Circular Renovation Pathways - Evaluating Energy Performance, Thermal Comfort, Life Cycle Assessment and Material Flow Circularity in 1960s Swedish Residential Buildings
(2026) AEBM01 20261Division of Energy and Building Design
- Abstract
- Many Swedish multifamily buildings from the 1960s are now reaching a stage where major renovation is needed to improve energy performance, indoor environmental quality, and long-term climate performance. At the same time, renovation strategies may involve trade-offs between operational energy savings, embodied carbon, thermal comfort, and material circularity. This thesis evaluates energy-efficient and circular renovation pathways for Swedish 1960s multifamily buildings, using the Äpplet and Päronet residential area in Växjö as a case study. The case is based on Vidingehem’s renovation project, which includes 220 apartments and was completed in 2025.
Two representative building typologies were analysed: a low-rise building and a high-rise... (More) - Many Swedish multifamily buildings from the 1960s are now reaching a stage where major renovation is needed to improve energy performance, indoor environmental quality, and long-term climate performance. At the same time, renovation strategies may involve trade-offs between operational energy savings, embodied carbon, thermal comfort, and material circularity. This thesis evaluates energy-efficient and circular renovation pathways for Swedish 1960s multifamily buildings, using the Äpplet and Päronet residential area in Växjö as a case study. The case is based on Vidingehem’s renovation project, which includes 220 apartments and was completed in 2025.
Two representative building typologies were analysed: a low-rise building and a high-rise building. Three renovation scenarios with different levels of intervention were developed and assessed. The study combined dynamic energy simulation using Climate Studio/EnergyPlus, calibration against measured energy data before and after renovation, thermal comfort analysis, life-cycle assessment, and a material-level circularity assessment using OneClick LCA tools. The scenarios were evaluated in terms of total energy use, primary energy use according to BBR 29, indoor temperatures, overheating risk, global warming potential over a 50-year assessment period, carbon payback time, and circularity indicators.
The results show that deeper renovation leads to substantial energy reductions in both representative buildings. Total energy use was reduced by approximately 8-10%, 43-44%, and 62-63% in Scenarios 01, 02, and 03, respectively. Winter indoor temperatures remained close to or above the housing company’s target, with an average improvement of approximately 0.5-1°C after renovation. However, the overheating assessment indicated increased risk in the high-rise building, especially on upper floors and in south-oriented apartments, while the low-rise building showed limited overheating risk.
The LCA results indicate that deeper renovation reduces total GWP over the 50-year period, mainly due to reduced operational carbon. However, this is accompanied by increased embodied carbon and longer carbon payback times, particularly in Scenario 03. The circularity assessment showed similar patterns for both building typologies, with the highest circularity score in Scenario 02 and the lowest in Scenario 03.
The study concludes that no renovation scenario performs best across all assessed indicators. Renovation strategies should therefore be evaluated using a multi-indicator approach, where operational energy savings are considered together with embodied carbon, thermal comfort, circularity, regulatory compliance, and long-term climate performance. (Less) - Popular Abstract
- Renovating for lower energy use — but at what cost?
Renovating old buildings is often seen as an obvious climate solution. If a building uses less energy after renovation, it may seem clear that the renovation is better for the environment. However, the situation is more complex. Many Swedish apartment buildings from the 1960s need energy improvements, but renovation also requires new materials, and these materials have their own climate impact. Renovation can also change the indoor climate, especially during warmer periods. This means that energy savings are only one part of the overall picture.
This degree project studied a residential area in Växjö, Sweden, where several multifamily buildings were constructed during the 1960s and... (More) - Renovating for lower energy use — but at what cost?
Renovating old buildings is often seen as an obvious climate solution. If a building uses less energy after renovation, it may seem clear that the renovation is better for the environment. However, the situation is more complex. Many Swedish apartment buildings from the 1960s need energy improvements, but renovation also requires new materials, and these materials have their own climate impact. Renovation can also change the indoor climate, especially during warmer periods. This means that energy savings are only one part of the overall picture.
This degree project studied a residential area in Växjö, Sweden, where several multifamily buildings were constructed during the 1960s and have recently undergone renovation. Instead of analysing every building in detail, two representative building types were selected: a low-rise building and a high-rise building. These buildings were used to compare different renovation pathways, ranging from limited improvements to more extensive renovation measures. Since similar multifamily buildings exist in many parts of Sweden, the results can also be relevant for other renovation projects with comparable buildings and climate conditions.
The renovation pathways were assessed from several perspectives. Energy simulations were used to estimate how much energy could be saved. Indoor thermal comfort was analysed to understand how the renovation could affect indoor temperatures, especially during summer. The climate impact was evaluated by considering both the materials used in the renovation and the energy used during operation. Material circularity was also studied by looking at how materials could be recovered, recycled or reused at the end of their service life.
