Skip to main content

LUP Student Papers

LUND UNIVERSITY LIBRARIES

Responsibility and Accountability of the Russian Federation for the Treatment of Ukrainian Prisoners of War During the 2014…War

Dudnyk, Anastasiia LU (2026) JAMM07 20261
Department of Law
Faculty of Law
Abstract
This thesis analyzes the responsibility and accountability of the Russian Federation for torture and ill-treatment of Ukrainian prisoners of war during the armed conflict between Russia and Ukraine. The purpose is to explain the legal protection of POWs under international law, and examine whether these protections are actually meaningful in practice when serious violations continue during an ongoing war. The focus is mainly on the attribution of violations to Russia, and the efficiency of legal mechanisms to ensure accountability and justice.
The legal basis here is mostly international humanitarian law, international human rights law, international criminal law, and the law of state responsibility. Particular attention was placed on... (More)
This thesis analyzes the responsibility and accountability of the Russian Federation for torture and ill-treatment of Ukrainian prisoners of war during the armed conflict between Russia and Ukraine. The purpose is to explain the legal protection of POWs under international law, and examine whether these protections are actually meaningful in practice when serious violations continue during an ongoing war. The focus is mainly on the attribution of violations to Russia, and the efficiency of legal mechanisms to ensure accountability and justice.
The legal basis here is mostly international humanitarian law, international human rights law, international criminal law, and the law of state responsibility. Particular attention was placed on Geneva Convention III, the Convention against Torture, the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court, customary international law, and the International Law Commission Articles on State Responsibility. To answer the research questions, there is a combination of doctrinal legal analysis with a law in context approach, and examined treaties, case law, academic literature, reports from international organizations, investigations, and testimonies from former prisoners of war.
First, the thesis explains the legal status and protection of prisoners of war under international law. Ukrainian combatants captured during the conflict qualify as prisoners of war under the Geneva Convention III and therefore must be treated humanely in all circumstances. Second, it moves to the actual treatment of Ukrainian POWs in Russian captivity. Torture and ill-treatment are systematic and widespread across all detention facilities.
Third, it analyzes the attribution of violations to the Russian Federation under the law of state responsibility. Russia is responsible for the conduct of its organs, including members of the armed forces. Fourth, it states that there is a problem in enforcement. The international legal system depends heavily on political will and decisions. Finally, it argues that justice for victims is not effective and needs several reforms.
Overall, the final remarks show that the treatment of Ukrainian POWs by Russia constitutes grave breaches of international law and invokes the responsibility of the Russian Federation under the law of state responsibility and international criminal law. At the same time, it demonstrates the difficulty of enforcing this accountability during the ongoing armed conflict that involves a powerful state.
As a possible way forward, the thesis suggests that stronger cooperation between democratic states. It is an important step that could improve accountability and ensure that democratic values are respected. (Less)
Please use this url to cite or link to this publication:
author
Dudnyk, Anastasiia LU
supervisor
organization
course
JAMM07 20261
year
type
H2 - Master's Degree (Two Years)
subject
keywords
Responsibility, accountability, torture, ill-treatment, detention, prisoner of war, combatant, armed conflict, international humanitarian law, human rights, justice, human dignity, enforcement.
language
English
id
9237499
date added to LUP
2026-08-14 08:48:41
date last changed
2026-08-14 08:48:41
@misc{9237499,
  abstract     = {{This thesis analyzes the responsibility and accountability of the Russian Federation for torture and ill-treatment of Ukrainian prisoners of war during the armed conflict between Russia and Ukraine. The purpose is to explain the legal protection of POWs under international law, and examine whether these protections are actually meaningful in practice when serious violations continue during an ongoing war. The focus is mainly on the attribution of violations to Russia, and the efficiency of legal mechanisms to ensure accountability and justice.
The legal basis here is mostly international humanitarian law, international human rights law, international criminal law, and the law of state responsibility. Particular attention was placed on Geneva Convention III, the Convention against Torture, the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court, customary international law, and the International Law Commission Articles on State Responsibility. To answer the research questions, there is a combination of doctrinal legal analysis with a law in context approach, and examined treaties, case law, academic literature, reports from international organizations, investigations, and testimonies from former prisoners of war.
First, the thesis explains the legal status and protection of prisoners of war under international law. Ukrainian combatants captured during the conflict qualify as prisoners of war under the Geneva Convention III and therefore must be treated humanely in all circumstances. Second, it moves to the actual treatment of Ukrainian POWs in Russian captivity. Torture and ill-treatment are systematic and widespread across all detention facilities.
Third, it analyzes the attribution of violations to the Russian Federation under the law of state responsibility. Russia is responsible for the conduct of its organs, including members of the armed forces. Fourth, it states that there is a problem in enforcement. The international legal system depends heavily on political will and decisions. Finally, it argues that justice for victims is not effective and needs several reforms.
Overall, the final remarks show that the treatment of Ukrainian POWs by Russia constitutes grave breaches of international law and invokes the responsibility of the Russian Federation under the law of state responsibility and international criminal law. At the same time, it demonstrates the difficulty of enforcing this accountability during the ongoing armed conflict that involves a powerful state.
As a possible way forward, the thesis suggests that stronger cooperation between democratic states. It is an important step that could improve accountability and ensure that democratic values are respected.}},
  author       = {{Dudnyk, Anastasiia}},
  language     = {{eng}},
  note         = {{Student Paper}},
  title        = {{Responsibility and Accountability of the Russian Federation for the Treatment of Ukrainian Prisoners of War During the 2014…War}},
  year         = {{2026}},
}