Advanced

The unknown but well-known wells in Holma. Public participation and norms in the City Tunnel Project in Malmö

Wickenberg, Per LU (2011) In Retfærd: Nordisk juridisk tidsskrift 133(2). p.42-57
Abstract
Environmental management in the City Tunnel Project was a three-year, sociology of law research project (1999-2003) on how the new Environmental Code was applied to one of the largest infrastructural projects in Sweden: the City Tunnel in Malmö. The aim of this article is, after some years, to reflect on and re-examine what happened during the two extended consultations processes to try to find an understanding and explanation of what happened when the tunnel project totally changed the focus and structure for the consultations.



In this article there is an interesting combination of both lifeworld and system oriented perspectives and findings. The law (the Environmental Code), belonging to the system, could, with new... (More)
Environmental management in the City Tunnel Project was a three-year, sociology of law research project (1999-2003) on how the new Environmental Code was applied to one of the largest infrastructural projects in Sweden: the City Tunnel in Malmö. The aim of this article is, after some years, to reflect on and re-examine what happened during the two extended consultations processes to try to find an understanding and explanation of what happened when the tunnel project totally changed the focus and structure for the consultations.



In this article there is an interesting combination of both lifeworld and system oriented perspectives and findings. The law (the Environmental Code), belonging to the system, could, with new and more bold, personal knowledge and interpretations by the management how to realize the extended consultations, thus meet the citizens’ personal demands and needs stemming from their lifeworld. Legality and legitimacy became in my interpretation two of the other key concepts in the analysis of the public consultations in the City Tunnel project. These concepts were also to have a great significance for the interpretation and understanding of what happened and why the design of the consultations totally changed form and content. The need for legitimacy regarding the City Tunnel project in Malmö – with its big social pressure that the tunnel at all costs must be accepted by the residents and citizens of Malmö – was also a driving force behind the fact that the management was realizing and using the legal means which included new opportunities. This change in the City Tunnel organisation regarding the public consultations was thus made possible due to two factors: the need for legitimacy by the citizens for the great construction project in Malmö; and a reflective leadership using social norms on public participation, realising the need for a revamp of the consultation design. In this last part the new environmental law was clearly supporting changes in a direction towards concrete public participation by citizens to have a say leading to sharing local knowledge and thus to some extent influence the building project. This local knowledge saved a lot of time and money for the City Tunnel Project e.g. in finding the unknown wells in Holma. Local knowledge was an excellent example and a result of real public participation during the second round of the consultations according to an open interpretation of the new Environmental Code. The law – in congruence with social norms and attitudes toward public participation in the management of the City Tunnel organisation – could in this case open up for broader public participation. (Less)
Please use this url to cite or link to this publication:
author
organization
publishing date
type
Contribution to journal
publication status
in press
subject
keywords
environment, public consultations, lifeworld, system, law, norm, legality, City Tunnel in Malmö, legitimacy, sustainable development, leadership
in
Retfærd: Nordisk juridisk tidsskrift
volume
133
issue
2
pages
42 - 57
publisher
DJØF Publishing
ISSN
0105-1121
project
MiC-projektet, Miljöledning i Citytunnelprojektet i Malmö
language
English
LU publication?
yes
id
ba85d297-c326-4c05-a9b5-6ee57f814fc8 (old id 1890736)
date added to LUP
2011-04-15 10:33:33
date last changed
2016-04-16 01:03:54
@article{ba85d297-c326-4c05-a9b5-6ee57f814fc8,
  abstract     = {Environmental management in the City Tunnel Project was a three-year, sociology of law research project (1999-2003) on how the new Environmental Code was applied to one of the largest infrastructural projects in Sweden: the City Tunnel in Malmö. The aim of this article is, after some years, to reflect on and re-examine what happened during the two extended consultations processes to try to find an understanding and explanation of what happened when the tunnel project totally changed the focus and structure for the consultations. <br/><br>
<br/><br>
In this article there is an interesting combination of both lifeworld and system oriented perspectives and findings. The law (the Environmental Code), belonging to the system, could, with new and more bold, personal knowledge and interpretations by the management how to realize the extended consultations, thus meet the citizens’ personal demands and needs stemming from their lifeworld. Legality and legitimacy became in my interpretation two of the other key concepts in the analysis of the public consultations in the City Tunnel project. These concepts were also to have a great significance for the interpretation and understanding of what happened and why the design of the consultations totally changed form and content. The need for legitimacy regarding the City Tunnel project in Malmö – with its big social pressure that the tunnel at all costs must be accepted by the residents and citizens of Malmö – was also a driving force behind the fact that the management was realizing and using the legal means which included new opportunities. This change in the City Tunnel organisation regarding the public consultations was thus made possible due to two factors: the need for legitimacy by the citizens for the great construction project in Malmö; and a reflective leadership using social norms on public participation, realising the need for a revamp of the consultation design. In this last part the new environmental law was clearly supporting changes in a direction towards concrete public participation by citizens to have a say leading to sharing local knowledge and thus to some extent influence the building project. This local knowledge saved a lot of time and money for the City Tunnel Project e.g. in finding the unknown wells in Holma. Local knowledge was an excellent example and a result of real public participation during the second round of the consultations according to an open interpretation of the new Environmental Code. The law – in congruence with social norms and attitudes toward public participation in the management of the City Tunnel organisation – could in this case open up for broader public participation.},
  author       = {Wickenberg, Per},
  issn         = {0105-1121},
  keyword      = {environment,public consultations,lifeworld,system,law,norm,legality,City Tunnel in Malmö,legitimacy,sustainable development,leadership},
  language     = {eng},
  number       = {2},
  pages        = {42--57},
  publisher    = {DJØF Publishing},
  series       = {Retfærd: Nordisk juridisk tidsskrift},
  title        = {The unknown but well-known wells in Holma. Public participation and norms in the City Tunnel Project in Malmö},
  volume       = {133},
  year         = {2011},
}