Skip to main content

LUP Student Papers

LUND UNIVERSITY LIBRARIES

Duped but not defeated? How original brands respond to dupes of their flagship products

Lorentz, Jasmin LU ; Røkke, Erle LU and Schellenberg, Inga Marie LU (2026) BUSN21 20262
Department of Business Administration
Abstract
Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to explore how original brands strategically respond to dupes of their flagship product(s), in order to sustain the value of the original.
Design/methodology/approach: This exploratory, qualitative multiple-case study compares the dupe responses of Lululemon (2023), Olaplex (2023) and OMHU (2026). Publicly available documents, such as press releases, statements by brand representatives and press coverage, are analysed through the Decode, Anchor and Engage framework developed for this study.
Findings: The three original brands responded by highlighting qualities of the original beyond what the dupes were compared on: the experience of using the product (Lululemon), patented technology (Olaplex), and... (More)
Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to explore how original brands strategically respond to dupes of their flagship product(s), in order to sustain the value of the original.
Design/methodology/approach: This exploratory, qualitative multiple-case study compares the dupe responses of Lululemon (2023), Olaplex (2023) and OMHU (2026). Publicly available documents, such as press releases, statements by brand representatives and press coverage, are analysed through the Decode, Anchor and Engage framework developed for this study.
Findings: The three original brands responded by highlighting qualities of the original beyond what the dupes were compared on: the experience of using the product (Lululemon), patented technology (Olaplex), and the quality and brand behind the product (OMHU). All of the brands engaged in the dupe conversation through formats borrowed from dupe culture while placing the flagship at the centre of its response and without lowering the price of the original. The responses suggest a hybrid of brand and market orientation where dupe culture shapes the format and the brand provides the substance.
Research limitations/implications: The study relies on public material as the case brands did not respond to interview requests. It therefore shows what brands communicate in public, not why they chose a response. Nor does it include how customers perceived a response or whether it succeeded. Differences between the cases cannot be attributed to the type of dupe comparison alone, since both the brands and the categories differ.
Practical implications: The cases suggest that managers may begin by establishing what a dupe comparison claims to match, and then consider which qualities of the original lie beyond it and how these can be made tangible to the audience. Engagement with dupe culture may become an opportunity to restate why the original is worth choosing, without criticising dupe buyers or lowering the price of the original.
Originality/value: Research on imitation has mainly examined how consumers evaluate copies. This paper takes the perspective of the original brand and shows what three brands communicated when their flagship product was publicly compared with dupes.
Keywords: Dupe culture, Brand imitation, Flagship product, Brand identity, Brand kernel, Case study
Paper type: Research paper (Less)
Please use this url to cite or link to this publication:
author
Lorentz, Jasmin LU ; Røkke, Erle LU and Schellenberg, Inga Marie LU
supervisor
organization
course
BUSN21 20262
year
type
L3 - Miscellaneous, Projetcs etc.
subject
language
English
id
9253795
date added to LUP
2026-11-19 09:19:41
date last changed
2026-11-19 09:19:41
@misc{9253795,
  abstract     = {{Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to explore how original brands strategically respond to dupes of their flagship product(s), in order to sustain the value of the original. 
Design/methodology/approach: This exploratory, qualitative multiple-case study compares the dupe responses of Lululemon (2023), Olaplex (2023) and OMHU (2026). Publicly available documents, such as press releases, statements by brand representatives and press coverage, are analysed through the Decode, Anchor and Engage framework developed for this study.
Findings: The three original brands responded by highlighting qualities of the original beyond what the dupes were compared on: the experience of using the product (Lululemon), patented technology (Olaplex), and the quality and brand behind the product (OMHU). All of the brands engaged in the dupe conversation through formats borrowed from dupe culture while placing the flagship at the centre of its response and without lowering the price of the original. The responses suggest a hybrid of brand and market orientation where dupe culture shapes the format and the brand provides the substance.
Research limitations/implications: The study relies on public material as the case brands did not respond to interview requests. It therefore shows what brands communicate in public, not why they chose a response. Nor does it include how customers perceived a response or whether it succeeded. Differences between the cases cannot be attributed to the type of dupe comparison alone, since both the brands and the categories differ. 
Practical implications: The cases suggest that managers may begin by establishing what a dupe comparison claims to match, and then consider which qualities of the original lie beyond it and how these can be made tangible to the audience. Engagement with dupe culture may become an opportunity to restate why the original is worth choosing, without criticising dupe buyers or lowering the price of the original.
Originality/value: Research on imitation has mainly examined how consumers evaluate copies. This paper takes the perspective of the original brand and shows what three brands communicated when their flagship product was publicly compared with dupes.
Keywords: Dupe culture, Brand imitation, Flagship product, Brand identity, Brand kernel, Case study
Paper type: Research paper}},
  author       = {{Lorentz, Jasmin and Røkke, Erle and Schellenberg, Inga Marie}},
  language     = {{eng}},
  note         = {{Student Paper}},
  title        = {{Duped but not defeated? How original brands respond to dupes of their flagship products}},
  year         = {{2026}},
}