5(n)10(dberg)10( an)10(d Dan)10(i)5(el)5( Wes)7(t)5(m)23(a)2(n)10(,)1( pag)10(e)2( 27.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 77.67 Tm
0 Tc
(86)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 73.11 Tm
0.003 Tw
[( T)-16(h)6(is exam)19(p)-6(l)1(e is co)-6(m)19(p)-6(letely)18( f)8(i)1(ctive, b)-6(u)6(t the co)-6(m)19(p)-6(anies d)-6(o)-6( exist.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
348 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
349 0 obj
<<
/Length 6606
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(27)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(com)-4(p)-2(any)28( l)-4(e)2(g)8(a)2(l)-4(l)-4(y)28( can cl)-4(ai)-4(m)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e ri)-4(g)8(h)-2(t)-4( t)-4(o)-2( do so. P)-6(r)1(ot)-4(ect)-4(ed nam)-4(e)2(s, such as)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(trademarks, may)29( only)29( be used by)29( the rig)9(h)-1(tful owners. However, trademarks)]TJ
T*
[(may)29( only)29( be used if they)29( represent the name of the org)9(a)3(niz)-7(a)3(tion, not if they)]TJ
T*
(represent a service, product or equivalent.)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 313.89 708.51 Tm
0.007 Tc
(87)Tj
12 0 0 12 322.05 702.99 Tm
-0.001 Tc
( This circumstantial procedure)Tj
-17.38 -1.18 TD
[(may)29( be bothersome, but it may)29( hinder sinister cy)29(bersquatters.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 665.07 Tm
[(\031\021\032\003)-436(&\\)10(EHUVTXDWWLQJ)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 634.23 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Anothe)4(r proble)4(m)-2( is tha)4(t)-2( of c)4(y)30(be)4(rsqua)4(tting)10(.)0( I)23(ndividua)4(ls de)4(libe)4(r)3(a)4(t)-2(e)4(l)-2(y)30( re)4(g)10(i)-2(ste)4(r)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(well-known trademarks in order to sell or lease them back to the rig)9(h)-1(tful)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(r)1(adem)-4(ark owners i)-4(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e fut)-4(u)-2(re, i)-4(f)1( t)-4(h)-2(e com)-4(p)-2(ani)-4(e)2(s deci)-4(de t)-4(o)-2( creat)-4(e a websi)-4(t)-4(e)2(. I)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(be)5(lie)5(ve)5( this is a)5( diminishing)11( proble)5(m)-1(, sinc)5(e)5( most c)5(o)1(mpa)5(n)1(ie)5(s ha)5(ve)5( g)11(one)5( on-)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(line by)29( now. There have been a number of suits, especially)29( in the U.S.,)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(re)4(la)4(ting)10( to c)4(y)30(be)4(rsqua)4(tting)10(.)0( I)23(n)0( Europe)4( the)4(r)3(e)4( ha)4(ve)4( be)4(e)4(n)0( a)4( numbe)4(r of suits,)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(especially)29( in the U.K., the Netherlands and Germany)29(.)-1( One could say)29( that the)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(leg)10(a)4(l status of domain names is relatively)30( uncertain. I)23(t)-2( is not decided y)30(e)4(t,)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(whether domain names are like trademarks, capable of being)9( protected, or if)]TJ
T*
[(they)29( are similar to street addresses without protection.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 372.09 512.31 Tm
0.007 Tc
(88)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 484.47 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\031\021\032\021\024)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(5HDVRQV\003ZK\\\003RQH\003RXJKW\003WR\003ILJKW\003D\003F\\EHUVTXDWWHU)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 456.03 Tm
0.001 Tw
[(These people with questionable motives, who barg)9(ain for monetary)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(se)4(ttle)4(me)4(nts in orde)4(r to re)4(le)4(a)4(s)-1(e)4( the)4( doma)4(i)-2(n na)4(me)4(s to the)4( tra)4(d)0(e)4(m)-2(a)4(r)3(k owne)4(rs,)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(have caused a lot of ang)9(e)3(r and frustration among)9( larg)9(e well known)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
[(companies during)9( the last couple of y)29(ears. I)22(f)2( one detects that one\222s)]TJ
T*
[(trademark is reg)9(i)-3(stered as a domain name by)29( a cy)29(bersquatter, should one)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(choose to fig)10(h)0(t him or simply)30( let it be, especially)30( if the trademark owner)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(does not need the domain name?)-17( Ex)-11(cept for the costs involved in fig)9(h)-1(ting)9( a)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(c)4(y)30(be)4(rsqua)4(tte)4(r, the)4(r)3(e)4( ma)4(y)30( be)4( se)4(ve)4(ra)4(l worthy)30( re)4(a)4(s)-1(ons \(re)4(la)4(ting)10( to inte)4(lle)4(c)4(t)-2(ua)4(l)]TJ
T*
[(prope)4(rty)30( issue)4(s)-1(\) to fig)10(h)0(t a)4( le)4(g)10(a)4(l ba)4(ttle)4( a)4(g)10(a)4(i)-2(nst a)4( c)4(y)30(be)4(rsqua)4(tte)4(r. I)23(f)3( the)4( c)4(o)0(mpa)4(n)0(y)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(does not care about the cy)29(bersquatter\222s unauthoriz)-7(ed continuous use of its)]TJ
T*
[(trademark, as a domain name, this may)29( dilute the streng)9(th of the)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
[(t)-4(r)1(adem)-4(ark.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 164.97 305.79 Tm
0.007 Tc
(89)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 173.13 300.27 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[( People may)29( not associate the trademark to a certain product or)]TJ
-4.97 -1.18 TD
[(company)29( any)29( long)9(er if the cy)29(bersquatter\222s website is popular and frequently)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(visited by)30( numerous users. Also imag)10(i)-2(ne if the domain name \(that includes)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(h)-2(e unaut)-4(hori)-4(z)-8(ed use of t)-4(h)-2(e com)-4(p)-2(any)28(\222)1(s t)-4(r)1(adem)-4(ark\) i)-4(s)-3( associ)-4(at)-4(ed wi)-4(t)-4(h)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(immoral material, such as adult information, racist propag)10(a)4(nda or)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(equivalent. This could directly)29( have a harmful effect on the company)29(\222)2(s)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(reputation and g)10(oodwill.)]TJ
0 -4.95 TD
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 159.03 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 148.23 Tm
(87)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 143.67 Tm
-0.023 Tc
0.026 Tw
[( H)-24(t)-22(t)-22(p)-29(:)-22(/)-22(/)-22(www.)-26(i)-22(n)-17(t)-22(e)-25(r)-27(n)-17(i)-22(c)-25(.)-26(s)-20(e)-25( \()]TJ
9.9398 0 TD
0.006 Tc
(971104\))Tj
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 136.47 Tm
0 Tc
(88)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 131.91 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(7HQVLRQ\003%HWZHHQ\0033DUDOHOO\0038QLYHUVHV\035\0037UDGHPDUNV\003FODVK\003ZLWK\003GRPDLQ)Tj
-0.9036 -1.1807 TD
(QDPHV\003DV\003EXVLQHVV\003LGHQWLI\\\003PRYHV\003RQWR\003WKH\003,QWHUQHW)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
20.3494 0 TD
0.003 Tc
[(, by)21( Mark)9( F. R)7(a)1(dclif)11(f)11(e)1( an)9(d)]TJ
-20.3494 -1.1807 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(Mau)10(r)0(een)10( S)6(.)1( Dorn)10(ey)22(. In)10(t)5(e)2(l)5(l)5(ect)5(u)10(a)2(l)5( Propert)5(y)22( Mag)10(azi)5(n)10(e)2(, Wi)5(n)10(t)5(er 1996.)]TJ
T*
-0.021 Tc
0.024 Tw
[(H)-22(t)-20(t)-20(p)-27(:)-20(/)-20(/)-20(www.)-24(i)-20(p)-27(ma)-23(g)-15(.)-24(c)-23(o)-27(m/)-20(r)-25(a)-23(d)-27(c)-23(l)-20(i)-20(f)-13(f)-13(.)-24(h)-15(t)-20(m \()]TJ
15 0 TD
0.006 Tc
(970716\))Tj
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
0 Tc
(89)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 84.87 Tm
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( Satterlee Steph)8(e)0(n)8(s)5( B)-6(u)8(rk)8(e &)9( B)-6(u)8(rk)8(e L)11(L)11(P)-8(.)]TJ
-0.6506 -1.1807 TD
-0.022 Tc
0.025 Tw
[(H)-23(t)-21(t)-21(p)-28(:)-21(/)-21(/)-21(www.)-25(s)-19(s)-19(b)-28(b)-28(.)-25(c)-24(o)-28(m/)-21(t)-21(r)-26(a)-24(d)-28(e)-24(m)-3(a)-24(r)-26(.)-25(h)-16(t)-21(m)-3(l)-21( \()]TJ
15.1928 0 TD
0.006 Tc
(971009\))Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
350 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
351 0 obj
<<
/Length 5665
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(28)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 743.31 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\031\021\032\021\025)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(+RVWLOH\003WDNHRYHU\003RI\003WUDGHPDUN\003E\\\003F\\EHUVTXDWWHU)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 714.87 Tm
0.001 Tw
[(Another reason to fig)9(h)-1(t a cy)29(bersquatter is that he/she may)29( in the future claim)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(that the trademark no long)9(er is entitled to protection, since it has been used)]TJ
T*
[(by)29( other parties as a domain name, without any)29( objection from the)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(r)1(adem)-4(ark owner.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 197.85 677.91 Tm
0.007 Tc
(90)Tj
12 0 0 12 206.01 672.39 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( An unre)4(g)10(iste)4(re)4(d tra)4(d)0(e)4(m)-2(a)4(r)3(k ma)4(y)30( be)4( e)4(n)0(title)4(d to prote)4(c)4(tion,)]TJ
-7.71 -1.18 TD
[(if it ha)4(s be)4(e)4(n)0( use)4(d)0( a)4(nd e)4(s)-1(ta)4(blishe)4(d for a)4( long)10( pe)4(riod of time)4(.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 399.93 663.75 Tm
0.007 Tc
(91)Tj
12 0 0 12 408.09 658.23 Tm
0 Tc
( Suppose a)Tj
-24.55 -1.18 TD
[(c)4(y)30(be)4(rsqua)4(tte)4(r is le)4(ft a)4(l)-2(one)4( for a)4( long)10( time)4(. Wha)4(t)-2( if he)4(/she)4( sta)4(r)3(ts a)4( busine)4(s)-1(s)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(with the \223stolen\224 domain name and uses it for several y)29(ears. I)22(t)-3( is not)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(c)5(o)1(mple)5(te)5(ly)31( unlike)5(l)-1(y)31( tha)5(t)-1( the)5( c)5(y)31(be)5(rsqua)5(tte)5(r c)5(ould be)5( e)5(n)1(title)5(d to use)5( the)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(r)1(adem)-4(ark due t)-4(o)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e fact)-4( t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e com)-4(p)-2(any)28( never prot)-4(est)-4(e)2(d t)-4(o)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e usag)8(e of)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(the domain name.)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 563.67 Tm
[(\031\021\033\003)-436(&RQIXVLQJ\003GRPDLQ\003QDPHV)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 532.83 Tm
[(Suppose a potential client ty)29(pes the name of a law firm \(or other firm\) in the)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(URL)21(,)0( and discovers that the site is filled with very)30( disturbing)10( and unpleasant)]TJ
T*
[(content?)-16( I)23(f)3( it is not obvious that the site belong)10(s to someone else, the user)]TJ
T*
[(may)30( be deceived. Even if it is obvious that the site does not belong)10( to the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(company)29(,)-1( the user may)29( be doubtful and believe that the company)29( supports,)]TJ
T*
(or has some kind of connection to the obscene site, since the name of the)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(company)30( is display)30(e)4(d in the URL)21(.)0( This kind of confusion has actually)30( been)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(the case with the domain name \223internic.com\224. Users soug)9(ht reg)9(i)-3(stration for)]TJ
T*
(their domain names at a website with the above described domain name.)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(They)30( all thoug)10(ht that it was the official site of Network Solution\222s I)23(n)0(terNI)23(C)-3(,)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(and paid $250 for a domain reg)9(i)-3(stration. However, the official I)22(n)-1(terNI)22(C)-4( site)]TJ
T*
[(has the domain \223internic.net\224, and charg)9(e)3( $100 for a domain name)]TJ
T*
[(reg)9(i)-3(stration. Apparently)29(, the phony)29( company)29( owning)9( \223intenic.com\224)]TJ
T*
[(reg)9(i)-3(stered the domain names for its \223clients\224 at the cost of $100 at the \223real\224)]TJ
T*
[(I)22(n)-1(terNI)22(C)-4(. This fake company)29( seeming)9(l)-3(y)29( made a profit of $150 of every)]TJ
T*
[(reg)9(i)-3(strant believing)9( that the site was the official I)22(n)-1(terNI)22(C)-4( site, due to its)]TJ
T*
[(confusing)9( domain name.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 231.57 311.79 Tm
0.007 Tc
(92)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 254.19 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(\031\021\034\003)-436(3RVVLEOH\003FRQIOLFWV\003EHWZ)-15(HHQ\003GRPDLQ\003QDPHV)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
(DQG\003WUDGHPDUNV)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 204.51 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(Much of the controversies about trademarks on the I)22(n)-1(ternet concern the)]TJ
T*
[(reg)9(i)-3(stration as well as the use of domain names. Trademark issues were not)]TJ
T*
[(taken into account when reg)9(i)-3(stering)9( domain names at first-come, first-served)]TJ
T*
[(basis. This did, naturally)29(, lead to various conflicts between the allocated)]TJ
T*
[(domain names, and the ex)-11(isting)9( intellectual property)29( rig)9(h)-1(ts. Trademark law)]TJ
0 -2.27 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 123.75 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 112.95 Tm
(90)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 108.39 Tm
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
( Ibid.)Tj
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 101.19 Tm
0 Tc
(91)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 96.63 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(/lURERN\003,\003,PPDWHULDOUlWW)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
10.1566 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, by)22( Kok)10(t)5(v)10(e)2(dg)10(aard an)10(d L)13(e)2(v)10(i)5(n)10(,)1( pag)10(e)2( 297.)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
0 Tc
(92)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 84.87 Tm
0.016 Tc
-0.013 Tw
[( Th)22(e)14( N)15(e)14(t)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
3.5181 0 TD
0 Tc
(\035\003'RPDLQ\003UHVHOOHUV\003FRQIXVHV\003XVHUV)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
13.5904 0 TD
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[(, by)21( J)-6(a)1(n)9(e)1(t Korn)9(blu)9(m)22(, J)-6(u)9(ly)21( 9,)]TJ
-17.759 -1.1807 TD
0.001 Tw
(1997. Http://)Tj
5.1446 0 TD
-0.023 Tc
[(www.)-26(n)-17(e)-25(ws)-20(.)-26(c)-25(o)-29(m)-4(/)-22(n)-17(e)-25(w)0(s)]TJ
8.6386 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(/item)23(/)5(o,4,12296,00.h)10(t)5(m)23(l)5(?)-10(d)-2(tn)10(.h)10(ead \(971009\))]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
352 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
353 0 obj
<<
/Length 7636
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(29)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(permits that the same trademark is used for different ty)29(pes of g)9(oods.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 439.77 750.99 Tm
0.007 Tc
(93)Tj
12 0 0 12 447.93 745.47 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
( A)Tj
-27.87 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(trademark may)29( co-ex)-11(i)-3(st in different countries as well. However, on the)]TJ
T*
[(I)22(n)-1(ternet, there cannot ex)-11(ist two domain names spelled ex)-11(actly)29( the same way)29(.)]TJ
T*
[(Companies using)9( the same trademark, operating)9( in different fields or)]TJ
T*
[(countries may)29( have to fig)9(h)-1(t to be able to use the trademark as a domain)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
(name.)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(The term \223trademarks\224 does not include domain names, even thoug)9(h one)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(m)-4(a)2(y)28( say)28( t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( dom)-4(ai)-4(n nam)-4(e)2(s are t)-4(r)1(adem)-4(ark-l)-4(i)-4(k)-2(e by)28( t)-4(h)-2(ei)-4(r nat)-4(u)-2(re.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 412.41 637.71 Tm
0.007 Tc
(94)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 420.57 632.19 Tm
0.002 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[( Some)6( ma)6(y)]TJ
-25.59 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(a)5(r)4(g)11(u)1(e)5( tha)5(t)-1( doma)5(i)-1(n na)5(me)5(s a)5(r)4(e)5( ve)5(ry)31( muc)5(h)1( like)5( tra)5(d)1(e)5(m)-1(a)5(r)4(ks, a)5(nd thus e)5(n)1(title)5(d to)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(protection, and others may)29( arg)9(u)-1(e that domain names are more like street)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(addresses, not to be protected or owned. I)23(t)-2( is almost indisputable that)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(domain names are performing)9( a similar role, in Cy)29(berspace, as trademarks)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(have play)30(ed in traditional ty)30(pes of businesses.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 332.85 566.91 Tm
0.007 Tc
(95)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 341.01 561.39 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( Doma)5(in na)5(me)5(s a)5(r)4(e)5( ofte)5(n)]TJ
-18.96 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(used to identify)29( a source of g)9(oods or services. W)-7(I)22(PO has called for a)]TJ
T*
[(discussion concerning)9( issues mentioned above. F)5(o)-1(r ex)-11(ample, in the)]TJ
T*
[(September memorandum, it say)29(s)-2( that the I)22(n)-1(ternational B)6(u)-1(reau has initiated a)]TJ
T*
[(survey)29( reg)9(a)3(rding)9( under which conditions holders of domain names could)]TJ
T*
[(obtain and maintain the reg)9(i)-3(stration of the domain name as a trademark.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 458.13 496.11 Tm
0.007 Tc
(96)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 466.83 Tm
0 Tc
[(\031\021\024\023\003)-434(7UDGHPDUNV\003DQG\003GRPDLQ\003QDPHV\003LQ\0036Z)-14(H)-1(GHQ)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 421.83 Tm
0 Tw
[(I)23(n)0( the lig)10(ht of Swedish rules, domain names could in some cases be)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(consi)-4(d)-2(ered equal)-4( t)-4(o)-2( t)-4(r)1(adem)-4(arks. I)21(n)-2( S)-6(w)0(edi)-4(s)-3(h l)-4(a)2(w, t)-4(h)-2(e t)-4(r)1(adem)-4(ark i)-4(s)-3( t)-4(h)-2(e l)-4(i)-4(n)-2(k)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(between a company)29( and its customers. I)22(t)-3( could function as a source of)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(orig)10(in, wa)4(rra)4(nty)30( of qua)4(lity)30(, a)4(s)-1( we)4(ll a)4(s)-1( tool for individua)4(lizing)10( the)4( c)4(o)0(mpa)4(n)0(y)30(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 473.25 384.87 Tm
0.007 Tc
(97)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 365.19 Tm
0 Tc
[(I)23(f)3( a)4( tra)4(d)0(e)4(m)-2(a)4(r)3(k ha)4(s e)4(x)-10(iste)4(d for a)4( long)10( pe)4(riod of time)4(, it ma)4(y)30( ha)4(ve)4( a)4(n)0( intrinsic)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
(value.)Tj
0 -2.36 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(A trademark must be distinct and different from other trademarks in order to)Tj
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(enjoy)30( protection.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 194.37 314.07 Tm
0.007 Tc
(98)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 202.53 308.55 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( I)22(f)2( only)29( minor details separate a mark from another, it is)]TJ
-7.42 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(not sa)5(id to be)5( distinc)5(t)-1(, sinc)5(e)5( it re)5(se)5(mble)5(s the)5( prima)5(ry)31( ma)5(rk. Re)5(g)11(i)-1(stra)5(tion a)5(s)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(trademark in such a situation would therefore not be possible. I)22(f)2( domain)]TJ
T*
[(names would enjoy)29( the same protection as trademarks, the same rules would)]TJ
T*
[(apply)29( to them. One could arg)9(u)-1(e that a domain name, which is reg)9(i)-3(stered)]TJ
T*
[(after another with merely)29( a minor deviance from the first \(such as a number)]TJ
0 -1.92 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 217.83 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 207.03 Tm
(93)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 202.47 Tm
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( F)6(o)-2(r i)5(n)10(s)7(t)5(an)10(ce, Varu)10(m)23(\344)2(rk)10(es)7(l)5(a)2(g)10( \(1960:)5(644\) 6\247.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 195.27 Tm
0 Tc
(94)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 190.71 Tm
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( W)-6(I)-2(P)-8(O)1( C)6(o)-4(n)8(s)5(u)8(ltativ)8(e m)21(eetin)8(g)8( on)8( tradem)21(ark)8(s)5( an)8(d In)8(tern)8(et dom)21(ain)8( n)8(a)0(m)21(e)0(s,)]TJ
-0.6506 -1.1807 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(F)6(i)5(rs)7(t)5( S)6(e)2(s)7(s)7(i)5(on)10(, Gen)10(e)2(v)10(a)2(, May)22( 26 t)5(o)-2( 30, 1997.)]TJ
T*
-0.022 Tc
[(H)-23(t)-21(t)-21(p)-28(:)-21(/)-21(/)-21(www.)-25(wi)-21(p)-28(o)-28(.)-25(i)-21(n)-16(t)-21(/)-21(e)-24(n)-16(g)-16(/)-21(I)-26(n)-16(t)-21(e)-24(r)-26(n)-16(e)-24(t)-21(/)-21(d)-28(o)-28(m)-3(a)-24(i)-21(n)-16(s)-19(/)-21(t)-21(d)-28(n)-16(/)-21(c)-24(m)-3(/)-21(c)-24(m_)-28(I)-26(_)-28(2)-28(.)-25(h)-16(t)-21(m)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 159.99 Tm
0 Tc
(95)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 155.43 Tm
0.003 Tw
[( INT)-16(A)11( \(Internatio)-6(nal T)-16(r)-4(ad)-6(em)19(ark A)11(sso)-6(ciatio)-6(n\)\223)10(W)-8(hite P)-10(a)-2(p)-6(e)-2(r\224 -)8( )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
25.012 0 TD
(7KH)Tj
-25.6626 -1.1807 TD
(,QWHUVHFWLRQ\003RI\0037UDGHPDUNV\003DQG\003'RPDLQ\0031DPHV)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
19.1687 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, F)6(e)2(b 5, 1997, Vers)7(i)5(o)-2(n)10( 1.0.)]TJ
-19.1687 -1.1807 TD
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Http://plaz.in)8(terport.n)8(e)0(t/in)8(t/w)25(pw)25(h)8(o)-4(le.h)8(tm)21( \(971121\))]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 124.71 Tm
0 Tc
(96)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 120.15 Tm
0.002 Tc
[( W)-6(I)-2(P)-8(O)1(, C)6(o)-4(n)8(s)5(u)8(ltativ)8(e m)21(eetin)8(g)8( on)8( T)-14(r)-2(adem)21(ark)8(s)5( an)8(d In)8(tern)8(et Dom)21(a)0(in)8( n)8(a)0(m)21(e)0(s,)]TJ
-0.6506 -1.1807 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(s)7(econ)10(d)-2( s)7(e)2(s)7(s)7(i)5(on)10(, Gen)10(e)2(v)10(a)2(, S)6(e)2(pt)5(em)23(ber 1 an)10(d 2, 1997.)]TJ
T*
-0.021 Tc
0.024 Tw
[(H)-22(t)-20(t)-20(p)-27(:)-20(/)-20(/)-20(www.)-24(wi)-20(p)-27(o)-27(.)-24(i)-20(n)-15(t)-20(/)-20(e)-23(n)-15(g)-15(/)-20(i)-20(n)-15(t)-20(e)-23(r)-25(n)-15(e)-23(t)-20(/)-20(d)-27(o)-27(m)-2(a)-23(i)-20(n)-15(s)-18(/)-20(t)-20(d)-27(n)-15(/)-20(c)-23(m)-2(/)-20(c)-23(m_)-27(i)-20(i)-20(_)-27(2)-27(.)-24(h)-15(t)-20(m \()]TJ
25.9036 0 TD
0.006 Tc
(971025\))Tj
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
0 Tc
(97)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 84.87 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(/lURERN\003,\003LPPPDWHULDOUlWW)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
10.8193 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, Kok)10(t)5(v)10(e)2(dg)10(aard an)10(d L)13(e)2(v)10(i)5(n)10(,)1( pag)10(e)2( 305.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 77.67 Tm
0 Tc
(98)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 73.11 Tm
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[( Varu)11(m)24(\344)3(rk)11(es)8(l)6(a)3(g)11( \(1960:)6(644\) 2\247 an)11(d 12\247.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
354 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
355 0 obj
<<
/Length 7296
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(30)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(or sing)9(le letter\), would not be able to reg)9(i)-3(ster as a domain name in Sweden.)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(The first name, however, may)29( be able to do so. F)5(o)-1(r ex)-11(ample, suppose a)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(com)-4(p)-2(any)28( reg)8(i)-4(st)-4(ered t)-4(h)-2(e dom)-4(ai)-4(n nam)-4(e)2( \223cy)28(berburg)8(e)2(r\224 as a t)-4(r)1(adem)-4(ark. P)-6(e)2(rhaps)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(this is distinct enoug)9(h to enjoy)29( protection as a reg)9(i)-3(stered trademark, but I)22( am)]TJ
T*
[(of the opinion that a second reg)9(i)-3(stration such as \223cy)29(berburg)9(e)3(rs\224 or)]TJ
T*
[(\223cy)29(berburg)9(e)3(r1\224 would not be distinct enoug)9(h to enjoy)29( protection as)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(reg)8(i)-4(st)-4(ered t)-4(r)1(adem)-4(arks. However, t)-4(h)-2(ese dom)-4(ai)-4(n nam)-4(e)2(s m)-4(a)2(y)28( aft)-4(e)2(r a l)-4(e)2(ng)8(t)-4(h)-2(y)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(pe)4(riod of time)4(, be)4( distinc)4(t)-2( due)4( to the)4( fa)4(c)4(t)-2( tha)4(t)-2( the)4(y)30( ha)4(ve)4( be)4(e)4(n)0( use)4(d)0( a)4(n)0(d)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(wi)-4(del)-4(y)28( recog)8(n)-2(i)-4(z)-8(ed.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 204.21 637.71 Tm
0.007 Tc
(99)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 212.37 632.19 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( They)30( would at that point not qualify)30( for reg)10(i)-2(stration,)]TJ
-8.24 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(but perhaps for protection. Another question is whether they)29( would be)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(a)4(d)0(mitte)4(d to be)4( use)4(d)0( for suc)4(h)0( a)4( long)10( pe)4(riod a)4(t)-2( a)4(ll. Ac)4(c)4(o)0(rding)10( to inte)4(rnic)4(.se)4(,)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(onl)-4(y)28( t)-4(h)-2(e respect)-4(i)-4(v)-2(e owners m)-4(a)2(y)28( use prot)-4(ect)-4(ed t)-4(r)1(adem)-4(arks, i)-4(f)1( t)-4(h)-2(e t)-4(r)1(adem)-4(arks)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(are the same as the name of the org)9(a)3(niz)-7(a)3(tion. As mentioned above, no)]TJ
T*
[(trademarks related to names of products, services etc. can be reg)9(i)-3(stered as)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
(domain names in Sweden.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 239.37 552.75 Tm
0.007 Tc
(100)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 251.61 547.23 Tm
0 Tc
[( However, in the U.S., it is possible to reg)10(i)-2(ster a)]TJ
-11.51 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(trademark referring)9( to a product, service etc. as a domain name as long)9( as no)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(r)1(adem)-4(ark i)-4(n)-2(fri)-4(ng)8(em)-4(ent)-4( i)-4(s)-3( at)-4( hand.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 278.73 524.43 Tm
0.007 Tc
(101)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 495.15 Tm
0 Tc
[(\031\021\024\024\003)-434('RPDLQ\003QDPHV\003DUH\003QRW\003VROHO\\)11(\003)2(GHVFULSWLY)21(H)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 464.31 Tm
-0.002 Tc
[(I)21(f)1( a m)-4(a)2(rk i)-4(s)-3( sol)-4(e)2(l)-4(y)28( descri)-4(pt)-4(i)-4(v)-2(e, i)-4(t)-4( m)-4(a)2(y)28( not)-4( be reg)8(i)-4(st)-4(ered as a t)-4(r)1(adem)-4(ark and)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(enjoy)29( protection. Could one arg)9(u)-1(e that domain names in g)9(e)3(neral are)]TJ
T*
[(descriptive and not distinct at all?)-17( Can a domain name in itself be more than)]TJ
T*
[(merely)29( a descriptive phrase?)-17( I)22( am of the opinion that it can, since a domain)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(na)5(me)5( c)5(a)5(n)1( e)5(x)-9(pre)5(ss orig)11(ina)5(lity)31(, distinc)5(tive)5(n)1(e)5(ss a)5(s)0( we)5(ll a)5(s)0( g)11(i)-1(ve)5( a)5( hint of the)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(content of the site. Special orig)10(inal combinations and combinations of words)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(may)29( enjoy)29( protection. I)22( believe that domain names can be reg)9(i)-3(stered as)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(tra)4(d)0(e)4(m)-2(a)4(r)3(ks, if the)4(y)30( fulfill the)4( re)4(quire)4(me)4(nts e)4(x)-10(pre)4(sse)4(d by)30( the)4( la)4(w. I)23(t)-2( ma)4(y)30( be)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(worth to reg)9(i)-3(ster a domain name as a trademark as fast as possible in order)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(to a)4(void c)4(onflic)4(ts in the)4( future)4(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 261.33 342.39 Tm
0.007 Tc
(102)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 313.11 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(\031\021\024\025\003)-435(5HJLVWHULQJ\003D\003WUDGHPDUN\003FRQVLVWLQJ\003RI\003D)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
(J7/')Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 263.43 Tm
[(Some authors claim that domain names have nothing)10( in common with)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(trademarks, and should therefore not be able to enjoy)29( trademark protection)]TJ
T*
-0.003 Tc
0.003 Tw
[(at)-5( al)-5(l)-5(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 140.13 240.63 Tm
0.007 Tc
(103)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 152.37 235.11 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( One arg)9(u)-1(ment is that some websites, such as \223NB)6(C)-4(.COM\224, which)]TJ
-3.24 -1.18 TD
[(are named after their domain addresses cannot be reg)9(i)-3(stered. The Patent and)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(Tradem)-4(arks Offi)-4(ce \(P)-6(TO\) has sai)-4(d)-2( t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( \223NBC)-5(\224 can be reg)8(i)-4(st)-4(ered and enj)-4(o)-2(y)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(protection, but the \223.COM\224 part cannot. This is by)30( some authors, seen as a)]TJ
0 -2.08 TD
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 170.79 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 159.99 Tm
(99)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 148.29 155.43 Tm
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( Varu)10(m)23(\344)2(rk)10(es)7(l)5(a)2(g)10( \(1960:)5(644\) 2\247 \(i)5(n)10(a)2(rbet)5(n)10(i)5(n)10(g)10(\))0(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 148.23 Tm
0 Tc
(100)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 143.67 Tm
-0.023 Tc
0.026 Tw
[( I)-27(n)-17(t)-22(r)-27(e)-25(n)-17(i)-22(c)-25(.)-26(s)-20(e)-25(.)-26( H)-24(t)-22(t)-22(p)-29(:)-22(/)-22(/)-22(www.)-26(i)-22(n)-17(t)-22(e)-25(r)-27(n)-17(i)-22(c)-25(.)-26(s)-20(e)-25( \()]TJ
14.6386 0 TD
0.006 Tc
(971104\))Tj
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 136.47 Tm
0 Tc
(101)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 131.91 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
357 0 obj
<<
/Length 5965
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(31)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(sig)9(n)-1( supporting)9( the arg)9(u)-1(ment that domain names are similar to addresses. I)22(t)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
0 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(m)-4(a)2(y)28( very)28( wel)-4(l)-4( be t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e g)8(T)-1(L)19(D)0(s, such as \223.com)-4(\224)2(, are t)-4(oo com)-4(m)-4(on even t)-4(o)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(be part of a trademark, but I)22( believe that the SL)20(Ds must be individual and)]TJ
T*
[(distinct in order to be reg)9(i)-3(stered.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 679.23 Tm
[(\031\021\024\026\003)-435(7KH\003SRVVLELOLWLHV\003RI\003GRPDLQ\003QDPHV)]TJ
T*
[(LQIULQJLQJ\003XSRQ\003DOUHDG\\)10(\003)1(H[LVWLQJ\003WUDGHPDUNV\003DQG)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
[(Y)22(L)3(FH\003Y)22(HUVD)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 610.71 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(Another question is whether domain names can infring)9(e upon already)]TJ
T*
[(ex)-11(isting)9( trademarks and vice versa. Can solely)29( the reg)9(i)-3(stration of a domain)]TJ
T*
[(name be an act of infring)9(ement, if a domain name is the same as a reg)9(i)-3(stered)]TJ
T*
[(trademark?)-17( I)22(f)2( a company)29( only)29( offers its services on-line, providing)]TJ
T*
[(information for ex)-11(ample, the domain name could possibly)29( be considered as a)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(tra)4(d)0(e)4(m)-2(a)4(r)3(k. The)4( doma)4(i)-2(n na)4(me)4( c)4(ould fulfill the)4( sa)4(me)4( func)4(tion a)4(s)-1( a)4( tra)4(d)0(e)4(m)-2(a)4(r)3(k.)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(The use of the domain name would be treated in the same way)29( as the use of)]TJ
T*
-0.003 Tc
0.003 Tw
[(a t)-5(r)0(adem)-5(ark.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 173.25 517.11 Tm
0.007 Tc
(104)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 185.49 511.59 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( I)23(f)3( this would be the case, a domain name could possibly)]TJ
-6 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(infring)9(e upon an already)29( ex)-11(isting)9( trademark, if the ty)29(pe of business is the)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(sa)5(me)5(, or if the)5( distinc)5(tive)5(n)1(e)5(ss of the)5( tra)5(d)1(e)5(m)-1(a)5(r)4(k is dilute)5(d by)31( the)5( use)5( of the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(domain name. Once the leg)9(a)3(l status of domain names is more certain around)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(the)4( g)10(l)-2(obe)4(, it will be)4( e)4(a)4(s)-1(ie)4(r to de)4(te)4(rmine)4( whe)4(t)-2(he)4(r doma)4(i)-2(n na)4(me)4(s infring)10(e)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(upon trademarks and vice versa. Some cases, such as the Roadrunner case)Tj
T*
[(described below, sug)9(g)9(e)3(st that trademarks and domain names can infring)9(e)]TJ
T*
(upon each other.)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 388.71 Tm
[(\031\021\024\027\003)-435('RPDLQ\003QDPH\003LQIULQJHPHQWV\003DQG\003GLVSXWHV)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 357.87 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Since domain names have g)10(r)3(own to become an important issue to most)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(companies today)29(,)-1( there have been many)29( disputes relating)9( to this issue. There)]TJ
T*
[(ex)-11(ist numerous disputes concerning)9( domain names and trademarks,)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(especi)-4(al)-4(l)-4(y)28( i)-4(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e U.S)-6(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 215.37 320.91 Tm
0.007 Tc
(105)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 227.61 315.39 Tm
-0.002 Tc
[( Many)28( of t)-4(h)-2(e cases rai)-4(s)-3(e ex)-12(t)-4(r)1(em)-4(el)-4(y)28( i)-4(n)-2(t)-4(e)2(rest)-4(i)-4(n)-2(g)]TJ
-9.51 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(questions relating)9( to the whole concept of domain names, but)]TJ
T*
[(\223unfortunately)29(\224 many)29( of the parties choose to settle their domain and)]TJ
T*
(trademark disputes outside the courtrooms in order to keep the costs and)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(publicity)30( down. I)23(t)-2( mig)10(ht be g)10(ood for the parties involved settling)10( quietly)30(, but)]TJ
T*
[(it does not help clarify)30(i)-2(ng)10( or improving)10( the reg)10(u)0(latory)30( evolution of)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(C)-5(y)28(berspace l)-4(a)2(w.)]TJ
0 -4.25 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 182.55 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 171.75 Tm
(104)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 167.19 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(1lWMXULGLN\003\261\003/DJ\003RFK\003UlWW\003Sn\003,QWHUQHW)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
14.8072 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, by)22( T)-12(h)10(om)23(as)7( C)8(a)2(rl)5(\351n)10(-)12(W)-4(en)10(del)5(s)7(, pag)10(e)]TJ
-16.0361 -1.1807 TD
0.006 Tc
(111.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 148.23 Tm
0 Tc
(105)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 143.67 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.076 Tw
[( )12(One )12(o)-7(f)7( )12(the )12(m)18(o)-7(st p)-7(u)5(b)-7(licized)-7( early)17( d)-7(i)0(sp)-7(utes w)22(a)-3(s b)-7(e)-3(tw)22(een J)-10(o)-7(sh Quittner and)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
0 Tc
0.172 Tw
[(McDo)-6(nald)-6(\222)8(s)3(. Quittner d)-6(i)1(sco)-6(v)6(ered)-6( that McDo)-6(nald)-6(\222)8(s)3( had)-6( no)-6(t registered)-6( )-12(their)]TJ
T*
0.003 Tc
0.024 Tw
[(tradem)22(ark)9( as a dom)22(ain)9( n)9(a)1(m)22(e)1(, an)9(d did so h)9(i)4(m)22(s)6(elf)11(.)0( A)14(t)4( f)11(i)4(rst McDon)9(a)1(ld\222)11(s)6( did n)9(o)-3(t)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
1.015 Tw
[(care. In ad)-6(d)-6(itio)-6(n to)-6( this, he registered)-6( )-12(an )-12(e-)8(m)19(a)-2(il )-12(ad)-6(d)-6(r)-4(ess)]TJ
T*
0.004 Tc
0.18 Tw
[(\223)14(r)0(on)10(al)5(d@)9(m)23(c)2(don)10(al)5(ds)7(.com)23(\224. He w)27(r)0(ot)5(e an)10( art)5(i)5(c)2(l)5(e)2( abou)10(t)5( h)10(i)5(s)7( en)10(deav)10(ors)7( )-12(on)10( )-12(h)10(i)5(s)]TJ
T*
0.047 Tw
[(s)7(i)5(t)5(e)2(. McDon)10(a)2(l)5(d)-2(\222)12(s)7( h)10(a)2(d t)5(o)-2( pay)22( $3,500 t)5(o)-2( a pu)10(bl)5(i)5(c)2( s)7(c)2(h)10(ool)5( s)7(o)-2( )-12(t)5(h)10(at)5( )-12(i)5(t)5( )-12(cou)10(l)5(d )-12(af)12(f)12(o)-2(rd)]TJ
T*
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[(com)22(p)-3(u)9(t)4(ers, in)9( order to receiv)9(e)1( th)9(e dom)22(ain)9( n)9(a)1(m)22(e)1(.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
358 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
359 0 obj
<<
/Length 5975
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(32)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 741.51 Tm
[(\031\021\024\030\003)-434(079\0031HWZ)-14(RUNV\003Y)21(\021)0(\003$GDP\003&XUU\\)]TJ
10.56 0 0 10.56 378.69 749.07 Tm
0.001 Tc
(\024\023\031)Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 739.83 30.84 -1.56 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 696.51 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(One of the early)29( disputes concerning)9( domain names and trademarks is )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
28.21 0 TD
-0.002 Tc
[(07)-8(9)]TJ
-28.21 -1.18 TD
-0.004 Tc
[(Y\021\003&)-11(XU)-8(U)-8(\\)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
3.33 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(. Adam Curry)29( served as a video disc jockey)29( \(VJ)-12(\))2( for MTV. During)]TJ
-3.33 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(his e)5(m)-1(ploy)31(me)5(nt time)5( a)5(s)0( a)5( VJ)-10( a)5(t)-1( MTV, he)5( org)11(a)5(nize)5(d a)5( we)5(bsite)5( with the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(domain name MTV \(www.mtv.com\). He reg)9(i)-3(stered the domain name in his)]TJ
T*
[(own name. I)22(n)-1( J)-12(une 1993 Curry)29( discussed the site with the MTV Vice)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(P)-6(r)1(esi)-4(d)-2(ent)-4( Mat)-4(t)-4(h)-2(ew Farber, who apparent)-4(l)-4(y)28( i)-4(ndi)-4(cat)-4(ed t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( C)-5(u)-2(rry)28( was free t)-4(o)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(continue the development of the I)22(n)-1(ternet website at his own ex)-11(pense. MTV)]TJ
T*
[(was not interested in any)29( joint venture at all, and did not object to the fact)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
[(that Curry)29( reg)9(i)-3(stered the domain name \223mtv.com\224. During)9( the same y)29(ear,)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Curry)30( left MTV, but Curry)30( continued to develop mtv.com at his own)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(ex)-11(pense another half y)29(ear until J)-12(a)3(nuary)29( 19, 1994, when MTV formally)]TJ
T*
[(requested that Curry)29( should cease using)9( the \223mtv.com\224 domain. At this)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(point in time, his website had been accessed by)30( millions of users worldwide.)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Since Curry)29( had reg)9(i)-3(stered the domain name personally)29(, MTV could not)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(c)5(ontrol the)5( site)5(.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(The dispute was moved to court as MTV sued Curry)29( for trademark)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(infring)9(ement and unfair competition. Curry)29( arg)9(u)-1(ed that MTV used Curry)29( to)]TJ
T*
[(\223test the waters\224 and if the development of the site was proving)9( to be)]TJ
T*
(successful, MTV planned to take over the site themselves. He claimed to be)Tj
T*
[(ex)-11(ploited. MTV, on the other hand, arg)9(u)-1(ed that Curry)29( used the reg)9(i)-3(stered)]TJ
T*
[(MTV trademark. I)22(t)-3( seems like MTV, back in 1993, failed to appreciate the)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(c)5(o)1(mme)5(rc)5(ia)5(l va)5(lue)5( a)5(nd pote)5(n)1(tia)5(l of a)5( music)5( we)5(bsite)5( a)5(nd the)5(r)4(e)5(f)4(ore)5( g)11(r)4(a)5(n)1(te)5(d a)5(l)-1(l)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(the rig)10(h)0(t to Curry)30(. The dispute was settled quietly)30( on March 24, 1995, and)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(MTV obtained the \223mtv.com\224 domain name.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 328.89 362.19 Tm
0.007 Tc
(107)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 318.75 Tm
0 Tc
[(\031\021\024\031\003)-434(5RDGUXQQHU\003Y)21(\021)0(\00316,)]TJ
ET
113.49 317.07 30.84 -1.56 re
f
BT
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 287.91 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(Thi)-4(s)-3( i)-4(s)-3( a case t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( m)-4(a)2(y)28( affect)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e way)28( dom)-4(ai)-4(n nam)-4(e)2(s are t)-4(o)-2( be reg)8(i)-4(st)-4(ered and)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(challeng)9(ed in the future. I)22(t)-3( therefore could be of importance to trademark)]TJ
T*
(and domain name holders in the U.S. and perhaps in other countries as well.)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(An I)23(SP in New Mex)-10(i)-2(co called Roadrunner Computer Sy)30(stems, I)23(n)0(c. \(RCS\))]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(with over 700 pay)29(i)-3(ng)9( subscribers provides computer hardware as well as)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
(technical support in order to allow individuals and small businesses to)Tj
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(access the I)22(n)-1(ternet. During)9( the spring)9( of 1994, RCS)-5( was g)9(r)2(anted the domain)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(name \223roadrunner.com\224 by)30( NSI)23(.)0( At this point in time, NSI)23( provided domain)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(na)5(me)5(s sole)5(ly)31( on a)5( first-c)5(o)1(me)5(, first se)5(rve)5(d)1( ba)5(sis. Shortly)31( a)5(f)4(te)5(r, in J)-10(u)1(ly)31( a)5(n)1(d)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(November of 1995, NSI)23( instituted new policies relating)10( to the reg)10(i)-2(stration of)]TJ
0 -2.34 TD
( )Tj
ET
113.49 135.51 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 124.71 Tm
(106)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 120.15 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(079\0031HWZRUNV\003Y\021\003&XUU\\)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
9.6145 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(, 867 F)7(.)2(S)7(u)11(pp. 1028 \(C)9(.D.C)9(al)6(.1994\))]TJ
-10.8434 -1.1807 TD
-0.023 Tc
[(H)-24(t)-22(t)-22(p)-29(:)-22(/)-22(/)-22(www.)-26(l)-22(a)-25(w.)-26(s)-20(e)-25(a)]TJ
7.9157 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(ttleu)10(.)1(edu)10(/)5(ch)10(on)10(m)23(/)5(C)8(a)2(s)7(e)2(s)7(/)5(m)23(t)5(v)10(.)1(h)10(t)5(m)23(l)5( \(971026\))]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 101.19 Tm
0 Tc
(107)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 96.63 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(7UDGHPDUNV\003$ORQJ\003WKH\003,QIREDKQ\035\003$\003\)LUVW\003ORRN\003DW\003WKH\003\(PHUJLQJ\003/DZ\003RI)Tj
-1.2289 -1.1807 TD
(&\\EHUPDUNV)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
4.8916 0 TD
0.003 Tc
[(, by)21( Dan)9( L)12(.)0( B)-5(u)9(rk)9(, A)14(p)-3(ril 10, 1995. Http://)]TJ
16.3012 0 TD
-0.023 Tc
[(www.)-26(n)-17(l)-22(v)-17(-)]TJ
-21.1928 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(bn)11(c.ca/)6(i)6(f)13(l)6(a)3(/)6(docu)11(m)24(en)11(t)6(s)8(/)6(i)6(n)11(f)13(opool)6(/)6(c)3(opy)23(ri)6(g)11(h)11(t)6(/)6(b)-1(u)11(r)1(d1.h)11(t)6(m)24( \(970725\))]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
360 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
361 0 obj
<<
/Length 5473
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(33)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(domain names. These policies included new rules under which a party)Tj
0 -1.18 TD
[(holding)9( a reg)9(i)-3(stered trademark in any)29( country)29( could lodg)9(e a challeng)9(e)]TJ
T*
[(ag)9(ainst an ex)-11(isting)9( domain name reg)9(i)-3(stration. The trademark should be)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(ide)5(n)1(tic)5(a)5(l)-1( to the)5( doma)5(i)-1(n na)5(me)5( in orde)5(r to c)5(h)1(a)5(lle)5(ng)11(e)5( it.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(The owner of the reg)9(i)-3(stered trademark, W)-7(a)3(rner B)6(r)2(others, challeng)9(ed the)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(a)4(w)2(a)4(r)3(d of the)4( doma)4(i)-2(n na)4(me)4( to RCS c)4(l)-2(a)4(iming)10( tha)4(t)-2( it ha)4(d a)4( fe)4(de)4(ra)4(l tra)4(d)0(e)4(m)-2(a)4(r)3(k)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(reg)9(i)-3(stration for the mark \223Roadrunner\224. RCS arg)9(u)-1(ed that it had been using)]TJ
T*
[(the domain name for over a y)29(ear before W)-7(a)3(rner B)6(r)2(others was g)9(r)2(anted the)]TJ
T*
[(trademark reg)9(i)-3(stration. I)22(n)-1( its communications with NSI)22(,)-1( W)-7(a)3(rner B)6(r)2(others)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(did not alleg)10(e)4( any)30( wrong)10(doing)10( on the part of RCS.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(NSI)22( decided to apply)29( the new domain name policy)29( to all domain names)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(including)9( those which, like \223roadrunner.com\224, were reg)9(i)-3(stered prior to the)]TJ
T*
[(new policy)29(.)-1( As a result of the W)-7(a)3(rner B)6(r)2(others challeng)9(e, NSI)22( required RCS)]TJ
T*
[(to present a trademark reg)9(i)-3(stration for the mark \223Roadrunner\224 within thirty)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(day)30(s)-1(. I)23(n)0( December 1995, J)-11(a)4(ne M. Hill, president of RCS responded to NSI)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(st)-4(at)-4(i)-4(n)-2(g)8( t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e words were not)-4( i)-4(d)-2(ent)-4(i)-4(cal)-4(. The W)-8(a)2(rner Brot)-4(hers t)-4(r)1(adem)-4(ark)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(\223Road runner\224 consisted of two words, not one word as in the case of RCS\222s)Tj
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(doma)5(i)-1(n na)5(me)5(. Ms Hill a)5(l)-1(so sta)5(t)-1(e)5(d)1( tha)5(t)-1( the)5( two na)5(me)5(s we)5(re)5( use)5(d)1( in tota)5(lly)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(different businesses, and therefore could co-ex)-11(i)-3(st. W)-7(a)3(rner B)6(r)2(others used the)]TJ
T*
[(t)-3(r)2(adem)-3(ark i)-3(n)-1( connect)-3(i)-3(on wi)-3(t)-3(h)-1( t)-3(o)-1(y)29(s)-2( such as dol)-3(l)-3(s)-2(, Hal)-3(l)-3(o)-1(ween cost)-3(um)-3(es and)]TJ
T*
[(masks. RCS)-5( provided I)22(n)-1(ternet access services, as ex)-11(plained above. I)22(f)2( the)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
(domain name would be put \223on hold\224, all the subscribers would be without)Tj
T*
[(e-mail and other services. B)7(a)4(sically)30(, RCS would be without business. NSI)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(replied that such circumstances were totally)29( irrelevant under the new NSI)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
[(polic)5(y)31(.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(The options for RCS was either to g)9(i)-3(ve up the domain name to W)-7(a)3(rner)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(B)7(r)3(othe)4(rs, pre)4(s)-1(e)4(n)0(t a)4( tra)4(d)0(e)4(m)-2(a)4(r)3(k re)4(g)10(i)-2(stra)4(tion doc)4(ume)4(n)0(t to NSI)23( within thirty)]TJ
T*
[(day)30(s)-1(, or have the domain placed ")8(on hold,")8( to be used by)30( no one, until the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(dispute between the RCS and W)-7(a)3(rner B)6(r)2(others was resolved by)29( ag)9(reement,)]TJ
T*
[(court order or arbitration. RCS obtained several ex)-11(tensions of time from)]TJ
T*
[(Warner B)6(r)2(others and NSI)22(.)-1( During)9( the ex)-11(tended time \(in March 1996\) RCS)]TJ
T*
[(manag)9(e)3(d to obtain a Tunisian trademark reg)9(i)-3(stration for \223roadrunner.com\224.)]TJ
T*
[(I)22(n)-1( Tunisia, trademark reg)9(i)-3(strations are g)9(r)2(anted quickly)29(, often within one or)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(two day)30(s)-1(. Even thoug)10(h the reg)10(i)-2(stration document was sent to NSI)23( within the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(ex)-11(tended time period, NSI)22( refused to accept it, due to the fact that it was not)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(provi)-4(ded t)-4(o)-2( NS)-6(I)21( wi)-4(t)-4(h)-2(i)-4(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e ori)-4(g)8(i)-4(n)-2(al)-4( t)-4(h)-2(i)-4(r)1(t)-4(y)28( day)28(s)-3( aft)-4(e)2(r recei)-4(vi)-4(ng)8( t)-4(h)-2(e fi)-4(rst)-4( not)-4(i)-4(c)2(e)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(from NSI)22(,)-1( as the new NSI)22( policy)29( required.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 170.91 Tm
-0.003 Tc
(\031\021\024\031\021\024)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.5128 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(+RVWLOH\003WDNHRYHUV\003RI\003GRPDLQ\003QDPHV)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 142.47 Tm
0 Tc
[(This c)4(a)4(s)-1(e)4( ra)4(ise)4(s)-1( se)4(ve)4(ra)4(l inte)4(re)4(sting)10( que)4(stions. Ac)4(c)4(o)0(rding)10( to the)4( NSI)23( polic)4(y)30(,)0( a)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(person \(A\) who finds a valuable reg)9(i)-3(stered \(with the old policy)29(\))2( domain)]TJ
T*
[(name used by)29( someone else \(B)6(\) on the net, could basically)29( reg)9(i)-3(ster the same)]TJ
T*
[(word as a trademark. A could then challeng)9(e NSI)22(.)-1( I)22(f)2( B)6( does not have enoug)9(h)]TJ
T*
[(money)29( to obtain a foreig)9(n trademark or have a court decide it, the domain)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
362 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
363 0 obj
<<
/Length 5136
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(34)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(na)5(me)5( will be)5( put on hold, a)5(nd e)5(v)1(e)5(n)1(tua)5(lly)31( A ma)5(y)31( be)5( a)5(b)1(le)5( se)5(ize)5( the)5( doma)5(i)-1(n)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(name. Reg)9(i)-3(stering)9( the word used in the domain name as a trademark before)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(a)5(n)1(y)31(one)5( e)5(l)-1(se)5( doe)5(s it, c)5(ould sa)5(ve)5( time)5( a)5(nd mone)5(y)31(.)1( I)24(t)-1( is inte)5(re)5(sting)11( tha)5(t)-1( NSI)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(did not consider the fact that the two names were used in completely)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(different kinds of businesses. A case like this sug)10(g)10(e)4(sts that domain names)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(and trademarks could infring)9(e upon each other. This does not support the)]TJ
T*
[(idea that domain names would merely)29( be like street addresses.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
[(Unfortunately)29( for the leg)9(a)3(l development, the case was dismissed by)29( the court)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(on J)-12(une 21, 1996. The court held that the orig)9(inal dispute no long)9(er ex)-11(isted)]TJ
T*
[(between the parties since W)-7(a)3(rner B)6(r)2(others ag)9(reed to obtain another domain)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
(name, \223Road_Runner.com\224.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 249.21 595.23 Tm
0.007 Tc
(108)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 565.95 Tm
0 Tc
[(\031\021\024\032\003)-434(6XPPDU\\)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 535.11 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(The SL)20(D of domain names is a very)29( controversial issue, since only)29( one)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(re)4(g)10(i)-2(stra)4(tion of a)4( na)4(me)4( is possible)4( tog)10(e)4(the)4(r)3( with the)4( sa)4(me)4( TL)21(D. B)7(a)4(sic)4(a)4(lly)30(,)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(there can ex)-11(ist an unlimited number of different SL)20(Ds in each TL)20(D, but)]TJ
T*
[(there can only)29( ex)-11(ist one specific S)-5(L)20(D in each TL)20(D. Most companies around)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(h)-2(e worl)-4(d crave t)-4(o)-2( have t)-4(h)-2(ei)-4(r t)-4(r)1(adem)-4(arks reg)8(i)-4(st)-4(ered as dom)-4(ai)-4(n nam)-4(e)2(s, but)-4( are)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(often hindered by)29( Cy)29(bersquatters or other companies that already)29( reg)9(i)-3(stered)]TJ
T*
[(the desired SL)20(D. I)22( succumb to the opinion of W)-7(I)22(PO, that the creation of a)]TJ
T*
[(universal domain directory)29( service could make domain names which are)]TJ
T*
[(\223easy)29( t)-3(o)-1( rem)-3(e)3(m)-3(b)-1(er\224 l)-3(e)3(ss at)-3(t)-3(r)2(act)-3(i)-3(v)-1(e. C)-4(o)-1(m)-3(p)-1(ani)-3(e)3(s coul)-3(d use S)-5(L)20(Ds t)-3(h)-1(at)-3( do not)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(necessari)-4(l)-4(y)28( refl)-4(ect)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e com)-4(p)-2(ani)-4(e)2(s\222 t)-4(r)1(adem)-4(arks, si)-4(nce t)-4(h)-2(e di)-4(rect)-4(ory)28( woul)-4(d l)-4(ead)]TJ
T*
[(any)28(one t)-4(o)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e ri)-4(g)8(h)-2(t)-4( address any)28(w)0(ay)28(. I)21(f)1( a com)-4(p)-2(any)28( fi)-4(nds t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( a cy)28(bersquat)-4(t)-4(e)2(r)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(reg)9(i)-3(stered its\222 trademark as a domain name, it may)29( be a g)9(ood idea to fig)9(h)-1(t a)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(le)4(g)10(a)4(l ba)4(ttle)4( in orde)4(r to \223)4(r)3(e)4(t)-2(rie)4(v)0(e)4(\224)4( it. I)23(f)3( not foug)10(ht, a)4( c)4(y)30(be)4(rsqua)4(tte)4(r c)4(ould)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(make the name well known in connection with the cy)29(bersquatter\222s business.)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(The)4(r)3(e)4( is a)4( risk tha)4(t)-2( the)4( c)4(y)30(be)4(rsqua)4(tte)4(r will be)4( a)4(llowe)4(d to use)4( the)4( na)4(me)4( in the)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(fut)-4(u)-2(re and t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e nam)-4(e)2( becom)-4(e)2(s di)-4(l)-4(u)-2(t)-4(e)2(d. There are cases as wel)-4(l)-4( as fact)-4(s)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(sug)9(g)9(e)3(sting)9( that trademarks and domain names are very)29( alike, and could)]TJ
T*
[(infring)9(e upon each other. I)22( do believe that this is the case, but is not)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(a)5(b)1(solute)5(ly)31( c)5(e)5(r)4(ta)5(in y)31(e)5(t. Howe)5(ve)5(r, I)24( a)5(m)-1( c)5(e)5(r)4(ta)5(in tha)5(t)-1( e)5(ithe)5(r)4( la)5(ws or c)5(a)5(s)0(e)5(s)0( will)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(clarify)29( the situation concerning)9( trademarks and domain names within a near)]TJ
T*
(future.)Tj
0 -11.92 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 111.99 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 101.19 Tm
(108)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 96.63 Tm
0.003 Tw
[( INT)-16(A)11( \(Internatio)-6(nal T)-16(r)-4(ad)-6(em)19(ark A)11(sso)-6(ciatio)-6(n\)\223)10(W)-8(hite P)-10(a)-2(p)-6(e)-2(r\224 -)8( )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
25.0121 0 TD
(7KH)Tj
-25.988 -1.1807 TD
(,QWHUVHFWLRQ\003RI\0037UDGHPDUNV\003DQG\003'RPDLQ\0031DPHV)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
19.1687 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, F)6(e)2(b 5, 1997, Vers)7(i)5(o)-2(n)10( 1.0.)]TJ
-19.1687 -1.1807 TD
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(pag)8(e)0( 12. Http://plaz.in)8(terport.n)8(e)0(t/in)8(t/w)25(pw)25(h)8(o)-4(le.h)8(tm)21( \(971121\))]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
364 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
365 0 obj
<<
/Length 5977
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(35)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
24 0 0 24 113.49 733.71 Tm
[(\032\003)-310(,QWHOOHFWXDO\0033URSHUW\\\003SLUDF\\\003LQ)]TJ
0 -1.175 TD
(&\\EHUVSDFH)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 650.91 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Since the day)29( information became dig)9(itiz)-7(ed, the possibilities of reproducing)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(such material have underg)9(one a sensational improvement. Because)]TJ
T*
[(every)29(t)-3(hing)9( posted in Cy)29(berspace is dig)9(itiz)-7(ed, virtually)29( every)29(t)-3(hing)9( can)]TJ
T*
[(technically)29( be ex)-11(actly)29( reproduced without any)29( loss of quality)29( or data. This of)]TJ
T*
[(course, has lead not only)29( to enhanced lawful reproduction, but also illeg)9(a)3(l)]TJ
T*
[(copy)29(ing)9( of protected material. Suppose a computer prog)9(ram which costs)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(millions of dollars to develop is publicly)30( released Monday)30(.)0( A website owner)]TJ
T*
[(obtains it, copies it to his website or B)7(B)7(S)-4(, and later the same week, the)]TJ
T*
[(prog)10(ra)4(m is not worth more)4( tha)4(n)0( a)4( fre)4(e)4(w)2(a)4(r)3(e)4(.)0( Nume)4(rous use)4(r)3(s will c)4(opy)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(\(download\) the posted software from the web, instead of buy)29(ing)9( it.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 433.17 528.99 Tm
0.007 Tc
(109)Tj
12 0 0 12 445.41 523.47 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
( Even)Tj
-27.66 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(if the website owner does not post the reg)9(i)-3(stration number needed in order to)]TJ
T*
[(run the prog)9(ram, it is not a problem for the downloaders. Most)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(seri)-4(al)-4(num)-4(bers needed i)-4(n)-2( order t)-4(o)-2( st)-4(art)-4( a prog)8(ram)-4( are pl)-4(aced at)-4( vari)-4(ous si)-4(t)-4(e)2(s)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(i)-3(n)-1( C)-4(y)29(berspace. Any)29(one i)-3(n)-1( need of a reg)9(i)-3(st)-3(rat)-3(i)-3(on num)-3(ber i)-3(n)-1( order t)-3(o)-1( st)-3(art)-3( up a)]TJ
T*
[(pirate copy)29( of a prog)9(ram can find lists containing)9( thousands of numbers.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 460.41 458.19 Tm
0.007 Tc
(110)Tj
12 0 0 12 113.49 438.51 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(Once posted, any)29( material may)29( be reproduced and spread throug)9(hout the)]TJ
T*
[(I)22(n)-1(ternet community)29(, lawfully)29( or not. The incentive to develop new products)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(will c)5(e)5(r)4(ta)5(inly)31( de)5(c)5(r)4(e)5(a)5(s)0(e)5( if we)5(b-pira)5(c)5(y)31( is tota)5(lly)31( unc)5(ontrolle)5(d. I)24(f)4( the)5(r)4(e)5( doe)5(s not)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(ex)-11(ist any)29( proper protection for material posted on the web, companies may)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(due to the risk of being)10( ex)-10(ploited, choose not to post any)30( such material out)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(there, and such a move could slow down and possibly)29( harm the development)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(of t)-4(h)-2(e el)-4(ect)-4(roni)-4(c com)-4(m)-4(e)2(rce. S)-6(i)-4(nce i)-4(t)-4( i)-4(s)-3( t)-4(echni)-4(cal)-4(l)-4(y)28( possi)-4(bl)-4(e t)-4(o)-2( copy)28( al)-4(m)-4(o)-2(st)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(a)5(n)1(y)31( dig)11(itize)5(d)1( ma)5(te)5(ria)5(l)-1(, it is of hig)11(h)1(e)5(s)0(t importa)5(nc)5(e)5( tha)5(t)-1( the)5( la)5(ws prote)5(c)5(ting)]TJ
T*
-0.003 Tc
0.003 Tw
[(i)-5(n)-3(form)-5(at)-5(i)-5(on are effect)-5(i)-5(v)-3(e and enforceabl)-5(e)1(.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 301.47 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(\032\021\024\003)-436(5)-1(HVSRQVLELOLW\\)10(\003)1(IRU\003SRVWLQJ\017\003VWRULQJ\003DQG)]TJ
T*
[(GRZ)-15(QORDGLQJ\003SURWHFWHG\003PDWHULDO)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 251.79 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(W)-6(ho should be responsible for what in Cy)30(berspace?)-16( I)23(t)-2( is obvious that the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(process of spreading)9( material in Cy)29(berspace involves several different steps.)]TJ
T*
[(F)5(i)-3(rstly)29(, there may)29( be a person or company)29( copy)29(ing)9( protected material from)]TJ
T*
[(the orig)9(inal source \(for ex)-11(ample a CD-ROM\) without any)29( contact with)]TJ
T*
[(Cy)29(berspace \(at this stag)9(e\). S)-5(econdly)29(,)-1( there may)29( be a person or company)]TJ
T*
[(\(possibly)29( the same person or company)29( that created the copy)29( from the)]TJ
0 -2.09 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 159.03 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 148.23 Tm
(109)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 143.67 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
('HSXWL]LQJ\003WKH\003,63V\003\261\003,QWHUQHW\0036HUYLFH\0033URYLGHUV\003VKRXOG\003WDNH)Tj
-1.2289 -1.1807 TD
(UHVSRQVLELOLW\\\003IRU\003SROLFLQJ\003FRS\\ULJKW\003LQIULQJHPHQW\003LQ\003&\\EHUVSDFH)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
25.9518 0 TD
0.001 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(, b)-5(y)19( W)-7(illiam)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
-25.9518 -1.1807 TD
-0.021 Tc
0.024 Tw
[(J)-30(.)-24( C)-17(o)-27(o)-27(k)-15(.)-24( I)-25(n)-15(t)-20(e)-23(l)-20(l)-20(e)-23(c)-23(t)-20(u)-15(a)-23(l)-20( P)-31(r)-25(o)-27(p)-27(e)-23(r)-25(t)-20(y M)-24(a)-23(g)-15(a)-23(z)-23(i)-20(n)-15(e)-23(,)-24( s)-18(p)-27(r)-25(i)-20(n)-15(g)-15( \222)-13(9)-27(6)-27(.)-24( H)-22(t)-20(t)-20(p)-27(:)-20(/)-20(/)-20(www.)-24(i)-20(p)-27(ma)-23(g)-15(.)-24(c)-23(o)-27(m)]TJ
T*
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(/)6(acook)11(.h)11(t)6(m)24( \(970716\))]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 101.19 Tm
0 Tc
(110)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 96.63 Tm
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( Serialn)8(u)8(m)21(bers to sh)8(arew)25(are prog)8(ram)21(s)5( are also w)25(i)3(dely)20( spread in)8( th)8(e)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
[(In)8(tern)8(et com)21(m)21(u)8(n)8(ity)20(. If)10( on)8(e search)8(es f)10(o)-4(r \223)12(s)5(erials\224 in)8( an)8(y)20( search)8( en)8(g)8(i)3(n)8(e)0(, on)8(e)]TJ
T*
-0.003 Tc
0.006 Tw
[(w)20(ill find)-9( huge)-5( lists o)-9(f)5( num)16(b)-9(e)-5(r)-7(s)0( to)-9( b)-9(o)-9(t)-2(h sha)-5(r)-7(e)-5(w)20(a)-5(r)-7(e)-5( a)-5(n)3(d)-9( c)-5(o)-9(m)16(p)-9(le)-5(te)-5( p)-9(r)-7(o)-9(g)3(r)-7(a)-5(m)16(s)0(.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
366 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
368 0 obj
<<
/Length 7823
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(36)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
-14.85 58.94 TD
0 Tw
