Skip to main content

LUP Student Papers

LUND UNIVERSITY LIBRARIES

From Climate Targets to Robust Pathways Framing Uncertainty as a Strategic Lever for Material Decarbonization in Swedish Construction

Pandey, Pranjal LU (2026) In IIIEE Master Thesis IMEM02 20261
The International Institute for Industrial Environmental Economics
Abstract
Material decarbonization in construction is often framed as a technical challenge of substituting high-carbon materials with lower-carbon alternatives. However, organizations seeking to reduce material-related/ embodied emissions must also address significant uncertainties related to regulation, supplier capacity, technology scale-up, client demand, project economics, data quality, and internal governance. This study investigates how these uncertainties influence the robustness of material-decarbonization strategies within a Swedish construction organization. It identifies which strategic levers remain viable across plausible future scenarios, highlights points of vulnerability in current pathways and explores the organizational... (More)
Material decarbonization in construction is often framed as a technical challenge of substituting high-carbon materials with lower-carbon alternatives. However, organizations seeking to reduce material-related/ embodied emissions must also address significant uncertainties related to regulation, supplier capacity, technology scale-up, client demand, project economics, data quality, and internal governance. This study investigates how these uncertainties influence the robustness of material-decarbonization strategies within a Swedish construction organization. It identifies which strategic levers remain viable across plausible future scenarios, highlights points of vulnerability in current pathways and explores the organizational capabilities and risk-governance mechanisms that can facilitate more adaptive responses.

This research adopts a qualitative-dominant exploratory single-case study design. A literature-informed contextual review was conducted to develop an uncertainty register specific to Swedish and European construction. An internal expert survey subsequently prioritized key uncertainties, such as supply resilience, geopolitical inflation, technology scaling, regulatory and metric changes, subsidy volatility, demand fragility, and preparedness gaps. These findings informed eight semi-structured expert interviews, which utilized scenario prompts to stress-test the organization’s pathway under material-scale-up, demand-side and geopolitical/civil-preparedness uncertainty. The analysis utilized Decision Making under Deep Uncertainty as the decision logic, XLRM as the structuring framework, and applied Dynamic Capabilities and Enterprise Risk Management as organizational and governance perspectives.

The findings indicate that the case organization’s pathway exhibits conditional robustness. Strategies such as design efficiency, early-stage carbon steering, material optimization, supplier engagement, enhanced supplier data, and selective transformation or reuse remain effective across multiple plausible futures. In contrast, dependence on green premiums, single-path breakthrough materials, stable accounting rules, and unprotected climate ambition under margin pressure introduces vulnerability. The organization demonstrates strong sensing capacity and partial seizing capacity, but exhibits weaker reconfiguring capacity regarding decision rights, procurement mandates, incentives, and escalation procedures.

The study contributes to the construction-decarbonization literature by reframing material decarbonization as an adaptive governance challenge rather than solely a technical material-selection issue. It contends that robust material-decarbonization strategies require ongoing monitoring of signposts, minimization of single-path dependence, and periodic reassessment of which strategic levers remain robust, conditional, or fragile as uncertainty conditions evolve. (Less)
Please use this url to cite or link to this publication:
author
Pandey, Pranjal LU
supervisor
organization
course
IMEM02 20261
year
type
H2 - Master's Degree (Two Years)
subject
keywords
Embodied Emissions, Material Decarbonization, Decision Making Under Deep Uncertainty, DMDU, Deep Uncertainty, XLRM, Robust Decision-Making, Adaptive Governance, Construction Sector, Dynamic Capabilities, Enterprise Risk Management.
publication/series
IIIEE Master Thesis
report number
2026:34
ISSN
1401-9191
language
English
id
9248322
date added to LUP
2026-08-17 08:53:10
date last changed
2026-08-17 08:53:10
@misc{9248322,
  abstract     = {{Material decarbonization in construction is often framed as a technical challenge of substituting high-carbon materials with lower-carbon alternatives. However, organizations seeking to reduce material-related/ embodied emissions must also address significant uncertainties related to regulation, supplier capacity, technology scale-up, client demand, project economics, data quality, and internal governance. This study investigates how these uncertainties influence the robustness of material-decarbonization strategies within a Swedish construction organization. It identifies which strategic levers remain viable across plausible future scenarios, highlights points of vulnerability in current pathways and explores the organizational capabilities and risk-governance mechanisms that can facilitate more adaptive responses.

This research adopts a qualitative-dominant exploratory single-case study design. A literature-informed contextual review was conducted to develop an uncertainty register specific to Swedish and European construction. An internal expert survey subsequently prioritized key uncertainties, such as supply resilience, geopolitical inflation, technology scaling, regulatory and metric changes, subsidy volatility, demand fragility, and preparedness gaps. These findings informed eight semi-structured expert interviews, which utilized scenario prompts to stress-test the organization’s pathway under material-scale-up, demand-side and geopolitical/civil-preparedness uncertainty. The analysis utilized Decision Making under Deep Uncertainty as the decision logic, XLRM as the structuring framework, and applied Dynamic Capabilities and Enterprise Risk Management as organizational and governance perspectives.

The findings indicate that the case organization’s pathway exhibits conditional robustness. Strategies such as design efficiency, early-stage carbon steering, material optimization, supplier engagement, enhanced supplier data, and selective transformation or reuse remain effective across multiple plausible futures. In contrast, dependence on green premiums, single-path breakthrough materials, stable accounting rules, and unprotected climate ambition under margin pressure introduces vulnerability. The organization demonstrates strong sensing capacity and partial seizing capacity, but exhibits weaker reconfiguring capacity regarding decision rights, procurement mandates, incentives, and escalation procedures.

The study contributes to the construction-decarbonization literature by reframing material decarbonization as an adaptive governance challenge rather than solely a technical material-selection issue. It contends that robust material-decarbonization strategies require ongoing monitoring of signposts, minimization of single-path dependence, and periodic reassessment of which strategic levers remain robust, conditional, or fragile as uncertainty conditions evolve.}},
  author       = {{Pandey, Pranjal}},
  issn         = {{1401-9191}},
  language     = {{eng}},
  note         = {{Student Paper}},
  series       = {{IIIEE Master Thesis}},
  title        = {{From Climate Targets to Robust Pathways Framing Uncertainty as a Strategic Lever for Material Decarbonization in Swedish Construction}},
  year         = {{2026}},
}