Skip to main content

Lund University Publications

LUND UNIVERSITY LIBRARIES

Continuous butanol fermentation with submerged ceramic membranes

Outram, V. LU orcid and Lipnizki, F. LU orcid (2024) Euromembrane 2024 p.861-861
Abstract
Introduction.
Building block chemicals, such as butanol, can be produced via fermentation and biobased feedstocks as a more sustainable alternative compared to the current petrochemical methods. However, the butanol fermentation is subjected to low product titres (<20 g/L) due to product inhibition of the bacteria [1]. To overcome this continuous fermentation can be applied, as it offers considerably higher volumetric productivities compared to batch fermentation. However, it suffers from lower yields and concentrations due to the continuous dilution effects due to the feed stream. An integrated membrane-fermentation process would retain the microorganism in the fermenter, resulting in higher biomass concentrations and thereby... (More)
Introduction.
Building block chemicals, such as butanol, can be produced via fermentation and biobased feedstocks as a more sustainable alternative compared to the current petrochemical methods. However, the butanol fermentation is subjected to low product titres (<20 g/L) due to product inhibition of the bacteria [1]. To overcome this continuous fermentation can be applied, as it offers considerably higher volumetric productivities compared to batch fermentation. However, it suffers from lower yields and concentrations due to the continuous dilution effects due to the feed stream. An integrated membrane-fermentation process would retain the microorganism in the fermenter, resulting in higher biomass concentrations and thereby enhancing both the yield and the volumetric productivity. Most research combining membrane and fermentation technology uses an external membrane unit [2]; but this leads to problems with sterility, increased process volume and cell viability due to shear stress in the circulation pump. In contrast, less research has been performed using submerged membranes. The key problem with membrane bioreactors for continuous fermentation is a stable membrane operation with small membrane area to fermenter volume ratio due to internal space limitations. Especially with regards to minimising membrane fouling, allowing operation for 150+ hours with no chemical cleaning agents.

Experimental/methodology.
Continuous acetone butanol ethanol fermentation was performed using Clostridium beijerinckii in a 5 L fermenter. A silica carbide membrane (0.1 μm, 0.01 m2, Cembrane) was submerged in the fermenter. The permeate was constantly logged, providing
online flux measurements. The membrane was periodically backflushed with deionised water, with the frequency of the
backflushing varied to find the optimal operating conditions, aiming to maintain the flux at 20 kg/m2·h.

Results and discussion.
While a continuous fermentation process without a membrane achieved a cell density of 0.6 g/L and butanol productivity of 0.10 g/L·h, incorporating a membrane into the fermenter tripled the cell density to 1.8 g/L. However, this high density could only be maintained for 50 hours before a decrease in membrane flux resulted in cell loss. This flux decline caused more broth to
leave through the waste line rather than as the desired product in the permeate, therefore proportionally increasing cell loss. Maintaining a flux of 20 kg/m2·h was crucial for fermentation performance. Backflushing the membrane was implemented, initially every 2 minutes for 10 seconds. This maintained the flux at 19 kg/m2·h, but significantly diluted the broth, keeping the cell density at 0.7 g/L. By optimizing backwash duration and frequency (as shown in Figure 1), a steady flux of 16-18 kg/m2·h was achieved when the backflushing occurred for 10 seconds. Reducing the backflush frequency to every 20 minutes minimized dilution by 85%. This significantly improved the fermentation: peak cell density reached 3 g/L, with an average of 2 g/L (three times higher than the control without a membrane), and butanol productivity increased by 24% to 0.13 g/L·h for a stable 150 hours of operation.

Conclusions and outlook.
This work has demonstrated the successful operation of a submerged membrane bioreactor under sterile operation for 150 hours. With further optimisation of the fermentation and membrane operation it will be possible to increase the productivity gains further, improving the viability of sustainable manufacturing routes.