[(orig)10(inal source\) posting)10( material to his or someone else\222s website or B)7(u)0(lletin)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(Board S)-6(y)28(st)-4(em)-4( \(BBS)-6(\), whi)-4(c)2(h i)-4(s)-3( a phy)28(si)-4(cal)-4( pl)-4(ace of st)-4(orag)8(e on a server)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(somewhere on the g)9(l)-3(obe. Thirdly)29(,)-1( there usually)29( is a person or company)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(\(ofte)4(n)0( the)4( I)23(SP\) owning)10( a)4(nd c)4(ontrolling)10( the)4( se)4(rve)4(r)3( whe)4(r)3(e)4( the)4( ma)4(te)4(ria)4(l)-2( is)]TJ
T*
[(phy)30(sically)30( stored. The I)23(SP may)30( consent to uploading)10( and downloading)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(protected material. F)5(ourthly)29(, there may)29( be a person or company)29( that, after)]TJ
T*
[(finding)9( the material located on the server, downloads it into a personal)]TJ
T*
[(harddrive. F)5(i)-3(nally)29(, once the material is downloaded, it can be reproduced an)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(infinite number of times, with or without the aid of I)23(n)0(ternet. This scenario is)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(an every)28(d)-2(ay)28( m)-4(a)2(t)-4(t)-4(e)2(r al)-4(l)-4( over t)-4(h)-2(e I)21(n)-2(t)-4(e)2(rnet)-4( com)-4(m)-4(uni)-4(t)-4(y)28(. Are al)-4(l)-4( t)-4(h)-2(ese act)-4(i)-4(ons)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(considered illeg)10(a)4(l?)-16( Can all these actions lead to responsibility)30(?)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 580.11 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(\032\021\025\003)-436(7)-1(KH\003ILUVW\003FRS\\)10(\003PDGH\003IURP\003WKH\003RULJLQDO)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
[(VRXUFH\003RXWVLGH\003&\\)11(E)0(HUVSDFH)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 530.43 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(W)-7(h)-1(en a person makes a copy)29( to the harddrive from the orig)9(inal source \(such)]TJ
T*
[(as software from a CD-ROM, a song)9( from a CD, or equivalent\) it is not)]TJ
T*
[(considered an I)22(n)-1(ternet issue since it does not involve I)22(n)-1(ternet at all. I)22(t)-3( would)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(most like)5(l)-1(y)31( be)5( c)5(onside)5(r)4(e)5(d)1( a)5(s)0( a)5( tra)5(d)1(itiona)5(l c)5(opy)31(rig)11(h)1(t infring)11(e)5(m)-1(e)5(n)1(t, or)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(equivalent, depending)9( on what material and amount that was reproduced.)]TJ
T*
[(One must not forg)9(et that under certain circumstances, it may)29( be leg)9(a)3(l to)]TJ
T*
[(perform a backup copy)29( for personal private use.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 342.45 450.99 Tm
0.007 Tc
(111)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 354.69 445.47 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[( \(I)22(n the U.S. such actions)]TJ
-20.1 -1.18 TD
[(may)29( be leg)9(a)3(l this is considered to constitute fair use according)9( to the fair use)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
[(doc)4(trine)4(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 155.73 422.67 Tm
0.007 Tc
(112)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 167.97 417.15 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(\) Only)30( the)4( c)4(l)-2(ose)4(s)-1(t frie)4(nds a)4(nd re)4(la)4(tive)4(s)-1( ma)4(y)30( use)4( the)4( c)4(opy)30(, if it is)]TJ
-4.54 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(to be classified as a personal copy)29(. I)22(f)2( that is the case, no crime has occurred)]TJ
T*
[(at this stag)9(e. Since not all kinds of material may)29( be copied for private use,)]TJ
T*
[(one must be careful. I)22( have chosen to further ex)-11(amine the leg)9(a)3(l situation)]TJ
T*
[(concerning)9( software, music and pictures.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 338.19 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\032\021\025\021\024)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(&RS\\LQJ\003VRIWZDUH\003RII\020OLQH)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 309.75 Tm
0 Tc
[(I)23(t)-2( is not leg)10(a)4(l to make a personal copy)30(,)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 298.17 315.27 Tm
0.007 Tc
(113)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 310.41 309.75 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( other than a backup copy)29(, intended)]TJ
-16.41 -1.18 TD
[(for complementary)29( use in case the orig)9(inal copy)29( is destroy)29(e)3(d, or if needed)]TJ
T*
[(for running)9( the prog)9(ram properly)29(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 274.89 286.95 Tm
0.007 Tc
(114)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 287.13 281.43 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( I)24(t)-1( is a)5(n)1( inte)5(re)5(sting)11( fa)5(c)5(t)-1( tha)5(t)-1(, it is ille)5(g)11(a)5(l)]TJ
-14.47 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(to make a personal copy)29( of software in Sweden, while since 1994 there do)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(not e)4(x)-10(ist a)4(n)0(y)30( le)4(g)10(a)4(l re)4(pe)4(rc)4(ussions re)4(la)4(ting)10( to suc)4(h)0( a)4(n)0( a)4(c)4(t)-2(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 379.89 258.63 Tm
0.007 Tc
(115)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 392.13 253.11 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[( S)-6(w)0(eden adapt)-4(e)2(d)]TJ
-23.22 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(to the)5( )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
2.5 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(&)-12(RXQFL)-8(O)-8(\003'L)-8(U)-9(HFW)-8(L)-8(YH\003RI)-8(\0030D\\\003\024\034\034\024\003RQ\003W)-8(KH\003O)-8(HJDO)-8(\003SU)-9(R)1(W)-8(HFW)-8(L)-8(RQ\003RI)-8(\003FRPSXW)-8(HU)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
-2.5 -2.02 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 217.83 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 207.03 Tm
(111)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 202.47 Tm
0.003 Tc
[( L)12(a)1(g)9( \(1960:729\) om)22( u)9(pph)9(ov)9(s)6(r)-1(\344tt till litter\344ra v)9(e)1(rk)9( och)9( k)9(o)-3(n)9(s)6(tn)9(\344rlig)9(a v)9(e)1(rk)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(\24712:)5(1. T)-12(h)10(e ri)5(g)10(h)10(t)5( t)5(o)-2( m)23(a)2(k)10(e)2( a pers)7(on)10(al)5( copy)22( can)10(n)10(o)-2(t)5( be l)5(i)5(m)23(i)5(t)5(e)2(d by)22( a n)10(o)-2(t)5(e)2( at)5(t)5(ach)10(ed)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0.003 Tw
[(to)-6( the m)19(a)-2(terial, say)18(i)1(ng it is f)8(o)-6(rb)-6(id)-6(d)-6(e)-2(n to)-6( m)19(a)-2(ke a p)-6(e)-2(rso)-6(n)6(al co)-6(p)-6(y)18(. It is, ho)-6(w)23(e)-2(ver,)]TJ
T*
[(p)-6(o)-6(ssib)-6(l)1(e to)-6( lim)19(it this right b)-6(y)18( a m)19(u)6(tual agreem)19(ent. )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
20.1084 0 TD
(/lURERN\003,\003,PPDWHULDOUlWW)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
10.1566 0 TD
0 Tw
(,)Tj
-30.2651 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(by)23( Kok)11(t)6(v)11(e)3(dg)11(aard an)11(d L)14(e)3(v)11(i)6(n)11(,)2( pag)11(e)3( 152.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 148.23 Tm
0 Tc
(112)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 143.67 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(3UDNWLVN\003,7\020UlWW)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
6.2651 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, by)22( A)15(g)10(n)10(e)2( L)13(i)5(n)10(dberg)10( an)10(d Dan)10(i)5(el)5( Wes)7(t)5(m)23(a)2(n)10(,)1( pag)10(e)2( 91.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 136.47 Tm
0 Tc
(113)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 131.91 Tm
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[( L)12(a)1(g)9( \(1960:729\) om)22( u)9(pph)9(ov)9(s)6(r)-1(\344tt till litter\344ra v)9(e)1(rk)9( och)9( k)9(o)-3(n)9(s)6(tn)9(\344rlig)9(a v)9(e)1(rk)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
0.006 Tc
[(\24712:)7(2.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 112.95 Tm
0 Tc
(114)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 108.39 Tm
0.003 Tc
[( L)12(a)1(g)9( \(1960:729\) om)22( u)9(pph)9(ov)9(s)6(r)-1(\344tt till litter\344ra v)9(e)1(rk)9( och)9( k)9(o)-3(n)9(s)6(tn)9(\344rlig)9(a v)9(e)1(rk)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(\24726g)11( an)11(d \24726h)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
5.9759 0 TD
0 Tc
(\021\0031lWMXULGLN\003\261\003/DJ\003RFK\003UlWW\003Sn\003,QWHUQHW)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
15.3132 0 TD
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(, by)20( C)6(a)0(rl\351n)8(-)10(W)-6(en)8(dels,)]TJ
-21.2892 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(pag)11(e)3( 76.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 77.67 Tm
0 Tc
(115)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 73.11 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(3UDNWLVN\003,7\020UlWW)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
6.2651 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, by)22( A)15(g)10(n)10(e)2( L)13(i)5(n)10(dberg)10( an)10(d Dan)10(i)5(el)5( Wes)7(t)5(m)23(a)2(n)10(,)1( pag)10(e)2( 91)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
369 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
370 0 obj
<<
/Length 8656
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(37)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(SU)-9(RJU)-9(DPV)-9(\003)-2(\013)-5(\034\024\022)-5(\025\030\023\022)-5(\(\(&)-12(\014\021)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 233.25 750.99 Tm
0.007 Tc
(116)Tj
12 0 0 12 245.49 745.47 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
( Article 7.1 states that appropriate remedies in)Tj
-11 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(accordance wi)-4(t)-4(h)-2( nat)-4(i)-4(onal)-4( l)-4(e)2(g)8(i)-4(sl)-4(at)-4(i)-4(on shal)-4(l)-4( be provi)-4(ded by)28( t)-4(h)-2(e Mem)-4(b)-2(er)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(States. Sweden interpreted the directive as not requiring)9( penaliz)-7(ation when)]TJ
T*
[(copy)29(ing)9( software for private use.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 270.93 708.51 Tm
0.007 Tc
(117)Tj
12 0 0 12 283.17 702.99 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[( Therefore, S)-6(w)0(eden deci)-4(ded t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( copy)28(i)-4(n)-2(g)]TJ
-14.14 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(for priva)4(t)-2(e)4( use)4( is forbidde)4(n a)4(nd c)4(onside)4(r)3(e)4(d)0( ille)4(g)10(a)4(l c)4(opy)30(rig)10(h)0(t infring)10(e)4(m)-2(e)4(n)0(t,)]TJ
T*
(but without punishment.)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 230.61 680.19 Tm
0.007 Tc
(118)Tj
12 0 0 12 242.85 674.67 Tm
0 Tc
( This is, however, not the case in all situations.)Tj
-10.78 -1.18 TD
(There will be punishment, if the software is used in a business or public)Tj
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(activity)29(. The copy)29( may)29( not be used bey)29(ond the scope of private use.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 437.49 651.87 Tm
0.007 Tc
(119)Tj
12 0 0 12 449.73 646.35 Tm
-0.001 Tc
( One)Tj
-28.02 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(should keep in mind that other sanctions, such as penalty)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 386.25 637.71 Tm
0.007 Tc
(120)Tj
12 0 0 12 398.49 632.19 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
( of a fine or)Tj
-23.75 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
[(damag)8(e)2(s)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 155.25 623.55 Tm
0.007 Tc
(121)Tj
12 0 0 12 167.49 618.03 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[( may)29( be appropriate.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 265.53 623.55 Tm
0.007 Tc
(122)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 595.71 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\032\021\025\021\025)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(&RS\\LQJ\003PXVLF\003RII\020OLQH)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 567.27 Tm
0.001 Tw
[(A very)29( common feature of Cy)29(berspace is the supply)29( of various music files.)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(I)22(m)-3(ag)9(ine a person buy)29(ing)9( a record and copies the music into his personal)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(c)4(o)0(mpute)4(r)3( or ma)4(ke)4(s a)4( pe)4(rfe)4(c)4(t)-2( dig)10(itize)4(d)0( c)4(opy)30( with a)4( CD-write)4(r. Sinc)4(e)4( this c)4(a)4(n)]TJ
T*
[(be)4( ma)4(de)4( a)4(n)0( infinite)4( numbe)4(r of time)4(s, c)4(opy)30(ing)10( for priva)4(t)-2(e)4( use)4( is g)10(i)-2(ve)4(n a)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(completely)29( new dimension. Currently)29(, copy)29(ing)9( music for private use is)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(a)5(llowe)5(d in the)5( ma)5(jority)31( of the)5( EC Me)5(mbe)5(r)4( Sta)5(t)-1(e)5(s)0(.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 351.93 501.99 Tm
0.007 Tc
(123)Tj
12 0 0 12 364.17 496.47 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[( The m)-4(a)2(j)-4(o)-2(r reason for)]TJ
-20.89 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(this ex)-11(ception from the ex)-11(clusive rig)9(h)-1(t of reproduction is that the)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Community)30( does not wish to invade the privacy)30( of individuals. The)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(reproduction must be made for private use and for non-commercial ends.)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
T*
[(The term \223private use\224 must be understood in a narrow sense, according)9( to)]TJ
T*
[(the proposal. Eleven out of fifteen Member States compensate rig)9(h)-1(tholders)]TJ
T*
[(for eliminating)9( their ex)-11(clusive rig)9(h)-1(t with a rig)9(h)-1(t to remuneration. I)22(t)-3( works as)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(a)5( le)5(vy)31( sy)31(ste)5(m)-1( whe)5(n)1( se)5(lling)11( a)5(udiota)5(p)1(e)5(s)0(. The)5( mone)5(y)31( c)5(o)1(lle)5(c)5(t)-1(e)5(d)1( from the)5( le)5(vie)5(s)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(g)9(o)-1(es to the rig)9(h)-1(tholders. F)5(o)-1(r instance, 120 million ECU were collected in)]TJ
T*
[(F)5(r)2(ance in 1995, as remuneration for private copy)29(ing)9(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 365.37 374.55 Tm
0.007 Tc
(124)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 377.61 369.03 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( I)24(n)1(te)5(re)5(sting)11( is tha)5(t)]TJ
-22.01 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(only)29( one Member State \(Denmark\) makes a distinction between analog)9(ue)]TJ
T*
[(and dig)9(ital technolog)9(y)29( concerning)9( private copy)29(ing)9(.)-1( Denmark, thus, does not)]TJ
T*
[(provide a private copy)29( ex)-11(emption reg)9(a)3(rding)9( material incorporated in dig)9(ital)]TJ
T*
[(media. I)22(n)-1( Sweden, music is protected by)29( law,)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 330.57 317.91 Tm
0.007 Tc
(125)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 342.81 312.39 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( a)5(nd it is c)5(onside)5(r)4(e)5(d)1( le)5(g)11(a)5(l to)]TJ
-19.11 -1.28 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 300.15 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 289.35 Tm
(116)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 284.79 Tm
-0.022 Tc
0.025 Tw
[( H)-23(t)-21(t)-21(p)-28(:)-21(/)-21(/)-21(www2)-28(.)-25(e)-24(c)-24(h)-16(o)-28(.)-25(l)-21(u)-16(.)-25(/)-21(l)-21(e)-24(g)-16(a)-24(l)-21(/)-21(e)-24(n)-16(/)-21(i)-21(p)-28(r)-26(/)-21(s)-19(o)-28(f)-14(t)-21(wa)-24(r)-26(e)-24(/)-21(s)-19(o)-28(f)-14(t)-21(w)1(a)-24(r)-26(e)-24(.)-25(h)-16(t)-21(ml)-21( \()]TJ
23.7711 0 TD
0.006 Tc
(971201\).)Tj
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 277.59 Tm
0 Tc
(117)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 273.03 Tm
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[( Prop. 1993/)6(94:)6(122 pag)11(e)3( 60.)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 265.83 Tm
0 Tc
(118)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 261.27 Tm
0.006 Tc
[( Prop 1992/)7(93:)7(48 pag)12(e)4( 131.)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 254.07 Tm
0 Tc
(119)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 249.51 Tm
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[( L)12(a)1(g)9( \(1960:729\) om)22( u)9(pph)9(ov)9(s)6(r)-1(\344tt till litter\344ra v)9(e)1(rk)9( och)9( k)9(o)-3(n)9(s)6(tn)9(\344rlig)9(a v)9(e)1(rk)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
0.006 Tc
[(\24753:)7(2.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 230.55 Tm
0 Tc
(120)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 225.99 Tm
0.003 Tc
[( L)12(a)1(g)9( \(1960:729\) om)22( u)9(pph)9(ov)9(s)6(r)-1(\344tt till litter\344ra v)9(e)1(rk)9( och)9( k)9(o)-3(n)9(s)6(tn)9(\344rlig)9(a v)9(e)1(rk)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
(\24753a.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 207.03 Tm
0 Tc
(121)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 202.47 Tm
0.003 Tc
[( L)12(a)1(g)9( \(1960:729\) om)22( u)9(pph)9(ov)9(s)6(r)-1(\344tt till litter\344ra v)9(e)1(rk)9( och)9( k)9(o)-3(n)9(s)6(tn)9(\344rlig)9(a v)9(e)1(rk)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
0.006 Tc
(\24754.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 183.51 Tm
0 Tc
(122)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 178.95 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(3UDNWLVN\003,7\020UlWW)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
6.2651 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, by)22( A)15(g)10(n)10(e)2( L)13(i)5(n)10(dberg)10( an)10(d Dan)10(i)5(el)5( Wes)7(t)5(m)23(a)2(n)10(,)1( pag)10(e)2( 99.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 171.75 Tm
0 Tc
(123)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 167.19 Tm
0.001 Tc
0.002 Tw
[( A)12(r)-3(ticle 5)-5( \(2)-5(\) b)-5( in the )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
8.7229 0 TD
0 Tc
(3URSRVDO\003IRU\003D\003\(XURSHDQ\0033DUOLDPHQW\003DQG\003&RXQFLO)Tj
-9.6988 -1.1807 TD
('LUHFWLYH\003RQ\003WKH\003KDUPRQLVDWLRQ\003RI\003FHUWDLQ\003DVSHFWV\003RI\003FRS\\ULJKW\003DQG\003UHODWHG)Tj
T*
(ULJKWV\003LQ\003WKH\003,QIRUPDWLRQ\0036RFLHW\\)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
13.0723 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(, Bru)11(s)8(s)8(e)3(l)6(s)8(, 10.12.1997. C)9(O)4(M\(97\)628 f)13(i)6(n)11(a)3(l)6(,)]TJ
-13.0723 -1.1807 TD
[(pag)11(e)3( 7.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 124.71 Tm
0 Tc
(124)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 120.15 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(3URSRVDO\003IRU\003D\003\(XURSHDQ\0033DUOLDPHQW\003DQG\003&RXQFLO\003'LUHFWLYH\003RQ\003WKH)Tj
-1.2289 -1.1807 TD
(KDUPRQLVDWLRQ\003RI\003FHUWDLQ\003DVSHFWV\003RI\003FRS\\ULJKW\003DQG\003UHODWHG\003ULJKWV\003LQ\003WKH)Tj
T*
(,QIRUPDWLRQ\0036RFLHW\\)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
7.9639 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(, Bru)11(s)8(s)8(e)3(l)6(s)8(, 10.12.1997. C)9(O)4(M\(97\)628 f)13(i)6(n)11(a)3(l)6(,)2( pag)11(e)3( 18.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
0 Tc
(125)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 84.87 Tm
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[( L)12(a)1(g)9( \(1960:729\) om)22( u)9(pph)9(ov)9(s)6(r)-1(\344tt till litter\344ra v)9(e)1(rk)9( och)9( k)9(o)-3(n)9(s)6(tn)9(\344rlig)9(a v)9(e)1(rk)9( \2472)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
0.006 Tc
-0.003 Tw
[(poi)7(n)12(t)7( 3.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
371 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
372 0 obj
<<
/Length 6458
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(38)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(produce a pri)-4(v)-2(at)-4(e copy)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 222.45 750.99 Tm
0.007 Tc
(126)Tj
12 0 0 12 234.69 745.47 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( as long)10( as this is done by)30( the user himself. I)23(f)]TJ
-10.1 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(another person than the user copies the music, it is considered copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(t)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
[(i)-4(n)-2(fri)-4(ng)8(em)-4(ent)-4(.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 178.29 722.67 Tm
0.007 Tc
(127)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 694.83 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\032\021\025\021\026)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(&RS\\LQJ\003SLFWXUHV\003RII\020OLQH)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 666.39 Tm
0 Tc
[(Pic)4(t)-2(ure)4(s)-1( a)4(r)3(e)4( tre)4(a)4(t)-2(e)4(d)0( simila)4(r to othe)4(r prote)4(c)4(t)-2(e)4(d)0( ma)4(te)4(ria)4(l)-2(. Photog)10(ra)4(phs e)4(n)0(joy)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(protection independent of quality)30( and orig)10(inality)30(. I)23(n)0( recent y)30(ears, the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(majority)29( of the EC Member States have an ex)-11(ception to the reproduction)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
[(rig)9(h)-1(t for photo/print ty)29(pe reproductions \(called \223reprog)9(r)2(aphy)29(\224\))]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 412.53 629.43 Tm
0.007 Tc
(128)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 424.77 623.91 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( c)5(o)1(mbine)5(d)]TJ
-25.94 -1.18 TD
[(with a)5( le)5(vy)31( sy)31(ste)5(m)-1(, quite)5( simila)5(r to tha)5(t)-1( of a)5(udio-visua)5(l)-1( ma)5(te)5(ria)5(l)-1(. I)24(n)1( Swe)5(d)1(e)5(n)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(it is acceptable to reproduce a few copies for personal use only)29(.)-1( The rules)]TJ
T*
[(are less string)9(ent when it comes to who actually)29( carries out the personal)]TJ
T*
[(copy)29(ing)9(.)-1( The user may)29( have someone else copy)29(ing)9( his personal copies for)]TJ
T*
0.002 Tc
(him.)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 529.35 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(\032\021\026\003)-436(/)-1(HJDO\003UHVSRQVLELOLW\\)10(\003)1(Z)-15(K)0(HQ\003SRVWLQJ\003SURWHFWHG)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
[(PDWHULDO\003LQ\003&\\)11(E)0(HUVSDFH)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 479.67 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(B)6(e)3(fore any)29( downloading)9( from the net may)29( occur, material must be uploaded,)]TJ
T*
[(or posted on a remote server somewhere. I)22(s)-2( uploading)9( equivalent of)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(copy)30(ing)10(?)-16( I)23(s)-1( it considered illeg)10(a)4(l to post protected material in Cy)30(berspace?)]TJ
T*
[(What is the responsibility)30( of the person uploading)10( such material?)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 414.87 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\032\021\026\021\024)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(8SORDGLQJ\003VRIWZDUH)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 386.43 Tm
0.001 Tw
[(I)22(m)-3(ag)9(ine a person owning)9( a leg)9(a)3(l copy)29( of a software prog)9(ram. This person)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(ha)4(s a)4( pe)4(c)4(u)0(lia)4(r c)4(r)3(a)4(v)0(ing)10( urg)10(e)4( to sha)4(r)3(e)4( this softwa)4(re)4( with the)4( re)4(st of the)4( world,)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(by)29( posting)9( a full version of it on a website or B)6(B)6(S)-5( server. W)-7(h)-1(at kind of leg)9(a)3(l)]TJ
T*
[(responsibility)29( would such an action activate?)-17( I)22(t)-3( is, as described above,)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(ille)4(g)10(a)4(l to c)4(opy)30( prote)4(c)4(t)-2(e)4(d)0( softwa)4(re)4(. Would uploa)4(ding)10( softwa)4(re)4( c)4(onstitute)4( a)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(private copy)29(?)-17( The result of uploading)9( software to a remote server is that an)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(ex)-12(act)-4( copy)28( of t)-4(h)-2(e soft)-4(ware i)-4(s)-3( pl)-4(aced i)-4(n)-2( C)-5(y)28(berspace. The ori)-4(g)8(i)-4(n)-2(al)-4( i)-4(s)-3( not)-4( sent)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(away)29( from the person uploading)9( it, and therefore it is a matter of copy)29(ing)9(.)-1( A)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(tra)5(d)1(itiona)5(l c)5(opy)31( is ma)5(de)5(.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
0 -1.7 TD
[(\032\021\026\021\024\021\024\003)-189(8SORDGLQJ\003LV\003QRW\003HTXLY)16(DOHQW\003RI\003SULY)16(DWH\003FRS\\)16(LQJ)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
0 -2.34 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(By)28( pl)-4(aci)-4(ng)8( t)-4(h)-2(e soft)-4(ware i)-4(n)-2( C)-5(y)28(berspace, vi)-4(rt)-4(ual)-4(l)-4(y)28( al)-4(l)-4( users i)-4(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e uni)-4(versal)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(I)22(n)-1(t)-3(e)3(rnet)-3( com)-3(m)-3(uni)-3(t)-3(y)29( woul)-3(d g)9(a)3(i)-3(n)-1( access t)-3(o)-1( i)-3(t)-3(.)-1( I)22(n)-1( S)-5(w)1(eden, t)-3(h)-1(i)-3(s)-2( woul)-3(d)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(constitute copy)30(rig)10(h)0(t infring)10(ement under the L)21(a)4(g)10( \(1960:729\) om upphovsr\344tt)]TJ
0 -1.41 TD
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 182.55 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 171.75 Tm
(126)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 167.19 Tm
0.003 Tc
[( L)12(a)1(g)9( \(1960:729\) om)22( u)9(pph)9(ov)9(s)6(r)-1(\344tt till litter\344ra v)9(e)1(rk)9( och)9( k)9(o)-3(n)9(s)6(tn)9(\344rlig)9(a v)9(e)1(rk)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(\24746:)6(2 an)11(d \24712.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 148.23 Tm
0 Tc
(127)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 143.67 Tm
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[( L)12(a)1(g)9( \(1960:729\) om)22( u)9(pph)9(ov)9(s)6(r)-1(\344tt till litter\344ra v)9(e)1(rk)9( och)9( k)9(o)-3(n)9(s)6(tn)9(\344rlig)9(a v)9(e)1(rk)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
0.006 Tc
-0.003 Tw
[(\24712:)7(3 poi)7(n)12(t)7( 1. )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
5.8795 0 TD
0 Tc
(/lURERN\003,\003,PPDWHULDOUlWW)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
10.1566 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, by)22( Kok)10(t)5(v)10(e)2(dg)10(aard an)10(d L)13(e)2(v)10(i)5(n)10(,)1( pag)10(e)]TJ
-16.0361 -1.1807 TD
0.006 Tc
(152.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 112.95 Tm
0 Tc
(128)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 108.39 Tm
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[( A)14(r)-1(ticle 5 \(2\) \(b\) of)11( th)9(e )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
9.4578 0 TD
0 Tc
(3URSRVDO\003IRU\003D\003\(XURSHDQ\0033DUOLDPHQW\003DQG\003&RXQFLO)Tj
-10.4337 -1.1807 TD
('LUHFWLYH\003RQ\003WKH\003KDUPRQLVDWLRQ\003RI\003FHUWDLQ\003DVSHFWV\003RI\003FRS\\ULJKW\003DQG\003UHODWHG)Tj
T*
(ULJKWV\003LQ\003WKH\003,QIRUPDWLRQ\0036RFLHW\\)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
13.0723 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(, Bru)11(s)8(s)8(e)3(l)6(s)8(, 10.12.1997. C)9(O)4(M\(97\)628 f)13(i)6(n)11(a)3(l)6(,)]TJ
-13.0723 -1.1807 TD
[(pag)11(e)3( 18.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
373 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
374 0 obj
<<
/Length 7204
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(39)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(till litter\344ra och konstn\344rlig)9(a verk)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 273.81 750.99 Tm
0.007 Tc
(129)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 286.05 745.47 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(, unless the author g)10(i)-2(ves his consent to)]TJ
-14.38 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(the uploading)9(. I)22(t)-3( is, as described above, not permitted to copy)29( software, even)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(for pri)-4(v)-2(at)-4(e use. Even i)-4(f)1( i)-4(t)-4( )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
10.23 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(Z)-13(RXO)-9(G)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
2.45 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( be leg)9(a)3(l to make a copy)29( for private use, I)]TJ
-12.68 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(believe it is impossible to consider such an uploaded copy)30( being)10( a private)]TJ
T*
(one in most cases.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 200.73 694.35 Tm
( )Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 202.77 688.83 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(P)-5(e)3(rhaps if the site where the software is placed is a non-)]TJ
-7.44 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(access si)-4(t)-4(e)2( secured from)-4( ot)-4(her users as wel)-4(l)-4( as t)-4(h)-2(e I)21(S)-6(P)-6( by)28( a personal)-4( code, i)-4(t)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(could be considered a private copy)29(. This is irrelevant concerning)9( the)]TJ
T*
[(lawfulness, since private copy)29(ing)9( is forbidden but it may)29( be relevant)]TJ
T*
[(concerning)9( the punishment. As described above, private copy)29(ing)9( of software)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
(does not lead to punishment in some cases.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 320.01 623.55 Tm
0.007 Tc
(130)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 332.25 618.03 Tm
0 Tc
[( I)23( am of the opinion that not all)]TJ
-18.23 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(on-line copies necessarily)29( must be considered public.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
0 -1.7 TD
0.002 Tc
[(\032\021\026\021\024\021\025\003)-188(2Q\020OLQH\003EDFNXS\003FRS\\)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
0 -2.34 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(The on-line copy)29( cannot normally)29( be considered a backup copy)29( either, for)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(obvious reasons. I)22(t)-3( would therefore constitute an illeg)9(a)3(l copy)29(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 408.33 546.75 Tm
0.007 Tc
(131)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 420.57 541.23 Tm
-0.001 Tc
( However, if)Tj
-25.59 -1.18 TD
[(the site is a non-access site, perhaps it could be a backup copy)29(. I)22(m)-3(ag)9(ine a)]TJ
T*
[(person with very)29( little free harddrive space, who needs a backup copy)29( for his)]TJ
T*
[(lawfully)29( boug)9(ht prog)9(ram. I)22(f)2( he has a personal place on a server, which )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
28.33 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(RQO)-9(\\)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
-28.33 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(he can access, I)22( believe he can use this space for storing)9( his backup copy)29(.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
0 -1.7 TD
0.002 Tc
[(\032\021\026\021\024\021\026\003)-188(7KH\003XSORDGLQJ\003SHUVRQ\003LV\003UHVSRQVLEOH)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
0 -2.34 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(The person uploading)9( software would most likely)29( be held responsible for)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(such an act)-4(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 169.65 427.47 Tm
0.007 Tc
(132)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 181.89 421.95 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( Swe)5(d)1(ish rule)5(s a)5(r)4(e)5( quite)5( string)11(e)5(n)1(t whe)5(n)1( it c)5(o)1(me)5(s to posting)]TJ
-5.7 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(material on servers. I)22(t)-3( is not necessary)29( to prove that any)29( downloading)9( has)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(oc)4(c)4(u)0(rre)4(d in orde)4(r to show tha)4(t)-2( ille)4(g)10(a)4(l spre)4(a)4(d)0(ing)10( of softwa)4(re)4( is a)4(t)-2( ha)4(nd.)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Any)29(one placing)9( protected software on a host server is by)29( that action alone)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(infring)10(ing)10( the)4( c)4(opy)30(rig)10(h)0(t.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 230.37 370.83 Tm
0.007 Tc
(133)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 342.99 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\032\021\026\021\025)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(8SORDGLQJ\003SLFWXUHV)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 314.55 Tm
0.001 Tw
[(I)22( am of the opinion, that by)29( uploading)9( a picture \(or any)29(t)-3(hing)9( else for that)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
(matter\) to a website or server, the picture is considered to be spread and)Tj
T*
[(redistributed to the public. I)22(t)-3( is therefore, as with software, not a question of)]TJ
T*
[(private personal copy)29(ing)9(.)-1( W)-7(h)-1(en uploading)9( a protected picture, a copy)29( is)]TJ
T*
[(transferred to the targ)9(et site, and this is not allowed unless the author g)9(i)-3(ves)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
(his/her permission.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 204.81 249.27 Tm
0.007 Tc
(134)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 202.95 Tm
0 Tc
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 206.07 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 195.27 Tm
(129)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 190.71 Tm
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[( \24712:)6(2)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 183.51 Tm
0 Tc
(130)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 178.95 Tm
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[( L)12(a)1(g)9( \(1960:729\) om)22( u)9(pph)9(ov)9(s)6(r)-1(\344tt till litter\344ra v)9(e)1(rk)9( och)9( k)9(o)-3(n)9(s)6(tn)9(\344rlig)9(a v)9(e)1(rk)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
0.006 Tc
[(\24753:)7(2.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 159.99 Tm
0 Tc
(131)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 155.43 Tm
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( T)-12(h)10(i)5(s)7( v)10(i)5(ew)27( i)5(s)7( s)7(u)10(pport)5(e)2(d by)22( t)5(h)10(e S)6(w)27(edi)5(s)7(h)10( H\366g)10(s)7(t)5(a)2( Dom)23(s)7(t)5(o)-2(l)5(e)2(n)10( \(HD\) i)5(n)10( NJA)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
0.006 Tc
-0.003 Tw
[(1996:)7(79 pag)12(e)4( 90.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 136.47 Tm
0 Tc
(132)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 131.91 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(1lWMXULGLN\017\003/DJ\003RFK\003UlWW\003Sn\003,QWHUQHW)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
14.3012 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, by)22( T)-12(h)10(om)23(as)7( C)8(a)2(rl)5(\351n)10(-)12(W)-4(en)10(del)5(s)7(, pag)10(e)2( 77.)]TJ
-15.5301 -1.1807 TD
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(T)-14(h)8(e law)25( L)11(a)0(g)8( \(1960:729\) om)21( u)8(pph)8(ov)8(s)5(r)-2(\344tt till litter\344ra v)8(e)0(rk)8( och)8( k)8(o)-4(n)8(s)5(tn)8(\344rlig)8(a)]TJ
T*
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(v)10(e)2(rk)10( \24751:)5(1 s)7(a)2(y)22(s)7( t)5(h)10(at)5( t)5(h)10(e pers)7(on)10( perf)12(orm)23(i)5(n)10(g)10( t)5(h)10(e i)5(n)10(f)12(r)0(i)5(n)10(g)10(i)5(n)10(g)10( act)5(s)7(,)1( i)5(s)7( t)5(h)10(e on)10(e)]TJ
T*
[(res)7(pon)10(s)7(i)5(bl)5(e.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
0 Tc
(133)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 84.87 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(3UDNWLVN\003,7\020UlWW)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
6.2651 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, by)22( L)13(i)5(n)10(dberg)10( an)10(d Wes)7(t)5(m)23(a)2(n)10(,)1( pag)10(e)2( 88)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 77.67 Tm
0 Tc
(134)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 73.11 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(1lWMXULGLN\017\003/DJ\003RFK\003UlWW\003Sn\003,QWHUQHW)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
14.3012 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, by)22( T)-12(h)10(om)23(as)7( C)8(a)2(rl)5(\351n)10(-)12(W)-4(en)10(del)5(s)7(, pag)10(e)2( 71.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
375 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
376 0 obj
<<
/Length 6074
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(40)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 723.15 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\032\021\026\021\026)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(8SORDGLQJ\003PXVLF)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 694.71 Tm
0 Tc
[(I)23(t)-2( is pe)4(rfe)4(c)4(tly)30( possible)4( to c)4(o)0(mpre)4(ss a)4( c)4(o)0(mple)4(te)4( song)10( from a)4( CD to a)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(compression format called MPEG-1 L)21(a)4(y)30(e)4(r 3 \(MP3\) without losing)10( any)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(qua)5(lity)31(. This, due)5( to the)5( fa)5(c)5(t)-1( tha)5(t)-1( music)5( file)5(s from a)5( CD a)5(r)4(e)5( dig)11(itize)5(d)1( a)5(n)1(d)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(stay)29( the same \(master quality)29(\) even thoug)9(h they)29( are compressed and)]TJ
T*
[(transferred to a harddrive on a computer. A user with a CD-g)9(rabber \(a)]TJ
T*
[(prog)9(ram that allows the user to copy)29( song)9(s from CDs to the harddrive\) or)]TJ
T*
[(other ordinary)29( software that comes with CD-writers, can smoothly)29( read the)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(dig)10(itize)4(d)0( song)10( to the)4( ha)4(rddrive)4(.)0( Most ofte)4(n, the)4( song)10(s a)4(r)3(e)4( tra)4(n)0(sforme)4(d from)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(the CD standard format CD-DA \(Compact Disc-Dig)9(ital Audio\) to the DOS)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(sta)4(nda)4(rd forma)4(t)-2( c)4(a)4(lle)4(d wa)4(ve)4( \(some)4(time)4(s re)4(fe)4(rre)4(d to a)4(s)-1( \226wa)4(v)0( sinc)4(e)4( this is the)]TJ
T*
[(ending)10( used in W)-6(i)-2(ndows\). The situation when copy)30(ing)10( the song)10( to the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(harddrive in the wave format is not much different from making)9( an ordinary)]TJ
T*
[(personal copy)29( for private use, as described above. I)22(t)-3( is a question of copy)29(ing)]TJ
T*
[(and reproducing)9( protected material. The only)29( difference is that the copy)29( of)]TJ
T*
[(t)-3(h)-1(e song)9( i)-3(s)-2( pl)-3(aced on t)-3(h)-1(e harddri)-3(v)-1(e, and not)-3( on som)-3(e)3( ot)-3(her m)-3(e)3(di)-3(um)-3(. The)]TJ
T*
[(wave format is very)29( inconvenient, since song)9(s in this format are ex)-11(tremely)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(me)4(mory)30( c)4(onsuming)10(.)0( A two-minute)4( song)10( will roug)10(hly)30( use)4( twe)4(n)0(ty)30( MB)7( of the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(harddrive. Therefore, many)29( users choose to decompress the audio-files to)]TJ
T*
[(MP3 format in order to make storing)9( and electronic transfer more)]TJ
T*
(convenient, faster and cheaper. One should keep in mind that there is no)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(notable chang)10(e)4( in quality)30(. The copy)30( is as g)10(ood as the orig)10(inal.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 409.05 417.03 Tm
0.007 Tc
(135)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 383.19 Tm
0 Tc
[(Compressing)10( ordinary)30( CD song)10(s can easily)30( be made by)30( using)10( a small)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(prog)9(ram called L)20(a)3(y)29(e)3(r 3 encoder/decoder \(There certainly)29( ex)-11(ists other)]TJ
T*
[(prog)9(rams as well\) which can be found on the I)22(n)-1(ternet as a normal z)-7(i)-3(pped file)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(ready)28( for ex)-12(t)-4(r)1(act)-4(i)-4(on.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 210.57 346.23 Tm
0.007 Tc
(136)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 222.81 340.71 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( W)-7(h)-1(en entering)9( the L)20(a)3(y)29(e)3(r 3 directory)29( \(in DOS\) the)]TJ
-9.11 -1.18 TD
[(user writes for ex)-11(ample: \223l3enc c:\\)17(s)-2(ong)9(name.wav c:\\)17(s)-2(ong)9(name.mp3 \226hq \226br)]TJ
T*
(128000\224. This will encode the wave sound-file to a compressed MP3 file.)Tj
T*
[(This process is not very)29( fast, and a slow computer could work for hours with)]TJ
T*
[(a three-minute song)9(. F)5(a)3(ster computers can encode several song)9(s at the same)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(time)4(. Onc)4(e)4( the)4( song)10( is c)4(o)0(mpre)4(sse)4(d into MP3 forma)4(t)-2(, the)4(r)3(e)4( e)4(x)-10(ist two c)4(opie)4(s)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(of the song)9( on the harddrive: one wave file and one MP3 file. Users delete)]TJ
T*
[(t)-3(h)-1(e wave fi)-3(l)-3(e)3( and keep t)-3(h)-1(e MP)-5(3 fi)-3(l)-3(e)3(, whi)-3(c)3(h requi)-3(res m)-3(u)-1(ch l)-3(e)3(ss space on t)-3(h)-1(e)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(ha)4(rddrive)4(.)0( A two-minute)4( MP3 song)10( will a)4(pprox)-10(ima)4(te)4(ly)30( use)4( two MB)7(. The)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(MP3 forma)5(t)-1( fa)5(c)5(ilita)5(te)5(s the)5( proc)5(e)5(ss of se)5(nding)11( song)11(s e)5(l)-1(e)5(c)5(t)-1(ronic)5(a)5(lly)31(, sinc)5(e)5( the)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(tra)4(n)0(sfe)4(r)3( time)4( is re)4(duc)4(e)4(d)0( e)4(normously)30(.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(The MP3 files can be play)29(ed on the computer\222s sound-sy)29(stem using)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(speci)-4(al)-4(l)-4(y)28( desi)-4(g)8(n)-2(ed prog)8(ram)-4(s)-3(, such as \223W)-8(i)-4(npl)-4(ay)28(\224 or \223W)-8(i)-4(n)-2(am)-4(p\224 t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( can be)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(downloa)5(de)5(d from the)5( I)24(n)1(te)5(rne)5(t)-1(. Unle)5(ss the)5( c)5(o)1(mpute)5(r)4( is a)5( Pe)5(ntium with ple)5(n)1(ty)]TJ
0 -1.82 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 123.75 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 112.95 Tm
(135)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 108.39 Tm
0.001 Tc
0.002 Tw
[( T)-15(h)7(e co)-5(p)-5(y)19( w)24(ill b)-5(e)-1( o)-5(f)9( m)20(a)-1(ster q)-5(u)7(ality)19( if)9( d)-5(eco)-5(m)20(p)-5(ressed)-5( w)24(ith a b)-5(itrate o)-5(f)9( at)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(leas)5(t 128000. A)13( low)25(e)0(r bitrate w)25(ill res)5(u)8(lt in)8( in)8(f)10(e)0(rior qu)8(ality)20(.)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
0 Tc
(136)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 84.87 Tm
0.002 Tc
[( Of)10(ten)8( f)10(iles are zipped in)8( order to decrease th)8(e size of)10( th)8(e prog)8(ram)21(s)5(. T)-14(h)8(is)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
0.001 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(is, h)7(o)-5(w)24(e)-1(v)7(e)-1(r, n)7(o)-5(t alw)24(a)-1(y)19(s)4( th)7(e case.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
377 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
378 0 obj
<<
/Length 7084
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(41)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
0 Tw
[(of RAM, play)30(ing)10( of such files in the computer sound sy)30(stem will not be of)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(optimum CD-quality)29(. B)6(o)-1(th Microsoft and Netscape have announced new)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(browse)4(rs, whic)4(h inc)4(l)-2(ude)4( MP3 pla)4(y)30(e)4(r)3(s. This will furthe)4(r e)4(a)4(s)-1(e)4( the)4( pla)4(y)30(ing)10( of)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(such files among)9( ordinary)29( I)22(n)-1(ternet users I)22(t)-3( is of importance to know that)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(MP3 files cannot be play)30(ed in normal CD play)30(ers y)30(e)4(t. I)23( believe it may)30( be)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(possible to do so in the future, since there already)29( ex)-11(ist various prototy)29(p)-1(es of)]TJ
T*
[(such CD play)29(ers. However, it is perfectly)29( possible to decode a MP3 song)9( to)]TJ
T*
(a normal wave file and write it on a normal CD-R)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 352.41 651.87 Tm
0.007 Tc
(137)Tj
12 0 0 12 364.65 646.35 Tm
-0.001 Tc
(. This procedure is very)Tj
-20.93 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(fast and convenient. A two-minute MP3 song)10( is decoded within seconds in a)]TJ
T*
[(fa)4(st c)4(o)0(mpute)4(r)3(. Onc)4(e)4( the)4( wa)4(ve)4( file)4(s a)4(r)3(e)4( writte)4(n on the)4( CD-R, the)4( song)10(s c)4(a)4(n)]TJ
T*
[(be)4( pla)4(y)30(e)4(d)0( on a)4(n)0(y)30( sta)4(nda)4(rd ste)4(r)3(e)4(o)0( with pe)4(rfe)4(c)4(t)-2( ma)4(ste)4(r)3( qua)4(lity)30(. The)4(r)3(e)4(f)3(ore)4(,)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(any)29(one with a CD writer and an I)22(n)-1(ternet connection can produce own music)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(CDs without buy)30(ing)10( traditional music CDs.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
0 -1.7 TD
0.001 Tc
[(\032\021\026\021\026\021\024\003)-189(8SORDGLQJ\00303\026\003ILOHV\003WR\003D\003Z)-9(HEVLWH)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
0 -2.34 TD
0 Tc
[(W)-6(ould uploading)10( a MP3)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 231.81 532.59 Tm
0.007 Tc
(138)Tj
12 0 0 12 244.05 527.07 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( file)5( to a)5( public)5( I)24(n)1(te)5(rne)5(t)-1( we)5(bsite)5( c)5(onstitute)]TJ
-10.88 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(copy)30(rig)10(h)0(t infring)10(ement?)-16( W)-6(ithout the consent and permission of the author, it)]TJ
T*
(would)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 143.49 504.27 Tm
0.007 Tc
(139)Tj
12 0 0 12 155.73 498.75 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
( due to the fact that it is not a matter of private use.)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 400.05 504.27 Tm
0.007 Tc
(140)Tj
12 0 0 12 412.29 498.75 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[( The copi)-4(ed)]TJ
-24.9 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(fi)-3(l)-3(e)3( i)-3(s)-2( ex)-11(posed t)-3(o)-1( t)-3(h)-1(e publ)-3(i)-3(c)3( t)-3(h)-1(e very)29( sam)-3(e)3( m)-3(o)-1(m)-3(e)3(nt)-3( i)-3(t)-3( i)-3(s)-2( pl)-3(aced on t)-3(h)-1(e)]TJ
T*
[(website. An undefined g)9(r)2(oup of users can access the copy)29(, and that would be)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(e)5(quiva)5(le)5(nt of spre)5(a)5(d)1(ing)11( the)5( ma)5(te)5(ria)5(l)-1( to the)5( public)5(.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 351.69 461.79 Tm
0.007 Tc
(141)Tj
12 0 0 12 363.93 456.27 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[( A European ex)-12(am)-4(pl)-4(e)]TJ
-20.87 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(illustra)4(ting)10( this is the)4( F)6(r)3(e)4(n)0(c)4(h)0( c)4(a)4(s)-1(e)4( we)4(re)4( F)6(r)3(a)4(n)0(c)4(o)0(is-Xa)4(v)0(ie)4(r B)7(e)4(rg)10(ot uploa)4(de)4(d)]TJ
T*
[(twenty)30( song)10(s by)30( Michel Sardou to his website. The Tribunal De Grande)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(I)22(n)-1(stance in Paris found this manner unlawful. B)6(e)3(rg)9(ot contended that the)]TJ
T*
[(song)9(s were intended for private use. The Tribunal stated that, due to the fact)]TJ
T*
[(t)-3(h)-1(at)-3( t)-3(h)-1(i)-3(r)2(d part)-3(i)-3(e)3(s coul)-3(d access and copy)29( t)-3(h)-1(e upl)-3(oaded song)9(s, t)-3(h)-1(e si)-3(t)-3(e)]TJ
T*
[(functioned as an encourag)9(ement to use the reproductions.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 388.77 376.83 Tm
0.007 Tc
(142)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 322.59 Tm
0.002 Tc
[(\032\021\026\021\026\021\025\003)-188(%DFNJURXQG\003PXVLF\003RQ\003Z)-8(HEVLWHV)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
0 -2.34 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(Sometimes the website owner chooses to play)29( a \223backg)9(r)2(ound music\224 to)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(users while visiting)9( the site. The user cannot alway)29(s)-2( decide whether or not to)]TJ
T*
[(activate the music. I)22(f)2( the user\222s computer is not equipped with a soundcard)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(a)4(nd browse)4(r with he)4(lp-a)4(pplic)4(a)4(tions he)4(/she)4( will not be)4( a)4(b)0(le)4( to he)4(a)4(r)3( the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(soundfile play)29(ed. \(Sometimes midi-files are used, but more and more often)]TJ
T*
[(other ty)29(pes of files that can reproduce the music not very)29( much different)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(from)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e ori)-4(g)8(i)-4(n)-2(al)-4( are used\). Today)28( m)-4(o)-2(st)-4( st)-4(andard com)-4(put)-4(ers as wel)-4(l)-4( as)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(webbrowsers are capable of play)29(ing)9( such files. W)-7(ould this \223public)]TJ
0 -1.33 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 182.55 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 171.75 Tm
(137)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 167.19 Tm
0.003 Tc
[( C)7(D)2(-)11(R)7( is a recordable C)7(D)2(.)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 159.99 Tm
0 Tc
(138)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 155.43 Tm
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( MP)-8(3 is on)8(ly)20( a f)10(o)-4(rm)21(at, bu)8(t w)25(h)8(en)8( I u)8(s)5(e th)8(e term)21( I presu)8(m)21(e th)8(at th)8(e MP)-8(3s)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
[(con)8(s)5(ist of)10( protected m)21(u)8(sic son)8(g)8(s)5(.)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 136.47 Tm
0 Tc
(139)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 131.91 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(1lWMXULGLN\017\003/DJ\003RFK\003UlWW\003Sn\003,QWHUQHW)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
14.3012 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, by)22( T)-12(h)10(om)23(as)7( C)8(a)2(rl)5(\351n)10(-)12(W)-4(en)10(del)5(s)7(, pag)10(e)2( 70.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 124.71 Tm
0 Tc
(140)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 120.15 Tm
0.004 Tc
[( Ibi)5(d)-2(. pag)10(e)2( 82.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 112.95 Tm
0 Tc
(141)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 108.39 Tm
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[( L)12(a)1(g)9( \(1960:729\) om)22( u)9(pph)9(ov)9(s)6(r)-1(\344tt till litter\344ra v)9(e)1(rk)9( och)9( k)9(o)-3(n)9(s)6(tn)9(\344rlig)9(a v)9(e)1(rk)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
0.006 Tc
[(\24746:)7(1. )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
2.8072 0 TD
0 Tc
(/lURERN\003,\003,PPDWHULDOUlWW)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
10.1566 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, by)22( Kok)10(t)5(v)10(e)2(dg)10(aard an)10(d L)13(e)2(v)10(i)5(n)10(,)1( pag)10(e)2( 134.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
0 Tc
(142)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 84.87 Tm
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( A)13(r)-2(t Mu)8(sic Fran)8(ce v)8(.)-1( L)11(\222)10(Ecole Nation)8(a)0(le Su)8(perieu)8(re Des)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(T)-12(e)2(l)5(ecom)23(m)23(u)10(n)10(i)5(cat)5(i)5(o)-2(n)10(s)7(, T)-12(r)0(i)5(b)-2(u)10(n)10(a)2(l)5( de Gran)10(de In)10(s)7(t)5(an)10(ce Pari)5(s)7( [1997]EEC)8(97.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
379 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
380 0 obj
<<
/Length 6583
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(42)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(performance\224 constitute copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(t infring)9(ement?)-17( I)22(t)-3( depends on the nature of)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(the)5( site)5(. I)24(f)4( the)5( music)5( is not the)5( e)5(sse)5(ntia)5(l pa)5(rt of the)5( site)5(, a)5(nd the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(\223performance\224 is non-commercial it is leg)9(itimate. Thus, a private website)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(owner would normally)30( not need permission from the author to )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
25.11 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(SO)-9(D\\)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
1.72 0 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
( the)Tj
-26.83 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(soundfiles on the website. However, if the website is a commercial one,)Tj
T*
[(permission is required. According)9( to Carl\351n-W)-7(endels, the difference)]TJ
T*
[(between non-commercial and commercial sites is merely)29( theoretical, since)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
(permission is needed in both situations in order to )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
20.19 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(SO)-9(DFH)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
2.16 0 TD
0 Tc
( the copied music)Tj
-22.35 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(file on the site. The \223play)29(i)-3(ng)9(\224 described above is a completely)29( different)]TJ
T*
(issue.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 140.49 623.55 Tm
0.007 Tc
(143)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 565.95 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(\032\021\027\003)-436(7KH\003OHJDO\003UHVSRQVLELOLWLHV\003RI\003,63V\003DQG\003%%6)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
(RSHUDWRUV)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 516.27 Tm
0 Tw
[(I)23(s)-1( it possible)4( tha)4(t)-2( I)23(SPs \(some)4(time)4(s re)4(fe)4(rre)4(d to a)4(s)-1( on-line)4( se)4(rvic)4(e)4( provide)4(rs,)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(OSPs\) and B)6(B)6(S)-5( operators have a leg)9(a)3(l responsibility)29( reg)9(a)3(rding)9( uploaded)]TJ
T*
[(protected material?)-17( Are I)22(SPs responsible not only)29( for their own acts, but)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(al)-4(so for t)-4(h)-2(e act)-4(s of t)-4(h)-2(ei)-4(r subscri)-4(b)-2(ers?)-18( I)21(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e U.S)-6(., t)-4(h)-2(e S)-6(o)-2(ft)-4(ware P)-6(ubl)-4(i)-4(s)-3(hers)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
(Association \(SPA\))Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 203.13 465.15 Tm
0.007 Tc
(144)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 215.37 459.63 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( ag)9(g)9(r)2(essively)29( arg)9(u)-1(es that I)22(SPs are liable under a theory)]TJ
-8.49 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(of contributory)30( copy)30(rig)10(h)0(t infring)10(ement.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 301.65 450.99 Tm
0.007 Tc
(145)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 313.89 445.47 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[( S)-6(o)-2(m)-4(e)2( arg)8(u)-2(e t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( an I)21(S)-6(P)-6( i)-4(s)-3( i)-4(n)-2( a)]TJ
-16.7 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(situation similar to that of a telephone company)29( supply)29(i)-3(ng)9( the necessary)]TJ
T*
[(infrastructure. A telecommunications company)29( supply)29(i)-3(ng)9( the phy)29(sical)]TJ
T*
[(infrastructure such as wires would not be liable to contributory)29( infring)9(ement)]TJ
T*
[(as a result of subscribers using)9( the phone when committing)9( a crime.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
[(Some arg)9(u)-1(e that I)22(SPs are similar to newspaper publishers. When a)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(newspaper publishes illeg)9(a)3(l material, the publisher and not the author bears)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(the main responsibility)30(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 226.17 337.71 Tm
0.007 Tc
(146)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 238.41 332.19 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( I)22(f)2( one applies the \223newspaper model\224 to the)]TJ
-10.41 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(situation of the I)23(SPs, it can be sug)10(g)10(e)4(sted that the I)23(SPs should bear the final)]TJ
T*
[(responsibility)30( for any)30(t)-2(hing)10( posted by)30( its subscribers. However, one must not)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(ig)9(nore the fact that newspaper publishers have a much easier task)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(monitoring)10( published material, than an I)23(SP.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 253.23 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\032\021\027\021\024)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
(7KH\003PRQLWRULQJ\003RI\003SRVWHG\003LQIRUPDWLRQ)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 224.79 Tm
[(I)23(t)-2( ma)4(y)30( be)4( diffic)4(u)0(lt for a)4(n)0( I)23(SP to monitor e)4(v)0(e)4(r)3(y)30( sing)10(le)4( bit of informa)4(tion)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(flowing)10( throug)10(h its sy)30(stem, since uploading)10( and downloading)10( of diverse)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(material take place rapidly)29( all the time from various places. There are)]TJ
T*
[(billions of messag)9(e)3(s flowing)9( across Cy)29(berspace every)29( day)29(.)-1( Not all of them)]TJ
0 -2.2 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 159.03 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 148.23 Tm
(143)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 143.67 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(1lWMXULGLN\017\003/DJ\003RFK\003UlWW\003Sn\003,QWHUQHW)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
14.3012 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, by)22( T)-12(h)10(om)23(as)7( C)8(a)2(rl)5(\351n)10(-)12(W)-4(en)10(del)5(s)7(, pag)10(e)2( 70.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 136.47 Tm
0 Tc
(144)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 131.91 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.004 Tw
[( SP)-11(A)10( is an internatio)-7(nal trad)-7(e asso)-7(ciatio)-7(n o)-7(f)7( the d)-7(e)-3(skto)-7(p)-7( so)-7(f)7(t)0(w)22(a)-3(re ind)-7(u)5(stry)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(repres)7(en)10(t)5(i)5(n)10(g)10( pu)10(bl)5(i)5(s)7(h)10(e)2(rs)7(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 112.95 Tm
0 Tc
(145)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 108.39 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(,QWHOOHFWXDO\0033URSHUW\\)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
8.3976 0 TD
0.003 Tc
[(, by)21( J)-6(e)1(f)11(f)11(r)-1(ey)21( R)7(.)0( Ku)9(ester an)9(d Dan)9(i)4(el R)7(.)0( McC)7(l)4(u)9(r)-1(e, T)-13(h)9(e)]TJ
-9.6265 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(Nat)6(i)6(o)-1(n)11(a)3(l)6( L)14(a)3(w)28( Jou)11(r)1(n)11(a)3(l)6(,)2( Jan)11( 20, 1997.)]TJ
T*
-0.022 Tc
[(H)-23(t)-21(t)-21(p)-28(:)-21(/)-21(/)-21(www.)-25(l)-21(j)-33(x)-16(.)-25(c)-24(o)-28(m/)-21(i)-21(n)-16(t)-21(e)-24(r)-26(n)-16(e)-24(t)-21(/)]TJ
11.5904 0 TD
0.005 Tc
[(0120i)6(s)8(p)-1(cp.h)11(t)6(m)24(l)6( \(971006\))]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 77.67 Tm
0 Tc
(146)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 73.11 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(7U\\FNIULKHWVUlWW)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
6.2771 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
0.008 Tw
[(,)-8( b)-11(y)13( H)-6(\345)-7(ka)-7(n Str)-9(\366)-11(m)14(b)-11(e)-7(r)-9(g,)-8( p)-11(a)-7(ge)-7( 6)-11(6)-11(.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
381 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
382 0 obj
<<
/Length 6750
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(43)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
0 Tw
[(involve copy)30(rig)10(h)0(t infring)10(ements, but the monitoring)10( required to find such)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(infring)10(ements would be costly)30(, and could perhaps invade on)]TJ
T*
[(communications privacy)30(. The I)23(SPs would have to permanently)30( scan the)]TJ
T*
[(sy)30(stem and monitor all communications, in the search for possible)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(infring)9(ements. I)22(t)-3( has been arg)9(u)-1(ed that the I)22(SPs may)29( be best equipped of all)]TJ
T*
[(parties to supervise the flow of information, if these have enoug)9(h hardware)]TJ
T*
(and software in order to determine when improper material is posted.)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 445.17 666.03 Tm
0.007 Tc
(147)Tj
12 0 0 12 113.49 646.35 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Some companies, such as I)23(n)0(tersect I)23(n)0(c., can help the I)23(SPs finding)10( commonly)]TJ
T*
[(used formats used to deliver audio and video by)30( scanning)10( the net using)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(Audio Video Scan \(AVS\).)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 239.97 623.55 Tm
0.007 Tc
(148)Tj
12 0 0 12 252.21 618.03 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( The)5( AVS c)5(a)5(n)1( sc)5(a)5(n)1( up to e)5(l)-1(e)5(v)1(e)5(n)1( million)]TJ
-11.56 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(webpag)8(e)2(s per day)28(.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 201.69 609.39 Tm
0.007 Tc
(149)Tj
12 0 0 12 213.93 603.87 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( There ex)-11(ist numerous way)29(s)-2( of scanning)9( and)]TJ
-8.37 -1.18 TD
[(monitoring)9( Cy)29(berspace, but whether these are effective in reality)29(, I)22( cannot)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(sa)4(y)30(.)0( I)23(t)-2( is possible)4( to wa)4(te)4(rma)4(r)3(k music)4( file)4(s, but whe)4(t)-2(he)4(r pira)4(te)4(s will be)4( a)4(b)0(le)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(to remove such marks remains to be seen. I)22(t)-3( would be easier for I)22(SPs to)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(de)4(te)4(rmine)4( whe)4(t)-2(he)4(r file)4(s a)4(r)3(e)4( infring)10(ing)10( c)4(opy)30(rig)10(h)0(ts, if a)4(ll file)4(s whe)4(r)3(e)4( ta)4(g)10(g)10(e)4(d)]TJ
T*
[(with information. Technical equipment, however, is not the only)30( solution to)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(the monitoring)9(. Knowledg)9(e of the law is just as important in order to decide)]TJ
T*
(the nature of the posted information.)Tj
0 -2.36 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(I)23(n)0( order to decide which messag)10(e)4(s that are infring)10(ing)10( upon copy)30(rig)10(h)0(ts, I)23(SPs)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(would be put in a position where they)29( must be able to decide whether posted)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(ma)4(te)4(ria)4(l)-2( is infring)10(ing)10( c)4(opy)30(rig)10(h)0(ts or whe)4(t)-2(he)4(r it c)4(onstitute)4(s \223)4(f)3(a)4(i)-2(r use)4(\224)4(.)0( Sinc)4(e)]TJ
T*
[(this is not alway)30(s)-1( obvious, it may)30( not be an effortless task for the I)23(SPs. I)23(SPs)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(would, preferably)29(, have to be educated in I)22(P)-5( law in order to determine the)]TJ
T*
[(nature of the posted information within their spheres. I)22(n)-1( order to avoid)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(lia)5(bility)31(, I)24(SPs ma)5(y)31( be)5( e)5(a)5(g)11(e)5(r)4( to c)5(l)-1(ose)5( down a)5(n)1(y)31(one)5( tha)5(t)-1( tra)5(n)1(smits ma)5(te)5(ria)5(l)]TJ
T*
[(tha)5(t)-1( )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
1.75 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
(PD\\)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
1.66 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( infring)9(e upon copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(ts. Subscribers may)29( therefore be punished)]TJ
