Integrating Indigenous perspectives for a just energy transition of Saskatchewan
(2024) In IIIEE Master Thesis IMEM02 20241The International Institute for Industrial Environmental Economics
- Abstract
- Canada pledged to achieve net zero by 2050 and important efforts revolving around the energy transition of electricity generation systems toward renewables sources are being carried. Currently, most renewable systems developed are occurring on Indigenous communities’ lands for various reasons. Climatic conditions are suitable for solar and wind-based solutions, space is available, and this trend constitutes an opportunity for the economic development and diversification of Indigenous communities.
However, several scholars argue that renewable electricity production projects do not integrate sufficiently Indigenous perspectives as Indigenous communities are still more considered stakeholders that must be consulted rather than partners... (More) - Canada pledged to achieve net zero by 2050 and important efforts revolving around the energy transition of electricity generation systems toward renewables sources are being carried. Currently, most renewable systems developed are occurring on Indigenous communities’ lands for various reasons. Climatic conditions are suitable for solar and wind-based solutions, space is available, and this trend constitutes an opportunity for the economic development and diversification of Indigenous communities.
However, several scholars argue that renewable electricity production projects do not integrate sufficiently Indigenous perspectives as Indigenous communities are still more considered stakeholders that must be consulted rather than partners involved in decision making. According to energy justice scholars, this results in the occultation of several environmental and cultural impacts while the integration of Indigenous views could lead to higher sustainability thanks to higher considerations for nature and benefits for the community. These researchers question the sustainability of an energy transition maintaining Indigenous communities in a situation of dependency and increasing inequalities, instead of becoming participants to their own electric systems, as a crucial step towards the respect of their right to self-determination.
This thesis explores the impacts of provincial policies on shaping the conditions of the dialogue among actors involved in renewable electricity generation projects. Using the concepts of “shared visions” and “collaboration” developed by Transition Management scholars, this paper interrogates the challenges and success of the different provinces in integrating Indigenous communities as partners. A comparative study, based on interviews and a review of documents made by provincial governments and energy developers, has been carried to assess how Saskatchewan, a province located in the center south of Canada, could improve its existing supportive mechanisms toward a better integration of Indigenous perspectives in renewable electricity generation projects.
This thesis demonstrates that important efforts have been carried by developmental agencies, provincial governments, and advocacy groups across Canada, including Saskatchewan, to advance Indigenous inclusion in renewable energy projects. They have contributed to change stakeholders’ perceptions on Indigenous communities which are increasingly considered. Moreover, Indigenous capacities to get involved in projects have largerly improved in the recent years thanks to provincial and federal programs.
Nevertheless, in Sasaktchewan, actors’ sensitivity to Indigenous perspectives is still limited to experts and frontrunners. Compared to northern provinces and British Columbia, collaboration is still at its early stages and most times Indigenous communities must acquire a majority shares in projects to be integrated in decision making. The idea of a shared vision on sustainability is still far along the road and a stronger political stance promoting Indigenous involvement into renewable electricity projects is needed. In Saskatchewan compared to other provinces, indigenous communities face a stronger lack of interests and trust from energy developers to engage in partnerships due to lower public policies incentives. While provincial characteristics play a crucial role in defining political landscapes and interventionism possibilities, it seems that Saskatchewan could implement more ambitious mechanisms to promote shared sustainability visions and collaboration in renewable electricity projects. (Less)
Please use this url to cite or link to this publication:
http://lup.lub.lu.se/student-papers/record/9170896
- author
- Chiarello Coupinot, Guilhem Antoine LU
- supervisor
-
- Lena Neij LU
- organization
- course
- IMEM02 20241
- year
- 2024
- type
- H2 - Master's Degree (Two Years)
- subject
- keywords
- Indigenous communities’ perspectives, shared sustainability vision, collaboration, renewable energy transition, Canada, Saskatchewan.
- publication/series
- IIIEE Master Thesis
- report number
- 2024.29
- ISSN
- 1401-9191
- language
- English
- id
- 9170896
- date added to LUP
- 2024-08-01 10:55:49
- date last changed
- 2024-08-01 10:55:49
@misc{9170896,
abstract = {{Canada pledged to achieve net zero by 2050 and important efforts revolving around the energy transition of electricity generation systems toward renewables sources are being carried. Currently, most renewable systems developed are occurring on Indigenous communities’ lands for various reasons. Climatic conditions are suitable for solar and wind-based solutions, space is available, and this trend constitutes an opportunity for the economic development and diversification of Indigenous communities.
However, several scholars argue that renewable electricity production projects do not integrate sufficiently Indigenous perspectives as Indigenous communities are still more considered stakeholders that must be consulted rather than partners involved in decision making. According to energy justice scholars, this results in the occultation of several environmental and cultural impacts while the integration of Indigenous views could lead to higher sustainability thanks to higher considerations for nature and benefits for the community. These researchers question the sustainability of an energy transition maintaining Indigenous communities in a situation of dependency and increasing inequalities, instead of becoming participants to their own electric systems, as a crucial step towards the respect of their right to self-determination.
This thesis explores the impacts of provincial policies on shaping the conditions of the dialogue among actors involved in renewable electricity generation projects. Using the concepts of “shared visions” and “collaboration” developed by Transition Management scholars, this paper interrogates the challenges and success of the different provinces in integrating Indigenous communities as partners. A comparative study, based on interviews and a review of documents made by provincial governments and energy developers, has been carried to assess how Saskatchewan, a province located in the center south of Canada, could improve its existing supportive mechanisms toward a better integration of Indigenous perspectives in renewable electricity generation projects.
This thesis demonstrates that important efforts have been carried by developmental agencies, provincial governments, and advocacy groups across Canada, including Saskatchewan, to advance Indigenous inclusion in renewable energy projects. They have contributed to change stakeholders’ perceptions on Indigenous communities which are increasingly considered. Moreover, Indigenous capacities to get involved in projects have largerly improved in the recent years thanks to provincial and federal programs.
Nevertheless, in Sasaktchewan, actors’ sensitivity to Indigenous perspectives is still limited to experts and frontrunners. Compared to northern provinces and British Columbia, collaboration is still at its early stages and most times Indigenous communities must acquire a majority shares in projects to be integrated in decision making. The idea of a shared vision on sustainability is still far along the road and a stronger political stance promoting Indigenous involvement into renewable electricity projects is needed. In Saskatchewan compared to other provinces, indigenous communities face a stronger lack of interests and trust from energy developers to engage in partnerships due to lower public policies incentives. While provincial characteristics play a crucial role in defining political landscapes and interventionism possibilities, it seems that Saskatchewan could implement more ambitious mechanisms to promote shared sustainability visions and collaboration in renewable electricity projects.}},
author = {{Chiarello Coupinot, Guilhem Antoine}},
issn = {{1401-9191}},
language = {{eng}},
note = {{Student Paper}},
series = {{IIIEE Master Thesis}},
title = {{Integrating Indigenous perspectives for a just energy transition of Saskatchewan}},
year = {{2024}},
}