Skip to main content

LUP Student Papers

LUND UNIVERSITY LIBRARIES

Autocratic Legality: Legal Mutation in Hybrid Political Regimes - Case studies of ‘Foreign Agents Laws’ in Hungary and Georgia

Macková, Simona LU (2026) SOLM02 20261
Sociology of Law Department
Abstract
This thesis examines how Foreign Agents Laws (FALs) transform when travelling from
authoritarian origins into hybrid and EU-constrained democratic regimes, using Hungary and Georgia as comparative case studies. Drawing on legal transfer and autocratic legalism as the primary analytical framework, the thesis traces how FAL-type instruments mutate their formal legal architecture in response to domestic and supranational constraints whilst preserving their substantive function of constraining foreign-funded civil society. Through qualitative content analysis of legislative texts and Critical Discourse Analysis of government justifications, the study finds that mutation takes two analytically distinct pathways: sequential redesign and... (More)
This thesis examines how Foreign Agents Laws (FALs) transform when travelling from
authoritarian origins into hybrid and EU-constrained democratic regimes, using Hungary and Georgia as comparative case studies. Drawing on legal transfer and autocratic legalism as the primary analytical framework, the thesis traces how FAL-type instruments mutate their formal legal architecture in response to domestic and supranational constraints whilst preserving their substantive function of constraining foreign-funded civil society. Through qualitative content analysis of legislative texts and Critical Discourse Analysis of government justifications, the study finds that mutation takes two analytically distinct pathways: sequential redesign and parallel escalation under binding ECJ jurisdiction in Hungary, and dual-track legal deployment under non-binding EU candidacy pressure in Georgia. In both cases, institutional pressure appears to have contributed to rather than constrained legislative escalation. The thesis also identifies three travelling justificatory frames—transparency, sovereignty, and FARA equivalence claims—that provide democratic cover for instruments whose structural logic resembles the Russian model. From a sociology of law perspective, the thesis contributes to understanding how legal categories and administrative procedures do not merely regulate civil society but actively constitute it as a legally suspect category — making legality itself the mechanism through which political interventions are normalized and democratic resistance foreclosed. (Less)
Please use this url to cite or link to this publication:
author
Macková, Simona LU
supervisor
organization
course
SOLM02 20261
year
type
H2 - Master's Degree (Two Years)
subject
keywords
Foreign Agents Laws, legal transfer, autocratic legalism, civil society, hybrid regimes, mutation
language
English
id
9250937
date added to LUP
2026-10-23 12:58:34
date last changed
2026-10-23 12:58:34
@misc{9250937,
  abstract     = {{This thesis examines how Foreign Agents Laws (FALs) transform when travelling from 
authoritarian origins into hybrid and EU-constrained democratic regimes, using Hungary and Georgia as comparative case studies. Drawing on legal transfer and autocratic legalism as the primary analytical framework, the thesis traces how FAL-type instruments mutate their formal legal architecture in response to domestic and supranational constraints whilst preserving their substantive function of constraining foreign-funded civil society. Through qualitative content analysis of legislative texts and Critical Discourse Analysis of government justifications, the study finds that mutation takes two analytically distinct pathways: sequential redesign and parallel escalation under binding ECJ jurisdiction in Hungary, and dual-track legal deployment under non-binding EU candidacy pressure in Georgia. In both cases, institutional pressure appears to have contributed to rather than constrained legislative escalation. The thesis also identifies three travelling justificatory frames—transparency, sovereignty, and FARA equivalence claims—that provide democratic cover for instruments whose structural logic resembles the Russian model. From a sociology of law perspective, the thesis contributes to understanding how legal categories and administrative procedures do not merely regulate civil society but actively constitute it as a legally suspect category — making legality itself the mechanism through which political interventions are normalized and democratic resistance foreclosed.}},
  author       = {{Macková, Simona}},
  language     = {{eng}},
  note         = {{Student Paper}},
  title        = {{Autocratic Legality: Legal Mutation in Hybrid Political Regimes - Case studies of ‘Foreign Agents Laws’ in Hungary and Georgia}},
  year         = {{2026}},
}