-3.41 -1.18 TD
[(without a fair trial. Subscribers may)29( g)9(o)-1( out of business, or be offended, if)]TJ
T*
[(they)29( are shut down without reason and cause. I)22(SPs could lose their)]TJ
T*
[(customers if they)29( are too threatening)9( to them. I)22(f)2( the I)22(SPs, on the other hand,)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(a)4(r)3(e)4( too le)4(nie)4(n)0(t, subsc)4(r)3(ibe)4(r)3(s tha)4(t)-2( a)4(r)3(e)4( re)4(a)4(l)-2( vic)4(tims of va)4(rious infring)10(e)4(m)-2(e)4(n)0(ts)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(m)-4(a)2(y)28( l)-4(eave t)-4(h)-2(e servi)-4(ce, or even t)-4(r)1(y)28( t)-4(o)-2( sue t)-4(h)-2(e I)21(S)-6(P)-6(s)-3(.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
0 -4.06 TD
0.002 Tc
[(\032\021\027\021\024\021\024\003)-188(7KH\003PRVW\003VXLWDEOH\003VXSHUY)17(LVRU)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
0 -2.34 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(On the other hand, one may)29( arg)9(u)-1(e that I)22(SPs are best equipped of all possible)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(supervi)-3(s)-2(ors t)-3(o)-1( hi)-3(nder copy)29(ri)-3(g)9(h)-1(t)-3( i)-3(n)-1(fri)-3(ng)9(em)-3(ent)-3(s)-2( i)-3(n)-1( C)-4(y)29(berspace, si)-3(nce I)22(S)-5(P)-5(s)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(have a relatively)30( close relationship with their subscribers. I)23(SPs possess the)]TJ
T*
[(power to cut off or ban users not comply)30(ing)10( with laws, g)10(u)0(idelines or basic)]TJ
T*
[(netiquette. This power, I)23( believe is a special one, not belong)10(ing)10( to all other)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(institutions. I)24(SPs ma)5(y)31( se)5(t the)5(i)-1(r own polic)5(ie)5(s a)5(nd g)11(u)1(ide)5(line)5(s)0( of c)5(o)1(mplia)5(nc)5(e)]TJ
0 -1.23 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 147.27 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 136.47 Tm
(147)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 131.91 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
('HSXWL]LQJ\003WKH\003,63V)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
7.988 0 TD
0.003 Tw
[(, b)-6(y)18( W)-8(illiam)19( J)-9(.)-3( Co)-6(o)-6(k)6(, Intellectual P)-10(r)-4(o)-6(p)-6(e)-2(rty)18( Magazine,)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
-9.2169 -1.1807 TD
-0.021 Tc
0.024 Tw
[(S)-19(p)-27(r)-25(i)-20(n)-15(g)-15( \2649)-27(6)-27(.)-24( H)-22(t)-20(t)-20(p)-27(:)-20(/)-20(/)-20(www.)-24(i)-20(p)-27(ma)-23(g)-15(.)-24(c)-23(o)-27(m/)-20(a)-23(c)-23(o)-27(o)-27(k)-15(.)-24(h)-15(t)-20(m)-2( \()]TJ
19.2048 0 TD
0.006 Tc
(970716\))Tj
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 112.95 Tm
0 Tc
(148)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 108.39 Tm
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[( PR)9( New)28(s)8(w)28(i)6(re, Ju)11(n)11(e)3( 2, 1997.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 101.19 Tm
0 Tc
(149)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 96.63 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(7UDFNLQJ\003DQG\0030RQLWRULQJ\0030XVLF\003RQ\003WKH\003,QWHUQHW)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
19.1084 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(, Wh)11(i)6(t)6(e)3( Paper, S)7(e)3(pt)6( 1997,)]TJ
-20.3373 -1.1807 TD
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[(by)21( Marco P)-7(a)1(pa, P)-7(h)9(.D. C)7(h)9(ief)11( f)11(r)-1(om)22( In)9(ters)6(ect In)9(c.)]TJ
T*
-0.021 Tc
0.024 Tw
[(H)-22(t)-20(t)-20(p)-27(:)-20(/)-20(/)-20(www.)-24(i)-20(n)-15(t)-20(e)-23(r)-25(s)-18(e)-23(c)-23(t)-20(i)-20(n)-15(c)-23(.)-24(c)-23(o)-27(m/)-20(t)-20(e)-23(c)-23(h)-15(n)-15(o)-27(l)-20(o)-27(g)-15(y)-3(.)-24(h)-15(yml)-20( \()]TJ
19.0843 0 TD
0.006 Tc
(971212\))Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
383 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
384 0 obj
<<
/Length 6451
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(44)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(for the pay)29(i)-3(ng)9( \(or non-pay)29(i)-3(ng)9(\) subscribers. They)29( have the ability)29( to seriously)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(warn any)29(one posting)9( improper material in the on-line community)29(, and I)]TJ
T*
[(believe such a warning)9( may)29(,)-1( in many)29( cases, function as a deterrent. Of)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(c)4(ourse)4(, not a)4(ll infring)10(ing)10( subsc)4(r)3(ibe)4(r)3(s will be)4( te)4(rrifie)4(d)0( by)30( a)4( thre)4(a)4(t)-2( of)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(terminating)9( the I)22(n)-1(ternet subscription, and as a result discontinue whatever)]TJ
T*
[(infring)9(ing)9( activities they)29( are conducting)9(.)-1( However, once the I)22(SP shuts off)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(the)5( subsc)5(r)4(ibe)5(r)4(, he)5(/she)5( will not be)5( a)5(b)1(le)5( to g)11(o)1( online)5( using)11( tha)5(t)-1( ve)5(ry)31( sa)5(me)5( I)24(SP.)]TJ
T*
[(The)5(r)4(e)5( is a)5(l)-1(wa)5(y)31(s)0( a)5( possibility)31( tha)5(t)-1( the)5( use)5(r)4( simply)31( switc)5(he)5(s to a)5(nothe)5(r I)24(S)-3(P)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(and continues the infring)10(ing)10( activities in Cy)30(berspace until the nex)-10(t)-2( I)23(SP does)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(the)5( sa)5(me)5(.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
0 -4.06 TD
[(\032\021\027\021\024\021\025\003)-189(7UDQVIHUULQJ\003WKH\003UHVSRQVLELOLW\\)16(\003)1(IURP\003WKH\003,63\003WR\003WKH)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0.003 Tc
(VXEVFULEHU)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0 -2.34 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(I)22(m)-3(ag)9(ine I)22(SPs being)9( responsible for the acts of its subscribers. At what point)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(would the responsibility)29( for infring)9(ing)9( acts be transferred to the subscribers?)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(The)5(r)4(e)5( must be)5( a)5(c)5(tions tha)5(t)-1( the)5( I)24(SP c)5(ould pe)5(rform in orde)5(r to a)5(void lia)5(bility)31(,)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(such as warning)9(s)-2( or refusal to connect the subscriber to the I)22(n)-1(ternet. W)-7(ould)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(a)5(n)1( e)5(-)4(ma)5(il wa)5(rning)11( \(or via)5( tra)5(d)1(itiona)5(l \223)5(s)0(na)5(il ma)5(il\224)5(\) from a)5(n)1( I)24(SP to a)5(n)1( a)5(lle)5(g)11(e)5(d)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(infring)9(er be considered enoug)9(h steps taken in order to prevent further acts of)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(infring)11(e)5(m)-1(e)5(n)1(ts, a)5(nd thus a)5(void I)24(SP c)5(ontributory)31( lia)5(bility)31(?)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(I)22(f)2( a subscriber breaks the rules over and over ag)9(ain, the I)22(SPs could simply)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(refuse further access to the web. S)-5(hould I)22(S)-5(P)-5(s)-2( shut off any)29( subscriber that)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(posts ma)5(te)5(ria)5(l)-1( tha)5(t)-1( )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
7.58 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
(PD\\)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
1.66 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( be infring)10(ing)10( on other\222s protected material?)-16( This is)]TJ
-9.24 -1.18 TD
[(some)4(time)4(s re)4(fe)4(rre)4(d to a)4(s)-1( the)4( \224)4(notic)4(e)4( a)4(nd ta)4(ke)4( down\224)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 364.17 376.83 Tm
0.007 Tc
(150)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 376.41 371.31 Tm
0 Tc
[( oblig)10(ation, which)]TJ
-21.91 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(ma)5(y)31( le)5(a)5(d)1( to a)5(voida)5(nc)5(e)5( of I)24(SP lia)5(bility)31(. Some)5( ma)5(y)31( a)5(r)4(g)11(u)1(e)5( tha)5(t)-1( suc)5(h)1( a)5( me)5(thod)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(could lead to a situation where subscribers would not dare to post)Tj
T*
[(information at all, in fear of being)9( shut down. I)22(t)-3( could be arg)9(u)-1(ed that)]TJ
T*
[(freedom)-3( of speech i)-3(s)-2( endang)9(ered, i)-3(f)2( one i)-3(s)-2( shut)-3( down from)-3( furt)-3(her access t)-3(o)]TJ
T*
[(the on-line community)29(, due to a transfer of completely)29( non-infring)9(ing)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(material that is falsely)30( labeled illeg)10(a)4(l or infring)10(ing)10( by)30( a doubtful and perhaps)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(uninformed I)22(SP. This could lead to a situation where I)22(n)-1(ternet users avoid)]TJ
T*
[(sending)9( any)29( material on-line \(at least without encry)29(p)-1(tion\) or that users turn)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(o)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e I)21(S)-6(P)-6( whi)-4(c)2(h appl)-4(y)28( t)-4(h)-2(e l)-4(east)-4( st)-4(ri)-4(ng)8(ent)-4( pol)-4(i)-4(c)2(y)28( concerni)-4(ng)8( t)-4(h)-2(e \223t)-4(aki)-4(n)-2(g)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(down\224)4( a)4(nd shutting)10( off.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Some arg)9(u)-1(e that since I)22(SPs should bear a g)9(r)2(eater responsibility)29( due to the)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(si)-4(m)-4(p)-2(l)-4(e)2( fact)-4( t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( t)-4(h)-2(ey)28( recei)-4(ve pay)28(m)-4(ent)-4( for t)-4(h)-2(e servi)-4(ces t)-4(h)-2(ey)28( provi)-4(de. I)21(t)-4( has)]TJ
T*
[(al)-4(so been sai)-4(d)-2( t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( i)-4(f)1( an I)21(S)-6(P)-6( act)-4(ual)-4(l)-4(y)28( uses hi)-4(s aut)-4(hori)-4(t)-4(y)28( t)-4(o)-2( pre-check)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(uploaded infring)10(ing)10( material but declines to remove it, the I)23(SP should be)]TJ
T*
0.002 Tc
[(lia)6(ble)6(.)2( )]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 146.13 150.27 Tm
0.007 Tc
(151)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 158.37 144.75 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( There is a dang)9(er in a situation were responsibility)29( only)29( burdens)]TJ
-3.74 -2.01 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 123.75 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 112.95 Tm
(150)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 108.39 Tm
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( Statem)21(en)8(t by)20( R)6(o)-4(y)20( Neel, presiden)8(t an)8(d C)6(E)-1(O of)10( th)8(e U.S. T)-14(e)0(leph)8(on)8(e)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(A)10(sso)-7(ciatio)-7(n)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
4.7108 0 TD
0 Tc
(\021\0036HQDWH\003-XGLFLDU\\\003PXOOV\003RQ\020OLQH\003FRS\\ULJKW\003LQIULQJHPHQW)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
22.2651 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, BNA)15(,)]TJ
-26.9759 -1.1807 TD
[(Pat)5(e)2(n)10(t)5(, T)-12(r)0(adem)23(ark)10( &)11( C)8(opy)22(ri)5(g)10(h)10(t)5( L)13(a)2(w)27( Dai)5(l)5(y)22(, S)6(e)2(pt)5(.5, 1997)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 77.67 Tm
0 Tc
(151)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 73.11 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(6N\\GG\003I|U\003XSSKRYVUlWW\003Sn\003,QWHUQHW)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
13.5904 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, by)22( C)8(h)10(ri)5(s)7(t)5(i)5(n)10(a F)6(o)-2(l)5(k)10(es)7(on)10(, pag)10(e)2( 22.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
385 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
386 0 obj
<<
/Length 7439
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(45)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
0 Tw
[(I)23(SPs that pre-check uploaded files. W)-6(h)0(y)30(?)-16( I)23(f)3( an I)23(SP ig)10(nores all incoming)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(ma)5(te)5(ria)5(l)-1(, he)5(/she)5( will not be)5( lia)5(ble)5(.)1( This ma)5(y)31( le)5(a)5(d)1( to a)5( situa)5(tion whe)5(r)4(e)5( I)24(SPs)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(ne)4(ve)4(r c)4(h)0(e)4(c)4(k)0(s a)4(n)0(y)30( uploa)4(de)4(d ma)4(te)4(ria)4(l)-2( in orde)4(r to a)4(void lia)4(bility)30(. Use)4(r)3(s c)4(ould)]TJ
T*
[(then upload any)30( file without I)23(SP intervention.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 680.67 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\032\021\027\021\025)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(&\\EHUVSDFH\003ZLWKRXW\003,)-8(6)1(3)6(\003)4(OLDELOLW\\)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 652.23 Tm
0 Tc
[(I)23(f)3( I)23(SPs would not be responsible for the acts of their subscribers, and if I)23(SPs)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(could set their own policies, I)23( believe that the rules and g)10(u)0(idelines would be)]TJ
T*
[(kept at a bare minimum. I)23(SPs would have no interest in searching)10( the)]TJ
T*
[(I)23(n)0(te)4(rne)4(t)-2( for infring)10(ing)10( ma)4(te)4(ria)4(l)-2( or wa)4(rn infring)10(ing)10( subsc)4(r)3(ibe)4(r)3(s. I)23(t)-2( is like)4(l)-2(y)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(tha)5(t)-1( the)5( I)24(SP with the)5( le)5(a)5(s)0(t string)11(e)5(n)1(t rule)5(s a)5(nd c)5(h)1(e)5(a)5(p)1(e)5(s)0(t ra)5(te)5(s would be)5( the)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(most popular I)23(SP among)10( all subscribers.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
0 -1.7 TD
0.002 Tc
[(\032\021\027\021\025\021\024\003)-188(7KH\0038)4(\021)0(6\021\003,63\003H[HPSW)7(LRQ)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
0 -2.34 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(I)22(n)-1( the U.S., there has been a turbulent debate during)9( the autumn of 1997, as)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(to whether I)23(SPs should be ex)-10(empted from liability)30( for any)30( copy)30(rig)10(h)0(t)]TJ
T*
[(infring)10(e)4(m)-2(e)4(n)0(ts by)30( subsc)4(r)3(ibe)4(r)3(s. The)4( On-L)21(ine)4( L)21(i)-2(a)4(b)0(ility)30( L)21(imita)4(tion Ac)4(t)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 437.01 510.15 Tm
0.007 Tc
(152)Tj
12 0 0 12 449.25 504.63 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
( \(HR)Tj
-27.98 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(2180\) was introduced J)-12(u)-1(ly)29( 17, 1997 and referred to the J)-12(udiciary)]TJ
T*
[(Committee. The I)22(SPs demanded ex)-11(emption while creators and producers of)]TJ
T*
[(movies, recorded music and software opposed such an ex)-11(emption. The act)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(would make I)23(SPs liable only)30( if six)-10( criteria were not met. F)6(i)-2(rstly)30(, the I)23(S)-4(P)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(must not ha)5(ve)5( initia)5(lly)31( )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
9.2 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(SO)-9(DFHG)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
2.66 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( the material on-line. Secondly)30(,)0( the I)23(SP must)]TJ
-11.86 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(not have )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
3.66 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(JHQHU)-9(DW)-8(HG\017\003V)-9(HO)-8(HFW)-8(HG\003RU)-9(\003DO)-8(W)-8(H)1(U)-9(H)1(G)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
11.92 0 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( the)5( ma)5(te)5(ria)5(l)-1(. Thirdly)31(,)1( the)5( I)24(SP must)]TJ
-15.58 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(not have )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
3.66 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(GHW)-8(HU)-9(PL)-8(QHG\003W)-8(KH\003U)-9(HFL)-8(SL)-8(HQW)-8(V)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
10.15 0 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( of the)5( ma)5(te)5(ria)5(l)-1(. F)7(ourthly)31(, the)5( I)24(SP must)]TJ
-13.81 -1.18 TD
(not )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
1.53 0 TD
-0.002 Tc
(EHQHILW\003ILQDQFLDOO\\)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
7.25 0 TD
0.001 Tc
[( from the)5( infring)11(e)5(m)-1(e)5(n)1(t. F)7(i)-1(fthly)31(,)1( the)5( I)24(SP must not)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
-8.78 -1.18 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(V)-10(SRQV)-10(RU)-10(\017\003HQGRU)-10(V)-10(H)0(\003RU)-10(\003)-3(DGYHU)-10(W)-9(L)-9(V)-10(H)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
11.88 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( the material. Six)-10(t)-2(hly)30(,)0( the I)23(SP must not be)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
-11.88 -1.18 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(DZ)-13(DU)-10(H)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
2.5 0 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[( of t)-4(h)-2(e i)-4(n)-2(fri)-4(ng)8(i)-4(n)-2(g)8( nat)-4(u)-2(re of t)-4(h)-2(e m)-4(a)2(t)-4(e)2(ri)-4(al)-4(, nor t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( access t)-4(o)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e m)-4(a)2(t)-4(e)2(ri)-4(al)]TJ
-2.5 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(is prohibited by)29( law. At a Senate hearing)9( September 4, 1997, the J)-12(udiciary)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(Committe)5(e)5( wa)5(s wa)5(rne)5(d)1( tha)5(t)-1( a)5(n)1( I)24(SP e)5(x)-9(e)5(m)-1(ption would a)5(llow I)24(SPs to)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(com)-4(p)-2(l)-4(e)2(t)-4(e)2(l)-4(y)28( i)-4(g)8(nore onl)-4(i)-4(n)-2(e pi)-4(racy)28( and t)-4(h)-2(i)-4(s)-3( coul)-4(d l)-4(ead t)-4(o)-2( i)-4(n)-2(creased pi)-4(racy)28(.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 454.65 326.07 Tm
0.007 Tc
(153)Tj
12 0 0 12 466.89 320.55 Tm
-0.023 Tc
0.023 Tw
[( It)]TJ
-29.45 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(has been arg)9(u)-1(ed that the cost of piracy)29( in the U.S. is approx)-11(imately)29( $18-20)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(billion a y)30(ear and that companies depending)10( upon copy)30(rig)10(h)0(ts employ)30( about)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(five percent of the U.S. workforce. One must, however, keep in mind that)Tj
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(any)28( fi)-4(g)8(u)-2(re l)-4(i)-4(k)-2(e t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( m)-4(a)2(y)28( not)-4( be accurat)-4(e)2(. I)21( am)-4( of t)-4(h)-2(e opi)-4(ni)-4(on t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e sl)-4(og)8(an)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(\223)5(E)2(ve)5(ry)31( sa)5(le)5( of a)5( pira)5(te)5(d ite)5(m is a)5( lost sa)5(le)5( of a)5( le)5(g)11(itima)5(te)5( ite)5(m\224)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 413.49 255.27 Tm
0.007 Tc
(154)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 425.73 249.75 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
( is not true.)Tj
-26.02 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Many)29( people who buy)29( or download pirate copies would never have boug)9(ht)]TJ
T*
[(the orig)9(inal, due to lack of financial streng)9(th. I)22(f)2( these people g)9(e)3(t their hands)]TJ
T*
[(upon a cheap or free pirated version, they)29( obtain it, but if they)29( would have to)]TJ
T*
[(pay)29( full price they)29( do not.)]TJ
0 -5.06 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 135.51 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 124.71 Tm
(152)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 120.15 Tm
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( BNA)15(\222)12(s)7( El)5(ect)5(ron)10(i)5(c In)10(f)12(o)-2(rm)23(at)5(i)5(o)-2(n)10( Pol)5(i)5(c)2(y)22( an)10(d L)13(a)2(w)27( R)8(e)2(port)5(,)1( Ju)10(l)5(y)22( 18, 1997, pag)10(e)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(741 an)11(d 778.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 101.19 Tm
0 Tc
(153)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 96.63 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(,QWHUQHW\0036HUYLFH\0033URYLGHUV\003VHHN\003WR\003EH\003VKLHOGHG\003IURP\003ODZV\003WDUJHWLQJ\003SLUDWHV)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
29.6145 0 TD
(,)Tj
-30.8434 -1.1807 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(by)22( Bob Dart)5(. T)-12(h)10(e A)15(t)5(l)5(a)2(n)10(t)5(a Jou)10(r)0(n)10(a)2(l)5(,)1( S)6(e)2(pt)5(. 5, 1997, pag)10(e)2( 11A)15(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 77.67 Tm
0 Tc
(154)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 73.11 Tm
-0.004 Tc
0.007 Tw
[( E)-7(l)-3(e)-6(c)-6(t)-3(r)-8(o)-10(nic)-6( E)-7(ngine)-6(e)-6(r)-8(ing T)-20(i)-3(m)15(e)-6(s,)-7( August 1)-10(1)-10(,)-7( )]TJ
17.3735 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(1997, by)23( Bri)6(a)3(n)11( R)9(o)-1(s)8(t)6(, pag)11(e)3( 115.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
387 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
389 0 obj
<<
/Length 6458
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(46)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 743.31 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\032\021\027\021\026)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
[(\(XURSHDQ\003SURSRVDOV\003FRQFHUQLQJ\003,)-7(6)2(3)7(\003)5(OLDELOLW\\)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 714.87 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(A proposal for a Directive harmoniz)-7(i)-3(ng)9( aspects of rules on copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(t and)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(rel)-4(a)2(t)-4(e)2(d ri)-4(g)8(h)-2(t)-4(s)-3( i)-4(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e I)21(n)-2(form)-4(at)-4(i)-4(on S)-6(o)-2(ci)-4(et)-4(y)28( has been present)-4(e)2(d t)-4(o)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e European)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
(Commission)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 174.33 692.07 Tm
0.007 Tc
(155)Tj
12 0 0 12 186.57 686.55 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(. However, the proposed Directive does not include)Tj
-6.09 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(provisions c)5(onc)5(e)5(r)4(ning)11( lia)5(bility)31( of I)24(SPs, due)5( to the)5( fa)5(c)5(t)-1( tha)5(t)-1( lia)5(bility)31( is a)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(horizontal issue. L)21(i)-2(ability)30( of I)23(SPs is to be included in a specific proposal for)]TJ
T*
[(leg)10(i)-2(slation that will be put forward by)30( the Commission during)10( 1998.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 439.89 649.59 Tm
0.007 Tc
(156)Tj
12 0 0 12 113.49 615.75 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(I)22(n)-1( Sweden, a new law has been proposed to ensure that B)6(B)6(S)-5(-operators have)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(a leg)10(a)4(l responsibility)30( to eliminate any)30( posted information that in an)]TJ
T*
[(obviously)30( way)30( infring)10(es upon protected material.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 348.33 592.95 Tm
0.006 Tc
-0.002 Tw
( 157)Tj
12 0 0 12 362.61 587.43 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
( The proposal states that)Tj
-20.76 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(B)7(B)7(S)-4(-ope)4(ra)4(tors will ha)4(ve)4( a)4( rig)10(h)0(t to re)4(a)4(d)0( a)4(nd c)4(ontrol a)4(ll ma)4(te)4(ria)4(l)-2( flowing)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(throug)9(h the sy)29(stem in order to detect and remove infring)9(ing)9( material.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 443.97 564.63 Tm
0.007 Tc
(158)Tj
12 0 0 12 456.21 559.11 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
( The)Tj
-28.56 -1.18 TD
[(B)7(B)7(S)-4(-ope)4(ra)4(tors, howe)4(v)0(e)4(r)3(, will not be)4( lia)4(ble)4( for the)4( infring)10(ing)10( ma)4(te)4(ria)4(l)-2(, but)]TJ
T*
[(the)4(y)30( will be)4( lia)4(ble)4( for not re)4(moving)10( suc)4(h)0( ma)4(te)4(ria)4(l)-2(.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 494.31 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\032\021\027\021\027)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(&DVHV\003VXJJHVWLQJ\003WKDW\003,)-8(6)1(3)6(V)-1(\003RU\003%)7(%)7(6)1(\003RSHUDWRUV\003KDYH\003D)]TJ
-2.6154 -1.1795 TD
0 Tc
(OHJDO\003UHVSRQVLELOLW\\)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 449.31 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Several cases sug)9(g)9(e)3(st that operators of electronic bulletin boards \(B)6(B)6(S)-5(\))]TJ
T*
[(allowing)9( users to upload and download copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(ted material are liable to)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(c)4(opy)30(rig)10(h)0(t infring)10(e)4(m)-2(e)4(n)0(t.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
0 -1.7 TD
0.002 Tc
[(\032\021\027\021\027\021\024\003)-188(1-$\003\024\034\034\031\035)-7(\032\027)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
0 -2.34 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(Thi)-4(s)-3( i)-4(s)-3( a S)-6(w)0(edi)-4(s)-3(h case where a S)-6(w)0(edi)-4(s)-3(h BBS)-6( operat)-4(o)-2(r, Fredri)-4(k H, m)-4(a)2(de)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(over 1000 protected software available to the public on his B)6(B)6(S)-5(. At least)]TJ
T*
[(300 pay)29(i)-3(ng)9( users could access and download the protected software from the)]TJ
T*
[(B)6(B)6(S)-5( using)9( a modem and a computer. Users could upload, trade and)]TJ
T*
[(download whatever software they)29( desired after they)29( had paid a base fee to)]TJ
T*
[(F)5(r)2(edrik. He, himself, merely)29( stored the uploaded software in his base, and)]TJ
T*
[(under such circumstances, it could not be said that F)5(r)2(edrik produced copies)]TJ
T*
[(of the software himself. However, it was stated that by)29( allowing)9( 300 persons)]TJ
T*
[(to barter, borrow and download over 1000 protected prog)9(rams without the)]TJ
T*
[(consent of the owners, it was a matter of copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(t infring)9(ement. F)5(r)2(edrik)]TJ
T*
(claimed that the 300 persons in question, all were his close friends, and that)Tj
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(h)-2(e m)-4(a)2(t)-4(t)-4(e)2(r t)-4(h)-2(erefore was wi)-4(t)-4(h)-2(i)-4(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e pri)-4(v)-2(at)-4(e use sphere. The court)-4(,)-2( however,)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(basically)29( said that nobody)29( has 300 close friends, and ig)9(nored F)5(r)2(edrik\222s)]TJ
T*
[(claim. Therefore, the B)6(B)6(S)-5( operator was responsible for allowing)9( users \(not)]TJ
T*
[(being)9( family)29( or close friends\) to access the protected files.)]TJ
0 -1.53 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 159.03 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 148.23 Tm
(155)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 143.67 Tm
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( Propos)7(al)5( f)12(o)-2(r a Eu)10(ropean)10( Parl)5(i)5(a)2(m)23(e)2(n)10(t)5( an)10(d C)8(o)-2(u)10(n)10(c)2(i)5(l)5( Di)5(rect)5(i)5(v)10(e on)10( t)5(h)10(e)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.004 Tw
[(harm)18(o)-7(n)5(isatio)-7(n o)-7(f)7( certain asp)-7(ects o)-7(f)7( co)-7(p)-7(y)17(right and)-7( related)-7( rights in the)]TJ
T*
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(In)10(f)12(o)-2(rm)23(at)5(i)5(o)-2(n)10( S)6(o)-2(ci)5(et)5(y)22(,)1( C)8(O)3(M\(97\)628. Dat)5(e)2(d Bru)10(s)7(s)7(e)2(l)5(s)7(. 10.12.1997.)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 112.95 Tm
0 Tc
(156)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 108.39 Tm
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( Sin)8(g)8(l)3(e Mark)8(et New)25(s)5(, T)-14(h)8(e New)25(s)5(letter of)10( DG XV \226 In)8(tern)8(al Mark)8(et an)8(d)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(F)6(i)5(n)10(a)2(n)10(c)2(i)5(a)2(l)5( S)6(e)2(rv)10(i)5(ces)7(, No 10, Dec 1997, pag)10(e)2( 22-)12(23.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
0 Tc
(157)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 84.87 Tm
0.004 Tc
[( 5 \247 L)13(a)2(g)10( \(1998:)5(000\) om)23( an)10(s)7(v)10(ar f)12(\366)-2(r el)5(ek)10(t)5(r)0(on)10(i)5(s)7(k)10(a)2( an)10(s)7(l)5(ag)10(s)7(t)5(av)10(l)5(o)-2(r.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 77.67 Tm
0 Tc
(158)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 73.11 Tm
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[( Prop. 1997/)6(98:)6(15 pag)11(e)3( 4.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
390 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
391 0 obj
<<
/Length 6152
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(47)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
-14.85 58.92 TD
0.002 Tc
[(\032\021\027\021\027\021\025\003)-188(3OD\\)17(ER\\)17(\003)2(\(QW)7(H)-3(USULVHV\003Y)17(\021)0(\003\)UHQD)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 320.49 751.23 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(159)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 717.15 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(A B)7(B)7(S)-4( ope)4(ra)4(tor, Ge)4(org)10(e)4( F)6(r)3(e)4(n)0(a)4(,)0( c)4(ould not e)4(s)-1(c)4(a)4(p)0(e)4( lia)4(bility)30( for c)4(opy)30(rig)10(h)0(t)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(infring)9(ement, althoug)9(h he was not aware that his subscribers uploaded and)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(downloaded over 170 copy)30(rig)10(h)0(ted Play)30(boy)30( photog)10(raphs from his B)7(B)7(S)-4(.)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(F)5(r)2(ena claimed that he never uploaded any)29( of Play)29(boy)29(\222s photog)9(raphs onto his)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(B)7(B)7(S)-4( himself and that only)30( subscribers to his B)7(B)7(S)-4( uploaded photog)10(raphs.)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(Frena furt)-4(her st)-4(at)-4(ed t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( he hi)-4(m)-4(s)-3(el)-4(f had never pl)-4(aced t)-4(h)-2(e pi)-4(ct)-4(ures, nor t)-4(h)-2(e)]TJ
T*
[(words \223P)-6(l)-4(a)2(y)28(boy)28(\224 or \223P)-6(l)-4(a)2(y)28(m)-4(at)-4(e\224 ont)-4(o t)-4(h)-2(e BBS)-6(. Frena sai)-4(d)-2( he i)-4(nnocent)-4(l)-4(y)28( and)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(without malice, allowed subscribers to upload whatever they)29( wanted onto)]TJ
T*
[(his B)6(B)6(S)-5(. As soon as he was made aware of the matter, he removed the)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(photog)10(raphs from his B)7(B)7(S)-4(. He further claimed that he then monitored the)]TJ
T*
[(B)7(B)7(S)-4( to prevent additional photog)10(raphs of PEI)23( from being)10( uploaded. An)]TJ
T*
[(inte)4(re)4(sting)10( fa)4(c)4(t)-2( is tha)4(t)-2( F)6(r)3(e)4(n)0(a)4( a)4(tte)4(mpte)4(d to ta)4(ke)4( c)4(r)3(e)4(d)0(it for Pla)4(y)30(boy)30(\222s work by)]TJ
T*
[(placing)10( its own advertisement with its phone number on some of the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(photog)9(raphs. Such removal of Play)29(boy)29(\222s trademarks from the photog)9(raphs)]TJ
T*
[(constituted \224reverse passing)9( off\224 according)9( to the court.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
[(Public distribution of a copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(ted work is a rig)9(h)-1(t reserved to the copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(t)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(owner. The court concluded that the display)29( on the B)6(B)6(S)-5( of Play)29(boy)29(\222s)]TJ
T*
[(copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(ted photog)9(raphs to the subscribers was a matter of public display)29(.)-1( I)22(t)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(wa)4(s the)4(r)3(e)4(f)3(ore)4(,)0( a)4( ma)4(tte)4(r of infring)10(e)4(m)-2(e)4(n)0(t. I)23( find it inte)4(re)4(sting)10( tha)4(t)-2( F)6(r)3(e)4(n)0(a)4( wa)4(s)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(found liable for infring)9(ement, even thoug)9(h he may)29( have been unaware of the)]TJ
T*
[(files being)9( copied. The court stated: \223I)22(t does not matter that Defendant F)5(r)2(ena)]TJ
T*
[(may)29( have been unaware of the copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(t infring)9(ement. I)22(n)-1(tent to infring)9(e is)]TJ
T*
[(not needed to find copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(t infring)9(ement. I)22(n)-1(tent or knowledg)9(e is not an)]TJ
T*
[(element of infring)9(ement, and thus even an innocent infring)9(er is liable for)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
[(i)-4(n)-2(fri)-4(ng)8(em)-4(ent)-4(\224)2(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 183.57 354.51 Tm
0.007 Tc
(160)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 195.81 348.99 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( This states that B)7(B)7(S)-4( operators and perhaps I)23(SPs can be)]TJ
-6.86 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(liable even thoug)9(h they)29( are not aware of the infring)9(ing)9(.)-1( L)20(ack of knowledg)9(e)]TJ
T*
[(may)29( therefore not a valid defense. I)22(t)-3( g)9(i)-3(ves an incentive to scan and monitor)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(e)4(v)0(e)4(r)3(y)30( me)4(ssa)4(g)10(e)4( flowing)10( throug)10(h a)4( sy)30(ste)4(m)-2(, in orde)4(r to a)4(void lia)4(bility)30(.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
0 -2.88 TD
0.002 Tc
[(\032\021\027\021\027\021\026\003)-188(6HJD\003\(QW)7(HUSULVHV\003/W)7(G\021\0039\021\0030)6(D)-3(SKLD)]TJ
/T3 1 Tf
8.039 0 0 8.039 339.33 277.95 Tm
0 Tc
(\024\031\024)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 243.87 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Seg)9(a)3(, the video g)9(a)3(me manufacturer filed a suit for copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(t infring)9(ement)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(ag)8(ai)-4(nst)-4( a BBS)-6( cal)-4(l)-4(e)2(d Maphi)-4(a. C)-5(h)-2(ad S)-6(h)-2(erm)-4(a)2(n \(S)-6(herm)-4(an\) was t)-4(h)-2(e sy)28(st)-4(em)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(operator of the B)6(B)6(S)-5( Maphia, which had about 400 users swapping)9( files.)]TJ
T*
[(Users needed a password in order to log)9( on to the B)6(B)6(S)-5(.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
[(S)-5(e)3(g)9(a)3( received an anony)29(mous tip that S)-5(h)-1(erman operated a BBS)-5(, which)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(contained and distributed pirated and unauthoriz)-7(ed versions of Seg)9(a)3(\222s video)]TJ
0 -1.81 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 140.31 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 129.51 Tm
(159)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 124.95 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(3OD\\ER\\\003\(QWHUSULVHV\017\003,QF\021\003Y\003\)UHQD)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
13.6265 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(, 839 F)7(.)2( S)7(u)11(pp. 1552 \(M.D. F)7(l)6(ori)6(d)-1(a 1993\))]TJ
-14.8554 -1.1807 TD
-0.022 Tc
0.025 Tw
[(H)-23(t)-21(t)-21(p)-28(:)-21(/)-21(/)-21(www.)-25(l)-21(e)-24(e)-24(p)-28(f)-14(r)-26(o)-28(g)-16(.)-25(c)-24(o)-28(m)-3(/)-21(E)-25(-)-14(L)-13(a)-24(w)1(/)-21(C)-18(a)-24(s)-19(e)-24(s)-19(/)-21(P)-32(l)-21(a)-24(yb)-28(o)-28(y)-4(_)-28(v)-16(_)-28(F)-20(r)-26(e)-24(n)-16(a)-24(.)-25(h)-16(t)-21(m)-3(l)-21( \()]TJ
25.8072 0 TD
0.006 Tc
(971212\))Tj
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 105.99 Tm
0 Tc
(160)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 101.43 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.004 Tw
[( Quo)-7(ting the co)-7(urt.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 141.81 93.27 Tm
0.007 Tc
(161)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 154.05 87.75 Tm
0 Tc
13.19 Tw
[( Http://www.leepfrog)10(.)0(com/E-)]TJ
-1.02 -1.18 TD
0 Tw
[(L)21(a)4(w/Cases/Seg)10(a)4(_v_MAPHI)23(A2.html \(971208\))]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
392 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F5 276 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
/T3 393 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
394 0 obj
<<
/Length 4746
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(48)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
0 Tw
[(g)10(a)4(me)4( softwa)4(re)4(. At the)4( time)4( of the)4( ra)4(id, the)4( Ma)4(phia)4( B)7(B)7(S)-4( c)4(onta)4(i)-2(ne)4(d twe)4(l)-2(ve)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(unauthoriz)-6(ed copies of Seg)10(a)4( g)10(a)4(mes, ten Seg)10(a)4(-licensed g)10(a)4(mes, and six)-10( Seg)10(a)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(beta version g)9(a)3(mes. I)22(t)-3( was proved in the case that Sherman was well aware)]TJ
T*
[(of the fact that the users uploaded and downloaded copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(ted g)9(a)3(mes from)]TJ
T*
-0.006 Tc
0.006 Tw
[(t)-8(h)-6(e BBS)-10(.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Seg)9(a)3( stated that Sherman, as the B)6(B)6(S)-5( operator, was liable for copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(t)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(infring)9(ement. I)22(n)-1( order to have Sherman liable of direct copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(t)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(infring)10(ement, Seg)10(a)4( had to prove its ownership of a valid copy)30(rig)10(h)0(t in the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(infring)9(ed work, and that Sherman had copied the material. Seg)9(a)3( could not)]TJ
T*
[(prove that Sherman did the copy)29(ing)9( himself. However, nobody)29( could deny)]TJ
T*
(that copies were made, as the files were uploaded and downloaded from the)Tj
T*
[(Maphia B)6(B)6(S)-5(, and thus, copy)29(ing)9( made by)29( )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
16.6 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(V)-9(R)1(PHRQH)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
3.49 0 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[( was a fact)-4(. S)-6(i)-4(nce S)-6(e)2(g)8(a)]TJ
-20.09 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(could not prove that Sherman directly)29( caused the copy)29(ing)9(,)-1( he could not be)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(l)-4(i)-4(a)2(bl)-4(e for di)-4(rect)-4( i)-4(n)-2(fri)-4(ng)8(em)-4(ent)-4(.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Seg)9(a)3( then claimed that Sherman was liable for contributory)29( infring)9(ement.)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Contributory)30( copy)30(rig)10(h)0(t infring)10(ement stems from the idea that one who)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
[(directly)30( contributes to another\222s infring)10(ement should be held liable. I)23(n)0( order)]TJ
T*
[(to prove that, Seg)10(a)4( had to establish that the users of the B)7(B)7(S)-4( directly)]TJ
T*
[(infring)10(ed Seg)10(a)4(\222s copy)30(rig)10(h)0(t. Seg)10(a)4( also had to establish that Sherman knew)]TJ
T*
[(about the infring)10(ing)10( activities, and that Sherman materially)30( contributed to,)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(c)5(a)5(u)1(se)5(d or induc)5(e)5(d)1( the)5( infring)11(ing)11( a)5(c)5(tivitie)5(s. Se)5(g)11(a)5( ma)5(na)5(g)11(e)5(d to prove)5( a)5(ll of the)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(above. Sherman had intentionally)30( contributed to the users\222 infring)10(ement of)]TJ
T*
[(Seg)10(a)4(\222s copy)30(rig)10(h)0(t.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Sherman arg)9(u)-1(ed that the copy)29(ing)9( of files fitted under the fair use defense)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(si)-4(nce t)-4(h)-2(e users sol)-4(e)2(l)-4(y)28( used t)-4(h)-2(e copi)-4(es at)-4( hom)-4(e and t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( any)28( copy)28(ri)-4(g)8(h)-2(t)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
(violation was de minimis. The court found that Sherman failed to prove fair)Tj
T*
[(use, and thus stated that Sherman\222s role in the copy)30(ing)10( of Seg)10(a)4( g)10(a)4(mes was a)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(case of contributory)29( copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(t infring)9(ement.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 270.03 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\032\021\027\021\030)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(&DVHV\003GHQ\\LQJ\003,)-8(6)1(3)6(\003)4(RU\003%)7(%)7(6)1(\003RSHUDWRU\003UHVSRQVLELOLW\\)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 207.03 Tm
0.002 Tc
[(\032\021\027\021\030\021\024\003)-188(1-$\003\024\034\034\031\035)-7(\032\034\003\2637KH\003%%6\020FDVH\264)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
0 -2.34 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(This is a Swedish case from 1996, where a Swedish B)6(B)6(S)-5( operator, L)20(a)3(rs R,)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
(allowed subscribers to upload and download various software. At least 35)Tj
T*
[(copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(ted prog)9(rams were found on the B)6(B)6(S)-5(. About 40 users were allowed)]TJ
T*
[(to download all files \(including)9( the copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(ted ones\), while other users had)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(access onl)-4(y)28( t)-4(o)-2( ot)-4(her prog)8(ram)-4(s)-3( \(m)-4(ost)-4( shareware, freeware and bet)-4(a)2(-versi)-4(ons\).)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(The Swedish Supreme court, H\366g)9(s)-2(ta Domstolen \(HD\) held that in g)9(e)3(neral,)]TJ
T*
[(uploading)9( as well as downloading)9( of protected software is copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(t)]TJ
T*
[(infring)9(ement, since it is not a matter of private use. This was, however, not)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
395 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
396 0 obj
<<
/Length 6177
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(49)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(the main question in the case. The basic question was, if solely)29( placing)9( a)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(B)7(B)7(S)-4( at disposal is enoug)10(h to fulfill the requirement of activity)30( needed in)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(order t)-4(o)-2( est)-4(a)2(bl)-4(i)-4(s)-3(h t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( copy)28(ri)-4(g)8(h)-2(t)-4( i)-4(n)-2(fri)-4(ng)8(em)-4(ent)-4( has t)-4(a)2(ken pl)-4(ace. The court)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(sta)4(t)-2(e)4(d)0( tha)4(t)-2( the)4( re)4(quire)4(me)4(nt of a)4(c)4(tivity)30( wa)4(s not fulfille)4(d due)4( to the)4( fa)4(c)4(t)-2( tha)4(t)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(L)20(a)3(rs R had not done any)29(t)-3(hing)9( to the files placed in his BBS)-5(. He was)]TJ
T*
[(passively)29( watching)9( the users uploading)9( and downloading)9( the software. I)22(f)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(L)21(a)4(rs R had tried to destroy)30( the files or limit the access to them but failed)]TJ
T*
[(pa)4(rtia)4(lly)30( to do so, the)4( re)4(quire)4(me)4(nt of a)4(c)4(tivity)30( would ha)4(ve)4( be)4(e)4(n)0( fulfille)4(d a)4(n)0(d)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(he would have been liable for copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(t infring)9(ement. The messag)9(e)3( of the)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(court is basically)30( the following)10(: do not try)30( to remove protected software)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(from the B)6(B)6(S)-5( unless y)29(ou are 100% sure that y)29(ou will be able remove all)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(file)4(s. I)23(t)-2( is be)4(tte)4(r not to c)4(a)4(r)3(e)4( in orde)4(r to a)4(void fulfilling)10( the)4( re)4(quire)4(me)4(nt of)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(act)-4(i)-4(v)-2(i)-4(t)-4(y)28(. The court)-4( decl)-4(ared t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e l)-4(a)2(w)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 303.69 581.07 Tm
0.007 Tc
(162)Tj
12 0 0 12 315.93 575.55 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
( was not prepared for modern)Tj
-16.87 -1.18 TD
(problems like this, and needs to be revised in order to offer a satisfactory)Tj
T*
[(protection for software when stored on a B)6(B)6(S)-5(.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
0 -2.88 TD
0.002 Tc
[(\032\021\027\021\030\021\025\003)-188(=HUDQ\003Y)17(\021\003$PHULFD\0032QOLQH)]TJ
/T3 1 Tf
8.039 0 0 8.039 293.37 518.67 Tm
0 Tc
(\024\031\026)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 484.59 Tm
0 Tw
[(Ke)4(nne)4(th M. Z)11(e)4(ra)4(n \(Z)11(e)4(r)3(a)4(n)0(\) wa)4(s a)4( vic)4(tim of a)4( dista)4(s)-1(te)4(ful hoa)4(x)-10( pe)4(rpe)4(t)-2(ra)4(te)4(d via)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(the I)22(n)-1(ternet services of America Online, I)22(n)-1(c. \(AOL)20(\). Somebody)29( posted)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
[(Z)10(e)3(ran\222s name and phone number tog)9(e)3(ther with an advertisement for t-shirts)]TJ
T*
[(and other items carry)29(ing)9( various slog)9(ans g)9(l)-3(orify)29(i)-3(ng)9( the Oklahoma bombing)]TJ
T*
[(in which 168 people died. Of course, Z)10(e)3(ran was bombarded with disturbing)]TJ
T*
[(and threatening)9( telephone calls from people who were offended by)29( the)]TJ
T*
[(posted notice. Z)10(e)3(ran complained to AOL)20( \(Z)10(eran was not an AOL)20( subscriber\))]TJ
T*
[(and asked t)-3(o)-1( have t)-3(h)-1(e di)-3(sg)9(raceful)-3( m)-3(e)3(ssag)9(e)3(s rem)-3(oved. The sam)-3(e)3( day)29( \(Apri)-3(l)]TJ
T*
[(26, 1995\) as these were deleted, another similar messag)9(e)3( was posted. Z)10(e)3(ran)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(had to put up with more ang)10(r)3(y)30( phonecalls. The person or persons posting)10( the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(messag)9(e)3(s could not be found since false names had been used when)]TJ
T*
[(reg)9(i)-3(stering)9( the AOL)20( service. On may)29( 1, 1995, a radio station in Oklahoma)]TJ
T*
[(read the posted notice on the air and encourag)9(ed listeners to call Z)10(e)3(ran and)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(e)2(l)-4(l)-4( hi)-4(m)-4( how di)-4(sg)8(ust)-4(e)2(d t)-4(h)-2(ey)28( were. Z)9(e)2(ran recei)-4(ved num)-4(erous deat)-4(h t)-4(h)-2(reat)-4(s)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(from ang)9(r)2(y)29( people believing)9( that he vended the offending)9( material.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
[(Z)10(e)3(ran sued AOL)20( and claimed that AOL)20( had been neg)9(lig)9(ent due to the fact)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(that AOL)20( allowed the notices to remain and reappear on AOL)20(\222s B)6(B)6(S)-5( even)]TJ
T*
[(thoug)9(h Z)10(e)3(ran had noticed and complained about it. Z)10(e)3(ran claimed that)]TJ
T*
[(distributors of information are liable for distributing)9( material which they)]TJ
T*
[(know is of a defamatory)29( character. AOL)20( required the case to be dismissed)]TJ
T*
[(since it violated section 230 of the Communications Decency)29( Act of 1996)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(\(CDA\). AOL)21( a)4(r)3(g)10(u)0(e)4(d)0( tha)4(t)-2( by)30( imposing)10( lia)4(bility)30( on it for ha)4(rm c)4(a)4(u)0(se)4(d by)30( the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(posted messag)9(e)3(s, it would be treated as the \223publisher\224 of third-party)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(c)4(onte)4(n)0(t. This would re)4(quire)4( supe)4(rvising)10(,)0( e)4(d)0(iting)10( a)4(nd c)4(e)4(n)0(soring)10( of a)4(l)-2(l)]TJ
T*
[(material orig)10(inating)10( from third parties. Z)11(e)4(ran claimed that section 230 would)]TJ
0 -1.81 TD
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 111.99 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 101.19 Tm
(162)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 96.63 Tm
0.003 Tc
[( L)12(a)1(g)9( \(1960:729\) om)22( u)9(pph)9(ov)9(s)6(r)-1(\344tt till litter\344ra v)9(e)1(rk)9( och)9( k)9(o)-3(n)9(s)6(tn)9(\344rlig)9(a v)9(e)1(rk)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
0 Tc
(163)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 84.87 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(=HUDQ\003Y\021\003$PHULFD\0032QOLQH)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.9879 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(, 958 F)7( S)7(u)11(pp.1124 \(E.D. Va. 1997\))]TJ
-11.2169 -1.1807 TD
-0.022 Tc
0.025 Tw
[(H)-23(t)-21(t)-21(p)-28(:)-21(/)-21(/)-21(www.)-25(b)-28(n)-16(a)-24(.)-25(c)-24(o)-28(m/)-21(e)-24(-)-14(l)-21(a)-24(w/)-21(c)-24(a)-24(s)-19(e)-24(s)-19(/)-21(z)-24(e)-24(r)-26(a)-24(n)-16(.)-25(h)-16(t)-21(m)-3(l)-21( \()]TJ
18.3253 0 TD
0.006 Tc
(971208\))Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
397 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
/T3 393 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
398 0 obj
<<
/Length 6303
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(50)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(not hinde)5(r his suit, due)5( to the)5( fa)5(c)5(t)-1( tha)5(t)-1( he)5( did not se)5(e)5(k)1( to impose)5( lia)5(bility)31( for)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
0 -1.18 TD
[(\223)5(publishing)11(\224)5( the)5( me)5(ssa)5(g)11(e)5(s. He)5( soug)11(ht to impose)5( lia)5(bility)31( on AOL)22( for)]TJ
T*
[(\223)5(n)1(e)5(g)11(lig)11(e)5(n)1(tly)31( distributing)11(\224)5( the)5( poste)5(d me)5(ssa)5(g)11(e)5(s a)5(f)4(te)5(r be)5(ing)11( informe)5(d)1( tha)5(t)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(these were bog)9(us ads. The court stated that Z)10(e)3(ran\222s suit was in violation of)]TJ
T*
[(section 230. AOL)20( was not found to be responsible for the posted messag)9(e)3(s)]TJ
T*
[(on the B)6(B)6(S)-5(.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
0 -2.88 TD
0.002 Tc
[(\032\021\027\021\030\021\026\003)-188('RH\003Y)17(\021)0(\003$PHULFD\0032QOLQH\003,QF\021)]TJ
/T3 1 Tf
8.039 0 0 8.039 307.41 646.11 Tm
0 Tc
(\024\031\027)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 612.03 Tm
0 Tw
[(I)23(n)0( 1994, Richard L)21(ee Russell \(Russel\) committed sex)-10(u)0(al battery)30( on J)-11(ohn)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Doe \(Doe\), who was then eleven y)29(ears old, and two other minor males. The)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(sma)4(ll boy)30(s we)4(re)4( forc)4(e)4(d)0( to pe)4(rform va)4(rious se)4(x)-10(u)0(a)4(l)-2( a)4(c)4(tivitie)4(s with Russe)4(l a)4(n)0(d)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(with one another. These sex)-11(u)-1(al acts were videotaped and photog)9(raphed.)]TJ
T*
[(Russel used AOL)20( services such as AOL)20( chat-rooms in order to sell the)]TJ
T*
[(videotape and the photog)9(raphs to other subscribers. Doe stated that AOL)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(ha)4(d be)4(e)4(n)0( informe)4(d)0( tha)4(t)-2( its se)4(rvic)4(e)4( wa)4(s be)4(ing)10( use)4(d)0( for ma)4(rke)4(ting)10( of c)4(h)0(ild)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(pornog)9(raphy)29( material. Doe had also complained to AOL)20( reg)9(a)3(rding)9( Russell.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Doe)4( sue)4(d)0( AOL)21( c)4(l)-2(a)4(iming)10( tha)4(t)-2( AOL)21( ha)4(d be)4(e)4(n)0( ne)4(g)10(lig)10(e)4(n)0(t a)4(nd viola)4(t)-2(e)4(d)0( F)6(l)-2(orida)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(c)5(r)4(imina)5(l)-1( obsc)5(e)5(n)1(ity)31( la)5(ws sinc)5(e)5( it ha)5(d not e)5(a)5(r)4(lie)5(r pre)5(v)1(e)5(n)1(te)5(d Russe)5(l\222s a)5(c)5(tivitie)5(s)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(on its se)4(rvic)4(e)4(s)-1(. The)4( re)4(a)4(s)-1(oning)10( of the)4( c)4(ourt wa)4(s ve)4(ry)30( simila)4(r to tha)4(t)-2( in )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
27.56 0 TD
0.005 Tc
[(=H)11(UD)11(Q)]TJ
-27.56 -1.18 TD
-0.004 Tc
(Y\021\003$2/)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
2.83 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(, since the court based its decision upon it. Doe\222s claims were)Tj
-2.83 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(dismissed. AOL)21( was not responsible for the detestable acts of Russel.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 377.31 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\032\021\027\021\031)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(0)23(XVLF\003DUFKLYHV\003LQ\003&\\EHUVSDFH)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 334.71 Tm
0.001 Tw
[(During)9( the end of 1996 and the beg)9(i)-3(nning)9( of 1997, websites started to)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(supply)30( the I)23(n)0(ternet community)30( with hug)10(e archives of song)10(s in MP3 format.)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Any)29(one visiting)9( such a website or F)5(T)0(P can often find very)29( new and popular)]TJ
T*
[(song)9(s, ready)29( for downloading)9(. The website owner usually)29( never charg)9(e)3(s)]TJ
T*
[(any)29(t)-3(hing)9(. I)22(t)-3( is a peculiar situation, since we all know that \223there are no free)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(lunc)5(he)5(s\224)5(. Some)5(time)5(s, howe)5(v)1(e)5(r)4(, use)5(r)4(s a)5(r)4(e)5( e)5(n)1(c)5(oura)5(g)11(e)5(d)1( to uploa)5(d song)11(s to the)]TJ
T*
0.002 Tc
[(site)6(s.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 137.85 255.27 Tm
0.007 Tc
(165)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 150.09 249.75 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( W)-7(h)-1(y)29( would any)29(one take the risk of supply)29(i)-3(ng)9( the I)22(n)-1(ternet)]TJ
-3.05 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(community)30( with illeg)10(a)4(lly)30( uploaded song)10(s, without any)30( financial g)10(a)4(in at all?)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(P)-6(e)2(rhaps websi)-4(t)-4(e)2(s t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( g)8(e)2(nerat)-4(e)2( a hi)-4(g)8(h)-2( num)-4(ber of hi)-4(t)-4(s)-3( are abl)-4(e)2( t)-4(o)-2( recei)-4(ve)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(profitable contracts with unscrupulous advertisers, not afraid of being)Tj
0 -4.28 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 159.03 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 148.23 Tm
(164)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 143.67 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
('RH\003Y\021\003$PHULFD\0032QOLQH\003,QF\021)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
11.0602 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, C)8(L)13( 97-)12(63\(F)6(l)5(a. C)8(i)5(r. C)8(t)5(., P)-6(a)2(lm)23( Beach)10( C)8(o)-2(.1997)]TJ
-12.2892 -1.1807 TD
-0.021 Tc
0.024 Tw
[(H)-22(t)-20(t)-20(p)-27(:)-20(/)-20(/)-20(www.)-24(n)-15(a)-23(v)-15(i)-20(t)-20(u)-15(s)-18(.)-24(c)-23(o)-27(m/)-20(i)-20(c)-23(o)-27(n)-15(s)-18(/)-20(n)-15(e)-23(t)-20(w)2(o)-27(r)-25(k)-15(l)-20(a)-23(w)2(/)-20(c)-23(a)-23(s)-18(e)-23(_)-27(D)-22(o)-27(e)-23(.)-24(h)-15(t)-20(m \()]TJ
23.6867 0 TD
0.006 Tc
(971208\))Tj
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 124.71 Tm
0 Tc
(165)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 120.15 Tm
0.003 Tw
[( So)-6(m)19(e)-2( sites are \223)10(r)-4(atio)-6( sites\224 w)23(h)6(ere y)18(o)-6(u are no)-6(t allo)-6(w)23(e)-2(d)-6( to)-6( d)-6(o)-6(w)23(nlo)-6(a)-2(d)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.004 Tw
[(any)17(t)0(hing if)7( y)17(o)-7(u d)-7(o)-7( no)-7(t up)-7(lo)-7(ad)-7( new)22( \(no)-7(t)0( alread)-7(y)17( sto)-7(r)-5(ed)-7( in the site\) m)18(a)-3(terial)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0.003 Tw
[(p)-6(r)-4(io)-6(r to)-6( d)-6(o)-6(w)23(nlo)-6(a)-2(d)-6(i)1(ng. Fo)-6(r instance, so)-6(m)19(e)-2( sites co)-6(uld)-6( call them)19(selves 1)-6(:)1(5)-6( ratio)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.004 Tw
[(sites, m)18(eaning that if)7( o)-7(n)5(e up)-7(lo)-7(ad)-7(s o)-7(n)5(e MB)-9(, o)-7(n)5(e is allo)-7(w)22(e)-3(d)-7( to)-7( d)-7(o)-7(w)22(nlo)-7(a)-3(d)-7( f)7(i)0(ve)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(MB)-7( f)9(r)-3(o)-5(m)20( the site.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
399 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
/T3 393 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
400 0 obj
<<
/Length 6519
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(51)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
0 Tw
[(a)4(ssoc)4(i)-2(a)4(t)-2(e)4(d)0( with pira)4(te)4( we)4(bsite)4(s)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 261.57 750.99 Tm
0.007 Tc
(166)Tj
12 0 0 12 273.81 745.47 Tm
0 Tc
[(, but I)23( am sure this is not the g)10(e)4(neral)]TJ
-13.36 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(situation. The music industry)29(,)-1( I)22( believe, did not realiz)-7(e the potential dang)9(er)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(of t)-4(h)-2(e g)8(r)1(owi)-4(n)-2(g)8( num)-4(ber of m)-4(u)-2(si)-4(c archi)-4(v)-2(es i)-4(n)-2( C)-5(y)28(berspace at)-4( fi)-4(rst)-4(.)-2( Duri)-4(ng)8( t)-4(h)-2(e)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(late spring)9( and early)29( summer of 1997, the music industry)29( reacted to this)]TJ
T*
[(ex)-11(tremely)29( rapidly)29( g)9(r)2(owing)9( hobby)29( of many)29( devoted I)22(n)-1(ternet users throug)9(hout)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(the I)23(n)0(ternet community)30(. I)23(t)-2( was the B)7(r)3(itish pop g)10(r)3(oup Oasis that partly)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(t)-3(r)2(i)-3(g)9(g)9(e)3(red t)-3(h)-1(e cont)-3(ent)-3(i)-3(ous debat)-3(e)3( concerni)-3(ng)9( copy)29(ri)-3(g)9(h)-1(t)-3( i)-3(n)-1( C)-4(y)29(berspace. S)-5(o)-1(m)-3(e)]TJ
T*
[(pop bands, such as U2 discovered their tracks available on the I)22(n)-1(ternet)]TJ
T*
[(before officially)29( released.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 235.65 637.71 Tm
0.007 Tc
(167)Tj
12 0 0 12 113.49 603.87 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(The music industry)29( in the U.S. was terrified, and the Recording)9( I)22(ndustry)29( of)]TJ
T*
[(America \(RI)22(AA\) requested, on behalf of several of its members, the)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(shutdown of three U.S. websites distributing)10( sound recording)10(s)-1( on J)-11(une 9 and)]TJ
T*
[(10, 1997. F)6(e)4(deral district courts in California, N.Y. and Tex)-10(a)4(s issued)]TJ
T*
[(te)4(mpora)4(r)3(y)30( re)4(stra)4(ining)10( orde)4(rs dire)4(c)4(ting)10( the)4( I)23(SPs to c)4(o)0(mple)4(te)4(ly)30( bloc)4(k the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(unauthoriz)-7(ed recording)9(s)-2(, and to g)9(u)-1(ard the evidence.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 361.41 538.59 Tm
0.007 Tc
(168)Tj
12 0 0 12 373.65 533.07 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( Thre)4(e)4( la)4(wsuits we)4(re)]TJ
-21.68 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(fi)-4(l)-4(e)2(d ag)8(ai)-4(nst)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e archi)-4(v)-2(e si)-4(t)-4(e)2(s)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 252.45 524.43 Tm
0.007 Tc
(169)Tj
12 0 0 12 264.69 518.91 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
( and are considered to be first of this kind.)Tj
-12.6 -1.18 TD
[(The three operators may)29( face up to $100,000 in damag)9(e)3(s for each infring)9(ed)]TJ
T*
[(copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(ted recording)9(.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 221.97 496.11 Tm
0.007 Tc
(170)Tj
12 0 0 12 234.21 490.59 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( The RI)23(AA strives to put current copy)30(rig)10(h)0(t law to)]TJ
-10.06 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(the)5( te)5(st in the)5( c)5(onte)5(x)-9(t of the)5( I)24(n)1(te)5(rne)5(t)-1(. I)24(n)1( the)5( me)5(a)5(n)1(time)5(, ma)5(ny)31( c)5(o)1(mpa)5(n)1(ie)5(s)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(anx)-11(i)-3(ous to protect their copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(ts ag)9(ainst the increasing)9( problem of dig)9(ital)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(pi)-4(racy)28( hi)-4(re di)-4(g)8(i)-4(t)-4(a)2(l)-4( det)-4(ect)-4(i)-4(v)-2(es t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( surf t)-4(h)-2(e I)21(n)-2(t)-4(e)2(rnet)-4( searchi)-4(n)-2(g)8( for)]TJ
T*
[(i)-4(n)-2(fri)-4(ng)8(em)-4(ent)-4(s)-3(.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 182.97 439.47 Tm
0.007 Tc
(171)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 410.19 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(\032\021\030\003)-436(/HJDO\003UHVSRQVLELOLW\\)10(\003)1(Z)-15(K)0(HQ\003GRZ)-15(QORDGLQJ)]TJ
T*
(SURWHFWHG\003PDWHULDO)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 360.51 Tm
0.001 Tw
[(One must not forg)9(et that every)29( day)29( millions of people around the g)9(l)-3(obe)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(download material that they)30( find on the I)23(n)0(ternet. Much of this material is, of)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(course, protected. W)-7(ho is liable when downloading)9( of such material occur?)]TJ
T*
[(I)22(s)-2( the situation the same concerning)9( software, music and pictures?)-17( Are all)]TJ
T*
[(users who download protected material from the net, infring)9(ing)9( upon)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(somebody)30( else\222s copy)30(rig)10(h)0(ts?)]TJ
0 -8.21 TD
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 194.31 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 183.51 Tm
(166)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 178.95 Tm
0.001 Tc
0.002 Tw
[( It seem)20(s lik)7(e th)7(e porn)7(-)9(in)7(du)7(stry)19( does n)7(o)-5(t care if)9( its ban)7(n)7(e)-1(r ads are display)19(e)-1(d)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.004 Tw
[(in co)-7(nnectio)-7(n w)22(ith illegal m)18(u)5(sic archives and)-7( o)-7(t)0(her w)22(a)-3(rez sites.)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 159.99 Tm
0 Tc
(167)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 155.43 Tm
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( T)-12(h)10(e Gu)10(ardi)5(an)10( \(L)13(on)10(don)10(\), May)22( 16, 1997 pag)10(e)2( 12. On)10(e can)10( on)10(l)5(y)22( s)7(p)-2(ecu)10(l)5(a)2(t)5(e)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(h)8(o)-4(w)25( an)8(y)20(o)-4(n)8(e)0( can)8( receiv)8(e)0( a track)8( n)8(o)-4(t y)20(e)0(t released.)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 136.47 Tm
0 Tc
(168)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 131.91 Tm
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( BNA)15( Pat)5(e)2(n)10(t)5(, T)-12(r)0(adem)23(ark)10( &)11( C)8(opy)22(ri)5(g)10(h)10(t)5( L)13(a)2(w)27( Dai)5(l)5(y)22(, Ju)10(n)10(e)2( 13, 1997.)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 124.71 Tm
0 Tc
(169)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 120.15 Tm
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[( Kn)9(ow)26(n)9( as)6(: f)11(t)4(p://208.197.0.28 an)9(d f)11(t)4(p://pars)6(o)-3(f)11(t)4(.com)22(/MP)-7(3)-3(s)6( an)9(d Fres)6(h)9( Ku)9(tz.)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
0 Tc
0.003 Tw
[(A)11(ll the o)-6(p)-6(e)-2(rato)-6(rs w)23(e)-2(re no)-6(t id)-6(entif)8(ied)-6( at the tim)19(e o)-6(f)8( the suits.)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 101.19 Tm
(170)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 96.63 Tm
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( Dai)5(l)5(y)22( Vari)5(et)5(y)22(,)1( Ju)10(n)10(e)2( 10, 1997, pag)10(e)2( 1, by)22( C)8(h)10(ri)5(s)7(t)5(of)12(f)12(e)2(r S)6(t)5(ern)10(.)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
0 Tc
(171)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 84.87 Tm
-0.004 Tc
0.007 Tw
[( T)-20(h)2(e)-6( Fina)-6(nc)-6(ia)-6(l P)-14(o)-10(st,)-7( August 2)-10(8)-10(,)-7( )]TJ
12.9036 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(1997, by)22( A)15(l)5(i)5(ce R)8(a)2(w)27(s)7(t)5(h)10(orn)10(,)1( F)6(i)5(n)10(a)2(n)10(c)2(i)5(a)2(l)]TJ
-13.8795 -1.1807 TD
0.016 Tc
[(Ti)17(m)35(e)14(s)19(.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
401 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
402 0 obj
<<
/Length 6742
