Is it useful to catch attention - The analysis of unconventional brand actions and its implications
(2026) In The Strategic Brand Management - Masters Paper Series BUSN21 20262Department of Business Administration
- Abstract
- Purpose: To explore how respondents evaluate unconventional brand actions that differ in expectedness and brand fit, and which conditions help a brand break convention without weakening its identity or distinctiveness.
Design/methodology/approach: An exploratory comparative case study of four brand actions: Duolingo’s Death of Duo campaign, KFC’s “FCK” apology, Ryanair’s sarcastic replies to customer complaints, and Jaguar’s rebrand. The authors positioned the cases in a 2×2 matrix of expectedness and brand fit through theory-guided qualitative coding of secondary material. A supporting survey of young adults showed how respondents evaluated each action in terms of brand perception, distinctiveness, and memorability.
Findings:... (More) - Purpose: To explore how respondents evaluate unconventional brand actions that differ in expectedness and brand fit, and which conditions help a brand break convention without weakening its identity or distinctiveness.
Design/methodology/approach: An exploratory comparative case study of four brand actions: Duolingo’s Death of Duo campaign, KFC’s “FCK” apology, Ryanair’s sarcastic replies to customer complaints, and Jaguar’s rebrand. The authors positioned the cases in a 2×2 matrix of expectedness and brand fit through theory-guided qualitative coding of secondary material. A supporting survey of young adults showed how respondents evaluated each action in terms of brand perception, distinctiveness, and memorability.
Findings: Unexpected actions were associated with fewer negative evaluations than expected ones, and on-brand actions were generally seen as more distinctive. Neither dimension explained the results on its own: KFC’s off-brand apology drew the largest share of positive evaluations, and Ryanair’s action was distinctive and memorable but not better liked. The context of the action, the scope of the change, the brand assets retained, and the expectations the brand has built appear to shape how surprise is evaluated.
Research limitations/implications: The findings are exploratory. Expectedness and brand fit were classified by the authors. Only four cases were studied; the sample is a convenience sample of young adults, and no statistical tests were conducted. Future research should measure expectedness and brand fit from respondents, test the associations statistically, and examine further brands and types of action.
Practical implications: Managers considering breaking convention can ask four questions: why now, how far, what should remain, and how much freedom the brand has. Surprise is less a choice between on-brand and off-brand than a decision about timing, scale, and which brand assets to keep.
Originality/value: The paper brings together incongruity theory and distinctiveness research, which are usually considered separately, and complements them with a practical framework for managers. (Less)
Please use this url to cite or link to this publication:
https://lup.lub.lu.se/student-papers/record/9252746
- author
- Barabas, Paulina LU ; Salinas Almanza, Valeria Maria LU and Summerer, Anna LU
- supervisor
- organization
- course
- BUSN21 20262
- year
- 2026
- type
- L1 - 1st term paper (old degree order)
- subject
- keywords
- Unconventional brand actions, Expectednes, Brand fit, Brand distinctiveness, Incongruity
- publication/series
- The Strategic Brand Management - Masters Paper Series
- language
- English
- id
- 9252746
- date added to LUP
- 2026-11-19 09:18:51
- date last changed
- 2026-11-19 09:18:51
@misc{9252746,
abstract = {{Purpose: To explore how respondents evaluate unconventional brand actions that differ in expectedness and brand fit, and which conditions help a brand break convention without weakening its identity or distinctiveness.
Design/methodology/approach: An exploratory comparative case study of four brand actions: Duolingo’s Death of Duo campaign, KFC’s “FCK” apology, Ryanair’s sarcastic replies to customer complaints, and Jaguar’s rebrand. The authors positioned the cases in a 2×2 matrix of expectedness and brand fit through theory-guided qualitative coding of secondary material. A supporting survey of young adults showed how respondents evaluated each action in terms of brand perception, distinctiveness, and memorability.
Findings: Unexpected actions were associated with fewer negative evaluations than expected ones, and on-brand actions were generally seen as more distinctive. Neither dimension explained the results on its own: KFC’s off-brand apology drew the largest share of positive evaluations, and Ryanair’s action was distinctive and memorable but not better liked. The context of the action, the scope of the change, the brand assets retained, and the expectations the brand has built appear to shape how surprise is evaluated.
Research limitations/implications: The findings are exploratory. Expectedness and brand fit were classified by the authors. Only four cases were studied; the sample is a convenience sample of young adults, and no statistical tests were conducted. Future research should measure expectedness and brand fit from respondents, test the associations statistically, and examine further brands and types of action.
Practical implications: Managers considering breaking convention can ask four questions: why now, how far, what should remain, and how much freedom the brand has. Surprise is less a choice between on-brand and off-brand than a decision about timing, scale, and which brand assets to keep.
Originality/value: The paper brings together incongruity theory and distinctiveness research, which are usually considered separately, and complements them with a practical framework for managers.}},
author = {{Barabas, Paulina and Salinas Almanza, Valeria Maria and Summerer, Anna}},
language = {{eng}},
note = {{Student Paper}},
series = {{The Strategic Brand Management - Masters Paper Series}},
title = {{Is it useful to catch attention - The analysis of unconventional brand actions and its implications}},
year = {{2026}},
}