Skip to main content

LUP Student Papers

LUND UNIVERSITY LIBRARIES

Deliberation by Design? Relational Preconditions for Innovation and Their Institutionalisation in EU Governance. A Framework Analysis of Horizon Europe's Third Pillar

Schneider, Joost Bennet LU (2026) STVM23 20261
Department of Political Science
Abstract
This thesis examines the extent to which relational preconditions for innovation are institutionalised within the governance framework of the third pillar of Horizon Europe. Departing from the observation that existing research on EU innovation governance has focused predominantly on funding mechanisms and regulatory instruments, the study addresses a conceptual gap: while innovation theory consistently identifies relational preconditions as essential drivers of systemic innovation, it does not explain how governance structures can actively generate them.
To address this gap, the thesis develops an original analytical framework that combines innovation theory with deliberative democratic theory. Five relational preconditions are derived... (More)
This thesis examines the extent to which relational preconditions for innovation are institutionalised within the governance framework of the third pillar of Horizon Europe. Departing from the observation that existing research on EU innovation governance has focused predominantly on funding mechanisms and regulatory instruments, the study addresses a conceptual gap: while innovation theory consistently identifies relational preconditions as essential drivers of systemic innovation, it does not explain how governance structures can actively generate them.
To address this gap, the thesis develops an original analytical framework that combines innovation theory with deliberative democratic theory. Five relational preconditions are derived from the innovation literature and operationalised through corresponding deliberative democratic processes, organised across two analytical levels: interactional preconditions and system-stabilising preconditions. This framework is applied through a deductive qualitative content analysis of eight governance documents spanning the regulatory, programmatic, and implementation levels of Horizon Europe's third pillar.
The findings reveal a consistent and analytically significant pattern of selective institutionalisation. System-stabilising preconditions, namely trust and risk management as well as institutional coherence, are comprehensively or almost comprehensively embedded. Interactional preconditions, by contrast, are institutionalised primarily through structural proxies that create the conditions for deliberative interaction without fully enacting its quality. The thesis concludes that Horizon Europe's third pillar embeds deliberation structurally rather than processually and proposes concrete recommendations for strengthening the relational architecture of EU innovation governance. (Less)
Please use this url to cite or link to this publication:
author
Schneider, Joost Bennet LU
supervisor
organization
course
STVM23 20261
year
type
H2 - Master's Degree (Two Years)
subject
keywords
innovation theory, deliberative democratic theory, EU innovation framework, Horizon Europe
language
English
id
9226533
date added to LUP
2026-06-16 14:53:28
date last changed
2026-06-16 14:53:28
@misc{9226533,
  abstract     = {{This thesis examines the extent to which relational preconditions for innovation are institutionalised within the governance framework of the third pillar of Horizon Europe. Departing from the observation that existing research on EU innovation governance has focused predominantly on funding mechanisms and regulatory instruments, the study addresses a conceptual gap: while innovation theory consistently identifies relational preconditions as essential drivers of systemic innovation, it does not explain how governance structures can actively generate them.
To address this gap, the thesis develops an original analytical framework that combines innovation theory with deliberative democratic theory. Five relational preconditions are derived from the innovation literature and operationalised through corresponding deliberative democratic processes, organised across two analytical levels: interactional preconditions and system-stabilising preconditions. This framework is applied through a deductive qualitative content analysis of eight governance documents spanning the regulatory, programmatic, and implementation levels of Horizon Europe's third pillar.
The findings reveal a consistent and analytically significant pattern of selective institutionalisation. System-stabilising preconditions, namely trust and risk management as well as institutional coherence, are comprehensively or almost comprehensively embedded. Interactional preconditions, by contrast, are institutionalised primarily through structural proxies that create the conditions for deliberative interaction without fully enacting its quality. The thesis concludes that Horizon Europe's third pillar embeds deliberation structurally rather than processually and proposes concrete recommendations for strengthening the relational architecture of EU innovation governance.}},
  author       = {{Schneider, Joost Bennet}},
  language     = {{eng}},
  note         = {{Student Paper}},
  title        = {{Deliberation by Design? Relational Preconditions for Innovation and Their Institutionalisation in EU Governance. A Framework Analysis of Horizon Europe's Third Pillar}},
  year         = {{2026}},
}