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(52)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 743.31 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\032\021\030\021\024)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(5HVSRQVLELOLW\\\003ZKHQ\003GRZQORDGLQJ\003VRIWZDUH\003IURP\003WKH)Tj
-2.6154 -1.1795 TD
0 Tc
[(,)-7(QWHUQHW)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 684.15 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(There are various kinds of software that one may)29( encounter in the virtual)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
[(world. I)22(f)2( the software is a so-called \223freeware\224, it is to be distributed freely)29(.)]TJ
T*
[(B)6(y)29( downloading)9( such a prog)9(ram, no infring)9(ing)9( what so ever is at hand.)]TJ
T*
(Another kind is the \223shareware\224 which can be downloaded and used freely)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(only)30( for a)4( limite)4(d time)4(. I)23(f)3( one)4( de)4(c)4(i)-2(de)4(s to ke)4(e)4(p)0( the)4( sha)4(r)3(e)4(w)2(a)4(r)3(e)4( prog)10(ra)4(m, one)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(must pay)29( a specified amount to the author. Often, shareware is equipped)]TJ
T*
[(with \223nag)9( screens\224 reminding)9( the user of the oblig)9(ation to pay)29( the fee within)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(time)4(, or \223)4(time)4( limits\224)4(.)0( I)23(n)0( orde)4(r to re)4(move)4( the)4( na)4(g)10( sc)4(re)4(e)4(n)0(s or ope)4(n up the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(prog)9(ram after the time limit ex)-11(pired, one must pay)29( the fee in order to receive)]TJ
T*
-0.003 Tc
0.003 Tw
(a code.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 147.33 562.23 Tm
0.007 Tc
(172)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 159.57 556.71 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( I)22( have no intentions of further study)29(ing)9( neither freeware nor)]TJ
-3.84 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(sha)4(r)3(e)4(w)2(a)4(r)3(e)4( in this the)4(s)-1(is. I)23( find it more)4( inte)4(re)4(sting)10( to c)4(onside)4(r)3( softwa)4(re)4( not)]TJ
T*
[(inte)4(nde)4(d for I)23(n)0(te)4(rne)4(t)-2( downloa)4(ding)10( i.e)4(.)0( softwa)4(re)4( tha)4(t)-2( is ille)4(g)10(a)4(lly)30( uploa)4(de)4(d in)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(C)-5(y)28(berspace and downl)-4(oaded by)28( reg)8(u)-2(l)-4(a)2(r users. I)21(m)-4(ag)8(i)-4(n)-2(e a person t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( for)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(some odd reason wants to achieve a hig)9(h)-1( number of \223hits\224 \(a user visiting)9( a)]TJ
T*
[(site is considered to cause a \223hit\224\) on a particular site. This person may)29( store)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(a)4( c)4(opy)30( of a)4(ttra)4(c)4(tive)4( prote)4(c)4(t)-2(e)4(d)0( softwa)4(re)4( on his we)4(bsite)4(. Would it be)4( ille)4(g)10(a)4(l if)]TJ
T*
(another person finds this software on the site and downloads it to his/her)Tj
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(own computer in order to use it privately)29(?)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
[(I)22(n)-1( Sweden, as described above, software cannot be copied, even for private)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
(use)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 129.45 406.47 Tm
0.007 Tc
(173)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 141.69 400.95 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( unless it is a backup copy)30( not to be utilized unless the orig)10(inal is)]TJ
-2.35 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(dest)-3(roy)29(e)3(d or l)-3(o)-1(st)-3(. I)22(t)-3( i)-3(s)-2( t)-3(h)-1(erefore not)-3( l)-3(e)3(g)9(a)3(l)-3( t)-3(o)-1( copy)29( prot)-3(ect)-3(ed soft)-3(ware pl)-3(aced)]TJ
T*
[(in Cy)29(berspace. The fact that somebody)29( else committed a crime by)29( uploading)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(soft)-4(ware i)-4(n)-2( C)-5(y)28(berspace i)-4(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e fi)-4(rst)-4( pl)-4(ace, i)-4(s)-3( no ex)-12(cuse for downl)-4(oadi)-4(ng)8( i)-4(t)-4(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 465.81 363.99 Tm
0.007 Tc
(174)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 344.31 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(I)22(t)-3( is certain, that downloading)9( software is equivalent of producing)9( a copy)]TJ
T*
(from one computer to another.)Tj
0 -2.36 TD
[(One could arg)9(u)-1(e that downloading)9( software is a matter of copy)29(ing)9( within the)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(priva)4(t)-2(e)4( sphe)4(re)4(, whic)4(h in Swe)4(d)0(e)4(n, of c)4(ourse)4(, is ille)4(g)10(a)4(l)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 366.57 293.19 Tm
0.007 Tc
(175)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 378.81 287.67 Tm
0 Tc
( but without)Tj
-22.11 -1.18 TD
(punishment.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 172.53 279.03 Tm
0.007 Tc
(176)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 184.77 273.51 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( This may)29( very)29( well be true, but in some cases I)22( believe the)]TJ
-5.94 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(L)21(a)4(g)10( \(1960:729\) om upphovsr\344tt till litter\344ra verk och konstn\344rlig)10(a verk 53:2)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(cannot be applied. I)22(f)2( a private copy)29( is made from software orig)9(inating)9( from)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(public businesses, this cannot be ex)-10(cepted from punishment even thoug)10(h the)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(copy)28( i)-4(s)-3( i)-4(n)-2(t)-4(e)2(nded for pri)-4(v)-2(at)-4(e use onl)-4(y)28(.)-2( I)21(f)1( such a copy)28( i)-4(s)-3( pl)-4(aced i)-4(n)-2( C)-5(y)28(berspace,)]TJ
0 -3.12 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 182.55 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 171.75 Tm
(172)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 167.19 Tm
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( A)15(s)7( des)7(c)2(ri)5(bed abov)10(e, s)7(e)2(ri)5(al)5( n)10(u)10(m)23(ber arch)10(i)5(v)10(es)7( are popu)10(l)5(a)2(r readi)5(n)10(g)10( i)5(n)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
0.003 Tc
[(C)7(y)21(berspace.)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 148.23 Tm
0 Tc
(173)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 143.67 Tm
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[( L)12(a)1(g)9( \(1960:729\) om)22( u)9(pph)9(ov)9(s)6(r)-1(\344tt till litter\344ra v)9(e)1(rk)9( och)9( k)9(o)-3(n)9(s)6(tn)9(\344rlig)9(a v)9(e)1(rk)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
0.006 Tc
(12\247.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 124.71 Tm
0 Tc
(174)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 120.15 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(1lWMXULGLN\017\003/DJ\003RFK\003UlWW\003Sn\003,QWHUQHW)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
14.3012 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, by)22( T)-12(h)10(om)23(as)7( C)8(a)2(rl)5(\351n)10(-)12(W)-4(en)10(del)5(s)7(, pag)10(e)2( 77.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 112.95 Tm
0 Tc
(175)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 108.39 Tm
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[( L)12(a)1(g)9( \(1960:729\) om)22( u)9(pph)9(ov)9(s)6(r)-1(\344tt till litter\344ra v)9(e)1(rk)9( och)9( k)9(o)-3(n)9(s)6(tn)9(\344rlig)9(a v)9(e)1(rk)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
0.006 Tc
[(12:)7(2.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
0 Tc
(176)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 84.87 Tm
0.003 Tc
[( L)12(a)1(g)9( \(1960:729\) om)22( u)9(pph)9(ov)9(s)6(r)-1(\344tt till litter\344ra v)9(e)1(rk)9( och)9( k)9(o)-3(n)9(s)6(tn)9(\344rlig)9(a v)9(e)1(rk)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
0.006 Tc
[(53:)7(2.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
403 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
404 0 obj
<<
/Length 6275
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(53)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
0 Tw
[(the)4( downloa)4(ding)10( of the)4( c)4(opy)30( for priva)4(t)-2(e)4( use)4( is \(a)4(s a)4(l)-2(wa)4(y)30(s)-1(\) ille)4(g)10(a)4(l )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
26.04 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
(EXW)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.28 0 TD
0.002 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[( it ma)6(y)]TJ
-27.32 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(be punished since 53:2 is not applicable.)Tj
0 -2.36 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(I)22(f)2( one downloads a copy)29( from the I)22(n)-1(ternet, it could be arg)9(u)-1(ed that the copy)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
(\(made between the site owner and the downloader\) is not made within the)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(priva)4(t)-2(e)4( sphe)4(re)4(, a)4(nd the)4(r)3(e)4(f)3(ore)4( is ille)4(g)10(a)4(l. The)4( pe)4(rson offe)4(ring)10( the)4( softwa)4(re)4( in)]TJ
T*
[(Cy)30(berspace does not know the persons downloading)10( it. I)23(t)-2( is possible that)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(one could maintain that second g)9(e)3(neration copies made from illeg)9(a)3(l copies)]TJ
T*
[(never can be made for private use and be ex)-11(cluded from punishment)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(according)10( to the L)21(a)4(g)10( \(1960:729\) om upphovsr\344tt till litter\344ra verk och)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(konstn\344rlig)9(a verk 53:2. Most copies of popular software found in)]TJ
T*
[(Cy)29(berspace are probably)29( illeg)9(a)3(l copies according)9( to this reasoning)9(. I)22(t)-3( is hard)]TJ
T*
[(t)-3(o)-1( bel)-3(i)-3(e)3(ve t)-3(h)-1(at)-3( som)-3(e)3(one pl)-3(aces an ori)-3(g)9(i)-3(n)-1(al)-3( copy)29( ont)-3(o a server. However, i)-3(t)]TJ
T*
[(may)29( be difficult to decide whether the software is a copy)29( or an orig)9(inal,)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(sinc)5(e)5( the)5(y)31( both a)5(r)4(e)5( dig)11(itize)5(d)1( a)5(nd ide)5(n)1(tic)5(a)5(l)-1(.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(I)23(t)-2( is possible)4( tha)4(t)-2( a)4( c)4(opy)30( within the)4( priva)4(t)-2(e)4( sphe)4(re)4( ma)4(de)4( from a)4(n)0( ille)4(g)10(a)4(l c)4(opy)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(is illeg)10(a)4(l and that L)21(a)4(g)10( \(1960:729\) om upphovsr\344tt till litter\344ra verk och)]TJ
T*
[(konstn\344rlig)10(a verk 53:2 cannot be applied. I)23(f)3( this is the case, all downloading)]TJ
T*
[(of prote)4(c)4(t)-2(e)4(d)0( softwa)4(re)4( from the)4( I)23(n)0(te)4(rne)4(t)-2( is ille)4(g)10(a)4(l \(e)4(ve)4(n within the)4( priva)4(t)-2(e)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(sphere\) and can be punished according)9( to S)-5(w)1(edish law. W)-7(h)-1(ether a copy)29( of a)]TJ
T*
[(software can be copied an additional time \(from the I)22(n)-1(ternet\) and still be)]TJ
T*
[(covered by)29( 53:2 is not mentioned in the law, nor the preparatory)29( work.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 451.53 439.47 Tm
0.007 Tc
(177)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 419.79 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Sinc)4(e)4( it doe)4(s not se)4(e)4(m)-2( to be)4( tota)4(lly)30( c)4(l)-2(e)4(a)4(r)3( whe)4(t)-2(he)4(r ille)4(g)10(a)4(l softwa)4(re)4( c)4(opie)4(s)-1( c)4(a)4(n)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(be copied an additional time for private use without being)9( punished, persons)]TJ
T*
[(downloading)9( such software could possibly)29( claim that they)29( are merely)]TJ
T*
[(making)9( a copy)29( for private use, and therefore cannot be punished. I)22(t)-3( could be)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(a)4(r)3(g)10(u)0(e)4(d)0( tha)4(t)-2( it doe)4(s not ma)4(tte)4(r whe)4(t)-2(he)4(r the)4( priva)4(t)-2(e)4( c)4(opy)30( is ma)4(de)4( from the)]TJ
T*
[(orig)10(inal or from a copy)30(. I)23( am of the opinion that the situation is unclear,)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(whether one must copy)29( \(for private use\) from an )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
19.56 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(RU)-10(L)-9(J)0(L)-9(QDO)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
3.23 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.25 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(RQO)-9(\\)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
1.72 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(, in order to)Tj
-24.76 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(avoid punishment according)10( to the L)21(a)4(g)10( \(1960:729\) om upphovsr\344tt till)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(litter\344ra verk och konstn\344rlig)9(a verk 53:2. I)22(s)-2( a )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
18.18 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
(FRS\\)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
1.88 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
( of the software \(not the)Tj
-20.06 -1.18 TD
[(orig)9(inal\) found in Cy)29(berspace included in the meaning)9( of the law in 53:2?)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 241.71 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\032\021\030\021\025)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(5HVSRQVLELOLW\\\003ZKHQ\003GRZQORDGLQJ\003PXVLF\003IURP\003WKH)Tj
-2.6154 -1.1795 TD
0 Tc
[(,)-7(QWHUQHW)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 196.71 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(I)21(m)-4(ag)8(i)-4(n)-2(e an I)21(n)-2(t)-4(e)2(rnet)-4( user, si)-4(t)-4(u)-2(at)-4(ed i)-4(n)-2( S)-6(w)0(eden who di)-4(scovers a websi)-4(t)-4(e)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(containing)9( uploaded musicfiles and he/she decides to download a few song)9(s.)]TJ
T*
[(I)22(s)-2( the downloader infring)9(ing)9( any)29( copy)29(rig)9(h)-1(ts by)29( such an action?)-17( I)22(n)-1( Sweden, it)]TJ
T*
[(is as described above, leg)9(a)3(l to copy)29( music for private use, if the music)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(la)5(wfully)31( ha)5(s be)5(e)5(n)1( ma)5(de)5( a)5(v)1(a)5(ila)5(ble)5( to the)5( public)5(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 338.73 145.59 Tm
0.007 Tc
(178)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 350.97 140.07 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( I)22(t)-3( is, however, required)]TJ
-19.79 -1.18 TD
(that the downloader does not spread the music outside the private sphere.)Tj
0 -1.42 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 111.99 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 101.19 Tm
(177)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 96.63 Tm
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( P)-6(r)0(opos)7(ition)10( 1992/93:48 Sk)10(y)22(dd f)12(\366)-2(r datorprog)10(r)0(am)23(, pag)10(e)2( 131 an)10(d f)12(o)-2(rw)27(ards)7(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
0 Tc
(178)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 84.87 Tm
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[( L)12(a)1(g)9( \(1960:729\) om)22( u)9(pph)9(ov)9(s)6(r)-1(\344tt till litter\344ra v)9(e)1(rk)9( och)9( k)9(o)-3(n)9(s)6(tn)9(\344rlig)9(a v)9(e)1(rk)9( 81,)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(12\247 an)11(d 46\247.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
405 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
406 0 obj
<<
/Length 7048
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(54)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(One could therefore say)29( that users are allowed to download music from the)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(I)23(n)0(te)4(rne)4(t)-2( if the)4( music)4( is for priva)4(t)-2(e)4( use)4( only)30(.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 320.25 736.83 Tm
0.007 Tc
(179)Tj
12 0 0 12 332.49 731.31 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( Thus, if the user only)29( as much)]TJ
-18.25 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
(as )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
1.08 0 TD
0.003 Tc
[(R)9(IIH)9(UV)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
2.28 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( a)4( c)4(opy)30( of the)4( downloa)4(de)4(d music)4(f)3(ile)4( to a)4(n)0(y)30(one)4( not be)4(ing)10( fa)4(mily)30( or)]TJ
-3.36 -1.18 TD
[(close friend, it would constitute infring)10(ement.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 332.85 708.51 Tm
0.007 Tc
(180)Tj
12 0 0 12 113.49 674.67 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(I)22( believe that if a user finds music that has not y)29(e)3(t been officially)29( released to)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(the)5( public)5(,)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 164.13 666.03 Tm
0.007 Tc
(181)Tj
12 0 0 12 176.37 660.51 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( it would constitute an infring)10(ement, since such music cannot)]TJ
-5.24 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(be copi)-4(ed even for pri)-4(v)-2(at)-4(e use.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 260.37 651.87 Tm
0.007 Tc
(182)Tj
12 0 0 12 272.61 646.35 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( I)22(t)-3( would, however, not alway)29(s)-2( be obvious)]TJ
-13.26 -1.18 TD
[(to all users whether or not a song)9( has been officially)29( released.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
[(One could arg)9(u)-1(e that users should know that much of the musicfiles found)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(i)-3(n)-1( C)-4(y)29(berspace are upl)-3(oaded by)29( som)-3(e)3(one l)-3(acki)-3(n)-1(g)9( perm)-3(i)-3(ssi)-3(on from)-3( t)-3(h)-1(e)]TJ
T*
[(rig)9(h)-1(tful authors, and that the musicfiles therefore are infring)9(ing)9( upon)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(copy)30(rig)10(h)0(ts. I)23(t)-2( is true but it does not eliminate the rig)10(h)0(t to produce a private)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(copy)29(. I)22(n)-1( the above-mentioned F)5(r)2(ench case, the Tribunal de Grande I)22(n)-1(stance)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(in Pa)5(ris sa)5(id tha)5(t)-1( the)5(r)4(e)5( is a)5(n)1( implic)5(it a)5(u)1(thoriza)5(tion to c)5(opy)31( whe)5(n)1( visiting)11( a)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(private webpag)8(e)2(.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 195.09 524.43 Tm
0.007 Tc
(183)Tj
12 0 0 12 207.33 518.91 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( This ma)4(y)30( some)4(time)4(s ve)4(ry)30( we)4(ll be)4( the)4( c)4(a)4(s)-1(e)4(,)0( if the)4(r)3(e)4( doe)4(s)]TJ
-7.82 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(not e)5(x)-9(ist a)5(n)1(y)31( disc)5(la)5(ime)5(r or writte)5(n te)5(x)-9(t)-1( tha)5(t)-1( e)5(x)-9(plic)5(itly)31( prohibits downloa)5(ding)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(of any)29( kind.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 466.83 Tm
0 Tc
[(\032\021\031\003)-435(6XPPDU\\)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 435.99 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(With the)5( a)5(g)11(e)5( of dig)11(itizing)11(,)1( c)5(opie)5(s)0( a)5(nd orig)11(ina)5(l)-1(s ha)5(ve)5( e)5(x)-9(a)5(c)5(tly)31( the)5( sa)5(me)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(qua)4(lity)30(. One)4( c)4(ould sa)4(y)30( tha)4(t)-2( inte)4(lle)4(c)4(t)-2(ua)4(l prope)4(rty)30( pira)4(c)4(y)30( is he)4(re)4( to sta)4(y)30( a)4(n)0(d)]TJ
T*
[(flourish. F)6(a)4(ste)4(r)3( c)4(onne)4(c)4(tions will a)4(llow ve)4(ry)30( la)4(rg)10(e)4( prog)10(ra)4(ms a)4(nd file)4(s to be)]TJ
T*
[(tra)4(n)0(sfe)4(rre)4(d e)4(l)-2(e)4(c)4(t)-2(ronic)4(a)4(lly)30( be)4(twe)4(e)4(n)0( use)4(r)3(s in no time)4(. At this point in time)4(,)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Cy)29(berspace provides numerous opportunities for persons around the g)9(l)-3(obe)]TJ
T*
[(to barter and copy)29( material. Every)29(d)-1(ay)29( and nig)9(h)-1(t thousands of prog)9(rams and)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(file)4(s tra)4(v)0(e)4(l)-2( throug)10(h the)4( te)4(le)4(c)4(o)0(mmunic)4(a)4(tion infra)4(struc)4(t)-2(ure)4(.)0( The)4(s)-1(e)4( a)4(c)4(tivitie)4(s)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(are m)-4(o)-2(re wi)-4(del)-4(y)28( spread t)-4(h)-2(an m)-4(o)-2(st)-4( soft)-4(ware producers can ever i)-4(m)-4(a)2(g)8(i)-4(ne.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Copy)29(ing)9( software for private use in Sweden is not lawful any)29( long)9(er, but)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(there does not ex)-11(ist any)29( punishment for such actions. Uploading)9( software in)]TJ
T*
[(Cy)29(berspace is equivalent of producing)9( a copy)29( and is therefore illeg)9(a)3(l. Such a)]TJ
T*
[(copy)29( cannot constitute a private copy)29(, and therefore may)29( such actions be)]TJ
T*
[(punished according)9( to S)-5(w)1(edish law. Downloading)9( protected software from)]TJ
T*
[(Cy)29(berspace is illeg)9(a)3(l. The question of whether such actions \(for private use\))]TJ
T*
[(will be punished in Sweden is, however, unclear if one analy)29(z)-7(es the law and)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(h)-2(e preparat)-4(ory)28( work.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Nowa)4(da)4(y)30(s)-1( music)4( is be)4(ing)10( c)4(o)0(mpre)4(sse)4(d into sma)4(ll ha)4(ndy)30( file)4(s tha)4(t)-2( c)4(a)4(n)0( be)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(tra)4(n)0(sfe)4(rre)4(d from one)4( c)4(ontine)4(n)0(t to a)4(nothe)4(r within minute)4(s)-1(. An inte)4(re)4(sting)10( fa)4(c)4(t)]TJ
0 -1.9 TD
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 147.27 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 136.47 Tm
(179)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 131.91 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(1lWMXULGLN\017\003/DJ\003RFK\003UlWW\003Sn\003,QWHUQHW)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
14.3012 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, by)22( T)-12(h)10(om)23(as)7( C)8(a)2(rl)5(\351n)10(-)12(W)-4(en)10(del)5(s)7(, pag)10(e)2( 70.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 124.71 Tm
0 Tc
(180)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 120.15 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(3UDNWLVN\003,7\020UlWW)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
6.2651 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, by)22( A)15(g)10(n)10(e)2( L)13(i)5(n)10(dberg)10( an)10(d Dan)10(i)5(el)5( Wes)7(t)5(m)23(a)2(n)10(,)1( pag)10(e)2( 88.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 112.95 Tm
0 Tc
(181)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 108.39 Tm
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( Su)8(ch)8( as th)8(e u)8(n)8(r)-2(eleased U2 son)8(g)8(s)5( m)21(e)0(n)8(tion)8(e)0(d abov)8(e.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 101.19 Tm
0 Tc
(182)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 96.63 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(3UDNWLVN\003,7\020UlWW)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
6.2651 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, by)22( A)15(g)10(n)10(e)2( L)13(i)5(n)10(dberg)10( an)10(d Dan)10(i)5(el)5( Wes)7(t)5(m)23(a)2(n)10(,)1( pag)10(e)2( 109.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
0 Tc
(183)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 84.87 Tm
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( A)13(r)-2(t Mu)8(sic Fran)8(ce v)8(.)-1( L)11(\222)10(Ecole Nation)8(a)0(le Su)8(perieu)8(re Des)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(T)-12(e)2(l)5(ecom)23(m)23(u)10(n)10(i)5(cat)5(i)5(o)-2(n)10(s)7(, T)-12(r)0(i)5(b)-2(u)10(n)10(a)2(l)5( de Gran)10(de In)10(s)7(t)5(an)10(ce Pari)5(s)7( [1997]EEC)8(97.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
407 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
409 0 obj
<<
/Length 1273
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(55)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(is tha)5(t)-1( the)5( music)5( c)5(a)5(n)1( be)5( writte)5(n on a)5( CD-R a)5(nd be)5( pla)5(y)31(e)5(d)1( in a)5(n)1(y)31( ste)5(r)4(e)5(o, with)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(the)5( sa)5(me)5( qua)5(lity)31( a)5(s)0( the)5( orig)11(ina)5(l)-1( CD. Uploa)5(d)1(ing)11( a)5( music)5( file)5( to a)5( we)5(bsite)5( or)]TJ
T*
[(e)5(quiva)5(le)5(nt c)5(onstitute)5(s c)5(opy)31(rig)11(h)1(t infring)11(e)5(m)-1(e)5(n)1(t a)5(b)1(se)5(nt pe)5(rmission from the)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(a)4(u)0(thor. Downloa)4(d)0(ing)10( suc)4(h)0( file)4(s is la)4(wful within the)4( priva)4(t)-2(e)4( use)4( sphe)4(re)4(.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
[(The)4( que)4(stion of I)23(SP a)4(nd B)7(B)7(S)-4(-ope)4(ra)4(tor lia)4(bility)30( is a)4(n)0( infe)4(c)4(t)-2(e)4(d)0( issue)4( in ma)4(ny)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(countries. Sweden has proposed a new law, making)9( the B)6(B)6(S)-5(-operators liable)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(for not)-4( rem)-4(ovi)-4(ng)8( i)-4(n)-2(fri)-4(ng)8(i)-4(n)-2(g)8( m)-4(a)2(t)-4(e)2(ri)-4(al)-4(. There are cases sug)8(g)8(e)2(st)-4(i)-4(n)-2(g)8( as wel)-4(l)-4( as)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(opposing)11( I)24(SP liability)31(.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
410 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
412 0 obj
<<
/Length 6200
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(56)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
24 0 0 24 113.49 733.71 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(\033\003)-311(-XULVGLFWLRQ)]TJ
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 683.67 Tm
[(\033\021\024\003)-436(7)-1(KH\003LPSRUWDQFH\003RI\003MXULVGLFWLRQ\003LQ\003WKH\003Z)-15(RUOG)]TJ
0 -1.1805 TD
(RI\003LQIRUPDWLRQ\003WHFKQRORJ\\)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 633.99 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(J)-13(u)-2(ri)-4(sdi)-4(c)2(t)-4(i)-4(on i)-4(s)-3( an ex)-12(t)-4(r)1(em)-4(el)-4(y)28( i)-4(m)-4(port)-4(a)2(nt)-4( i)-4(ssue, because a j)-4(udg)8(em)-4(ent)-4( by)28( a court)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(without proper jurisdiction over a defendant is considered void.)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Tra)4(d)0(itiona)4(lly)30( jurisdic)4(tion re)4(quire)4(d phy)30(sic)4(a)4(l)-2( pre)4(s)-1(e)4(n)0(c)4(e)4( within the)4( te)4(rritoria)4(l)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(boundaries of the court, but this has g)9(r)2(adually)29( chang)9(e)3(d. I)22(n)-1( Cy)29(berspace,)]TJ
T*
[(people from all over the world g)9(a)3(ther and ex)-11(chang)9(e)3( various kinds of)]TJ
T*
[(information without even reflecting)9( upon the fact that there ex)-11(ists phy)29(sical)]TJ
T*
[(borders between them. I)22(t)-3( does not matter any)29( long)9(er \(technically)29( speaking)9(\))2(,)]TJ
T*
[(where on earth one is located, as long)9( as one has a computer and an I)22(n)-1(ternet)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(connection available. Even thoug)10(h it may)30( look like it, one cannot claim that)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(C)-4(y)29(berspace consi)-3(s)-2(t)-3(s)-2( of one nat)-3(i)-3(onal)-3( j)-3(u)-1(ri)-3(sdi)-3(c)3(t)-3(i)-3(on sol)-3(e)3(l)-3(y)29(, si)-3(nce t)-3(h)-1(e net)-3(w)1(ork i)-3(s)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(om)-4(ni)-4(present)-4( and uni)-4(versal)-4(. The users i)-4(n)-2( C)-5(y)28(berspace are si)-4(t)-4(u)-2(at)-4(ed i)-4(n)-2( separat)-4(e)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(different countries with different leg)9(a)3(l frameworks and traditions. Therefore)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(it ma)5(y)31( be)5( ha)5(rd to de)5(te)5(rmine)5( whic)5(h jurisdic)5(tion\222s la)5(w tha)5(t)-1( a)5(pplie)5(s. I)24(t)-1( is not a)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(problem ex)-11(clusively)29( between miscellaneous countries around the world. I)22(t)-3( is)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(a)4(l)-2(so a)4( proble)4(m)-2( re)4(la)4(ting)10( to the)4( diffe)4(re)4(nt sta)4(t)-2(e)4(s)-1( within the)4( U.S.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(The rapid technolog)9(ical development may)29( result in a situation where)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(c)5(o)1(mpa)5(n)1(ie)5(s a)5(nd individua)5(ls a)5(r)4(e)5( submitte)5(d to jurisdic)5(tion in a)5( wide)5( ra)5(ng)11(e)5( of)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(pl)-3(aces al)-3(l)-3( over t)-3(h)-1(e worl)-3(d as a resul)-3(t)-3( of post)-3(i)-3(n)-1(g)9( i)-3(n)-1(form)-3(at)-3(i)-3(on on a si)-3(ng)9(l)-3(e)]TJ
T*
[(websi)-3(t)-3(e)3(. Mat)-3(e)3(ri)-3(al)-3(s publ)-3(i)-3(s)-2(hed i)-3(n)-1( C)-4(y)29(berspace m)-3(a)3(y)29( be read, downl)-3(oaded, and)]TJ
T*
[(copied by)29( people in various countries around the world. Most of these)]TJ
T*
(countries have different laws, and authors must take into consideration that)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(publishing)10( the)4(i)-2(r work on the)4( I)23(n)0(te)4(rne)4(t)-2( c)4(ould e)4(x)-10(pose)4( the)4(m)-2( to lia)4(bility)30( in those)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(countries. Even if a web advertiser wishes to aim an advertisement only)29( to a)]TJ
T*
[(specific location, the technolog)9(y)29( enables all users on-line around the g)9(l)-3(obe)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(o)-2( recei)-4(ve t)-4(h)-2(e m)-4(e)2(ssag)8(e)2(s, unl)-4(ess cert)-4(a)2(i)-4(n)-2( unat)-4(t)-4(r)1(act)-4(i)-4(v)-2(e securi)-4(t)-4(y)28( m)-4(easures are)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(ta)4(ke)4(n. Doe)4(s)-1( this le)4(a)4(d)0( to a)4( possibility)30( to sue)4( a)4(n)0(y)30(w)2(he)4(re)4( in the)4( world, if not)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(technolog)9(ical barriers are used to hinder omnipresent access to the posted)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(messag)10(e)4(s?)-16( Should courts focus on the )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
15.38 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(L)-9(Q)0(W)-9(HQGHG)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
3.44 0 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[( recei)-4(vers of a speci)-4(fi)-4(c)]TJ
-18.82 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(website, or should they)29( concentrate on every)29( user that has the )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
24.72 0 TD
0.003 Tc
[(S)9(R)9(VVLE)9(LOLW\\)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
4.12 0 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
( to)Tj
-28.84 -1.18 TD
-0.003 Tc
0.003 Tw
[(access t)-5(h)-3(e m)-5(a)1(t)-5(e)1(ri)-5(al)-5(?)-19( W)-9(h)-3(at)-5( i)-5(f)0( a web advert)-5(i)-5(s)-4(em)-5(ent)-5( cl)-5(earl)-5(y)27( ex)-13(cl)-5(udes every)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(jurisdic)4(tion e)4(x)-10(c)4(e)4(p)0(t one)4(, by)30( re)4(fe)4(rring)10( to a)4( poste)4(d disc)4(la)4(ime)4(r sta)4(ting)10( tha)4(t)-2( the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(products or services offered are solely)29( available to customers in a specific)]TJ
T*
[(jurisdiction?)-17( W)-7(ould it be reasonable to sue such an advertiser in another)]TJ
T*
[(jurisdiction than the targ)9(eted one?)-17( Some arg)9(u)-1(e that it would be reasonable to)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(sue)5( in a)5( \224)5(d)1(isc)5(l)-1(a)5(ime)5(d jurisdic)5(tion\224)5( only)31( if the)5( a)5(dve)5(rtise)5(r)4( is )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
23 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(DZ)-13(DU)-10(H)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
2.5 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( that he sells)Tj
-25.5 -1.18 TD
(products or services to customers situated in a \224disclaimed jurisdiction\224.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 460.41 129.75 Tm
0.007 Tc
(184)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 97.11 Tm
0 Tc
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 100.23 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
(184)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 84.87 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(6ROLFLWDWLRQ\003YLD\003WKH\003,QWHUQHW\036\003-XULVGLFWLRQ\003RYHU\003&ODLPV)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
21.5422 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[( by)23( Edw)28(a)3(rd Brods)8(k)11(y)23(,)]TJ
-22.7711 -1.1807 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(T)-12(h)10(e New)27( York)10( L)13(a)2(w)27( Jou)10(r)0(n)10(a)2(l)5(,)1( Ju)10(n)10(e)2( 11, 1997)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
413 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
414 0 obj
<<
/Length 6391
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(57)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(Wha)5(t)-1( e)5(x)-9(a)5(c)5(tly)31( doe)5(s this me)5(a)5(n)1(?)-15( I)24(f)4( the)5( c)5(o)1(mpa)5(n)1(y)31( ma)5(ke)5(s busine)5(ss in a)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(jurisdiction that has been ex)-11(cluded by)29( a disclaimer, as described above, it)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(would be possible to sue the company)30( only)30( if it is proven that the company)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(is aware of the location of its customers. I)22(t)-3( has been sug)9(g)9(e)3(sted that courts)]TJ
T*
(also should take into consideration whether the advertiser uses available)Tj
T*
[(technolog)9(ical barriers in order to filter out residents of certain jurisdictions)]TJ
T*
[(and ex)-11(clude them from receiving)9( the messag)9(e)3(s. Some kind of written)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(a)5(pplic)5(a)5(tion from the)5( c)5(u)1(stome)5(r)4( tha)5(t)-1( would ide)5(n)1(tify)31( his jurisdic)5(tion is)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(mentioned as an ex)-11(ample.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 238.05 637.71 Tm
0.007 Tc
(185)Tj
12 0 0 12 250.29 632.19 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[( The buy)29(er could fax)-11( or e-mail to the seller, who)]TJ
-11.4 -1.18 TD
(sends back, via e-mail, a password and a user name. The customers in)Tj
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(cert)-4(a)2(i)-4(n)-2( desi)-4(red l)-4(o)-2(cat)-4(i)-4(ons woul)-4(d t)-4(h)-2(en be accept)-4(e)2(d and recei)-4(ve access t)-4(o)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(information. However, such complicated procedures may)29( discourag)9(e some)]TJ
T*
[(buy)29(ers, which may)29( have a neg)9(a)3(tive effect on the trade.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(I)23(f)3( one wishes to advertise on the I)23(n)0(ternet, on must bear in mind that a)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(potential plaintiff may)29( in some cases be allowed to choose the most)]TJ
T*
[(favorable law to him, depending)9( on the claim he wants to pursue.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 426.57 524.43 Tm
0.007 Tc
(186)Tj
12 0 0 12 438.81 518.91 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( Suc)5(h)]TJ
-27.11 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(forum shopping)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 189.69 510.27 Tm
0.007 Tc
(187)Tj
12 0 0 12 201.93 504.75 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( may)29( complicate the situation. The website owner may)]TJ
-7.37 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(have to defend himself in jurisdictions in which he is not a resident. All over)Tj
T*
[(the)4( world, jurisdic)4(tiona)4(l issue)4(s)-1( re)4(g)10(a)4(rding)10( the)4( I)23(n)0(te)4(rne)4(t)-2( a)4(r)3(e)4( c)4(ontrove)4(rsia)4(l)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(i)-3(ssues. I)22(n)-1( som)-3(e)3( pl)-3(aces, such as Mi)-3(nnesot)-3(a)3( for i)-3(n)-1(st)-3(ance, t)-3(h)-1(e arrang)9(em)-3(ent)-3( used)]TJ
T*
[(to ex)-11(ercise jurisdiction is considered very)29( arg)9(u)-1(able and controversial from)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
[(an international perspective. I)22(f)2( countries do not respect each other\222s methods)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(and strive for harmonization, jurisdictional issues on the I)23(n)0(ternet will be)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(even harder t)-4(o)-2( resol)-4(v)-2(e i)-4(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e fut)-4(u)-2(re.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 381.87 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(\033\021\025\003)-436(6)-1(Z)-15(H)-2(GLVK\003UXOHV\003FRQFHUQLQJ\003MXULVGLFWLRQ)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 336.87 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(I)24(t)-1( is importa)5(nt to notic)5(e)5( tha)5(t)-1( a)5(t)-1( this point in time)5( the)5(r)4(e)5( doe)5(s not se)5(e)5(m)-1( to e)5(x)-9(ist)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(any)30( Swedish cases relating)10( to the I)23(n)0(ternet and jurisdiction. Do Swedish)]TJ
T*
[(courts have jurisdiction over foreig)10(n web-editors posting)10( information not)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(c)5(o)1(mply)31(ing)11( with Swe)5(d)1(ish pe)5(na)5(l la)5(ws, due)5( to the)5( me)5(re)5( fa)5(c)5(t)-1( tha)5(t)-1( the)5( site)5(s c)5(a)5(n)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(be accessed and viewed in S)-5(w)1(eden \(and certainly)29( in most other countries as)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(well\)?)-16( I)23(f)3( the posting)10( of information takes place in a foreig)10(n jurisdiction, the)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(pl)-4(ace of t)-4(h)-2(e al)-4(l)-4(e)2(g)8(e)2(d cri)-4(m)-4(e)2( i)-4(s)-3( not)-4( S)-6(w)0(eden. The pl)-4(ace of t)-4(h)-2(e cri)-4(m)-4(e)2( i)-4(s)-3( t)-4(h)-2(e pl)-4(ace)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(whe)4(r)3(e)4( the)4( a)4(c)4(t)-2( wa)4(s c)4(o)0(mple)4(te)4(d, i.e)4(.)0( in the)4( jurisdic)4(tion we)4(re)4( the)4( posting)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(occurred. Therefore, one certainly)29( must find a rule of jurisdiction, which)]TJ
T*
[(allows Swedish law to be applied. I)22(f)2( the web-editor \(the person\) has a strong)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(c)5(onne)5(c)5(tion to Swe)5(d)1(e)5(n, suc)5(h)1( a)5(s)0( a)5( Swe)5(d)1(ish c)5(itize)5(n)1(ship, or domic)5(ile)5(, the)]TJ
0 -2.3 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 170.79 368.4 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 141.81 155.43 Tm
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(\(Http://lj)-9(ex)8(tra.com)21(/)3(In)8(tern)8(et/061irs)5(olic.h)8(tm)21(\). Mr. B)-6(r)-2(ods)5(k)8(y)20( is)5( a partn)8(e)0(r at)]TJ
0 -1.1807 TD
-0.006 Tc
0.009 Tw
[(P)-16(r)-10(o)-12(s)-3(ka)-8(ue)-8(r)-10( Ro)-12(se)-8( LLP)-16(.)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 136.47 Tm
0 Tc
(185)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 131.91 Tm
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
( Ibid.)Tj
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 124.71 Tm
0 Tc
(186)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 120.15 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(6ROLFLWDWLRQ\003YLD\003WKH\003,QWHUQHW\036\003-XULVGLFWLRQ\003RYHU\003&ODLPV)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
21.5422 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[( by)23( Edw)28(a)3(rd Brods)8(k)11(y)23(,)]TJ
-22.7711 -1.1807 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(T)-12(h)10(e New)27( York)10( L)13(a)2(w)27( Jou)10(r)0(n)10(a)2(l)5(,)1( Ju)10(n)10(e)2( 11, 1997)]TJ
T*
0.002 Tc
[(\(Http://lj)-9(ex)8(tra.com)21(/)3(In)8(tern)8(et/061irs)5(olic.h)8(tm)21(\).)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
0 Tc
(187)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 84.87 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(6YHQVN\003LQWHUQDWLRQHOO\003SULYDW\020\003RFK\003SURFHVVUlWW)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
17.9157 0 TD
0.003 Tc
[(, by)21( Mich)9(ael Bog)9(d)-3(an)9(, pag)9(e)]TJ
-19.1446 -1.1807 TD
0.006 Tc
(34.)Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
415 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
416 0 obj
<<
/Length 6685
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(58)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
-14.85 58.94 TD
0 Tw
[(\223)4(a)4(c)4(tive)4( pe)4(rsona)4(lity)30(-rule)4(\224)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 231.09 750.99 Tm
0.007 Tc
(188)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 243.33 745.47 Tm
0 Tc
[( may)30( be applied. Another situation that may)]TJ
-10.82 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(a)5(llow the)5( a)5(pplic)5(a)5(tion of Swe)5(d)1(ish la)5(w is if the)5( c)5(r)4(ime)5( is spe)5(c)5(i)-1(fic)5(a)5(lly)31( dire)5(c)5(t)-1(e)5(d)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(o)-2(wards S)-6(w)0(eden, and t)-4(h)-2(erefore has a cl)-4(ose connect)-4(i)-4(on t)-4(o)-2( S)-6(w)0(eden.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 428.37 722.67 Tm
0.007 Tc
(189)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 440.61 717.15 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
( One)Tj
-27.26 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(must a)5(l)-1(so c)5(onside)5(r)4( whe)5(t)-1(he)5(r or not the)5( posting)11( of ma)5(te)5(ria)5(l)-1( is ille)5(g)11(a)5(l in the)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(jurisdiction in which the posting)10( took place.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 324.33 694.35 Tm
0.007 Tc
(190)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 336.57 688.83 Tm
0 Tc
[( I)23(t)-2( may)30( be difficult to have a)]TJ
-18.59 -1.18 TD
[(Swedish ruling)10( ex)-10(ecuted in another jurisdiction, especially)30( if posting)10( the)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(informa)5(tion is not c)5(r)4(imina)5(lize)5(d)1( the)5(r)4(e)5(.)1( Conc)5(e)5(r)4(ning)11( da)5(ma)5(g)11(e)5(s in c)5(i)-1(vil c)5(a)5(s)0(e)5(s)0(, the)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(forum)-4( del)-4(i)-4(c)2(t)-4(i)-4(,)-2( i)-4(.)-2(e. t)-4(h)-2(e pl)-4(ace of t)-4(h)-2(e dam)-4(a)2(g)8(e)2(, m)-4(a)2(y)28( be of i)-4(m)-4(port)-4(a)2(nce.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(The)5( some)5(time)5(s ve)5(ry)31( c)5(o)1(mplic)5(a)5(t)-1(e)5(d)1( issue)5(s)0( re)5(la)5(ting)11( to jurisdic)5(tion a)5(r)4(e)5( fa)5(c)5(ilita)5(te)5(d)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(by)29( various conventions, in which states voluntarily)29( ag)9(ree to accept and)]TJ
T*
[(ex)-11(ecute each other\222s ruling)9(s)-2( etc. W)-7(h)-1(en no convention is applicable, S)-5(w)1(eden)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(is forced to apply)30( Swedish law only)30( within the Swedish borders.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 421.53 581.07 Tm
0.007 Tc
(191)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 433.77 575.55 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( I)22(t)-3( has)]TJ
-26.69 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(be)5(e)5(n)1( sug)11(g)11(e)5(ste)5(d)1( tha)5(t)-1( Swe)5(d)1(e)5(n)1( must limit the)5( a)5(pplic)5(a)5(b)1(ility)31( of Swe)5(d)1(ish la)5(w only)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(o)-2( m)-4(a)2(t)-4(t)-4(e)2(rs wi)-4(t)-4(h)-2( a cl)-4(ose rel)-4(a)2(t)-4(i)-4(onshi)-4(p t)-4(o)-2( S)-6(w)0(eden and t)-4(hus accept)-4( forei)-4(g)8(n)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(websites that do not specifically)29( turn to a Swedish audience. I)22(f)2( a foreig)9(n)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(we)5(bsite)5( is writte)5(n in the)5( Swe)5(d)1(ish la)5(ng)11(ua)5(g)11(e)5(, it ma)5(y)31( be)5( re)5(a)5(s)0(ona)5(ble)5( to a)5(pply)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(S)-6(w)0(edi)-4(s)-3(h l)-4(a)2(w, si)-4(nce t)-4(h)-2(e websi)-4(t)-4(e)2( t)-4(h)-2(en i)-4(s)-3( cl)-4(earl)-4(y)28( di)-4(rect)-4(ed t)-4(o)-2(wards S)-6(w)0(eden and)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(its\222 inte)4(re)4(sts.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 174.81 496.11 Tm
0.007 Tc
(192)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 187.05 490.59 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( This approach to foreig)9(n websites differs very)29( much from)]TJ
-6.13 -1.18 TD
(that of the American Minnesota approach, described below.)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 452.67 Tm
[(\033\021\026\003)-436(8\0216\021\003MXULVGLFWLRQ\003LVVXHV\003LQ\003EULHI)]TJ
10.56 0 0 10.56 380.25 460.23 Tm
0.001 Tc
(\024\034\026)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 407.67 Tm
-0.001 Tc
(State courts can in certain circumstances decide in matters involving)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
(nonresidents, who do not consent to be sued in the state, never visited the)Tj
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(state, nor opened an office in the state. F)5(e)3(deral courts can assert jurisdiction)]TJ
T*
(over persons within the territorial borders of the state in which the court is)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(situated. F)6(e)4(deral courts may)30( also use long)10(-arm statutes \(state jurisdictional)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(laws\) over nonresidents, in order to have the same reach as local state)Tj
T*
(courts.)Tj
0 -2.36 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(I)24(f)4( a)5( pe)5(rson ha)5(s c)5(e)5(r)4(ta)5(in minimum c)5(onta)5(c)5(t)-1(s with the)5( forum a)5(nd the)5( suit doe)5(s)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(not offend traditional notions of fair play)30( and substantial justice, a court may)]TJ
T*
(have jurisdiction over him. The person should, based upon his contacts, be)Tj
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(able to foresee and anticipate being)9( haled into court in the jurisdiction. A)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(court may)30( find jurisdiction over a foreig)10(n business if it purposefully)30( availed)]TJ
T*
[(itself of the privileg)10(e)4( of conducting)10( activities within the forum state.)]TJ
0 -5.64 TD
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 159.03 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 148.23 Tm
(188)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 143.67 Tm
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[( Brot)6(t)6(s)8(bal)6(k)11(en)11( 2:)6(2 p2.)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 136.47 Tm
0 Tc
(189)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 131.91 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.004 Tw
[( T)-17(h)5(e \223)9(p)-7(assive p)-7(e)-3(rso)-7(n)5(ality)17(-)7(r)-5(ule\224 in B)-9(r)-5(o)-7(ttsb)-7(a)-3(lken 2)-7(:)0(3)-7( p)-7(4)-7(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 124.71 Tm
0 Tc
(190)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 120.15 Tm
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[( Brot)6(t)6(s)8(bal)6(k)11(en)11( 2:)6(2:)6(2.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 112.95 Tm
0 Tc
(191)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 108.39 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(1lWMXULGLN\003\261\003/DJ\003RFK\003UlWW\003Sn\003,QWHUQHW)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
14.8072 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, by)22( T)-12(h)10(om)23(as)7( C)8(a)2(rl)5(\351n)10(-)12(W)-4(en)10(del)5(s)7(, pag)10(e)]TJ
-16.0361 -1.1807 TD
0.006 Tc
(33.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
0 Tc
(192)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 84.87 Tm
0.004 Tc
[( Ibi)5(d)-2(. pag)10(e)2( 34.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 77.67 Tm
0 Tc
(193)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 73.11 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(&\\EHUODZ\003\261\0037KH\003ODZ\003RI\003WKH\003,QWHUQHW)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
14.0602 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(, by)23( Jon)11(a)3(t)6(h)11(an)11( R)9(o)-1(s)8(e)3(n)11(o)-1(er, pag)11(e)3( 227-)13(230.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
417 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
419 0 obj
<<
/Length 5128
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(59)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Electronic contacts are commonly)29( used today)29(,)-1( and may)29( g)9(i)-3(ve rise to)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(jurisdiction, if the electronic contacts are purposefully)29( directed and have a)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(sig)11(n)1(ific)5(a)5(n)1(t c)5(onne)5(c)5(tion to the)5( litig)11(a)5(tion.)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(Am)-4(eri)-4(can cases coveri)-4(ng)8( I)21(n)-2(t)-4(e)2(rnet)-4( and j)-4(u)-2(ri)-4(sdi)-4(c)2(t)-4(i)-4(on i)-4(ssues)]TJ
T*
[(At)-4( t)-4(h)-2(i)-4(s)-3( m)-4(o)-2(m)-4(e)2(nt)-4(, t)-4(h)-2(ere ex)-12(i)-4(s)-3(t)-4(s)-3( very)28( few cases concerni)-4(ng)8( C)-5(y)28(berspace and)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(jurisdiction, and most of them emanate from the U.S. B)6(e)3(ing)9( a European, one)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(should not completely)30( ig)10(nore the U.S. cases, since Europe is roug)10(hly)30( lag)10(g)10(i)-2(ng)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(two or three y)29(ears behind the U.S. concerning)9( the I)22(n)-1(ternet, and any)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(innovative leg)10(a)4(l solution reg)10(a)4(rding)10( novel technolog)10(ies found by)30( U.S. courts,)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(may)29( be of interest even for European countries with different leg)9(a)3(l sy)29(stems.)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(The)5( U.S. ha)5(s some)5(time)5(s be)5(e)5(n)1( c)5(r)4(itic)5(ize)5(d)1( for its e)5(a)5(g)11(e)5(r)4( to a)5(pply)31( its fe)5(de)5(ra)5(l la)5(ws)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(o)-2(wards forei)-4(g)8(ners, even when Am)-4(eri)-4(can i)-4(n)-2(t)-4(e)2(rest)-4(s are not)-4( at)-4( st)-4(ake. Even)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(thoug)9(h many)29( of such judg)9(ements and sentences are not ex)-11(ecutable in all)]TJ
T*
[(countries, they)29( could have a serious affect upon the people or companies in)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(question. This, because the U.S)-4(.)0( is such a mig)10(hty)30( business nation and people)]TJ
T*
[(around the world depend upon the U.S. in many)30( situations. One could be)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
[(a)4(rre)4(ste)4(d)0( if visiting)10( the)4( U.S., or one)4(\222s prope)4(rty)30( in the)4( U.S. c)4(ould be)]TJ
T*
-0.003 Tc
0.003 Tw
[(confi)-5(s)-4(cat)-5(ed et)-5(c.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 187.89 510.27 Tm
0.007 Tc
(194)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 476.43 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(The)4(r)3(e)4( sure)4(ly)30( e)4(x)-10(ists othe)4(r I)23(n)0(te)4(rne)4(t)-2( re)4(la)4(te)4(d U.S. c)4(a)4(s)-1(e)4(s)-1( c)4(onc)4(e)4(r)3(ning)10( jurisdic)4(tion)]TJ
T*
[(issues, but I)23( restricted this study)30( to cover the ones I)23( find most relevant and)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(i)-4(n)-2(t)-4(e)2(rest)-4(i)-4(n)-2(g)8(.)-2( W)-8(h)-2(en anal)-4(y)28(z)-8(i)-4(n)-2(g)8( t)-4(h)-2(e cases bel)-4(o)-2(w, one recei)-4(ves t)-4(h)-2(e i)-4(m)-4(p)-2(ressi)-4(on)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(tha)4(t)-2( the)4( c)4(ourts a)4(r)3(e)4( striving)10( towa)4(rds a)4( more)4( re)4(la)4(x)-10(e)4(d a)4(ttitude)4( c)4(onc)4(e)4(r)3(ning)10( the)]TJ
T*
[(c)4(r)3(ite)4(ria)4( ne)4(e)4(d)0(e)4(d)0( in orde)4(r to e)4(s)-1(ta)4(blish jurisdic)4(tion ove)4(r out-of-sta)4(te)4( I)23(n)0(te)4(rne)4(t)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(users. This may)29( be a desperate attempt to g)9(a)3(in control over the various)]TJ
T*
[(activities that take place in Cy)29(berspace, as the technolog)9(y)29( is developing)9( at)]TJ
T*
[(such a rapid speed that g)9(overnments fear that present laws may)29( soon be)]TJ
T*
(superfluous. Some of these cases have been criticized for not fully)Tj
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(com)-4(p)-2(rehendi)-4(ng)8( t)-4(h)-2(e new m)-4(e)2(di)-4(um)-4( i)-4(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e el)-4(ect)-4(roni)-4(c C)-5(y)28(berspace.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 412.41 354.51 Tm
0.007 Tc
(195)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 144.15 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 147.27 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 136.47 Tm
(194)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 131.91 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(1lWMXULGLN\003\261\003/DJ\003RFK\003UlWW\003Sn\003,QWHUQHW)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
14.8072 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, by)22( T)-12(h)10(om)23(as)7( C)8(a)2(rl)5(\351n)10(-)12(W)-4(en)10(del)5(s)7(, pag)10(e)]TJ
-16.0361 -1.1807 TD
0.006 Tc
(33.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 112.95 Tm
0 Tc
(195)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 108.39 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(*RYHUQPHQW\003LQ\003&\\EHUVSDFH\003\020\003:KDW\003-XULVGLFWLRQ)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
18.9879 0 TD
0.003 Tw
[(, NZ)9( Institute o)-6(f)8( P)-10(u)6(b)-6(lic)]TJ
-20.2169 -1.1807 TD
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[(A)14(d)-3(m)22(i)4(n)9(i)4(s)6(t)4(ration)9( \(In)9(c.\), Gov)9(e)1(rn)9(an)9(ce in)9( C)7(y)21(bers)6(pace C)7(o)-3(n)9(f)11(eren)9(ce, 17 A)14(p)-3(ril 1997,)]TJ
T*
[(presen)9(ted by)21( Mich)9(ael C)7(r)-1(on)9(in)9( an)9(d B)-5(e)1(rn)9(adette J)-6(e)1(w)26(.)]TJ
T*
-0.021 Tc
[(H)-22(t)-20(t)-20(p)-27(:)-20(/)-20(/)-20(www.)-24(r)-25(mmb)-27(.)-24(c)-23(o)-27(.)-24(n)-15(z)-23(/)-20(c)-23(yb)-27(e)-23(r)-25(g)-15(o)-27(v)-15(h)-15(t)-20(m)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
420 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
421 0 obj
<<
/Length 4904
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(60)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
24 0 0 24 113.49 733.71 Tm
[(\034\003)-310($)-28(P)-3(HULFDQ\003FDVHV\003LQ\003ZKLFK)]TJ
0 -1.175 TD
(MXULVGLFWLRQ\003LV\003JUDQWHG)Tj
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 655.47 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(\034\021\024\003)-436(8)-1(QLWHG\0036WDWHV\003Y)20(\021)-1(\0037KRPDV)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
10.56 0 0 10.56 331.89 663.03 Tm
0.001 Tc
(196)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 624.63 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(This is a criminal obscenity)29( case from 1996 where Mr. Robert Alan Thomas)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(and his wife Carleen Thomas operated \(from February)29( 1991\) a B)6(B)6(S)-5( on a)]TJ
T*
[(computer in their home in Milpitas, California called ")7(A)1(mateur Action,")]TJ
T*
[(from which subscribers could download pornog)9(raphic materials. Mr.Thomas)]TJ
T*
[(converted pictures from adult paperback mag)9(a)3(z)-7(i)-3(nes to Graphic I)22(n)-1(terchang)9(e)]TJ
T*
[(F)5(o)-1(rmat files \(GI)22(F)5(\) by)29( using)9( a scanner and stored these in the harddrive of his)]TJ
T*
[(computer. The B)6(B)6(S)-5( contained close to 14,000 GI)22(F)5( files. The Thomases also)]TJ
T*
[(made it possible to order adult videotapes by)29( e-mail and have them delivered)]TJ
T*
[(by)29( the United Parcel Service \(UPS\). Surfers who were not members could)]TJ
T*
[(only)29( view the introductory)29( screens, which contained descriptions of the)]TJ
T*
[(material posted deeper into the web-sy)29(stem. I)22(n)-1( order to view all the GI)22(F)]TJ
T*
[(files, membership was oblig)9(atory)29(.)-1( After pay)29(i)-3(ng)9( a membership fee of $55 and)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(submitting)10( a)4( sig)10(n)0(e)4(d)0( a)4(pplic)4(a)4(tion form \(inc)4(luding)10( the)4( a)4(pplic)4(a)4(n)0(t\222s a)4(ddre)4(ss\), a)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(personal)-3( password woul)-3(d be sent)-3(, g)9(r)2(ant)-3(i)-3(n)-1(g)9( ful)-3(l)-3( access t)-3(o)-1( t)-3(h)-1(e deeper si)-3(t)-3(e)3(s of)]TJ
T*
-0.006 Tc
0.006 Tw
[(t)-8(h)-6(e BBS)-10(.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 404.07 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\034\021\024\021\024)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(7KH\003&DOLIRUQLD\003ZHEVLWH\003GLVWULEXWHG\003REVFHQH\003PDWHULDO\003LQ)Tj
-2.6154 -1.1795 TD
0 Tc
(7HQQHVVHH)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 359.07 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(As part of an undercover operation in 1993, David Dirmay)29(er, a federal)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(post)-4(a)2(l)-4( worker i)-4(n)-2( Tennessee appl)-4(i)-4(e)2(d and recei)-4(ved ful)-4(l)-4( access t)-4(o)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Californian B)6(B)6(S)-5(. Mr.Thomas e-mailed and spoke to Mr.Dirmay)29(e)3(r on the)]TJ
T*
[(phone, and therefore knew Mr.Dirmay)29(e)3(r was a resident of Tennessee.)]TJ
T*
[(Mr.Dirmay)29(e)3(r downloaded some of the GI)22(F)5( files and ordered six)-11( adult)]TJ
T*
[(videotapes, which were delivered to an address in Tennessee by)29( the UPS.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 265.95 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\034\021\024\021\025)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(7KH\003REVFHQH\003GRZQORDGHG\003PDWHULDO\003GLG\003OHDYH\003WKH)Tj
-2.6154 -1.1795 TD
(&DOLIRUQLDQ\003ZHEVLWH)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 220.95 Tm
0 Tc
[(Mr.Dirma)4(y)30(e)4(r broug)10(ht a)4( c)4(r)3(imina)4(l)-2( c)4(o)0(mpla)4(int a)4(g)10(a)4(i)-2(nst the)4( Thoma)4(s)-1(e)4(s)-1( for)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(di)-4(st)-4(ri)-4(but)-4(i)-4(n)-2(g)8( obscene m)-4(a)2(t)-4(e)2(ri)-4(al)-4( i)-4(n)-2( Tennessee. The Thom)-4(ases arg)8(u)-2(ed t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( t)-4(h)-2(ey)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(had no intention of distributing)10( the material in Tennessee and that the)]TJ
T*
[(ma)4(te)4(ria)4(l)-2( ne)4(ve)4(r le)4(ft the)4(i)-2(r home)4( sinc)4(e)4( the)4( me)4(mbe)4(r)3( himse)4(l)-2(f ha)4(d pulle)4(d the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(material into a foreig)9(n jurisdiction. The court rejected this arg)9(u)-1(ment. I)22(t)-3( is)]TJ
T*
[(illeg)9(a)3(l to receive, transport or distribute obscene material and apparently)29( this)]TJ
T*
[(was the case when posting)9( material on a website. I)22(t)-3( is unfortunate that the)]TJ
T*
[(court did not further ex)-11(plain when information on a site is considered to)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(ha)5(ve)5( le)5(ft the)5( jurisdic)5(tion.)]TJ
0 -1.86 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 88.47 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 77.67 Tm
(196)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 73.11 Tm
0.003 Tc
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.506 0 TD
0 Tc
(8QLWHG\0036WDWHV\003Y\021\0037KRPDV)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
9.7711 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[( 74 F)7(.)2(3d 701 \(6)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 315.69 77.67 Tm
0 Tc
(th)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 320.73 73.11 Tm
0.005 Tc
[( C)9(i)6(r.\). Jan)11(u)11(a)3(ry)23( 29, 1996.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
422 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F5 276 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
423 0 obj
<<
/Length 5680
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(61)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 743.31 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\034\021\024\021\026)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(5HIXVLQJ\003FXVWRPHUV\003LQ\003FHUWDLQ\003MXULVGLFWLRQV\003LQ\003RUGHU\003WR)Tj
-2.6154 -1.1795 TD
(GLPLQLVK\003ULVN\003RI\003OLDELOLW\\)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 698.31 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(I)24(f)4( the)5( Thoma)5(s)0(e)5(s)0( would not ha)5(ve)5( wishe)5(d)1( to subje)5(c)5(t)-1( the)5(m)-1(se)5(lve)5(s)0( to lia)5(bility)31( in)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(jurisdic)4(tions with le)4(ss tole)4(ra)4(nt sta)4(nda)4(rds for de)4(te)4(rmining)10( obsc)4(e)4(n)0(ity)30(, the)4(y)]TJ
T*
[(could have refused to supply)30( passwords to members in those districts, thus)]TJ
T*
[(diminishing)10( the)4( risk of lia)4(bility)30(. The)4( c)4(ourt se)4(e)4(m)-2(e)4(d)0( to find pe)4(rsona)4(l)]TJ
T*
[(jurisdiction merely)30( on the accessibility)30( of the site)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 348.93 647.19 Tm
0.007 Tc
(197)Tj
12 0 0 12 361.17 641.67 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(, and t)-4(h)-2(e fact)-4( t)-4(h)-2(at)]TJ
-20.64 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(Mr.Thomas had clear intention to avail himself of the Tennessee market,)Tj
T*
(because he requested information about the applicant and thus knew that the)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(applicant was situated in Tennessee. This knowledg)10(e did not stop him from)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(providing)9( the necessary)29( password to the applicant. The effects of)]TJ
T*
(Mr.Thomas conduct had reached Tennessee, and therefore Tennessee was)Tj
T*
[(considered the proper jurisdiction. As a result of this reasoning)9(, the)]TJ
T*
[(Thomases were convicted and sentenced to two and a half y)29(ears in prison.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 518.79 Tm
[(\034\021\025\003)-436(,)1(QVHW\0036\\)10(V)-2(WHPV\017\003,QF\021\003Y)20(\021\003,QVWUXFWLRQV\0036HW\017\003,QF\021)]TJ
ET
1 i
113.49 517.11 21.96 -1.56 re
f
BT
/F5 1 Tf
10.56 0 0 10.56 113.49 507.51 Tm
0.001 Tc
(198)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 469.11 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(This case from 1996 is considered to be in the g)9(r)2(ay)29( area between the two)]TJ
T*
[(ex)-11(tremes, meaning)9( that neither the passive contact standard, nor the active)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(contact standard is met. I)23(n)0(set Sy)30(stems, I)23(n)0(c. \(I)23(nset\), a Connecticut)]TJ
T*
[(corporation broug)10(ht trademark infring)10(ement action ag)10(ainst I)23(n)0(structions Set,)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(I)21(n)-2(c. \(I)21(S)-6(I)21(\), a Massachuset)-4(t)-4(s)-3( corporat)-4(i)-4(on whi)-4(c)2(h used i)-4(t)-4(s)-3( t)-4(r)1(adem)-4(ark \224I)21(nset)-4(\224 as)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(the I)22(n)-1(ternet domain name \224I)22(nset.com\224. I)22(S)-5(I)22( filed a motion to dismiss for lack)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(of personal jurisdiction. I)23(n)0( 1995, when I)23(n)0(set attempted to obtain the above)]TJ
T*
[(mentioned domain address, I)23(n)0(set found out that it was already)30( taken by)30( I)23(S)-4(I)23(.)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(I)22(S)-5(I)22( also used the phone number \2241-800-US-I)22(NSET\224 when advertising)9( its)]TJ
T*
[(products on the web. There was no kind of authoriz)-7(ation from I)22(n)-1(set to use)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(i)-4(t)-4(s)-3( t)-4(r)1(adem)-4(ark \224I)21(nset)-4(\224 i)-4(n)-2( any)28( way)28(.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 291.03 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\034\021\025\021\024)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
(:HEVLWH\003DGYHUWLVHPHQW\003IXOILOOHG\003WKH\003\263PLQLPXP\003FRQWDFWV)Tj
-2.6154 -1.1795 TD