References
[1] Jones, D.T.; Woods, D.R. Microbiol Rev 1986, 4, 44-524.
[2] Carstensen, F. et al. J. Membr Sci 2012, 394-395, 1-36. (Less)
Please use this url to cite or link to this publication:
author
and
organization
publishing date
type
Contribution to conference
publication status
published
subject
keywords
Continuous fermentation, Membrane bioreactors, Bioprocessing
pages
1 pages
conference name
Euromembrane 2024
conference location
Prague, Czech Republic
conference dates
2024-09-08 - 2024-09-12
project
Continuous processing of biofuel and biochemical production using membrane processes
language
English
LU publication?
yes
id
105fb8ef-4d3d-4375-b92a-a534f0eb755c
alternative location
https://euromembrane2024.cz/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Book-of-Abstracts-EuroMembrane2024-small-1.pdf
date added to LUP
2025-12-30 22:09:32
date last changed
2026-01-19 09:58:34
@misc{105fb8ef-4d3d-4375-b92a-a534f0eb755c,
  abstract     = {{Introduction. <br/>Building block chemicals, such as butanol, can be produced via fermentation and biobased feedstocks as a more sustainable alternative compared to the current petrochemical methods. However, the butanol fermentation is subjected to low product titres (&lt;20 g/L) due to product inhibition of the bacteria [1]. To overcome this continuous fermentation can be applied, as it offers considerably higher volumetric productivities compared to batch fermentation. However, it suffers from lower yields and concentrations due to the continuous dilution effects due to the feed stream. An integrated membrane-fermentation process would retain the microorganism in the fermenter, resulting in higher biomass concentrations and thereby enhancing both the yield and the volumetric productivity. Most research combining membrane and fermentation technology uses an external membrane unit [2]; but this leads to problems with sterility, increased process volume and cell viability due to shear stress in the circulation pump. In contrast, less research has been performed using submerged membranes. The key problem with membrane bioreactors for continuous fermentation is a stable membrane operation with small membrane area to fermenter volume ratio due to internal space limitations. Especially with regards to minimising membrane fouling, allowing operation for 150+ hours with no chemical cleaning agents.<br/><br/>Experimental/methodology.  <br/>Continuous acetone butanol ethanol fermentation was performed using Clostridium beijerinckii  in a 5 L fermenter. A silica carbide membrane (0.1 μm, 0.01 m2, Cembrane) was submerged in the fermenter. The permeate was constantly logged, providing<br/>online flux measurements. The membrane was periodically backflushed with deionised water, with the frequency of the<br/>backflushing varied to find the optimal operating conditions, aiming to maintain the flux at 20 kg/m2·h.<br/><br/>Results  and  discussion. <br/>While a continuous fermentation process without a membrane achieved a cell density of 0.6 g/L and butanol productivity of 0.10 g/L·h, incorporating a membrane into the fermenter tripled the cell density to 1.8 g/L. However, this high density could only be maintained for 50 hours before a decrease in membrane flux resulted in cell loss. This flux decline caused more broth to<br/>leave through the waste line rather than as the desired product in the permeate, therefore proportionally increasing cell loss. Maintaining a flux of 20 kg/m2·h was crucial for fermentation performance. Backflushing the membrane was implemented, initially every 2 minutes for 10 seconds. This maintained the flux at 19 kg/m2·h, but significantly diluted the broth, keeping the cell density at 0.7 g/L. By optimizing backwash duration and frequency (as shown in Figure 1), a steady flux of 16-18 kg/m2·h was achieved when the backflushing occurred for 10 seconds. Reducing the backflush frequency to every 20 minutes minimized dilution by 85%. This significantly improved the fermentation: peak cell density reached 3 g/L, with an average of 2 g/L (three times higher than the control without a membrane), and butanol productivity increased by 24% to 0.13 g/L·h for a stable 150 hours of operation.<br/><br/>Conclusions and outlook. <br/>This work has demonstrated the successful operation of a submerged membrane bioreactor under sterile operation for 150 hours. With further optimisation of the fermentation and membrane operation it will be possible to increase the productivity gains further, improving the viability of sustainable manufacturing routes.<br/><br/>References <br/>[1] Jones, D.T.; Woods, D.R. Microbiol Rev 1986, 4, 44-524.<br/>[2] Carstensen, F. et al. J. Membr Sci 2012, 394-395, 1-36.}},
  author       = {{Outram, V. and Lipnizki, F.}},
  keywords     = {{Continuous fermentation; Membrane bioreactors; Bioprocessing}},
  language     = {{eng}},
  month        = {{09}},
  pages        = {{861--861}},
  title        = {{Continuous butanol fermentation with submerged ceramic membranes}},
  url          = {{https://euromembrane2024.cz/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Book-of-Abstracts-EuroMembrane2024-small-1.pdf}},
  year         = {{2024}},
}