Advanced

Two claims about potential human beings

Persson, Ingmar LU (2003) In Bioethics 17(5-6). p.503-516
Abstract
It seems that at conception something is formed which, due to its genetic make-up, has the potentiality to develop into a full-blown human being. Many believe that in virtue of this potentiality, this organism, the human zygote or early embryo, has an intrinsic value which makes it wrong to use or produce it merely as a means to some end, e.g., some scientific end such as to produce embryonic stem cells. Against this it is here argued, first, that it does not follow from the fact that something has a potential to become a (fully developed) human being that it already is a human being (in a rudimentary sense). In fact, a human being begins to exist no earlier than a couple of weeks after conception, at the stage known as gastrulation. Thus,... (More)
It seems that at conception something is formed which, due to its genetic make-up, has the potentiality to develop into a full-blown human being. Many believe that in virtue of this potentiality, this organism, the human zygote or early embryo, has an intrinsic value which makes it wrong to use or produce it merely as a means to some end, e.g., some scientific end such as to produce embryonic stem cells. Against this it is here argued, first, that it does not follow from the fact that something has a potential to become a (fully developed) human being that it already is a human being (in a rudimentary sense). In fact, a human being begins to exist no earlier than a couple of weeks after conception, at the stage known as gastrulation. Thus, even granted the questionable assumption that something has intrinsic value in virtue of being a human being, the zygote will not have intrinsic value. Secondly, the value an embryo has in virtue of its potentiality to become a full-blown human being can only be instrumental, a value as a means. But Of course it cannot be wrong to treat that which has merely instrumental value as a mere means or instrument to some end. (Less)
Please use this url to cite or link to this publication:
author
organization
publishing date
type
Contribution to journal
publication status
published
subject
in
Bioethics
volume
17
issue
5-6
pages
503 - 516
publisher
Wiley-Blackwell
external identifiers
  • wos:000186065000011
  • pmid:14959719
  • scopus:0142177982
ISSN
0269-9702
DOI
language
English
LU publication?
yes
id
978be374-5cd5-4634-86a8-ba2eb5e0bede (old id 298114)
date added to LUP
2007-09-20 09:18:22
date last changed
2018-05-29 12:31:48
@article{978be374-5cd5-4634-86a8-ba2eb5e0bede,
  abstract     = {It seems that at conception something is formed which, due to its genetic make-up, has the potentiality to develop into a full-blown human being. Many believe that in virtue of this potentiality, this organism, the human zygote or early embryo, has an intrinsic value which makes it wrong to use or produce it merely as a means to some end, e.g., some scientific end such as to produce embryonic stem cells. Against this it is here argued, first, that it does not follow from the fact that something has a potential to become a (fully developed) human being that it already is a human being (in a rudimentary sense). In fact, a human being begins to exist no earlier than a couple of weeks after conception, at the stage known as gastrulation. Thus, even granted the questionable assumption that something has intrinsic value in virtue of being a human being, the zygote will not have intrinsic value. Secondly, the value an embryo has in virtue of its potentiality to become a full-blown human being can only be instrumental, a value as a means. But Of course it cannot be wrong to treat that which has merely instrumental value as a mere means or instrument to some end.},
  author       = {Persson, Ingmar},
  issn         = {0269-9702},
  language     = {eng},
  number       = {5-6},
  pages        = {503--516},
  publisher    = {Wiley-Blackwell},
  series       = {Bioethics},
  title        = {Two claims about potential human beings},
  url          = {http://dx.doi.org/},
  volume       = {17},
  year         = {2003},
}