Advanced

Aligning normativity with Luhmann for a critical study of industrial relations

Hartzén, Ann-Christine LU (2019) In Retfærd: Nordisk juridisk tidsskrift p.9-19
Abstract
This article examines the possibility for conducting an empirical analysis of a system of industrial relations using Luhmann’s theory on autopoietic systems as a framework of analysis, but aligning that analysis with the aspirations of critical theory. The article provides a methodological contribution and based on the dual understanding of the concept of values as containing both a positivistic and a normative character, the article identifies a methodological model. Through the application of this methodological model, analysing the empirical material in two steps, the researcher will be able to conduct an analysis that can generate conclusions holding normative aspirations. This is possible since the model will allow the researcher to... (More)
This article examines the possibility for conducting an empirical analysis of a system of industrial relations using Luhmann’s theory on autopoietic systems as a framework of analysis, but aligning that analysis with the aspirations of critical theory. The article provides a methodological contribution and based on the dual understanding of the concept of values as containing both a positivistic and a normative character, the article identifies a methodological model. Through the application of this methodological model, analysing the empirical material in two steps, the researcher will be able to conduct an analysis that can generate conclusions holding normative aspirations. This is possible since the model will allow the researcher to identify the normative values that frame the programming of the system of industrial relations and the structurally coupled systems. As such the analysis will provide ground for questioning the normative values that frame the programming of the studied systems and thus generate conclusions in line with the ambitions of critical theory. (Less)
Please use this url to cite or link to this publication:
author
organization
publishing date
type
Contribution to journal
publication status
published
subject
keywords
socio-legal methodology, autopoietic systems theory, critical theory, normative values, positivistic values, industrial relations
in
Retfærd: Nordisk juridisk tidsskrift
issue
2-3
pages
9 - 19
publisher
DJØF Forlag
ISSN
0105-1121
language
English
LU publication?
yes
id
3e7ad01f-2896-4aac-b553-6efbe9d6e787
date added to LUP
2020-01-22 09:05:51
date last changed
2020-01-22 13:10:03
@article{3e7ad01f-2896-4aac-b553-6efbe9d6e787,
  abstract     = {This article examines the possibility for conducting an empirical analysis of a system of industrial relations using Luhmann’s theory on autopoietic systems as a framework of analysis, but aligning that analysis with the aspirations of critical theory. The article provides a methodological contribution and based on the dual understanding of the concept of values as containing both a positivistic and a normative character, the article identifies a methodological model. Through the application of this methodological model, analysing the empirical material in two steps, the researcher will be able to conduct an analysis that can generate conclusions holding normative aspirations. This is possible since the model will allow the researcher to identify the normative values that frame the programming of the system of industrial relations and the structurally coupled systems. As such the analysis will provide ground for questioning the normative values that frame the programming of the studied systems and thus generate conclusions in line with the ambitions of critical theory.},
  author       = {Hartzén, Ann-Christine},
  issn         = {0105-1121},
  language     = {eng},
  number       = {2-3},
  pages        = {9--19},
  publisher    = {DJØF Forlag},
  series       = {Retfærd: Nordisk juridisk tidsskrift},
  title        = {Aligning normativity with Luhmann for a critical study of industrial relations},
  year         = {2019},
}