Skip to main content

LUP Student Papers

LUND UNIVERSITY LIBRARIES

Facial Recognition Surveillance and Chilling of Peaceful Protest: The Case of Georgia before the European Court of Human Rights

Gvishiani, Lela LU (2026) JAMM07 20261
Department of Law
Faculty of Law
Abstract
The idea for this thesis was born out of a concrete, living, and still unfolding experience, namely the measures taken by the Georgian authorities in response to the large-scale protest movement from 2024 to 2026, which made clear how modern technology acquires a political function in the hands of the state, particularly under conditions of democratic backsliding. While the authorities presented facial recognition infrastructure as a neutral instrument of public safety and order, practice showed that the network of cameras installed on and around the Parliament building, that is, at the epicentre of the protests, immediately became a primary instrument for mapping the political identity of participants in a peaceful assembly.
This... (More)
The idea for this thesis was born out of a concrete, living, and still unfolding experience, namely the measures taken by the Georgian authorities in response to the large-scale protest movement from 2024 to 2026, which made clear how modern technology acquires a political function in the hands of the state, particularly under conditions of democratic backsliding. While the authorities presented facial recognition infrastructure as a neutral instrument of public safety and order, practice showed that the network of cameras installed on and around the Parliament building, that is, at the epicentre of the protests, immediately became a primary instrument for mapping the political identity of participants in a peaceful assembly.
This observation, and this particular use of technological progress, became the point of departure for the present master’s thesis, and at the same time a troubling problem for me. Against the backdrop of the deterioration of state institutions and judicial independence, I ask to what extent the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR), within the framework of its doctrine as developed to date, can respond to a threat that is technologically novel and fundamentally different from the threat that existed at the moment that doctrine took shape. This question is neither purely theoretical nor remote to me; it bears directly on the fate of individuals who did no more than express a political opinion, and who now face AI-driven surveillance, disproportionate fines, and administrative detention precisely because of facial recognition technologies (FRT).
In this thesis, I seek to answer this question through doctrinal legal research. However, I deliberately move beyond a purely positivist analysis, combining Michel Foucault’s theory of disciplinary power, Corey Brettschneider’s value theory of democracy, and Strasbourg case law within a single analytical framework. This framework allows me to assess not only individual harm, but also the collective, systemic harm produced by the chilling effects that technological surveillance exerts on a functioning democracy.
Because the ECtHR has not yet examined an application concerning Georgia’s technological regime, the central part of my thesis is necessarily predictive in nature and constructed by analogy with existing precedent. For me, this absence of precedent was not a limiting factor but a methodological challenge. This lack of precedent raises the question of whether the Convention, within its existing doctrinal framework, including in light of the ‘living instrument’ doctrine, can respond effectively to the chilling effects that invoking technological progress has on societies more broadly. It was particularly important to me to maintain academic rigour with respect to the factual record on Georgia, even though, because of the lack of transparency in state institutions, this record is largely based on materials produced by non-governmental organisations and investigative journalists working in Georgia.
I hope this thesis will contribute not only to understanding the specific case of Georgia, but also to the broader international discussion of how human rights law should adapt to the era of mass AI-driven surveillance. (Less)
Please use this url to cite or link to this publication:
author
Gvishiani, Lela LU
supervisor
organization
course
JAMM07 20261
year
type
H2 - Master's Degree (Two Years)
subject
keywords
Artificial Intelligence, Facial Recognition Technology, European Convention on Human Rights, European Court of Human Rights, Remote Biometric Identification, Retrospective Facial Recognition, Protest, Freedom of Assembly, Abuse of Power.
language
English
id
9251565
date added to LUP
2026-09-30 16:38:38
date last changed
2026-09-30 16:38:38
@misc{9251565,
  abstract     = {{The idea for this thesis was born out of a concrete, living, and still unfolding experience, namely the measures taken by the Georgian authorities in response to the large-scale protest movement from 2024 to 2026, which made clear how modern technology acquires a political function in the hands of the state, particularly under conditions of democratic backsliding. While the authorities presented facial recognition infrastructure as a neutral instrument of public safety and order, practice showed that the network of cameras installed on and around the Parliament building, that is, at the epicentre of the protests, immediately became a primary instrument for mapping the political identity of participants in a peaceful assembly.
This observation, and this particular use of technological progress, became the point of departure for the present master’s thesis, and at the same time a troubling problem for me. Against the backdrop of the deterioration of state institutions and judicial independence, I ask to what extent the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR), within the framework of its doctrine as developed to date, can respond to a threat that is technologically novel and fundamentally different from the threat that existed at the moment that doctrine took shape. This question is neither purely theoretical nor remote to me; it bears directly on the fate of individuals who did no more than express a political opinion, and who now face AI-driven surveillance, disproportionate fines, and administrative detention precisely because of facial recognition technologies (FRT).
In this thesis, I seek to answer this question through doctrinal legal research. However, I deliberately move beyond a purely positivist analysis, combining Michel Foucault’s theory of disciplinary power, Corey Brettschneider’s value theory of democracy, and Strasbourg case law within a single analytical framework. This framework allows me to assess not only individual harm, but also the collective, systemic harm produced by the chilling effects that technological surveillance exerts on a functioning democracy.
Because the ECtHR has not yet examined an application concerning Georgia’s technological regime, the central part of my thesis is necessarily predictive in nature and constructed by analogy with existing precedent. For me, this absence of precedent was not a limiting factor but a methodological challenge. This lack of precedent raises the question of whether the Convention, within its existing doctrinal framework, including in light of the ‘living instrument’ doctrine, can respond effectively to the chilling effects that invoking technological progress has on societies more broadly. It was particularly important to me to maintain academic rigour with respect to the factual record on Georgia, even though, because of the lack of transparency in state institutions, this record is largely based on materials produced by non-governmental organisations and investigative journalists working in Georgia. 
I hope this thesis will contribute not only to understanding the specific case of Georgia, but also to the broader international discussion of how human rights law should adapt to the era of mass AI-driven surveillance.}},
  author       = {{Gvishiani, Lela}},
  language     = {{eng}},
  note         = {{Student Paper}},
  title        = {{Facial Recognition Surveillance and Chilling of Peaceful Protest: The Case of Georgia before the European Court of Human Rights}},
  year         = {{2026}},
}