Three renovation pathways were compared. The first pathway included smaller improvements, mainly better airtightness and additional roof insulation. The second pathway represented a more balanced renovation strategy, including new windows, additional roof insulation, selected façade insulation and heat recovery ventilation. The third pathway represented a deeper renovation, with more extensive façade and roof insulation, new windows, improved airtightness and an optimised heat recovery ventilation system.
The results showed that deeper renovation can strongly reduce energy use. Both the balanced and the deep renovation pathways were able to bring the buildings below current Swedish energy performance requirements. However, the most extensive renovation was not automatically the best overall solution. It saved the most energy, but it also required more new materials, which increased the climate impact from the renovation itself. Since Swedish electricity and district heating have relatively low carbon emissions, the additional climate benefit from the deepest energy renovation was partly limited by the added emissions from materials.
Indoor comfort was also affected by the renovation. The high-rise building showed a higher risk of summer overheating, especially on upper floors and in apartments with more solar exposure. The low-rise building was less affected, partly because its recessed balconies helped shade the façade. From a material circularity perspective, the balanced renovation pathway performed well because it combined large energy savings with a more moderate use of new materials.
The main lesson from this study is that renovation should not be evaluated from only one perspective. Energy savings are important, but they should be considered together with the climate impact of materials, indoor comfort and the possibility of keeping materials in use for longer. For housing companies, municipalities and designers, this type of integrated assessment can support better renovation decisions at an early planning stage. It can help reduce energy use and climate impact without solving one problem while creating another. (Less)
Please use this url to cite or link to this publication:
https://lup.lub.lu.se/student-papers/record/9239095
- author
- Alabrash, Ahmad LU and Sleman, Savo LU
- supervisor
-
- Vahid Nik LU
- organization
- alternative title
- Cirkulära renoveringsvägar- Utvärdering av energiprestanda, termisk komfort, livscykelanalys och materialflödescirkularitet i svenska flerbostadshus från 1960-talet
- course
- AEBM01 20261
- year
- 2026
- type
- H2 - Master's Degree (Two Years)
- subject
- keywords
- Energy-efficient renovation, Multifamily residential buildings, 1960s housing stock, Building energy simulation, Life cycle assessment (LCA), Embodied carbon, Operational energy use, Thermal comfort, Overheating risk, Material circularity, Renovation scenarios, Carbon payback time
- language
- English
- id
- 9239095
- date added to LUP
- 2026-06-16 12:59:32
- date last changed
- 2026-06-16 12:59:32
@misc{9239095,
abstract = {{Many Swedish multifamily buildings from the 1960s are now reaching a stage where major renovation is needed to improve energy performance, indoor environmental quality, and long-term climate performance. At the same time, renovation strategies may involve trade-offs between operational energy savings, embodied carbon, thermal comfort, and material circularity. This thesis evaluates energy-efficient and circular renovation pathways for Swedish 1960s multifamily buildings, using the Äpplet and Päronet residential area in Växjö as a case study. The case is based on Vidingehem’s renovation project, which includes 220 apartments and was completed in 2025.
Two representative building typologies were analysed: a low-rise building and a high-rise building. Three renovation scenarios with different levels of intervention were developed and assessed. The study combined dynamic energy simulation using Climate Studio/EnergyPlus, calibration against measured energy data before and after renovation, thermal comfort analysis, life-cycle assessment, and a material-level circularity assessment using OneClick LCA tools. The scenarios were evaluated in terms of total energy use, primary energy use according to BBR 29, indoor temperatures, overheating risk, global warming potential over a 50-year assessment period, carbon payback time, and circularity indicators.
The results show that deeper renovation leads to substantial energy reductions in both representative buildings. Total energy use was reduced by approximately 8-10%, 43-44%, and 62-63% in Scenarios 01, 02, and 03, respectively. Winter indoor temperatures remained close to or above the housing company’s target, with an average improvement of approximately 0.5-1°C after renovation. However, the overheating assessment indicated increased risk in the high-rise building, especially on upper floors and in south-oriented apartments, while the low-rise building showed limited overheating risk.
The LCA results indicate that deeper renovation reduces total GWP over the 50-year period, mainly due to reduced operational carbon. However, this is accompanied by increased embodied carbon and longer carbon payback times, particularly in Scenario 03. The circularity assessment showed similar patterns for both building typologies, with the highest circularity score in Scenario 02 and the lowest in Scenario 03.
The study concludes that no renovation scenario performs best across all assessed indicators. Renovation strategies should therefore be evaluated using a multi-indicator approach, where operational energy savings are considered together with embodied carbon, thermal comfort, circularity, regulatory compliance, and long-term climate performance.}},
author = {{Alabrash, Ahmad and Sleman, Savo}},
language = {{eng}},
note = {{Student Paper}},
title = {{Circular Renovation Pathways - Evaluating Energy Performance, Thermal Comfort, Life Cycle Assessment and Material Flow Circularity in 1960s Swedish Residential Buildings}},
year = {{2026}},
}