Altered Video Task : A Promising Alternative for Elicited/deferred Imitation Task in Young Children
Bobrowicz, Katarzyna LU
; Haman, Maciej
and Bobrowicz, Ryszard
(2016)
10th International Conference on Methods and Techniques in Behavioral Research
p.140-146
- Abstract
- The method presented in this paper is invented to address the problem of episodic memory in participants with highly restricted verbal abilities, 15-month-olds in this case. Here, we refer to episodic memory defined as a mind/brain system with three main responsibilities: to encode, to store and to recall individual memories. Episodic memory system requires three additional capacities, which make it uniquely human: a sense of self, a sense of subjective time, and autonoetic awareness [26]. Such approach is currently predominant both in developmental psychology and in cognitive zoology research.
With a focus on developmental studies, we introduce a method, which aims to pair a measure of episodic memory and a measure of self-awareness.... (More) - The method presented in this paper is invented to address the problem of episodic memory in participants with highly restricted verbal abilities, 15-month-olds in this case. Here, we refer to episodic memory defined as a mind/brain system with three main responsibilities: to encode, to store and to recall individual memories. Episodic memory system requires three additional capacities, which make it uniquely human: a sense of self, a sense of subjective time, and autonoetic awareness [26]. Such approach is currently predominant both in developmental psychology and in cognitive zoology research.
With a focus on developmental studies, we introduce a method, which aims to pair a measure of episodic memory and a measure of self-awareness. Episodic recall is measured via presentation of an original and a modified recording of a personal past event after a delay. The participant is expected to watch the unfamiliar video significantly longer than the familiar video, and so evince the differentiation between them. Alongside, the participant takes part in a mirror-mark task (a standard measure of self-recognition) and also in a real-time video task (a possible alternative for the mirror-mark task).
Measuring of the recall is based on “what”-“who”-“where” aspects of the past event. Three modified videos are generated from the original one, and the modifications refer to: 1. a toy (“what”), 2. an experimenter (“who”) and 3. a setting (“where”). That is why this method also derives from cognitive zoology studies, where episodic memory is measured via behavioural signs of remembering “what”, “where” and “when” happened [9]. The “who” aspect is a common addition in case of highly social animals [23][24][25].
The most typical method of measuring episodic recall in human children, even as young as 6-month-olds [2, p. 175] is elicited/deferred imitation task. However, it does not involve measuring of any of the “uniquely human” capacities and can be only applied to these organisms, which can readily imitate human experimenter’s actions.
Further, we also elaborate on the above-mentioned issues. We also discuss the results and possible improvements of the method implementation, for we actually tested it with a group of 15-month-olds. The results were statistically significant for the “who” and “what” aspects, but remained insignificant for the aspect of “where”. (Less)
Please use this url to cite or link to this publication:
https://lup.lub.lu.se/record/a1d42be9-5a7e-4273-88eb-2629d0a69a05
- author
- Bobrowicz, Katarzyna
LU
; Haman, Maciej
and Bobrowicz, Ryszard
- organization
- publishing date
- 2016-05-23
- type
- Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceeding
- publication status
- published
- subject
- host publication
- Proceedings of Measuring Behavior 2016 : 10th International Conference on Methods and Techniques in Behavioral Research - 10th International Conference on Methods and Techniques in Behavioral Research
- editor
- Spink, Andrew ; Riedel, Gernot ; Zhou, Liting ; Teekens, Lisanne E. A. ; Albatal, Rami and Gurrin, Cathal
- pages
- 7 pages
- conference name
- 10th International Conference on Methods and Techniques in Behavioral Research
- conference location
- Dublin, Ireland
- conference dates
- 2016-05-25 - 2016-05-27
- ISBN
- 978-1-873769-59-1
- language
- English
- LU publication?
- yes
- id
- a1d42be9-5a7e-4273-88eb-2629d0a69a05
- alternative location
- http://www.measuringbehavior.org/files/2016/MB2016_Proceedings.pdf#page=162
- date added to LUP
- 2016-12-13 19:09:24
- date last changed
- 2019-03-08 02:51:03
@inproceedings{a1d42be9-5a7e-4273-88eb-2629d0a69a05,
abstract = {{The method presented in this paper is invented to address the problem of episodic memory in participants with highly restricted verbal abilities, 15-month-olds in this case. Here, we refer to episodic memory defined as a mind/brain system with three main responsibilities: to encode, to store and to recall individual memories. Episodic memory system requires three additional capacities, which make it uniquely human: a sense of self, a sense of subjective time, and autonoetic awareness [26]. Such approach is currently predominant both in developmental psychology and in cognitive zoology research.<br/>With a focus on developmental studies, we introduce a method, which aims to pair a measure of episodic memory and a measure of self-awareness. Episodic recall is measured via presentation of an original and a modified recording of a personal past event after a delay. The participant is expected to watch the unfamiliar video significantly longer than the familiar video, and so evince the differentiation between them. Alongside, the participant takes part in a mirror-mark task (a standard measure of self-recognition) and also in a real-time video task (a possible alternative for the mirror-mark task).<br/>Measuring of the recall is based on “what”-“who”-“where” aspects of the past event. Three modified videos are generated from the original one, and the modifications refer to: 1. a toy (“what”), 2. an experimenter (“who”) and 3. a setting (“where”). That is why this method also derives from cognitive zoology studies, where episodic memory is measured via behavioural signs of remembering “what”, “where” and “when” happened [9]. The “who” aspect is a common addition in case of highly social animals [23][24][25].<br/>The most typical method of measuring episodic recall in human children, even as young as 6-month-olds [2, p. 175] is elicited/deferred imitation task. However, it does not involve measuring of any of the “uniquely human” capacities and can be only applied to these organisms, which can readily imitate human experimenter’s actions.<br/>Further, we also elaborate on the above-mentioned issues. We also discuss the results and possible improvements of the method implementation, for we actually tested it with a group of 15-month-olds. The results were statistically significant for the “who” and “what” aspects, but remained insignificant for the aspect of “where”.}},
author = {{Bobrowicz, Katarzyna and Haman, Maciej and Bobrowicz, Ryszard}},
booktitle = {{Proceedings of Measuring Behavior 2016 : 10th International Conference on Methods and Techniques in Behavioral Research}},
editor = {{Spink, Andrew and Riedel, Gernot and Zhou, Liting and Teekens, Lisanne E. A. and Albatal, Rami and Gurrin, Cathal}},
isbn = {{978-1-873769-59-1}},
language = {{eng}},
month = {{05}},
pages = {{140--146}},
title = {{Altered Video Task : A Promising Alternative for Elicited/deferred Imitation Task in Young Children}},
url = {{http://www.measuringbehavior.org/files/2016/MB2016_Proceedings.pdf#page=162}},
year = {{2016}},
}