Skip to main content

LUP Student Papers

LUND UNIVERSITY LIBRARIES

Legal analysis of an EU DST: Is there a legal basis for it under EU law and would it violate the EU's duty to respect international law?

Egger, Tobias LU (2023) HARN60 20231
Department of Business Law
Abstract
This thesis examines a potential EU digital services tax under two aspects. Those are first, whether a sufficient legal basis is given for it within EU law and second, whether it would violate the EU’s duty to respect international law. To make the analysis more tangible it is based on the directive proposal for such a tax from 2018.
In the first content part the concept of a digital services tax is explained, and its nature is examined. The major issue discussed here is, whether the tax can be classified as a turnover tax, a general indirect tax, or a direct tax under EU law. In this regard, the thesis qualifies a DST as a direct tax.
The second content part of the thesis deals with a potential legal basis. Examined are Art. 113, 115... (More)
This thesis examines a potential EU digital services tax under two aspects. Those are first, whether a sufficient legal basis is given for it within EU law and second, whether it would violate the EU’s duty to respect international law. To make the analysis more tangible it is based on the directive proposal for such a tax from 2018.
In the first content part the concept of a digital services tax is explained, and its nature is examined. The major issue discussed here is, whether the tax can be classified as a turnover tax, a general indirect tax, or a direct tax under EU law. In this regard, the thesis qualifies a DST as a direct tax.
The second content part of the thesis deals with a potential legal basis. Examined are Art. 113, 115 and 116 TFEU. The focus lies on Art. 115 TFEU. For this provision its material requirement and the principles of subsidiarity and proportionality are examined, and it is concluded that a DST would not fulfil the material requirement and that it violates the two principles.
The last content part examines a violation of the EU’s duty to respect international law. The focus here lies on the principle of territoriality, as a digital services tax would not be dependent
on an actual physical presence within the territory of its taxed subjects. Nonetheless, the principle of nationality is also mentioned. For both principles the outcome of the research is
that a DST would not violate them. (Less)
Please use this url to cite or link to this publication:
author
Egger, Tobias LU
supervisor
organization
course
HARN60 20231
year
type
H1 - Master's Degree (One Year)
subject
keywords
Digital Services Tax, EU law, Art. 115 TFEU, Principle of territoriality, nexus requirement
language
English
id
9123151
date added to LUP
2023-06-15 11:02:30
date last changed
2023-06-15 11:02:30
@misc{9123151,
  abstract     = {{This thesis examines a potential EU digital services tax under two aspects. Those are first, whether a sufficient legal basis is given for it within EU law and second, whether it would violate the EU’s duty to respect international law. To make the analysis more tangible it is based on the directive proposal for such a tax from 2018.
In the first content part the concept of a digital services tax is explained, and its nature is examined. The major issue discussed here is, whether the tax can be classified as a turnover tax, a general indirect tax, or a direct tax under EU law. In this regard, the thesis qualifies a DST as a direct tax.
The second content part of the thesis deals with a potential legal basis. Examined are Art. 113, 115 and 116 TFEU. The focus lies on Art. 115 TFEU. For this provision its material requirement and the principles of subsidiarity and proportionality are examined, and it is concluded that a DST would not fulfil the material requirement and that it violates the two principles.
The last content part examines a violation of the EU’s duty to respect international law. The focus here lies on the principle of territoriality, as a digital services tax would not be dependent 
on an actual physical presence within the territory of its taxed subjects. Nonetheless, the principle of nationality is also mentioned. For both principles the outcome of the research is 
that a DST would not violate them.}},
  author       = {{Egger, Tobias}},
  language     = {{eng}},
  note         = {{Student Paper}},
  title        = {{Legal analysis of an EU DST: Is there a legal basis for it under EU law and would it violate the EU's duty to respect international law?}},
  year         = {{2023}},
}