Identifying the Electromagnetic Counterparts of the LISA Double White Dwarfs
(2026) ASTM32 20261Astrophysics
Department of Physics
- Abstract
- Gravitational wave (GW) astronomy will enter a new era with the introduction of modern detectors. One such detector is the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA). LISA will be a space based GW detector that will allow us to detect sources emitting GW at comparatively low frequencies, i.e., 10−4 Hz-10−1 Hz. Among the different sources that LISA will detect, the most abundant will be a population of galactic double white dwarfs (DWDs). These DWDs will be close, with shorter orbits and shorter periods ∼ of 1 hr−1s. These sources have uncertainties associated with their evolution that could be addressed if we understand them better. In order to have a deeper insight into these objects, we have to do a multimessenger analysis of these
DWDs.... (More) - Gravitational wave (GW) astronomy will enter a new era with the introduction of modern detectors. One such detector is the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA). LISA will be a space based GW detector that will allow us to detect sources emitting GW at comparatively low frequencies, i.e., 10−4 Hz-10−1 Hz. Among the different sources that LISA will detect, the most abundant will be a population of galactic double white dwarfs (DWDs). These DWDs will be close, with shorter orbits and shorter periods ∼ of 1 hr−1s. These sources have uncertainties associated with their evolution that could be addressed if we understand them better. In order to have a deeper insight into these objects, we have to do a multimessenger analysis of these
DWDs. In this work, we attempt to understand whether it will be realistic to locate the electromagnetic (EM) counterparts of these sources. We do a multisurvey (LSST, Gaia, PanSTARRS, SDSS, 2MASS) based analysis of a theoretical LISA DWD population. The LISA DWD population has been produced using simulated Milky Way like galaxies and the Binary Population Synthesis code, and filtered for a cut of signal to noise ratio ≥ 7. Using the amplitude, frequency, and chirp mass from this data, we determine the distance and the sky localization area (dΩ) of these DWDs. We make simplified assumptions about the chirp mass and mass ratio of the two types of DWDs, i.e., He-CO and CO-CO. This allows us to determine the individual masses of the two components of the binaries. We draw age tracks on the Colour Magnitude Diagram (CMD). CMD is an observational tool where the brightness of stars is plotted against their apparent colours. For two possible masses inferred from our assumptions. We calculate the EM sources falling between both age tracks and the three different age bins, which are log age = 7−8, 8−9, 9−10 years. The EM source counts for each are scaled with their respective dΩ and compared with different important parameters. From this study, we
find that the best localized LISA DWDs would be found in the galactic center, but due to the high density of the EM sources there, it would be hard to resolve the exact EM counterpart among the other EM sources. On the other hand, the density of EM sources near the galactic poles is lower, but the LISA DWDs in that region have higher dΩ, which will also make it harder to resolve the actual counterpart. We show a strong
correlation between EM counts and dΩ. We also analyze the relation of dΩ with distance to the DWD and galactic coordinates. We also discuss the type of stellar population that will appear as the background EM sources. We also discuss the difficulties that might be faced in the future while attempting to resolve these
binaries spectroscopically. (Less) - Popular Abstract
- Close your eyes, take a deep breath, and look at what you can see. Nothing! This is exactly how a gravitational wave detector "looks" at the universe. Gravitational waves (GW) are the ripples in the spacetime continuum, like the waves in an ocean. GW detectors are large, sensitive instruments that detect these sources. These waves appear to them in a similar fashion to how sound will appear to you with closed eyes. You can only hear the sound and hence the frequency, and this is how these GWs are detected. As science has developed rapidly over the past 100 years, similarly, the scientific instruments have also evolved. The GW detectors on Earth are not old but are limited to a range of frequencies. For lower frequencies, we need a new... (More)
- Close your eyes, take a deep breath, and look at what you can see. Nothing! This is exactly how a gravitational wave detector "looks" at the universe. Gravitational waves (GW) are the ripples in the spacetime continuum, like the waves in an ocean. GW detectors are large, sensitive instruments that detect these sources. These waves appear to them in a similar fashion to how sound will appear to you with closed eyes. You can only hear the sound and hence the frequency, and this is how these GWs are detected. As science has developed rapidly over the past 100 years, similarly, the scientific instruments have also evolved. The GW detectors on Earth are not old but are limited to a range of frequencies. For lower frequencies, we need a new detector, and that in space as well. The Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA) will be a space based GW detector, which will detect GW from objects that are not detectable from Earth. One of those exciting objects is Double White Dwarfs (DWDs). A single White Dwarf (WD) is a low mass star in the late phase of its life. We have an understanding of how a star evolves and reaches that phase. But this evolution becomes complex when there are two. The evolution of so called binary stars into DWDs is less understood than that of single stars. LISA will detect GWs from these DWDs and reveal some of their properties. In order to understand them better, we also have to look at them. In this work, we try to locate the electromagnetic (EM) counterparts of the LISA DWDs. To look for the EM counterparts, we use different astronomical surveys of our Milky Way galaxy. We look in different directions of the Milky Way and try to find the exact EM counterpart among other stars that are emitting GWs for LISA and light waves/particles for our astronomical surveys. If we are successful, we can better understand their complex evolution.
