Advanced

From a liberal to a Social Democratic welfare state: the policy transfer of the UK Compact?

Johansson, Håkan LU and Johansson, Mairon (2012) In Nonprofit Policy Forum 3(2).
Abstract
England was one of the first countries to install a Compact to regulate the relationship between state and civil society and since then several other countries have followed and initiated national Agreements, Charters or Concordats. Despite a growing academic interest into such national Compact models we have insufficient knowledge of how such ideas ‘from abroad’ are adapted and molded to fit with ‘domestic’ legacies, institutions and power disparities. The purpose of this article is to analyse the translation of the English Compact into a Swedish context and above all how domestic Civil Society Organizations (CSOs) acted to adjust such an international model to a national context. The article draws upon studies of written documents and... (More)
England was one of the first countries to install a Compact to regulate the relationship between state and civil society and since then several other countries have followed and initiated national Agreements, Charters or Concordats. Despite a growing academic interest into such national Compact models we have insufficient knowledge of how such ideas ‘from abroad’ are adapted and molded to fit with ‘domestic’ legacies, institutions and power disparities. The purpose of this article is to analyse the translation of the English Compact into a Swedish context and above all how domestic Civil Society Organizations (CSOs) acted to adjust such an international model to a national context. The article draws upon studies of written documents and interviews with key actors (politicians and CSO representatives) and two main conclusions are being presented. First, the article demonstrates that CSOs played an important role as translation agents as they identified the Compact idea long before key decision makers did, yet that the complete translation of the Compact model into a Swedish context was dependent upon the political will and ownership of central decision-makers. Second, the article demonstrates that the translation process was not as ordered as sometimes depicted within the translation literature and instead chains of translation processes was detected. These findings address a need to open up the translation perspective for the analysis of multiple types of translation agents and to understand translation as a nested process, in which one translation process might very well be interrelated with other parallel translation processes. (Less)
Please use this url to cite or link to this publication:
author
organization
publishing date
type
Contribution to journal
publication status
published
subject
keywords
Civil Society Organisations, Translation, NGOs, Compac models, Social democratic welfare state
in
Nonprofit Policy Forum
volume
3
issue
2
publisher
De Gruyter
ISSN
2194-6035
language
English
LU publication?
yes
id
d8d4d8fb-edd1-4aee-9598-e767241d2708 (old id 3631374)
date added to LUP
2013-04-08 11:27:29
date last changed
2016-04-15 13:38:45
@article{d8d4d8fb-edd1-4aee-9598-e767241d2708,
  abstract     = {England was one of the first countries to install a Compact to regulate the relationship between state and civil society and since then several other countries have followed and initiated national Agreements, Charters or Concordats. Despite a growing academic interest into such national Compact models we have insufficient knowledge of how such ideas ‘from abroad’ are adapted and molded to fit with ‘domestic’ legacies, institutions and power disparities. The purpose of this article is to analyse the translation of the English Compact into a Swedish context and above all how domestic Civil Society Organizations (CSOs) acted to adjust such an international model to a national context. The article draws upon studies of written documents and interviews with key actors (politicians and CSO representatives) and two main conclusions are being presented. First, the article demonstrates that CSOs played an important role as translation agents as they identified the Compact idea long before key decision makers did, yet that the complete translation of the Compact model into a Swedish context was dependent upon the political will and ownership of central decision-makers. Second, the article demonstrates that the translation process was not as ordered as sometimes depicted within the translation literature and instead chains of translation processes was detected. These findings address a need to open up the translation perspective for the analysis of multiple types of translation agents and to understand translation as a nested process, in which one translation process might very well be interrelated with other parallel translation processes.},
  author       = {Johansson, Håkan and Johansson, Mairon},
  issn         = {2194-6035},
  keyword      = {Civil Society Organisations,Translation,NGOs,Compac models,Social democratic welfare state},
  language     = {eng},
  number       = {2},
  publisher    = {De Gruyter},
  series       = {Nonprofit Policy Forum},
  title        = {From a liberal to a Social Democratic welfare state: the policy transfer of the UK Compact?},
  volume       = {3},
  year         = {2012},
}