(WHVW\264)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 246.03 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Since March 1995, I)22(S)-5(I)22( had been advertising)9( its products on-line, and there)]TJ
T*
(were at least 10,000 access sites on the web in Connecticut. The court)Tj
T*
[(stressed the power of the I)22(n)-1(ternet as an advertising)9( medium, stating)9( that)]TJ
T*
[(\224...unlike hard-copy)29( advertisements... ...which are often quickly)29( disposed of)]TJ
T*
[(and reach a limited number of potential consumers, I)22(n)-1(ternet advertisements)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(are i)-4(n)-2( el)-4(ect)-4(roni)-4(c pri)-4(n)-2(t)-4(e)2(d form)-4( so t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( t)-4(h)-2(ey)28( can be accessed ag)8(ai)-4(n and ag)8(ai)-4(n)]TJ
0 -3.57 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
113.49 135.51 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 124.71 Tm
(197)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 120.15 Tm
0.003 Tc
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.506 0 TD
0 Tc
(\([WHQGLQJ\0033HUVRQDO\003-XULVGLFWLRQ\003WR\003$FWV\003LQ\003&\\EHUVSDFH)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
22.0482 0 TD
0.003 Tc
[(, by)21( Dan)9(e)]TJ
-23.5301 -1.1807 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(S)6(t)5(ef)12(f)12(e)2(n)10(s)7(s)7(o)-2(n)10( f)12(o)-2(r L)13(a)2(w)27( 7333 \(L)13(aw)27( &)11( T)-12(h)10(e In)10(t)5(e)2(rn)10(et)5(\) s)7(p)-2(ri)5(n)10(g)10( s)7(e)2(m)23(e)2(s)7(t)5(er 1997 at)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(Georg)7(i)2(a State Un)7(iv)7(ersity)19( C)5(o)-5(lleg)7(e)-1( of)9( L)10(a)-1(w)24(.)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
0 Tc
(198)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 84.87 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(,QVHW\0036\\VWHPV\017\003,QF\021\003Y\021\003,QVWUXFWLRQ\0036HW)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
14.5181 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(, In)11(c. 937 F)7(.)2(S)7(u)11(pp.161 \(D. C)9(o)-1(n)11(n)11(.)2(1996\))]TJ
-15.747 -1.1807 TD
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[(A)14(p)-3(ril 17, 1996. Http://zeu)9(s)6(.)0(bn)9(a.com)22(/)4(e-)11(law)26(/)4(cas)6(es)6(/in)9(s)6(e)1(t.h)9(t)4(m)22(l)4( \(970925\))]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
424 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F5 276 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
425 0 obj
<<
/Length 7127
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(62)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
-14.85 58.94 TD
0 Tw
[(by)30( many)30( more potential consumers.\224)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 289.53 750.99 Tm
0.007 Tc
(199)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 301.77 745.47 Tm
0 Tc
[( This quality)30( of continuous contacts)]TJ
-15.69 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(tha)5(t)-1( I)24(n)1(te)5(rne)5(t)-1( provide)5(s, fulfills the)5( \223)5(minimum c)5(onta)5(c)5(t)-1(s te)5(st\224)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 393.69 736.83 Tm
0.007 Tc
(200)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 405.93 731.31 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[( accordi)-4(n)-2(g)8( t)-4(o)]TJ
-24.37 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(the court. B)6(y)29( posting)9( the advertisements on the web, I)22(S)-5(I)22( had purposefully)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(availed itself of the privileg)10(e)4( of doing)10( business with Connecticut and could)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(the)5(r)4(e)5(f)4(ore)5( re)5(a)5(s)0(ona)5(bly)31( a)5(n)1(tic)5(ipa)5(t)-1(e)5( the)5( possibility)31( of be)5(ing)11( ha)5(ile)5(d into c)5(ourt in)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(there. I)22(S)-5(I)22( had posted an 800 number, which could be seen as an indication)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(that the site was try)30(i)-2(ng)10( to g)10(e)4(t in contact with residents outside)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Massachusetts. However, there was hardly)29( any)29( discussion whether the site)]TJ
T*
[(was ever visited or if the number ever used, or if I)22(S)-5(I)22( had any)29( knowledg)9(e of)]TJ
T*
[(Connecticut residents accessing)9( the site or calling)9( the number.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 411.81 623.55 Tm
0.007 Tc
(201)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 589.71 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(I)22( find this reasoning)9( very)29( peculiar. The only)29( contact was the advertisement)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(with the 800 number on the webpag)10(e)4(, but still the court stated that I)23(S)-4(I)23( had)]TJ
T*
[(purposefully)30( availed itself to the benefits of the privileg)10(e)4( of doing)10( business)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(in Connecticut. Are web operators and advertisers using)9( toll-free numbers)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(a)4(ll ove)4(r the)4( world purpose)4(f)3(ully)30( a)4(v)0(a)4(iling)10( the)4(m)-2(se)4(lve)4(s)-1( to the)4( privile)4(g)10(e)4( of)]TJ
T*
[(conducting)10( business in Connecticut, even if they)30( do not know that)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(Conne)5(c)5(tic)5(ut e)5(x)-9(ists a)5(t)-1( a)5(ll?)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 234.09 510.27 Tm
0.007 Tc
(202)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 480.99 Tm
0 Tc
[(\034\021\026\003)-435(3)0(OD\\)11(E)0(R\\)11(\003\(QWHUSULVHV\003Y)21(\021)0(\003&KXFNOHEHUU\\)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
(3XEOLVKLQJ\003,QF\021)Tj
10.56 0 0 10.56 226.89 469.71 Tm
0.001 Tc
(\025\023\026)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 431.31 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(The)4( de)4(fe)4(nda)4(nt, Ta)4(tillo, situa)4(t)-2(e)4(d)0( in I)23(t)-2(a)4(l)-2(y)30(,)0( infring)10(e)4(d)0( the)4( tra)4(d)0(e)4(m)-2(a)4(r)3(k of Pla)4(y)30(boy)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(a)5(nd wa)5(s subje)5(c)5(t)-1( to a)5(n)1( injunc)5(tion prohibiting)11( him to se)5(ll or e)5(v)1(e)5(n)1( distribute)5( his)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(mag)9(a)3(z)-7(i)-3(ne \223Play)29(m)-3(en\224 in the U.S. and in other countries as well. I)22(t)-3(aly)29( was one)]TJ
T*
[(of the countries where P)-5(l)-3(ay)29(boy)29( did not successfully)29( obtain any)29( injunction.)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(The I)21(t)-4(al)-4(i)-4(a)2(n publ)-4(i)-4(s)-3(her t)-4(h)-2(erefore creat)-4(ed an I)21(t)-4(al)-4(i)-4(a)2(n websi)-4(t)-4(e)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(\(http://www.play)30(men.it\) and withheld that he did not at all distribute his)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(ma)5(g)11(a)5(zine)5( in the)5( U.S. sinc)5(e)5( he)5( utilize)5(d)1( a)5( se)5(rve)5(r)4( situa)5(t)-1(e)5(d)1( in I)24(t)-1(a)5(l)-1(y)31(.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 324.03 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\034\021\026\021\024)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(3)6(ODFLQJ\003LQIRUPDWLRQ\003RQ\003DQ\003,)-8(WDOLDQ\003VHUYHU\003LV\003HTXLYDOHQW)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 297.51 Tm
0 Tc
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 300.63 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 289.83 Tm
(199)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 285.27 Tm
-0.005 Tc
0.008 Tw
[( I)-9(b)-11(id)-11(.)-8( Q)-6(u)1(o)-11(t)-4(e)-7( fr)-9(o)-11(m)14( d)-11(i)-4(sc)-7(ussio)-11(n)1( c)-7(o)-11(nc)-7(e)-7(r)-9(ning the)-7( Co)-11(nne)-7(c)-7(tic)-7(ut Lo)-11(ng-Ar)-9(m)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
0 Tc
[(Statu)6(t)1(e.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 141.81 265.35 Tm
0.007 Tc
(200)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 154.05 259.83 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( The)4( \221minimum c)4(onta)4(c)4(t)-2(s te)4(st\222 is fulfille)4(d if the)4( de)4(fe)4(nda)4(nt)]TJ
-1.02 -1.18 TD
[(throug)10(h some act purposefully)30( avails himself of the privileg)10(e)4( of)]TJ
T*
[(conducting)10( activities within the forum State, thus invoking)10( the)]TJ
T*
(benefits and protections of its laws.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 209.67 Tm
(201)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 205.11 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(*RYHUQPHQW\003LQ\003&\\EHUVSDFH\003\020\003:KDW\003-XULVGLFWLRQ)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
18.9879 0 TD
0.003 Tw
[(, NZ)9( Institute o)-6(f)8( P)-10(u)6(b)-6(lic)]TJ
-20.2169 -1.1807 TD
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[(A)14(d)-3(m)22(i)4(n)9(i)4(s)6(t)4(ration)9( \(In)9(c.\), Gov)9(e)1(rn)9(an)9(ce in)9( C)7(y)21(bers)6(pace C)7(o)-3(n)9(f)11(eren)9(ce, 17 A)14(p)-3(ril 1997,)]TJ
T*
[(presen)9(ted by)21( Mich)9(ael C)7(r)-1(on)9(in)9( an)9(d B)-5(e)1(rn)9(adette J)-6(e)1(w)26(,)0( at 3.21.)]TJ
T*
-0.021 Tc
[(H)-22(t)-20(t)-20(p)-27(:)-20(/)-20(/)-20(www.)-24(r)-25(mmb)-27(.)-24(c)-23(o)-27(.)-24(n)-15(z)-23(/)-20(c)-23(yb)-27(e)-23(r)-25(g)-15(o)-27(v)-15(h)-15(t)-20(m)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 141.81 161.67 Tm
0.007 Tc
(202)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 154.05 156.15 Tm
-0.006 Tc
[(\003-XU)-10(L)-9(V)-10(GL)-9(FW)-9(L)-9(RQ\003L)-9(Q)0(\003D\003:RU)-10(O)-9(G)0(\003:L)-9(W)-9(KRXW)-9(\003%RU)-10(GHU)-10(V)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
16.41 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(, Dan L)20(.)-1( B)6(u)-1(rk.)]TJ
-17.43 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(Http://zeus.bna.com/e-law/cases/heroes.html \(970925\))Tj
/F3 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 141.81 129.75 Tm
-0.023 Tc
[(www.)-26(s)-20(t)-22(u)-17(d)-29(e)-25(n)-17(t)-22(.)-26(v)-17(i)-22(r)-27(g)-17(i)-22(n)-17(i)-22(a)-25(.)-26(e)-25(d)-29(u)-17(/)-22(~)-24(v)-17(j)-34(o)]TJ
12.3855 0 TD
-0.002 Tc
[(lt/vo)-8(l)-1(1)-8(/)-1(B)-10(U)-3(RK.htm)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 141.81 121.59 Tm
0.007 Tc
(203)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 154.05 116.07 Tm
0 Tc
( United States District Court Southern district of N.Y. )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
21.8 0 TD
(\020)Tj
-22.82 -1.18 TD
-0.003 Tc
[(3OD\\ER\\\003\(QWHU)-7(S)3(U)-7(L)-6(V)-7(H)3(V)-7(\003)0(,)4(QF\021\003Y\021\003&)-10(KXFNOHEHU)-7(U)-7(\\)3(\0033XEOLV)-7(KLQJ\003,)4(QF\017\0037)-9(DWLOOR)]TJ
T*
0.003 Tc
[(\()7(G)9(LWULF)9(H)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
3.22 0 TD
0 Tc
[(. 939 F)6(.)0(Supp.1032 \(S.D.N.Y 1996\) J)-11(une 19, 1996.)]TJ
-3.22 -1.18 TD
[(Http://www.jmls.edu/cy)30(ber/cases/play)30(m)-2(en.tx)-10(t)-2( \(970917\))]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
426 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
427 0 obj
<<
/Length 5681
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(63)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 743.31 Tm
-0.001 Tc
(RI\003GLVWULEXWLQJ\003WKH\003LQIRUPDWLRQ\003ZLWKLQ\003WKH\0038\0216\021)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 700.71 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(Ta)5(tillo ma)5(inta)5(ine)5(d)1( tha)5(t)-1( pe)5(ople)5( in the)5( U.S. ha)5(d to visit the)5( I)24(t)-1(a)5(lia)5(n se)5(rve)5(r)4( in)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(order to receive the posted information, which would be similar to boarding)Tj
T*
[(a flig)9(ht to I)22(t)-3(aly)29( and, once there, buy)29( the mag)9(a)3(z)-7(i)-3(ne, and then fly)29( back to the)]TJ
T*
[(U.S. ag)9(ain. The court ag)9(reed to the fact that the users downloaded the)]TJ
T*
[(information from an I)22(t)-3(alian based server, but stated that such reasoning)9( was)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
[(irrelevant. The U.S. court stated: \224Defendant has actively)29( solicited United)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(States customers to its I)23(n)0(ternet site, and in doing)10( so has distributed its)]TJ
T*
[(product within the United States. W)-6(h)0(en a potential subscriber fax)-10(e)4(s the)]TJ
0 -1.26 TD
[(re)4(quire)4(d form to Ta)4(tillo)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12.96 0 0 12.96 227.01 586.47 Tm
(,)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 230.25 586.47 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[( he recei)-4(ves back vi)-4(a e-m)-4(a)2(i)-4(l)-4( a password and user)]TJ
-9.73 -1.2 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(name. B)7(y)30( this process, Tatillo distributes its product within the United)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
[(S)-6(t)-4(at)-4(es.\224)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 150.45 563.43 Tm
0.007 Tc
(204)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 162.69 557.91 Tm
0 Tc
[( The)4( c)4(ourt a)4(l)-2(so he)4(ld tha)4(t)-2( by)30( inviting)10( U.S. use)4(r)3(s to downloa)4(d the)]TJ
-4.1 -1.18 TD
(posted information, Tatillo caused and contributed to the distribution of the)Tj
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(ma)5(g)11(a)5(zine)5( within the)5( U.S.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 507.27 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\034\021\026\021\025)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(,)-8(WDOLDQ\003SXEOLVKHU\003RUGHUHG\003WR\003LJQRUH\0038\0216\021\003XVHUV\003RU\003VKXW)]TJ
-2.6154 -1.1795 TD
(GRZQ\003WKH\003VLWH)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 462.27 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(The I)21(t)-4(al)-4(i)-4(a)2(n publ)-4(i)-4(s)-3(her was ordered by)28( t)-4(h)-2(e U.S)-6(.)-2( court)-4( not)-4( t)-4(o)-2( accept)-4( Am)-4(eri)-4(can)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(customers or shut down the website. F)5(r)2(om such a statement one can draw)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(the)4( c)4(onc)4(lusion tha)4(t)-2( if Ta)4(tillo would not ha)4(ve)4( sold to U.S. c)4(u)0(stome)4(r)3(s, a)4(nd not)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(being)9( subjected to the earlier injunction, he would not have been)]TJ
T*
[(subordinated American jurisdiction. I)22(n)-1( this case, however, the court found)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(jurisdic)5(tion due)5( to the)5( fa)5(c)5(t)-1( tha)5(t)-1( Ta)5(tillo ha)5(d a)5(c)5(tive)5(l)-1(y)31( solic)5(ite)5(d U.S. c)5(u)1(stome)5(r)4(s)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(to the I)22(t)-3(alian based site, and thereby)29( vended the Play)29(men mag)9(a)3(z)-7(i)-3(ne within)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(the U.S. Nevertheless, one can disting)10(u)0(ish a bit of \223territorial hesitation\224)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(from the U.S. court, since Tatillo could proceed publishing)9( the Play)29(men)]TJ
T*
[(mag)9(a)3(z)-7(i)-3(ne on the world wide web, as long)9( as no subscribers where situated in)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(the)5( U.S. The)5( c)5(ourt a)5(l)-1(so me)5(ntione)5(d the)5( option shutting)11( down the)5( I)24(n)1(te)5(rne)5(t)-1( site)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(completely)30(, but I)23( doubt that such an action is effortless to perform. Tatillo)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(could easily)29( open up the same ty)29(pe of site in some other remote location)]TJ
T*
(where the American injunction was not obtained.)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 254.43 Tm
0 Tc
[(\034\021\027\003)-435(&RPSX6HUY)21(H\003Y)21(\021)0(\0033DWWHUVRQ)]TJ
10.56 0 0 10.56 340.53 261.99 Tm
0.001 Tc
(\025\023\030)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 223.59 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(This case from 1997 has been widely)29( debated and also heavily)29( criticized in)]TJ
T*
[(the media. Mr.Patterson, a software desig)9(n)-1(er in Houston, Tex)-11(a)3(s, was found)]TJ
T*
[(being)9( subject to Ohio jurisdiction. He was a shareware provider, attempting)]TJ
T*
[(to sell his prog)9(rams on-line. Patterson entered into a ")7(S)-5(hareware)]TJ
T*
[(Reg)9(i)-3(stration Ag)9(reement")7( \(SRA\) with CompuServe, which is a computer)]TJ
0 -2.08 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 145.11 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 134.31 Tm
(204)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 129.75 Tm
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( Ibi)5(d)-2(. at)5( 1309.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 141.81 121.59 Tm
0.007 Tc
(205)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 154.05 116.07 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( United States Court of Appeals for the six)-11(t)-3(h circuit)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
20.63 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\017)Tj
-21.65 -1.18 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(&)-12(R)1(PSX6HU)-9(YH\017\003,QF)]TJ
/F8 1 Tf
6.87 0 TD
0 Tc
(\021)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.25 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(\003Y\021\0035L)-8(FKDU)-9(G\0036\021\0033DW)-8(W)-8(H)1(U)-9(V)-9(RQ\017\003L)-8(QGL)-8(YL)-8(GXDO)-8(O)-8(\\)1(\017\003DQG)]TJ
-7.12 -1.18 TD
[(\)O)-8(DV)-9(KSRL)-8(QW)-8(\003'HYHO)-8(RSPHQW)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
9.85 0 TD
0 Tc
[(. \( No. 95-3452\) J)-11(u)0(ly)30( 22, 1997.)]TJ
-9.85 -1.18 TD
[(Http://www.jmls.edu/cy)30(ber/cases/patter.html \(970922\))]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
428 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
/F8 429 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
430 0 obj
<<
/Length 4961
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(64)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
0 Tw
(information service headquartered in Columbus, Ohio. CompuServe)Tj
0 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(provi)-4(ded i)-4(t)-4(s)-3( subscri)-4(b)-2(ers wi)-4(t)-4(h)-2( access t)-4(o)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e soft)-4(ware, or shareware, t)-4(h)-2(at)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Patterson created. CompuServe then started distributing)10( software with a)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
[(na)4(me)4( ve)4(ry)30( simila)4(r to tha)4(t)-2( of Pa)4(tte)4(rson\222s softwa)4(re)4(. Pa)4(tte)4(rson a)4(lle)4(g)10(e)4(d tha)4(t)]TJ
T*
[(CompuServe was infring)10(ing)10( his trademarks and demanded at least $100,000)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(to se)5(ttle)5( his pote)5(n)1(tia)5(l c)5(l)-1(a)5(ims. CompuSe)5(r)4(ve)5( obse)5(r)4(ve)5(d tha)5(t)-1( if Pa)5(tte)5(rson\222s)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(al)-4(l)-4(e)2(g)8(a)2(t)-4(i)-4(ons of t)-4(r)1(adem)-4(ark i)-4(n)-2(fri)-4(ng)8(em)-4(ent)-4( were correct)-4(, t)-4(h)-2(i)-4(s)-3( woul)-4(d t)-4(h)-2(reat)-4(en)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(CompuServe')9(s)-2( software sales revenue with a loss of approx)-11(imately)29( $10.8)]TJ
T*
[(million. Therefore CompuServe soug)9(ht a declaratory)29( judg)9(ment in the federal)]TJ
T*
(district court for the Southern District of Ohio, in order to ascertain that no)Tj
T*
[(trademark infring)9(ements had been conducted.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 553.23 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\034\021\027\021\024)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
[($\003IHZ\003VDOHV\003YLD\003WKH\003,)-8(QWHUQHW\003DUH\003FRQVLGHUHG\003VXIILFLHQW)]TJ
-2.6154 -1.1795 TD
0 Tc
(FRQWDFWV)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 494.07 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(Patterson required the case would be dismissed for lack of personal)Tj
T*
[(jurisdiction. He claimed that he had never phy)29(sically)29( been to Ohio and that)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(he sold less than $650 worth of his software to only)30( 12 Ohio residents on-)]TJ
T*
(line. The court believed that Patterson had sufficient contacts with Ohio to)Tj
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(support the ex)-11(ercise of personal jurisdiction. According)9( to this case, by)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(entering)10( into contract with residents of foreig)10(n jurisdictions that involve the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(knowing)9( and repeated transmission of computer files over the I)22(n)-1(ternet,)]TJ
T*
(personal jurisdiction is considered proper.)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 372.63 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\034\021\027\021\025)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(6WXEERUQ\003IRFXV\003RQ\003WKH\003SK\\VLFDO\003SODFHPHQW\003RI\003WKH\003VHUYHU)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 344.19 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(B)8(a)5(sic)5(a)5(lly)31(, it se)5(e)5(m)-1(s like)5( the)5( c)5(ourt foc)5(u)1(se)5(d on the)5( phy)31(sic)5(a)5(l)-1( loc)5(a)5(tion of the)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(C)-5(o)-2(m)-4(puS)-6(erve server when det)-4(e)2(rm)-4(i)-4(n)-2(i)-4(n)-2(g)8( t)-4(h)-2(e pl)-4(ace of sal)-4(e)2(. The court)-4( st)-4(at)-4(ed)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(tha)5(t)-1( it is re)5(a)5(s)0(ona)5(ble)5( to subje)5(c)5(t)-1( Pa)5(tte)5(rson to suit in Ohio, the)5( sta)5(t)-1(e)5( whic)5(h is)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(home to the computer network service he chose to employ)29(, since he)]TJ
T*
[(repeatedly)29( sent his computer software, via electronic links, to the)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(CompuServe sy)30(stem in Ohio and advertised that software on the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(CompuServe sy)29(stem. The software was sent electronically)29( from Tex)-11(a)3(s to)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(CompuSe)4(r)3(ve)4( in Ohio for the)4(i)-2(r ultima)4(te)4( sa)4(le)4( a)4(n)0(y)30(w)2(he)4(re)4( in the)4( world.)]TJ
T*
[(CompuServe in Ohio, acted as Patterson')10(s distributor, albeit electronically)]TJ
T*
[(and not phy)30(sically)30(.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
[(Even thoug)10(h most of the sales were made to customers outside of Ohio, the)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(court)-4( seem)-4(s t)-4(o)-2( have assum)-4(e)2(d t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( si)-4(nce t)-4(h)-2(e soft)-4(ware was el)-4(ect)-4(roni)-4(cal)-4(l)-4(y)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(stored on a server in Ohio, all the vending)10( to Ohio customers and non-Ohio)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(customers took place in Ohio. I)22(f)2( a person or business conducts a business)]TJ
T*
[(within a forum state by)29( being)9( a subscriber to a local I)22(SP, and sells a product)]TJ
T*
[(throug)9(h that provider, jurisdiction is proper. I)22(n)-1( this case the server was)]TJ
T*
(located in Ohio, but what if the server would have been located in another)Tj
T*
[(state, another country)29( or in several states, each unknown to P)-5(a)3(tterson?)-17( I)22(t)-3( has)]TJ
T*
[(been pointed out that such reasoning)9( may)29( create problems, since vendors)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
431 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
432 0 obj
<<
/Length 6246
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(65)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(who lease I)22(n)-1(ternet space not alway)29(s)-2( know the location of the servers.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 444.09 750.99 Tm
0.007 Tc
(206)Tj
12 0 0 12 113.49 731.31 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(The)4(r)3(e)4( is a)4(l)-2(wa)4(y)30(s)-1( a)4( possibility)30( tha)4(t)-2( ove)4(rloa)4(de)4(d se)4(rve)4(r)3(s in orde)4(r to e)4(limina)4(t)-2(e)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(cong)9(estion, automatically)29( switch to secondary)29( servers in other g)9(e)3(og)9(raphic)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(locations and by)30( doing)10( so, the place of vending)10( would immediately)30( also)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(switch to the new location. I)22(f)2( that would have been the case, such stubborn)]TJ
T*
[(focus on the server location may)29( create a very)29( unpredictable situation for the)]TJ
T*
(on-line vendors.)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 638.19 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\034\021\027\021\026)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(3)6(RVVLELOLW\\\003RI\003\263VHUYHU\003KDYHQV\264\003LQ\003UHPRWH\003ORFDWLRQV)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 609.75 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(I)21( bel)-4(i)-4(e)2(ve t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( i)-4(f)1( t)-4(h)-2(e pl)-4(acem)-4(ent)-4( of t)-4(h)-2(e server deci)-4(des whet)-4(her or not)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(jurisdiction is proper, on-line vendors may)29( strive to use servers placed in)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
[(remote \223havens\224 which will under no circumstances file any)29( suits. I)22(f)2( this is)]TJ
T*
[(the case, I)22(n)-1(ternet users around the g)9(l)-3(obe could really)29( be without protection if)]TJ
T*
[(injured by)29( an on-line vendor since the \223havens\224 would not assist in any)29( way)29(.)]TJ
T*
[(I)22(t)-3( is not a difficult task any)29(m)-3(ore, utiliz)-7(ing)9( a server placed on the other side)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(of t)-4(h)-2(e worl)-4(d. Oft)-4(e)2(n t)-4(h)-2(e choi)-4(ce of server, i)-4(s)-3( a choi)-4(ce of free capaci)-4(t)-4(y)28( as wel)-4(l)]TJ
T*
[(as a choi)-4(ce of pri)-4(ce.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 208.77 516.15 Tm
0.007 Tc
(207)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 486.87 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(\034\021\030\003)-436(0DULW]\017\003,QF\021\003Y)20(\021\003&\\)10(EHU*ROG\017\003,QF\021)]TJ
10.56 0 0 10.56 368.97 494.43 Tm
0.001 Tc
(\025\023\033)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 456.03 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(C)-4(y)29(berGold\222s site on the I)22(n)-1(ternet at \223www.cy)29(berg)9(old.com\224 was accessible to)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(all users in the I)23(n)0(ternet community)30(. This Californian website contained)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(information about Cy)29(berGold\222s upcoming)9( planned I)22(n)-1(ternet service, which)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(na)5(tura)5(lly)31( wa)5(s not ope)5(ra)5(tiona)5(l a)5(t)-1( the)5( time)5(. Ma)5(ritz, I)24(n)1(c)5(., loc)5(a)5(t)-1(e)5(d)1( in Missouri,)]TJ
T*
[(soug)11(ht a)5( pre)5(limina)5(r)4(y)31( injunc)5(tion a)5(g)11(a)5(i)-1(nst Cy)31(be)5(rGold. Ma)5(ritz c)5(l)-1(a)5(ime)5(d tha)5(t)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Cy)30(berGold infring)10(ed upon Maritz)-6(\222s trademarks in violation of the L)21(a)4(nham)]TJ
T*
-0.003 Tc
(Act)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 130.77 376.59 Tm
0.007 Tc
(209)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 143.01 371.07 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( and that the infring)9(ement caused economic harm and injury)29( to Maritz)-7(.)]TJ
-2.46 -1.18 TD
[(Cy)29(berGold requested the court to dismiss the case due to lack of)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(jurisdiction. Maritz)-6( claimed that the injury)30( from Cy)30(berGold\222s infring)10(ement)]TJ
T*
[(occurred in Missouri. Maritz)-6( further stated that Cy)30(berGold\222s site invited)]TJ
T*
[(Missouria)4(ns to put the)4(i)-2(r na)4(me)4(s on Cy)30(be)4(rGold\222s ma)4(iling)10( list in orde)4(r to g)10(e)4(t)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(up-to-date information about the company)29( and its forthcoming)9( I)22(n)-1(ternet)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(se)5(rvic)5(e)5(.)1( Ma)5(ritz a)5(l)-1(so c)5(l)-1(a)5(ime)5(d tha)5(t)-1( Cy)31(be)5(rGold a)5(c)5(tive)5(l)-1(y)31( solic)5(ite)5(d c)5(u)1(stome)5(r)4(s)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(from Missouri throug)10(h the)4( I)23(n)0(te)4(rne)4(t)-2( a)4(dve)4(rtising)10(.)]TJ
0 -7.71 TD
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 182.55 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 171.75 Tm
(206)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 167.19 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(*RYHUQPHQW\003LQ\003&\\EHUVSDFH\003\020\003:KDW\003-XULVGLFWLRQ)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
18.9879 0 TD
0.003 Tw
[(, NZ)9( Institute o)-6(f)8( P)-10(u)6(b)-6(lic)]TJ
-20.2169 -1.1807 TD
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[(A)14(d)-3(m)22(i)4(n)9(i)4(s)6(t)4(ration)9( \(In)9(c.\), Gov)9(e)1(rn)9(an)9(ce in)9( C)7(y)21(bers)6(pace C)7(o)-3(n)9(f)11(eren)9(ce, 17 A)14(p)-3(ril 1997,)]TJ
T*
[(presen)9(ted by)21( Mich)9(ael C)7(r)-1(on)9(in)9( an)9(d B)-5(e)1(rn)9(adette J)-6(e)1(w)26( at 3.5.)]TJ
T*
-0.021 Tc
[(H)-22(t)-20(t)-20(p)-27(:)-20(/)-20(/)-20(www.)-24(r)-25(mmb)-27(.)-24(c)-23(o)-27(.)-24(n)-15(z)-23(/)-20(c)-23(yb)-27(e)-23(r)-25(g)-15(o)-27(v)-15(h)-15(t)-20(m)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 124.71 Tm
0 Tc
(207)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 120.15 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(1lWMXULGLN\003\261\003/DJ\003RFK\003UlWW\003Sn\003,QWHUQHW)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
14.8072 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, by)22( T)-12(h)10(om)23(as)7( C)8(a)2(rl)5(\351n)10(-)12(W)-4(en)10(del)5(s)7(, pag)10(e)]TJ
-16.0361 -1.1807 TD
0.006 Tc
(34.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 101.19 Tm
0 Tc
(208)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 96.63 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(0DULW]\003,QF\021\003Y\021\003&\\EHUJROG)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.9036 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[( 947 F)7(.)2( S)7(u)11(pp.1328 \(E.D. Mo.1996\).)]TJ
-11.1325 -1.1807 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(Ht)5(t)5(p)-2(:)5(/)5(/)5(zeu)10(s)7(.)1(bn)10(a.com)23(/)5(e-)12(l)5(a)2(w)27(/)5(cas)7(es)7(/)5(c)2(y)22(b_g)10(ol)5(d.h)10(t)5(m)23(l)5( \(970925\))]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 77.67 Tm
0 Tc
(209)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 73.11 Tm
0.004 Tc
[( 15 U.S)6(.)1(C)8(.)1( S)6(ect)5(i)5(o)-2(n)10( 1125\(a\).)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
433 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
435 0 obj
<<
/Length 5326
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(66)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 743.31 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\034\021\030\021\024)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
[(0)24(LQLPXP\003FRQWDFWV)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 714.87 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(The Court had to decide whether or not ex)-11(ercise of personal jurisdiction)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(over Cy)29(berGold would violate due process. Due process requires that there)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
(are \223minimum contacts\224 between the nonresident defendant and the forum)Tj
T*
[(state before a court can ex)-11(ercise personal jurisdiction over the defendant.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 462.93 677.91 Tm
0.007 Tc
(210)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 658.23 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(The)4( c)4(ourt use)4(d)0( the)4( \223)4(f)3(ive)4(-)3(pa)4(rt te)4(st\224)4( for me)4(a)4(s)-1(uring)10( minimum c)4(onta)4(c)4(t)-2(s. F)6(i)-2(rstly)30(,)]TJ
T*
[(the)4( na)4(ture)4( a)4(nd qua)4(lity)30( of the)4( c)4(onta)4(c)4(t)-2(s with the)4( forum sta)4(t)-2(e)4( must be)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(considered. Secondly)29(,)-1( the quantity)29( of those contacts oug)9(ht to be evaluated.)]TJ
T*
[(Thirdly)29(,)-1( the relation of the cause of action to the contacts must be)]TJ
T*
[(determined. F)5(ourthly)29(, the interest of the forum state in providing)9( a forum for)]TJ
T*
[(its residents should be considered and fifthly)29(,)-1( the convenience of the parties)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
(must be taken into account.)Tj
0 -2.36 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(The quest)-4(i)-4(on was, whet)-4(her m)-4(a)2(i)-4(n)-2(t)-4(a)2(i)-4(n)-2(i)-4(n)-2(g)8( a websi)-4(t)-4(e)2( accessi)-4(bl)-4(e t)-4(o)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e whol)-4(e)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(world, including)10( Missouri, was enoug)10(h to ex)-10(ercise personal jurisdiction. The)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(court ex)-11(pressed doubts as to whether old rules concerning)9( jurisdiction could)]TJ
T*
[(be used in novel I)22(n)-1(ternet related cases. The court stated that analog)9(ies to)]TJ
T*
[(ordinary)29( mail and ordinary)29( telephone calls could not be made due to the fact)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e I)21(n)-2(t)-4(e)2(rnet)-4( i)-4(s)-3( m)-4(u)-2(ch fast)-4(er and m)-4(o)-2(re effect)-4(i)-4(v)-2(e. The C)-5(y)28(berGol)-4(d websi)-4(t)-4(e)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(was accessed approx)-10(imately)30( 130 times by)30( users situated in Missouri. Ex)-10(cept)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(for the site, Cy)29(berGold claimed to have no other contacts with the state of)]TJ
T*
[(Mi)-3(ssouri)-3(.)-1( The si)-3(t)-3(e)3( was passi)-3(ve, accordi)-3(n)-1(g)9( t)-3(o)-1( C)-4(y)29(berGol)-3(d.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 409.35 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\034\021\030\021\025)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(7KH\003LQWHQW\003RI\003VHWWLQJ\003XS\003D\003VLWH\003FDQ\003GHFLGH\003ZKHWKHU\003LW\003LV)Tj
-2.6154 -1.1795 TD
(FODVVLILHG\003DV\003SDVVLYH\003RU\003DFWLYH)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 364.35 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(The court)-4( st)-4(at)-4(ed t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
9.9 0 TD
0.003 Tc
[(LQ)9(WH)9(Q)9(W)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
2.28 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( of setting)9( up the site was to reach all I)22(n)-1(ternet)]TJ
-12.18 -1.18 TD
[(users, reg)9(a)3(rdless of g)9(e)3(og)9(raphic location, in order to establish a mailing)9( list)]TJ
T*
[(of I)22(n)-1(ternet users. The court used an analog)9(y)29( in order to decide that the site)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(not a)5(c)5(tive)5(.)1( I)24(t)-1( sa)5(id tha)5(t)-1( if a)5( Missouri re)5(side)5(nt ma)5(ils a)5( tra)5(d)1(itiona)5(l le)5(tte)5(r to)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Cy)30(berGold in California requesting)10( information from Cy)30(berGold reg)10(a)4(rding)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(its planned service, Cy)29(berGold would have to take some active measures in)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(orde)4(r to re)4(ply)30(,)0( suc)4(h)0( a)4(s)-1( writing)10( a)4(nd posting)10( a)4( le)4(tte)4(r or e)4(quiva)4(le)4(nt. The)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(we)5(bsite)5(, whic)5(h did not c)5(onta)5(i)-1(n a)5(n)1(y)31( inte)5(ra)5(c)5(tivity)31(, a)5(u)1(toma)5(tic)5(a)5(lly)31( a)5(n)1(d)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(indiscriminately)29( responds to each and every)29( I)22(n)-1(ternet user who accesses its)]TJ
T*
[(website. The court therefore thoug)9(ht that Cy)29(berGold\222s web based contacts)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(we)4(re)4( of suc)4(h)0( a)4( qua)4(lity)30( a)4(nd na)4(ture)4( tha)4(t)-2( the)4(y)30( fa)4(vore)4(d)0( the)4( e)4(x)-10(e)4(r)3(c)4(i)-2(se)4( of pe)4(rsona)4(l)]TJ
T*
[(jurisdiction over Cy)30(berGold. The motion of Maritz)-6( to dismiss for lack of)]TJ
T*
(personal jurisdiction was denied.)Tj
0 -6.15 TD
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 123.75 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 112.95 Tm
(210)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 108.39 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.004 Tw
[( T)-17(h)5(is w)22(a)-3(s o)-7(r)-5(iginally)17( exp)-7(r)-5(essed)-7( in )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
13.4217 0 TD
0 Tc
(:RUOG\020:LGH\0039RONVZDJHQ\003&RUS\021\003Y\021)Tj
-14.3976 -1.1807 TD
(:RRGVRQ)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
3.7349 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(, 444 U.S)7(.)2( \(1980\).)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
436 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
437 0 obj
<<
/Length 6570
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(67)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 741.51 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(\034\021\031\003)-436(3DQDY)20(L)1(VLRQ\003,QWHUQDWLRQDO\017\003/\0213\017\003Y)20(\021)-1(\003'HQQLV)]TJ
0 -1.1805 TD
0 Tc
(7RHSSHQ)Tj
/F5 1 Tf
10.56 0 0 10.56 179.85 730.23 Tm
0.001 Tc
(211)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 691.83 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(This case dealt with the assig)9(n)-1(ment of I)22(n)-1(ternet domain names, which are the)]TJ
T*
[(equivalent of I)22(n)-1(ternet Protocol \(I)22(P\) addresses used to identify)29( the operator or)]TJ
T*
[(owner of websites. Dennis Toeppen, an individual from I)22(llinois, reg)9(i)-3(stered)]TJ
T*
[(numerous domain names at Network Solutions, I)22(n)-1(c. which were already)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(federal)-4(l)-4(y)28( reg)8(i)-4(st)-4(ered t)-4(r)1(adem)-4(arks. He was a so-cal)-4(l)-4(e)2(d \224spoi)-4(l)-4(e)2(r\224 or)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(cy)29(bersquatter preventing)9( others from conducting)9( business on the web under)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(r)1(adem)-4(arked nam)-4(e)2(s, i)-4(f)1( not)-4( pay)28(i)-4(ng)8( a \223ransom)-4(-fee\224. The di)-4(sput)-4(e arose when)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Panavision, a company)30( conducting)10( business mostly)30( in L)21(o)0(s Ang)10(e)4(les)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(California, wanted to use its company)29( name as a domain name for a website)]TJ
T*
(and discovered that it was not possible due to the fact that Toeppen already)Tj
T*
[(reg)9(i)-3(stered it. Since Panavision could not use the two federally)29( reg)9(i)-3(stered)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(r)1(adem)-4(arks \224P)-6(anavi)-4(s)-3(i)-4(on\224 and \224P)-6(anafl)-4(e)2(x)-12(\224)2(, i)-4(t)-4( cont)-4(act)-4(ed Toeppen and asked)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(him if they)29( could use the domain names \224Panavision.com\224 and)]TJ
T*
[(\224Pananflex)-11(.com\224. Toeppen replied that he would only)29( g)9(i)-3(ve up the domain)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(names if Panavision paid him $13,000. Panavision refused to pay)30( and filed a)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(trademark infring)9(ement ag)9(ainst Toeppen in May)29( 1996. Toeppen responded)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(by)30( filing)10( a)4( motion to dismiss the)4( c)4(a)4(s)-1(e)4( for la)4(c)4(k)0( of pe)4(rsona)4(l jurisdic)4(tion.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 442.95 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\034\021\031\021\024)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
(7KH\003WKUHH\020SDUW\003WHVW\003FRQFHUQLQJ\003VSHFLILF\003MXULVGLFWLRQ)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 414.51 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(The court conducted the three-part test for specific jurisdiction.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 416.49 420.03 Tm
0.007 Tc
(212)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 428.73 414.51 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( F)6(i)-2(rst, the)]TJ
-26.27 -1.18 TD
[(nonresident must perform some activity)30( by)30( which he purposefully)30( avails)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(himself of the privileg)9(e)3( of conducting)9( activities in the forum, thereby)]TJ
T*
[(invoking)9( the benefits and protections of its laws. He would then be aware)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
(that he could be sued in this forum.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 282.69 363.39 Tm
0.007 Tc
(213)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 294.93 357.87 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( I)24(f)4( it is a)5( tort, jurisdic)5(tion c)5(a)5(n)1( be)]TJ
-15.12 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(found if harmful actions are intentional, ex)-11(pressly)29( aimed at the forum state,)]TJ
T*
[(and that the defendant is aware that the harm is likely)29( to be suffered there.)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Secondly)30(,)0( the claim must be one, which arises out of or results from the)]TJ
T*
[(de)4(fe)4(nda)4(nt')10(s)-1( forum-re)4(la)4(te)4(d a)4(c)4(tivitie)4(s. Thirdly)30(,)0( the)4( e)4(x)-10(e)4(r)3(c)4(i)-2(se)4( of jurisdic)4(tion)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(must be reasonable.)Tj
0 -2.36 TD
(The court found Toeppen subject to personal jurisdiction under the \224effects)Tj
0 -1.18 TD
(doctrine\224 mentioned above in the three-part test. Toeppen was found to have)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
(aimed his out of state conduct at California. Panavision was harmed by)Tj
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(Toeppen\222s conduct and since California is the place of business for)Tj
T*
(Panavision, Toeppen must have known that the harmful effects would result)Tj
0 -1.89 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 182.55 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 171.75 Tm
(211)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 167.19 Tm
0.003 Tc
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.506 0 TD
0 Tc
(3DQDYLVLRQ\003,QWHUQDWLRQDO\017\003/\0213\021\003Y\021\0037RHSSHQ)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
16.9518 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(, 945 F)7(.)2(S)7(u)11(pp. 1296 \(C)9(.D. C)9(a)3(l)6(.)]TJ
-18.4337 -1.1807 TD
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
(Sept. 19, 1996\). Http://)Tj
9.2892 0 TD
-0.021 Tc
[(www.)-24(j)-32(m)-2(l)-20(s)-18(.)-24(e)-23(d)-27(u)-15(/)-20(c)-23(yb)-27(e)-23(r)-25(/)-20(c)-23(a)-23(s)-18(e)-23(s)-18(/)-20(p)-27(a)-23(n)-15(a)-23(v)-15(i)-20(s)-18(.)-24(h)-15(t)-20(m)-2(l)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 148.23 Tm
0 Tc
(212)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 143.67 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.004 Tw
[( General j)-12(u)5(risd)-7(ictio)-7(n is the case w)22(h)5(en the d)-7(e)-3(f)7(e)-3(nd)-7(ant is d)-7(o)-7(m)18(iciled)-7( in the)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
[(f)7(o)-7(rum)18( state o)-7(r)-5( its activities there are sub)-7(s)2(tantial o)-7(r)-5( co)-7(ntinuo)-7(us and)-7( sy)17(stem)18(atic.)]TJ
T*
[(General j)-12(u)5(risd)-7(ictio)-7(n o)-7(v)5(er T)-17(o)-7(ep)-7(p)-7(e)-3(n w)22(a)-3(s no)-7(t p)-7(o)-7(ssib)-7(l)0(e. Sp)-7(ecif)7(i)0(c j)-12(u)5(risd)-7(ictio)-7(n is)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
[(w)22(h)5(en the d)-7(e)-3(f)7(e)-3(nd)-7(ant\222)7(s activities in the f)7(o)-7(rum)18( are suf)7(f)7(i)0(cient to)-7( estab)-7(lish)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0.003 Tw
[(j)-11(u)6(risd)-6(ictio)-6(n f)8(o)-6(r the p)-6(u)6(rp)-6(o)-6(s)3(es o)-6(f)8( the litigatio)-6(n. T)-16(h)6(ere is no)-6( need)-6( to)-6( b)-6(e)]TJ
T*
[(p)-6(h)6(y)18(s)3(ically)18( p)-6(r)-4(esent in the f)8(o)-6(rum)19( state in o)-6(r)-4(d)-6(e)-2(r to)-6( ap)-6(p)-6(l)1(y)18( sp)-6(ecif)8(i)1(c j)-11(u)6(risd)-6(ictio)-6(n.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 77.67 Tm
(213)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 73.11 Tm
[( T)-16(h)6(is is f)8(r)-4(o)-6(m)19( )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
5.3855 0 TD
(:RUOG\020:LGH\0039RONVYDJHQ\003&RUS\021\003Y\021\003:RRGVRQ)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
17.2771 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(, 444 U.S)7(.)2( \(1980\).)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
438 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F5 276 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
439 0 obj
<<
/Length 6586
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(68)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(there. The court specially)29( pointed out that Toeppen did not in any)29( way)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(conduct business in California via the I)22(n)-1(ternet, but simply)29( running)9( a scam)]TJ
T*
(directed at this jurisdiction. This fact, makes cases such as )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
23.52 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(%HQV)-10(XV)-10(DQ)]TJ
-23.52 -1.18 TD
[(5HV)-9(W)-8(DXU)-9(DQW)-8(\003&)-12(RU)-9(S\021\003Y\021\003.)-12(L)-8(Q)1(J)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
10.09 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(, and )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
2.19 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(&)-12(R)1(PSX6HU)-9(YH\003Y\021\0033DW)-8(W)-8(H)1(U)-9(V)-9(R)1(Q)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
10.18 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( not analog)10(ous to)]TJ
-22.46 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(this case. I)22( believe that this case would not be treated much different by)29( a)]TJ
T*
(Swedish court. As described above, Swedish law can be applied if the crime)Tj
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(is c)5(o)1(mmitte)5(d towa)5(rds Swe)5(d)1(ish inte)5(re)5(sts, i.e)5(.)1( the)5( vic)5(tim is Swe)5(d)1(ish.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 636.75 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(\034\021\032\003)-436(6WDWH\003RI\0030LQQHVRWD\003Y)20(\021\003*UDQLWH\003*DWH\0035HVRUWV)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
(,QF\021)Tj
10.56 0 0 10.56 140.97 625.47 Tm
0.002 Tc
[(\003)9(\025\024\027)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 587.07 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(I)22(n)-1( Minnesota, the Attorney)29( General has taken the very)29( ag)9(g)9(r)2(essive position,)]TJ
T*
[(that any)29(one conducting)9( business on the net any)29(w)1(here in the world is subject)]TJ
T*
[(t)-3(o)-1( j)-3(u)-1(ri)-3(sdi)-3(c)3(t)-3(i)-3(on i)-3(n)-1( Mi)-3(nnesot)-3(a)3( i)-3(f)2( t)-3(h)-1(e i)-3(n)-1(form)-3(at)-3(i)-3(on can be accessed and read by)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
(the residents of Minnesota. Consumer protection statutes protect those who)Tj
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(are subject to advertisements in Minnesota and this is one reason why)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Minnesota strives to make foreig)10(n web editors subject to Minnesota)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
[(jurisdic)5(tion.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 171.21 507.63 Tm
0.007 Tc
(215)Tj
12 0 0 12 183.45 502.11 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[( I)21(n)-2( a st)-4(at)-4(em)-4(ent)-4( from)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e Mi)-4(nnesot)-4(a)2( At)-4(t)-4(o)-2(rney)28( General)-4( one can)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
-5.83 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(read the following)9(: \224W)-7(arning)9( to all I)22(n)-1(ternet users and providers ... Persons)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(outside of Minnesota who transmit information via the I)23(n)0(ternet knowing)10( that)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(informa)5(tion will be)5( disse)5(mina)5(t)-1(e)5(d)1( in Minne)5(sota)5( a)5(r)4(e)5( subje)5(c)5(t)-1( to jurisdic)5(tion in)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Minne)4(sota)4( c)4(ourts for viola)4(tions of sta)4(t)-2(e)4( c)4(r)3(imina)4(l)-2( a)4(nd c)4(i)-2(vil la)4(ws\224)4(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 422.49 450.99 Tm
0.007 Tc
(216)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 423.15 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\034\021\032\021\024)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(/DV\0039HJDV\003,)-8(QWHUQHW\003DGYHUWLVHPHQW\003YLRODWHG\0030)23(LQQHVRWD)]TJ
-2.6154 -1.1795 TD
0 Tc
(FRQVXPHU\003SURWHFWLRQ)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 378.15 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(I)21(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e U.S)-6(.)-2( case )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
6.52 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(6W)-8(DW)-8(H\003RI)-8(\0030L)-8(QQHV)-9(RW)-8(D\003Y\021\003*U)-9(DQL)-8(W)-8(H)1(\003*DW)-8(H)1(\0035HV)-9(RU)-9(W)-8(V)-9(\003,QF)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
18.76 0 TD
-0.002 Tc
[(., a L)19(a)2(s)]TJ
-25.28 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Veg)9(a)3(s on line bookmaking)9( company)29( was not allowed to advertise such)]TJ
T*
(services in Minnesota. The state of Minnesota)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 334.17 355.35 Tm
0.007 Tc
(217)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 346.41 349.83 Tm
-0.001 Tc
( filed a consumer fraud)Tj
-19.41 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(c)4(o)0(mpla)4(int a)4(g)10(a)4(i)-2(nst Gra)4(n)0(ite)4( Ga)4(te)4( Re)4(sorts, I)23(n)0(c)4(.)0( a)4(nd Ke)4(rry)30( Rog)10(e)4(rs, the)4( pre)4(s)-1(ide)4(n)0(t)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(and principal officer of Granite Gate Resorts, I)22(n)-1(c. who thereafter filed a)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(motion to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction. I)23(n)0( Minnesota,)]TJ
T*
[(commercial sports betting)10( and sports bookmaking)10( is considered illeg)10(a)4(l and)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(the Attorney)29( General declared that by)29( advertising)9( in Minnesota, and by)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(e)5(x)-9(plic)5(itly)31( a)5(nd implic)5(itly)31( pre)5(s)0(e)5(n)1(ting)11( tha)5(t)-1( it is la)5(wful, the)5( c)5(o)1(mpa)5(n)1(y)31( ha)5(d)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(violated Minnesota')10(s)-1( consumer protection.)]TJ
0 -4.74 TD
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 196.95 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 141.81 185.19 Tm
0.007 Tc
(214)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 154.05 179.67 Tm
0 Tc
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.25 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(6W)-8(DW)-8(H\003RI)-8(\0030L)-8(QQHV)-9(RW)-8(D\003Y\021\003*U)-9(DQL)-8(W)-8(H)1(\003*DW)-8(H)1(\0035HV)-9(RU)-9(W)-8(V)-9(\003,QF)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
18.76 0 TD
0 Tc
[(. 1996 W)-6(L)]TJ
-20.03 -1.18 TD
(767431 \(Minn. Dist. Ct., 2d Dist, Dec. 11, 1996\))Tj
T*
[(Http://www.ag)10(.state.mn.us/consumer/news/OnlineScams/g)10(g)10(R)-3(es)]TJ
T*
[(pB)7(rief.html \(970920\))]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 129.51 Tm
(215)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 124.95 Tm
0.003 Tc
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.506 0 TD
0 Tc
(-XULVGLFWLRQ\0032YHU\003&RPPHUFH\0032Q\003WKH\003,QWHUQHW)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
18.0361 0 TD
-0.018 Tc
0.021 Tw
[( b)-24(y)0( B)-26(r)-22(a)-20(d)-24(l)-17(e)-20(y A)-7(.)-21( S)-16(l)-17(u)-12(t)-17(s)-15(k)-12(y,)]TJ
-19.5181 -1.1807 TD
-0.021 Tc
0.024 Tw
[(H)-22(t)-20(t)-20(p)-27(:)-20(/)-20(/)-20(www.)-24(k)-15(s)-18(l)-20(a)-23(w.)-24(c)-23(o)-27(m/)-20(me)-23(n)-15(u)-15(/)-20(j)-32(u)-15(r)-25(i)-20(s)-18(d)-27(i)-20(c)-23(.)-24(h)-15(t)-20(m)-2(,)-24( p)-27(a)-23(g)-15(e)-23( 5)-27(-)-13(6)-27(.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 141.81 105.03 Tm
0.007 Tc
(216)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 154.05 99.51 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( Statement of Minnesota Attorney)29( General on I)22(n)-1(ternet)]TJ
-1.02 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(J)-11(u)0(risdiction. Http://jmls.edu./cy)30(ber/docs/minn-ag)10(.html)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 77.67 Tm
(217)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 73.11 Tm
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( Via its)5( A)13(ttorn)8(ey)20( Gen)8(e)0(ral Hu)8(bert H. Hu)8(m)21(p)-4(h)8(r)-2(ey)20( III.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
440 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
441 0 obj
<<
/Length 5375
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(69)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 743.31 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\034\021\032\021\025)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
($\003GLVFODLPHU\003RQ\003WKH\003ZHEVLWH\003QRW\003HQRXJK\003WR\003DYRLG)Tj
-2.6154 -1.1795 TD
0 Tc
[(0)24(LQQHVRWD\003MXULVGLFWLRQ)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 698.31 Tm
[(An injunction was soug)10(ht, preventing)10( the company)30( from continuing)10( to)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(a)5(dve)5(rtise)5( the)5( ille)5(g)11(a)5(l g)11(a)5(mbling)11( se)5(rvic)5(e)5(s)0( to Minne)5(sota)5( re)5(side)5(nts. The)5( c)5(o)1(mpa)5(n)1(y)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(arg)8(u)-2(ed t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( t)-4(h)-2(ey)28( had sol)-4(e)2(l)-4(y)28( pl)-4(aced "i)-4(nform)-4(a)2(t)-4(i)-4(on" concerni)-4(ng)8( t)-4(h)-2(e g)8(a)2(m)-4(b)-2(l)-4(i)-4(n)-2(g)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(se)4(rvic)4(e)4( a)4(nd how to be)4( pa)4(rt of a)4( ma)4(iling)10( list, on the)4( I)23(n)0(te)4(rne)4(t)-2(. The)4( c)4(o)0(mpa)4(n)0(y)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(claimed they)29( had no contacts whatsoever with Minnesota. The web site even)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(cont)-4(ai)-4(ned a di)-4(scl)-4(a)2(i)-4(m)-4(e)2(r i)-4(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e form)-4( of a warni)-4(n)-2(g)8( speci)-4(fy)28(i)-4(n)-2(g)8( t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( vi)-4(ewers)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(should contact the local authorities to make sure it was leg)10(a)4(l to participate in)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(any)29( of the offered off-shore sports betting)9( via telephone. This, however,)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(prove)4(d to be)4( a)4(n)0( ine)4(ffe)4(c)4(tive)4( wa)4(y)30( of re)4(stric)4(ting)10( lia)4(bility)30( in Minne)4(sota)4(, sinc)4(e)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(h)-2(e court)-4( di)-4(d not)-4( at)-4( al)-4(l)-4( appreci)-4(at)-4(e such an arrang)8(em)-4(ent)-4(.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 548.55 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\034\021\032\021\026)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
[(,)-7(QWHUQHW\003DGYHUWLVHPHQWV\003PRUH\003SHUYDVLYH\003WKDQ)]TJ
-2.6154 -1.1795 TD
(WUDGLWLRQDO\003DGYHUWLVHPHQWV)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 503.55 Tm
[(The)4( I)23(n)0(te)4(rne)4(t)-2( a)4(dve)4(rtise)4(m)-2(e)4(n)0(t a)4(l)-2(so liste)4(d a)4( toll-fre)4(e)4( numbe)4(r to c)4(a)4(ll for more)]TJ
T*
(information about the activities and it was possible to confirm that people)Tj
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(from Minnesota had called the number. The court also stated that the)Tj
T*
[(I)22(n)-1(ternet advertising)9( is available to Minnesota consumers \(and to any)29( other)]TJ
T*
[(I)22(n)-1(ternet user as well\) 24 hours a day)29(,)-1( seven day)29(s)-2( a week, 365 day)29(s)-2( a y)29(ear,)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(until ta)4(ke)4(n off the)4( site)4(. I)23(t)-2( wa)4(s a)4(l)-2(so sa)4(id, tha)4(t)-2( for pe)4(rsona)4(l jurisdic)4(tion)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(purposes, I)22(n)-1(ternet advertising)9( has the same effect as television, newspaper)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(a)4(nd y)30(e)4(llow pa)4(g)10(e)4(s a)4(dve)4(rtising)10(.)0( I)23(n)0(te)4(rne)4(t)-2( a)4(dve)4(rtising)10( ma)4(y)30( e)4(v)0(e)4(n)0( be)4( more)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(pervasive than other forms of advertising)9( due to the fact that advertisements)]TJ
T*
[(over the I)22(n)-1(ternet are available to I)22(n)-1(ternet users continually)29( and constantly)29(.)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(The)5( c)5(ourt sta)5(t)-1(e)5(d)1(: \224)5(I)24(f na)5(tiona)5(l or inte)5(rna)5(tiona)5(l c)5(o)1(mpa)5(n)1(ie)5(s a)5(r)4(e)5( a)5(b)1(le)5( to se)5(e)5(k)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(business in Minnesota, obtain money)30( from Minnesota consumers, claim the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(protection of the Minnesota courts, but escape personal jurisdiction,)Tj
T*
[(Minnesota consumers are essentially)29( without redress if they)29( are injured by)]TJ
T*
[(an I)22(n)-1(ternet advertiser--despite the fact that the consumers could have sued if)]TJ
T*
[(the same advertisement had appeared in a national mag)9(a)3(z)-7(i)-3(ne or)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
(newspaper.\224)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 172.89 268.35 Tm
0.007 Tc
(218)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 234.51 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(The court held that the company)29( should not be able to seek profit from the)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Minnesota market, y)30(e)4(t claim it is bey)30(ond the jurisdiction of the Minnesota)]TJ
T*
[(c)4(ourts. Sinc)4(e)4( the)4( a)4(dve)4(rtise)4(m)-2(e)4(n)0(ts we)4(re)4( ma)4(id in Minne)4(sota)4( via)4( the)4( I)23(n)0(te)4(rne)4(t)-2(,)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(the court stated it would not be unreasonable to ask that they)29( bear the)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(responsibilities that come with such advertising)10(.)]TJ
0 -5.15 TD
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 119.19 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 141.81 107.43 Tm
0.007 Tc
(218)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 154.05 101.91 Tm
0 Tc
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.25 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(6W)-8(DW)-8(H\003RI)-8(\0030L)-8(QQHV)-9(RW)-8(D\003Y\021\003*U)-9(DQL)-8(W)-8(H)1(\003*DW)-8(H)1(\0035HV)-9(RU)-9(W)-8(V)-9(\003,QF)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
18.76 0 TD
0 Tc
[(. Pag)10(e)4( 25.)]TJ
-20.03 -1.18 TD
[(Http://www.ag)10(.state.mn.us/consumer/news/OnlineScams/g)10(g)10(R)-3(es)]TJ
T*
[(pB)7(rief.html)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
442 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
443 0 obj
<<
/Length 5802
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(70)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(The court)-4( t)-4(h)-2(erefore succum)-4(b)-2(ed t)-4(o)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e opi)-4(ni)-4(on t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e com)-4(p)-2(any)28( had)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(suffic)5(i)-1(e)5(n)1(t minimum c)5(onta)5(c)5(t)-1(s with Minne)5(sota)5( to a)5(llow the)5( e)5(x)-9(e)5(r)4(c)5(i)-1(se)5( of)]TJ
T*
[(jurisdic)5(tion.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(I)23(t)-2( seems like Minnesota is one of the states in the U.S. which most)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(ag)10(g)10(r)3(essively)30( pursue what it considers to be on-line violations of Minnesota)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(la)5(w, by)31( filing)11( va)5(rious la)5(wsuits a)5(g)11(a)5(i)-1(nst out-of-sta)5(te)5( a)5(dve)5(rtise)5(r)4(s a)5(nd I)24(SPs.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 455.97 666.03 Tm
0.007 Tc
(219)Tj
12 0 0 12 113.49 646.35 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Such reasoning)9( could function as a deterrent for an ex)-11(pansion and)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(development of Cy)30(berspace. I)23(f)3( all countries and states would file suits)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(ag)9(ainst foreig)9(n web-editors whenever any)29( material found in Cy)29(berspace)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(does not comply)30( with national law, it would be ex)-10(tremely)30( confusing)10( for all)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(parties involved. I)22(f)2( a country)29( does not allow advertisements containing)]TJ
T*
[(certain elements, while such elements can be found on the I)22(n)-1(ternet, I)22( see no)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(re)5(a)5(s)0(on to file)5( a)5(n)1(y)31( suit, unle)5(ss the)5( on-line)5( a)5(dve)5(rtise)5(m)-1(e)5(n)1(t spe)5(c)5(i)-1(fic)5(a)5(lly)31( is)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(targ)9(eted at this country)29(. I)22(n)-1( the Minnesota case, it was actually)29( proven that)]TJ
T*
[(Minnesota residents had called the toll-free telephone number, but I)22( am not)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(com)-4(p)-2(l)-4(e)2(t)-4(e)2(l)-4(y)28( cert)-4(a)2(i)-4(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( one coul)-4(d say)28( t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e com)-4(p)-2(any)28( speci)-4(fi)-4(cal)-4(l)-4(y)28( di)-4(rect)-4(ed)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
[(i)-4(t)-4(s)-3(\222 websi)-4(t)-4(e)2( t)-4(o)-2(wards Mi)-4(nnesot)-4(a)2( si)-4(m)-4(p)-2(l)-4(y)28( because a t)-4(o)-2(l)-4(l)-4(-free num)-4(ber was)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(posted. Any)29(one can call a telephone number, even those who live in a)]TJ
T*
[(jurisdiction covered by)29( the disclaimer posted on the site.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 452.67 Tm
0 Tc
[(\034\021\033\003)-435(+HURHV\017\003,QF\021\003Y)21(\021\003+HURHV\003\)RXQGDWLRQ)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
10.56 0 0 10.56 404.61 460.23 Tm
0.001 Tc
(220)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 421.83 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(This case does not really)29( present any)29( new ideas concerning)9( personal)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(jurisdic)5(tion a)5(nd I)24(n)1(te)5(rne)5(t)-1( a)5(c)5(tivitie)5(s. A c)5(h)1(a)5(r)4(ita)5(ble)5( org)11(a)5(niza)5(tion in Columbia)5(,)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Heroes, sued another charitable org)9(a)3(niz)-7(a)3(tion in New York, Heroes)]TJ
T*
[(F)5(oundation, for trademark infring)9(ement. Heroes F)5(oundation wanted the)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(c)4(ourt to dismiss the)4( c)4(o)0(mpla)4(int for la)4(c)4(k)0( of pe)4(rsona)4(l jurisdic)4(tion a)4(nd imprope)4(r)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(venue. The court found that personal jurisdiction was proper. \223Heroes\224,)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(founded in 1964, provides financial assistance to the surviving)10( family)]TJ
T*
[(me)4(mbe)4(r)3(s of Distric)4(t)-2( of Columbia)4( la)4(w e)4(n)0(forc)4(e)4(m)-2(e)4(n)0(t offic)4(e)4(r)3(s a)4(nd fire)4(fig)10(h)0(te)4(rs)]TJ
T*
[(who are killed in the line of duty)30(.)0( I)23(n)0( 1990, another org)10(a)4(nization started using)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(the name \223Heroes F)5(oundation\224 in connection with its charitable activities.)]TJ
T*
[(Heroes sued Heroes F)5(oundation, claiming)9( that the related names may)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
