First Person Readings of MAN : On semantic and pragmatic restrictions on an impersonal pronoun
(2018)- Abstract
- Cinque (1988) notices that Italian impersonal si can be interpreted so as to include the speaker and that such a reading is actually mandatory in certain contexts. A similar conclusion holds for impersonal man in a language such as Swedish, with the difference that, in the relevant contexts, man takes on the reading of 1st person singular, hence ‘I’ and not ‘we’. In this paper, I argue that Cinque’s observation can only be understood in a theory explaining how impersonal readings (generic and existential) are restricted, rather than in a general theory of “inclusiveness”. The first part of paper is dedicated to showing how impersonal readings are restricted by the temporal and aspectual specification of the clause. This part summarizes... (More)
- Cinque (1988) notices that Italian impersonal si can be interpreted so as to include the speaker and that such a reading is actually mandatory in certain contexts. A similar conclusion holds for impersonal man in a language such as Swedish, with the difference that, in the relevant contexts, man takes on the reading of 1st person singular, hence ‘I’ and not ‘we’. In this paper, I argue that Cinque’s observation can only be understood in a theory explaining how impersonal readings (generic and existential) are restricted, rather than in a general theory of “inclusiveness”. The first part of paper is dedicated to showing how impersonal readings are restricted by the temporal and aspectual specification of the clause. This part summarizes some by now well-known facts concerning the interpretation of man. The second part of the paper discusses a further restriction on impersonal readings, stemming from focus and contrastiveness. The relevant effect is shown in cases of topicalization
of SELF-anaphora in impersonal constructions in some Germanic languages.
To my knowledge, these data have so far gone unobserved in the literature. (Less)
Please use this url to cite or link to this publication:
https://lup.lub.lu.se/record/85780701-5858-4bc5-bcf9-824424503688
- author
- Egerland, Verner LU
- organization
- publishing date
- 2018
- type
- Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceeding
- publication status
- published
- subject
- keywords
- Impersonal pronoun, Genericity, Scandinavian, Self-anaphora
- host publication
- Order and structure in syntax II : Subjecthood and argument structure - Subjecthood and argument structure
- editor
- Sheehan, Michelle and Bailey, Laura
- pages
- 16 pages
- publisher
- Language Science Press
- external identifiers
-
- scopus:85085077633
- ISBN
- 978-3-96110-028-6
- DOI
- 10.5281/zenodo.1116765
- language
- English
- LU publication?
- yes
- id
- 85780701-5858-4bc5-bcf9-824424503688
- date added to LUP
- 2018-02-01 16:39:11
- date last changed
- 2025-04-04 13:59:57
@inbook{85780701-5858-4bc5-bcf9-824424503688,
abstract = {{Cinque (1988) notices that Italian impersonal si can be interpreted so as to include the speaker and that such a reading is actually mandatory in certain contexts. A similar conclusion holds for impersonal man in a language such as Swedish, with the difference that, in the relevant contexts, man takes on the reading of 1st person singular, hence ‘I’ and not ‘we’. In this paper, I argue that Cinque’s observation can only be understood in a theory explaining how impersonal readings (generic and existential) are restricted, rather than in a general theory of “inclusiveness”. The first part of paper is dedicated to showing how impersonal readings are restricted by the temporal and aspectual specification of the clause. This part summarizes some by now well-known facts concerning the interpretation of man. The second part of the paper discusses a further restriction on impersonal readings, stemming from focus and contrastiveness. The relevant effect is shown in cases of topicalization<br/>of SELF-anaphora in impersonal constructions in some Germanic languages.<br/>To my knowledge, these data have so far gone unobserved in the literature.}},
author = {{Egerland, Verner}},
booktitle = {{Order and structure in syntax II : Subjecthood and argument structure}},
editor = {{Sheehan, Michelle and Bailey, Laura}},
isbn = {{978-3-96110-028-6}},
keywords = {{Impersonal pronoun; Genericity; Scandinavian; Self-anaphora}},
language = {{eng}},
publisher = {{Language Science Press}},
title = {{First Person Readings of MAN : On semantic and pragmatic restrictions on an impersonal pronoun}},
url = {{http://dx.doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1116765}},
doi = {{10.5281/zenodo.1116765}},
year = {{2018}},
}