Every beauty fades away with time, and the brightness of stars is no exception. As these WDs grow older, their brightness decreases. We try to understand the variation in their brightness with their age. It is important to understand this variation so we can see which of our EM surveys are powerful enough to see these DWDs even when they are faint. The surveys we are using include Gaia, Pan-STARRS, SDSS, 2MASS, and LSST. We realize that 2MASS can only look at very nearby sources, so we decided not to continue with
it. For the remaining 4 surveys, we chose 13 different spots in our galaxy where we would try to find the EM counterparts.
Since LISA is expected to launch in 2035, for our study, we use a simulated population of LISA DWDs. This population is simulated in an MW like galaxy, and it supports the formation of such binary stars, which can then form the DWDs that will be detected by LISA. To be in that range, the LISA DWDs will have to orbit each other in a period ranging from a few seconds to around an hour. This population gives us some useful information. It tells the frequency, period, and intensity (amplitude) of the GW from these DWDs, allowing us to calculate the distance to these DWDs. Most importantly, it gives us an elliptical region (dΩ) around that DWD. dΩ could be assumed to be a playground for hide and seek. We only seek EM counterparts on this playground. After that, we make Colour Magnitude Diagrams (CMD) from our astronomical surveys of the stars in the galactic regions we are studying. This diagram helps us understand the brightness and the temperature (colour) of the stars that the survey will find in that sky area. This particular CMD is made up of apparent brightness, i.e., we do not correct the brightness for the distance to the stars. We can assume a fainter bulb, which is 10 m away, and a brighter bulb 10 km away, and due to the distance, the fainter one will appear brighter. With some assumptions, we calculate the masses of each component of the LISA DWDs. Then we pick 2 possible masses of the brighter component for each LISA
DWD, and we draw age tracks for them on these CMDs. Between these 2 age tracks, we define 3 age bins between 10 Myr − 100 Myr, 100 Myr − 1 Gyr, and 1 Gyr − 10 Gyr.
In our results, we first show an example case in which we explain how a distant source would not be detectable and a nearer one could be detected. But this finding is only about detection. The actual problem is how many stars can also appear along with the true EM counterpart to confuse us. Imagine meeting your friend at a concert: would you call them in a highly dense, packed region with hundreds of people near the stage, or would you suggest meeting at the food truck at the beginning, where you might have around 10 people in the queue? This is the challenge we are facing in this study. We narrow down our surveys to the best one, i.e., LSST. It has a fainter detection range compared to other surveys. We also narrow down our sample of LISA DWD to the top 10 best sources. The term "best" here means that those with the smallest dΩ will be easier to seek in a smaller playground. We calculate the count of EM sources in each of the 3
age bins, which we made on the CMDs. We find two problems. Firstly, most of our sources will remain undetected as they are far and faint. The majority of such undetected sources lie in the oldest age bin, where we expect to find most WDs. Secondly, the sources for which we do not find a single other confusing EM source lie in the youngest age bin, where we would hardly find a WD.