(confuse potential contributors and thus stated that it was a question of)Tj
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(trademark infring)9(ement and unfair competition. I)22(f)2( a person transacts)]TJ
T*
[(business in the District of Columbia, the court may)29( ex)-11(ercise personal)]TJ
T*
[(jurisdiction over this person, as a result of the District')9(s)-2( long)9(-arm statute.)]TJ
0 -7.2 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 140.31 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 141.81 128.55 Tm
0.007 Tc
(219)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 154.05 123.03 Tm
0 Tc
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.25 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(-XU)-10(L)-9(V)-10(GL)-9(FW)-9(L)-9(RQ\003L)-9(Q)0(\003D\003:RU)-10(O)-9(G)0(\003:L)-9(W)-9(KRXW)-9(\003%RU)-10(GHU)-10(V)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
16.16 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(, Dan L)20(.)-1( B)6(u)-1(rk.)]TJ
-17.43 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(Http://zeus.bna.com/e-law/cases/heroes.html \(970925\))Tj
/F3 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 141.81 96.63 Tm
-0.023 Tc
[(H)-24(t)-22(t)-22(p)-29(:)-22(/)-22(/)-22(www.)-26(s)-20(t)-22(u)-17(d)-29(e)-25(n)-17(t)-22(.)-26(v)-17(i)-22(r)-27(g)-17(i)-22(n)-17(i)-22(a)-25(.)-26(e)-25(d)-29(u)-17(/)-22(~)-24(v)-17(j)-34(o)]TJ
15 0 TD
-0.002 Tc
[(lt/vo)-8(l)-1(1)-8(/)-1(B)-10(U)-3(RK.htm)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
0 Tc
(220)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 84.87 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(+HURHV\017\003,QF\021\003Y\021\003+HURHV\003\)RXQGDWLRQ)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
14 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, C)8(i)5(v)10(.)1(96-)12(1260 \(D.C)8(.D.C)8(.. Dec. 19,)]TJ
-15.2289 -1.1807 TD
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[(1996\) Http://zeu)9(s)6(.)0(bn)9(a.com)22(/)4(e-)11(law)26(/)4(cas)6(es)6(/h)9(eroes)6(.)0(h)9(t)4(m)22(l)4( \(970925\))]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
444 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F5 276 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
445 0 obj
<<
/Length 5905
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(71)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 743.31 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\034\021\033\021\024)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
($\003ZHEVLWH\003DQG\003DGYHUWLVHPHQW\003LQ\003D\003QHZVSDSHU\003LV\003HQRXJK)Tj
-2.6154 -1.1795 TD
(WR\003H[HUFLVH\003MXULVGLFWLRQ\003LQ\003&ROXPELD)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 698.31 Tm
0.001 Tw
[(The court had to determine if Heroes F)5(oundation had purposefully)29( availed)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(itself of the privileg)10(e)4( of conducting)10( activities within the District. This was)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(based upon two facts. F)5(i)-3(rstly)29(, a newspaper advertisement published in The)]TJ
T*
[(W)-7(a)3(shi)-3(n)-1(g)9(t)-3(on P)-5(o)-1(st)-3(, and a websi)-3(t)-3(e)3(, accessi)-3(bl)-3(e t)-3(o)-1( resi)-3(dent)-3(s i)-3(n)-1( C)-4(o)-1(l)-3(u)-1(m)-3(b)-1(i)-3(a)3(. Due t)-3(o)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(the)4( fa)4(c)4(t)-2( tha)4(t)-2( the)4( site)4( wa)4(s not the)4( sole)4( c)4(onta)4(c)4(t)-2( with the)4( forum, the)4( c)4(ourt ne)4(ve)4(r)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(had to determine whether the homepag)9(e alone was enoug)9(h for personal)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
[(jurisdic)5(tion.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(The website containing)9( the infring)9(ing)9( trademarks)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(\(Http://www.heroes.org)9(/)-3(heroes\) invited users to donate money)29(.)-1( Heroes)]TJ
T*
[(F)5(oundation claimed that the website was passive and not targ)9(eted at any)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(speci)-4(fi)-4(c forum)-4(,)-2( as i)-4(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
9.87 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(%HQV)-10(XV)-10(DQ)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
3.83 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( case. Any)29(one in the world with I)22(n)-1(ternet)]TJ
-13.7 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(access coul)-4(d vi)-4(si)-4(t)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e si)-4(t)-4(e)2(. The court)-4( st)-4(at)-4(ed t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( any)28(one wi)-4(t)-4(h)-2(i)-4(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e forum)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(could g)9(a)3(in access to the posted material, any)29( time since it was put there.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
[(The court found that the website and the advertisement in The W)-7(a)3(shing)9(t)-3(on)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Post tog)10(e)4(ther showed that Heroes F)6(oundation had purposefully)30( availed itself)]TJ
T*
[(of the privileg)10(e)4( of conducting)10( activities within the District, and could)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(re)5(a)5(s)0(ona)5(bly)31( a)5(n)1(tic)5(ipa)5(t)-1(e)5(d)1( the)5( possibility)31( of be)5(ing)11( ha)5(le)5(d into c)5(ourt the)5(r)4(e)5(.)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Therefore the court stated that jurisdiction over Heroes F)5(oundation was)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
[(proper under the \223transacting)9( any)29( business\224 clause of the District')9(s)-2( long)9(-arm)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
[(st)-4(at)-4(ut)-4(e.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 377.19 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(\034\021\034\003)-436(=LSSR\0030DQXIDFWXULQJ\003&R\021\003Y)20(\021)-1(\003=LSSR\003'RW\003&RP\017)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
(,QF\021)Tj
/F5 1 Tf
10.56 0 0 10.56 140.97 365.91 Tm
0.001 Tc
(221)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 327.51 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(Z)10(i)-3(ppo Manufacturing)9( Corporation, the producer of Z)10(i)-3(ppo fuel lig)9(hters)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(among)10( other thing)10(s)-1(, filed a complaint ag)10(ainst Z)11(i)-2(ppo Dot Com, I)23(n)0(c alleg)10(i)-2(ng)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(trademark dilution, infring)9(ement, and false desig)9(n)-1(ation under the F)5(e)3(deral)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(Tradem)-4(ark Act)-4(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 189.21 290.55 Tm
0.007 Tc
(222)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 201.45 285.03 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( I)22(t)-3( was the usag)9(e of the name \224Z)10(ippo\224 in the domain name)]TJ
-7.33 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(that trig)10(g)10(e)4(red this action. Dot Com demanded the court to dismiss for lack)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(of personal jurisdiction. Dot Com operated an I)22(n)-1(ternet website and an)]TJ
T*
[(I)22(n)-1(ternet news service and had obtained the ex)-11(clusive rig)9(h)-1(t to use the domain)]TJ
T*
[(names \223z)-7(ippo.com\224, \223z)-7(ippo.net\224 and \223z)-7(ipponews.com\224 on the I)22(n)-1(ternet. Dot)]TJ
T*
[(Com\222s contacts with Pennsy)29(l)-3(vania had almost ex)-11(clusively)29( occurred via the)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(I)21(n)-2(t)-4(e)2(rnet)-4(. Dot)-4( C)-5(o)-2(m)-4(\222)1(s offi)-4(ces, em)-4(pl)-4(oy)28(ees and I)21(n)-2(t)-4(e)2(rnet)-4( servers were l)-4(o)-2(cat)-4(ed i)-4(n)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(California and not in Pennsy)29(l)-3(vania. However, residents of Pennsy)29(l)-3(vania)]TJ
T*
[(were able to view the website via the W)-7(o)-1(rld W)-7(i)-3(de W)-7(e)3(b. Dot Com had about)]TJ
T*
[(140,000 pay)29(i)-3(ng)9( subscribers worldwide and only)29( about 3,000 \(two percent\))]TJ
T*
[(of those subscribers were Pennsy)29(l)-3(vanian residents. Therefore one could say)]TJ
0 -1.9 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 123.75 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 112.95 Tm
(221)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 108.39 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(=LSSR\0030DQXIDFWXULQJ\003&R\021\003Y\021\003=LSSR\003'RW\003&RP\017\003,QF\021)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
19.8193 0 TD
0.001 Tc
0.002 Tw
[( Dis)4(t)2(rict C)5(o)-5(u)7(r)-3(t f)9(o)-5(r th)7(e)]TJ
-21.0482 -1.1807 TD
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[(W)-5(e)1(s)6(t)4(ern)9( Dis)6(t)4(rict of)11( P)-7(e)1(n)9(n)9(s)6(y)21(l)4(v)9(a)1(n)9(i)4(a, J)-6(a)1(n)9(u)9(a)1(ry)21( 16, 1997. Http://zeu)9(s)6(.)0(bn)9(a.com)22(/)4(e-)]TJ
T*
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(l)5(a)2(w)27(/)5(cas)7(es)7(/)5(z)2(i)5(ppo.h)10(t)5(m)23(l)5( \(970920\))]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 77.67 Tm
0 Tc
(222)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 73.11 Tm
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[( 15 U.S)7(.)2(C)9(.)2( \247\2471051-)13(1127)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
446 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F5 276 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
447 0 obj
<<
/Length 5882
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(72)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e websi)-4(t)-4(e)2( was especi)-4(al)-4(l)-4(y)28( desi)-4(g)8(n)-2(ed t)-4(o)-2( at)-4(t)-4(r)1(act)-4( vi)-4(ewers i)-4(n)-2( al)-4(l)-4( st)-4(at)-4(es)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(\(including)10( Pennsy)30(l)-2(vania\) and establish continuous relationships with these.)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(Dot)-4( C)-5(o)-2(m)-4( had a cont)-4(ract)-4( wi)-4(t)-4(h)-2( seven I)21(n)-2(t)-4(e)2(rnet)-4( access provi)-4(ders i)-4(n)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Pennsy)29(l)-3(vania that permitted the subscribers to access Dot Com\222s news)]TJ
T*
-0.003 Tc
[(servi)-5(ce.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 666.51 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\034\021\034\021\024)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(7KH\003OHYHO\003RI\003FRPPHUFLDO\003DFWLYLW\\\003DQG\003LQWHUDFWLYLW\\\003RI)Tj
-2.6154 -1.1795 TD
0 Tc
(ZHEVLWHV)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 621.51 Tm
[(I)23(n)0( the Z)11(i)-2(ppo case, it was discussed how the level of activity)30( and interactivity)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(of various websites mig)9(ht have an impact on whether or not jurisdiction can)]TJ
T*
[(be established in remote states. According)9( to the Z)10(i)-3(ppo court, there are three)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(different ty)30(pes of situations that should be taken into consideration. The)]TJ
T*
(court stated that \224...the likelihood that personal jurisdiction can be)Tj
T*
[(constitutionally)30( ex)-10(ercised is directly)30( proportionate to the nature and quality)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(of commercial activity)29( that an entity)29( conducts over the I)22(n)-1(ternet.\224)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 422.61 542.07 Tm
0.007 Tc
(223)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 434.85 536.55 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( I)24(f)4( the)]TJ
-26.78 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(web site owners wish to avoid jurisdiction, the sites should contain as few)Tj
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(inte)5(ra)5(c)5(tive)5( e)5(l)-1(e)5(m)-1(e)5(n)1(ts a)5(s)0( possible)5(,)1( sinc)5(e)5( sole)5(ly)31( the)5( posting)11( of informa)5(tion on a)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(site is not alway)30(s)-1( enoug)10(h to be bound to a jurisdiction. I)23(t)-2( may)30( be better to)]TJ
T*
(use the site to inform potential customers of traditional telephone numbers)Tj
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(or addresses.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 175.29 471.27 Tm
0.007 Tc
(224)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 187.53 465.75 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( Such a behavior, may)30( still not be enoug)10(h to avoid)]TJ
-6.17 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
[(jurisdic)5(tion.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 429.27 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\034\021\034\021\025)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
(\(QWHULQJ\003LQWR\003FRQWUDFW\003DQG\003WUDQVPLWWLQJ\003FRPSXWHU\003ILOHV)Tj
-2.6154 -1.1795 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(YLD\003WKH\003,)-8(QWHUQHW)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 384.27 Tm
0.001 Tw
[(The first situation is when contracts are entered with residents of foreig)9(n)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
(jurisdictions, and that the parties understand that this is the case. The)Tj
T*
(situation should also consist of repeated transmissions of computer files)Tj
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(over the I)22(n)-1(ternet, in order to establish personal jurisdiction. An ex)-11(ample of)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(suc)5(h)1( a)5( situa)5(tion is )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
7.39 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(&)-12(R)1(PSX6HU)-9(YH\003Y\021\0033DW)-8(W)-8(H)1(U)-9(V)-9(R)1(Q)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
10.18 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(.)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 305.31 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\034\021\034\021\026)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
[(3)7(DVVLYH\003ZHEVLWHV)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 276.87 Tm
(The second situation is when the website is passive)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
20.48 0 TD
(\017)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
0.25 0 TD
[( and basically)30( only)]TJ
-20.73 -1.18 TD
[(displa)4(y)30(s)-1( informa)4(tion to a)4(n)0(y)30(one)4( inte)4(re)4(ste)4(d, no ma)4(tte)4(r in whic)4(h jurisdic)4(tion)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(the users are located. This is not alway)29(s)-2( enoug)9(h to g)9(i)-3(ve rise to personal)]TJ
T*
(jurisdiction, since there is no intent to make immediate contact with viewers)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(in any)30( specific jurisdiction. )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
11.1 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(%HQV)-9(XV)-9(DQ\0035HV)-9(W)-8(DXU)-9(DQW)-8(\003&)-12(RU)-9(S\021\003Y\021\003.)-12(L)-8(Q)1(J)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
14.17 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
( would be an)Tj
-25.27 -1.18 TD
[(ex)-11(ample of such a passive site which was not enoug)9(h to establish)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(jurisdiction. However, one should bear in mind that the situation is likely)30( to)]TJ
0 -4.96 TD
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 135.51 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 124.71 Tm
(223)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 120.15 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(=LSSR\0030DQXIDFWXULQJ\003&R\021\003Y\021\003=LSSR\003'RW\003&RP\017\003,QF)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
19.5663 0 TD
0.003 Tc
[(. at III A)14( 2.)]TJ
-20.7952 -1.1807 TD
[(Ht)4(t)4(p)-3(:)4(/)4(/)4(zeu)9(s)6(.)0(bn)9(a.com)22(/)4(e-)11(l)4(a)1(w)26(/)4(cas)6(es)6(/)4(z)1(i)4(ppo.h)9(t)4(m)22(l)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 101.19 Tm
0 Tc
(224)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 96.63 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(,QWHUQHW\003/DZ)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
5.1566 0 TD
0.003 Tw
[( b)-6(y)18( Michael J)-9(.)-3( W)-8(a)-2(gner and)-6( Matthew)23( G. A)11(lliso)-6(n)6( in T)-16(h)6(e)]TJ
-6.3855 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(Nat)6(i)6(o)-1(n)11(a)3(l)6( L)14(a)3(w)28( Jou)11(r)1(n)11(a)3(l)6(,)2( Ju)11(l)6(y)23( 7, 1997. Ht)6(t)6(p)-1(:)6(/)6(/)]TJ
T*
0.004 Tc
[(l)5(j)-7(ex)10(t)5(r)0(a.com)23(/)5(In)10(t)5(e)2(rn)10(et)5(/)5(o7o7ju)10(r)0(i)5(s)7(.h)10(t)5(m)23(.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
448 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
449 0 obj
<<
/Length 6821
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(73)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(chang)9(e)3(, once a certain number of sales occur, or contractual relationships are)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(e)5(s)0(ta)5(blishe)5(d in one)5( spe)5(c)5(i)-1(fic)5( jurisdic)5(tion.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 300.33 736.83 Tm
0.007 Tc
(225)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 708.99 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\034\021\034\021\027)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
[(,)-7(QWHUDFWLYLW\\)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 680.55 Tm
(The third situation involves interactive websites, such as in)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
23.62 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(\0030DU)-9(L)-8(W)-8(])-9(\003,QF\021\003Y\021)]TJ
-23.62 -1.18 TD
[(&)-13(\\EHU)-10(JRO)-9(G\003,QF)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
5.74 0 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(. \224I)21(n t)-4(h)-2(ese cases, t)-4(h)-2(e ex)-12(erci)-4(se of j)-4(u)-2(ri)-4(sdi)-4(c)2(t)-4(i)-4(on i)-4(s)-3( det)-4(e)2(rm)-4(i)-4(n)-2(ed by)]TJ
-5.74 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(e)5(x)-9(a)5(mining)11( the)5( le)5(ve)5(l of inte)5(ra)5(c)5(tivity)31( a)5(nd c)5(o)1(mme)5(rc)5(ia)5(l na)5(ture)5( of the)5( e)5(x)-9(c)5(h)1(a)5(n)1(g)11(e)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(of information that occurs on the W)-6(e)4(b site.\224)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 324.57 643.59 Tm
0.007 Tc
(226)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 615.75 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\034\021\034\021\030)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(7KH\003'RW\003&RP\003ZHEVLWH\003ZDV\003PRUH\003WKDQ\003LQWHUDFWLYH)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 587.31 Tm
0.001 Tw
(The Dot Com website was not considered to be a passive site. The court)Tj
0 -1.18 TD
(found that the site was more than interactive, and that it involved more than)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(advertising)10( on the I)23(n)0(ternet in Pennsy)30(l)-2(vania. I)23(t)-2( was said that if Dot Com did)]TJ
T*
[(not wish to be subject to Pennsy)30(l)-2(vania jurisdiction, Dot Com should never)]TJ
T*
[(have chosen to vend its services to the residents of Pennsy)30(l)-2(vania. Dot Com)]TJ
T*
[(arg)10(u)0(ed that the activities were not sig)10(n)0(ificant enoug)10(h to establish a)]TJ
T*
[(substantial connection with Pennsy)30(l)-2(vania, but this was rejected by)30( the court,)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(si)-4(nce t)-4(h)-2(e S)-6(uprem)-4(e C)-5(ourt)-4( once st)-4(at)-4(ed t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( even a si)-4(ng)8(l)-4(e)2( cont)-4(act)-4( can be)]TJ
T*
[(suffi)-4(ci)-4(ent)-4(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 161.73 479.55 Tm
0.007 Tc
(227)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 173.97 474.03 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( The court found it appropriate to ex)-11(ercise personal jurisdiction)]TJ
-5.04 -1.18 TD
[(in the Z)10(i)-3(ppo case.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 437.55 Tm
-0.004 Tc
(\034\021\034\021\031)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.0085 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
($QDORJ\\\003EHWZHHQ\003SDVVLYH\003ZHEVLWHV\003DQG\003SDSHUEDFN)Tj
-2.6154 -1.1795 TD
0 Tc
(DGYHUWLVHPHQWV)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 392.55 Tm
[(I)23(t)-2( still seems dubious how courts would consider a non-interactive site that)]TJ
T*
[(solely)30( functions as an advertisement, striving)10( to invite customers in all)]TJ
T*
[(various jurisdictions. I)23(f)3( it is clear that such a site is equivalent of a)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(traditional advertisement, there may)29( not be any)29( proper jurisdiction due to the)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(fa)4(c)4(t)-2( tha)4(t)-2( tra)4(d)0(itiona)4(lly)30( a)4(dve)4(rtising)10( a)4(l)-2(one)4( is not suffic)4(i)-2(e)4(n)0(t pre)4(s)-1(e)4(n)0(c)4(e)4( within a)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(forum to support jurisdiction. I)22(t)-3( may)29( be arg)9(u)-1(ed that such an analog)9(y)29( between)]TJ
T*
[(sites and ads may)29( not sustain, since \(even passive\) websites may)29( be able to)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(c)4(r)3(e)4(a)4(t)-2(e)4( g)10(r)3(e)4(a)4(t)-2(e)4(r)3( c)4(onta)4(c)4(t)-2( tha)4(n)0( a)4(n)0(y)30( ha)4(rd-c)4(opy)30( a)4(dve)4(rtise)4(m)-2(e)4(n)0(t e)4(v)0(e)4(r)3( will. The)4( )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
28.31 0 TD
-0.007 Tc
[(,QV)-11(H)-1(W)]TJ
-28.31 -1.18 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(6\\V)-9(W)-8(H)1(PV)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
3.16 0 TD
0 Tc
[( court stated in 1996 that: \224...unlike hard-copy)30( advertisements ...)]TJ
-3.16 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(which are often quickly)29( disposed of and reach a limited number of potential)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(consum)-4(ers, I)21(n)-2(t)-4(e)2(rnet)-4( advert)-4(i)-4(s)-3(em)-4(ent)-4(s)-3( are i)-4(n)-2( el)-4(ect)-4(roni)-4(c pri)-4(n)-2(t)-4(e)2(d form)-4( so t)-4(h)-2(at)]TJ
T*
[(t)-4(h)-2(ey)28( can be accessed ag)8(ai)-4(n and ag)8(ai)-4(n by)28( m)-4(a)2(ny)28( m)-4(o)-2(re pot)-4(ent)-4(i)-4(a)2(l)-4( consum)-4(ers.\224)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 469.29 242.31 Tm
0.007 Tc
(228)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 222.63 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(I)23(f)3( the courts will succumb to such an opinion, it may)30( be more facile to)]TJ
T*
[(e)4(x)-10(e)4(r)3(c)4(i)-2(se)4( pe)4(rsona)4(l jurisdic)4(tion for we)4(b site)4(s e)4(x)-10(posing)10( the)4(m)-2(se)4(lve)4(s)-1( in re)4(mote)]TJ
0 -3 TD
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 175.59 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 164.79 Tm
(225)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 160.23 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(7KH\003ODZ\003ORQJ\003DUP\003RI\003WKH\003ODZ)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
11.3373 0 TD
0.003 Tw
[( b)-6(y)18( W)-8(illiam)19( S. Galkin, esq)-6( in Co)-6(m)19(p)-6(uter L)9(a)-2(w)]TJ
-12.5663 -1.1807 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(Obs)7(e)2(rv)10(er i)5(s)7(s)7(u)10(e No.24, March)10( 1997, at)]TJ
T*
-0.022 Tc
[(H)-23(t)-21(t)-21(p)-28(:)-21(/)-21(/)-21(www.)-25(l)-21(a)-24(wc)-24(i)-21(r)-26(c)-24(l)-21(e)-24(.)-25(c)-24(o)-28(m/)-21(i)-21(s)-19(s)-19(u)-16(e)-24(2)-28(4)-28(.)-25(h)-16(t)-21(ml)-21(.)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 129.51 Tm
0 Tc
(226)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 124.95 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(=LSSR\0030DQXIDFWXULQJ\003&R\021\003Y\021\003=LSSR\003'RW\003&RP\017\003,QF)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
19.5663 0 TD
0.003 Tc
[(. at III A)14( 2.)]TJ
-20.7952 -1.1807 TD
[(Ht)4(t)4(p)-3(:)4(/)4(/)4(zeu)9(s)6(.)0(bn)9(a.com)22(/)4(e-)11(l)4(a)1(w)26(/)4(cas)6(es)6(/)4(z)1(i)4(ppo.h)9(t)4(m)22(l)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 105.99 Tm
0 Tc
(227)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 101.43 Tm
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( McGee, 355 U.S)6(.)1( at)5( 223.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 141.81 93.27 Tm
0.007 Tc
(228)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 154.05 87.75 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.25 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(,QV)-9(H)1(W)-8(\003)-2(6\\V)-9(W)-8(H)1(PV)-9(\017\003,QF\021\003Y\021\003,QV)-9(W)-8(U)-9(XFW)-8(L)-8(RQ\0036HW)-8(\003,QF)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
15.94 0 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
(. Civil No. 3:95CV-)Tj
-17.21 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(01314 \(AVC\). April 17, 1996.)Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
450 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
451 0 obj
<<
/Length 5251
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(74)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(countries. On the other hand, if the courts disag)9(r)2(ee with the analog)9(y)29(,)-1( it may)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(be harder to ex)-11(ercise jurisdiction for non-active websites.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 707.55 Tm
0 Tc
[(\034\021\024\023\003)-434(&RG\\)11(\003Y)21(\021\003:DUG)]TJ
10.56 0 0 10.56 257.25 715.11 Tm
0.002 Tc
(\025\025\034)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 676.71 Tm
-0.001 Tc
(This case from 1997 concerns personal jurisdiction when e-mails, chatting)Tj
T*
(and telephones were the mediums used in order to induce a person in)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(another state to buy)30( stocks which turned out to be worthless. Mr.Colin M.)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Cody)29(, a resident of Connecticut, was persuaded \(by)29( Mr.Kevin M. W)-7(a)3(rd - a)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Californian resident\) into buy)30(ing)10( $196,000 worth of stocks in E. N. Phillips)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(com)-3(p)-1(any)29( \(ENP)-5(\). ENP)-5( was a L)20(oui)-3(si)-3(ana based com)-3(p)-1(any)29( t)-3(h)-1(at)-3( i)-3(n)-1(st)-3(al)-3(l)-3(e)3(d vi)-3(deo)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(bing)10(o g)10(a)4(mes in various casino-like locations in L)21(ouisiana. Since the stock)]TJ
T*
[(was worthless, Mr.Cody)30( soug)10(ht damag)10(e)4(s from Mr.W)-6(ard, based on)]TJ
T*
[(fraudulent misrepresentations. Mr.W)-6(ard wanted the court to dismiss the)]TJ
T*
[(action due to lack of personal jurisdiction on the g)10(r)3(ound that he had not)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(e)5(n)1(g)11(a)5(g)11(e)5(d in a)5(n)1(y)31( a)5(c)5(tivitie)5(s tha)5(t)-1( would subje)5(c)5(t)-1( him to the)5( jurisdic)5(tion of)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Connecticut. He contended that the long)10( arm statute did not apply)30( to him)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(since he was not phy)29(sically)29( present in Connecticut when the alleg)9(e)3(d)]TJ
T*
(misrepresentations were made.)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 470.31 Tm
-0.003 Tc
(\034\021\024\023\021\024)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.5128 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(\))6(LIWHHQ\003H\020PDLOV\003DQG\003D\003IRXU\003SKRQH\003FDOOV\003IXOILOOV\003WKH)]TJ
-3.1197 -1.1795 TD
(UHTXLUHPHQW\003RI\003SXUSRVHIXO\003PLQLPXP\003FRQWDFWV\003ZLWK)Tj
T*
0 Tc
(&RQQHFWLFXW)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 408.75 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Mr.W)-7(ard had communicated with potential investors concerning)9( the ENP)]TJ
T*
(stock via an on-line chat service, which maintains a channel for discussion)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
T*
[(of financial matters known as \223Money)29( Talk.\224 He had posted 225 messag)9(e)3(s)]TJ
T*
[(on-line in order to encourag)9(e people to buy)29( or hold ENP shares. Mr.W)-7(ard)]TJ
T*
[(claimed to have personal contacts with the manag)9(e)3(ment of ENP and)]TJ
T*
[(therefore possessed very)29( reliable information. Some of the messag)9(e)3(s were)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(also addressed specifically)30( to particular individuals, including)10( Mr.Cody)30(.)]TJ
T*
[(During)10( 1993 Mr.Cody)30( purchased 101,000 shares of ENP stock for $196,000)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(in re)5(lia)5(nc)5(e)5( on ma)5(te)5(ria)5(lly)31( fa)5(lse)5( a)5(nd misle)5(a)5(d)1(ing)11( sta)5(t)-1(e)5(m)-1(e)5(n)1(ts. Mr.Wa)5(r)4(d)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(telephoned Mr.Cody)30( in Connecticut four times to discuss the ENP stock and)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(se)5(nt him a)5(t)-1( le)5(a)5(s)0(t 15 e)5(-)4(ma)5(ils to his PC in Conne)5(c)5(tic)5(ut re)5(g)11(a)5(rding)11( the)5( ENP)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(stock which caused Mr.Cody)30( to hold his ENP shares.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(The court)-4( ci)-4(t)-4(e)2(d t)-4(h)-2(e Burg)8(er Ki)-4(ng)8( case)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 290.01 230.19 Tm
0.007 Tc
(230)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 302.25 224.67 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( se)4(ve)4(ra)4(l time)4(s a)4(nd c)4(onc)4(lude)4(d tha)4(t)]TJ
-15.73 -1.18 TD
[(Mr.W)-6(ard had purposefully)30( established minimum contacts in Connecticut)]TJ
T*
[(and that these contacts with Mr.Cody)30( in Connecticut were substantial)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(enoug)9(h that he should reasonably)29( have anticipated being)9( sued in)]TJ
T*
(Connecticut. The court took into consideration the nature and number of)Tj
T*
[(Mr.W)-7(ard\222s telephone calls and e-mails to Mr.Cody)29(. Contacts that are merely)]TJ
0 -2.17 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 130.95 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 141.81 119.19 Tm
0.007 Tc
(229)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 154.05 113.67 Tm
0 Tc
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.25 0 TD
-0.004 Tc
[(&)-11(R)2(O)-7(L)-7(Q)2(\0030\021\003&)-11(RG\\\003Y\021\003.)-11(HYL)-7(Q\0030\017\003:DU)-8(G)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
13.22 0 TD
0 Tc
[(, 954 F)6(.)0( Supp. 43 \(D. Conn.)]TJ
-14.49 -1.18 TD
[(1997\). F)6(e)4(b.4, 1997.)]TJ
T*
[(Http://zeus.bna.com/e-law/cases/cody)30(.html \(970925\))]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 77.67 Tm
(230)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 73.11 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(%XUJHU\003.LQJ\003&RUS\021\003Y\021\0035XG]HZLF])Tj
/F3 1 Tf
13.0482 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(, 471 U.S)7(.)2( \(1985\).)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
452 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
453 0 obj
<<
/Length 6773
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(75)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(random, or accidental, do not provide an adequate basis for personal)Tj
0 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(j)-4(u)-2(ri)-4(sdi)-4(c)2(t)-4(i)-4(on accordi)-4(n)-2(g)8( t)-4(o)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e Burg)8(er Ki)-4(ng)8( court)-4(,)-2( but)-4( t)-4(h)-2(i)-4(s)-3( was not)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e case)]TJ
T*
(here.)Tj
0 -2.36 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(The court stated that since the requirement of purposeful minimum contacts)Tj
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(with Connecticut was satisfied, jurisdiction was proper. I)23(t)-2( should be noted)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(that unfortunately)29( the court found it unnecessary)29( to decide whether)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
[(Mr.W)-7(ard\222s chat messag)9(e)3(s were to be seen as purposeful contacts with)]TJ
T*
[(Connecticut, since the e-mails and phonecalls tog)9(e)3(ther were enoug)9(h to prove)]TJ
T*
[(this. That could have been an interesting)9( issue.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 594.27 Tm
[(\034\021\024\024\003)-435('LJLWDO\003\(TXLSPHQW\003&RUS\021\003Y)20(\021\003$OWDY)20(L)1(VWD)]TJ
ET
1 i
113.49 592.59 30.84 -1.56 re
f
BT
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 575.43 Tm
[(7HFKQRORJ\\)10(\003,QF\021)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
10.56 0 0 10.56 234.45 582.99 Tm
0.001 Tc
(231)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 544.59 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(This case involved a dispute between two corporations over rig)9(h)-1(ts and)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(c)4(o)0(mme)4(rc)4(ia)4(l inte)4(re)4(sts on the)4( I)23(n)0(te)4(rne)4(t)-2(. B)7(o)0(th pa)4(rtie)4(s ope)4(ra)4(te)4(d e)4(l)-2(e)4(c)4(t)-2(ronic)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(services and distributed software via the I)22(n)-1(ternet. Dig)9(ital Equipment)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Corporation \(Dig)10(ital\) broug)10(ht suit ag)10(ainst AltaVista Technolog)10(y)30(,)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(I)21(n)-2(corporat)-4(ed \(ATI)21(\), for breach of a t)-4(r)1(adem)-4(ark l)-4(i)-4(censi)-4(ng)8( ag)8(reem)-4(ent)-4(,)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(trademark infring)9(ement, unfair competition, and trademark dilution. Dig)9(ital)]TJ
T*
[(was the owner of the search eng)9(i)-3(ne called Alta Vista)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 365.01 465.15 Tm
0.007 Tc
(232)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 377.25 459.63 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( and of all the rig)10(h)0(ts)]TJ
-21.98 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(i)-4(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(i)-4(s)-3( t)-4(r)1(adem)-4(ark. The t)-4(w)0(o com)-4(p)-2(ani)-4(e)2(s wrot)-4(e an ag)8(reem)-4(ent)-4(,)-2( g)8(i)-4(vi)-4(ng)8( ATI)21( a)]TJ
T*
[(l)-4(i)-4(cense t)-4(o)-2( use t)-4(h)-2(e word Al)-4(t)-4(a)2(Vi)-4(st)-4(a i)-4(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e corporat)-4(e nam)-4(e)2(, and i)-4(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e UR)-5(L)19(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 462.33 436.83 Tm
0.007 Tc
(233)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 417.15 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(ATI)22( was not, however, allowed to use AltaVista as a name of a product or)]TJ
T*
-0.003 Tc
[(servi)-5(ce.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 380.67 Tm
(\034\021\024\024\021\024)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.5128 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(&RQIXVLQJO\\\003VLPLODU\003ZHEVLWHV)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 352.23 Tm
0.001 Tw
[(After a short period of time ATI)22(\222)2(s site looked similar to and even operated)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(in the)4( sa)4(me)4( wa)4(y)30( a)4(s)-1( Dig)10(ita)4(l\222s Alta)4(Vista)4( we)4(b-se)4(a)4(r)3(c)4(h)0( se)4(rvic)4(e)4(.)0( Use)4(r)3(s hitting)10( the)]TJ
T*
[(ATI)23( site could easily)30( be deceived that they)30( were actually)30( visiting)10( Dig)10(ital')10(s)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(AltaVista search site. I)22(n)-1( the court, it was said that several hundred thousand)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(visitors se)4(a)4(r)3(c)4(h)0(ing)10( for Dig)10(ita)4(l\222s Alta)4( Vista)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 311.37 301.11 Tm
0.007 Tc
(234)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 323.61 295.59 Tm
0 Tc
[( involuntarily)30( ended up hitting)]TJ
-17.51 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(ATI)24(\222)4(s site)5( inste)5(a)5(d)1(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 201.45 286.95 Tm
0.007 Tc
(235)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 213.69 281.43 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
( This affected advertisers who wished to put banner ads)Tj
-8.35 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(on the)4( Dig)10(ita)4(l-site)4(, whic)4(h use)4(d)0( to ha)4(ve)4( ove)4(r 20 million hits pe)4(r da)4(y)30(.)0( I)23(f)3( the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Dig)9(ital Search eng)9(i)-3(ne did not have enoug)9(h hits per day)29(,)-1( the situation for)]TJ
T*
[(advertisers would be completely)29( different. Dig)9(ital claimed that ATI)22(\222)2(s web)]TJ
T*
[(site broke the above mentioned license ag)9(reement and therefore was)]TJ
T*
[(responsible for trademark infring)9(ements. ATI)22( wanted the court to dismiss)]TJ
T*
[(for lack of personal jurisdiction, but the court rejected this arg)9(u)-1(ment.)]TJ
0 -1.8 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
113.49 177.99 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 141.81 166.23 Tm
0.007 Tc
(231)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 154.05 160.71 Tm
0 Tc
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.25 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[('L)-8(JL)-8(W)-8(D)1(O)-8(\003)-2(\(TXL)-8(SPHQW)-8(\003&)-12(RU)-9(S\021\003Y\021\003$O)-8(W)-8(DYL)-8(V)-9(W)-8(D\0037)-11(HFKQRO)-8(RJ\\\003,QF)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
21.16 0 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
(. Civil)Tj
-22.43 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(Action No. 96-12192NG, March 12, 1997.)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
(Http://zeus.bna.com/e-law/cases/alta.html \(970925\))Tj
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 124.71 Tm
(232)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 120.15 Tm
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( T)-14(h)8(e A)13(lta Vis)5(t)3(a s)5(earch)8( en)8(g)8(i)3(n)8(e)0( h)8(a)0(s)5( been)8( av)8(ailable s)5(i)3(n)8(ce Decem)21(ber 1995 at)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(Http)-7(:// )]TJ
2.8675 0 TD
-0.022 Tc
[(www.)-25(a)-24(l)-21(t)-21(a)-24(v)-16(i)-21(s)-19(t)-21(a)-24(.)-25(d)-28(i)-21(g)-16(i)-21(t)-21(a)-24(l)-21(.)-25(c)-24(o)-28(m.)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 101.19 Tm
0 Tc
(233)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 96.63 Tm
-0.023 Tc
0.026 Tw
[( T)-39(h)-17(e)-25( U)-24(R)-19(L)-14(:)-22( H)-24(t)-22(t)-22(p)-29(:)-22(/)-22(/)-22(www.)-26(a)-25(l)-22(t)-22(a)-25(v)-17(i)-22(s)-20(t)-22(a)-25(.)-26(c)-25(o)-29(m)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
0 Tc
(234)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 84.87 Tm
-0.023 Tc
[( H)-24(t)-22(t)-22(p)-29(:)-22(/)-22(/)-22(www.)-26(a)-25(l)-22(t)-22(a)-25(v)-17(i)-22(s)-20(t)-22(a)-25(.)-26(d)-29(i)-22(g)-17(i)-22(t)-22(a)-25(l)-22(.)-26(c)-25(o)-29(m)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 77.67 Tm
0 Tc
(235)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 73.11 Tm
0.003 Tw
[( Http)-6(:// )]TJ
3.1205 0 TD
-0.023 Tc
[(www.)-26(a)-25(l)-22(t)-22(a)-25(v)-17(i)-22(s)-20(t)-22(a)-25(.)-26(c)-25(o)-29(m)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
454 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F5 276 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
456 0 obj
<<
/Length 5875
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(76)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 743.31 Tm
-0.003 Tc
(\034\021\024\024\021\025)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.5128 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
($\003FRQVWDQWO\\\003DFFHVVLEOH\003ZHEVLWH\003LV\003D\003VLJQ\003RI\003FRQGXFWLQJ)Tj
-3.1197 -1.1795 TD
0 Tc
[(EXVLQHVV\003LQ\0030)24(DVVDFKXVHWWV)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 698.31 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(ATI)21( al)-4(so desi)-4(g)8(n)-2(ed a C)-5(a)2(l)-4(i)-4(f)1(orni)-4(an websi)-4(t)-4(e)2( t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( was accessi)-4(bl)-4(e t)-4(o)-2( surfers)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(situa)4(t)-2(e)4(d)0( in Ma)4(ssa)4(c)4(huse)4(tts. The)4( site)4( a)4(dve)4(rtise)4(d)0( a)4(nd sold ATI)23(\222)3(s softwa)4(re)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(products. At least three sales to Massachusetts residents were documented.)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(ATI)23( c)4(l)-2(a)4(ime)4(d tha)4(t)-2( thre)4(e)4( sa)4(le)4(s we)4(re)4( re)4(la)4(tive)4(l)-2(y)30( insig)10(n)0(ific)4(a)4(n)0(t. Ex)-10(c)4(e)4(p)0(t for the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(website and the three sales, ATI)22( had no further presence in Massachusetts.)]TJ
T*
[(The court, however, found that ATI)22( had been conducting)9( business in)]TJ
T*
[(Massachusetts. The fact that the website was accessible twenty)29(-four hours a)]TJ
T*
[(day)29( and seven day)29(s)-2( a week t)-3(o)-1( al)-3(l)-3( Massachuset)-3(t)-3(s)-2( resi)-3(dent)-3(s who coul)-3(d access)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(h)-2(e W)-8(e)2(b, as wel)-4(l)-4( as t)-4(h)-2(e fact)-4( t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( ATI)21( sol)-4(d)-2( advert)-4(i)-4(s)-3(i)-4(n)-2(g)8( space and soft)-4(ware)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(throug)11(h its site)5( to c)5(itize)5(n)1(s of Ma)5(ssa)5(c)5(huse)5(tts wa)5(s a)5( sig)11(n)1( of c)5(ontinuing)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(busi)-3(n)-1(ess cont)-3(act)-3(s wi)-3(t)-3(h)-1( t)-3(h)-1(e st)-3(at)-3(e.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 534.39 Tm
-0.003 Tc
(\034\021\024\024\021\026)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.5128 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(&RQVHTXHQFHV\003RI\003EXVLQHVV\003LQ\003&\\EHUVSDFH\003VKRXOG\003EH)Tj
-3.1197 -1.1795 TD
0 Tc
(FRQVLGHUHG\003LQ\003DGYDQFH)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 489.39 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(The court discussed the fact that the dispute had come about as a result of)Tj
T*
[(new rapidly)29( chang)9(i)-3(ng)9( technolog)9(ical means, and urg)9(e)3(d courts to be careful in)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(apply)30(i)-2(ng)10( traditional concepts in all situations. The reasoning)10( of the court)]TJ
T*
[(concerning)10( the risks of conducting)10( business on-line is very)30( interesting)10(.)0( Since)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(ATI)22( had to travel considerably)29( far in order to appear in court, it was said that)]TJ
T*
[(this is the price of doing)9( business on the I)22(n)-1(ternet. I)22(f)2( one acts in a way)29( that)]TJ
T*
[(may)29( cause a tort in another state, the inconvenience of traveling)9( to the court)]TJ
T*
[(in that state should be considered before acting)9(.)-1( I)22( find this reasoning)9( peculiar)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(if it would be applied to all cases involving)10( websites around the world, but I)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(have reason to believe that this was not the intention of the court, since the)Tj
T*
[(reasoning)9( above is valid only)29( under the circumstances of this case.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 325.47 Tm
-0.003 Tc
(\034\021\024\024\021\027)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.5128 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(&RVW\003HIILFLHQF\\\003DQG\003MXULVGLFWLRQ)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 297.03 Tm
0.001 Tw
[(Another issue discussed by)29( the court in this case, was the relationship)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(between cost efficiency)29( and jurisdiction. On the one hand, many)29( companies)]TJ
T*
[(conduct business via the I)22(n)-1(ternet due to the low costs, but if they)29( have to)]TJ
T*
[(anticipate costs of being)9( drag)9(g)9(e)3(d into courts all over America, the web-)]TJ
T*
(based business will be much more uneconomical. On the other hand, it may)Tj
T*
[(be dang)9(erous to allow that businessmen conducting)9( business via the web,)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(are unt)-4(ouchabl)-4(es i)-4(n)-2( al)-4(l)-4( j)-4(u)-2(ri)-4(sdi)-4(c)2(t)-4(i)-4(ons ex)-12(cept)-4( for t)-4(h)-2(e one where t)-4(h)-2(ey)28( are)]TJ
T*
[(phy)28(si)-4(cal)-4(l)-4(y)28( l)-4(o)-2(cat)-4(ed.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 174.15 Tm
0 Tc
[(\034\021\024\025\003)-434(+DOO\003Y)21(\021\003/D5RQGH)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
10.56 0 0 10.56 275.25 181.71 Tm
0.001 Tc
(236)Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 172.47 30.84 -1.56 re
f
BT
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 143.31 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(This case holds that the use of e-mail and telephone by)29( a party)29( situated in)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(Ne)5(w York ma)5(y)31( e)5(s)0(ta)5(blish suffic)5(i)-1(e)5(n)1(t minimum c)5(onta)5(c)5(t)-1(s with Ca)5(lifornia)5( to)]TJ
0 -1.69 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
113.49 111.99 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 101.19 Tm
(236)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 96.63 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(+DOO\003Y\021\003/DURQGH\017)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
6.6506 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( 2d C)8(i)5(v)10(i)5(l)5( No. B107423\(S)6(u)10(per. C)8(t)5(. No. 165615\)\(Ven)10(t)5(u)10(ra)]TJ
-7.8795 -1.1807 TD
0.002 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(C)6(o)-4(u)8(n)8(t)3(y)20(\))-2( J)-7(u)8(ly)20( 8, 1997. Http://)]TJ
11.5663 0 TD
-0.022 Tc
[(www.)-25(l)-21(j)-33(x)-16(.)-25(c)-24(o)-28(m/)-21(L)-13(J)-31(X)-23(f)-14(i)-21(l)-21(e)-24(s)-19(/)-21(l)-21(a)-24(r)-26(o)-28(n)-16(d)-28(e)-24(/)-21(l)-21(a)-24(r)-26(o)-28(n)-16(c)-24(o)-28(u)-16(r)-26(t)-21(.)-25(h)-16(t)-21(m)-3(l)]TJ
-11.5663 -1.1807 TD
0.006 Tc
(\(971017\))Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
457 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F5 276 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
458 0 obj
<<
/Length 5709
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(77)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(support personal jurisdiction. B)6(l)-3(ake Hall \(California\) entered into contract in)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(1994 with B)7(r)3(ad L)21(a)4(Ronde \(New York\). L)21(a)4(Ronde was supposed to sell)]TJ
T*
[(lic)4(e)4(n)0(se)4(s for the)4( use)4( of a)4( c)4(o)0(mpute)4(r)3( softwa)4(re)4( a)4(pplic)4(a)4(tion tha)4(t)-2( Ha)4(ll ha)4(d writte)4(n.)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Hall was supposed to be compensated for every)29( license L)20(a)3(Ronde sold.)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(L)21(a)4(Ronde sold the licenses, but compensated Hall only)30( once. Hall wanted his)]TJ
T*
[(full compensation and filed a suit in California. L)21(a)4(Ronde maintained that)]TJ
T*
(Californian courts had no jurisdiction, since sufficient minimum contacts)Tj
T*
[(with Ca)4(lifornia)4( we)4(re)4( la)4(c)4(k)0(ing)10(.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 624.03 Tm
-0.003 Tc
(\034\021\024\025\021\024)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.5128 0 TD
0 Tc
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(\(\020PDLO\003DQG\003WHOHSKRQH\003FDOOV\003ZHUH\003WKH\003RQO\\\003FRQWDFWV)Tj
-3.1197 -1.1795 TD
(EHWZHHQ\003WKH\003SDUWLHV)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 579.03 Tm
0.001 Tw
(The contacts between the parties took place via e-mail and telephone. Hall)Tj
T*
(had no other contacts with New York besides from the contacts with)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(L)21(a)4(Ronda. Hall worked on the prog)10(ram in California and L)21(a)4(Ronda sold the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(licenses in New York. L)20(a)3(Ronda had no other contacts with California than)]TJ
T*
[(those with Hall. The trial court g)9(r)2(anted L)20(a)3(Ronda')162(s)-2( motion and ordered the)]TJ
T*
(case dismissed. The court of appeal of the state of California reversed the)Tj
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(judg)11(e)5(m)-1(e)5(n)1(t from the)5( tria)5(l c)5(ourt.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 471.75 Tm
-0.003 Tc
(\034\021\024\025\021\025)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.5128 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
[(*)-7(HQHUDO\003SHUVRQDO\003MXULVGLFWLRQ)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 443.31 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Personal jurisdiction may)29( be either g)9(e)3(neral or specific. W)-7(h)-1(ere a)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
0 -1.18 TD
(nonresident\222s contacts with the forum state are substantial, continuous and)Tj
T*
[(sy)29(stematic, a court may)29( assert g)9(e)3(neral jurisdiction over that person. The)]TJ
T*
[(court said that such g)9(e)3(neral jurisdiction does not require a connection)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(bet)-4(w)0(een t)-4(h)-2(e speci)-4(fi)-4(c t)-4(r)1(ansact)-4(i)-4(on at)-4( i)-4(ssue and t)-4(h)-2(e forum)-4( st)-4(at)-4(e. Hal)-4(l)-4( ag)8(reed t)-4(o)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(the fact that the evidence was not enoug)9(h to support g)9(e)3(neral jurisdiction, but)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(he arg)10(u)0(ed that it was sufficient to support specific jurisdiction.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 336.03 Tm
-0.003 Tc
(\034\021\024\025\021\026)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.5128 0 TD
0 Tc
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
(6SHFLILF\003SHUVRQDO\003MXULVGLFWLRQ)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 307.59 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(The court)-4( ex)-12(pl)-4(ai)-4(ned t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( speci)-4(fi)-4(c j)-4(u)-2(ri)-4(sdi)-4(c)2(t)-4(i)-4(on can be affi)-4(rm)-4(ed when t)-4(h)-2(e)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(nonresident purposefully)30( avails himself of various forum benefits and the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(controversy)29( is related to or arise out of his/her contacts with the forum. The)]TJ
T*
[(court cited the B)6(u)-1(rg)9(er King)9( court)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 272.49 270.63 Tm
0.007 Tc
(237)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 284.73 265.11 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(, which in 1985 stated that sufficient)Tj
-14.27 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(minimum contacts for specific jurisdiction ex)-11(ist where a nonresident)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(de)5(libe)5(r)4(a)5(t)-1(e)5(l)-1(y)31( ha)5(s e)5(n)1(g)11(a)5(g)11(e)5(d in sig)11(n)1(ific)5(a)5(n)1(t a)5(c)5(tivitie)5(s within a)5( sta)5(t)-1(e)5( or ha)5(s c)5(r)4(e)5(a)5(t)-1(e)5(d)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(continuing)10( oblig)10(ations between himself and residents of the forum.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 200.31 Tm
-0.003 Tc
(\034\021\024\025\021\027)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.5128 0 TD
0 Tc
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(0)23(LQLPXP\003FRQWDFWV\003FDQ\003EH\003HOHFWURQLF)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 171.87 Tm
0.001 Tw
[(The court discussed various aspects of personal jurisdiction. I)22(t)-3( was said that)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(all persons have an interest in not being)10( subject to judg)10(ments of a forum)]TJ
T*
(with which he or she has no minimum contacts. The court succumbed to the)Tj
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(I)22(n)-1(ternational Shoe court)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 229.05 134.91 Tm
0.007 Tc
(238)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 241.29 129.39 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(, which in 1945 said that the requirement of)Tj
-10.65 -2.69 TD
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 100.23 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
(237)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 84.87 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(%XUJHU\003.LQJ\003&RUS\021\003Y\021\0035XG]HZLF])Tj
/F3 1 Tf
13.0482 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[( \(1985\) 471 U.S)7(.)2( [85 L)14(.Ed.2d])]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 77.67 Tm
0 Tc
(238)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 73.11 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(,QWHUQDWLRQDO\0036KRH\003&R\021\003Y\021\003:DVKLQJWRQ)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
15.2048 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[( \(1945\) 326 U.S)7(.)2( [90 L)14(.Ed. 95, 102].)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
459 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
460 0 obj
<<
/Length 5990
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(78)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
0 Tw
(minimum contacts ensures that the assertion of jurisdiction does not violate)Tj
0 -1.18 TD
[(traditional notions of fair play)30( and substantial justice.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(The court further stated that phy)29(sical presence in California should not at all)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
(be determinative since the effectiveness of modern communications does)Tj
T*
[(not even require people leaving)9( their offices in order to conduct business.)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(The requi)-4(si)-4(t)-4(e)2( m)-4(i)-4(n)-2(i)-4(m)-4(u)-2(m)-4( cont)-4(act)-4(s can be el)-4(ect)-4(roni)-4(c, accordi)-4(n)-2(g)8( t)-4(o)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e court)-4(.)-2( I)21(n)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(this case, Hall contacted New York electronically)29( and L)20(a)3(Ronde contacted)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
[(California electronically)29(. The court found that L)20(a)3(Ronde\222s contacts with)]TJ
T*
(California were more than random, fortuitous, or attenuated and that he had)Tj
T*
[(purposefully)29( derived a benefit from his interstate activities. B)6(ecause of this)]TJ
T*
(fact, it was not unfair to require that he should answer in California for any)Tj
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(c)5(onse)5(que)5(nc)5(e)5(s)0( tha)5(t)-1( a)5(r)4(ose)5( from his a)5(c)5(tivitie)5(s. Spe)5(c)5(i)-1(fic)5( pe)5(rsona)5(l jurisdic)5(tion)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
(was proper.)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
0 -2.88 TD
0.002 Tc
[(\034\021\024\025\021\027\021\024\003)-188(3HRSOH\003Y)17(\021\003/LSVLW])]TJ
/T3 1 Tf
8.039 0 0 8.039 256.89 532.83 Tm
0 Tc
(\025\026\034)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 498.75 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(This case involved fraudulent and deceptive consumer sales practices.)Tj
0 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(Ke)5(nne)5(th L)22(i)-1(psitz use)5(d)1( a)5(nd a)5(buse)5(d)1( the)5( e)5(-)4(ma)5(il sy)31(ste)5(m)-1( to solic)5(it ma)5(g)11(a)5(zine)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(subsc)4(r)3(iptions to the)4( worldwide)4( I)23(n)0(te)4(rne)4(t)-2( c)4(o)0(mmunity)30(, from a)4( loc)4(a)4(tion in Ne)4(w)]TJ
T*
[(York. L)21(i)-2(psitz)-6( sent friendly)30( e-mails to various e-mail discussion g)10(r)3(oups and)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(port)-4(r)1(ay)28(ed hi)-4(m)-4(s)-3(el)-4(f as a m)-4(e)2(m)-4(b)-2(er, whi)-4(c)2(h g)8(a)2(ve a fal)-4(s)-3(e feel)-4(i)-4(n)-2(g)8( of confi)-4(d)-2(ence)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(a)4(m)-2(ong)10( the)4( othe)4(r use)4(r)3(s. He)4( a)4(l)-2(so se)4(nt e)4(-)3(ma)4(ils from fic)4(titious pa)4(st c)4(u)0(stome)4(r)3(s)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(prai)-4(si)-4(ng)8( L)19(i)-4(psi)-4(t)-4(z)-8(\222s ex)-12(cel)-4(l)-4(e)2(nt)-4( cust)-4(om)-4(er servi)-4(ce as wel)-4(l)-4( as t)-4(h)-2(e l)-4(o)-2(w pri)-4(ces. The)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(mag)9(a)3(z)-7(i)-3(nes he sold rarely)29( ever arrived, and if they)29( did, only)29( with a shortened)]TJ
T*
[(subscription, often by)29( as much as half the leng)9(th of time for which the)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(consum)-4(er had pai)-4(d)-2( for. S)-6(e)2(veral)-4( unsuccessful)-4( at)-4(t)-4(e)2(m)-4(p)-2(t)-4(s)-3( were m)-4(a)2(de t)-4(o)-2( t)-4(r)1(ace t)-4(h)-2(e)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(author of the e-mails, since L)20(i)-3(psitz)-7( used various methods for sending)]TJ
T*
[(anony)29(mous e-mails, which sometimes is referred to as \223spoofing)9(\224)3(. Several)]TJ
T*
(consumers from New York, other states and from abroad filed complaints)Tj
T*
0.002 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(a)6(g)12(a)6(i)0(nst L)23(i)0(psitz.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 292.35 Tm
-0.003 Tc
(\034\021\024\025\021\030)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.5128 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(1R\003DOWHUQDWLYH\003WUHDWLQJ\003RI\003&\\EHUVSDFH\003LVVXHV)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 263.91 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(L)22(i)-1(psitz c)5(l)-1(a)5(ime)5(d tha)5(t)-1( the)5( c)5(ourt ha)5(d no jurisdic)5(tion ove)5(r his I)24(n)1(te)5(rne)5(t)-1( a)5(c)5(tivity)31(.)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(The court stated that althoug)10(h I)23(n)0(ternet transactions mig)10(ht appear to pose)]TJ
T*
(novel jurisdictional issues, traditional jurisdictional standards often are)Tj
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(enoug)9(h to resolve I)22(n)-1(ternet jurisdictional issues. I)22( find the courts reliance)]TJ
T*
[(upon \223old\224 principles quite remarkable. I)22(t)-3( was stated that for I)22(n)-1(ternet)]TJ
T*
[(consumer fraud claims, the I)22(n)-1(ternet medium is irrelevant. The court stressed)]TJ
T*
[(the importance of placing)9( a realistic contex)-11(t upon I)22(n)-1(ternet matters and)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(i)-4(g)8(nore t)-4(h)-2(e fact)-4( t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e fraud act)-4(ual)-4(l)-4(y)28( happened i)-4(n)-2( C)-5(y)28(berspace. I)21(t)-4( was sai)-4(d)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(that there is no reason to take a \223hands off\224 approach because a criminal is)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(technolog)10(ically)30( sophisticated enoug)10(h to sell on the I)23(n)0(ternet. According)10( to the)]TJ
0 -2.3 TD
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 111.99 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 101.19 Tm
(239)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 96.63 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(3HRSOH\003Y\021\003/LSVLW])Tj
/F3 1 Tf
6.6627 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, NY S)6(u)10(pC)8(t)5(,)1( New)27( York)10( C)8(o)-2(u)10(n)10(t)5(y)22(,)1( In)10(dex)10( No. 400945/)5(97,)]TJ
-7.8916 -1.1807 TD
-0.022 Tc
0.025 Tw
[(6)-28(/)-21(2)-28(3)-28(/)-21(9)-28(7)-28(.)-25( H)-23(t)-21(t)-21(p)-28(:)-21(www.)-25(l)-21(j)-33(x)-16(.)-25(c)-24(o)-28(m/)-21(i)-21(n)-16(t)-21(e)-24(r)-26(n)-16(e)]TJ
14.0723 0 TD
0 Tc
0.003 Tw
[(t/lip)-6(sd)-6(cc.htm)19(l)1( and)-6( Electro)-6(nic Inf)8(o)-6(rm)19(atio)-6(n)]TJ
-14.0723 -1.1807 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(Pol)6(i)6(c)3(y)23( &)12( L)14(a)3(w)28( R)9(e)3(port)6( Ju)11(l)6(y)23( 18, 1997, Vol)6( 2, No 28, pag)11(e)3( 773.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
461 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
/T3 393 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
462 0 obj
<<
/Length 2653
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(79)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(court, the focus in a consumer fraud claim should be upon the location of the)Tj
0 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(m)-4(e)2(sseng)8(er and whet)-4(her t)-4(h)-2(e m)-4(e)2(sseng)8(er del)-4(i)-4(v)-2(ered what)-4( was purchased.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 708.99 Tm
(\034\021\024\025\021\031)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.5128 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
(-XULVGLFWLRQDO\003FRQVLGHUDWLRQV)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 680.55 Tm
[(The)4( c)4(ourt he)4(ld tha)4(t)-2( the)4( first jurisdic)4(tiona)4(l c)4(onside)4(r)3(a)4(tion is whe)4(t)-2(he)4(r phy)30(sic)4(a)4(l)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(presence or a sufficiently)29( close equivalent in the jurisdiction is established.)]TJ
T*
(The second is whether the acts performed provide sufficient minimum)Tj
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(c)5(onta)5(c)5(t)-1(s with the)5( forum to me)5(e)5(t)-1( the)5( c)5(onstitutiona)5(l jurisdic)5(tion te)5(st from)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
T*
-0.006 Tc
[(,QW)-9(H)0(U)-10(QDW)-9(L)-9(RQDO)-9(\0036KRH\003Y\021\003:DV)-10(KL)-9(QJW)-9(RQ)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
13.42 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(.)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 277.53 629.43 Tm
0.007 Tc
(240)Tj
12 0 0 12 289.77 623.91 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( L)22(i)-1(psitz wa)5(s phy)31(sic)5(a)5(lly)31( loc)5(a)5(t)-1(e)5(d)1( within)]TJ
-14.69 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(the jurisdiction, and jurisdiction was proper since the complaints occurred)Tj
T*
[(within the same jurisdiction. F)5(r)2(om this case one can draw the conclusion)]TJ
T*
[(that if a crime is committed in Cy)29(berspace, jurisdiction may)29( be proper at)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(le)5(a)5(s)0(t in the)5( jurisdic)5(tion whe)5(r)4(e)5( the)5( c)5(r)4(imina)5(l)-1( is phy)31(sic)5(a)5(lly)31( loc)5(a)5(t)-1(e)5(d. The)5( fa)5(c)5(t)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(that I)22(n)-1(ternet is the medium used is therefore irrelevant. One must keep in)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(mind tha)5(t)-1( if a)5( suit is file)5(d in a)5(nothe)5(r jurisdic)5(tion tha)5(n)1( in the)5( one)5( whe)5(r)4(e)5( the)]TJ
T*
[(a)5(lle)5(g)11(e)5(d c)5(r)4(imina)5(l)-1( is loc)5(a)5(t)-1(e)5(d, jurisdic)5(tion ma)5(y)31( not be)5( prope)5(r.)]TJ
0 -36.62 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 88.47 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 77.67 Tm
(240)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 73.11 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(,QWHUQDWLRQDO\0036KRH\003&R\021\003Y\021\003:DVKLQJWRQ)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
15.2048 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(, 326 U.S)7(.)2( \(1945\).)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
463 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
464 0 obj
<<
/Length 5703
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(80)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
24 0 0 24 113.49 733.71 Tm
[(\024\023\003)-310($)-28(PHULFDQ\003FDVHV\003LQ\003ZKLFK)]TJ
0 -1.175 TD
(MXULVGLFWLRQ\003LV\003UHIXVHG)Tj
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 655.47 Tm
[(\024\023\021\024\003)-434(3)0(UHV\020.DS\003,QF\021\003Y)21(\021\0036\\)11(VWHP\0032)5(QH\017\003'LUHFW)]TJ
0 -1.1805 TD
($FFHVV\003,QF\021)Tj
/F5 1 Tf
10.56 0 0 10.56 200.85 644.19 Tm
0.001 Tc
(241)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 605.79 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(S)-6(y)28(st)-4(em)-4( One Di)-4(rect)-4( Access, I)21(n)-2(c. operat)-4(e)2(d a com)-4(put)-4(eri)-4(z)-8(ed ai)-4(rl)-4(i)-4(n)-2(e reservat)-4(i)-4(o)-2(n)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(sy)29(st)-3(em)-3(. The server for t)-3(h)-1(e sy)29(st)-3(em)-3(, and t)-3(h)-1(e m)-3(a)3(i)-3(n)-1( busi)-3(n)-1(ess offi)-3(ce, were)]TJ
T*
[(located in F)5(l)-3(orida. Pres-Kap, I)22(n)-1(c., a New York corporation, operated a travel)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
