Advanced

Sinners and citizens: Bestiality and homosexuality in Sweden

Rydström, Jens LU (2001)
Abstract
This study is based on an analysis of more than 2,300 court cases concerning acts of bestiality and

same-sex sexuality in rural and urban Sweden 1880–1950. Other written sources are forensic psychi-

atric statements, mental hospital records, material from the Swedish Sex Reform movement, news-

papers and scientific journals, and minutes of the Swedish Parliament and its subcommittees. In

cooperation with the Nordiska Museet - The National Museum of Cultural History, a questionnaire

was sent out to 286 informers born before 1945, asking about attitudes to bestiality and same-sex

sexuality in their childhood. Finally, a limited number of interviews has been used.

The... (More)
This study is based on an analysis of more than 2,300 court cases concerning acts of bestiality and

same-sex sexuality in rural and urban Sweden 1880–1950. Other written sources are forensic psychi-

atric statements, mental hospital records, material from the Swedish Sex Reform movement, news-

papers and scientific journals, and minutes of the Swedish Parliament and its subcommittees. In

cooperation with the Nordiska Museet - The National Museum of Cultural History, a questionnaire

was sent out to 286 informers born before 1945, asking about attitudes to bestiality and same-sex

sexuality in their childhood. Finally, a limited number of interviews has been used.

The material is analysed on two levels: the level of social control and the level of sexual practice.

This allows the author to use the sources partly as remnants of the regulatory practice of the judicial

system, and partly as a second hand source of the personal lives of those who were prosecuted for

these crimes. The method is a mixture of quantitative analysis of all the court cases and close reading

and analysis of the contents of each case. Parameters as class, age and gender are especially investig-

ated, in order to place the development of the understanding of sexuality in a social context.

The dissertation argues that Sweden underwent a paradigm shift during the twentieth century –

with the 1930s as the most important breaking point – from a rural penetrative sodomy paradigm, to

an urban masturbatory homosexual paradigm. The paradigm shift was the result of deep-going social

and demographic change in Sweden, but more specifically, it had to do with the production of new

sexological knowledge. In the dichotomy homosexuality/heterosexuality, bestiality had no place and

was never seen as a sexual deviance in its own right. In rural areas, however, the older paradigm

lingered on. On the level of social control, medical science gave new incentives and new methods for

control of sexual deviance. Commitment to mental hospitals, hormonal treatment and castrations were

used to neutralise unwanted manifestations of same-sex sexual behaviour.

Sweden, unlike most other European countries, included women in the ban on bestiality and

”unnatural fornication.” However, women were only rarely prosecuted. Of the 2,333 court cases

under study, only 12 concern same-sex sexuality between women, and no women were prosecuted

for sexual acts with animals. Lesbian identity was discussed and redefined in the 1930s, and most

court cases concerning sex between women are from the 1940s, when the legislators actively sought

knowledge about female homosexuality. The new urban masturbatory paradigm of homosexuality

facilitated the inclusion of same-sex sexuality between women in the legal and medical discourses. (Less)
Please use this url to cite or link to this publication:
author
opponent
  • Professor Chauncey, George, University of Chicago
publishing date
type
Thesis
publication status
published
subject
keywords
queer theory, Swedish history, welfare state, modernity, sexual history, bestiality, homosexuality, sodomy, gay and lesbian history, gender, medical discourse, legal discourse
pages
401 pages
publisher
Stockholm University
defense location
G-salen, Stockholm University
defense date
2001-07-02 10:00
ISBN
91-7265-284-5
language
English
LU publication?
no
id
7eaa9b54-f012-4027-9b9b-8af7f41dbfb6 (old id 1763915)
date added to LUP
2011-02-17 16:44:53
date last changed
2016-09-19 08:45:06
@phdthesis{7eaa9b54-f012-4027-9b9b-8af7f41dbfb6,
  abstract     = {This study is based on an analysis of more than 2,300 court cases concerning acts of bestiality and <br/><br>
same-sex sexuality in rural and urban Sweden 1880–1950. Other written sources are forensic psychi- <br/><br>
atric statements, mental hospital records, material from the Swedish Sex Reform movement, news- <br/><br>
papers and scientific journals, and minutes of the Swedish Parliament and its subcommittees. In <br/><br>
cooperation with the Nordiska Museet - The National Museum of Cultural History, a questionnaire <br/><br>
was sent out to 286 informers born before 1945, asking about attitudes to bestiality and same-sex <br/><br>
sexuality in their childhood. Finally, a limited number of interviews has been used. <br/><br>
The material is analysed on two levels: the level of social control and the level of sexual practice. <br/><br>
This allows the author to use the sources partly as remnants of the regulatory practice of the judicial <br/><br>
system, and partly as a second hand source of the personal lives of those who were prosecuted for <br/><br>
these crimes. The method is a mixture of quantitative analysis of all the court cases and close reading <br/><br>
and analysis of the contents of each case. Parameters as class, age and gender are especially investig- <br/><br>
ated, in order to place the development of the understanding of sexuality in a social context. <br/><br>
The dissertation argues that Sweden underwent a paradigm shift during the twentieth century – <br/><br>
with the 1930s as the most important breaking point – from a rural penetrative sodomy paradigm, to <br/><br>
an urban masturbatory homosexual paradigm. The paradigm shift was the result of deep-going social <br/><br>
and demographic change in Sweden, but more specifically, it had to do with the production of new <br/><br>
sexological knowledge. In the dichotomy homosexuality/heterosexuality, bestiality had no place and <br/><br>
was never seen as a sexual deviance in its own right. In rural areas, however, the older paradigm <br/><br>
lingered on. On the level of social control, medical science gave new incentives and new methods for <br/><br>
control of sexual deviance. Commitment to mental hospitals, hormonal treatment and castrations were <br/><br>
used to neutralise unwanted manifestations of same-sex sexual behaviour. <br/><br>
Sweden, unlike most other European countries, included women in the ban on bestiality and <br/><br>
”unnatural fornication.” However, women were only rarely prosecuted. Of the 2,333 court cases <br/><br>
under study, only 12 concern same-sex sexuality between women, and no women were prosecuted <br/><br>
for sexual acts with animals. Lesbian identity was discussed and redefined in the 1930s, and most <br/><br>
court cases concerning sex between women are from the 1940s, when the legislators actively sought <br/><br>
knowledge about female homosexuality. The new urban masturbatory paradigm of homosexuality <br/><br>
facilitated the inclusion of same-sex sexuality between women in the legal and medical discourses.},
  author       = {Rydström, Jens},
  isbn         = {91-7265-284-5},
  keyword      = {queer theory,Swedish history,welfare state,modernity,sexual history,bestiality,homosexuality,sodomy,gay and lesbian history,gender,medical discourse,legal discourse},
  language     = {eng},
  pages        = {401},
  publisher    = {Stockholm University},
  title        = {Sinners and citizens: Bestiality and homosexuality in Sweden},
  year         = {2001},
}