Advanced

Decision-making styles, stress and gender among investigators

Salo, Ilkka LU and Allwood, Carl Martin (2011) In Policing 34(1). p.97-119
Abstract
Purpose - The purpose of this study is to analyze the relationship between police investigators' decision-making styles, degree of judgmental self-doubt and work conditions, on the one hand, and their wellbeing, stress, burnout tendency and sleep quality, on the other. Design/methodology/approach - The study concerns investigative police officers (n = 203). Decision-making styles were measured by Scott and Bruce's General Decision Making Style scale (GDMS), and judgmental self-doubt by Mirels et at's Judgmental Self-Doubt Scale (JSDS). Wellbeing was measured by the Satisfaction With Life scale (SWL), and stress and burnout tendency by the Perceived Stress Questionnaire (PSQ) and a scale for Performance Based Self-Esteem (PBS). Questions on... (More)
Purpose - The purpose of this study is to analyze the relationship between police investigators' decision-making styles, degree of judgmental self-doubt and work conditions, on the one hand, and their wellbeing, stress, burnout tendency and sleep quality, on the other. Design/methodology/approach - The study concerns investigative police officers (n = 203). Decision-making styles were measured by Scott and Bruce's General Decision Making Style scale (GDMS), and judgmental self-doubt by Mirels et at's Judgmental Self-Doubt Scale (JSDS). Wellbeing was measured by the Satisfaction With Life scale (SWL), and stress and burnout tendency by the Perceived Stress Questionnaire (PSQ) and a scale for Performance Based Self-Esteem (PBS). Questions on sleep quality and work conditions were also used. Findings - High values on the decision-making styles Avoidant (tries to avoid making decisions) and Dependent (dependent on advice from others before important decisions) were associated with higher PBS, higher PSQ and poorer sleep quality. In addition, the Avoidant style was associated with lower SWL. Both the Dependent and the Avoidant styles were associated with higher influence experienced by others in the investigative work. Hierarchical regression analyses showed that JSDS explained the outcome measures better than the Dependent and the Avoidant decision-making styles. Gender analyses showed that male investigators showed higher values on Rational decision-making style ("exhaustive information search" and "logical evaluation of alternatives") and female investigators higher values on the Dependent decision-making style. Female investigators also evidenced a higher degree of stress and performance-based self-esteem. Research limitations/implications - The data were collected in a Swedish context and may not be fully generalizable to other countries. Practical implications - These results suggest the need to individualize training programs that seek to ameliorate stress and burnout. Originality/value - This paper furthers understanding of the relation between decision-making styles and wellbeing and stress in police investigators. (Less)
Please use this url to cite or link to this publication:
author
organization
publishing date
type
Contribution to journal
publication status
published
subject
keywords
Policing, Decision making, Self esteem, Stress, Management styles, Sweden
in
Policing
volume
34
issue
1
pages
97 - 119
publisher
Emerald Group Publishing Limited
external identifiers
  • wos:000289498200007
  • scopus:79952743533
ISSN
1363-951X
DOI
10.1108/13639511111106632
language
English
LU publication?
yes
id
9d30e44a-f4c6-459f-ad79-4a6264507db2 (old id 1964824)
date added to LUP
2011-05-23 13:47:39
date last changed
2017-09-03 04:24:22
@article{9d30e44a-f4c6-459f-ad79-4a6264507db2,
  abstract     = {Purpose - The purpose of this study is to analyze the relationship between police investigators' decision-making styles, degree of judgmental self-doubt and work conditions, on the one hand, and their wellbeing, stress, burnout tendency and sleep quality, on the other. Design/methodology/approach - The study concerns investigative police officers (n = 203). Decision-making styles were measured by Scott and Bruce's General Decision Making Style scale (GDMS), and judgmental self-doubt by Mirels et at's Judgmental Self-Doubt Scale (JSDS). Wellbeing was measured by the Satisfaction With Life scale (SWL), and stress and burnout tendency by the Perceived Stress Questionnaire (PSQ) and a scale for Performance Based Self-Esteem (PBS). Questions on sleep quality and work conditions were also used. Findings - High values on the decision-making styles Avoidant (tries to avoid making decisions) and Dependent (dependent on advice from others before important decisions) were associated with higher PBS, higher PSQ and poorer sleep quality. In addition, the Avoidant style was associated with lower SWL. Both the Dependent and the Avoidant styles were associated with higher influence experienced by others in the investigative work. Hierarchical regression analyses showed that JSDS explained the outcome measures better than the Dependent and the Avoidant decision-making styles. Gender analyses showed that male investigators showed higher values on Rational decision-making style ("exhaustive information search" and "logical evaluation of alternatives") and female investigators higher values on the Dependent decision-making style. Female investigators also evidenced a higher degree of stress and performance-based self-esteem. Research limitations/implications - The data were collected in a Swedish context and may not be fully generalizable to other countries. Practical implications - These results suggest the need to individualize training programs that seek to ameliorate stress and burnout. Originality/value - This paper furthers understanding of the relation between decision-making styles and wellbeing and stress in police investigators.},
  author       = {Salo, Ilkka and Allwood, Carl Martin},
  issn         = {1363-951X},
  keyword      = {Policing,Decision making,Self esteem,Stress,Management styles,Sweden},
  language     = {eng},
  number       = {1},
  pages        = {97--119},
  publisher    = {Emerald Group Publishing Limited},
  series       = {Policing},
  title        = {Decision-making styles, stress and gender among investigators},
  url          = {http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/13639511111106632},
  volume       = {34},
  year         = {2011},
}