We also find that with an increase in dΩ, the number of confusing EM sources also increases. We find that the sources with the smallest dΩ will lie in the disc of the galaxy where the density of stars is the highest in the galaxy. For the less dense areas in the galaxy, dΩ is big enough for the LISA DWD, which then includes a high density of confusing EM sources. As a result, in both situations, it will become impossible to find the exact EM counterpart. But it is not necessary to consider hopelessness as your loss.
Among a million particles of the ashes, the phoenix only rises from the few. In the majority of undetected and high density instances, we are able to locate some sources that would be detectable and with a reasonable count of confusing EM sources. This can allow us to conduct follow-up searches to find the exact EM counterpart. Such instances will be very few, but they will allow us to understand the complex evolution of the binary stars. Henceforth, this will be a small contribution to a longer journey towards unveiling the mysteries of the universe. (Less)
Please use this url to cite or link to this publication:
https://lup.lub.lu.se/student-papers/record/9253276
- author
- Ahmed, Moiz LU
- supervisor
-
- Ross Church LU
- organization
- course
- ASTM32 20261
- year
- 2026
- type
- H2 - Master's Degree (Two Years)
- subject
- keywords
- Multi-messenger Astronomy, Gravitational Waves, Double White Dwarfs, LISA, Binary Evolution
- report number
- EXA270
- language
- English
- id
- 9253276
- date added to LUP
- 2026-11-16 10:19:22
- date last changed
- 2026-11-16 10:19:22
@misc{9253276,
abstract = {{Gravitational wave (GW) astronomy will enter a new era with the introduction of modern detectors. One such detector is the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA). LISA will be a space based GW detector that will allow us to detect sources emitting GW at comparatively low frequencies, i.e., 10−4 Hz-10−1 Hz. Among the different sources that LISA will detect, the most abundant will be a population of galactic double white dwarfs (DWDs). These DWDs will be close, with shorter orbits and shorter periods ∼ of 1 hr−1s. These sources have uncertainties associated with their evolution that could be addressed if we understand them better. In order to have a deeper insight into these objects, we have to do a multimessenger analysis of these
DWDs. In this work, we attempt to understand whether it will be realistic to locate the electromagnetic (EM) counterparts of these sources. We do a multisurvey (LSST, Gaia, PanSTARRS, SDSS, 2MASS) based analysis of a theoretical LISA DWD population. The LISA DWD population has been produced using simulated Milky Way like galaxies and the Binary Population Synthesis code, and filtered for a cut of signal to noise ratio ≥ 7. Using the amplitude, frequency, and chirp mass from this data, we determine the distance and the sky localization area (dΩ) of these DWDs. We make simplified assumptions about the chirp mass and mass ratio of the two types of DWDs, i.e., He-CO and CO-CO. This allows us to determine the individual masses of the two components of the binaries. We draw age tracks on the Colour Magnitude Diagram (CMD). CMD is an observational tool where the brightness of stars is plotted against their apparent colours. For two possible masses inferred from our assumptions. We calculate the EM sources falling between both age tracks and the three different age bins, which are log age = 7−8, 8−9, 9−10 years. The EM source counts for each are scaled with their respective dΩ and compared with different important parameters. From this study, we
find that the best localized LISA DWDs would be found in the galactic center, but due to the high density of the EM sources there, it would be hard to resolve the exact EM counterpart among the other EM sources. On the other hand, the density of EM sources near the galactic poles is lower, but the LISA DWDs in that region have higher dΩ, which will also make it harder to resolve the actual counterpart. We show a strong
correlation between EM counts and dΩ. We also analyze the relation of dΩ with distance to the DWD and galactic coordinates. We also discuss the type of stellar population that will appear as the background EM sources. We also discuss the difficulties that might be faced in the future while attempting to resolve these
binaries spectroscopically.}},
author = {{Ahmed, Moiz}},
language = {{eng}},
note = {{Student Paper}},
title = {{Identifying the Electromagnetic Counterparts of the LISA Double White Dwarfs}},
year = {{2026}},
}