Advanced

On problems, joint problem solving and change - A human behavioural approach in a construction sector context.

Sunding, Lars LU (2015)
Abstract
Critics maintain that there are a number of troublesome issues resulting from the construction sector’s way of

operating and that these remain, despite widespread criticism and measures designed to change all of this. The

construction sector’s and the critics’ manner of describing these problems fails to a large extent to take into

consideration the way people function in connection with practical problem solving. This is remarkable. People

play a central role in all building activity, their being the ones who experience a need, make demands, commission

work, formulate and solve problems, evaluate results, and the like. Therefore, people need to be included as a

factor in an extended... (More)
Critics maintain that there are a number of troublesome issues resulting from the construction sector’s way of

operating and that these remain, despite widespread criticism and measures designed to change all of this. The

construction sector’s and the critics’ manner of describing these problems fails to a large extent to take into

consideration the way people function in connection with practical problem solving. This is remarkable. People

play a central role in all building activity, their being the ones who experience a need, make demands, commission

work, formulate and solve problems, evaluate results, and the like. Therefore, people need to be included as a

factor in an extended problem description here; the problem solver should be seen as part of the problem.

Theories in psychology and social psychology can be used to identify relevant issues and to support the

management of the human factor in such an extended problem definition.

The research work which has resulted in the present thesis represents an attempt to understand the relationship

between (1) the problems of the construction sector, (2) how the problems tend to be formulated, (3) the problemsolving

strategies that are employed and (4) the problem solver involved. The aim of all of this has been to

develop a methodology able to provide practical support for a given work group in a manner enabling it to make

use of a greater share of its intrinsic and potential problem solving and value-creating capacity than would

otherwise be the case.

In a study of literature that is relevant, and in three separate empirical studies, the construction sector’s problem

panorama and the possibility of creating extended and more effective problem management is investigated. The

one study, involving use of a questionnaire, investigates the relationship between different problems, the work

situation and how people tend to function generally. Another study was carried out as a series of seminars in

which the participants were given the opportunity to increase their understanding of the significance of the human

factor. A third study was carried out within an actual construction project, a small group of site managers being

given, in connection with the ordinary meetings they held at the workplace, the opportunity to increase their

understanding of the significance of the human factor and of the need for more extended problem formulations.

The results presented in the thesis represent a proposal for just such an extended problem formulation and a

methodology for implementing it. The studies carried out show that even those with long experience in the

construction industry can discover new ways of seeing their daily sphere of activity. Implementation of the

methodology involved presupposes the presence of a facilitating interventionist - “the liberator” – whose main

objective is to free the problem solvers from different inhibiting phenomena (mainly psychological) that are

operating in the problem-solving situation. This is done by introducing and leading an initiated dialogue regarding

(1) the specific problems involved, as well as (2) problem solving in general, and (3) the effect of the human factor

on the problem formulation, the problem solving and the decision making to be carried out. (Less)
Please use this url to cite or link to this publication:
author
supervisor
opponent
  • Associate Professor Bonke, Sten, DTU Technical University of Denmark, Copenhagen.
organization
publishing date
type
Thesis
publication status
published
subject
keywords
Problem solving., Human behavior and psychology, Information distortion, Problem formulation, Action research, Behavioral Change, Collaboration, Construction sector
pages
338 pages
publisher
Lund University (Media-Tryck)
defense location
Hörsal A:B, A-huset, Sölvegatan 24, Lund University, Faculty of Engineering LTH, Lund
defense date
2016-02-11 09:00
ISSN
1651-0380
ISBN
978-91-85257-13-3 (print)
91-85257-13-3 (PDF)
language
English
LU publication?
yes
id
dbe2bb86-8a5f-44c6-83b0-1faa9dbda53d (old id 8522296)
date added to LUP
2016-01-19 09:22:44
date last changed
2016-09-19 08:44:45
@phdthesis{dbe2bb86-8a5f-44c6-83b0-1faa9dbda53d,
  abstract     = {Critics maintain that there are a number of troublesome issues resulting from the construction sector’s way of<br/><br>
operating and that these remain, despite widespread criticism and measures designed to change all of this. The<br/><br>
construction sector’s and the critics’ manner of describing these problems fails to a large extent to take into<br/><br>
consideration the way people function in connection with practical problem solving. This is remarkable. People<br/><br>
play a central role in all building activity, their being the ones who experience a need, make demands, commission<br/><br>
work, formulate and solve problems, evaluate results, and the like. Therefore, people need to be included as a<br/><br>
factor in an extended problem description here; the problem solver should be seen as part of the problem.<br/><br>
Theories in psychology and social psychology can be used to identify relevant issues and to support the<br/><br>
management of the human factor in such an extended problem definition.<br/><br>
The research work which has resulted in the present thesis represents an attempt to understand the relationship<br/><br>
between (1) the problems of the construction sector, (2) how the problems tend to be formulated, (3) the problemsolving<br/><br>
strategies that are employed and (4) the problem solver involved. The aim of all of this has been to<br/><br>
develop a methodology able to provide practical support for a given work group in a manner enabling it to make<br/><br>
use of a greater share of its intrinsic and potential problem solving and value-creating capacity than would<br/><br>
otherwise be the case.<br/><br>
In a study of literature that is relevant, and in three separate empirical studies, the construction sector’s problem<br/><br>
panorama and the possibility of creating extended and more effective problem management is investigated. The<br/><br>
one study, involving use of a questionnaire, investigates the relationship between different problems, the work<br/><br>
situation and how people tend to function generally. Another study was carried out as a series of seminars in<br/><br>
which the participants were given the opportunity to increase their understanding of the significance of the human<br/><br>
factor. A third study was carried out within an actual construction project, a small group of site managers being<br/><br>
given, in connection with the ordinary meetings they held at the workplace, the opportunity to increase their<br/><br>
understanding of the significance of the human factor and of the need for more extended problem formulations.<br/><br>
The results presented in the thesis represent a proposal for just such an extended problem formulation and a<br/><br>
methodology for implementing it. The studies carried out show that even those with long experience in the<br/><br>
construction industry can discover new ways of seeing their daily sphere of activity. Implementation of the<br/><br>
methodology involved presupposes the presence of a facilitating interventionist - “the liberator” – whose main<br/><br>
objective is to free the problem solvers from different inhibiting phenomena (mainly psychological) that are<br/><br>
operating in the problem-solving situation. This is done by introducing and leading an initiated dialogue regarding<br/><br>
(1) the specific problems involved, as well as (2) problem solving in general, and (3) the effect of the human factor<br/><br>
on the problem formulation, the problem solving and the decision making to be carried out.},
  author       = {Sunding, Lars},
  isbn         = {978-91-85257-13-3 (print)},
  issn         = {1651-0380},
  keyword      = {Problem solving.,Human behavior and psychology,Information distortion,Problem formulation,Action research,Behavioral Change,Collaboration,Construction sector},
  language     = {eng},
  pages        = {338},
  publisher    = {Lund University (Media-Tryck)},
  school       = {Lund University},
  title        = {On problems, joint problem solving and change - A human behavioural approach in a construction sector context.},
  year         = {2015},
}