Skip to main content

Lund University Publications

LUND UNIVERSITY LIBRARIES

Aristocrats and Refined Peasants : The Concept of Aristocracy in Swedish Historiography

Isacsson, Alexander LU (2024) In Royal Studies Journal 11(1). p.45-81
Abstract
This article investigates the evolution of aristocracy as a concept in Swedish historiography from the early nineteenth century to the present. In the political climate of the early 1800s, aristocracy became an increasingly contested concept, as reflected in ordinary language and the writing of national histories. A scholarly debate over anti-aristocratic prejudice between the historians Anders Fryxell and Erik Gustaf Geijer in the 1840s illustrates contemporary concerns to define the Swedish aristocracy and its relation to the nation. The debate gave rise to a persistent yet adaptable dualistic view of history, enduring well into the twentieth century. Historians portrayed monarchs, aristocrats, nobles, and peasants in a dualistic manner,... (More)
This article investigates the evolution of aristocracy as a concept in Swedish historiography from the early nineteenth century to the present. In the political climate of the early 1800s, aristocracy became an increasingly contested concept, as reflected in ordinary language and the writing of national histories. A scholarly debate over anti-aristocratic prejudice between the historians Anders Fryxell and Erik Gustaf Geijer in the 1840s illustrates contemporary concerns to define the Swedish aristocracy and its relation to the nation. The debate gave rise to a persistent yet adaptable dualistic view of history, enduring well into the twentieth century. Historians portrayed monarchs, aristocrats, nobles, and peasants in a dualistic manner, dividing social groups into two oppositional forces. By emphasising the agency of freeholding peasants, notions of a Swedish Sonderweg were reinforced, facilitating the conceptualisation of peasant aristocrats. In tracing this historical trajectory, the article demonstrates how the meaning of aristocracy has evolved in response to scholarly objectives and historiographical trends. (Less)
Please use this url to cite or link to this publication:
author
publishing date
type
Contribution to journal
publication status
published
subject
keywords
aristocracyanti, anti-aristocratic prejudice, Sweden, historiography, peasant elites
in
Royal Studies Journal
volume
11
issue
1
pages
45 - 81
ISSN
2057-6730
language
English
LU publication?
no
id
3a57aee7-2df7-4a18-ab22-c7d5a2bac80e
alternative location
https://rsj.winchester.ac.uk/articles/438
date added to LUP
2024-06-06 16:16:25
date last changed
2024-06-19 15:39:47
@article{3a57aee7-2df7-4a18-ab22-c7d5a2bac80e,
  abstract     = {{This article investigates the evolution of aristocracy as a concept in Swedish historiography from the early nineteenth century to the present. In the political climate of the early 1800s, aristocracy became an increasingly contested concept, as reflected in ordinary language and the writing of national histories. A scholarly debate over anti-aristocratic prejudice between the historians Anders Fryxell and Erik Gustaf Geijer in the 1840s illustrates contemporary concerns to define the Swedish aristocracy and its relation to the nation. The debate gave rise to a persistent yet adaptable dualistic view of history, enduring well into the twentieth century. Historians portrayed monarchs, aristocrats, nobles, and peasants in a dualistic manner, dividing social groups into two oppositional forces. By emphasising the agency of freeholding peasants, notions of a Swedish Sonderweg were reinforced, facilitating the conceptualisation of peasant aristocrats. In tracing this historical trajectory, the article demonstrates how the meaning of aristocracy has evolved in response to scholarly objectives and historiographical trends.}},
  author       = {{Isacsson, Alexander}},
  issn         = {{2057-6730}},
  keywords     = {{aristocracyanti; anti-aristocratic prejudice; Sweden; historiography; peasant elites}},
  language     = {{eng}},
  number       = {{1}},
  pages        = {{45--81}},
  series       = {{Royal Studies Journal}},
  title        = {{Aristocrats and Refined Peasants : The Concept of Aristocracy in Swedish Historiography}},
  url          = {{https://rsj.winchester.ac.uk/articles/438}},
  volume       = {{11}},
  year         = {{2024}},
}