Navigating the Minefield : Women's Experiences of Abortion in a Country with a Conscience Clause—The Case of Croatia
(2021) In Journal of International Women's Studies 22(1). p.166-180- Abstract
Many countries around the world have a conscience clause allowing physicians and health care providers to opt-out of performing abortions. This practice of conscientious objection to abortion care affects both healthcare providers and women's access to abortion care. In Croatia, a conscience clause was introduced in 2003. Nonetheless, women's experiences of abortion after the introduction have not been previously studied. The aim of our study was to explore women's experiences of abortion and conscientious objection in a country with a conscience clause. The study has a qualitative inductive and explorative design. We interviewed seven (7) women in Croatia with experience of an unwanted pregnancy or abortion and analyzed the interviews... (More)
Many countries around the world have a conscience clause allowing physicians and health care providers to opt-out of performing abortions. This practice of conscientious objection to abortion care affects both healthcare providers and women's access to abortion care. In Croatia, a conscience clause was introduced in 2003. Nonetheless, women's experiences of abortion after the introduction have not been previously studied. The aim of our study was to explore women's experiences of abortion and conscientious objection in a country with a conscience clause. The study has a qualitative inductive and explorative design. We interviewed seven (7) women in Croatia with experience of an unwanted pregnancy or abortion and analyzed the interviews using thematic content analysis. Our findings revealed one overarching theme: ‘Navigating the minefield—women's experiences of abortion in a country with a conscience clause’ and three categories: ‘Experiencing abortion—to endure a vulnerable situation,’ ‘The conscientious objection in practice—causing obstacles and stigma,’ and ‘Views on abortion—socio-cultural and religious influence’. The women perceived the abortion decision as being difficult and expressed feelings of shame, guilt, and fears of being judged in line with the general attitude toward abortion in society. They described the conscientious objection as having consequences in public healthcare by limiting their access to abortion care and affecting treatment in terms of i.e. derogatory comments, limited or lacking information about the abortion procedure and/or absent contraceptive counseling post abortion. According to the women, a shift towards more conservative ideas towards abortion seem to have taken place in the Croatian society. The conscientious objection was believed to reinforce a moralizing view of sexuality, where the women’s decisions regarding abortion became a collective concern causing stigma and involuntary social alienation. The conscientious clause made the women feel they had to navigate a ‘minefield,’ where their dependency situation and vulnerability in the abortion situation were reinforced by social stigma.
(Less)
- author
- Håkansson, Dubravka Ida Gladoić ; Ouis, Pernilla LU and Ragnar, Maria Ekstrand LU
- organization
- publishing date
- 2021
- type
- Contribution to journal
- publication status
- published
- subject
- keywords
- Abortion, Conscience clause, Conscientious objection, Croatia, Sexuality, Stigma, Women’s experiences
- in
- Journal of International Women's Studies
- volume
- 22
- issue
- 1
- pages
- 15 pages
- publisher
- Bridgewater State College
- external identifiers
-
- scopus:85101395726
- ISSN
- 1539-8706
- language
- English
- LU publication?
- yes
- id
- edafab9f-78c4-40a3-8cf7-e124c08c7eea
- alternative location
- https://vc.bridgew.edu/jiws/vol22/iss1/10
- date added to LUP
- 2021-03-10 09:18:31
- date last changed
- 2022-04-27 00:43:19
@article{edafab9f-78c4-40a3-8cf7-e124c08c7eea,
abstract = {{<p>Many countries around the world have a conscience clause allowing physicians and health care providers to opt-out of performing abortions. This practice of conscientious objection to abortion care affects both healthcare providers and women's access to abortion care. In Croatia, a conscience clause was introduced in 2003. Nonetheless, women's experiences of abortion after the introduction have not been previously studied. The aim of our study was to explore women's experiences of abortion and conscientious objection in a country with a conscience clause. The study has a qualitative inductive and explorative design. We interviewed seven (7) women in Croatia with experience of an unwanted pregnancy or abortion and analyzed the interviews using thematic content analysis. Our findings revealed one overarching theme: ‘Navigating the minefield—women's experiences of abortion in a country with a conscience clause’ and three categories: ‘Experiencing abortion—to endure a vulnerable situation,’ ‘The conscientious objection in practice—causing obstacles and stigma,’ and ‘Views on abortion—socio-cultural and religious influence’. The women perceived the abortion decision as being difficult and expressed feelings of shame, guilt, and fears of being judged in line with the general attitude toward abortion in society. They described the conscientious objection as having consequences in public healthcare by limiting their access to abortion care and affecting treatment in terms of i.e. derogatory comments, limited or lacking information about the abortion procedure and/or absent contraceptive counseling post abortion. According to the women, a shift towards more conservative ideas towards abortion seem to have taken place in the Croatian society. The conscientious objection was believed to reinforce a moralizing view of sexuality, where the women’s decisions regarding abortion became a collective concern causing stigma and involuntary social alienation. The conscientious clause made the women feel they had to navigate a ‘minefield,’ where their dependency situation and vulnerability in the abortion situation were reinforced by social stigma.</p>}},
author = {{Håkansson, Dubravka Ida Gladoić and Ouis, Pernilla and Ragnar, Maria Ekstrand}},
issn = {{1539-8706}},
keywords = {{Abortion; Conscience clause; Conscientious objection; Croatia; Sexuality; Stigma; Women’s experiences}},
language = {{eng}},
number = {{1}},
pages = {{166--180}},
publisher = {{Bridgewater State College}},
series = {{Journal of International Women's Studies}},
title = {{Navigating the Minefield : Women's Experiences of Abortion in a Country with a Conscience Clause—The Case of Croatia}},
url = {{https://vc.bridgew.edu/jiws/vol22/iss1/10}},
volume = {{22}},
year = {{2021}},
}