[(ag)9(ency)29( in New York. All of Pres-Kap\222s travel businesses were conducted)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(from)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e New York offi)-4(ce. The com)-4(p)-2(ani)-4(e)2(s ent)-4(e)2(red a l)-4(ease cont)-4(ract)-4( i)-4(n)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(December 1989 reg)9(a)3(rding)9( the airline reservation sy)29(stem. P)-5(r)2(es-Kap was)]TJ
T*
[(allowed to use the reservation sy)29(stem in return of pay)29(i)-3(ng)9( a monthly)29( fee.)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(S)-6(y)28(st)-4(em)-4( One del)-4(i)-4(v)-2(ered and i)-4(n)-2(st)-4(al)-4(l)-4(e)2(d t)-4(h)-2(e com)-4(put)-4(er t)-4(e)2(rm)-4(i)-4(n)-2(al)-4(s i)-4(n)-2( New York. I)21(n)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(1991 a dispute arose between the parties relating)9( to an alleg)9(e)3(d)]TJ
T*
[(malfunctioning)9( of the airline reservation sy)29(stem.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 456.03 Tm
-0.003 Tc
(\024\023\021\024\021\024)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.5128 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(3)6(ODFHPHQW\003RI\003VHUYHU\003LUUHOHYDQW)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 427.59 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(S)-6(y)28(st)-4(em)-4( One sued P)-6(r)1(es-Kap i)-4(n)-2( Fl)-4(ori)-4(d)-2(a. P)-6(r)1(es-Kap urg)8(e)2(d t)-4(h)-2(e court)-4( t)-4(o)-2( di)-4(sm)-4(i)-4(s)-3(s)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(the case due to lack of personal jurisdiction. Pres-Kap\222s contacts with)Tj
T*
[(F)5(l)-3(orida were not numerous. B)6(a)3(sically)29(, the only)29( two contacts were the)]TJ
T*
[(monthly)29( pay)29(m)-3(ents to Sy)29(stem One in F)5(l)-3(orida and the fact that the server of)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(the)4( a)4(i)-2(rline)4( re)4(se)4(rva)4(tion sy)30(ste)4(m)-2( wa)4(s situa)4(t)-2(e)4(d)0( in F)6(l)-2(orida)4(.)0( The)4( tria)4(l c)4(ourt in)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(F)5(l)-3(orida stated that the contacts with F)5(l)-3(orida were enoug)9(h to establish)]TJ
T*
[(jurisdiction over Pres-Kap. The District Court of Appeal in F)5(l)-3(orida was of)]TJ
T*
(the opposite opinion. The court cited the )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
16.43 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(%XU)-9(JHU)-9(\003.)-12(L)-8(Q)1(J)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
5.03 0 TD
0.002 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[( Ca)6(se)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 397.29 333.99 Tm
0.007 Tc
(242)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 409.53 328.47 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( whi)-3(c)3(h st)-3(at)-3(es)]TJ
-24.67 -1.18 TD
[(that an individual\222s \(A\222s\) contract with an out-of-state party)29( \(B)6(\) alone does)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(not a)5(u)1(toma)5(tic)5(a)5(lly)31( e)5(s)0(ta)5(blish suffic)5(i)-1(e)5(n)1(t minimum c)5(onta)5(c)5(t)-1(s in the)5( othe)5(r pa)5(rty)31(\222)4(s)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(\(A\222s\) home forum in order to find jurisdiction over the out-of-state)Tj
T*
[(defendant \(B)6(\). This is the case even when the foreig)9(n defendant \(B)6(\))]TJ
T*
(breaches the contract. The additional factor in the case, was the location of)Tj
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(h)-2(e dat)-4(a)2(base. However, t)-4(h)-2(e court)-4( st)-4(at)-4(ed t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e pl)-4(acem)-4(ent)-4( of t)-4(h)-2(e server was)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(irrelevant. I)22(t)-3( was said that a user mig)9(ht not even be aware of the ex)-11(act)]TJ
T*
(electronic location of the database. The court did not believe that such)Tj
T*
[(knowledg)9(e \(of the database location \226 New York\) would have made Pres-)]TJ
T*
[(Kap anticipate being)9( sued in New York. The court saw a pending)9( dang)9(er in)]TJ
T*
[(focusing)9( too much upon the location of the database. I)22(f)2( one would follow)]TJ
T*
[(the Trial courts reasoning)9(, all on-line services could be haled into court in)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(h)-2(e st)-4(at)-4(e where t)-4(h)-2(e suppl)-4(i)-4(e)2(r\222s server happens t)-4(o)-2( be l)-4(o)-2(cat)-4(ed. Therefore,)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 133.35 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 141.81 121.59 Tm
0.007 Tc
(241)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 154.05 116.07 Tm
0 Tc
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.25 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(3U)-9(HV)-9(\020.)-12(DS\003,QF\021\003Y\021\0036\\V)-9(W)-8(H)1(P\0032QH\017\003'L)-8(U)-9(HFW)-8(\003$FFHV)-9(V)-9(\003)-2(,QF\021)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
19.25 0 TD
0 Tc
( 636 So.2d)Tj
-20.52 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(1351 \(F)5(la. App.1994\) Http://www.jmls.edu/cy)29(ber/cases/pres-)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(kap.tx)-10(t)-2( \(980211\))]TJ
/T2 1 Tf
8.039 0 0 8.039 141.81 79.11 Tm
(\025\027\025)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 154.05 73.59 Tm
-0.005 Tc
[(\003%XU)-9(JHU)-9(\003.)-12(L)-8(QJ\003&)-12(R)1(U)-9(S)1(\021\003Y\021\0035XG])-9(HZ)-12(L)-8(F)1(])]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
13.25 0 TD
0 Tc
(, 471 U.S. \(1985\).)Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
465 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F5 276 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
/T2 331 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
466 0 obj
<<
/Length 5434
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(81)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(contacts based on transactions over a computer network when the defendant)Tj
0 -1.18 TD
(is unaware of where the electronic transaction takes place cannot constitute)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(minimum c)4(onta)4(c)4(t)-2(s. The)4( c)4(ourt re)4(ve)4(rse)4(d)0( the)4( Tria)4(l c)4(ourt\222s de)4(c)4(i)-2(sion a)4(n)0(d)]TJ
T*
(dismissed the case for lack of personal jurisdiction. This is fair, since it is)Tj
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(not alway)29(s)-2( obvious where a server is situated. Even if it is obvious, there is a)]TJ
T*
[(dang)9(er in such reasoning)9(. As described above, people and org)9(a)3(niz)-7(a)3(tions may)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(strive to utiliz)-6(e servers in countries that protect them and do not accept suits)]TJ
T*
-0.003 Tc
0.003 Tw
[(ag)7(ai)-5(nst)-5( t)-5(h)-3(em)-5(.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 622.59 Tm
0 Tc
[(\024\023\021\025\003)-434(%)-2(HQVXVDQ\0035HVWDXUDQW\003&RUS\021\0039\021\0035LFKDUG\003%\021)]TJ
ET
1 i
113.49 620.91 30.84 -1.56 re
f
BT
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 603.75 Tm
-0.001 Tc
(.LQJ)Tj
10.56 0 0 10.56 148.89 611.31 Tm
0.001 Tc
(\025\027\026)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 572.91 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(I)22(n)-1( this case from late 1996, the main question was whether the ex)-11(istence of a)]TJ
T*
[(website on the W)-7(o)-1(rld W)-7(i)-3(de W)-7(e)3(b, )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
13.64 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(DO)-9(RQH)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
2.22 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(, could prove sufficient in order to)Tj
-15.86 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(obtain personal jurisdiction. The court found that solely)30( a website would not)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(be enoug)9(h to ex)-11(ercise personal jurisdiction. B)6(e)3(nsusan Restaurant Corp. \(the)]TJ
T*
[(creator of a jaz)-7(z)-7( club in New York City)29( known as \223The B)6(l)-3(ue Note\224\) broug)9(ht)]TJ
T*
[(an action ag)9(ainst Richard King)9(, \(who owned and operated a small club in)]TJ
T*
[(Columbia, Missouri, also called \223The B)6(l)-3(ue Note.\224\) alleg)9(i)-3(ng)9( that King)9( was)]TJ
T*
[(infring)9(ing)9( upon B)6(e)3(nsusan')9(s)-2( federally)29( reg)9(i)-3(stered trademark \223The B)6(l)-3(ue Note\224.)]TJ
T*
[(King)9( wanted the court to dismiss the complaint for lack of personal)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
[(jurisdic)5(tion.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 423.15 Tm
-0.003 Tc
(\024\023\021\025\021\024)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.5128 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
($\003JHQHUDO\017\003SDVVLYH\003ZHEVLWH\003GRHV\003QRW\003IRFXV\003RQ\003DQ\\)Tj
-3.1197 -1.1795 TD
0 Tc
(SDUWLFXODU\003MXULVGLFWLRQ)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 378.15 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Mr.King)9(\222)2(s website was located on a computer server in Missouri, and it was)]TJ
T*
[(a so cal)-3(l)-3(e)3(d g)9(e)3(neral)-3( access si)-3(t)-3(e)3(, whi)-3(c)3(h does not)-3( ask for any)29( aut)-3(h)-1(ent)-3(i)-3(cat)-3(i)-3(on or)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(access code before ent)-4(e)2(ri)-4(ng)8(. Basi)-4(cal)-4(l)-4(y)28(, any)28(one wi)-4(t)-4(h)-2( access t)-4(o)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e I)21(n)-2(t)-4(e)2(rnet)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(would have been able to view the site, which contained g)9(e)3(neral information)]TJ
T*
[(about the club in Missouri as well as a prog)9(ram of events and information)]TJ
T*
[(reg)9(a)3(rding)9( tickets. However, tickets for the Missouri club were not available)]TJ
T*
(for purchase on the site. One would have to call, reserve and pick them up in)Tj
T*
[(Missouri. The court stated that, by)29( simply)29( creating)9( a site, one may)29( be seen)]TJ
T*
(worldwide but such behavior is not equivalent of an act purposefully)Tj
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(di)-4(rect)-4(ed t)-4(o)-2(wards a speci)-4(fi)-4(c forum)-4( st)-4(at)-4(e. The court)-4( al)-4(so hel)-4(d)-2( t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e si)-4(m)-4(p)-2(l)-4(e)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(fact that a person can g)9(a)3(in information on the alleg)9(e)3(dly)29( infring)9(ing)9( product, is)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(not the)4( e)4(quiva)4(le)4(nt of a)4( pe)4(rson a)4(dve)4(rtising)10(,)0( promoting)10(,)0( se)4(lling)10( or othe)4(rwise)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(making)9( an effort to targ)9(et its product )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
14.93 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(L)-8(Q)1(\0031)-12(HZ)-12(\003<)-21(RU)-9(N)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
4.96 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(. Mr.King)9( was apparently)]TJ
-19.89 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(not doing)10( any)30( of that. Mr.King)10(\222)3(s site even contained a disclaimer, stating)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(that The B)6(l)-3(ue Note')9(s)-2( site should not be confused with the B)6(l)-3(ue Note in New)]TJ
T*
[(York. Noteworthy)29( is also that the site contained a hy)29(perlink to B)6(e)3(nsusan\222s)]TJ
T*
0.002 Tc
[(site)6(.)]TJ
0 -2.96 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
113.49 119.19 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 141.81 107.43 Tm
0.007 Tc
(243)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 154.05 101.91 Tm
0 Tc
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.25 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(%HQV)-9(XV)-9(DQ\0035HV)-9(W)-8(DXU)-9(DQW)-8(\003&)-12(RU)-9(S\021\0039\021\0035L)-8(FKDU)-9(G\003%\021\003.)-12(L)-8(Q)1(J)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
18.92 0 TD
0 Tc
[(, 937 F)6(.)0( Supp.)]TJ
-20.19 -1.18 TD
(295 \(S.D.N.Y, Sep 9, 1996\).)Tj
T*
[(Http://www.jmls.edu/cy)30(ber/cases/bensusan.html)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
467 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
468 0 obj
<<
/Length 5710
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(82)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 723.15 Tm
-0.003 Tc
(\024\023\021\025\021\025)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.5128 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
(7KUHH\003IDFWRUV\003GHWHUPLQLQJ\003MXULVGLFWLRQ)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 694.71 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(Bensusan arg)8(u)-2(ed t)-4(h)-2(at)-4(, because Mr.Ki)-4(n)-2(g)8(\222)1(s si)-4(t)-4(e)2( was accessi)-4(bl)-4(e i)-4(n)-2( New York)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(\(and in the rest of the world as well\), he should have foreseen that surfers in)Tj
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(h)-2(e New York area were abl)-4(e)2( t)-4(o)-2( vi)-4(ew t)-4(h)-2(e si)-4(t)-4(e)2(\222s m)-4(a)2(t)-4(e)2(ri)-4(al)-4(. Bensusan t)-4(h)-2(erefore)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(want)-3(ed rest)-3(ri)-3(ct)-3(ed access t)-3(o)-1( t)-3(h)-1(e Mi)-3(ssouri)-3( si)-3(t)-3(e)3( by)29( t)-3(echni)-3(cal)-3( m)-3(eans, al)-3(l)-3(o)-1(wi)-3(ng)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(onl)-4(y)28( users i)-4(n)-2( a cert)-4(a)2(i)-4(n)-2( g)8(e)2(og)8(raphi)-4(c reg)8(i)-4(ons t)-4(o)-2( access t)-4(h)-2(e si)-4(t)-4(e)2(. The court)-4( st)-4(at)-4(ed)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(that solely)29( foreseeability)29( of an in-state consequence and a failure to prevent)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
(that consequence is not sufficient to establish personal jurisdiction. The)Tj
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(court ex)-11(pressed three factors that would be of relevance, when determining)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(whether or not jurisdiction is at hand. F)6(i)-2(rstly)30(, one should ascertain whether)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(or not, the site owner purposefully)29( availed himself of the benefits of the)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(forum state. Secondly)30(,)0( one should take into consideration, whether the site)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(owner\222s conduct or connection with the forum state g)9(a)3(ve reasonable)]TJ
T*
[(ex)-11(pectations of being)9( haled into court there. Thirdly)29(,)-1( one should decide)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(whether or not the site owner has continuous and sy)30(stematic business within)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(the forum.)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 474.15 Tm
-0.003 Tc
(\024\023\021\025\021\026)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.5128 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
($\003JHQHUDO\017\003SDVVLYH\003ZHEVLWH\003DORQH\003FDQQRW\003VXEMHFW\003D)Tj
-3.1197 -1.1795 TD
0 Tc
(ZHE\020HGLWRU\003WR\003RWKHU\003IRUXP\266V\003MXULVGLFWLRQV)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 429.15 Tm
(The court did not find personal jurisdiction in this case, due to the fact that it)Tj
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(was not possible to ascertain any)29( presence in New York, other than the)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(websi)-4(t)-4(e)2(, t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( can be accessed from)-4( al)-4(l)-4( over t)-4(h)-2(e worl)-4(d. Thi)-4(s)-3( case t)-4(h)-2(erefore)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(sug)11(g)11(e)5(sts that )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
5.37 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(PHU)-9(H)1(O)-8(\\)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
2.71 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( a passive website cannot make any)29(one subject to other)]TJ
-8.08 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(forum\222s jurisdic)4(tions. I)23( find it inte)4(re)4(sting)10( tha)4(t)-2( the)4( Ne)4(w York c)4(ourt did not)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(consider any)29( material on the I)22(n)-1(ternet that could be read in New York,)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(subject to jurisdiction. B)7(e)4(nsusan appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(the Second Circuit)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 202.77 335.55 Tm
0.007 Tc
(244)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 215.01 330.03 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(, which in September 1997, dismissed the complaint.)Tj
-8.46 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(The \223New York approach\224 i)-4(s)-3( m)-4(u)-2(ch l)-4(e)2(ss ag)8(g)8(r)1(essi)-4(ve and perhaps a bi)-4(t)-4( m)-4(o)-2(re)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(conservative than the \223Minnesota approach\224. A quote from the New York)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(court, supporting)10( such an arg)10(u)0(ment would be the following)10( tex)-10(t: \224Creating)10( a)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(site, like placing)9( a product into the stream of commerce, may)29( be felt)]TJ
T*
(nationwide--or even worldwide--but, without more, it is not an act)Tj
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(purposeful)-4(l)-4(y)28( di)-4(rect)-4(ed t)-4(o)-2(ward t)-4(h)-2(e forum)-4( st)-4(at)-4(e.\224)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 334.65 250.59 Tm
0.007 Tc
(245)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 346.89 245.07 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
( Of course, one must bear)Tj
-19.45 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(in mind tha)5(t)-1( not a)5(ll the)5( fa)5(c)5(t)-1(s a)5(r)4(e)5( e)5(x)-9(a)5(c)5(tly)31( the)5( sa)5(me)5( in diffe)5(re)5(nt c)5(a)5(s)0(e)5(s)0(, but it is)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(possible to see different kinds of approaches to jurisdiction in different)Tj
T*
(courts.)Tj
0 -6.03 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 133.35 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 141.81 121.59 Tm
0.007 Tc
(244)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 154.05 116.07 Tm
0 Tc
( Http://zeus.bna.com/e-law/ \(980214\))Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 141.81 107.43 Tm
0.007 Tc
(245)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 154.05 101.91 Tm
0 Tc
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.25 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(%HQV)-9(XV)-9(DQ\0035HV)-9(W)-8(DXU)-9(DQW)-8(\003&)-12(RU)-9(S\021\0039\021\0035L)-8(FKDU)-9(G\003%\021\003.)-12(L)-8(Q)1(J)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
18.92 0 TD
0 Tc
[(, 937 F)6(.)0( Supp.)]TJ
-20.19 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(295 \(S.D.N.Y, Sep 9, 1996\), under C. Due Process.)Tj
T*
0 Tc
[(Http://www.jmls.edu/cy)30(ber/cases/bensusan.html)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
469 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
470 0 obj
<<
/Length 5440
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(83)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 741.51 Tm
1 0 0 rg
0.001 Tc
(\024\023\021\026\003)Tj
0 g
2.6617 0 TD
0 Tc
[(+HDUVW\003&RUSRUDWLRQ\021\003Y)21(\021\003$UL\003*ROGEHUJHU)]TJ
10.56 0 0 10.56 439.65 749.07 Tm
0.001 Tc
(\025\027\031)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 696.51 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(This trademark infring)9(ement case from 1997 involves the question whether)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(h)-2(e court)-4( had personal)-4( j)-4(u)-2(ri)-4(sdi)-4(c)2(t)-4(i)-4(on over Gol)-4(dberg)8(er because hi)-4(s I)21(n)-2(t)-4(e)2(rnet)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(websi)-3(t)-3(e)3( was accessi)-3(bl)-3(e t)-3(o, and was el)-3(ect)-3(roni)-3(cal)-3(l)-3(y)29( vi)-3(si)-3(t)-3(e)3(d by)29(, users i)-3(n)-1( New)]TJ
T*
[(York. Hearst Corporation, is the publisher of ESQUI)22(RE Mag)9(a)3(z)-7(i)-3(ne since)]TJ
T*
[(1933. Hearst owns the trademark reg)9(i)-3(stration for the mark ESQUI)22(RE.)]TJ
T*
[(Goldberg)9(er, who lives in New J)-12(e)3(rsey)29( and works in Philadelphia, created a)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
[(website using)9( the I)22(n)-1(ternet domain name \223esquire.com\224. I)22(n)-1( September 1995,)]TJ
T*
[(Goldberg)9(er reg)9(i)-3(stered the above mentioned I)22(n)-1(ternet domain name with)]TJ
T*
[(I)22(n)-1(ternic and in J)-12(une 1996, Goldberg)9(er published his website on the I)22(n)-1(ternet)]TJ
T*
[(at the address Http://www.esqwire.com. Even thoug)9(h no services were y)29(e)3(t)]TJ
T*
[(available on his site, Goldberg)9(er planned to offer law office infrastructure)]TJ
T*
[(network services for attorney)29(s. Thus, he had not sold any)29( products or)]TJ
T*
[(services to any)29(one in New York. I)22(t)-3( was undisputed that New Yorkers as)]TJ
T*
[(well as users from at least 20 various states and 34 foreig)9(n countries had)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
(visited his site.)Tj
0 -2.36 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(I)22(n)-1( May)29( 1996, Hearst broug)9(ht this trademark infring)9(ement action ag)9(ainst)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Goldbe)4(rg)10(e)4(r)3(. I)23(t)-2( wa)4(s c)4(l)-2(a)4(ime)4(d tha)4(t)-2( Goldbe)4(rg)10(e)4(r)3(, by)30( se)4(tting)10( up the)4( we)4(bsite)4( using)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(the above mentioned domain name, infring)9(ed on Hearst')9(s)-2( reg)9(i)-3(stered)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(ESQUI)23(RE and ESQ. trademarks in violation of section 32 of the L)21(a)4(nham)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(Act, 15 U.S.C. \247 1114. Hearst also claimed that it was a matter false)Tj
T*
[(desig)9(n)-1(ation of orig)9(in, false descriptions and representations of fact, unfair)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(competition, dilution as well as deceptive acts and practices. I)23(n)0( J)-11(u)0(ly)30( 1996,)]TJ
T*
[(Goldberg)10(er moved to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction or)]TJ
T*
[(a)4(lte)4(rna)4(tive)4(l)-2(y)30( to tra)4(n)0(sfe)4(r)3( ve)4(nue)4(.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 334.35 Tm
-0.003 Tc
(\024\023\021\026\021\024)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.5128 0 TD
0 Tc
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
($\003ZHEVLWH\003LV\003DQDORJRXV\003WR\003D\003WUDGLWLRQDO\003DGYHUWLVHPHQW)Tj
-3.1197 -1.1795 TD
(LQ\003D\003SDSHU\003PDJD]LQH)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 289.35 Tm
0.001 Tw
[(The court found that Goldberg)9(er\222s ESQUI)22(RE I)22(n)-1(ternet website was)]TJ
T*
[(analog)9(ous to an advertisement in a national publication or mag)9(a)3(z)-7(i)-3(ne and)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(thus did not c)4(onstitute)4( suffic)4(i)-2(e)4(n)0(t c)4(onta)4(c)4(t)-2(s with Ne)4(w York to provide)4( the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(court with personal jurisdiction over Goldberg)9(er for transacting)9( business)]TJ
T*
[(under CPL)20(R)-4( \247 302\(a\)\(1\). This analog)9(y)29( was based upon the view that the)]TJ
T*
[(I)22(n)-1(ternet website in question could be viewed by)29( people all over the world)]TJ
T*
[(but it was not targ)9(eted at the residents of New York or any)29( other particular)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(sta)4(t)-2(e)4(.)0( Ac)4(c)4(o)0(rding)10( to the)4( c)4(ourt, Ne)4(w York la)4(w sa)4(y)30(s)-1( tha)4(t)-2( a)4(dve)4(rtise)4(m)-2(e)4(n)0(ts in)]TJ
T*
(national publications are not sufficient to provide personal jurisdiction under)Tj
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(Section 302\(a\)\(1\).)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 139.59 Tm
-0.003 Tc
(\024\023\021\026\021\025)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.5128 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(-XULVGLFWLRQ\003EDVHG\003XSRQ\003VROHO\\\003D\003ZHEVLWH\003ZRXOG\003FUHDWH)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 108.87 Tm
0 Tc
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 111.99 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 101.19 Tm
(246)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 96.63 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(+HDUVW\003&RUSRUDWLRQ\003&RUS\021\003Y\021\003*ROGEHUJHU)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
16.4578 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(, No. 96 C)9(I)1(V.3620 PKL)14( A)16(J)-4(P,)]TJ
-17.6867 -1.1807 TD
[(1997 WL)14(97097 \(S)7(.D.N.Y F)7(e)3(b 26, 1997\))]TJ
T*
-0.022 Tc
0.025 Tw
[(H)-23(t)-21(t)-21(p)-28(:)-21(/)-21(/)-21(www.)-25(l)-21(j)-33(x)-16(.)-25(c)-24(o)-28(m/)-21(L)-13(J)-31(X)-23(f)-14(i)-21(l)-21(e)-24(s)-19(/)-21(d)-28(o)-28(m)-3(a)-24(i)-21(n)-16(s)-19(u)-16(i)-21(t)-21(s)-19(/)-21(e)-24(s)-19(q)-28(wi)-21(r)-26(e)-24(.)-25(h)-16(t)-21(m)-3(l)-21( \()]TJ
22.8072 0 TD
0.006 Tc
(971012\))Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
471 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
472 0 obj
<<
/Length 6814
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(84)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 743.31 Tm
(ZRUOGZLGH\003MXULVGLFWLRQ)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 714.87 Tm
0 Tw
(The court also stated that if jurisdiction would be found on the website)Tj
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(alone, this would lead to a worldwide personal jurisdiction over any)29(one and)]TJ
T*
[(every)29(one who establishes an I)22(n)-1(ternet website. Such nationwide jurisdiction)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
(would not be consistent with traditional personal jurisdiction case law nor)Tj
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(woul)-4(d i)-4(t)-4( be accept)-4(a)2(bl)-4(e t)-4(o)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e court)-4( as a m)-4(a)2(t)-4(t)-4(e)2(r of pol)-4(i)-4(c)2(y)28(.)-2( The j)-4(udg)8(e sai)-4(d)-2( t)-4(h)-2(at)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Hearst mig)9(ht have placed itself in a catch 22 situation. I)22(f)2( Hearst would have)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(waited until Goldberg)10(er contracted to sell his attorney)30( support services to)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(New Yorkers, long)9(-arm jurisdiction)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 285.09 621.27 Tm
0.007 Tc
(247)Tj
12 0 0 12 297.33 615.75 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[( mig)9(ht have been appropriate. Hearst)]TJ
-15.32 -1.18 TD
[(did not wait long)9( enoug)9(h. The judg)9(e recommended that an out-of-state)]TJ
T*
[(creation of an I)22(n)-1(ternet website that is accessible in New York, alone, should)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
(not provide personal jurisdiction.)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 550.95 Tm
-0.003 Tc
(\024\023\021\026\021\026)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.5128 0 TD
0 Tc
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
($\003ZHEVLWH\003GLUHFWHG\003DW\003WKH\003ZKROH\003ZRUOG\003FRXOG\003EH)Tj
-3.1197 -1.1795 TD
(HTXLYDOHQW\003RI\003D\003QDWLRQDO\003PDJD]LQH)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 505.95 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(One can see t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( bot)-4(h i)-4(n)-2( )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
9.87 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(%HQV)-10(XV)-10(DQ)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
3.83 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( and in )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
2.97 0 TD
0.004 Tc
[(+)7(H)10(D)10(UVW)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
2.72 0 TD
0 Tc
(, the websites did not)Tj
-19.39 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(speci)-4(fi)-4(cal)-4(l)-4(y)28( di)-4(rect)-4( t)-4(h)-2(em)-4(sel)-4(v)-2(es at)-4( users i)-4(n)-2( New York, and t)-4(h)-2(erefore t)-4(h)-2(e court)-4(s)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(did not find personal jurisdiction. These cases sug)10(g)10(e)4(st that a website alone,)]TJ
T*
[(should not be enoug)10(h to establish jurisdiction. Only)30( when a website is aimed)]TJ
T*
[(towards a specific state, it will be enoug)10(h to g)10(r)3(ant jurisdiction. I)23(f)3( the site is)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(ai)-4(m)-4(e)2(d at)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e whol)-4(e worl)-4(d i)-4(t)-4( coul)-4(d, accordi)-4(n)-2(g)8( t)-4(o)-2( )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
19.13 0 TD
0.004 Tc
[(+)7(H)10(D)10(UVW)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
2.72 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(, be equivalent of an)Tj
-21.85 -1.18 TD
[(advertisement in a national mag)9(a)3(z)-7(i)-3(ne, which often is not considered as being)]TJ
T*
[(a contact sufficient for establishing)9( personal jurisdiction. F)5(r)2(om this, one can)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
(conclude that it is better \(from the web-editor\222s view\) to use a passive)Tj
T*
[(g)9(e)3(neral site, which focuses on one jurisdiction only)29(,)-1( or a g)9(e)3(neral site which)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(is directed towards all countries. Then, it mig)10(ht be classified as an)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(a)5(dve)5(rtise)5(m)-1(e)5(n)1(t in a)5( ma)5(g)11(a)5(zine)5( a)5(nd e)5(n)1(joy)31( the)5( a)5(dva)5(nta)5(g)11(e)5(s)0( tha)5(t)-1( c)5(o)1(me)5( with it.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 326.43 Tm
0 Tc
[(\024\023\021\027\003)-434(&\\)11(EHUVHOO\017\003,QF\021\017\003Y)21(\021)0(\003&\\)11(E)0(HUVHOO\017\003,QF\021)]TJ
10.56 0 0 10.56 398.01 333.99 Tm
0.001 Tc
(\025\027\033)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 295.59 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(This case from December 1997 involved alleg)9(e)3(d infring)9(ing)9( use of a service)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(m)-4(a)2(rk used i)-4(n)-2( a hom)-4(epag)8(e. C)-5(y)28(bersel)-4(l)-4(,)-2( I)21(n)-2(c. \(hereaft)-4(e)2(r referred t)-4(o)-2( as C)-5(y)28(bersel)-4(l)]TJ
T*
[(AZ)9(\))]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 133.29 272.79 Tm
0.007 Tc
(249)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 145.53 267.27 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( situa)5(t)-1(e)5(d)1( in Arizona)5(, c)5(l)-1(a)5(ime)5(d tha)5(t)-1( Cy)31(be)5(rse)5(ll, I)24(n)1(c)5(.)1( in F)7(l)-1(orida)5( \(he)5(r)4(e)5(a)5(f)4(te)5(r)]TJ
-2.67 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(referred to as C)-5(y)28(bersell FL)19(\))]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 245.73 258.63 Tm
0.007 Tc
(250)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 257.97 253.11 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( infring)9(ed its federally)29( reg)9(i)-3(stered mark)]TJ
-12.04 -1.18 TD
[(\223Cy)29(b)-1(ersell\224 by)29( posting)9( a log)9(o)-1( on the website say)29(i)-3(ng)9( \223W)-7(elcome to)]TJ
T*
[(Cy)29(bersell!\224. The main question was whether such an infring)9(ement in a)]TJ
0 -1.6 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 208.71 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 197.91 Tm
(247)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 193.35 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.004 Tw
[( T)-17(h)5(e lo)-7(ng-)7(arm)18( p)-7(r)-5(o)-7(v)5(isio)-7(n p)-7(r)-5(o)-7(v)5(id)-7(es j)-12(u)5(risd)-7(ictio)-7(n o)-7(v)5(er a d)-7(e)-3(f)7(e)-3(nd)-7(ant w)22(h)5(o)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
[(co)-7(m)18(m)18(its to)-7(rtio)-7(us acts o)-7(u)5(tsid)-7(e New)22( Yo)-7(rk causing inj)-12(u)5(ry)17( in the state.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 141.81 173.43 Tm
0.007 Tc
(248)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 154.05 167.91 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.25 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(&)-12(\\EHU)-9(V)-9(H)1(O)-8(O)-8(\003)-2(,QF\021\017\003Y\021\003&)-12(\\EHU)-9(V)-9(H)1(O)-8(O)-8(\003)-2(,QF\021)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12.64 0 TD
0 Tc
( No. 96-17087 D.C. No. CV-)Tj
-13.91 -1.18 TD
[(96-00089-EHC filed Dec.2, 1997. Http://cg)10(i)-2(.ljx)-10(.com/cg)10(i)-2(-)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
[(bin/f_cat?)-17(/)-3(prod/ljex)-11(t)-3(ra/data/ex)-11(ternal/1997/12/9712004.c09)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
(\(980112\))Tj
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 117.75 Tm
(249)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 113.19 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.004 Tw
[( Cy)17(b)-7(e)-3(rsell A)10(Z)8( p)-7(r)-5(o)-7(v)5(id)-7(ed)-7( Internet and)-7( W)-9(e)-3(b)-7( ad)-7(vertising and)-7( m)18(a)-3(rketing)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
0.001 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(serv)7(ices as w)24(e)-1(ll as con)7(s)4(u)7(ltin)7(g)7(.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 141.81 93.27 Tm
0.007 Tc
(250)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 154.05 87.75 Tm
0 Tc
0.45 Tw
[( Cy)30(be)4(rse)4(ll F)6(L)21( provide)4(d )-10(busine)4(ss-c)4(onsulting)10( )-10(se)4(rvic)4(e)4(s)-1( )-10(for)]TJ
-1.02 -1.18 TD
0 Tw
[(stra)4(te)4(g)10(i)-2(c)4( ma)4(na)4(g)10(e)4(me)4(nt a)4(nd ma)4(rke)4(ting)10( on the)4( we)4(b.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
473 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
474 0 obj
<<
/Length 5725
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(85)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
0 Tw
[(we)4(bsite)4( sole)4(ly)30( is suffic)4(i)-2(e)4(n)0(t for pe)4(rsona)4(l jurisdic)4(tion in the)4( sta)4(t)-2(e)4( whe)4(r)3(e)4( the)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(hol)-4(der of t)-4(h)-2(e m)-4(a)2(rk has i)-4(t)-4(s)-3( pri)-4(n)-2(ci)-4(pal)-4( pl)-4(ace of busi)-4(n)-2(ess. Ex)-12(cept)-4( for t)-4(h)-2(e websi)-4(t)-4(e)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Cy)30(bersell F)6(L)21( had no other contacts with Ariz)-6(ona.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
[(Cy)30(bersell AZ)11( filed a complaint J)-11(a)4(nuary)30( 9, 1996 in the District of Ariz)-6(ona,)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(a)5(lle)5(g)11(i)-1(ng)11( tra)5(d)1(e)5(m)-1(a)5(r)4(k infring)11(e)5(m)-1(e)5(n)1(t. On the)5( sa)5(me)5( da)5(y)31( Cy)31(be)5(rse)5(ll F)7(L)22( file)5(d suit for)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(de)4(c)4(l)-2(a)4(r)3(a)4(t)-2(ory)30( re)4(lie)4(f with re)4(g)10(a)4(rd to use)4( of the)4( na)4(me)4( \223)4(C)-3(y)30(b)0(e)4(r)3(se)4(ll\224)4( in the)4( U.S.)]TJ
T*
[(District Court for the Middle District of F)6(l)-2(orida, but that action was)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(transferred to the District of Ariz)-7(ona and consolidated with the Cy)29(bersell)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(AZ)11( action. Cy)30(bersell F)6(L)21( moved to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction.)]TJ
T*
[(The)4( distric)4(t)-2( c)4(ourt de)4(nie)4(d)0( Cy)30(be)4(rse)4(ll AZ)11(\222s re)4(que)4(st for a)4( pre)4(limina)4(r)3(y)]TJ
T*
[(injunction, and g)10(r)3(anted Cy)30(bersell F)6(L)21(\222s motion to dismiss for lack of)]TJ
T*
[(personal jurisdiction. Cy)30(bersell AZ)11( appealed.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 553.23 Tm
-0.003 Tc
(\024\023\021\027\021\024)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.5128 0 TD
0 Tc
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(7KUHH\020SDUW\003WHVW\003LQ\003RUGHU\003WR\003H[HUFLVH\003VSHFLILF)Tj
-3.1197 -1.1795 TD
0 Tc
(MXULVGLFWLRQ)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 508.23 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(The Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit used a three-part test to)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(de)4(te)4(rmine)4( if it wa)4(s possible)4( to e)4(x)-10(e)4(r)3(c)4(i)-2(se)4( spe)4(c)4(i)-2(fic)4( jurisdic)4(tion ove)4(r the)]TJ
T*
(nonresident defendant in this situation. The first requirement was that the)Tj
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(nonresident had performed an act by)29( which he purposefully)29( availed himself)]TJ
T*
[(of the privileg)9(e)3( of conducting)9( activities in the forum. The second)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(re)4(quire)4(me)4(nt wa)4(s tha)4(t)-2( the)4( c)4(l)-2(a)4(im must ha)4(ve)4( a)4(r)3(ise)4(n)0( from this forum-re)4(la)4(te)4(d)]TJ
T*
[(a)4(c)4(tivity)30(. The)4( third re)4(quire)4(me)4(nt wa)4(s tha)4(t)-2( the)4( e)4(x)-10(e)4(r)3(c)4(i)-2(se)4( of jurisdic)4(tion wa)4(s)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(consi)-4(d)-2(ered reasonabl)-4(e.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 386.79 Tm
(\024\023\021\027\021\025)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.5128 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(6ROHO\\\003D\003ZHEVLWH\003GLG\003QRW\003WULJJHU\003MXULVGLFWLRQ)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 358.35 Tm
0 Tc
[(Cy)30(bersell F)6(L)21( contended that a party)30( should not be subject to nationwide, or)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(pe)4(rha)4(p)0(s worldwide)4(,)0( jurisdic)4(tion simply)30( for using)10( the)4( I)23(n)0(te)4(rne)4(t)-2(. The)4( c)4(ourt)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(stated that no court it knew of had ever held that an I)22(n)-1(ternet advertisement)]TJ
T*
(alone was sufficient to subject the advertiser to jurisdiction in the plaintiff\222s)Tj
T*
[(home state. Cy)29(bersell AZ)10( claimed that a defendant should not be permitted)]TJ
T*
[(to take advantag)9(e of modern technolog)9(y)29( throug)9(h an I)22(n)-1(ternet website and)]TJ
T*
[(simultaneously)29( escape traditional notions of jurisdiction. The court referred)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(to the)5( )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
2.5 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(=)-12(L)-9(SSR\003)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
2.59 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(case and stated that the likelihood that personal jurisdiction can)Tj
-5.09 -1.18 TD
[(be constitutionally)29( ex)-11(ercised is directly)29( proportionate to the nature and)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(quality)30( of commercial activity)30( that an entity)30( conducts over the I)23(n)0(ternet.)]TJ
T*
[(Cy)30(bersell F)6(L)21( had not conducted any)30( commercial activity)30( throug)10(h the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(I)22(n)-1(ternet in Ariz)-7(ona. Ex)-11(cept for Cy)29(bersell AZ)10(, nobody)29( from Ariz)-7(ona had ever)]TJ
T*
(visited the site. The website was passive, as in )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
18.73 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(%HQV)-10(XV)-10(DQ\003)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
4.08 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(and no 800-)Tj
-22.81 -1.18 TD
(telephone number was posted on it, as in )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
16.51 0 TD
0.003 Tc
[(,)10(Q)9(VH)9(W\003)6(6)9(\\)9(V)-1(WH)9(P)6(V)-1(\021)6(\003)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
5.85 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(The court applied)Tj
-22.36 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(the \223minimum contacts\224 analy)30(s)-1(is, and concluded that it would not comport)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(wi)-3(t)-3(h)-1( \223t)-3(radi)-3(t)-3(i)-3(onal)-3( not)-3(i)-3(ons of fai)-3(r)2( pl)-3(ay)29( and subst)-3(a)3(nt)-3(i)-3(a)3(l)-3( j)-3(u)-1(st)-3(i)-3(ce\224 for Ari)-3(z)-7(ona t)-3(o)]TJ
T*
[(ex)-11(ercise personal jurisdiction over an alleg)9(e)3(dly)29( infring)9(ing)9( F)5(l)-3(orida website)]TJ
T*
[(advertiser who had no contacts with Ariz)-7(ona other than maintaining)9( a home)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(pag)8(e)2( t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( was accessi)-4(bl)-4(e t)-4(o)-2( Ari)-4(z)-8(onans, and every)28(one el)-4(se, vi)-4(a t)-4(h)-2(e I)21(n)-2(t)-4(e)2(rnet)-4(.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
475 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
477 0 obj
<<
/Length 3148
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(86)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 743.31 Tm
-0.003 Tc
(\024\023\021\027\021\026)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.5128 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
($\003SDVVLYH\003VLWH\003ZLWK\003QR\003FRPPHUFLDO\003DFWLYLWLHV\003UHODWLQJ)Tj
-3.1197 -1.1795 TD
(WR\003WKH\003MXULVGLFWLRQ)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 698.31 Tm
0.001 Tw
[(The court did not have to g)9(o)-1( any)29( further than the first part in the three-part)]TJ
T*
[(test for specific jurisdiction. I)22(t)-3( concluded that the passive nature of Cy)29(bersell)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(F)7(L)22(\222s a)5(c)5(tivity)31( in posting)11( a)5( home)5(p)1(a)5(g)11(e)5( tha)5(t)-1( a)5(lle)5(g)11(e)5(dly)31( use)5(d)1( the)5( se)5(rvic)5(e)5( ma)5(rk of)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Cy)30(bersell AZ)11( did not qualify)30( as purposeful activity)30( invoking)10( the benefits and)]TJ
T*
[(protections of Ariz)-6(ona. As it eng)10(a)4(g)10(e)4(d in no commercial activity)30( and had no)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(other contacts via the I)22(n)-1(ternet or otherwise in Ariz)-7(ona, Cy)29(bersell F)5(L)20( lacked)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(suffic)4(i)-2(e)4(n)0(t minimum c)4(onta)4(c)4(t)-2(s with Arizona)4( for pe)4(rsona)4(l jurisdic)4(tion to be)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(asserted over it. The court said that Cy)29(bersell F)5(L)20(\222s contacts were insufficient)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(to e)4(s)-1(ta)4(blish \223)4(purpose)4(f)3(ul a)4(v)0(a)4(ilme)4(nt\224)4( a)4(nd de)4(c)4(line)4(d)0( to g)10(o)0( a)4(n)0(y)30( furthe)4(r in the)]TJ
T*
-0.003 Tc
(case.)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 548.55 Tm
(\024\023\021\027\021\027)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.5128 0 TD
0 Tc
(\003)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.6068 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(0)23(F)-1(\021'RQRXJK\003Y\021\003\))6(DOORQ\0030)23(F)-1(\(OOLJRWW\017\003,)-8(QF\021)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 388.53 555.03 Tm
0.004 Tc
(251)Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 546.99 35.04 -1.2 re
f
BT
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 520.11 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(A photog)9(rapher, Mc.Donoug)9(h, sued F)5(a)3(llon for misappropriation of his)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(work. Fal)-3(l)-3(on soug)9(ht)-3( t)-3(o)-1( have t)-3(h)-1(e proceedi)-3(n)-1(g)9(s)-2( di)-3(sm)-3(i)-3(ssed for l)-3(ack of personal)]TJ
T*
(jurisdiction. The mere fact that Fallon\222s site could be accessed by)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Californians, was not by)30( itself, enoug)10(h to establish jurisdiction. The mere)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(creation of a website does not provide the necessary)29( minimum contacts with)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(a)4( forum sta)4(t)-2(e)4( to g)10(i)-2(ve)4( rise)4( to jurisdic)4(tion the)4(r)3(e)4(.)]TJ
0 -29.35 TD
( )Tj
ET
113.49 100.23 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
(251)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 84.87 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(0F\021'RQRXJK\003Y\021\003\)DOORQ\0030F\(OOLJRWW\017\003,QF)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
15.5181 0 TD
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[(. 40 U.S)7(.)2(P.Q.2d 1826 S)7(D)4( C)9(a)3(l)6(.)]TJ
-16.747 -1.1807 TD
[(\(A)16(u)11(g)11(.)2( 5, 1996\))]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
478 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F5 276 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
479 0 obj
<<
/Length 6181
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(87)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
24 0 0 24 113.49 733.71 Tm
[(\024\024\003)-310(&RQFOXVLRQ\003UHJDUGLQJ\003WKH)]TJ
0 -1.175 TD
(FDVHV\003LQYROYLQJ\003MXULVGLFWLRQ)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 665.07 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Even thoug)9(h the circumstances have not been ex)-11(actly)29( the same in all the)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(cases above, it may)29( be possible to perceive a pattern developing)9( during)9( 1996)]TJ
T*
[(and 1997. One may)29( try)29( to g)9(e)3(neraliz)-7(e the various circumstances in the cases)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(a)4(nd se)4(e)4( if the)4(r)3(e)4( e)4(x)-10(ists a)4(n)0(y)30( inte)4(re)4(sting)10( le)4(g)10(a)4(l solutions re)4(g)10(a)4(rding)10( I)23(n)0(te)4(rne)4(t)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(related jurisdiction issues that can be applied in possible future cases. W)-7(h)-1(at)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(should the perfect website look like, in order to avoid being)10( subject to)]TJ
T*
(jurisdiction in unwanted states or countries?)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 556.35 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(\024\024\021\024\003)-435(,QWHUDFWLY)20(LW\\)10(\003)1(DQG\003SDVVLY)20(L)1(W\\)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 525.51 Tm
0.001 Tw
[(Merely)29( a passive g)9(e)3(neral access website cannot make a web-editor subject to)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
[(ot)-3(her forum)-3(\222)2(s j)-3(u)-1(ri)-3(sdi)-3(c)3(t)-3(i)-3(ons, accordi)-3(n)-1(g)9( t)-3(o)-1( t)-3(h)-1(e )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
17.83 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(%HQV)-10(XV)-10(DQ)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
3.83 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( court in 1996. This)Tj
-21.66 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(reasoning)9( was ex)-11(panded by)29( the )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
12.69 0 TD
0.004 Tc
[(+)7(H)10(D)10(UVW)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
2.72 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( court in 1997. A website may)30( be)]TJ
-15.41 -1.18 TD
[(considered analog)10(ous to an advertisement in a national publication or)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(ma)5(g)11(a)5(zine)5(, whic)5(h g)11(e)5(ne)5(ra)5(lly)31( is insuffic)5(i)-1(e)5(n)1(t to e)5(x)-9(e)5(r)4(c)5(i)-1(se)5( pe)5(rsona)5(l jurisdic)5(tion)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(over the defendant. W)-7(o)-1(rldwide jurisdiction as an effect of a website alone,)]TJ
T*
[(woul)-3(d not)-3( be consi)-3(s)-2(t)-3(e)3(nt)-3( wi)-3(t)-3(h)-1( t)-3(r)2(adi)-3(t)-3(i)-3(onal)-3( personal)-3( case l)-3(a)3(w, accordi)-3(n)-1(g)9( t)-3(o)-1( t)-3(h)-1(e)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
T*
0.004 Tc
[(+)7(H)10(D)10(UVW)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
2.72 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
( court. The )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
4.6 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(&)-13(\\EHU)-10(V)-10(H)0(O)-9(O)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
3.83 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
( court stated in December 1997, as in )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
15.11 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(%HQV)-10(XV)-10(DQ)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
3.83 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(,)Tj
-30.09 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(that a passive site should not be enoug)9(h in order to ex)-11(ercise jurisdiction.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
[(I)22(n)-1( the beg)9(i)-3(nning)9( of 1996, the )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
11.81 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(7)-11(KRPDV)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
3.17 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( court basically)30( said that posting)]TJ
-14.98 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(obscene material on a website, and allowing)9( users in remote jurisdictions to)]TJ
T*
[(access t)-3(h)-1(at)-3( m)-3(a)3(t)-3(e)3(ri)-3(al)-3(, i)-3(s)-2( equi)-3(val)-3(e)3(nt)-3( of t)-3(r)2(ansport)-3(i)-3(n)-1(g)9( and di)-3(st)-3(ri)-3(but)-3(i)-3(n)-1(g)9( such)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(ma)4(te)4(ria)4(l)-2( to the)4( re)4(mote)4( jurisdic)4(tions. This is, howe)4(v)0(e)4(r)3(, a)4( ve)4(ry)30( va)4(g)10(u)0(e)4( a)4(n)0(d)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(incomplete ex)-11(planation. There should have been a more detailed ex)-11(planation)]TJ
T*
[(of what role the active downloading)9( user play)29(s in such a situation.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
(Even if a website is passive, a court \(as the )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
17.38 0 TD
0.002 Tc
[(0D)8(ULW])]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
2.67 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( court in 1996\) may)30( find)]TJ
-20.05 -1.18 TD
(that the intent of the site-owner is to conduct future business with users from)Tj
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(foreig)9(n jurisdictions. A court may)29( decide that the website functions as a)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(c)4(onta)4(c)4(t)-2( \(with the)4( pote)4(n)0(tia)4(l c)4(u)0(stome)4(r)3(s\) of suc)4(h)0( a)4( qua)4(lity)30( tha)4(t)-2( it fa)4(vors the)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(ex)-11(ercise of personal jurisdiction. I)22(n)-1( 1997 the )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
18.07 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(=)-12(L)-9(SSR)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
2.34 0 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( c)5(ourt ba)5(sic)5(a)5(lly)31( sa)5(id tha)5(t)]TJ
-20.41 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(in order to avoid jurisdiction, a website should contain as few interactive)Tj
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(e)5(l)-1(e)5(m)-1(e)5(n)1(ts a)5(s)0( possible)5(.)1( I)24(f)4( the)5( site)5( is c)5(o)1(mple)5(te)5(ly)31( pa)5(ssive)5( \(a)5(s in )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
23.87 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(%HQV)-10(XV)-10(DQ)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
3.83 0 TD
0.001 Tc
(\) it is)Tj
-27.7 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(not lia)4(ble)4( in othe)4(r jurisdic)4(tions until a)4( c)4(e)4(r)3(ta)4(in numbe)4(r of sa)4(le)4(s oc)4(c)4(u)0(r, or)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(contractual relationships are established in a specific jurisdiction. The )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
28.12 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(=)-12(L)-9(SSR)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
-28.12 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(court further stated that by)29( vending)9( services via the I)22(n)-1(ternet to residents in a)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(foreig)10(n jurisdiction, it is not a question of advertising)10( any)30( more. A sing)10(le)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(act)-4(i)-4(v)-2(e cont)-4(act)-4( wi)-4(t)-4(h)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e forei)-4(g)8(n j)-4(u)-2(ri)-4(sdi)-4(c)2(t)-4(i)-4(on i)-4(n)-2( C)-5(y)28(berspace can l)-4(ead t)-4(o)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
(jurisdiction. This is also the opinion of the )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
17.2 0 TD
0.003 Tc
[(')6(L)0(J)9(LWD)9(O\003)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
3.09 0 TD
0 Tc
(court in 1997. An)Tj
-20.29 -1.18 TD
[(a)4(dve)4(rtising)10( we)4(bsite)4( a)4(nd thre)4(e)4( sa)4(le)4(s to c)4(u)0(stome)4(r)3(s in a)4( fore)4(ig)10(n jurisdic)4(tion wa)4(s)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(a sig)9(n)-1( of continuing)9( business contacts with that state. A clear messag)9(e)3( was)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
480 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
481 0 obj
<<
/Length 5811
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(88)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
0 Tw
[(that if one wants to conduct business in Cy)30(berspace, one must consider the)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(risks of having)9( to travel to a court in another state.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 707.55 Tm
0 Tc
[(\024\024\021\025\003)-434('LVFODLPHUV)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 676.71 Tm
0 Tw
[(I)23(f)3( a)4( we)4(bsite)4( owne)4(r posts a)4( disc)4(la)4(ime)4(r in orde)4(r to a)4(void lia)4(bility)30( in fore)4(ig)10(n)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(jurisdic)5(tions, a)5(s)0( in the)5( )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
9.03 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(0L)-8(QQHV)-9(RW)-8(D)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
4.22 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( case from 1996, it may)30( not be enoug)10(h to)]TJ
-13.25 -1.18 TD
[(avoid jurisdiction. I)23(t)-2( is unfortunate that the Minnesota court did not specify)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(h)-2(e reasons for not)-4( accept)-4(i)-4(n)-2(g)8( such an arrang)8(em)-4(ent)-4(.)-2( W)-8(i)-4(t)-4(h)-2( such a rest)-4(ri)-4(ct)-4(i)-4(v)-2(e)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(a)4(ttitude)4(, a)4(s)-1( in Minne)4(sota)4(, it se)4(e)4(m)-2(s diffic)4(u)0(lt for fore)4(ig)10(n we)4(bsite)4( owne)4(rs to)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(foresee the consequences and abstain from actions that may)29( lead to being)]TJ
T*
(hauled into court there.)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 567.99 Tm
[(\024\024\021\026\003)-435($Y)20(DLOLQJ\003RQHVHOI\003RI\003WKH\003SULY)20(LOHJH\003RI)]TJ
T*
[(FRQGXFWLQJ\003EXVLQHVV\003Z)-15(L)1(WKLQ\003WKH\003IRUHLJQ)]TJ
T*
(MXULVGLFWLRQ)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 499.47 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Another interesting)10( issue is that of accessibility)30( to a website. I)23(f)3( one has a)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(password-secured website and refuses to supply)29( passwords to users in)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(fore)5(ig)11(n jurisdic)5(tions, one)5( c)5(e)5(r)4(ta)5(inly)31( diminishe)5(s the)5( risk of lia)5(bility)31( in those)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(j)-3(u)-1(ri)-3(sdi)-3(c)3(t)-3(i)-3(ons. I)22(f)2( one i)-3(n)-1(t)-3(e)3(nt)-3(i)-3(onal)-3(l)-3(y)29( g)9(i)-3(ves forei)-3(g)9(n users access t)-3(o)-1( a si)-3(t)-3(e)3(, a court)]TJ
T*
[(m)-3(a)3(y)29( presum)-3(e, as i)-3(n)-1( t)-3(h)-1(e )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
9.4 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(7)-11(KRPDV)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
3.17 0 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[( case, t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( t)-4(h)-2(e websi)-4(t)-4(e)2( owner has a cl)-4(ear)]TJ
-12.57 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(inte)4(ntion to a)4(v)0(a)4(il himse)4(l)-2(f to the)4( fore)4(ig)10(n ma)4(rke)4(t)-2(. Othe)4(r c)4(ourts, a)4(s)-1( the)4( )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
27.18 0 TD
-0.007 Tc
[(,QV)-11(H)-1(W)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
-27.18 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(court, may)29( be even more string)9(ent and state that the mere posting)9( of an)]TJ
T*
[(advertisement tog)9(e)3(ther with an 800 number on a website is equivalent of)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(purpose)4(f)3(ully)30( a)4(v)0(a)4(iling)10( one)4(se)4(lf to the)4( privile)4(g)10(e)4( of doing)10( busine)4(ss in fore)4(ig)10(n)]TJ
T*
[(jurisdic)4(tions. Ac)4(c)4(o)0(rding)10( to the)4( )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
12.4 0 TD
-0.007 Tc
[(,QV)-11(H)-1(W)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
1.94 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
( court, the number of users from the)Tj
-14.34 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(foreig)10(n jurisdiction actually)30( visiting)10( the site or calls the 800 number is of)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(subordinated importance. The )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
12.2 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(+HU)-9(RHV)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
2.88 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( court found in 1996 that if a website)Tj
-15.08 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(is not the sole contact with a foreig)9(n jurisdiction, the website owner may)29( be)]TJ
T*
[(liable in a foreig)9(n jurisdiction. The combination of a website and a)]TJ
T*
[(newspaper advertisement, which can be read in the foreig)9(n jurisdiction, may)]TJ
T*
[(demonstrate that one has purposefully)29( availed oneself of the privileg)9(e)3( of)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(conducting)10( activities within the jurisdiction and therefore should anticipate)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(be)5(ing)11( ha)5(le)5(d into c)5(ourt the)5(r)4(e)5(.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 234.99 Tm
0 Tc
[(\024\024\021\027\003)-434(7KH\003SK\\)11(VLFDO\003ORFDWLRQ\003RI\003VHUY)21(HUV\003DQG)]TJ
T*
(GDWDEDVHV)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 185.31 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(As early)29( as in 1994, the )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
9.65 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(3U)-10(HV)-10(\020.)-13(DS)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
3.83 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
[( court discussed the irrelevance of phy)29(sical)]TJ
-13.48 -1.18 TD
[(locations of servers and databases. According)9( to the court, contacts based on)]TJ
T*
(transactions via a computer network, when the defendant is unaware of the)Tj
T*
(location of the electronic transaction, i.e. the server or database location, do)Tj
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(not c)5(onstitute)5( minimum c)5(onta)5(c)5(t)-1(s. Se)5(ve)5(ra)5(l c)5(ourts, suc)5(h)1( a)5(s)0( the)5( )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
24.4 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(3O)-8(D\\ER\\)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
3.27 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
( court)Tj
-27.67 -1.18 TD
(and the )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
3.16 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(&)-13(R)0(PSX6HU)-10(YH)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
5.1 0 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[( court)-4(,)-2( have rej)-4(ect)-4(ed t)-4(h)-2(i)-4(s)-3( i)-4(d)-2(ea. I)21(f)1( one pl)-4(aces i)-4(n)-2(form)-4(at)-4(i)-4(o)-2(n)]TJ
-8.26 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(on a foreig)9(n server situated in e.g)9(.)-1( Europe, U.S. courts may)29( find that one is)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(di)-4(st)-4(ri)-4(but)-4(i)-4(n)-2(g)8( t)-4(h)-2(e m)-4(a)2(t)-4(e)2(ri)-4(al)-4( i)-4(n)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e U.S)-6(., accordi)-4(n)-2(g)8( t)-4(o)-2( t)-4(h)-2(e )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
21.3 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(3O)-8(D\\ER\\)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
3.27 0 TD
-0.002 Tc
( case from)Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
482 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
483 0 obj
<<
/Length 4593
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(89)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(1996. The phy)29(sical placement of a server seemed to be of less importance.)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Ac)4(c)4(o)0(rding)10( to the)4( c)4(ourt it se)4(e)4(m)-2(s irre)4(le)4(va)4(nt whe)4(t)-2(he)4(r the)4( informa)4(tion is store)4(d)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(in Europe or in the U.S. I)22(f)2( one, however, blocks users located in the U.S.)]TJ
T*
[(from)-3( accessi)-3(ng)9( t)-3(h)-1(e si)-3(t)-3(e)3(, one woul)-3(d not)-3( be consi)-3(d)-1(ered di)-3(st)-3(ri)-3(but)-3(i)-3(n)-1(g)9( m)-3(a)3(t)-3(e)3(ri)-3(al)-3( i)-3(n)]TJ
T*
[(the U.S. and one would not be liable there. Completely)29( different sig)9(n)-1(als)]TJ
T*
(were sent from the )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
7.7 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(&)-13(R)0(PSX6HU)-10(YH)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
5.1 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
( court in 1996. The court focused)Tj
-12.8 -1.18 TD
[(tenaciously)29( upon the server location, but I)22( believe that courts are beg)9(i)-3(nning)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(to c)4(o)0(mpre)4(he)4(nd tha)4(t)-2( it re)4(a)4(lly)30( doe)4(s not ma)4(tte)4(r a)4(n)0(y)30( long)10(e)4(r)3(, whe)4(r)3(e)4( the)4( se)4(rve)4(r)3( is)]TJ
T*
[(phy)30(sically)30( located. I)23(f)3( courts would adamantly)30( stick to the server location in)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(order to find personal jurisdiction, I)22( believe that server havens will be the)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(nex)-10(t)-2( move in order to avoid jurisdiction. I)23(f)3( one enters into contract with)]TJ
T*
[(residents of foreig)10(n jurisdictions and knowing)10(l)-2(y)30( transmits files repeatedly)30(,)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(jurisdiction may)29( be proper.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
[(I)22(f)2( a person sy)29(stematically)29( snatches domain names on the I)22(n)-1(ternet in order to)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
0 -1.18 TD
[(hurt a party)29( in a foreig)9(n jurisdiction, a court may)29( use the \223effects doctrine\224)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(as t)-4(h)-2(e )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
2.55 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(3DQDYL)-9(V)-10(R)0(Q)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
4.22 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( court did in 1996. Since it is a matter of intentionally)Tj
-6.77 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(directing)9( a crime towards victims in another jurisdiction, a court may)29( find)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(tha)4(t)-2( the)4( pe)4(rson is fully)30( a)4(w)2(a)4(r)3(e)4( of the)4( fa)4(c)4(t)-2( tha)4(t)-2( the)4( ha)4(rmful e)4(ffe)4(c)4(t)-2(s will re)4(sult in)]TJ
T*
[(that foreig)10(n jurisdiction, and g)10(r)3(ant jurisdiction over him.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 452.67 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(\024\024\021\030\003)-435(\(\020PDLO\003FRQWDFWV)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 421.83 Tm
0.001 Tw
[(I)22(f)2( one does not utilize a website but a couple of e-mail messag)9(e)3(s and a few)]TJ
T*
(telephone calls that are not random or accidental, in order to contact persons)Tj
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(in othe)5(r jurisdic)5(tions, it ma)5(y)31(,)1( a)5(s)0( in the)5( )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
15.36 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(&)-13(RG\\)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
