Advanced

"'We Can't Just Do It Any Which Way' – Objectivity Work among Swedish Prosecutors"

Jacobsson, Katarina LU (2008) In Qualitative Sociology Review 4(1). p.46-67
Abstract
Objectivity is a principle widely acknowledged and honoured in contemporary society. Rather than treating objectivity as an a priori defined category to be tested empirically, I refer to the construction of objectivity as it is accomplished in practice as “objectivity work” and consider how Swedish prosecutors in interviews make and communicatively realize (i.e. “make real”) its claims. In analyzing two facets of objectivity work – maintaining objectivity and responses to objectivity violations – seven mechanisms are identified: appeals to (1) regulation, (2) duty, and (3) professionalism; responses to violations by (4) incantations of objectivity, (5) corrections, (6) proclamation by contrast, and (7) appeals to human fallibility.... (More)
Objectivity is a principle widely acknowledged and honoured in contemporary society. Rather than treating objectivity as an a priori defined category to be tested empirically, I refer to the construction of objectivity as it is accomplished in practice as “objectivity work” and consider how Swedish prosecutors in interviews make and communicatively realize (i.e. “make real”) its claims. In analyzing two facets of objectivity work – maintaining objectivity and responses to objectivity violations – seven mechanisms are identified: appeals to (1) regulation, (2) duty, and (3) professionalism; responses to violations by (4) incantations of objectivity, (5) corrections, (6) proclamation by contrast, and (7) appeals to human fallibility. Directions for future research emphasize cross-cultural and cross-occupational comparisons, not only within the judiciary as objectivity is of a general concern in any area where disinterested truths are claimed. The concept of objectivity work allows one to study how various actors bring principle into everyday life. (Less)
Please use this url to cite or link to this publication:
author
organization
publishing date
type
Contribution to journal
publication status
published
subject
keywords
Ethnomethodology, Accounts, Objectivity work, Prosecutors, Sweden, Constructionism
in
Qualitative Sociology Review
volume
4
issue
1
pages
46 - 67
publisher
Lodz University
ISSN
1733-8077
language
English
LU publication?
yes
id
fe637c54-c503-4fd0-a49a-4cddea8175ba (old id 1359469)
date added to LUP
2009-03-12 17:02:12
date last changed
2016-04-16 11:23:38
@misc{fe637c54-c503-4fd0-a49a-4cddea8175ba,
  abstract     = {Objectivity is a principle widely acknowledged and honoured in contemporary society. Rather than treating objectivity as an a priori defined category to be tested empirically, I refer to the construction of objectivity as it is accomplished in practice as “objectivity work” and consider how Swedish prosecutors in interviews make and communicatively realize (i.e. “make real”) its claims. In analyzing two facets of objectivity work – maintaining objectivity and responses to objectivity violations – seven mechanisms are identified: appeals to (1) regulation, (2) duty, and (3) professionalism; responses to violations by (4) incantations of objectivity, (5) corrections, (6) proclamation by contrast, and (7) appeals to human fallibility. Directions for future research emphasize cross-cultural and cross-occupational comparisons, not only within the judiciary as objectivity is of a general concern in any area where disinterested truths are claimed. The concept of objectivity work allows one to study how various actors bring principle into everyday life.},
  author       = {Jacobsson, Katarina},
  issn         = {1733-8077},
  keyword      = {Ethnomethodology,Accounts,Objectivity work,Prosecutors,Sweden,Constructionism},
  language     = {eng},
  number       = {1},
  pages        = {46--67},
  publisher    = {ARRAY(0x888d240)},
  series       = {Qualitative Sociology Review},
  title        = {"'We Can't Just Do It Any Which Way' – Objectivity Work among Swedish Prosecutors"},
  volume       = {4},
  year         = {2008},
}