2.11 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
( case from 1997, fulfill the)Tj
-17.47 -1.18 TD
[(re)4(quire)4(me)4(nt of minimum c)4(onta)4(c)4(t)-2(s. This wa)4(s a)4(l)-2(so the)4( c)4(a)4(s)-1(e)4( in the)4( )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
25.69 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(+DO)-8(O)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
1.78 0 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
( case)Tj
-27.47 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(from 1997. The court stated that phy)29(sical presence is not determinative any)]TJ
T*
[(long)9(er. I)22(n)-1(tentional and sy)29(stematic e-mail contacts and telephone calls were)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(enoug)10(h to demand the party)30( to answer in the foreig)10(n jurisdiction. I)23(n)0( the)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
T*
0.004 Tc
[(/LS)10(V)0(LW])]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
2.68 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( case from 1997, e-mail contacts in discussion g)9(r)2(oups were enoug)9(h to)]TJ
-2.68 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(e)5(s)0(ta)5(blish jurisdic)5(tion in the)5( sta)5(t)-1(e)5( in whic)5(h the)5( \223)5(c)5(r)4(imina)5(l)-1(\224)5( wa)5(s phy)31(sic)5(a)5(lly)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(loc)4(a)4(t)-2(e)4(d. Tha)4(t)-2( prove)4(s tha)4(t)-2( the)4( I)23(n)0(te)4(rne)4(t)-2( is not a)4( ha)4(ve)4(n we)4(re)4( pe)4(ople)4( c)4(a)4(n)0( c)4(o)0(mmit)]TJ
T*
[(crimes without being)10( haled into court any)30(w)2(here. There is often a possibility)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(for \223)5(I)24(nte)5(r)4(ne)5(t vic)5(tims\224)5( to sue)5( the)5( \223)5(c)5(r)4(imina)5(l)-1(\224)5( in the)5( sta)5(t)-1(e)5( whe)5(r)4(e)5( he)5( is)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(phy)30(sically)30( present.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
484 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
485 0 obj
<<
/Length 5649
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(90)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
24 0 0 24 113.49 733.71 Tm
[(\024\025\003)-310(7KH\003UROH\003RI\003QDWLRQDO\003OHJDO)]TJ
0 -1.175 TD
(IUDPHZRUNV\003LQ\003D\003PXOWLQDWLRQDO)Tj
T*
(&\\EHUZRUOG)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 636.87 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(I)21(t)-4( has been arg)8(u)-2(ed t)-4(h)-2(at)-4( because t)-4(h)-2(ere are such a g)8(r)1(eat)-4( num)-4(ber of nat)-4(i)-4(onal)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(laws apply)30(i)-2(ng)10( to actions in the multinational Cy)30(berspace, the leg)10(a)4(l situation)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(is leading)9( towards international chaos. Every)29( country)29( has its own leg)9(a)3(l)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(fra)4(me)4(work re)4(la)4(ting)10( to a)4(c)4(tions pe)4(rforme)4(d)0( on the)4( I)23(n)0(te)4(rne)4(t)-2(. Due)4( to the)4( fa)4(c)4(t)-2( tha)4(t)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(informa)5(tion flows a)5(c)5(r)4(oss the)5( borde)5(rs a)5(ll the)5( time)5(, I)24( be)5(lie)5(ve)5( the)5(r)4(e)5( is a)5(n)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(overhang)9(i)-3(ng)9( need for cooperation between g)9(overnments in order to g)9(a)3(in)]TJ
T*
[(control over the I)22(n)-1(ternet. Domestic reg)9(u)-1(lation could lead to the creation of)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(c)4(y)30(be)4(r ha)4(ve)4(ns whe)4(r)3(e)4( inte)4(lle)4(c)4(t)-2(ua)4(l prope)4(rty)30( infring)10(e)4(m)-2(e)4(n)0(ts ne)4(ve)4(r will be)4( ta)4(ke)4(n)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(to court. Finland almost became a cy)29(ber haven in 1995, when a Finn wanted)]TJ
T*
[(to ex)-11(pand his anony)29(mous remailer services, which could be used in order to)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(act completely)30( anony)30(mously)30( in Cy)30(berspace.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 324.09 500.79 Tm
0.007 Tc
(252)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 471.51 Tm
-0.001 Tc
[(\024\025\021\024\003)-435(9LUWXDO\003&\\)10(E)-1(HUFRXUWV)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 440.67 Tm
0.001 Tw
[(There have been sug)9(g)9(e)3(stions of creating)9( an independent Cy)29(bercourt)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(jurisdiction totally)30( separated from ordinary)30( national courts outside)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Cy)29(berspace. Virtual courts should be able to arbitrate and mediate in on-line)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(disputes. There have also been sug)10(g)10(e)4(stions of allowing)10( individuals to)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(reg)9(u)-1(late the conduct on the I)22(n)-1(ternet throug)9(h contracts and custom such as)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
[(\223netiquette\224 were the sy)29(stem operators should ban any)29(one braking)9( such)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(rules. Groups would be formed with various constitutional principles. I)23(t)]TJ
T*
(would then be up to each individual to choose which rules he/she is willing)Tj
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(o)-2( accept)-4( and onl)-4(y)28( access t)-4(hose areas i)-4(n)-2( C)-5(y)28(berspace.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 363.69 332.91 Tm
0.006 Tc
-0.002 Tw
( 253)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 377.97 327.39 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( I)23( doubt such)]TJ
-22.04 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(informa)5(lly)31( sug)11(g)11(e)5(ste)5(d)1( solutions e)5(v)1(e)5(r)4( be)5(c)5(o)1(ming)11( re)5(a)5(lity)31( unle)5(ss the)5(r)4(e)5( is a)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(universal widespread consensus reg)9(a)3(rding)9( the issue.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
15.96 0 0 15.96 113.49 275.31 Tm
[(\024\025\021\025\003)-435(,QWHUQDWLRQDO\003&RS\\)10(ULJKW\0037UHDWLHV)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 244.47 Tm
[(I)22(n)-1( order to harmoniz)-7(e)3( national rules concerning)9( intellectual property)29(,)-1( several)]TJ
T*
(countries have accepted various international treaties. Due to the increasing)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(ex)-10(ploitation of intellectual property)30( in the on-line environment, which no)]TJ
T*
[(long)10(er knows any)30( phy)30(sical borders, it is very)30( important to have)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(inte)5(rna)5(tiona)5(lly)31( a)5(g)11(re)5(e)5(d)1( minimum sta)5(nda)5(rds of prote)5(c)5(tion a)5(s)0( we)5(ll a)5(s)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
(principles.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.04 0 0 8.04 163.77 179.19 Tm
0.007 Tc
(254)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 176.01 173.67 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
[( The)4( ma)4(in multila)4(te)4(ra)4(l a)4(g)10(re)4(e)4(m)-2(e)4(n)0(ts a)4(r)3(e)4( for e)4(x)-10(a)4(m)-2(ple)4( the)4( B)7(e)4(rne)]TJ
-5.21 -1.48 TD
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 159.03 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
/F3 1 Tf
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 148.23 Tm
(252)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 143.67 Tm
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(*RYHUQPHQW\003LQ\003&\\EHUVSDFH\003\020\003:KDW\003-XULVGLFWLRQ)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
18.9879 0 TD
0.003 Tw
[(, NZ)9( Institute o)-6(f)8( P)-10(u)6(b)-6(lic)]TJ
-20.2169 -1.1807 TD
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[(A)14(d)-3(m)22(i)4(n)9(i)4(s)6(t)4(ration)9( \(In)9(c.\), Gov)9(e)1(rn)9(an)9(ce in)9( C)7(y)21(bers)6(pace C)7(o)-3(n)9(f)11(eren)9(ce, 17 A)14(p)-3(ril 1997,)]TJ
T*
[(presen)9(ted by)21( Mich)9(ael C)7(r)-1(on)9(in)9( an)9(d B)-5(e)1(rn)9(adette J)-6(e)1(w)26(.)]TJ
T*
-0.021 Tc
[(H)-22(t)-20(t)-20(p)-27(:)-20(/)-20(/)-20(www.)-24(r)-25(mmb)-27(.)-24(c)-23(o)-27(.)-24(n)-15(z)-23(/)-20(c)-23(yb)-27(e)-23(r)-25(g)-15(o)-27(v)-15(.)-24(h)-15(t)-20(m)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 101.19 Tm
0 Tc
(253)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 96.63 Tm
0.003 Tc
[( Ibid. ch)9(apter 7.)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
0 Tc
(254)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 84.87 Tm
0.003 Tw
[( One im)19(p)-6(o)-6(r)-4(tant p)-6(r)-4(incip)-6(l)1(e is the p)-6(r)-4(incip)-6(l)1(e o)-6(f)8( eq)-6(ual treatm)19(e)-2(nt o)-6(f)8( natio)-6(nal and)]TJ
-0.9759 -1.1807 TD
0.003 Tc
0 Tw
[(f)11(o)-3(reig)9(n)9( w)26(o)-3(rk)9(s)6(.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
486 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
488 0 obj
<<
/Length 2977
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(91)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Convention for the protection of literary)29( and artistic works,)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 397.05 750.99 Tm
0.007 Tc
(255)Tj
12 0 0 12 409.29 745.47 Tm
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( the)5( Rome)]TJ
-24.65 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Convention for the protection of performers, producers of phonog)9(rams and)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(broadcasting)10( org)10(a)4(niz)-6(a)4(tions)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 242.13 722.67 Tm
0.007 Tc
(256)Tj
12 0 0 12 254.37 717.15 Tm
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[( and t)-4(h)-2(e Ag)8(reem)-4(ent)-4( on Trade-R)-5(e)2(l)-4(a)2(t)-4(e)2(d Aspect)-4(s)]TJ
-11.74 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(of I)23(n)0(tellectual Property)30( Rig)10(h)0(ts.)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 261.33 708.51 Tm
0.007 Tc
(257)Tj
12 0 0 12 273.57 702.99 Tm
0 Tc
[( The)4(r)3(e)4( e)4(x)-10(ist two ne)4(w tre)4(a)4(tie)4(s re)4(la)4(ting)10( to)]TJ
-13.34 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(inte)5(lle)5(c)5(t)-1(ua)5(l prope)5(rty)31( tha)5(t)-1( still ha)5(ve)5( not c)5(o)1(me)5( into forc)5(e)5(:)-1( the)5( WI)24(PO c)5(opy)31(rig)11(h)1(t)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(treaty)29(,)-1( and the W)-7(I)22(PO performances and phonog)9(rams treaty)29(.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(One drawback with the international conventions is that questions relating)10( to)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(jurisdiction are normally)30( not considered. This is not as serious as it may)]TJ
T*
[(se)4(e)4(m)-2(, sinc)4(e)4( the)4( le)4(g)10(a)4(l fra)4(me)4(works re)4(la)4(ting)10( to inte)4(lle)4(c)4(t)-2(ua)4(l prope)4(rty)30( a)4(r)3(e)4( ve)4(ry)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(alike in a number of countries.)Tj
8.04 0 0 8.04 259.89 609.39 Tm
0.007 Tc
(258)Tj
12 0 0 12 113.49 132.39 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
( )Tj
ET
1 i
113.49 135.51 143.88 -0.48 re
f
BT
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 124.71 Tm
(255)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 120.15 Tm
0.003 Tc
[( P)-7(a)1(ris)6( A)14(c)1(t of)11( J)-6(u)9(ly)21( 24, 1971. Http://)]TJ
13.8554 0 TD
-0.023 Tc
[(www.)-26(wi)-22(p)-29(o)-29(.)-26(i)-22(n)-17(t)-22(/)-22(e)-25(n)-17(g)-17(/)-22(i)-22(p)-29(l)-22(e)-25(x)-17(/)-22(w)]TJ
10.6024 0 TD
0.005 Tc
[(o_ber0_.h)11(t)6(m)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 112.95 Tm
0 Tc
(256)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 108.39 Tm
0.005 Tc
-0.002 Tw
[( Dat)6(e)3(d 1961.)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 101.19 Tm
0 Tc
(257)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 96.63 Tm
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( Gen)10(e)2(ral)5(l)5(y)22( ref)12(e)2(rred t)5(o)-2( as)7( t)5(h)10(e T)-12(R)8(IPs)7( ag)10(reem)23(en)10(t)5( of)12( 1995.)]TJ
6.48 0 0 6.48 141.81 89.43 Tm
0 Tc
(258)Tj
9.96 0 0 9.96 151.53 84.87 Tm
0 Tw
( )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0.253 0 TD
(1lWMXULGLN\003\261\003/DJ\003RFK\003UlWW\003Sn\003,QWHUQHW)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
14.8072 0 TD
0.004 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, by)22( T)-12(h)10(om)23(as)7( C)8(a)2(rl)5(\351n)10(-)12(W)-4(en)10(del)5(s)7(, pag)10(e)]TJ
-16.0361 -1.1807 TD
0.006 Tc
(79.)Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
489 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
490 0 obj
<<
/Length 4355
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(92)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
24 0 0 24 113.49 733.71 Tm
[(\024\026\003)-310(&RQFOXVLRQ)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 693.27 Tm
0 Tw
[(I)23(t)-2( surely)30( is most convenient if old laws can be applied to all new)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(technolog)10(ical developments, such as Cy)30(berspace, but sometimes it is not)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(enoug)9(h if one wants to cover all possible haz)-7(a)3(rds to intellectual property)29(.)]TJ
T*
[(Since we are only)29( in the beg)9(i)-3(nning)9( of the new information society)29(,)-1( I)22( believe)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(it is of hig)10(h)0(est importance to study)30( the technical developments as they)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(emerg)9(e)3(, in order to stay)29( ahead and predict possible new leg)9(a)3(l dilemmas and)]TJ
T*
[(reduce the lead of the pirates. I)22(f)2( the leg)9(a)3(l sy)29(stems do not recog)9(n)-1(iz)-7(e new)]TJ
T*
[(complex)-11( technolog)9(ical problems in time, they)29( may)29( be unable to act as)]TJ
T*
[(rapidly)29( as they)29( need in the future. Technolog)9(y)29( sy)29(stems develop much faster)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(than leg)10(a)4(l sy)30(stems, and I)23( am of the opinion that if laws are not updated and)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(revised constantly)29(, there is a risk that the laws could lag)9( behind the)]TJ
T*
[(technolog)9(y)29(,)-1( and be unable to satisfactory)29( protect intellectual property)29( from)]TJ
T*
[(piracy)29(. However, one should not be too restrictive if one wants to see further)]TJ
T*
[(technolog)9(ical developments in Cy)29(berspace. I)22(f)2( Cy)29(berspace becomes too)]TJ
T*
[(heavily)29( reg)9(u)-1(lated on all areas, there is a risk that the technolog)9(ical)]TJ
T*
[(development stag)9(nates. That would be a g)9(r)2(eat loss for future g)9(e)3(nerations. I)22(t)]TJ
T*
[(would also deprive intellectual property)29( owners of a g)9(r)2(eat medium for)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(display)30(i)-2(ng)10( their works. The leg)10(a)4(l sy)30(stems must be able to balance)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(intellectual property)29( protection ag)9(ainst the technolog)9(ical development,)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(without hindering)10( either one.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Perhaps the owners of intellectual property)29( will be forced to solely)29( rely)29( upon)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(technolog)9(ical protection measures, thus constantly)29( facing)9( the risk of)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(i)-4(n)-2(t)-4(e)2(l)-4(l)-4(ect)-4(ual)-4( propert)-4(y)28( pi)-4(rat)-4(e)2(s cracki)-4(n)-2(g)8( t)-4(h)-2(ei)-4(r safet)-4(y)28( sy)28(st)-4(em)-4(s. I)21(f)1( such a sy)28(st)-4(em)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(brakes down, intellectual property)29( owners could be completely)29( without)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(protection. I)23( believe such technolog)10(ical protection sy)30(stems may)30( function as a)]TJ
T*
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(c)5(o)1(mple)5(me)5(nt to inte)5(lle)5(c)5(t)-1(ua)5(l prope)5(rty)31( la)5(ws. At this point in time)5(, a)5(s)0( fa)5(r a)5(s)0( I)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(understand, there do not ex)-11(ist any)29( technical safety)29( measures for intellectual)]TJ
T*
[(property)29( that would not need the backup of laws in certain situations. I)22( am)]TJ
T*
[(afraid that without solid protection for intellectual property)29(,)-1( the incentive to)]TJ
T*
[(create may)29( disappear, which would be a g)9(r)2(eat loss to mankind. W)-7(h)-1(at is the)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(economical point of creating)10( something)10( if it cannot be sold?)-16( Perhaps the)]TJ
T*
[(a)4(u)0(thors will se)4(ll the)4( first c)4(opie)4(s)-1( of the)4(i)-2(r work ve)4(ry)30( e)4(x)-10(pe)4(nsive)4( in orde)4(r to)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(reg)9(a)3(in the predicted lost profits. After the first sales, every)29(body)29( may)29( be able)]TJ
T*
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(t)-4(o)-2( achi)-4(e)2(ve t)-4(h)-2(e work for free i)-4(n)-2( C)-5(y)28(berspace any)28(w)0(ay)28(. I)21(f)1( i)-4(n)-2(t)-4(e)2(l)-4(l)-4(ect)-4(ual)-4( propert)-4(y)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(be)4(c)4(o)0(me)4(s e)4(v)0(e)4(n)0( more)4( e)4(x)-10(pe)4(nsive)4( to use)4( in the)4( future)4(, the)4( inc)4(e)4(n)0(tive)4( to uploa)4(d)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(and download unlawful copies becomes even g)9(r)2(eater.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
491 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F7 289 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
493 0 obj
<<
/Length 4489
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(93)Tj
/F5 1 Tf
18 0 0 18 113.49 739.95 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.003 Tw
(Sources of information)Tj
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 711.03 Tm
0 Tc
(Bibliography)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 682.47 Tm
0 Tw
[(B)7(NA\222s Electronic I)23(n)0(formation Policy)30( and L)21(a)4(w Report, J)-11(u)0(ly)30( 18, 1997, pag)10(e)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
(741 and 778.)Tj
0 -2.36 TD
[(B)7(NA Patent, Trademark &)8( Copy)30(rig)10(h)0(t L)21(a)4(w Daily)30(, J)-11(une 13, 1997.)]TJ
T*
-0.007 Tc
[(Bo)-7(gd)-7(an)-7(,)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
3.34 0 TD
0 Tc
(\003)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
0.25 0 TD
-0.002 Tc
[(Mi)-4(chael)-4(.)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
3.52 0 TD
[(\0036YHQVN\003LQWHUQDWLRQHOO\003SULYDW\020)5(\003)1(RFK\003SURFHVVUlWW)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
18.07 0 TD
0 Tc
(, edition 4:3,)Tj
-25.18 -1.18 TD
[(L)21(und 1995. I)23(S)-4(B)7(N)2( 91-38-50115-5.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(C)-4(a)3(rl\351n-W)-7(endels,)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
6.74 0 TD
0 Tc
(\003)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
0.25 0 TD
(Thomas, )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
3.72 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(/)-11(DJ\003RFK\003U)-9(l)1(W)-8(W)-8(\003)-2(Sn\003,QW)-8(H)1(U)-9(QHW)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
9.61 0 TD
0 Tc
(, first edition, Stockholm,)Tj
-20.32 -1.18 TD
(1997.)Tj
0 -2.36 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(Coug)11(hlin, J)-10(r)4(,)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
5.2 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
0.25 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Georg)9(e)3( Gordon,)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
6.47 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(\003<)-21(RXU)-9(\003+DQGERRN\003RI)-8(\003\(YHU)-9(\\GD\\\003/)-11(D)1(Z)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
13.64 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(, fifth)Tj
-25.56 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(edition, New York, 1993. I)22(S)-5(B)6(N)1( 0-06-271572-0.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Dag)10( Mattson in Karnov 1996/97, pag)10(e)4( 919 at 14.)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Daily)29( Variety)29(,)-1( J)-12(une 10, 1997, pag)9(e)3( 1, by)29( Christoffer Stern.)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Electronic Eng)10(i)-2(neering)10( Times, Aug)10(u)0(st 11, 1997, by)30( B)7(r)3(ian Rost, pag)10(e)4( 115.)]TJ
T*
[(Electronic I)23(n)0(formation Policy)30( &)8( L)21(a)4(w Report J)-11(u)0(ly)30( 18, 1997, Vol 2, No 28,)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(pag)9(e)3( 773.)]TJ
0 -2.33 TD
0 Tc
[(F)6(o)0(lkeson,)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
3.91 0 TD
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
0.25 0 TD
0.001 Tc
[(Christina)5(,)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
3.92 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(\0036N\\GG\003I)-9(|)0(U)-10(\003)-3(XSSKRYV)-10(U)-10(l)0(W)-9(W)-9(\003)-3(Sn\003,QW)-9(H)0(U)-10(QHW)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
13.74 0 TD
0 Tc
(, Stockholm, 1996.)Tj
-21.82 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(I)22(S)-5(B)6(N)1( 91-7598-800-3.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
[(Koktvedg)9(aard and L)20(e)3(vin, )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
10.39 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(/)-11(l)1(U)-9(RERN\003L)-8(\003)-2(,PPDW)-8(H)1(U)-9(L)-8(DO)-8(U)-9(l)1(W)-8(W)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
10.06 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(, Stockholm 1996, fourth)Tj
-20.45 -1.18 TD
[(edition, I)23(S)-4(B)7(N)2( 91-38-50560-6.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
-0.002 Tc
[(L)19(i)-4(ndberg)8(,)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
3.88 0 TD
0 Tc
(\003)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
0.25 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Ag)9(ne and W)-7(e)3(stman,)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
8.12 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(\003)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
0.25 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
(Daniel, )Tj
/F6 1 Tf
3.16 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(3U)-10(DNW)-9(L)-9(V)-10(N\003,7)-12(\020U)-10(lW)-9(W)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
6.25 0 TD
0 Tc
(, Stockholm, 1997.)Tj
-21.91 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(I)22(S)-5(B)6(N)1( 91-38-50521-5.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(PR Newswire, J)-11(une 2, 1997.)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Rosenoer, J)-12(onathan, )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
8.33 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(&)-12(\\EHU)-9(O)-8(D)1(Z)-12(\003)-2(\261\0037)-11(KH\003/)-11(D)1(Z)-12(\003)-2(RI)-8(\003W)-8(KH\003,QW)-8(H)1(U)-9(QHW)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
14.28 0 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(, S)-6(p)-2(ring)8(er-Verlag)]TJ
-22.61 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(New York, I)22(n)-1(c1997. I)22(S)-5(B)6(N)1( 0-387-94832-5.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
[(S)-5(i)-3(ng)9(le Market News, The Newsletter of DG XV \226 I)22(n)-1(ternal Market and)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(F)5(i)-3(nancial Services, No 10, Dec 1997, pag)9(e)3( 22-23.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
[(Str\366mberg)9(,)-1( H\345kan, )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
7.81 0 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(7)-12(U)-10(\\FNI)-9(U)-10(L)-9(KHW)-9(V)-10(U)-10(l)0(W)-9(W)-9(\003)-3(RFK\003DQQDQ\003\\W)-9(W)-9(U)-10(DQGHI)-9(U)-10(L)-9(KHW)-9(V)-10(U)-10(l)0(W)-9(W)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
18.31 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(, tenth)Tj
-26.12 -1.18 TD
[(edition, L)21(und 1992. I)23(S)-4(B)7(N)2( 91-44-00031-6.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(The Guardian \(L)20(ondon\), May)29( 16, 1997 pag)9(e)3( 12.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
494 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F5 276 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
496 0 obj
<<
/Length 3126
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(94)Tj
-14.85 57.76 TD
0 Tw
[(The F)6(i)-2(nancial Post, Aug)10(u)0(st 28, 1997, by)30( Alice Rawsthorn, F)6(i)-2(nancial Times.)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
18 0 0 18 113.49 695.07 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.003 Tw
(Official sources)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 665.67 Tm
0.001 Tc
[(B)8(r)4(ottsba)5(lke)5(n)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(*HRU)-9(JL)-8(D\003&)-12(R)1(PSXW)-8(HU)-9(\0036\\V)-9(W)-8(H)1(PV)-9(\0033U)-9(R)1(W)-8(HFW)-8(L)-8(RQ\003$FW)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
17.04 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
( 16-9-93.1)Tj
-17.04 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Http://www.mindspring)10(.)0(com/~ajc10/g)10(a)4(law.html \(980215\))]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
[(Http://www2.echo.lu./leg)10(a)4(l/en/ipr/software/software.html \(971201\).)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(I)22(N)1(TA \(I)22(nternational Trademark Association\)\223W)-7(hite Paper\224 - )]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
24.62 0 TD
0.006 Tc
[(7K)12(H)]TJ
-24.62 -1.18 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(,QW)-8(H)1(U)-9(V)-9(HFW)-8(L)-8(RQ\003RI)-8(\0037)-11(U)-9(DGHPDU)-9(NV)-9(\003DQG\003'RPDL)-8(Q)1(\0031)-12(DPHV)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
19.07 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(, F)6(e)4(b 5, 1997, Version 1.0.)]TJ
-19.07 -1.18 TD
(Http://plaz.interport.net/int/wpwhole.htm \(971121\))Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(,QW)-9(H)0(U)-10(Q)0(L)-9(F)0(\0036Z)-13(HGHQ\021)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
(Http://www.internic.se \(971104\))Tj
0 -2.36 TD
[(L)21(a)4(g)10( \(1960:729\) om upphovr\344tt till litter\344ra och konstn\344rlig)10(a verk)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(L)20(a)3(g)9( \(1998:000\) om ansvar f\366r elektroniska anslag)9(stavlor.)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Paris Act of J)-11(u)0(ly)30( 24, 1971.)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(Http://www.wipo.int/eng)10(/iplex)-10(/)-2(wo_ber0_.htm)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(3U)-9(RSRV)-9(DO)-8(\003I)-8(RU)-9(\003D\003\(XU)-9(RSHDQ\0033DU)-9(O)-8(L)-8(D)1(PHQW)-8(\003DQG\003&)-12(RXQFL)-8(O)-8(\003'L)-8(U)-9(HFW)-8(L)-8(YH\003RQ\003W)-8(K)1(H)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(KDU)-9(PRQL)-8(V)-9(D)1(W)-8(L)-8(RQ\003RI)-8(\003FHU)-9(W)-8(D)1(L)-8(Q)1(\003DV)-9(SHFW)-8(V)-9(\003)-2(RI)-8(\003FRS\\U)-9(L)-8(JKW)-8(\003DQG\003U)-9(H)1(O)-8(D)1(W)-8(HG\003U)-9(L)-8(JKW)-8(V)-9(\003)-2(L)-8(Q)1(\003W)-8(KH)]TJ
T*
[(,QI)-9(R)0(U)-10(P)-3(DW)-9(L)-9(RQ\0036RFL)-9(HW)-9(\\)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
7.91 0 TD
0 Tc
[(, B)7(r)3(ussels, 10.12.1997. COM\(97\)628 final)]TJ
-7.91 -2.36 TD
(Prop. 1992/93:48)Tj
T*
(Prop. 1993/94:122)Tj
T*
(Prop. 1997/98:15)Tj
T*
[(Statement of Minnesota Attorney)30( General on I)23(n)0(ternet J)-11(u)0(risdiction.)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(Http://jmls.edu./cy)30(ber/docs/minn-ag)10(.html)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(7)-11(KH\003&)-12(RS\\U)-9(L)-8(JKW)-8(\003$FW)-8(\003\206)-5(\024\024\032\003/)-11(L)-8(PL)-8(W)-8(D)1(W)-8(L)-8(RQV)-9(\003RQ\003H[FO)-8(XV)-9(L)-8(YH\003U)-9(L)-8(JKW)-8(V)-9(\035)2(\003&)-12(RPSXW)-8(HU)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(SU)-10(RJU)-10(DPV)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
3.89 0 TD
0 Tc
[(. Http://www.sg)10(pdlaw.com/software_copy)30(rig)10(h)0(t/part1.html#117)]TJ
-3.89 -1.18 TD
(\(971025\))Tj
0 -2.36 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Varum\344rkeslag)9( \(1960: 644\))]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
497 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F5 276 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
499 0 obj
<<
/Length 5219
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(95)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(:,32\017\003,V)-9(V)-9(XHV)-9(\003U)-9(HO)-8(DW)-8(L)-8(QJ\003W)-8(R)1(\003W)-8(U)-9(DGHPDU)-9(NV)-9(\003DQG\003,QW)-8(H)1(U)-9(QHW)-8(\003GRPDL)-8(Q\003QDPHV)-9(\021)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
26.12 0 TD
0.005 Tw
[( Fi)-7(rs)-6(t)]TJ
-26.12 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(session, Geneva, May)30( 26 to 30, 1997.)]TJ
T*
[(Http://www.wipo.int/eng)10(/I)23(nternet/domains/tdn/cm/cm_I)23(_2.htm)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(:,32\017\003&)-12(RQV)-9(XO)-8(W)-8(D)1(W)-8(L)-8(YH\003PHHW)-8(L)-8(QJ\003RQ\0037)-11(U)-9(DGHPDU)-9(NV)-9(\003DQG\003,QW)-8(H)1(U)-9(QHW)-8(\003'RPDL)-8(Q)1(\003QDPHV)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
29.2 0 TD
0 Tc
(,)Tj
-29.2 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(second session, Geneva, September 1 and 2, 1997.)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Http://www.wipo.int/eng)10(/internet/domains/tdn/cm/cm_ii_2.htm \(971025\))]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 616.23 Tm
0.001 Tc
0.003 Tw
(Electronic articles)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 587.67 Tm
-0.005 Tc
[(&)-12(DFKH\020\025\025\035\003&)-12(RS\\L)-8(QJ\003DQG\003V)-9(W)-8(RU)-9(L)-8(QJ\003:HE\003SDJHV)-9(\003L)-8(V)-9(\003)-2(YL)-8(W)-8(D)1(O)-8(\003)-2(W)-8(R)1(\003W)-8(KH\003,QW)-8(H)1(U)-9(QHW)-8(\266V)-9(\003V)-9(XU)-9(YL)-8(YDO)]TJ
T*
[(\020\003EXW)-8(\003L)-8(V)-9(\003)-2(L)-8(W)-8(\003)-2(O)-8(HJDO)-8(")]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.34 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( B)6(y)29( Eric Schlachter. I)22(n)-1(tellectual Property)29( Mag)9(a)3(z)-7(i)-3(ne Summer)]TJ
-6.34 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(1996. Http://www.ipmag)10(.)0(com/schlacht.htm)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(&)-12(\\EHU)-9(O)-8(D)1(Z)-12(\035)2(\003,V)-9(V)-9(XHV)-9(\003L)-8(Q\003,QW)-8(H)1(U)-9(QHW)-8(\003&)-12(RPPHU)-9(F)1(H)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
15.92 0 TD
0 Tc
[(, by)30( Thomas E. J)-11(e)4(nsen.)]TJ
-15.92 -1.18 TD
[(Http://www.cy)30(berlaw.com/issues.htm \(970724\))]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.005 Tc
[('DQJHU)-9(RXV)-9(\003/)-11(L)-8(D)1(L)-8(V)-9(RQV)-9(\035\0037)-11(KH\003/)-11(HJDO)-8(\0035L)-8(V)-9(NV)-9(\003RI)-8(\003)-2(/)-11(L)-8(QNL)-8(QJ\003:HE\0036L)-8(W)-8(H)1(V)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
23.54 0 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(, R)-5(i)-4(chard)]TJ
-23.54 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Ray)29(s)-2(man and Peter B)6(r)2(own, The New York L)20(a)3(w J)-12(ournal, April 8, 1997.)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Http://www.ljx)-10(.com/I)23(nternet/0408lias.html \(971006\))]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.003 Tc
[('HSXWL])-7(LQJ\003WKH\003,)4(6)3(3V)-7(\003\261\003,)4(QWHU)-7(QHW\0036HU)-7(YLFH\0033U)-7(RYLGHU)-7(V)-7(\003)0(V)-7(KRXOG\003WDNH\003U)-7(H)3(V)-7(SRQV)-7(LELOLW\\)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(I)-8(R)1(U)-9(\003)-2(SRO)-8(L)-8(F)1(L)-8(QJ\003FRS\\U)-9(L)-8(JKW)-8(\003L)-8(QI)-8(U)-9(L)-8(QJHPHQW)-8(\003L)-8(Q\003&)-12(\\EHU)-9(V)-9(SDFH)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
20.13 0 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, by)31( William J)-10(.)1( Cook.)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
-20.13 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(I)22(n)-1(tellectual Property)29( Mag)9(a)3(z)-7(i)-3(ne, spring)9( \22296.)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Http://www.ipmag)10(.)0(com /acook.htm \(970716\))]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.005 Tc
[('RPDL)-8(Q)1(\003QDPH\003GL)-8(V)-9(SXW)-8(HV)-9(\035\0033U)-9(HHPSW)-8(L)-8(YH\0036XL)-8(W)-8(V)-9(\017\003)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
16.98 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(by)29( J)-12(o)-1(anna Glasner. L)20(a)3(w J)-12(ournal)]TJ
-16.98 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(EXTRA!, Sept. 17, 1997.)Tj
T*
[(Http://www.ljx)-10(.com/ljx)-10(files/domainlaw.html \(971012\))]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(\([W)-8(HQGL)-8(QJ\0033HU)-9(V)-9(RQDO)-8(\003-XU)-9(L)-8(V)-9(GL)-8(FW)-8(L)-8(RQ\003W)-8(R)1(\003$FW)-8(V)-9(\003)-2(L)-8(Q)1(\003&)-12(\\EHU)-9(V)-9(SDFH)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
21.93 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(, by)29( Dane Steffensson)]TJ
-21.93 -1.18 TD
[(for L)20(a)3(w 7333 \(L)20(aw &)7( The I)22(n)-1(ternet\) spring)9( semester 1997 at Georg)9(i)-3(a State)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Unive)4(r)3(sity)30( Colle)4(g)10(e)4( of L)21(a)4(w.)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.003 Tc
[(\)U)-7(DPH\003/)-9(L)-6(DELOLW\\\003&)-10(ORXGV)-7(\003WKH\003,)4(Q)3(WHU)-7(QHW\266)4(V)-7(\003\)XWXU)-7(H)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
17.97 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(, The New York L)20(a)3(w J)-12(ournal,)]TJ
-17.97 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(May)30( 19, 1997.)]TJ
T*
[(Htttp://www.ljx)-10(.com/I)23(nternet/0519ny)30(frame.html \(971006\).)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(\265\)U)-9(D)1(PL)-8(QJ\266\035\003,QW)-8(H)1(U)-9(QHW)-8(\003\(TXL)-8(YDO)-8(HQW)-8(\003RI)-8(\003)-2(3L)-8(U)-9(D)1(W)-8(L)-8(QJ"\017)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
17.85 0 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[( The New York L)19(a)2(w J)-13(ournal)]TJ
-17.85 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(April 4 and 11, 1997 \(published in two parts\))Tj
T*
[(Http://www.ljx)-10(.com/I)23(nternet/0411frame.html)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(\)U)-9(HHGRP\003W)-8(R\003/)-11(L)-8(QN\0038QGHU)-9(\003$W)-8(W)-8(DFN)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12.26 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(, The New York L)20(a)3(w J)-12(ournal, J)-12(une 23 1997.)]TJ
-12.26 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Http://www.ljx)-10(.com/I)23(nternet/0623link.html \(971006\))]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
0.004 Tc
[(*)7(O)1(R)10(VVD)10(U\\)10(\021)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
[(Http://www.g)10(l)-2(ossary)30(.com \(971014\).)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
500 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F5 276 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
504 0 obj
<<
/Length 4684
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(96)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
-14.85 57.76 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(*RYHU)-9(QPHQW)-8(\003L)-8(Q\003&)-12(\\EHU)-9(V)-9(SDFH\003\020\003:KDW)-8(\003-XU)-9(L)-8(V)-9(GL)-8(FW)-8(L)-8(R)1(Q)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
18.87 0 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, NZ)12( I)24(n)1(stitute)5( of Public)]TJ
-18.87 -1.18 TD
-0.002 Tc
0.002 Tw
[(Adm)-4(i)-4(n)-2(i)-4(s)-3(t)-4(r)1(at)-4(i)-4(on \(I)21(nc.\), Governance i)-4(n)-2( C)-5(y)28(berspace C)-5(onference, 17 Apri)-4(l)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(1997, presented by)29( Michael Cronin and B)6(e)3(rnadette J)-12(e)3(w.)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
[(Http://www.rmmb.co.nz)-6(/cy)30(b)0(erg)10(ovhtm)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
0 Tw
[(Http://www.clari.net/brad/linkrig)10(ht.html \(971021\))]TJ
T*
[(Http://www.news.com/News/I)23(t)-2(em/0,4,16280,00.html?)-16(dtn.head \(971212\))]TJ
T*
(Http://zeus.bna.com/e-law/ \(980214\))Tj
/F6 1 Tf
T*
-0.006 Tc
[(,QW)-9(H)0(O)-9(O)-9(HFW)-9(XDO)-9(\0033U)-10(RSHU)-10(W)-9(\\)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.35 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(, by)29( J)-12(e)3(ffrey)29( R)-4(.)-1( Kuester and Daniel R)-4(.)-1( McC)-4(l)-3(ure, The)]TJ
-8.35 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(National L)21(a)4(w J)-11(ournal, J)-11(a)4(n 20, 1997.)]TJ
T*
[(Http://www.ljx)-10(.com/internet/0120ispcp.html \(971006\))]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(,QW)-8(H)1(U)-9(QHW)-8(\003/)-11(DZ)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
5.14 0 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( by)31( Mic)5(h)1(a)5(e)5(l)-1( J)-10(.)1( Wa)5(g)11(n)1(e)5(r)4( a)5(nd Ma)5(tthe)5(w)3( G. Allison in The)5( Na)5(tiona)5(l)]TJ
-5.14 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(L)21(a)4(w J)-11(ournal, J)-11(u)0(ly)30( 7, 1997.)]TJ
T*
[(Http:// ljex)-10(t)-2(ra.com/I)23(nternet/o7o7juris.htm.)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(,QW)-8(H)1(U)-9(QHW)-8(\0036HU)-9(YL)-8(FH\0033U)-9(RYL)-8(GHU)-9(V)-9(\003)-2(V)-9(HHN\003W)-8(R)1(\003EH\003V)-9(K)1(L)-8(H)1(O)-8(GHG\003I)-8(U)-9(RP\003O)-8(DZ)-12(V)-9(\003)-2(W)-8(D)1(U)-9(JHW)-8(L)-8(QJ\003SL)-8(U)-9(D)1(W)-8(H)1(V)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
29.47 0 TD
0 Tc
(,)Tj
-29.47 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(by)29( B)6(ob Dart. The Atlanta J)-12(ournal, Sept. 5, 1997, pag)9(e)3( 11A.)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(,QW)-8(H)1(U)-9(QHW)-8(\0037)-11(HFKQRO)-8(RJ\\\003PDNHV)-9(\003L)-8(W)-8(\003)-2(KDU)-9(G\003W)-8(R)1(\003SU)-9(R)1(W)-8(HFW)-8(\003D\003FRS\\U)-9(L)-8(JKW)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
22.7 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(, I)23(n)0(side B)7(u)0(siness)]TJ
-22.7 -1.18 TD
[(J)-11(u)0(ly)30( 1997, by)30( Kristen Caldwell.)]TJ
T*
(Http:// www.hunton.com/in0797ib.htm \(971015\))Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.006 Tc
[(-XU)-10(L)-9(V)-10(GL)-9(FW)-9(L)-9(RQ\003L)-9(Q)0(\003D\003:RU)-10(O)-9(G)0(\003:L)-9(W)-9(KRXW)-9(\003%RU)-10(GHU)-10(V)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
16.16 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(, Dan L)20(.)-1( B)6(u)-1(rk.)]TJ
-16.16 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(Http://zeus.bna.com/e-law/cases/heroes.html \(970925\))Tj
T*
[(Http://www.student.virg)10(inia.edu/~vjolt/vol1/B)7(U)2(RK.htm)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(-XU)-9(L)-8(V)-9(GL)-8(FW)-8(L)-8(RQ\0032YHU)-9(\003&)-12(RPPHU)-9(FH\0032Q\003W)-8(KH\003,QW)-8(H)1(U)-9(QHW)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
17.94 0 TD
0 Tc
[( by)30( B)7(r)3(adley)30( A. Slutsky)30(,)]TJ
-17.94 -1.18 TD
[(Http://www.ksla)4(w.c)4(o)0(m/me)4(nu/jurisdic)4(.htm, pa)4(g)10(e)4( 5-6.)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(/)-11(L)-8(QNL)-8(QJ\003&)-12(RS\\U)-9(L)-8(JKW)-8(\003W)-8(R\003+RPHSDJHV)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
13.36 0 TD
0 Tc
[(, Matt J)-11(ackson.)]TJ
-13.36 -1.18 TD
(Http://www.law.indiana.edu/fclj/v49/no3/jackson.html)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(/)-11(L)-8(QNL)-8(QJ\0035L)-8(JKW)-8(V)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
5.87 0 TD
0 Tc
[(, B)7(r)3(ad Templeton.)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
-5.87 -2.36 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(1)-12(L)-8(QW)-8(K\003&)-12(L)-8(U)-9(FXL)-8(W)-8(\0038V)-9(HV)-9(\003&)-12(RS\\U)-9(L)-8(JKW)-8(\003/)-11(DZ)-12(\003W)-8(R\0036O)-8(DP\003,QGHSHQGHQW)-8(\0036HU)-9(YL)-8(FH)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(2U)-9(JDQL)-8(])-9(D)1(W)-8(L)-8(RQV)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
5.73 0 TD
0 Tc
[(, L)21(GU Technolog)10(y)30( L)21(a)4(w B)7(u)0(lletin, J)-11(u)0(ly)30( 1993.)]TJ
-5.73 -1.18 TD
[(Http://www.lg)10(u.com/cr47.htm \(971024\))]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(2SSHQKHL)-8(P\266V)-9(\003)-2(RSL)-8(QL)-8(RQ\003L)-8(Q)1(\003W)-8(KH\0036KHW)-8(O)-8(DQG\0031)-12(H)1(Z)-12(V)-9(\003&)-12(DV)-9(H\021)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
(Http://www.shetland-news.co.uk/editorial/profopp1.htm \(970715\))Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(5HYL)-8(V)-9(HG\0035XO)-8(H)1(V)-9(\003*RYHU)-9(Q\003'RPDL)-8(Q)1(\0201)-12(DPH\003'L)-8(V)-9(SXW)-8(HV)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
18.69 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(, by)29( Sey)29(a)3(mack Kouretchian,)]TJ
-18.69 -1.18 TD
[(The National L)20(a)3(w J)-12(ournal, Oct 28, 1996.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
505 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
507 0 obj
<<
/Length 5125
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(97)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
0 Tw
[(Http://www.ljx)-10(.com/I)23(nternet/filetm.html \(971104\))]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
-0.003 Tc
0.003 Tw
[(S)-7(a)1(t)-5(t)-5(e)1(rl)-5(ee S)-7(t)-5(ephens Burke & Burke L)18(L)18(P)-7(.)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(Http://www.ssbb.com/trademar.html \(971009\))Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(6HQDW)-8(H\003-XGL)-8(FL)-8(DU)-9(\\\003PXO)-8(O)-8(V)-9(\003RQ\020O)-8(L)-8(QH\003FRS\\U)-9(L)-8(JKW)-8(\003L)-8(QI)-8(U)-9(L)-8(QJHPHQW)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
21.62 0 TD
0 Tc
[(, B)7(NA, Patent,)]TJ
-21.62 -1.18 TD
[(Trademark &)8( Copy)30(rig)10(h)0(t L)21(a)4(w Daily)30(, Sept.5, 1997)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(6RO)-8(L)-8(F)1(L)-8(W)-8(D)1(W)-8(L)-8(RQ\003YL)-8(D\003W)-8(KH\003,QW)-8(H)1(U)-9(QHW)-8(\036\003-XU)-9(L)-8(V)-9(GL)-8(FW)-8(L)-8(RQ\003RYHU)-9(\003&)-12(O)-8(D)1(L)-8(P)-2(V)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
21.44 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[( by)29( Edward B)6(r)2(odsky)29(,)]TJ
-21.44 -1.18 TD
[(The New York L)20(a)3(w J)-12(ournal, J)-12(une 11, 1997)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
[(\(Http://ljex)-10(t)-2(ra.com/I)23(nternet/061irsolic.htm\).)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(7)-11(HQV)-9(L)-8(RQ\003%HW)-8(Z)-12(HHQ\0033DU)-9(D)1(O)-8(H)1(O)-8(O)-8(\0038QL)-8(YHU)-9(V)-9(H)1(V)-9(\035)2(\0037)-11(U)-9(DGHPDU)-9(NV)-9(\003FO)-8(D)1(V)-9(K)1(\003Z)-12(L)-8(W)-8(K)1(\003GRPDL)-8(Q\003QDPHV)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.004 Tc
[(DV)-8(\003EXV)-8(LQHV)-8(V)-8(\003)-1(LGHQWLI\\\003PRYHV)-8(\003RQWR\003WKH\003,)3(Q)2(WHU)-8(QHW)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
17.43 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(, by)29( Mark F)5(.)-1( Radcliffe and)]TJ
-17.43 -1.18 TD
[(Maureen S. Dorney)29(. I)22(n)-1(tellectual Property)29( Mag)9(a)3(z)-7(i)-3(ne, winter 1996.)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Http://www.ipmag)10(.)0(com/radcliff.htm \(970716\))]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(7)-11(KH\003GRPDL)-8(Q\003QDPH\003FXU)-9(U)-9(HQW)-8(O)-8(\\)1(\003FDO)-8(O)-8(HG\0033U)-9(L)-8(QFH)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
16.67 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(, by)29( Doug)9(hlas Hay)29(w)1(ard. Techwire)]TJ
-16.67 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
(07/31/97.)Tj
T*
0 Tw
(Http://techweb2.web.cerf.net/wire/news/jul/0731prince.htm \(970801)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
27.49 0 TD
(\014)Tj
-27.49 -2.36 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(7)-11(KH\003\)XW)-8(X)1(U)-9(H)1(\003RI)-8(\003)-2(W)-8(KH\003,QW)-8(H)1(U)-9(QHW)-8(\003\261\003:KDW)-8(\0035RO)-8(H\003I)-8(R)1(U)-9(\003)-2(\(XU)-9(RSH")]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
20.66 0 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( I)24(n)1(te)5(rim Re)5(port of a)5(n)]TJ
-20.66 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Advisory)30( Group 970311.)]TJ
T*
(Http://www.cordis.lu/esprit/src/i2eurepo.htm \(970805\))Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(7)-11(KH\003,QW)-8(H)1(U)-9(QHW)-8(\003&)-12(RS\\U)-9(L)-8(JKW)-8(\003&)-12(DV)-9(H\003DQG\003L)-8(W)-8(V)-9(\003L)-8(PSO)-8(L)-8(FDW)-8(L)-8(RQV)-9(\003I)-8(RU)-9(\003XV)-9(H)1(U)-9(V)-9(\003)-2(RI)-8(\003W)-8(KH\003:::)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
28.58 0 TD
0 Tc
(, by)Tj
-28.58 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(Professor Charles Oppenheim, Dec.6, 1996.)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(7)-11(KH\003O)-8(D)1(Z)-12(\003)-2(O)-8(RQJ\003DU)-9(P\003RI)-8(\003)-2(W)-8(KH\003O)-8(D)1(Z)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
11.29 0 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[( by)31( Willia)5(m S. Ga)5(lkin, e)5(s)0(q in Compute)5(r)4( L)22(a)5(w)]TJ
-11.29 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(Observer issue No.24, March 1997.)Tj
T*
0 Tc
(Http://www.lawcircle.com/issue24.html.)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(7)-11(KH\0031)-12(D)1(PH\0037)-11(U)-9(DGH\035\003+RZ)-12(\003)-2(W)-8(R)1(\003GHDO)-8(\003I)-8(RU)-9(\003D\003GRPDL)-8(Q)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
17.61 0 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(, by)29( J)-12(e)3(fferson Scher, I)22(n)-1(tellectual)]TJ
-17.61 -1.18 TD
[(P)-5(r)2(operty)29( Mag)9(a)3(z)-7(i)-3(ne, December 1996.)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Http:www.ipmag)10(.)0(com/scher.htm \(970716\))]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
-0.003 Tc
0.003 Tw
(The Net)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
3.24 0 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(\035\003'RPDL)-8(Q)1(\003U)-9(HV)-9(HO)-8(O)-8(H)1(U)-9(V)-9(\003)-2(FRQI)-8(XV)-9(HV)-9(\003XV)-9(H)1(U)-9(V)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
13.54 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(, by)30( J)-11(a)4(net Kornblum, J)-11(u)0(ly)30( 9, 1997.)]TJ
-16.78 -1.18 TD
[(Http://www.news.com/news/item/o,4,12296,00.html?)-16(dtn.head \(971009\))]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(7)-11(U)-9(DFNL)-8(QJ\003DQG\0030RQL)-8(W)-8(R)1(U)-9(L)-8(QJ\0030XV)-9(L)-8(F\003RQ\003W)-8(KH\003,QW)-8(H)1(U)-9(QHW)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
18.99 0 TD
0 Tc
[(, W)-6(h)0(ite Paper, Sept 1997, by)]TJ
-18.99 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Marco Papa, Ph.D. Chief from I)22(n)-1(tersect I)22(n)-1(c.)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Http://www.intersectinc.com/technolog)10(y)30(.hy)30(ml \(971212\))]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(7)-11(U)-9(DGHPDU)-9(NV)-9(\003$O)-8(RQJ\003W)-8(KH\003,QI)-8(REDKQ\035\003$\003I)-8(L)-8(U)-9(V)-9(W)-8(\003/)-11(RRN\003DW)-8(\003W)-8(KH\003\(PHU)-9(JL)-8(QJ\003/)-11(D)1(Z)-12(\003)-2(RI)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(&)-13(\\EHU)-10(PDU)-10(N)0(V)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
4.88 0 TD
0 Tc
[(, by)30( Dan L)21(.)0( B)7(u)0(rk, April 10, 1995, 1Rich. J)-11(.)0(L)21( &)8( Tech.1\(1995\).)]TJ
-4.88 -1.18 TD
[(Http://www.nlc-bnc.ca/ifla/documents/infopol/copy)30(rig)10(h)0(t/burd1.htm)]TJ
T*
(\(970725\))Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
508 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
510 0 obj
<<
/Length 3564
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(98)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
-14.85 58.94 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(7)-11(X)1(U)-9(Q)1(L)-8(QJ\0032Q\003DQG\0037)-11(X)1(U)-9(Q)1(L)-8(QJ\0032I)-8(I)-8(\035)2(\003&)-12(DQ\0030HU)-9(H)1(O)-8(\\)1(\0037)-11(XU)-9(QL)-8(QJ\0032Q\003D\003&)-12(RPSXW)-8(HU)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.003 Tc
[(&)-10(RQV)-7(WLWXWH\003&)-10(RS\\U)-7(LJKW\003,)4(QIU)-7(L)-6(QJHPHQW"\003,)4(Q)3(\003WKH\0031)-10(L)-6(QWK\003&)-10(L)-6(U)-7(FXLW\017\003<)-19(HV)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
24.36 0 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(, by)31( Ronald S.)]TJ
-24.36 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Katz)-7( and J)-12(a)3(net Arnold Hart, The Recorder I)22(n)-1(tellectual Property)29( Supplement,)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
(Autumn 1995. Http://www.coudert.com/turnon.htm \(971022\).)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
0 -2.36 TD
-0.005 Tc
[(:K\\\003\)HGHU)-9(DO)-8(\0037)-11(U)-9(DGHPDU)-9(N\003O)-8(D)1(Z)-12(\003)-2(GRHV)-9(\003QRW)-8(\003SU)-9(R)1(W)-8(HFW)-8(\003,QW)-8(HU)-9(QHW)-8(\003'RPDL)-8(Q)1(\003QDPHV)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
27.92 0 TD
0 Tc
(, by)Tj
-27.92 -1.18 TD
[(J)-11(e)4(ff W)-6(ilson.)]TJ
T*
[(Http://www.libraries.way)30(ne.edu/~jlitman/pwilson.html \(971121\))]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
14.04 0 0 14.04 113.49 602.07 Tm
-0.002 Tc
[(Cas)-6(e)-2(s)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 113.49 573.51 Tm
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Art Music F)5(r)2(ance v. L)20(\222)2(Ecole Nationale Superieure Des)]TJ
T*
[(Telecommunications, Tribunal de Grande I)22(n)-1(stance Paris [)-8(1997])-8(EEC97.)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(B)7(e)4(nsusan Restaurant Corp. V. Richard B)7(.)0( King)10(, 937 F)6(.)0( Supp. 295 \(S.D.N.Y,)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
(Sep 9, 1996\).)Tj
T*
[(Http://www.jmls.edu/cy)30(ber/cases/bensusan.html)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(B)6(u)-1(rg)9(er King)9( Corp. v. Rudz)-7(ewicz)-7(,)-1( 471 U.S. \(1985\).)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Colin M. Cody)30( v. Kevin M, W)-6(a)4(rd, 954 F)6(.)0( Supp. 43 \(D. Conn. 1997\). F)6(e)4(b.4,)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
(1997.)Tj
T*
[(Http://zeus.bna.com/e-law/cases/cody)30(.html \(970925\))]TJ
0 -2.38 TD
[(CompuServe, I)23(n)0(c)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97 0 TD
(\021)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
0.25 0 TD
[( v. Richard S. Patterson, individually)30(, and F)6(l)-2(ashpoint)]TJ
-7.22 -1.18 TD
[(Development. \( No. 95-3452\) J)-11(u)0(ly)30( 22, 1997. United States Court of Appeals)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(for the six)-11(t)-3(h circuit.)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Http://www.jmls.edu/cy)30(ber/cases/patter.html \(970922\))]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
[(Cy)30(bersell I)23(n)0(c., v. Cy)30(bersell I)23(n)0(c. No. 96-17087 D.C. No. CV-96-00089-EHC)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(filed Dec.2, 1997.)Tj
T*
0.001 Tc
[(Http://c)5(g)11(i)-1(.ljx)-9(.c)5(om/c)5(g)11(i)-1(-)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
[(bin/f_cat?)-17(/)-3(prod/ljex)-11(t)-3(ra/data/ex)-11(ternal/1997/12/9712004.c09 \(980112\))]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Dig)10(ital Equipment Corp. v. Altavista Technolog)10(y)30( I)23(n)0(c. Civil Action No. 96-)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
(12192NG, March 12, 1997.)Tj
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
(Http://zeus.bna.com/e-law/cases/alta.html \(970925\))Tj
0 -2.36 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Doe v. America Online I)22(n)-1(c., CL)20( 97-63\(Fla. Cir. Ct., P)-5(a)3(lm Beach Co.1997)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(Http://www.navitus.com/icons/networklaw/case_Doe.htm \(971208\))Tj
0 -2.36 TD
[(Hall v. L)21(a)4(ronde, 2d Civil No. B)7(107423\(Super. Ct. No. 165615\)\(Ventura)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0.001 Tc
-0.001 Tw
[(County)31(\))4( J)-10(u)1(ly)31( 8, 1997.)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Http://www.ljx)-10(.com/L)21(J)-11(X)2(files/laronde/laroncourt.html \(971017\))]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
511 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F2 269 0 R
/F3 279 0 R
/F4 275 0 R
/F5 276 0 R
/F6 280 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
513 0 obj
<<
/Length 3109
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 291.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(99)Tj
-14.85 58.94 TD
0 Tw
[(Hearst Corporation Corp. v. Goldberg)10(er, No. 96 CI)23(V.3620 PKL)21( AJ)-11(P, 1997)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(W)-6(L)21(97097 \(S.D.N.Y F)6(e)4(b 26, 1997\))]TJ
T*
[(Http://www.ljx)-10(.com/L)21(J)-11(X)2(files/domainsuits/esqwire.html \(971012\))]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Heroes, I)22(n)-1(c. v. Heroes F)5(oundation, Civ.96-1260 \(D.C.D.C.. Dec. 19, 1996\))]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(Http://zeus.bna.com/e-law/cases/heroes.html \(970925\))Tj
0 -2.36 TD
[(I)23(n)0(set Sy)30(stems, I)23(n)0(c. v. I)23(n)0(struction Set, I)23(n)0(c. 937 F)6(.)0(Supp.161 \(D. Conn.1996\))]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
(April 17, 1996.)Tj
T*
(Http://zeus.bna.com/e-law/cases/inset.html \(970925\))Tj
0 -2.36 TD
[(I)23(n)0(ternational Shoe Co. v. W)-6(a)4(shing)10(t)-2(on \(1945\) 326 U.S. [)-7(90 L)21(.)0(Ed. 95, 102])-7(.)]TJ
T*
[(MAI)23( Sy)30(stems Corporation v. Peak Computer I)23(n)0(c., 991 F)6(.2d 511 \(9)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 433.05 566.91 Tm
0.006 Tc
(th)Tj
12 0 0 12 113.49 547.23 Tm
0 Tc
(Cir.1993\))Tj
0 -1.18 TD
(Http://www.law.seattleu.edu/chonm/Cases/mai.html \(971026\))Tj
0 -2.36 TD
[(Maritz)-6( I)23(n)0(c. v. Cy)30(berg)10(old 947 F)6(.)0( Supp.1328 \(E.D. Mo.1996\).)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(Http://zeus.bna.com/e-law/cases/cy)30(b_g)10(old.html \(970925\))]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
[(MTV Networks v. Curry)30(, 867 F)6(.)0(Supp. 1028 \(C.D.Cal.1994\))]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
(Http://www.law.seattleu.edu/chonm/Cases/mtv.html \(971026\))Tj
0 -2.36 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(NJ)-12(A 1996:74)]TJ
T*
[(NJ)-12(A 1996:79)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Panavision I)23(n)0(ternational, L)21(.)0(P. v. Toeppen, 945 F)6(.)0(Supp. 1296 \(C.D. Cal.)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
(Sept. 19, 1996\).)Tj
T*
[(Http://www.jmls.edu/cy)30(ber/cases/panavis.html)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
[(Pla)4(y)30(boy)30( Ente)4(rprise)4(s I)23(n)0(c)4(.)0( v. Chuc)4(kle)4(b)0(e)4(rry)30( Publishing)10( I)23(n)0(c)4(,)0( Ta)4(tillo Editric)4(e)4(.)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(939 F)6(.)0(Supp.1032 \(S.D.N.Y 1996\) J)-11(une 19, 1996. United States District)]TJ
T*
(Court Southern district of N.Y.)Tj
T*
[(Http://www.jmls.edu/cy)30(ber/cases/play)30(m)-2(en.tx)-10(t)-2( \(970917\))]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Play)29(boy)29( Enterprises, I)22(n)-1(c. v F)5(r)2(ena, 839 F)5(.)-1( Supp. 1552 \(M.D. F)5(l)-3(orida 1993\))]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(Http://www.leepfrog)10(.)0(com/E-L)21(aw/Cases/Play)30(boy)30(_v_F)6(rena.html \(971212\))]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
[(People v. L)21(i)-2(psitz)-6(, NY SupCt, New York County)30(,)0( I)23(ndex)-10( No. 400945/97,)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(6/23/97. Http:www.ljx)-10(.com/internet/lipsdcc.html)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Pres-Kap I)22(n)-1(c. v. Sy)29(stem One, Direct Access I)22(n)-1(c. 636 So.2d 1351 \(F)5(la.)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(App.1994\) Http://www.jmls.edu/cy)29(ber/cases/pres-kap.tx)-11(t)-3( \(980211\))]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
[(Seg)9(a)3( Enterprises L)20(t)-3(d. V. Maphia.)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(http://www.leepfrog)10(.)0(com/E-L)21(aw/Cases/Seg)10(a_v_MAPHI)23(A2.html \(971208\))]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
514 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
516 0 obj
<<
/Length 2351
>>
stream
BT
/F3 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 288.69 38.19 Tm
0 g
BX /GS1 gs EX
0 Tc
(100)Tj
-14.6 58.94 TD
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(S)-5(h)-1(etland News)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(http://www.shetland-news.co.uk/opinion.html \(971006\))Tj
0 -2.36 TD
[(State of Minnesota v. Granite Gate Resorts I)23(n)0(c. 1996 W)-6(L)21( 767431 \(Minn.)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
(Dist. Ct., 2d Dist, Dec. 11, 1996\))Tj
T*
[(Http://www.ag)10(.state.mn.us/consumer/news/OnlineScams/g)10(g)10(R)-3(espB)7(rief.html)]TJ
T*
(\(970920\))Tj
0 -2.36 TD
[(Triad Sy)30(stems Corporation v. Southeastern Ex)-10(press Co., 64 F)6(.3d 1330 \(9)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 463.65 637.71 Tm
0.006 Tc
(th)Tj
12 0 0 12 113.49 618.03 Tm
0 Tc
(Cir.1995\))Tj
0 -1.18 TD
[(Http://www.softwareindustry)30(.org)10(/)-2(software/issues/docs-htm/triad-1.html)]TJ
T*
(Http://www.law.seattleu.edu/chonm/Cases/triad.html \(District court\))Tj
0 -2.36 TD
[(United States v. Thomas 74 F)6(.3d 701 \(6)]TJ
8.04 0 0 8.04 305.01 566.91 Tm
0.006 Tc
(th)Tj
12 0 0 12 311.37 561.39 Tm
0 Tc
[( Cir.\). J)-11(a)4(nuary)30( 29, 1996.)]TJ
-16.49 -1.18 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(Http://www.leepfrog)9(.)-1(com/E-L)20(aw/cases)]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
0 Tc
[(W)-6(a)4(shing)10(t)-2(on Post Company)30( et al. V. Total News I)23(n)0(c., U.S. District Court,)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(Southern District of New York, 97 Civ.1190\(PKL)21(\))3(.)]TJ
T*
[(Http://www.ljx)-10(.com/I)23(nternet/totalse.htm \(971011\))]TJ
T*
[(Http://www.ljx)-10(.com/I)23(nternet/complain.html \(971006\))]TJ
T*
[(http://www.ljx)-10(.com/L)21(J)-11(X)2(files/ticketmaster/complaint.html \(971017\))]TJ
T*
[(http://www.ljx)-10(.com/L)21(J)-11(X)2(files/ticketmaster/answer.html \(971017\))]TJ
T*
[(http://www.ljx)-10(.com/L)21(J)-11(X)2(files/ticketmaster/reply)30(.html \(971017\))]TJ
0 -2.36 TD
[(W)-6(o)0(rld-W)-6(i)-2(de Volksvag)10(en Corp. v. W)-6(oodson, 444 U.S. \(1980\).)]TJ
T*
-0.001 Tc
0.001 Tw
[(Z)10(e)3(ran v. America Online, 958 F)5( Supp.1124 \(E.D. Va. 1997\))]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(Http://www.bna.com/e-law/cases/zeran.html \(971208\))Tj
0 -2.36 TD
[(Z)11(i)-2(ppo Manufacturing)10( Co. v. Z)11(i)-2(ppo Dot Com, I)23(n)0(c. District Court for the)]TJ
0 -1.18 TD
[(W)-6(e)4(stern District of Pennsy)30(l)-2(vania, J)-11(a)4(nuary)30( 16, 1997.)]TJ
T*
(Http://zeus.bna.com/e-law/cases/zippo.html \(970920\))Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
517 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text ]
/Font <<
/F3 279 0 R
>>
/ExtGState <<
/GS1 270 0 R
>>
>>
endobj
518 0 obj
<<
/Type /Halftone
/HalftoneType 1
/HalftoneName (Default)
/Frequency 60
/Angle 45
/SpotFunction /Round
>>
endobj
270 0 obj
<<
/Type /ExtGState
/SA false
/OP false
/HT /Default
>>
endobj
519 0 obj
<<
/Type /FontDescriptor
/Ascent 0
/CapHeight 0
/Descent 0
/Flags 4
/FontBBox [-190 -241 1011 920]
/FontName /LPANAK+Arial.Black0100
/ItalicAngle 0
/StemV 0
/CharSet (/G55/G37/G60/G42/G15/G51/G56/G38/G47/G43/G29/G21/G57/G39/G3/G53/G44/G98/G40/G58/G49/G36/G54/G41/G50/G19)
/FontFile 520 0 R
>>
endobj
520 0 obj
<<
/Length 8508
/Length1 4969
/Length2 3537
/Length3 0
>>
stream
%!FontType1-1.0: LPANAK+Arial.Black0100 1
13 dict begin
/FontName /LPANAK+Arial.Black0100 def
/FontType 1 def
/FontBBox {-389 -493 2070 1884} readonly def
/FontMatrix [0.00049 0 0 0.00049 0 0] readonly def
/PaintType 0 def
/FontInfo 12 dict dup begin
/FullName (Monotype_-_Arial_Black_Regular) def
/FamilyName (Arial_Black) def
/ItalicAngle 0 def
/isFixedPitch false def
/UnderlinePosition -256 def
/UnderlineThickness 123 def
/Weight (Black) def
/BaseFontName (Arial.Black0100) def
end def
/Encoding 256 array
0 1 255 {1 index exch /.notdef put} for
dup 0 /G0 put
dup 1 /G1 put
dup 2 /G2 put
dup 3 /G3 put
dup 4 /G4 put
dup 5 /G5 put
dup 6 /G6 put
dup 7 /G7 put
dup 8 /G8 put
dup 9 /G9 put
dup 10 /G10 put
dup 11 /G11 put
dup 12 /G12 put
dup 13 /G13 put
dup 14 /G14 put
dup 15 /G15 put
dup 16 /G16 put
dup 17 /G17 put
dup 18 /G18 put
dup 19 /G19 put
dup 20 /G20 put
dup 21 /G21 put
dup 22 /G22 put
dup 23 /G23 put
dup 24 /G24 put
dup 25 /G25 put
dup 26 /G26 put
dup 27 /G27 put
dup 28 /G28 put
dup 29 /G29 put
dup 30 /G30 put
dup 31 /G31 put
dup 32 /G32 put
dup 33 /G33 put
dup 34 /G34 put
dup 35 /G35 put
dup 36 /G36 put
dup 37 /G37 put
dup 38 /G38 put
dup 39 /G39 put
dup 40 /G40 put
dup 41 /G41 put
dup 42 /G42 put
dup 43 /G43 put
dup 44 /G44 put
dup 45 /G45 put
dup 46 /G46 put
dup 47 /G47 put
dup 48 /G48 put
dup 49 /G49 put
dup 50 /G50 put
dup 51 /G51 put
dup 52 /G52 put
dup 53 /G53 put
dup 54 /G54 put
dup 55 /G55 put
dup 56 /G56 put
dup 57 /G57 put
dup 58 /G58 put
dup 59 /G59 put
dup 60 /G60 put
dup 61 /G61 put
dup 62 /G62 put
dup 63 /G63 put
dup 64 /G64 put
dup 65 /G65 put
dup 66 /G66 put
dup 67 /G67 put
dup 68 /G68 put
dup 69 /G69 put
dup 70 /G70 put
dup 71 /G71 put
dup 72 /G72 put
dup 73 /G73 put
dup 74 /G74 put
dup 75 /G75 put
dup 76 /G76 put
dup 77 /G77 put
dup 78 /G78 put
dup 79 /G79 put
dup 80 /G80 put
dup 81 /G81 put
dup 82 /G82 put
dup 83 /G83 put
dup 84 /G84 put
dup 85 /G85 put
dup 86 /G86 put
dup 87 /G87 put
dup 88 /G88 put
dup 89 /G89 put
dup 90 /G90 put
dup 91 /G91 put
dup 92 /G92 put
dup 93 /G93 put
dup 94 /G94 put
dup 95 /G95 put
dup 96 /G96 put
dup 97 /G97 put
dup 98 /G98 put
dup 99 /G99 put
dup 100 /G100 put
dup 101 /G101 put
dup 102 /G102 put
dup 103 /G103 put
dup 104 /G104 put
dup 105 /G105 put
dup 106 /G106 put
dup 107 /G107 put
dup 108 /G108 put
dup 109 /G109 put
dup 110 /G110 put
dup 111 /G111 put
dup 112 /G112 put
dup 113 /G113 put
dup 114 /G114 put
dup 115 /G115 put
dup 116 /G116 put
dup 117 /G117 put
dup 118 /G118 put
dup 119 /G119 put
dup 120 /G120 put
dup 121 /G121 put
dup 122 /G122 put
dup 123 /G123 put
dup 124 /G124 put
dup 125 /G125 put
dup 126 /G126 put
dup 127 /G127 put
dup 128 /G128 put
dup 129 /G129 put
dup 130 /G130 put
dup 131 /G131 put
dup 132 /G132 put
dup 133 /G133 put
dup 134 /G134 put
dup 135 /G135 put
dup 136 /G136 put
dup 137 /G137 put
dup 138 /G138 put
dup 139 /G139 put
dup 140 /G140 put
dup 141 /G141 put
dup 142 /G142 put
dup 143 /G143 put
dup 144 /G144 put
dup 145 /G145 put
dup 146 /G146 put
dup 147 /G147 put
dup 148 /G148 put
dup 149 /G149 put
dup 150 /G150 put
dup 151 /G151 put
dup 152 /G152 put
dup 153 /G153 put
dup 154 /G154 put
dup 155 /G155 put
dup 156 /G156 put
dup 157 /G157 put
dup 158 /G158 put
dup 159 /G159 put
dup 160 /G160 put
dup 161 /G161 put
dup 162 /G162 put
dup 163 /G163 put
dup 164 /G164 put
dup 165 /G165 put
dup 166 /G166 put
dup 167 /G167 put
dup 168 /G168 put
dup 169 /G169 put
dup 170 /G170 put
dup 171 /G171 put
dup 172 /G172 put
dup 173 /G173 put
dup 174 /G174 put
dup 175 /G175 put
dup 176 /G176 put
dup 177 /G177 put
dup 178 /G178 put
dup 179 /G179 put
dup 180 /G180 put
dup 181 /G181 put
dup 182 /G182 put
dup 183 /G183 put
dup 184 /G184 put
dup 185 /G185 put
dup 186 /G186 put
dup 187 /G187 put
dup 188 /G188 put
dup 189 /G189 put
dup 190 /G190 put
dup 191 /G191 put
dup 192 /G192 put
dup 193 /G193 put
dup 194 /G194 put
dup 195 /G195 put
dup 196 /G196 put
dup 197 /G197 put
dup 198 /G198 put
dup 199 /G199 put
dup 200 /G200 put
dup 201 /G201 put
dup 202 /G202 put
dup 203 /G203 put
dup 204 /G204 put
dup 205 /G205 put
dup 206 /G206 put
dup 207 /G207 put
dup 208 /G208 put
dup 209 /G209 put
dup 210 /G210 put
dup 211 /G211 put
dup 212 /G212 put
dup 213 /G213 put
dup 214 /G214 put
dup 215 /G215 put
dup 216 /G216 put
dup 217 /G217 put
dup 218 /G218 put
dup 219 /G219 put
dup 220 /G220 put
dup 221 /G221 put
dup 222 /G222 put
dup 223 /G223 put
dup 224 /G224 put
dup 225 /G225 put
dup 226 /G226 put
dup 227 /G227 put
dup 228 /G228 put
dup 229 /G229 put
dup 230 /G230 put
dup 231 /G231 put
dup 232 /G232 put
dup 233 /G233 put
dup 234 /G234 put
dup 235 /G235 put
dup 236 /G236 put
dup 237 /G237 put
dup 238 /G238 put
dup 239 /G239 put
dup 240 /G240 put
dup 241 /G241 put
dup 242 /G242 put
dup 243 /G243 put
dup 244 /G244 put
dup 245 /G245 put
dup 246 /G246 put
dup 247 /G247 put
dup 248 /G248 put
dup 249 /G249 put
dup 250 /G250 put
dup 251 /G251 put
dup 252 /G252 put
dup 253 /G253 put
dup 254 /G254 put
readonly def
currentdict end
currentfile eexec
ݸ !]/2.l&>mY݆ݼCN1Ƃb<5[9cGρ#^:%2moi/z*+,Qj83#aX#f_
}c'"߬C۲v#i
"-F=$ޢ\^h5p <zL(v
<>DeH(\BTQt0ョ-}%[M{D)uYyn/|I6BK3IΔ9r)<p?t×+ 4Q.lo{ܧZ;a&h)q =Vhw4hȲ}K7AKe:{lО-
gX!=H2/F 6gqH(!'/n@)w5րfr9~10|ذ"]z^7bK(K$Fձc.ĩd
xB@oGWի.^|š_-B|pWHKԔv؏.*6v)N:
|,cri,[1vܙGB~*Wh} 4vwL!4]XXzF]Qw.n&H $#6αnC.e9_=kS ^nU2ȓ?N@*Mod2A
^ty^P>-WXqͦzaa1,Uy#.A]&8Si[&zkJ/r2S"1#
]Wωb-k\d]6Ej5c6Ȃ]2fv{o' j4pt,IBV8a.h چ5c M͓@ӿ!:Rf7# fp?=c2[g.
qV{?Aǜ6~tw};ʃ3{w/1uЁ4d*-ng
1Mwz<T$p ~2Qd7[ siJm(Wl~j8~
_3t-prFYOP2yi qB{1W@Kʏ˃Rd-;ޕ ߖcCl8NW @?yjbV\=np-tУjȬZ
KBd\`8=-Ť^zUWgO`!_۸زE+N8.i'abO1-mX
tϥNnƀz-Ѻq4N7x<07}zNF